Redundancy Payments Bill, 1967: Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 111–239 of 239. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 10 of 1967 ›
In that case continuity of employment would arise. If the business were associated, continuity would be maintained.
Comment on this
Is there a section in the Bill which protects the right of an individual in the case I have mentioned?
Comment on this
There is a section which allows a man to go back and claim after so many weeks when he discovers he should have got compensation. The period is longer in a case where the man dies and the claim has to be made by his executors or relations. They can claim within a year if they discover he had a right to redundancy payment and did not get it. He himself, surviving, can make a claim within 30 weeks. It does not mean indefinitely.
Comment on this
Does it mean that a worker with, say, three years employment does not now qualify for redundancy? Can he claim against a person with whom he previously had 20 years employment?
Comment on this
On leaving his first employment, he should have got his compensation, if he was declared redundant by his first employer. If he leaves employment and goes to other employment, he foregoes continuity and has to re-establish his rights.
Comment on this
If, after 20 years, a person goes to other employment, he ought, on leaving his first employment, to claim redundancy payment.
Comment on this
There are areas in which an employee would want to know his rights and be conscious of them. I shall have to consider in what way we will communicate to workers what their rights are. A man, if he were not a member of a union and not conversant with the situation, could miss an occasion for claiming his rights.
Comment on this
Could all this not be published in a comprehensive form? Surely the obvious thing to do is to lay a condition on the employer to post up the regulations, with emphasis on workers' entitlements. That has to be done now in connection with certain Acts governing employment.
Comment on this
Some satisfactory method of advising the worker of his rights will have to be devised.
Comment on this
The Minister will undertake to have another look at this to see what he can do to protect the worker?
Comment on this
The only way in which to protect the worker is to have him conscious of his rights. I will do something.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 13:
In page 8, lines 16 and 17, to delete "the period of four weeks or thirteen weeks referred to in section 12 (2)" and substitute "the period of four weeks first referred to in section 12 (2) or the period of thirteen weeks referred to in that section".
This is a drafting amendment. In subsection (2) of section 12, there are two references to a period of four weeks or 13 weeks and this amendment is necessary to make it clear that it is the first of the two four-week periods that is referred to in subsection (2) of this section.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 14:
In page 10, line 21, after "unless" to insert "within a period of three months from the date upon which he was laid off or put on short-time by his employer, or such longer period as the employer may agree to in writing or the Board may, having regard to all the circumstances, allow".
The purpose of tabling this amendment is to indicate a fear we have in regard to the limitation on a claim period. There have been cases under the Workmen's Compensation Acts and, in these cases, the workers are limited to making a claim within a period of one year. This has often led to vexation because ordinary individuals have a right to make a claim up to a period of three years. We want to ensure that there will be no limitation or that a reasonable period will be allowed.
Comment on this
Strangely enough, this would have the opposite effect to that which the Deputy desires because, if we accept this amendment, it will impose on an employee the obligation to give notice of intention to claim within three months from the start of the period of lay-off and, if he does not do that, he will forfeit his right to payment. This would give a protection to the employer who would lay-off a worker and fail to terminate that lay-off either by dismissing the worker or by re-employing him. Under the provisions of section 12, the right of the employee to claim redundancy payment in respect of a period of lay-off or short time remains open as long as that lay-off or short time continues. When the lay-off or short time ceases, the right to claim redundancy payment is not retained indefinitely. Notice of intention to claim must be given within four weeks from the date on which the lay-off or short time ceases. I understand what the Deputy wants. He wants to time it from the beginning of the lay-off, That would give protection to the employer. The Deputy's intention is to protect the employee.
Comment on this
Instead of one month from the end of the lay-off period, would the Minister consider making it three months?
Comment on this
One has to balance it out. The employee is limited by having to finish his employment within a month. There could be a counter-notice by the employer. A dispute could arise and that could go on for longer than the four weeks. It is a case of trying to find what is fair.
Comment on this
I appreciate the Minisster's concern to ensure that people get their entitlements and that people know their entitlements. Appreciating that, it is obvious we should give them as long as possible because, when this Bill becomes law, it will be quite some time before people realise what they should or should not do. It would be a sad thing if some were debarred from getting anything because they did not know their rights.
Comment on this
There is not a great deal in it really. As the sanction stands, the employee will have two months after the short time. If a man is laid off for four weeks running or if he has an aggregate of six weeks within a period of 13 weeks—lay-off or short time does not matter—then he is entitled to give notice that he will claim and he is entitled to give that notice four weeks after the whole thing has stopped.
