Committee on Finance. - Vote 37—Agriculture (Resumed).
Contributions 102–226 of 226. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
He mentioned it very briefly in the course of his opening remarks but that does not license any Deputy to initiate a full dress debate on the matter. When the Bill comes before the House, Deputies will have an opportunity.
Comment on this
During the few remarks I hope to make on this Estimate I should like to mention it en passant.
Comment on this
Deputy Sheridan should reserve his remarks on this matter until the Bill comes before the House.
Comment on this
I am afraid you put me off. I am glad Deputy Kennedy mentioned the subject of tillage. It is a serious problem. While some people grew rich, others grew poor. This country will never be right until we produce the maximum amount we want, let it be malting barley, feeding barley and so on. I must pay tribute to Deputy Dillon. When he was Minister for Agriculture, he said there was no point in bringing in goods from a foreign country if you had to process them here and send them back to the same country. No matter what farmers say and no matter what organisations they have, surely it ought to be possible to produce—and I am speaking now as a farmer myself—the milk, the barley or whatever else we want in this country? We have the soil. It is up to us to do whatever we can to make a living for ourselves, our families and the nation. Surely nobody begrudges that right?
With regard to this problem of the NFA v. the Minister and the Government, it is something I do not want to intervene in. I know that irregular marketing and other things have discouraged farmers. But I want to make myself very clear on this: while I certainly will not ever align myself with any illegal organisation, anybody who obstructs bridges or does not pay rates, I will align myself with anybody who will come to the Minister and say: "Right; meet the farmers now. Have a round table conference and we will talk about the matters most important to farmers". That must be the nearest thing to the heart of any farmer or any farmer's wife, because the women are marching too. For heaven's sake, let us not be hypocritical. Let us get down to the people at street level and give them instances of where they are right or wrong. We live in a democracy and we know what can be done at county council level when we get people talking and get the best terms we can. On many occasions I have seen approaches to the local authority of which I am proud to be a member for increases in wages, shorter hours and so on. We got down to business and did the best we could. Surely we ought to be able to do something about this national problem? I will be only too glad to intervene in any way I can to help this matter.
Comment on this
The debate on this Estimate is a debate on the Estimate which relates to our foremost and most important industry. We are debating this Estimate this year in a sense of emergency, indeed almost of crisis. We are certainly debating the affairs of agriculture in this country at a time when there is a general air of despondency and disillusionment and a lack of leadership. Agriculture in the past 12 months certainly has gone through a very difficult period. Those in this House who represent rural constituencies will, I am sure, agree with me that the past 12 months has been a period in which farmers have received poor prices, prices that have consistently dropped. At the same time, it has been a period in which there has been for farmers the experience of rising rates and rising costs. This has to be put against a background where, at the beginning of the last calendar year, at the time this House debated the British Free Trade Agreement, the then Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries in the opening months of 1966 held out to Irish farmers a promise of tremendous profits and remuneration to be earned last year if only they would continue to make endeavours until the month of July of last year. Cattle prices were to rise and every farmer was promised by the then Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries good times, good prices and a fair return for everything he had to sell. It is against the background of that kind of absurd claim made by a Minister who has now left the Department of Agriculture and Fisheries, as he left previously the Department of Justice, leaving behind him in each case problems to be solved——
Comment on this
The principal fact, in any event, has been that, backgrounded against what was promised from the British Free Trade Area Agreement of last year, the actual experience by Irish farmers has been generally one of blighted hopes, of poor returns, leading to a general air of disillusionment and, as I say, despondency.
I want to remind the House that this time last year, when this Estimate was being discussed, outside in Kildare Street people who claimed to be representing the farmers of Ireland were marching up and down with pickets, picketing Dáil Éireann, picketing the people's Parliament. They felt they had a grievance. They felt that they had not been able to have access to the ear of the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries. Up and down they walked. As they did one turn up and another turn down, up would come a Garda officer to inquire their names. They all spoke with southern accents. They all came from Kerry, Limerick, Tipperary and Cork—let us not forget it. They were picketing Leinster House because the Minister would not listen to what they regarded as a reasonable claim and a reasonable demand. They were arrested. One after the other they went into the Black Marias that were lined up to take them away to prison and having been taken away to prison they were charged in our district courts and our district courts became so full of farmers from the south that the lists could not be dealt with. But there was a difference this time last year. It happened that on June 1st, which was then rapidly approaching, the people of Ireland would vote in an election for the President of this country.
Comment on this
On the Friday before they voted, lo and behold, those who picketed Leinster House and who were charged by the Government with breaking the law of the land, those who were charged with being engaged in a conspiracy to frustrate Parliament itself suddenly found that a vast sum of money was suddenly available to provide a concession for their demands and that a fairy godmother suddenly appeared on the scene to pay their fines, to release them from jail, to send them back to their wives and families without a stain upon their character.
Comment on this
I am not in the slightest bit displeased with the South. I would be happy to remind the Parliamentary Secretary that the south of Ireland backed the candidate opposed to the President.
Comment on this
I want to recall that 12 calendar months ago it paid Irish farmers to picket Leinster House and to break the law of this land, as was alleged by the Government. Fines were paid by nameless ones. Court sentences were wiped out and the matter there ended. I do not think there is anyone on any side of the House who did not welcome what we regarded as the end of a situation in which those who represented an important section of our farmers were frustrated by not being able to talk to Ireland's Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries. Everybody felt this time last year that that was the end of a situation in which, in frustration, in anger or in despondency, Irish farmers had to march on Ireland's Parliament or Ireland's capital because Ireland's Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries would not bid them the time of day or listen to them.
How wrong we were. June, July, August, September, October, what happened? Again, we found precisely the same thing, that in the autumn of last year a situation had arisen in which the same Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries did precisely the same thing with an organisation claiming to represent, and representing, the farmers of this country. He refused to speak to them, to entertain their demands or to listen to what they had to say and, once again, the farmers of Ireland were forced to march from Kerry, Clare, Donegal. From the west and from the east they marched in groups, meeting together, marching on the capital city. I do not think anyone who saw their advent into this city felt that they were coming to intimidate anyone, felt that they were coming to terrorise or cause trouble.
Of those who saw the long line of grim-faced, dust-coated men walking in an orderly manner from O'Connell Street down to this building, men weary from many miles of walking but grim and determined, there was not one in this city who did not entertain for them admiration and respect. They assembled outside the offices of their servant—let us not forget it. I want to remind members of the present Government, lest they forget it, that their title and style, of which they should be proud, is that they are the servants of the Irish people. When they assembled outside the offices of their servant, there to talk to him about Ireland's primary industry, the industry on which our towns, our villages and our cities depend fundamentally, they found he was not at home, he could not see them, he was not prepared to meet these farmers who had come from every part of Ireland, even to listen to what they had to say.
I do not know whether a thing like that could have happened anywhere else except in this country and under a Fianna Fáil Government. There could have been trouble. There was such a blast of anger through that vast crowd of farmers outside that for a moment those who had assembled might have done something that would have led to an open defiance and breach of the law. It is right that here in this House I or someone should acknowledge the fact that in that moment of danger when the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries refused to meet the farmers of Ireland there were wise heads and responsible people who said: "Be calm. Do not do anything wrong. Disband in an orderly way, as you met. Go back to your counties. Go back to your homes. Some of us will wait here because perhaps the man could not meet us this afternoon but maybe he can meet us tomorrow morning or the next day."
