Committee on Finance. - Vote 37—Agriculture (Resumed).
Contributions 98–217 of 217. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
It has. Deputy Cunningham knows as much about a fat bullock as a fat bullock knows about him.
Comment on this
I earned a fairly good living in that business before I came into this House, and if it ever comes to pass that I am not in this House, I will continue to provide for my wife and large family from that industry.
Comment on this
Through the Chair, may I ask Deputy Fanning does he agree that the £15 heifer subsidy has reduced the quality of cattle in Tipperary?
Comment on this
You must have had damn bad cattle there. Deputy Nolan is here. Through the Chair, may I be permitted to ask Deputy Nolan does he agree——
Comment on this
I wonder would Deputy Harte make his speech and abandon this cross-examination? We are not in court.
Comment on this
The reason I am using this method is that Deputy Cunningham asked did I agree that the £15 heifer subsidy had done harm to the cattle industry.
Comment on this
I am not running down the Donegal cattle industry. I believe that every small farmer, because he was living on a meagre income, and because he was tempted to grab this £15 subsidy, had every heifer that he owned serviced so that he could claim the £15, and claim it legally. That, Deputy Cunningham, is the reason why a certain type of cattle are substandard in Donegal. If you do not take my word for it, perhaps you would speak to some of your colleagues in the Fianna Fáil Party who are contesting the county council elections, and if they are manly enough, they will tell you I am right.
Comment on this
You are talking as a school teacher—theoretically. The £15 heifer subsidy has resulted in what Deputy Nolan, a Fianna Fáil Deputy from Carlow-Kilkenny said last night——
Comment on this
The scrub bull was encouraged by the £15 which was dangled in front of the farmer's nose——
Comment on this
In spite of what Deputy Cunningham says—and I will take him to task at any chapel gate on the next two Sundays——
Comment on this
I do not have to. We also had the statement by the then Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Haughey, when he returned to Dublin immediately after his visit to London with the former Taoiseach, when he announced that the trade agreement between Great Britain and this country would result in £10 million being put into the purse of the farmers of this country——
Comment on this
——in the first year. He was challenged during that long drawn out debate by practically every Deputy in Fine Gael and Labour to say exactly how he calculated that——
Comment on this
Deputy Nolan might read the debate. We voted on the principle of it but not on the details. We believe that there had to be a trade agreement between this country and Great Britain and, remember, this has been the policy of the Fine Gael Party since the inception of the State. Might I remind Deputy Nolan it was not always the policy of the Fianna Fáil Party, but we are glad they have been converted to our way of thinking. If we voted for it, it was because we believed in this approach.
Comment on this
I am criticising the details of it. I criticised them during that very long debate. The previous Minister, Deputy Haughey, was asked during that debate by practically every Opposition Deputy how he calculated £10 million would be put into the pockets of the farmers in the first year of the Agreement, but he declined to answer. In fact, £6 million less went to agriculture in those 12 months. This is another example of the muddled thinking of successive Fianna Fáil Ministers for Agriculture. Five or six weeks ago, the present Minister announced he had new ideas about agricultural committees, but this was a complete turnabout from what the same Minister voted against last year in the House. Fianna Fáil Ministers have the knack of saying the popular thing. The Minister's predecessor considered it was popular to come back to Dublin Airport and mention he had sold a few beefsteaks to the Germans, but those beefsteaks must still be in the deep freeze. Twelve months before that, he announced that £10 million would go to agriculture in the first 12 months of the Trade Agreement.
Agriculture is a major industry in this country. Unless the Government, irrespective of what Party are in power, have the confidence and goodwill of the agricultural industry, the best cannot be obtained from that industry. By no stretch of the imagination can one say that goodwill exists between agriculture and the present Fianna Fáil Government. That may be for different reasons. Certainly, the present Minister and his predecessor have done nothing to create harmony and closer relations with the organised bodies of the farming community. I heard a wisecrack made at a street corner in the last week that one of the reasons why the Minister's policy would not grow was that the men he had planted would not blossom.
I ask myself, when the Minister sees fit to appoint all outsiders to the NAC, persons not elected to this House, how he can relate that to the fact that he considers those elected to local authorities the best representatives on committees of agriculture. I have no axe to grind with any member of the NAC, and I wish that body well. I hope it makes a success of agriculture. But if the Minister had invited the NFA and other organised bodies who have given such great service to the agricultural community to play a more active part in the NAC——
Comment on this
I do not wish to interrupt the Deputy, but did the Minister not invite the NFA to join the NAC?
Comment on this
These organised bodies gave great service to agriculture. They are composed of men who came together to promote, organise, co-operate, discuss and do everything good to create better conditions in agriculture. They did all this, free, gratis and for nothing. If that service had been acknowledged and they were invited to play a more prominent part in a national association, I believe—and so does Deputy Fanning—that the NAC would have a brighter future. Deputy Fanning asked me were the NFA not invited to nominate two members to the NAC. The answer to that is that they were. But my point is that, if the Minister had allowed more people who had no committed political views to be associated with the NAC, then its future would have been more secure than it is at present.
I do not wish to be associated with any controversy between the NFA and the NAC, nor indeed any controversy which would not help in the present dispute between the NFA and the Government, but I am free to express the opinion that people prominently associated with the NFA, particularly in Donegal, have organised that association not for self-glorification but because there was a need for it. They have done this at great expense to themselves. They have been blackguarded by people who disagree with the actions of the NFA and who say that this was for their own personal gain. I do not have to spell out the names of the people I am thinking of. The people of Donegal know that these are prominent citizens who have given great service to agriculture, free, gratis and for nothing, not because they needed to organise markets for their own financial gain and not because they had to become involved in agriculture to earn a living. As Deputy Cunningham knows, most of these people could earn a living outside of agriculture. I would like to think they have organised the NFA, have become prominently identified with it and have accepted public remarks made by Ministers—remarks which were unbecoming to their office—for the sole purpose of creating a healthier agricultural community in Donegal.