Comment on this
He will have to be informed. When a worker gives notice, he then has another four weeks to give notice that he is going to finish his employment. There is notice to claim and notice to cease employment.
Comment on this
I shall have another look at it, because as it stands, the amendment would have a completely different effect from what Deputy Jones obviously wanted and I have not considered what Deputy Jones said in the context of the rest of the Bill and the counter notice. I shall consider it on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 15:
In page 10, line 27, after "unless" to insert the following: ", within a period of one month from the date of that notice, or, where the matter has been referred to the Appeals Tribunal, within one month from the date of notification to the employee of the Tribunal's decision,".
I must explain this. Subsection (2) of section 12 provides that where a worker gives notice of intention to claim a redundancy payment because of lay-off or short time working he will not be entitled to that payment until by the service of another notice —due notice— he terminates the contract of employment. The section prescribes a time limit in which to serve the notice of intention to claim and it does not prescribe—even though I mentioned a figure—a time limit in which to serve the notice of termination of contract of employment in pursuance of the notice of intention to claim. This was an omission and I think it should be rectified because it would be unfair to employers if it were left completely in the air indefinitely as to when a man would say: "I am redundant". This amendment would repair the omission.
The time limit which I have also mentioned but which has not been passed by the House is one month from the date of the notice of intention to claim but if there is a redundancy payment being disputed and the subject is being sent to the Appeals Board, the time limit which would be proposed would be one month from the date of the decision of the Appeals Board and I think this is reasonable. That is the two months I mentioned—the month's notice first of all that he will claim and then a month's notice to cease employment. It is near enough to what Deputy Jones wanted.
Comment on this
It is conditional that where a worker claims redundancy payments he must have been either dismissed by the employer on grounds of shortage of work or must have been kept on short time for four or more consecutive weeks of which the last before the service of the notice ended on the date of service thereof or ended not more than four weeks before that date, or that he has been laid off or kept on short time for a series of six or more weeks of which not more than three were consecutive within a period of thirteen weeks, where the last week of the series before the service of the notice ended on the date of service thereof or ended not more than four weeks before that date.
Clearly, the worker is very much restricted in declaring himself redundant even though he may have experienced very bad time. He may have been on short time over a very long, protracted period and because he was not laid off for four or more consecutive weeks, he obviously cannot claim redundancy payments. He cannot get out of that job and offer himself for redundancy payment and re-training and re-absorption in a more secure job. We know very many industries in which the work is seasonal and in which workers work short time for a long period. They may be on two or three days a week and one can imagine how frustrating it is to be depending on one or two days work per week over a long period of time. Eventually one is forced is decide that one cannot live in these circumstances and looks around for another job.
I appreciate that employers may want to hold on to their labour force, especially if they are a skilled labour force. It would be unwise to leave too much leeway for people to leave their jobs as such, but I think there ought to be a little more scope in this section whereby, if it is proven that short time is being worked over a long duration of one day, two days or even three days per week and where clearly the job cannot provide a living wage and offers no semblance of security of tenure for the future, in these circumstances workers should be entitled to opt for the redundancy scheme and all that it provides because to my mind the employers very definitely have the benefit here. However badly affairs may be going, if they want to hold on to their work force, they can hold on to them during saecula seculorum by reason of the provisions here. All they have to do is to carefully avoid leaving their operatives off for four or more consecutive weeks and they can work them one day or two days or a few hours a week apart from that indefinitely. This, I submit, would be an intolerable situation for industrial workers particularly to find themselves in.
Comment on this
I can assure Deputy Booth that I am speaking from personal experience in this matter.
Comment on this
I do not quite know what the Deputy means. Did he say that workers could work short time indefinitely?
Comment on this
Four weeks continuously or an aggregate of six weeks within a period of 13 weeks will entitle him to give notice.
Comment on this
I know that, but assuming the employer brings these operatives in for a day or two per week, there is nothing consecutive there.
Comment on this
It says here if
he has been laid off or kept on short time for four or more consecutive weeks...
I am presuming that he must have been completely idle for those four weeks.
Comment on this
No, he can have been laid off for one week, part time for the next, laid off for the third week and so on. As long as he has four weeks of lay off or short time he is entitled to give notice.
Comment on this
That clears up that point. Section (b) says that if
he has been laid off or kept on short time for a series of six or more weeks (of which not more than three were consecutive...
Here again we use the word "consecutive". Do we mean complete lay off?