None of us is perfect; all of us are human. I do not know in what circumstances people from time to time are forced, driven, led, persuaded into a situation in which they break the law, but certainly a well-known cause is provocation. Many a person finds and has found himself breaking the law because he has been provoked into a course which, in normal circumstances, he would never entertain. For weeks after that date in November, on the footpath outside Government Buildings, to our shame and disgrace, camped out like itinerants, there were the representatives in due course of every county in Ireland, in the wet, in the rain, in the snow, waiting patiently for the gracious day when their servant would deign to meet them and talk about a problem which should be the common responsibility of the Minister for Agriculture and every farmers' organisation.
Throughout November there they waited patiently, these representatives of the National Farmers' Association of Ireland. I may tell you they would still be waiting there now, months later, were it not for the fact that suddenly, at the end of last year, two by-elections had to be fought. When that situation came about, not wished, and regretted by all Members of the House who knew both of the Deputies concerned, with these two unexpected deaths and the impending decision of the then Taoiseach, in the circumstances, to get out, with provision being made for a new Taoiseach, it was then decided: "All right; we will start the new boys well. We will get the farmers off the steps so that the new Taoiseach and the new Minister for Agriculture can start off with a clean sheet, and everything may go well."
Therefore, the then Taoiseach, Deputy Lemass, and the then Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Haughey, with the usual face-saving on both sides, arranged to meet the National Farmers Association. The tents were folded and the caravans moved to one side of the road, and in they went to meet the Taoiseach of Ireland and Ireland's Minister for Agriculture. I do not know; politics is supposed to be at times, according to a certain well-known author who used to be quoted in this House from time to time, namely, Machiavelli, an exercise in expediency. It was an expedient thing to do. If the people were to vote in the constituency of Kerry and in the constituency of Waterford, it was expedient that the farmers should not be sitting outside Government Buildings. It was expedient that it be made possible for them to leave, and that meeting was accordingly convened.
Then our present Taoiseach was elected, and he appointed our present Minister for Agriculture. He met the farmers a day or two later and for six hours there was jaw, jaw, jaw. They talked and they talked and they talked. At least it was a good thing to see them talking, but for how long did the talking last? It is worth recalling that the talking lasted for just as long as it was necessary to get the people of Kerry and the people of Waterford to vote, and then we found that all the talking that was going on was under a sense of mutual confusion and misunderstanding. We then had a situation in which things were worse than they had been a few weeks before. The new Taoiseach was now being disowned by his Minister for Agriculture. The previous Minister for Agriculture who had promised a meat marketing board was being told by the new Minister for Agriculture: "That is out." The NFA were being told by the Minister for Agriculture that what they thought had been said had not been said at all. Things were worse than ever before, with the Taoiseach being told to keep out of it.
Comment on this
The new Minister was going to rule the roost. Provocation is a powerful thing. It has made sane men mad. It has made upright citizens do things they would never do. Provocation—a situation in which an organisation representative of many thousands of farmers whose leaders had suffered the possibility of a loss of face by getting up from the steps outside Government Buildings, who had sat down with the Leaders of two successive Governments, Deputy Lemass and Deputy Lynch, with their two Ministers for Agriculture, and who found at the end that they were merely being used as dupes, as tools, in a particular exercise in expediency. Where were they to go? They could no longer reason with Ireland's Minister for Agriculture. They could no longer look forward to a possibility of talking to the Leader of Ireland's Government, and so we had the road-blocking in the month of January of this year.
I want to know—and I regret that the Minister for Agriculture cannot spare the time to be here in this House for more than a few odd moments during this debate—what was the Government doing about these road blockades in January of this year. If ever an exercise was canvassed and advertised, that was. I saw it coming; the Minister saw it coming. We were told for weeks beforehand that, on a named date in January, desperate farmers, provoked into this particular exercise, were going to take their vehicles out and block the roads. In order to make the message quite clear, they had a test performance a week or ten days before. What were the Government doing? Blowing bubbles? The plain fact is that the Government, knowing this would be done, sat back with folded arms and waited for it to happen.
Provocation can lead to a breach of the law and the person who breaks the law, under provocation, goes outside the law. But there is nothing worse than the person who aids and abets, who watches a breach of the law, knowing it is taking place and does nothing about it. In relation to the road blockade in January of this year, I charge the Government that they aided and abetted that blockade. They knew it was coming. They wanted it to happen because they thought that it would put the NFA in the wrong and out on a limb.
Comment on this
It is a pity the Parliamentary Secretary is not a member of the Government because then he could speak on behalf of the Government. I suggest he should have a Minister here——
Comment on this
The Deputy's Party aided and abetted those who broke the law with much more serious intent.
Comment on this
I would also recommend to the Parliamentary Secretary the unwisdom of a member of the Fianna Fáil Party talking about breaking the law to a member of the Fine Gael Party.
Comment on this
I want to be quite clear about this: the National Farmers Association was, in my view, forced into a situation in which they put themselves outside the law. There is no one—let there be no doubt about this—on this side of the House or on the other side of the House who condoned or supported what was done in January of this year; quite the contrary. We regretted it happening. We regretted that decent, respectable men should have been forced into a situation in which they did what they did. It is fair to say, I think, that in the ensuing six weeks, the leaders of the National Farmers Association recognised—they did not expressely say it, but it was clear enough—that they had made a mistake in relation to the road blockade; having been invited to do so, asked to do so and, indeed, encouraged to do so by many people, they made it quite clear that at no stage in the future would they engage in a similar operation outside the law. Having made that declaration, it was then possible for the Leader of the Government and the Minister for Agriculture to meet the National Farmers Association.
I want, for the record, to remind Deputies now that in a period of three or four months we have had a chronic repetition of a certain situation—a boiling up, both sides at daggers drawn, and then somebody making a concession, an atmosphere of calmness for a period, and then someone losing his head again. The Taoiseach and the Minister for Agriculture met the NFA in February. There was a long discussion. Everybody said: "Thanks be to God; now we will have an end to this bitterness. Things will be all right." How long did that last? A matter of a few days. The next we heard was the usual statement, the denial, the charge and countercharge. They were back at it as hard as ever before.
That continued up to the beginning of this month when it was suggested the Spring Show would be boycotted by the NFA—the major agricultural show in the country. Lo and behold, after an indifferent start to the Spring Show, there was universal satisfaction because, once again, there had been an intervention, a meeting, a package deal, and all the farmers who had been arrested were out, or so people were led to believe. But, no. Apparently there was no package deal and, according to the Minister for Justice, it was quite wrong to say there was. There was no comprehensive settlement and we were back again to the same situation. The only redeeming feature was that the Spring Show was supported.
Where are we going? We are a small nation, a little over three million people. We are making ourselves the laughingstock of Europe. We have a potential in agriculture, a potential which is, perhaps, in the long run our one viable asset. We are supposed to be going into Europe in the next 18 months, going in to face competition from the hardheaded Danes and the Dutch. What are we doing? Cutting our own throats——
Comment on this
——and proceeding to destroy the one industry which might make this nation a viable economic unit. And all for the sake of dotting the i's and crossing the t's, insisting on the letter of the law. Twelve months ago there was no talk about the rule of law when the farmers were collected in Black Marias, brought down to Mountjoy, and sprung a few days later because someone was kind enough to pay their fines. That was all forgotten. Now, in order to enable someone's ego to be flattered and in order to prevent a situation in which some fallible member of the Fianna Fáil Government would have to be made realise that, as a Minister, he is a servant, the rule of law is puffed up as an impossible barrier against the promotion of a situation in which the National Farmers Association and the Government can co-operate and work together.