The point I was making when Deputy Fanning interrupted me was that if people like this, who have the sole interests of agriculture at heart, were invited to give their views, even if those views were not accepted, they have much more to offer to the agricultural industry than Deputy Fanning or Deputy Harte. Deputy Fanning is a farmer. He is trained in his own line of thought, the line of thought that is most beneficial to Deputy Fanning as a farmer running his own farm. It is likewise with every other Member of this House who is engaged in farming. But it should be remembered that men who have made a study of agriculture, men who have associated themselves with the problems of the smallholder, with the problems of what we describe in Donegal as the muck farmers, have a broad approach to our agricultural problem. It is unlikely in the extreme that they do this work for their own special gain or self-glorification. I am not a bad judge of human nature and therefore I must conclude that in the ranks of the NFA throughout the Twenty-Six Counties and in the ranks of the other agricultural organisations men of overall ability are to be found. These men would not have reached leadership in their own organisation if they did not have the qualities of leaders.
Therefore, I cannot see why a new Minister for Agriculture, taking office when the NFA and the Government were at each others throats, should embark on a policy of promoting a new association and of ignoring the qualities which these men have and which they have been giving to agriculture for the benefit of agriculture and for the good of every individual in this country.
Comment on this
Perhaps not all of them, but certainly most of them. I am convinced that it is now time for the Minister to take politics out of the NAC. If he does that, he will be congratulated by me and by every other member of the Fine Gael Party. I know that in County Donegal this body was received with very mixed feelings and that now it is lost in despair and it is felt that no good can come of it as long as the Minister for Agriculture cannot sit down as chairman of that body in the full feeling that he has the goodwill of every section of the agricultural community. No Minister for Agriculture can succeed in conditions in which he has not full co-operation of the farming community. The Minister sits in the hottest seat of Government and we are only kidding ourselves if we think that any Minister can succeed without the goodwill of the agricultural community.
That is a prerequisite for the success of any Minister and I would strongly urge that the Minister should take the earliest opportunity to sink his pride and come to the sensible conclusion that no success can be gained until such time as he comes to terms with the NFA. I do not want to become involed in the question of whether the NFA are right or wrong. They had certain claims to make and in a democratic way, they went about claiming their rights. I support the view expressed by other members of this Party that they were wrong to use the tactics they used during the road blockade. But people from that walk of life are not criminals. It has been said by more important people than I in this House that the will of the people can never be wrong, and if the vast majority of responsible people are driven to take action similar to that taken by the NFA in the middle of January, it surely emphasises the strength of thought which was rampant in the NFA at that time.
I do not wish to repeat the story of how that row started. It is sufficient for me to say that no matter who was right or who was wrong, the position is that unless the Government sit down and accept some of the views of the NFA, some of the views which some backbench members of Fianna Fáil have described as being healthy views in relation to agriculture, unless the Government thrash out their differences with the NFA, then not alone are the farming community going to bear the burden of these differences but every other individual in every other walk of life is going to have to pay for the blunders made by the Government.
In conclusion, may I reiterate the opinion that if the farming community are given an opportunity, they can produce the goods? If they are given that opportunity and if the Government face up to their responsibility in relation to major drainage, land reclamation, and in making available to the farming community limestone at a reasonable cost, then a great step forward will have been made.
One of the major difficulties in agriculture at the moment is lack of capital. Therefore, the Government should make available to smallholders credit free of interest repayable over a short term. It would have been a more profitable and more successful policy if the Agricultural Credit Corporation had given proper service to the people most in need of capital.
When Deputy Nolan was speaking last night, I interrupted to ask him did he know that one farmer got money from the Agricultural Credit Corporation to buy a Mercedes car. Deputy Nolan seemed to think that this was a slanderous statement on my part. The fact of the matter is that two years ago I raised this matter on the Adjournment and the present Taoiseach, who was then Minister for Finance, is on the records of the House as having stated that he had at that time given a directive that money should not be lent in this direction any longer. If Deputy Nolan does not accept my word, if he speaks to me privately, I will quote the volume where he can read the report of the debate on the Adjournment.
I conclude by saying that unless the agricultural industry is promoted to first place in the list of priorities by the Government, prosperity is not even around the corner for the country: emigration will continue; unemployment will be a major problem; our people will be condemned to live in the social conditions which they must tolerate at the moment. These problems can be solved if agriculture is given a new deal. If the Minister or the Government or any future Government accept that any organised group of farmers who agitate for better conditions are doing so because they believe that agriculture must get a better deal, and not in the spirit that these are a gang of crooks and cranks parading and demonstrating for their own glorification, then many things I would have liked to have seen in this country long ago can be achieved in the not too distant future.
Comment on this
As a rural Deputy, I have always considered the debate on the Estimate for Agriculture to be one of the most important, if not the most important, of the debates that take place in this House. Every aspect of agriculture has been covered in this debate, possibly more adequately than I can cover it now.
It is a pity that in this year of 1967 there should be any division of opinion between any farming organisation and any other farming organisation and between any farming organisation and the Government. The Government of a country as small as ours have an obligation to help the major industries. They have a duty to help the primary industry and the one that is sociologically the most important. It is a tragedy that there should be in this day and age any division of opinion between the Government and a major farming organisation.
I have never said anything in public about the dispute between the Government and the farmers because I would hesitate to do anything that might widen a breach that might do untold harm not alone to the farmers but to the economy of the country and to the image of this country abroad. But I do know that the NFA have done remarkable things for agriculture since they were established. There have been many and varied farming organisations which did their best for their own branch of agriculture. The NFA set out to weld together the many and varied farming organisations, and to do more than that. They set up a panel of experts to examine every aspect of agriculture so that they themselves would know the exact position with regard to production, with regard to selling, with regard to markets and the success that might be achieved in other markets. They got their experts to examine every facet of Irish farming, something that was never done before.
They also established a paper which in its own right can compare favourably with any farming journal in any country in the world. That in itself is a remarkable achievement for which they deserve credit not alone from the farming community but from every citizen of the State. As I have said, it is a tragedy that there is a difference of opinion between the Government and that organisation. I firmly believe that the former Minister for Agriculture made the greatest mistake of his life when he did not meet the farmers on the day they marched into Dublin. Had he met them on that day, there would be a different situation existing now. If he had told them that he had not the money to put into operation the things they demanded—and the things they demanded are the things farmers are entitled to get and will have to get eventually, regardless of what Minister gives them to them— we would have a different climate of opinion and a different situation in the country today. However, it did not happen. It is more difficult every day to find a reasonable method of approach to the NFA, and every day that goes by will make it still more difficult, but it is the duty of the Minister to attempt to find a method of meeting the NFA and getting over the difficulties that exist in negotiations between them.