I suggest that so far as ordinary people outside this are concerned—I speak in this regard not only in relation to the Fine Gael Party but in relation to most people—we are sick and tired of this performance, sick and tired of reading statements and counter-statements each day, one getting worse than the other, exchanges between the NFA and the Government.
Comment on this
I am glad the Parliamentary Secretary reminded me of that. Before I pass from this, I should like to answer the suggestion made by the Taoiseach and, I think, repeated by some Fianna Fáil Deputies recently. About a week or ten days ago, the Taoiseach said, in relation to the NFA dispute, that this Party had been making political capital out of it. I want to assert that that is not true. I want to assert that at all times, from the moment the farmers picketed outside in Kildare Street to the moment they marched up into Merrion Square and throughout all these months, our Party have maintained a situation in which, above all, we sought neither to embarras nor to prejudice either side and sought at all times to get people together. The Parliamentary Secretary and, indeed, other members of Fianna Fáil, know well that, behind the scenes and out in the open, we have sought by every means possible to encourage reason and goodwill and discussion. We have not made political capital out of it.
Comment on this
At no stage have we done it. It certainly did not suit the Taoiseach, nor was it appropriate for him to make that charge. I do not know what the end of this will be but I am certain that, so long as we have a situation in which the Government of Ireland goes one road and the farmers of Ireland find themselves going another road, the people who will suffer is our community, the country itself.
We simply cannot afford to have this kind of senseless feuding amongst important sections of our community. We cannot afford feuding between the farmers and the Government, nor can we afford feuding between different organisations amongst the farmers themselves. That is bad. It is a very bad thing that agriculture should be used as it has been used, particularly in recent years, as some kind of a political playground with gimmicks being introduced by the Government from time to time to placate one particular section and a leap-frogging effort between different organisations. That is bad and has been proved to be bad. Unless somebody bangs together the heads of all those responsible, including that of the Minister, this country will suffer.
We need to grow up. We need to be more adult. We need to realise that we must work out, as a matter of urgency, an agricultural policy that will prepare the way for our entry into Europe. There may be an outbreak of sanity on the part of the Government: I do not know. Usually, political Parties who find themselves in office, who are there one year, two years, three years, five years, ten years, become very settled in their ways. They become more or less certain that they are right because, after all, must they not be right because they won the last election and the election before it and the election before it again? In that way, they do not become receptive to public opinion. They have all their advisers who are there telling them what wonderful fellows they are, writing their speeches for them and then telling them that they made a wonderful speech. Therefore, with a Government who have been too long in office, an air of euphoria is created all around them until, some day, there comes the sudden realisation that they have not as many friends in the country as they thought they had, and then they are gone.
There is no general election now and there will not be one, I suppose, until the period of this Dáil has run its due course. There are local elections which will be held on 28th June. I suppose Deputy Davern will say that I am now going to exploit the NFA—I am. I am giving a bit of advice to the NFA if they will take it from me. One of their troubles has been that, under their constitution—and I can understand it and this was done bona fide and in order to achieve a sense of security and independence for Irish farmers— they have guaranteed that they will not enter into politics and that, whatever happens, they will not find themselves concerned with politics. Those are very sound sentiments, very high principles, but when you go to bargain and negotiate with a tough crowd of warriors like the Fianna Fáil Government and when you go into the council chamber and you start off by saying: “Whether you give us our demands or you do not, whether you kick us down or put us sitting down, whether you slap us in the face or do not, no matter what you do to us, we shall not advise anybody to vote against you”, you are not getting very far.
Comment on this
If the alternative for the NFA is to break the law of this land or to break their own constitution by going political and advising their members to vote against Fianna Fáil, I advise them to do it—
Comment on this
——because, the very moment they do it, the very moment the NFA decide: "If the Government will not be reasonable with us, will not talk over these matters with us, will not even meet us, then we shall advise our members and their wives to vote against Fianna Fáil candidates" then they will be amazed. Reason will break out. The NFA will be welcomed in to talk over a matter that should have been talked over months before that. Until such time as the NFA or any other body realises that we are a democracy and that, in a democracy, there is only one sanction that is effective, right and proper, namely, the use of the ballot box, until that is realised then decent men, responsible men, respectable men, law abiding men, in frustration, will be forced into doing things that they should not do because they have no other course open to them.
Now, I hope we shall see an end of this. It is a matter of urgency that we should get back into a situation in which Irish farmers know where long-term development lies, a situation in which Irish farmers, in a sense of enthusiasm, are gearing their industry for entry into Europe. We should get back to a sense of partnership between the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries and the farmers, the kind of partnership that existed when the NFA came into being at the invitation and with the encouragement of Deputy Dillon, who was then Minister for Agriculture. That was at a time when as Minister for Agriculture he saw the necessity for building up an association of this kind and the urgency for having a partnership between the Minister and the agricultural industry and those who work in it. I hope we can get back to that situation as quickly as possible because if we do not and if we enter Europe I fear we will have missed an opportunity, an opportunity which can mean a great deal for this country. Let there be no mistake about it, if we miss that opportunity our children and our children's children will hold us responsible for allowing our country and its economy to be wiped out in the fierce competition that Europe is going to bring.
Comment on this
I was rather amused by the statements made by Deputy O'Higgins. He evidently has a lot of wrong dates. I do not know where he found them but he found them. I am not at all surprised by his anxiety in view of what I saw as an old Member of this House. When I came into this House first, there was a pretty considerable number of farmer representatives here. To be exact, there were eight and they were some kind of allies with Deputy O'Higgins's Party which then had a different name, the Cumann na nGaedheal Party. I remember a Private Member's Bill being brought in here which was designed to compel the landlords to abide by the agreement they had made, known as temporary abatements, with their tenants. The landlords in all cases had returned the old rents as the rents and instead of getting a reduction in rent under the 1924 Land Act those unfortunate men found themselves with a ten per cent increase. They got a 30 per cent reduction under the 1924 Land Act and under the temporary abatements they got a reduction of 40 per cent. That is on the records of this House and on a vote here, the Bill was defeated by 11 votes. Eight of those 11 votes were the votes of the farmer representatives.
A few months later, in view of the unfortunate condition in which the farmers were, in view of their impoverished condition, a motion for a £ million relief of rates was brought in. That also was defeated by 11 or 12 votes—I am not sure which—but I do know that the eight farmers' votes were cast against the £1 million relief in rates for the farmers. I admit that the price was paid and a gentleman here, Michael R. Heffernan, was made Minister for Posts and Poles for that Government. They disappeared and another Farmers' Party came in which was called——
Comment on this
This is very interesting, I am sure, but will the Deputy relate it to what is before the House?
Comment on this
I cannot see any relevance in going into the history of the farmers as a political Party.