What the NFA are demanding are, in fact, the rights achieved by trade unions from the day Jim Larkin came out in Dublin town and organised the first trade union against the might of a British Empire, and with bloodshed. Trade unions achieved the right to negotiate and to put forward their views. It is only right and just that the members of the greatest organisation in the country should have that right accorded to them. The Minister will be accepted as the greatest man of all time if he achieves that.
The jackboot is not the method of dealing with a farming organisation. Farmers fought for the land of Ireland against tyrannical laws and against tyrannical landlordism. They fought with might and main in days when their subsistence was very low, in days when they were barely able to live. That engendered in the farmers an independence of spirit. That spirit is still there and will, please God, exist for all time. That independence of spirit makes it more difficult to approach a farmer, but it is an independence of spirit that every Irishman will admire. I would appeal to the Minister, even at this late stage, to come down off his high horse. We are a small country. There is no need for the Minister to act like a minister in Katanga or any other African state. We are a mature State here today. The Minister will not lose face if he meets the NFA. No Irish Minister will ever lose face by meeting the organisation of people of his own country, particularly people in the basic industry. Now is the time for him to meet them, and every day that it is postponed will make it more difficult.
To come to some of the organisational matters in the Department, in the rural areas, as the Minister well knows, particularly in the area from which I come, the pilot areas have been established. During the last year or two the pilot areas have been getting concessions. They have been getting advice and instruction also from the instructors. I would ask that an interim report be issued from time to time if not to the general public, at least to the members of the county committees of agriculture to tell them how this thing is getting along, what results are coming from it, whether one field is making greater progress than another. We in the county committees of agriculture are vitally interested in this. Through lack of knowledge we are not able to say whether or not an additional instructor should go to the area, or whether or not the instructor is a good enough man for the job.
As a member of a county committee of agriculture, I am more interested in that branch of education—because a branch of education it is—than in any other type of Departmental education brought down to farming level. The members of the committees of agriculture know everything about the local area. They are familiar with every aspect of it, and they would be good judges as to whether or not the work of the pilot areas was going according to the clock and whether the best results were being obtained from the methods used or whether the methods might be changed. I would appeal to the Minister to have an interim report issued on progress in all the areas.
Now the areas have been increased and I believe the decision is that areas alongside the existing ones will be taken in. There are two schools of thought about that. In my county certain members of the committee thought it would be better to take in other areas in the county that had a more varied type of farming, but the majority view was—and I agree with this myself—that it was better to take in the immediate areas, to enlarge the existing one so that the instructor or instructors, if it was necessary to put in another one, would be branching out in a widening circle rather than taking small areas here and there and attempting to do something in them. From the reports that we do get, though not officially, I have a feeling that progress is being made in the pilot areas. That is a good sign and it is something I am sure farmers on all sides of the House will be glad to hear.
The result of the calved heifer scheme has been talked about here from varied angles during the debate. However, the news the other day that we had over 100,000 extra cattle in the country for which there was no market surely must have shocked many people. It may mean we shall be faced with a depression, but it must mean that we shall be faced with depressed cattle prices in the market before the end of this year.
The scrub bull was mentioned here earlier and it was looked upon as a bit of a joke. I am sure the Minister and his Department and every officer of the Department throughout the country know well that scrub bulls were let loose and that the type of heifer used for progeny was not one for which any standard had been set, so that every farming Deputy knows we have in the country at the moment a great number of sub-standard cattle. If the 100,000 or more extra cattle we have were of good quality, it might be possible, by some Government action, to have them slaughtered and to have markets sought for them or even to have them kept in deep freeze for a certain period. However, they are not cattle that can come to any marketable value or weight in the near future, and I am afraid they will be a drug on the market for a long time to come. I know the Minister can say he had nothing to do with that. At the same time, I disagreed with the policy from the start in the county committee of agriculture and elsewhere. Although I am no expert, I foresaw that a situation like this could arise. If we had an unlimited market or if the markets some of the Fianna Fáil people used to talk about had materialised, then we would not have this number of cattle on our hands today.
I would appeal to the Minister to take action now. He has been given the warning sign. He has been told that the cattle are there, and it is the duty of the Minister and his Department to explore every avenue to get shut of this large number of cattle that will be a drug on the market, and also to ensure that the people who are rearing them will get adequate prices for them.
I do not know if the figures have come to light from the acreage of tillage this year. I would have imagined that due to depressed cattle prices, we would have an increase in tillage. However, the acreage of wheat has fallen. The acreage of beet has fallen. The acreage of barley may have risen, and I would expect that it would; I have not the figures at the moment. I remember some time ago when everybody on the Fianna Fáil side of the House said that if we could grow enough wheat, this country would be out of the wood. Wheat was glorified as the crop to grow.
Everybody knows that up to a certain point the growing of wheat is an excellent thing. Great work has been done in the Institute in breeding better types of wheat, and I see no reason why we should not keep our wheat-growing to the maximum, but we have to face the fact that we can buy wheat in the world market at a lower price and we can sell the loaf of bread baked from that wheat at a lower price to the consumer. One has to strike a balance. Balance is important from the point of view of our external balance of payments; it is important from the point of view of labour content and potential; it is important from the point of view that a native product gives the farmer some return. Unfortunately the growing of wheat is gradually declining.
I am sorry, too, to see a decline in beet acreage. The Sugar Company did a remarkable job of work in the early years of its establishment. I know that Fianna Fáil claim that they established the Sugar Company. I shall make no claims beyond stating the fact that it was established in 1926 under a Cumann na nGaedheal Government. That company has done an amazing amount of good work. It put a great deal of money into research in order to breed better seed and find suitable pesticides and weed killers. It did work that no organisation ever did before in this country and it has achieved remarkable results in the breeding of a better type of seed and improved methods of production, to say nothing of a higher sugar content able to command a better price. Whether or not beet growing will continue to be viable is a question, I find it difficult to say. It is said we are paying the highest price in Europe for our beet. We are also getting the highest sugar content per ton. If that is so, I cannot see why it should not be viable. Why are farmers not inclined to grow beet? There is machinery at their disposal today that they did not have ten and 15 years ago. Beet has become a completely mechanised crop. The right kind of fertiliser has been found for it, a fertiliser which will give the best suger content.