Comment on this
I am dealing with the anxiety of Deputy O'Higgins and his advice that the NFA should become political. The next team I saw swallowed up was that of Deputy McDermot and Deputy Dillon. Deputy Dillon has been hanging around over there ever since. That was the second exhibition that we got. Then we had Deputy Blowick and Deputy Donnellan and others on the same line. I saw those unfortunate men walk around that to vote against any increase in the price of milk for the farmers they represented. They disappeared too. There is one of them left, Deputy O'Hara. That is what we saw. I am a farmer, and I am sorry. We have seen the Labour Party doing their job for their people independently but I have given three instances of what Cumann na nGaedheal first and Fine Gael after them, did with the Farmers' Parties who came in here to do their job for the farmers.
Nobody regrets more than I any difference between farmers' organisations, speaking as a member of the oldest farmers' organisation in this State, an organisation formed in 1932 for the purpose of looking after the beetgrowers. We carried out negotiations and I know to my own grief the advantage that can be taken by any Minister for Agriculture—no matter from what Party he comes—when you find two farmers' organisations endeavouring to negotiate. I know to my grief because we were negotiating on the price of barley and wheat as well as on beet and vegetables for a long number of years when there was no other farmers' organisation to do it. Suddenly this child that we have now, of which Deputy Dillon is the father, according to Deputy O'Higgins anyway, the NFA, came into being.
We asked the then Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Dillon, to meet us to negotiate the price of wheat and feeding barley. He met us on a Thursday and we put up our case for an increase. He just stood up and said: "I had another farmers' organisation in here on Tuesday last. They were decent, responsible men, not like you fellows." As a result the poor farmers found themselves, instead of getting 48/- per barrel for feeding barley, getting 40/-. Those are stubborn, hard facts that cannot be contradicted. Following our example of organising to look after our commodity, the creamery milk suppliers came along and formed their organisation to look after creamery milk suppliers. As Deputy O'Higgins said, last year we had them marching up and down outside, picketing and seeking an increase in the price of milk. While they were marching up and down out there, we had the other farmers' organisation under Mr. Deasy walking in past them to interview the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, Deputy Haughey, to see if he would give them authority to say they had got 1d a gallon more for milk.
We see where this thing leads. Many years ago we called all the farmers' organisations together in Thurles in an effort to get what should exist in this country, a federation of farmers' organisations prepared to work together and help each other, each representing their own commodity and free to negotiate for that commodity. That is what is required. I say that as a founder member of the Beet Growers Association, as one who had to accept 35/- a ton for beet for the farmers on one occasion and who is now in the proud position of having 151/- per ton for the same commodity.
At that time we had to set a lead, so far as I was concerned, by getting a basic price, based on the cost of production plus a fair profit. We met General Costello when he was first appointed general manager of the Sugar Company and we negotiated on that basis with him. Afterwards, I said to him: "Surely there is some better way of settling this matter than by meeting here and fighting over pence for a month and then spending the next three months abusing each other, each thinking that the other has `done' him? Why not cost the production?""It would cost you a lot of money", he said. I said: "We will go in with you." We did, and the crop was costed in 1947 and 1948 and the cost of production was taken from 400 different farmers with different soils, different conditions and everything else. It cost £6,000 of which the Sugar Company paid £4,000 and the Beet Growers Association paid £2,000. On that costing, up to two years ago, we met the Sugar Company each year, brought the costings up to date and got our price.
Two years ago General Costello told us they could not meet our price unless they got an increase in the price of sugar. Apparently, that was not forthcoming. I told him we would have to get what we were entitled to. We had a strike. I led that strike and I am not a bit sorry for it. We fought it out to the point where we had to get the 5/3d a ton that the costings allowed us and we got it.
The trouble here is—how shall I put it?—there seems to be no conception as to the difference between the rural community, whether farmers or workers, and those in the towns and cities, organised industrial workers. Nobody has the slightest conception of what this means. In November 1965, for example, we went to General Costello to bring our costings up to date. He met us with his two hands up and said: "There is no money here for anybody." I said: "Let us in, in any case, and we shall have a chat." We went in and he repeated his statement inside. I said that I wanted to get one thing very clear: did he mean that there was no money for the farmers or no money for anybody, farmers or workers? He said there was no money for anybody. I said: "Very well; in those circumstances, I shall accept the present price of beet for the coming year, on condition that you sign an agreement with me that any increase you give your workers in the next 12 months will also be given to the farmers."
Comment on this
It leads up to the present position of agriculture. Twelve months ago General Costello came along and said: "You caught me out." I said: "Yes, for how much?" The amount was 8/9d per ton. That represented the £1 per week that was given to the workers. He did not give it until the 1st June and said that, therefore, something should come off. The amount that came off was 2/1d per ton and every beetgrower who grew beet for last season got an extra cheque for 6/8d per ton to make up for the increase of £1 per week that the workers got.
I am taking only one commodity as an example. If you find that £1 a week to the workers means a difference of 8/9d a ton to the farmers that is what is wrong with agriculture in this country. Agriculture and the price of agricultural products have not kept step with the increase in wages to industrial workers and the cost of living. That is the present position. As a matter of fact, my organisation were more than anxious two years ago to have set up, under the aegis of the Department of Agriculture and Fisheries, a farmers' consultative council that would advise the Minister as regards prices and everything else. The present Minister set that up a few months ago. He invited the three, as he called them, major bodies to take part in it. The Irish Creamery Milk Suppliers came in and were satisfied. The Beet Growers Association unanimously appointed two representatives. The National Farmers Association, first of all, attacked the Minister for daring to give the two commodity organisations mentioned, the Beet Growers Association or the Creamery Milk Suppliers two representatives each while they were only getting two representatives.
The people who talk about unity in the farming community endeavour by sabotage and threats to drive every other farmers' organisation out of existence. What did they want? They wanted themselves to be the only negotiating body to negotiate on the price of our agricultural products in this country and that when they were negotiating the price of milk going to the creameries the Irish Creamery Milk Suppliers Association, with their permission, would be allowed in as observers. That is why they remained out. Those are the people who endeavour to wipe out a commodity organisation of farmers who have done their work for the agricultural community for over 34 years. They try to wipe us out because we would not withdraw our two representatives from the National Agricultural Council set up by the Minister. They tried to drive us out whilst at the same time, they have two Government-appointed nominees of theirs, Mr. Mullen and Mr. Orpen. They are Government representatives on both grounds. They have Mr. Finnegan, I think his name is, another leader of their Party a Government-appointed representative on Nitrigin Éireann. They have Mr. Delahunty on the Pigs and Bacon Commission and they have another gentleman as their representative on An Bord Bainne. All those men are loyally co-operating with the Government they are pretending to have no co-operation with.
I would, if I were to ask as an organisation that another farmers' organisation withdraw their representatives, certainly withdraw my own representatives from the Government body. They have not done that. They are still there. Those are the conditions and that is the position. We did our utmost as far as any organisation could go to end this dispute. I was one of four men appointed, the four chairmen of our four boards, by our organisation to mediate in an endeavour to settle it. We went. I said that the first thing to do was to prevent the fire from spreading and that we would go to the Minister for Justice first. We went to the Minister for Justice. We said: "We are mediating on this thing and we hope to get some kind of agreement and settlement on it. We ask you to hold your hand." He said: "Look, you are mediating on this. If I can get any kind of guarantee that they will stop their illegal operations, I will do my best to meet you." I said: "What about stopping the arrests?" He said: "Good enough." He called up there and then and he stopped all the arrests. I then said: "What about a package deal? Throw them all out. What will you take for the bunch?"
Comment on this
I offered £100 from the Beet Growers Association in full settlement of all fines, complaints and threatened fines to end the dispute. I came down to our chairman, who is treasurer of the County Laois National Farmers Association, Mr. John Phelan, and I said to him: "Do your best now." He went to Mr. Deasy. Mr. Deasy said he wanted no interference. He said the worst which could be done in this was to secure the release of the men, that he wanted them in jail. That is what you are dealing with and that is the position.
A fortnight after this we had a joint meeting of the Irish Creamery Milk Suppliers Association and the four chairmen of the Beet Growers Association. We both approached the National Farmers Association before we decided to go to any Minister to see if anything could be done. They said they wanted no mediation. I believe, whilst they were doing that, they had another Fianna Fáil Deputy taking Mr. Jim Mullins on the back road to the Minister for Justice. However, those are the facts as far as I know them. I appeal to the Minister if there is any way out of this to take it before any tragedy occurs. You cannot have four or five gentlemen touring by night and going into an unfortunate farmer's house with a docket and saying: "Look, put your name to that, Mary."
Comment on this
Or with a farmer coming out with a shotgun and letting fly. It is then everything will be settled.
Comment on this
We fought the Blueshirts before and we beat them, and they came to our respected Member, Deputy William Kent of Castlelyons, God rest his soul. He sat where Deputy Corish is sitting now.
Comment on this
He was not. I do not know where you were sitting at the time but he sat there for two years all alone and the McDermots and the Dillons were shadow Ministers for the shadows.
Comment on this
When Deputy T.F. O'Higgins spoke I suggested that he should have a couple of reams from Deputy Cosgrave's speech and his attack on Deputy O.J. Flanagan—the poor man, I did not see him in the House since. I should like to have a look at that and see how far it was in support of the NFA activities. I do not wish to deal further with this, Sir. You would not have heard it at all but for Deputy T.F. O'Higgins. I did not intend to mention this matter but I could not allow Deputy T.F. O'Higgins get away with the statement and the attack he made here.
I can say, Sir, and I am proud to say, that for 33 years, odd, I have been a member of the Irish Sugar Beet Growers Association and I never allowed politics into discussions, even a mention of politics. I picked my team for any negotiations without favour. If we wanted to use politics they could have been used and the only reason they could have been used was this. When that industry was started in Mallow the Fine Gael organisation came out travelling around to the farmers' houses and they took the contracts that had been signed for the beet and burned them.
Comment on this
I am not talking about what you had in Carlow; I am talking about the factories. The Deputy knows nothing about them. We had to go around then and the result was that in the Mallow area beet was only grown by Fianna Fáil farmers.
I heard a commentary today by Deputy M.P. Murphy. I never cared for politics. We had a Chairman and a Vice-Chairman, Mr. John Phelan, County Treasurer of the NFA. To appoint a Chairman and a Vice-Chairman was the natural thing to do at that time. The Chairman was Mr. Phelan and the Vice-Chairman Mr. Bob Lahiffe. Those two were appointed unanimously by the council of 15. Deputy M.P. Murphy alluded here today to the political nature of the NAC. I should like to remind Deputy M.P. Murphy that for six long years, the former Deputy Lehane sat side by side with him as a member of the inter-Party Government. I should also like to remind Deputy M.P. Murphy, however, that the former Deputy Lehane is secretary of the Farmers Union of Cork County and there are at least seven members elected on Cork County Council.
I know because Deputy Lehane fought three general elections against me in my time. Surely you cannot brand Deputy Lehane with a political brand; if you can, what brand would you give him? You would hardly call him Fianna Fáil when you consider the number of times he walked around the lobbies here against them.
Comment on this
I do not think that there is any man in this House, to whatever Party he belongs and I do not care what his affiliations are, who was not happy and felt proud to see General Costello appointed to that council. General Costello is one man who not alone——
Comment on this
He was one of the politicians, Sir, to whom Deputy M.P. Murphy, your colleague, alluded here today.
Comment on this
When an allegation is made in this House we are allowed to contradict it if necessary.
Comment on this
I will contradict no more. Deputy T.F. O'Higgins said here that we got them off the steps for the by-election but on the week of the two by-elections in Waterford and Kerry, the boys had moved back on the steps to lend their spiritual aid, or their moral support, to the Fine Gael Party.
Comment on this
Anyway, we did not beat one of you; we beat the two of you.
To get down to the Estimate proper, I should like to start by supporting Deputy M.P. Murphy's request for a bacon factory in West Cork—not my constituency—but where you have 11 per cent of the total pig population reared and fattened they are entitled, surely, not to have to pay CIE transport at £1 per head of every pig dragged from Bantry to Cork.
Comment on this
It is a pretty stiff journey and if you were paying CIE for it you would know what it cost. One thing we cannot afford in this country is to have a factory too far from the production point. I certainly believe that Deputy M.P. Murphy is right in putting forward their claims in that respect.
I would ask the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries very earnestly to grant either some subsidy on sprays for weeds or ensure that the price is brought within a reasonable limit. Sprays cost £7 14s 0d an acre—a pretty hefty sum. Band spraying, spraying both sides of the drill of beet, a distance of three inches on each side, costs £2 5s 0d an acre. Then, with those costs, people wonder why farmers are looking for increased prices. Those are increased bills and, unfortunately, in the kind of weather we have been getting for the past fortnight I have seen fields of barley which had to be sprayed three times. You had a spray just finished when there was a thunder shower and the spray disappeared; it was of no use at all; you had to spray it again. I would suggest to the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries—if he proposes giving any assistance to the ordinary working and tillage farmer in this country—that he give it in the line of relieving the expenditure of those farmers. I do not know how the price of spray is made up, to be quite honest, but I think that 28/- for a lb of spray is something the Prices Commission should have a look at. I do not know how they arrive at the price or anything else about it but I do know that is the price of it to the farmer. If the Minister did that it would be something which would increase production, while keeping our costs down.
We hear complaints here about the price of cattle. I told the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries—Deputy Haughey—last year not to give any kind of a guarantee on the price of cattle because I felt no Minister could. It is beyond the power of any Minister to forecast the price of cattle for even three months in this country. It cannot be done. I remember being at a fair along with Deputy Dillon in Kilkenny a few years ago after he advised the farmers that if they had cattle to hold on to them because the price would be better in a few months. That was when Deputy Dillon was sitting over there where Deputy Carty is now sitting. That was Deputy Dillon's statement when I met him down at that fair. It was a bad fair and people were going up through the fair driving their cattle home and so on. I saw the Minister for Agriculture, as he was then, standing over on the footpath complete with his cigarette holder, cigarette and all, and I said: "A bad fair, lads." They answered "Devil a worse, Sir" and then I asked "What do you think of the gent in the black hat over there who advised you to keep them?"
Comment on this
I am merely saying that no Minister or anybody in this country can forecast the price of cattle for even three months ahead. You do not know what is happening. Take the Calved Heifer Scheme, for instance. If 50 per cent of the money is being paid for something which is happening, we will definitely have an increase of something between 100,000 and 200,000 young cattle every year. In my opinion, they are the cattle we will have to get sale for—the small cattle which the dairy farmer with nine or ten cows may have, which he has to sell at nine, ten or 15 months old, at the most. We got rid of 10,000 of them last year to Egypt, and a good sale they made— £9 10s per cwt, free on board, before the peddlers came after the rest of them.