Comment on this
I do not accept that. The Sugar Company could take twice as many acres if they could get them.
Comment on this
The point is they do not. Why did they refuse contracts? How could they not have enough if they had too many?
Comment on this
I have here the Minister's statement. The figures are supplied presumably by the Central Statistics Office. In the year 1963, we had 88,300 acres; in the year 1966, we had 53,500 acres. That answers the Deputy's question. I want to know why it is the beet acreage has decreased. I am a firm believer in beet growing and the day beet growing goes out will be a bad day for farming.
Comment on this
The land west of the Shannon can grow beet but it cannot grow as high a tonnage per acre as other parts of the country. The soils are not suitable. Secondly, more fertiliser has to be put in in order to take out a certain tonnage and, the more fertiliser you put in west of the Shannon, the lower the sugar content because basically the soil is lacking in the proper nutrients. The question of labour enters into the picture, too. The farmer in the midlands has the advantage of mechanisation. Beet is mechanised from start to finish. The machines are there. I see no reason why beet growing could not be upped in the midlands and even in the West to some extent.
In the West oats can be grown quite successfully, but the growing of oats has not been encouraged since the British left the country. The same consideration has not been given to oats as has been given to barley and wheat. There has been no research to find the right strain to suit the different conditions. The Agricultural Institute are to be congratulated on the work they have done in breeding different varieties of seed designed to give the best yield and to stand up instead of lodging. If a subsidy were given in the West for the growing of oats, I believe there would be an improvement in the present situation. Oats produce more food than any other cereal, and a better type of food. It may be a little more expensive but the finest men in Ireland in the past were reared on oatmeal stirabout. If a calf is not thriving, he gets oatmeal and the juice of oatmeal to bring him right.
The subsidisation of oat-growing in the West would help the small western farmer. I specify the West because it is my firm belief that agriculture should be zoned; areas in which particular crops can be grown successfully should be allowed to grow those crops. We can grow oats and potatoes in the West as good as anywhere else in the country. It is well known that there may be lime deficiencies and that there are lime deficiencies which we should like to see made up in the western areas but it is possible to grow oats and potatoes where there is no lime.
I appeal to the Minister and his Department not to stay in any rut. The time for new thinking has come. There is no use in saying that we will stick to a policy which gave results in the past. The Government and the Department must look to the future, must try for something new. They must try to obtain from each area the production it is capable of yielding.
I give great credit to the Agricultural Institute for the work they are doing. A booklet is published and is distributed to Members of Dáil Éireann, to members of county committees of agriculture, and so on. I think the work of the Institute is not brought down fast enough to the level of the CAO and the local instructors. More and more courses should be held for instructors. They should be brought at intervals to the Agricultural Institute and shown the progress made from month to month so as to keep abreast of events rather than think in terms of what they heard when they came out of an agricultural college ten or 15 years ago. There is a need for courses for people engaged in all aspects of agriculture, and the more of them the better.
I hope the Minister will find the money fast for the drainage and reclamation of land and for the other projects in which the Department is interested. We are well aware that, when he was Minister for Local Government, our present Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries was famous for telling us, across the floor of this House, that there were wagons of money around the corner. On every occasion on which he was asked a question, the money was always there and, fair play to him, he got away with it even when the money was seldom there. When we asked our local authorities if money was available for this grant or that grant or for this purpose or that purpose, we were told: "No, not yet". The Minister was able to do that kind of thing. I know he understands agriculture himself; he comes from a county of small farmers.
I asked the Minister earlier to try to make a break-through with the NFA and to finish for all time any antagonism that may exist between the Government and the farmers. I ask him to take as much money as possible from the Minister for Finance for the farming organisations already established by the Department and in order to establish new ones to help the farming community.
Comment on this
Having listened to the debate to-night and to what the previous speaker has said and having read the debate over the past week or so on the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture, I must congratulate the Minister, the Parliamentary Secretary and the officers of the Department for the concise and accurate manner in which they prepared the Estimate and the report. I intend to speak on this Estimate in both a favourable and a critical manner.
First of all, I do not agree with previous speakers from the Opposition benches who stated that the former Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries and the present Minister have made mistakes in relation to their attitude to the campaign of the NFA against the Government and against the law of this country. I think that both the NFA and the Fine Gael Party feel they have made mistakes in relation to this campaign. It is rather evident now that the Fine Gael Party are as sorry as the NFA are in relation to the stand they have taken, both privately and publicly, against the State, against the Government and against the authority of the people of Ireland.
I congratulate the Minister on obtaining the finance for the payment of unemployment assistance the whole year round to thousands of our small farmers, particularly those in the West and the South-West. I congratulate him on obtaining additional finance to enable derating of the first £20 of land valuation and to enable additional subsidies and grants to be made available for small farmers such as for the provision of milk coolers, and so on.
I should like to refer in particular to the services being provided by the county committees of agriculture. The existing CAOs and the local agricultural instructors are doing an excellent job. Perhaps the Minister would take a hard look at this service. I feel that, in lieu of the existing services, if we had a scheme which would provide for pilot farms in each county, rather than an agricultural instructor in areas in the county, it might benefit the farming community more. If we had a pilot farm covering certain areas in each county the farmers in the area would look at the farm as a pilot one and, provided it was run in an economic fashion and showed profits and showed a way, the agricultural community in general in each area would benefit from the experiment. The agricultural instructors and the agricultural service as a whole would benefit from this experiment.
The establishment of small co-operatives would go a long way towards the solving of problems in agricultural communities such as exist at the moment in the South and West. I refer to small co-operatives which would cater for pig fattening stations, for a pool of machinery for the benefit of the farmers in the co-operative, and also, perhaps, for small minor industries that could supplement the earnings of the farming communities in these areas. I was very glad to note that the Minister for Finance provided in his Budget for special development schemes in the underdeveloped counties which have county development teams at present. The bulk of this £¼ million should be channelled into such minor co-operatives and the schemes should cater in a large way for the smaller farmers in these areas.