The next thing that happened was that we succeeded in getting some 3,000 or 4,000 of them out to Italy. Those cattle were sent over like a trial lot, being tried out in the universities there. A fortnight after they had been landed, we had a big headline in The Farmers' Journal; “Joe Keane writes from Italy.” The National Farmers' Association had sent a gentleman named Joe Keane on a double-barrel mission on his honeymoon to see those cattle that had been sent out of the country.
Comment on this
Mr. Joe Keane stated that the Irish cattle that went to Italy were flukey, worm-infested, lice-infested. It was there on the front page of The Farmers' Journal. I raised it in this House by way of Parliamentary Question. The Minister was a bit too tolerant with those gentlemen. That was the help and assistance those gentlemen gave when we were making an endeavour to get sale for those cattle abroad. That is the kind of sabotage that is being worked and I think it is high time it were stopped.
The Italian buyers who came over here saw those cattle and bought them. Every beast had to be treated for both worm and fluke before it left this country. Then we have a gentleman whose honeymoon must have gone astray on him or something with that kind of a statement. The extraordinary thing is that those people who bought those 4,000 cattle are quite happy with them and are coming for more, thank God.
That is the class of cattle that I want to see sold because we can only fatten a certain proportion here; we cannot fatten them all. If we have a glut of those small cattle it means that the 700-acre gentlemen have cheap stock to put in, the gentlemen who do not milk cows, who do not thin beet and who do not dirty their hands with agricultural work, the bullock ranchers. They have cheap cattle and if there is a glut of those cattle, they have very cheap cattle. Therefore, in my opinion, that is the class of cattle that every endeavour should be made to get out of this country and to get sale for abroad. I do not believe there will be enough sale in the British market to cover them and we must go abroad and endeavour to sell them in other markets. We got rid of 10,000 of them to Egypt last year. We sent 3,000 or 4,000 to Italy at the begining of this year as a trial lot and then we had that disgraceful comment that appeared in The Farmers' Journal.
I can see one bright spot in so far as agriculture is concerned, that is, the joining-up of Erin Foods with Heinz. Four years ago when General Costello was travelling down in my constituency, he suggested to me that it was ideal country for vegetable growing. By putting our heads together and getting in on the one side £30,000 of farmers' money and on the other side, £30,000 from the Sugar Company and a decent grant from An Foras Tionscal, we were able to start that industry.
Comment on this
You are paid for coming in here. Go and do your own work and do not be trying to get my brains to do it for you. You will not get them.
We started with 300 acres odd the first year. We went on to 750 acres last year. We are having 1,240 acres this year. It has taken so well with my working farmers in East Cork that we had offers of contracts for 2,800 acres. We paid about £65,000 to the farmers last year and we paid somewhere between £45,000 and £55,000 to labour in that little industry. As I said, we are doubling it this year and we will double it again, please God, next year. I expect, in three years' time, to have that factory processing somewhere between 7,000 and 10,000 acres of vegetables for the people of East Cork with a ready market abroad for them.
That is the kind of work I would like to see the National Farmers' Association working on and co-operating in with the other farmers' organisations because that is the kind of work that will help out not alone the large farmer who goes in for peas but the smaller farmer who goes in for French beans, carrots, turnips and cabbage. In my opinion, in two or three years, Deputy Donegan will not be howling about the cost of having to buy feeding barley in Cork and transporting it up to the lazy farmers of Roscommon and Cavan and places up there and the cost of transporting it up there. He will not have to bother any more with it because peas will, in my area anyway, take the place of feeding barley. Those are the things that should be fostered and worked out.
I would say that an area very similar to mine would be County Wexford, another traditionally tillage area.
Comment on this
You have good tillage farmers there. They nearly broke my strike two years ago when they ran behind my back and contracted for 15,000 acres of beet.
Comment on this
Facts are very stubborn things. It is undoubtedly a tillage county. If I were to pick a place for another vegetable factory tomorrow, I would pick Wexford.
Comment on this
I was glad that the Minister in his statement today dealt with other matters that are not classed as agricultural products but which are agricultural products exported in a manufactured state. It is about time that was realised. For example, the products of the Midleton factory, and the processed foods from the Mallow factory, the Tuam factory and the Carlow factory, are all leaving this country in a processed state, and you will find them under the heading of exports and imports in Industry and Commerce. If you look at the increase in the subsidy on manures, you will see what Gouldings got during the past 12 months from the increased price of manures. The Minister has not filled that gap. Will it go down as a subsidy to agriculture or a subsidy to enable Gouldings to give a bigger cheque to the NFA? I do not know. Those are the facts.
Many of the subsidies we see in this book are not subsidies to agriculture but subsidies to industry. They are definite subsidies to industry. No one will convince me that if Gouldings increase the price of artificial manures by 10/- or £1 per ton, and the Minister gives us 5/- out of 10/- as a subsidy, that is a subsidy to agriculture. It is a subsidy to enable Messrs. Gouldings to increase their profits and nothing else. That is borne out in a peculiar way. Before General Costello left us, we went to get the price for superphosphates and we found that it was so juggled that if we imported superphosphates, the amount we would lose in subsidy would be exactly the same as what we would save by buying it from Gouldings.
These are hindrances to agriculture. If the people of this country are entitled to get cheap wheat from foreigners, then we are equally entitled to get our artificial manures in the cheapest markets we can find. That is one subsidy which I suggest has gone astray in this book. It should be under the heading of Industry and Commerce, and not Agriculture. There is also the subsidy on farm buildings. I suggest that the subsidy on hay barns and corrugated iron constructions of that description is actually a subsidy to Irish Steel, Limited. That is another subsidy that should be changed in this book from the heading of a subsidy to farming to a subsidy to industry. If you go through the list you will find that a large portion of the £60 million subsidy which the farmers are supposed to get is a subsidy not to agriculture but to industry.
I raised this matter in this House before and I hope that in the next book I will be looking at, I will see those items in their proper place. I suggest to the Minister that he would be doing a good job in dealing with that. I do not want to be coming in here in ten or 15 years' time——
Comment on this
I am only starting. There are many things we could deal with on this Estimate. Unfortunately, for a long number of years, I was like a voice crying in the wilderness when I suggested that the wage paid to agricultural labour should be brought into line with the price of industrial labour. Because that was not done, we lost the vast bulk of our agricultural labourers, and no one can blame them. If in fixing the price of milk, I were to take into consideration the fact that my workers have to work on Saturdays and Sundays—two days on which industrial workers do not have to work —and if I were to put those days down as overtime, I wonder what the price would be. The same applies to other agricultural products where agricultural workers, be they farmers or labourers, have different conditions. Many of them crop up from time to time.
I have nine agricultural labourers' cottages within 100 yards of my house. Thirty years ago they held nine agricultural labourers who worked on the land. Today they hold no agricultural labourers, working on the land. To be honest about it, I thank God for that, not for the fact that they are not working on the land but for the fact that we were able to find industrial employment for them and give them work. Out of those nine cottages there are 17 men going to work every morning. Thank God, they got the chance to purchase those cottages and they are now quite happy. Men walk into me on a Sunday. "Martin," they say, "give us a letter for the Steel or to Deputy Fitzpatrick's friend, the Verolme Dockyard."
Comment on this
I give it to them and they go off to work at a minimum of £13 a week and from that up to £25 or £26 for a five-day week. Does anybody think those boys would be idiots enough to come in to plough or milk cows or crown beet for Martin Corry when they get that wage for a five-day week in industry? It means one cannot get a skilled labourer in agriculture today. I have heard solemn statements here, day after day, week after week, about the flight from the land. I do not hear so much lately about the people flying from the rural districts. Is there anyone here who would be prepared to work a six-and-a-half or a seven-day week for 25 per cent less wages than he would get working a five-day week in industry? If there is, I should like to look at him.
These are facts, stubborn facts. They have stripped rural Ireland of its workers. We are told this is the age of machinery. It is the age of compulsory machinery, when one must get machinery or give the land up. I come from an area where 40 per cent of the land is under the plough each year. It has no resemblance to the 700-acre fellow with the dish-washer and all the rest of it. They are ordinary, honest tillage farmers, doing their work and fighting their corner to make a fair existence for themselves.
I say above board here that we have many a blessing in that stretch of country but the biggest blessing of all was General Costello and his factories. The little industry in a little rural town which will pay £60,000 or £70,000 a year for produce and another £60,000 or £70,000 a year in wages to local workers is the kind of economy we want more of. The employment in one such industry during the past 12 months has been 100. Next year it will average 200 and in the year after, please God, it will be 400 or 450. That is a small industry which that man organised out of his own brain and brought to fruition. And they say he is not worthy to sit with General Deasy on the NAC. What are we coming to? Where are we going? General Costello is the man who pulled four beet factories practically from the scrapheap to full production; he is the man responsible for building up those food factories throughout the country. And we are told he should not be allowed in to where Mr. Deasy and the fellows with the dishwashers are sitting.
These are the things we must apply our commonsense to and get to work on. I would rather have one hour of General Costello's advice on any matter of agriculture than the whole box and dice of all the agricultural organisations put together, and I think I would be wise. There are a lot of other matters I should like to deal with but I am getting hoarse. I think I have said enough tonight.
Comment on this
Deputy Corry has given us a lot of valuable information during the past hour or so. I never thought he was the father of the NAC. I understood it was the Minister for Agriculture who established the Council but Deputy Corry has informed us tonight that it is his brainchild, that he has been plugging in his own Party for this type of consultative council for many years. He made a lot of contradictory statements which I shall not bother to comment on. I shall keep to the Estimate.
The Estimate as I see it is not very exciting. The extra amount of money for aids to agriculture in the coming year is not very exciting. The amount of £40,370,000 for 1967/68 shows an increase of about £4½ million but we must not lose sight of the fact that during the past few years the Estimate for the Civil Service has been increased from £19 million to £30 million. With wages and production costs rising steeply, is it not right and just that there should be a big increase in the Estimate for Agriculture? I disagree with Deputy Corry who said that a lot of the money in this Estimate goes to the aid of agriculture. Some of it goes to industry, as Deputy Corry admitted.
The Minister said there was an increase in milk production and dairy produce and he added that this was the cause of increased grants this year. I noted in a Sunday newspaper recently a report that there was an expanding market for milk and milk products but I also noted that the market for dried milk is dropping. It has dropped by some thousands of pounds according to some estimates published in the newspapers during the past few days.
One important matter I wish to draw the Minister's attention to is the position of our poultry and egg production. The only type of poultry production of any advantage to the people today is the broiler industry. That industry seems to be able to survive because of the large volume of support on the home market. I was amazed to discover recently that we are importing liquid eggs. The Minister should look into this. Egg production on a commercial basis here for the past few years has been completely uneconomic. Today you cannot produce eggs and sell them at 1/6d to 1/10d per dozen. The reason given for the grant of an import licence for liquid eggs was that it was in respect of a confectionery business for the manufacture of cakes and pastries for export. If we have to produce eggs for as little as 1/6d or 1/8d per dozen in the peak periods of the year, we should be able to produce sufficient eggs to keep that factory in production all the year round. Nowadays, with deep freeze and storage facilities, I cannot see any reason why we would not be able to do that. We have seen on the television and read in the papers of the nine million eggs going into cakes by a certain firm. I was amazed when I discovered that these eggs were not coming from the Irish farmer and that many of them were coming from Northern Ireland. I would ask the Parliamentary Secretary to remind the Minister to have a serious look at this because I feel it is a matter about which we should be able to do something.
Much has been said recently about our pigs and bacon. The number of pigs has dropped considerably in the past two or three years. The reason for this was the very low price for bonhams and the inadequate price for fattening pigs. The small man who used to feed two or four pigs had to go out of business because the profit was too low. Therefore, it was left to the farmer with the big herd, the man who could fatten 100 pigs. If he was able to get £1 apiece profit after three to four months feeding, he would be able to carry on. But the small man had to go out of production.
There should be some subsidy for pig feed. If we cannot increase the price, we will have to subsidise a balanced ration for the production of bacon pigs. It is too bad, now that the price of bacon on the British market seems to be improving and our grades have been stepped up, that we may not have sufficient bacon in the near future to fill our quota on the British market and to supply the home market. It has happened in the past few months that pigs were smuggled into this country because we had not enough for our home market.
For some years back the trend was all towards the Landrace breed of pig. Nobody wanted to buy a pig to fatten if it was not a Landrace pig. Now I notice at the pig fairs and marts in my part of the country that that trend has changed and they have gone back now to the Large White Landrace Cross. I think they have discovered that, properly fed and properly handled, it is a better bacon pig.
I sincerely hope the Minister will be able to do something to eliminate the problem about the price of the finished article and the price of pig feed. I remember 20 years ago, when the small farmers around me kept a couple of sows, they always sold the bonhams. At that time they could get £5 each for them at eight to nine weeks, and in those days you could buy one cwt of meal for about 16/-or 17/-. Today you sell bonhams for anything from £5 10s to £6 10s and the price per cwt of pig feed is in the region of £2, and if you go in for the baby pig feed, it is over £2. That is something that needs to be looked into. I have a feeling that the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries and the Minister for Industry and Commerce, who control the feed assembly industry in this country, would be able to secure some kind of justice for the men who work so hard to feed pigs and produce bacon. The feed assemblers are getting exorbitant profits. There is a loss somewhere, and it is not exactly the high price of barley, as we have been told.
Deputy Corry referred to the heifer scheme and said it had been a very beneficial exercise for the Government to indulge in, but he went on to say that he thought at the time, and apparently still thinks, something I thought at the time and said, as can be seen from the records of this House. It is that the £15 per head for the additional heifer was going to benefit the big man and that the small farmer would get little, if anything, out of it. That is exactly what happened. The big farmer who could feed 50 to 100 heifers, instead of feeding bullocks, drew the subsidy. He flooded the market with store cattle and it left the small man in the position that, when he produced his few cattle for sale at the end of the year, one and a half or two year olds, the big man was not a customer any more because he had enough of his own. This tended to put on the market a large number of these young cattle without any buyers for them.
Deputy Corry also said we exported 10,000 of these animals last year at a very good price. Granted it was not the price he was complaining about, but about somebody on his honeymoon in Italy who discovered something terribly wrong with our cattle over there. However, that is not the point I want to make. He said they were sold at remunerative prices. I have seen many of them and the price they were sold at when they were about one and a half years was in the region of £9 per cwt. But these cattle weighed only three cwt or three and a quarter cwt. That was a very small sum of money for what we would term the finished product. We were finished with them in any case; they were going for export. Each beast had cost a subsidy of £15 and it was maintained in this country for a year and a half. That is not the type of cattle we want to export. The type of beast we want to export is a beast that is almost ready for slaughter. That is the only type of best that it is economic for this country to export and on which the farmer can make a profit.