Particular attention should be paid to the disposal of skim milk which is now posing a problem in many areas, particularly this year when milk production has increased beyond all expectations. I recommend to the Minister that he should give special consideration to any proposals put up to him and his Department for the disposal of skim milk. The Land Project is serving a very worthy purpose at the moment and I have no fault to find with the way in which the scheme is administered. I do feel, however, that special consideration should be given to applications for a second grant in cases where the operation of Section B of the Land Project proved a failure in the past. I know of some cases where schemes carried out under this section have not measured up to the schemes carried out under the previous section.
I should also like to refer to the £15 heifer scheme. The scheme was originally designed to increase the cattle population and despite the Opposition's criticism, it has achieved that purpose to a great extent. When this scheme was introduced, the Fine Gael Party did their best to take credit for it in so far as they stated that they had first hinted at this scheme in one of their written policies.
Comment on this
To speak on an Estimate such as this, embracing as it does the whole field of agriculture and fisheries, is to undertake quite a comprehensive survey of all the things that matter, of all the things that affect farmers, big and small, fishermen, big and small, all over the country and around our coasts. I have often felt, and still feel that in spite of the fact that there is a small farms division in the Department of Agriculture, the economy agriculturally is the economy of the good land, the economy of the wider tracts, the economy of greater scope, the economy that allows for mechanisation and all other modern methods that can be employed in agriculture. Deputy Lyons referred to the difficulty, if not the impossibility, of employing these modern methods in what he calls small fields. I therefore think that the small farms division in the Department of Agriculture and the various arms and advisory services that extend from it, via the Agriculture Institute, should be more publicised and, in the result, more advantage taken from it and, coincidentally, gained from it in that way.
Until such time as we take stock of the fact that there are these two divisions of the good land and the broad acres and the less good land and the smaller fields, then I do not think we will achieve the balanced result that is sought to be achieved from both official moves and voluntary aid directed to what they call the saving of the West and, of course, the saving of the West must include the whole coast from Derry to West Cork. Now, how could that be done? Certain steps have been taken; some of them have been successful and some have yet to be proved, but by and large enough is not being done at official level. It all springs from the fact that at official level neglect was so monstrous over so long a period that it is difficult now financially to curb this tide of population erosion in the West and the flight of people from it. There is no use now blaming this one or that one, this Party or that Party, for what happened. Everybody knows where the blame lies but the cure will not be effected by perpetually pinpointing blame, unless at the same time every effort is made and every possible source used to the full to improve the situation.
I do not think that enough use is being made of the advisory services. The advisory services are there. They are limited, of course, to some extent but I doubt very much if the people know sufficient of them to be able to avail of the great advantages they confer; nor, on the other hand, do I think there is sufficient communication as between the advisory services, either on the national or the local level, and the people they are meant to benefit. Something must be done in a very big way in the line of propaganda in this respect. It is no use going out on occasions prior to a local election or a by-election and saying: "We intend to set up a pilot area here or there; we are going to have a scheme for mountain-sheep farming somewhere else", if the gap between the promise and the performance is wide, as the gap generally tends to be when the promise is prior to some political activity, and once it is over the necessity for the performance slips away into oblivion.
These services should be more extended and, over and above that, the greatest advantage probably that any Government or any Department of Agriculture could confer upon the people in the smallholdings where things are difficult at present would be to make available to them lime, phosphates and artificial manures at the lowest possible prices. I should prefer to see some of the money that is being wasted at present, and was for a long time past, directed towards a subsidy to be used for this purpose. We are living now, particularly in the west of Ireland—and again in the west of Ireland, I include all the areas of which I have spoken—in times when the fairs have been turned from conventions of profit and enjoyment into meetings of gloom and cynicism, where small farmers walk their cattle long distances to the nearest fair day town or village, and in the evening walk them back again, not having been asked in the course of the day where they were going.
It must be a source of immense sadness—and indeed it is—to the father of a family, or the head of a household, who took his animals over the past year or so to fairs of this type and brought them home again, when he set out with hope that with the money he would get, he would be able to pay the rates, or buy the extra clothing that might be needed, or set aside a little for Christmas and for other necessaries or contingencies that might arise from time to time. How the people who are depending on these fairs nowadays are managing to overcome these difficulties, I do not know, but this is something of which the Department must take cognisance.
I recall—I think it was in January, 1966—when we were discussing the terms of the then new Trade Agreement, and I think it must be said fairly that we all, perhaps without enough study, welcomed the change in the qualification period for the British subsidy by its reduction from three months to two months. I am told that in the three-month period which obtained up to the Anglo-Irish Trade Agreement the big cattle, the strong cattle, had to wait too long to qualify for this subsidy or bounty, but that the three-month period was necessary for the small cattle to overcome the hardship of being brought from distant parts of the west of Ireland via accommodation grass to the cattle marts, then to the ships, then to more accommodation grass, and then to as far inland in England as York, Nottingham and such centres. In the three months, the cattle which conformed peculiarly to this area, that is, the west of Ireland, were able to regain that loss.
Now what is happening is that the demand for strong animals continues. There is no demand for small animals because they cannot within the two months make up the loss of weight caused by the hardships I have described. Accordingly, they are not profitable to the cross-Channel buyer. That is the argument I have heard used to explain the slackness at fairs in those areas where the small cattle are, and where they are so conformed, as I am told, that they cannot survive the test of the journey and the fast. Perhaps that is something that could be examined. If it is examined and it is revealed that there is any substance in it, I am sure the experts in the Department will be able to do something about it with their counterparts on the other side, because certainly the situation as it is is a frightening one, frightening not only to watch on the days these things are happening, that is, the fairdays, but frightening to contemplate in its consequences.
Reference was made to the calved heifer scheme. While there may have been merits in this scheme—and I am sure there were—they do not seem to have redounded to the profit of the small man again. It was easy under this scheme for a speculator to take large tracts of land, get hundreds of heifers in calf, have them examined and passed, and collect the £15 subsidy per head. For the small man, it involved extra time and extra room, and the benefit to him, while it was a benefit of a minimal kind, was nevertheless not great enough, and I am sure not as great as was originally intended.