The reason I refer to this matter is that we have heard a great deal recently about ordered marketing of our produce. In fairness to the Department, I should say that they went a long way to try to improve the marketing of dairy produce in England and other places and they are meeting with some success. However, the Government should have done something at the time the £15 subsidy was introduced in order to increase the number of cattle in the country to ensure that there would be a market for the increased cattle.
For the past year and a half the NFA have been pressing for the establistment of a meat marketing board. I do not think there would be anything wrong in having such a board. It would provide a system of ordered marketing and it would not mean that the dead meat export trade would be put in the hands of a few people. Producer members, exporters and representatives of the Department of Agriculture would be the people to man such a board. With that type of personnel I do not think any board could go too far wrong.
The trouble in this country is that when boards are established the producer members are crowded out. That is a pity. Civil servants of the Department of Agriculture and persons engaged in a big way in the trade are appointed, to the detriment of the producer members. A number of producer members should be appointed to all such boards and the boards should explore markets for dead meat in European countries. I know that that exploration has been taking place and that at the moment we are experiencing a bit of bother in continental countries. It is sincerely hoped that that will right itself in time.
I should like to comment on the dispute between the Department and the Minister and the National Farmers Association. A great deal has been said inside and outside the House about that matter. The position is a very serious one. I should be very glad if anything could be done at this stage to bring about negotiations between the parties because any dispute like this that continues for too long does not do anybody any good. Production will suffer. While there are decent respectable farmers in jail who could not be classified as criminals, there are upsets in the home and on the farm and production is bound to suffer and there will be high feeling between neighbours and between the Department and their advisers.
I notice from a report in the papers within the past day or two that our agricultural advisers have been asked by circular from the Minister for Agriculture to notify any cases of intimidation. I do not know whether that is true or not but I read it in a paper this very evening. If that is the position and if things are coming to that pass, it is really too bad.
Comment on this
If I may intervene, I should like to say that it is not true. What has been asked is that if people cannot send their milk which they have produced through their own labour to a creamery, the Department then be notified.
Comment on this
By the staff there to serve the farming community. Unfortunately, too much has been taken for granted as regards the liberalities that might appertain to the commandment, "Thou shalt not steal." You can steal a person's character and you are doing just as much injustice. You can steal his hard-won effort and work and production and you are doing him an injustice. It does not necessarily mean that you have to hold a person up at the point of a gun and steal the money out of his pocket. You can also take his produce from him.
Comment on this
I am making this point because I read it in the paper. If it is true, it is really too bad. I have been a member of the County Meath Committee of Agriculture for the past ten or 12 years. We have a very fine staff of advisory officers, as fine a staff as one could get in any county in Ireland.
Comment on this
Yes. We got it very hard in certain areas in Meath, especially in the poorer parts and in the case of the poorer farmers, to get farmers to accept the advisory service, to invite the advisory officer in and to take his advice. Over the years we have fairly well succeeded in doing that and I should not like it if at this stage any ill-feeling should arise between the farmers and the advisory officers through any action of the Department of Agriculture. That is the only point I want to make. I sincerely hope that the Parliamentary Secretary is right when he says the statement is wrong. Nevertheless, I read it in the paper.
Comment on this
They are not involved. The Department's staff have been asked to protect the interests of ordinary producers.
Comment on this
Nobody asked me and I am a member of a committee of agriculture. I want to say that if there is anything that I could do to help to bring about negotiations between the NFA and the Minister for Agriculture I would be quite willing to do it and I would stay up all night to do it.
Comment on this
It is fitting that I, as one of the city Deputies, would say at least a few words on behalf of one of the most important sections of the community, the consuming public. Listening to the inflammatory speeches here this evening, it struck me that members of the Opposition, rather than desiring to see the dispute terminated, tended to inflame the situation still further by the commission of character assassination in relation to the former Minister and the present Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries.
In relation to this dispute which has been in existence for some time, it has been made perfectly clear by the Taoiseach and by the Minister for Agriculture the terms on which a just settlement can be made, the terms on which the NFA can meet the Minister. The Minister has indicated on many occasions that he is only too willing and anxious to have the views and the assistance of the NFA together with the other farming organisations in relation to the various problems that arise from time to time in the development of our agricultural programme and policy. It would seem that the NFA by persisting in their action and in their refusal to associate with other members of the farming community are doing a great disservice to a very large section of that community and to themselves in the long run. In that organisation there are men of outstanding ability, men of substance, who have good ideas, and it is a pity to see the dispute being prolonged and the ideas lost at a stage when everyone believes it is essential that we get together on every occasion possible and have a full discussion on agricultural problems.
It is quite clear to this organisation, as it has been clear to other organisations, that they themselves can terminate the dispute tomorrow if they are prepared to obey the law as is required of all citizens of the State. There can be no exceptions to this. Listening to the speeches here tonight, one would gather that there should be one law to apply to the people living in the cities and elsewhere and another to those engaged in the NFA campaign, that the regulations in respect of offences that have been committed should be relaxed in favour of these people. They should realise that the decisions of the court must be upheld. It would seem there are sections of the House who on occasions want to see the law upheld and on other occasions feel, for political reasons, that it is wise to say that certain sections of the community should be allowed to do as they choose.
In relation to the recent produce strike, as a Dublin Deputy, I feel that strike hurt no one but the housewives and little children in our city, the housewives who were forced to pay high prices for farm produce and who in some cases, when their money was expended at the end of the week, were deprived of the necessaries of life because many of the items were unobtainable. I deplore this action and I ask the Government to ensure that, where there is an effort to deprive the people of the necessaries of life such as happened in the not too distant past, the supply lines will be kept open. This was probably only the second occasion in the history of the country that food was turned back; the previous occasion was during the Famine. On this occasion it was turned back by people who said that rather than allow those who were attempting to deliver it to give it to the people who required it, it should be pushed down their throats. We have a duty here to ensure that the housewives of this city, who pay a great proportion of the taxes that go to meet the subsidies the farmers get, will get the foodstuffs they require.
This very important section of the community, the housewives, have to pay the highest possible prices for the commodities they need. It is regrettable that there is a group of middlemen who are virtually robbing the housewives of this city. These middlemen take no part whatsoever in the production of these commodities. They can sit back in their office armchairs up to their ankles in carpet and, far removed from the scene of activity, they can, by their methods of distribution, direct vast sums into their pockets at the expense of the housewife. All this money could be diverted to the farmers and mean a saving to the housewives if there were marketing facilities which are not there at the moment. In addition to that, the housewives are the victims of suspect distribution groups or rings in this city handling farm produce.
The Minister will have to take a serious look at the situation in relation to Dublin city. We have heard a great deal of talk about what should be done for the producer, but there is also the consumer without whom the producers would be out of business. This is a section that has been overlooked. I have not heard one Deputy speak of the consumers in this city or in any other city, Cork and elsewhere, although in other cities they are not as badly placed as we are in regard to marketing. We are so far removed that we here in Dublin have to pay higher prices in order to meet the requirements imposed by the rings, cartels and the various groups that control the supply of potatoes and other essential commodities.