Perhaps the calved heifer scheme has been a success for some and a failure for others, but there is one irritating aspect of it, in so far as it relates to the west of Ireland, at any rate, that is, the almost unbearable delays in payments after herds have been inspected and passed. If the money were allocated in sufficiency in accordance with any kind of accurate peep into the future, these delays should not take place. I have to write to the Department, much more often than I should like, on behalf of people who tell me that as far back as 1965 and early 1966 their small herds were examined and passed but no payments made yet. In one case I had to write to the Department of Agriculture at least seven times and in reply to five of those letters, received communications to the effect that my letters had been received and that they were looking into the matter. By persistence we have been successful in getting payments for all of them, with the exception of one case which is outstanding since 1966. This is stalling of the most awful kind because it is stalling on people who cannot afford to wait. I urge on those responsible in the Department to speed things up as much as they can.
Reference was made to milk. In the notes on the Department's activities, though four or five pages are devoted to milk and its by-products, apart from a reference to deliveries back to suppliers, there is no mention of skim milk. Deputy O'Hara referred to this point. Recently in Kilalla the three Deputies for North Mayo attended a meeting. Many things were discussed but the one which seemed to agitate the farmers present most was the question of a market for skim milk. The case was put very strongly for the creation of a market through some process or other. Vague references were made to the fact that a large co-operative in the south were interested in going to the west, particularly Mayo. I had heard something about it but had also heard that there is a tug-of-war between North and South Mayo as to which of the two constituencies would be selected for the factory. Of course the odds are in favour of South Mayo, with two Ministers tugging hard on the one hand and Deputy Calleary trying to get a foothold on the other. We hope such a tug-of-war is not taking place. Indeed it is not necessary because, wherever the factory is sited, if and when it is, the only requirement would appear to be proximity to flowing water. So much for that. I hope the Minister will deal with the problem of skim milk. It seemed to excite the people at that meeting.
What I deplore about not alone the Department of Agriculture but every other Department is this Annie Oakley performance that goes on—"anything you can do I can do better"—while the citizens, driven into cynicism, wait for a better performance. Reverting to cattle prices, we had the example, on the Free Trad Agreement, of the then Minister for Agriculture coming into the House on 24th March, 1966, and, on the Vote for Agriculture, saying, as reported at column 2243 of the Official Report for that day:
The increase of 10/- per live cwt in the guaranteed price for fat cattle and the increase of ¾d per lb. dead-weight in the guaranteed price for fat sheep and lambs will apply both to Irish stores fattened in Britain and to the quantities of Irish carcase beef and Irish carcase lamb on which British guarantee payments will be made under the terms of the Free Trade Area Agreement. The value to this country of these price increases is quite significant. The increase on cattle is equivalent to about £5 per beast and on the 638,000 stores we have undertaken to supply to Britain this would represent over £3 million. A very substantial proportion of this sum will be reflected back in the prices paid for the stores here.
Cattle are down by virtually £20 per head. In the face of the stories of today, this fairytale of yesterday makes unpleasant reading. At the time it was meant to be something to inspire and create joy but now it is a very mournful wail indeed. The House and the country are familiar with another promise of that time, namely the finding of a market for 2,000 cattle in Germany. I do not know what happened to them. Did they ever go?
Comment on this
Where are they? On 12th October, 1966, as reported at column 1148, the then Minister for Agriculture said this:
For some time, we have been pressing the German Government and the Commission in Brussels to afford us facilities for the export to Germany of a certain number of our cattle in what is commonly known as the "Off the grass" season. I am glad to say that we have met with a great deal of sympathy and understanding by the German Government and by the Commission in Brussels. It has now been agreed with the German Government to afford us facilities during the coming weeks for the export to Germany of 2,000 head of our cattle either in the form of live cattle or beef.
That was in October, 1966. I do not know where the 2,000 cattle are. This raising of people's hopes in a matter of this kind is bad. It is bad citizenship and it is bad for the economy. It is bad for the morale of the people, whether in agriculture or in any other sphere. This Annie Oakley demonstration can be produced as food for the electorate. I am listening to Ministers and Parliamentary Secretaries all over this country talking of progress in agriculture, talking of the Second Programme for Economic Expansion, the targets, the dynamic approach, the small farmers, what is happening to everybody, everything great and glorious, that we are marching along the road to prosperity, greater prosperity and greater production as every year passes.
Here is the Party of wheat. I remember when I came into this House first in 1954. I remember I was then opposite and I was listening to the stalwarts across here, one after the other, promising an all-Irish loaf, deploring the then prices and weeping for the wheat growers of this country. Included among them I remember was the present Minister for Lands, who made a tremendous frothy speech in favour of wheat growing.
Comment on this
What is the position under this Party of wheat? In 1959 there were 282,200 acres of wheat. In 1960, there were 365,995 acres, a very substantial increase but by 1961 it had gone down to 344,800 acres, not a very substantial decrease, but nevertheless a decrease. In 1962, it was down to 314,000, a decrease of 30,000 acres. In 1963, it was down to 232,700 acres; in 1964 to 214,400 acres, down again; in 1965 to 182,170; and in 1966 to 131,300 acres. Those are the people who used to talk about the dead hand of the Coalition. There they are. There is the dead hand. In every year the dead hand is smiting the ears of wheat. All that means, of course, that the wheat growing farmers are in their thousands every year losing confidence in this Administration.
I will not go through them all, year by year, but in 1959 in respect of oats there were 462,000 acres. In 1960 it was down to 425,000; in 1961, it was down to 367,000; in 1962, down to 346,000; in 1963, down to 331,700; in 1964, to 288,600, down again; in 1965, to 284,392, down almost by 100,000 acres; and in 1966, down to 242,800 acres. Where is the progress? Where is the faith of the farmers? Where is their confidence in this Administration? It is not to be found in this gloomy progression in the oatfields of this country.
Comment on this
Rye is so small that it is not necessary to mention it. The highest figure for it was in 1959 when it was 2,800 acres. In 1966 it was down by 1,400 to 1,400 acres. Sugar beet is definitely gone. It is obviously fighting the county council elections, as an Independent probably. In 1959 the acreage of sugar beet was 69,200. It was 68,306 acres in 1960, a small drop. It was up by 10,000 to 78,600 in 1961; it remained static at 78,000 in 1962, but it was up by 10,000 in 1963. It was down by nearly 9,000 in 1964 to 79,000 odd. It was down in 1965 to 65,548, and in 1966, last year, it was down to 53,500 acres. Where is the progress we hear about regarding the growing of beet?
In relation to wheat and other cereals, and bearing in mind the litany of decreasing production to which I have just referred, £24 million worth of wheat and cereals were imported in 1966, which could have been grown here in our own country, giving work to our own people and keeping them at home in lucrative employment. Instead of that, people are rapidly leaving the land. The land itself is lying fallow and unproductive, altogether presenting a story that certainly is not in keeping with the dynamic approach we hear about from people like the Minister for Transport and Power and Posts and Telegraphs. Of course, he is a great statistician and he would probably find some statistics to support his view that there was progress somewhere.
Now I want to deal with fishing, if I may, for a few moments. Is fishing in order in this debate?
Comment on this
The Deputy will get an opportunity.
Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted, and 20 Members being present,
Comment on this
I should like to know from the Minister, despite the fact that there are remarks in the notes by the Department of Agriculture, what has happened to our pattern of pig breeding. How is it that the pig seems to have disappeared from vast areas in the country, and how is it while pig prices are low—and indeed this applies to beef, mutton and lamb as well—that the price of the finished article, or end product, continues to be high? I am told that it is no longer economic for farmers to keep the small number of pigs they have been accustomed to keep—a few for sale and a few for home consumption. I do not know if that is true and I do not know what the opinion of the Minister and his officials is on this. Will we be driven in agriculture too into what I would call the supermarket group?
Comment on this
How does the Deputy get on with the sale of his own pigs, lambs, mutton and beef?
Comment on this
Very well, thank you. I am grateful for the Deputy's concern but I can manage these things very well without him. It is pertinent to ask why, when the prices for livestock are low, with virtually no demand, the prices for the end products continue to be high. I do not think there is anything startingly controversial about a query of that kind. Some people, of course, prefer to make controversial interruptions without making a constructive speech, even a maiden one.
I see in the notes on the activities of the Department a small paragraph at the bottom of page 35 on the Gaeltacht and congested districts. It says:
In addition to the county and general Departmental schemes, special schemes of agricultural instruction and production are operated in the Congested Districts. These include the location of bulls and rams on special terms, the distribution of seed potatoes and seed grain at reduced prices and the establishment of plots to demonstrate proper methods of cultivation, improvement of grassland, etc. The Gaeltacht Glasshouse Scheme, initiated by this Department in 1947, is continuing in operation but the number of participants is decreasing according as the houses, now 20 years old, are wearing out. Under the new General Glasshouse Scheme introduced by Roinn na Gaeltachta in 1966-67 grants for the erection of glasshouses are available to suitable applicants in any part of the Gaeltacht.
Nobody would welcome more than I, or Deputy P. O'Donnell here beside me, the introduction of schemes into the areas we represent, but, for goodness sake, will the Minister, or those responsible for the giving of directions, urge on the people going down to examine applications, status, conditions and worthiness generally, to stop the red tape performances that are going on? Red tape is used to prevent expenditure and to keep the schemes from ever coming into the lives of these people and the slightest excuse is seized upon to deprive an applicant of a scheme.
I remember an occasion when I received a bitter complaint from a person who could not get a Gaeltacht housing grant. I was quite surprised because I knew this man well and knew him to be a fluent Irish speaker. However, the inspector reported back that he could not get a grant because Irish was not the spoken language of the household. There was nobody else in the house with this man; he was a native speaker but there was no one in the house with whom he could speak. However, I am glad to say that he got the grant.
The glasshouse scheme does not seem to be a great success. In these notes it is stated that as the houses are wearing out, the number of participants is decreasing. The note is very summary for the Gaeltacht and con gested districts, amounting to about a quarter of a page only.
Deputy J. O'Leary, whether by accident or design, came in here a little while ago to make a speech on this Estimate. He spoke with some feeling about the activities of the National Farmers Association and deplored the campaign against the Government and the country. I would have thought that a rather harsh description. I would have thought that what has been happening has been a campaign for the betterment of the conditions of the members of the particular organisation. He also said this campaign was a campaign against law and order and against authority but he said he felt that the Fine Gael Party were ashamed of their activities, both public and private in this regard. The Fine Gael Party are not ashamed of any activity, public or private, in relation to the trials and tribulations, and humiliation of the farmers by this Government.
Comment on this
You intimidated more farmers in Kerry; what about the day of the count when the returning officer was not even able to announce the result?
Comment on this
Irish farmers were lying and sleeping in the gutter in Merrion Street and they were taken out of it by a hoax by the Taoiseach and by the Minister for Agriculture, so that Deputy J. O'Leary could win South Kerry.
Comment on this
Will Deputy Geoghegan keep quiet? At least one credits him with a certain western courtesy. But it is a rather curious coincidence that that happened prior to two by-elections, but that now recognisances to keep the peace and be of good behaviour have been lifted prior to the local elections.
Comment on this
Let me say this—I know as much about the courts as Deputy Geoghegan—I, no less than many more people, was, to say the least of it, not a little surprised by the uniformity of punishment meted out to farmers in the district courts from north to south.
Comment on this
Deputy Lindsay will appreciate that that is a matter for another Minister, the Minister for Justice; it does not arise on this Estimate.
Comment on this
But recognisances have been lifted by the courts in the case of farmers who were in jail. If it was proper to do it yesterday, it was improper to impose it five weeks ago.
Comment on this
This does not arise on the Estimate for Agriculture; Deputy Lindsay is quite well aware of that.
Comment on this
Somebody here said there were a big number of farmers in the Fianna Fáil Party—I think, Deputy Allen—and Deputy Clinton replied: "If you have that number of farmers, they must have very little influence on the plans made by the Cabinet in your Party". I am amazed that the farmers in the Fianna Fáil Party have allowed a situation to arise in which we had this humiliation of decent men and women, the backbone of our country. Whether we like it or not, whether we are in business, in industry, in any profession, or anything else, our real wealth emanates from the soil of this small island, and comes from the toil and energies of the people who work that soil. It amazes me—and will never cease to amaze me—that a Government, supported by a Party with so many farmers, could ever have allowed this situation to develop, much less extend in the manner in which it did extend, leaving a very bad taste in the mouths of the real breadwinners of our nation.
I hope it is over, and I hope there will be greater understanding as between the Government and the governed, particularly the farmers, who comprise 35 per cent of our people and are responsible, directly or indirectly, for 70 per cent of our exports, and who in 1966, being responsible for 70 per cent of our exports, got 16.8 per cent of our national income. Is that fair or just? It certainly is not a state of affairs that could be tolerated, much less even contemplated in a society that would claim the term "just" for itself.
Comment on this
On a point of order, has Deputy L'Estrange not spoken? Is it proper that he should keep on speaking now?
Comment on this
You got your opportunity last night at 7 o'clock and the Minister refused to take it.
Comment on this
As I have said, I hope it is all over, that good relations will be established, and that we shall never again witness this humiliating spectacle. It must certainly be unique in our history, but it must always be remembered that the farmer as well as any member of any other trade union, through his own organisation, has a right to strike, to withdraw his services, his goods and his cattle within the law. Lest anybody might have thought we on this side of the House condoned what were the technical offences of January last—technical offences—it must be remembered that if an ordinary citizen were brought before the courts in similar circumstances, the Probation Act would be applied, or he would be ordered to put something in the poor box. He would not be rammed into jail.
Let this Government, or any government, recognise the fact once and for all that freedom carries with it the right to maintain that freedom. If the maintenance of that freedom involves the withdrawal of goods and services and labour, then that weapon must be used to maintain it. No man, no body of men, no Government, have a right to deprive the people of that, and I want to warn the Minister that if he is thinking of bringing legislation into this House to cripple or crush the farmers in their organisation or in part of it, by licensing marts in order to curb any activities he does not like— perfectly legal ones—he will get a very ready and quick answer from the only place in this country which is the last bastion of freedom in testing the constitutionality of bullying legislation. We in Fine Gael will not stand for that kind of thing. We will oppose it here, we will oppose it in the country and we will oppose it anywhere it can be challenged on proper grounds, and no threats, no intimidatory speeches by a Minister or by a Parliamentary Secretary when he grows up sufficiently to become intimidating rather than charming——
Comment on this
——no amount of this kind of stuff will terrify our people into bending the knee or going prostrate before a Government who are out of touch, whose members are wallowing in arrogance but who have lost the confidence of the people.
Comment on this
They will be preserved to work this Department or any other Department for only so long as the Government operate through large subscriptions from the moneyed few.
Comment on this
Many of us have been going around to the church gates in recent times and we are getting the feeling of the people and I think it is here we should express that feeling. I never saw so much disgust or dismay as there is among the farming community, and I am a city Deputy. When I can get that impact in the few days I have been out, the Minister should know the position. There is no confidence whatsoever in the Department of Agriculture. The people even do not know who the Minister is. They are asking: is it Mr. Haughey, is it Mr. Blaney or who is it? The fact is they do not care. They know for a fact that it is one who is not fit for the job, irrespective of who he is.
A while ago we heard Deputy Molloy saying that the small farmer could look to a Fianna Fáil Government with security and hope for the future. My colleague, Deputy Geoghegan, knows the position in regard to the small farmers in the West. He knows the position in regard to the policy of Fianna Fáil over the years. There was a glasshouse scheme but they begin to see through the glasshouses. Tulips were to be grown on the Aran Islands but the only tulips they ever saw there were Ministers with big rosy promises. That is as far as the tulips have gone. We could sing "Tulips from Amsterdam" instead.
The small farmers of the west, the mountain sheep farmers, asked for representation on this Agricultural Council. How far did they get? How far will they get? They would like to know. Possibly Deputy Molloy who was challenged in the public press by this group will tell them what Fianna Fáil are going to do for these people who have to depend on the wool and the little bit of mutton and who have to pay dearly for everything they have to buy. Could the Parliamentary Secretary at this stage—I am prepared to give way for a few moments—say what hope he holds out for those unfortunate people or will Deputy Geoghegan who is a representative of that area rise to the occasion and let them know? Will he let them know at the church gates next Sunday?
Mind you, they want the answer to this question and all praise to those small farmers. In my area there is not one NFA man, not one, but like the Donegal effort where we had a boycott of the fair—and there were NFA in Donegal—there was a boycott of the markets in Galway. Not one head of cabbage came into the markets, not one egg came into the markets. These are the small men, not the big farmers Fianna Fáil say are in the NFA. There is a solidarity among the farming community north, south, east and west which the Minister should take cognisance of. Of course he will wait until the 28th of this month. He will get his answers in that respect.
Now, Sir, they talk about the NFA blocking the bridges for a few hours but I remember a time when the gentlemen on the opposite side blew the bridges up and they were blocked for more than a few hours.
Comment on this
Contain yourself. Ordinarily you are a decent gentleman so let us not cross swords. We were told by the then Minister, Mr. Hee-Haw or Mr. Haw-Hee—whichever you like—that is what the donkeys around our country call him——
Comment on this
Yes, I can see them from here. He came into this House after coming down the gangway with big smiles coming home from England and telling us that he had a great agreement made in England. He came into this House and sat there and told us we would all have red faces before long because of the great effort that he had made. The red faces are on the wrong side of the House tonight. He promised us that 2,000 cattle would be going to Germany before long. What do we hear today? We hear that there are, I think, 150,000 too many cattle in the country at the moment and no outlet for them.
Before this year is out, there will be a lot more people marching than there have been up to the present and it will not be the NFA alone. There is a very bleak outlook for the farming community. If the farmer is hit, the townsman is hit, and the day the townsman and the farmer are hit, it is God save Ireland and God save Ireland from Fianna Fáil.
I should like the Minister to let us know what he proposes to do to help the small farmers who are now going to be deprived in my county of road work and, mind you, to eke out a livelihood, they have to work on the roads.
Comment on this
If you will allow me for a moment, Sir—they are depending 50 per cent on road work and 50 per cent on agriculture——
Comment on this
I do not think any of them is responsible for anything but £78,000 worth of road work has been stopped.