Comment on this
Or short time. Would the Minister have a look at the section to make it somewhat clearer?
Comment on this
If he has been either laid off or kept on short time for four or more consecutive weeks.
Comment on this
Can I be satisfied anyway that short time-work for a pretty long period of time will qualify for redundancy under the section?
Comment on this
If there was short time for four weeks running, then he could give notice that he is going to claim redundancy and the employer could counter the notice by saying: "I have work for you for at least 13 weeks." That counters the notice.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 16:
In page 11, lines 27, 31 and 36 to substitute "misconduct" for "conduct".
I think the word "conduct" here is too loose and it ought to be "misconduct" if that is really what the intention is.
Comment on this
I will ask the draftsman to have a look at this. This is really a drafting matter. You are concerned with the type of conduct which merits dismissal and this, I presume, is misconduct. I will ask the parliamentary draftsman to have a look at it and, if necessary, I will amend it on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I will ask the draftsman to have a look at it and, if necessary, I will amend it on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 17:
In page 11, line 50, after "offered" to insert "in writing".
Subsection (1) of this section states that an employee who has received the notice required by section 17 shall not be entitled to a redundancy payment if his employer has offered to renew the employee's contract of employment. I wish to ensure in this amendment that this offer is made in writing. I do not think it is sufficient that an offer could be just muttered in regard to such a matter as this. Later sections of the Bill deal with the matter in writing where the dismissal of the employee is concerned. I think the offer of employment, equally so, ought to be in writing and that it is much more beneficial to the person unemployed that he has the offer of re-employment. That ought to be in writing. There should be no question of a person finding out at a later stage, if he wishes to obtain employment, that somebody offered him employment but he did not take it. There is something tangible when the offer is made in writing. This can be produced in evidence in favour of the person who wants to claim.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy be satisfied if the offer did not give details? Usually the man knows what type of employment he was in and if it is offered loosely that if he wishes the same type of work, he could have it. I think the Deputy needs only evidence of the offer having been made and that it does not have to be detailed.
Comment on this
Very often it happens that you have this matter in dispute and you will find the worker saying that he was made no offer and the employer saying that he was made an offer. You then fall between both of them whereas, if the offer is made in writing it clarifies the matter.
Comment on this
It does not have to be detailed. It is just evidence of the offer. Is that what the Deputy wants?
Comment on this
If it is in writing there obviously will have to be some detail put in. It would be much tidier to have it in writing and both sides would know what is offered.
Comment on this
It would give more employment in the typing pools when you have those letters written.
Comment on this
It is just as easy for an employer to do it in writing and then the employee sees that he is going to be offered employment.
Comment on this
The employee is not entitled to redundancy payment if he is made an offer. If he has not anything to show that he was made an offer he can come before the appeals board.
Comment on this
If he has nothing to show that he was made an offer, then he is entitled to redundancy payment. He cannot claim a lump sum when he is offered employment. When this is in writing it could be to the detriment of the employee and is probably the opposite to what the Deputy requires.
Comment on this
The man could say: "I have a letter in my pocket to prove that I was offered the job."
Comment on this
Surely it is reasonable for him to ask the employer why he was dismissed from employment?
Comment on this
If the man has evidence in his pocket to show that he was offered employment, that evidence will show that he should not get redundancy payment and is, therefore, no help to him.
Comment on this
It very often happens that when people are seeking social welfare benefit that is the type of evidence that is taken.
Comment on this
I think it is a very wise thing if we have this but we must keep in mind that acceptance or refusal of the offer should also be put in writing.
Comment on this
It is quite obvious that we have got to have it both ways in the interests of both sides. An employer could find if this were a purely verbal offer that there was no evidence but if it were in writing he could say: "I made an offer and there is a carbon copy of it and of the man's refusal."
Comment on this
When it comes to an appeals tribunal, it should be before them that a written offer was made and there should be a copy of the reply which was received. That would help the appeals tribunal very much and make their job easier.
Comment on this
There are two things to be considered here. One is that the man is under notice and is claiming redundancy and the employer says that he will give him the same job back and you want evidence to be in writing. Is that not it? If the man is given a different type of job, this could come before the appeals tribunal and, perhaps, evidence would be needed. In the first part of the section you are only giving back the original job. I will have a look at this between now and Report Stage.
Comment on this
This section refers to the definition of associated companies and I think there is something that should be said before widening this definition to some extent. There is an increasing move in business generally towards association between companies by exchange of shares, and even though a company may not be a subsidiary of another company, it may be closely associated by means of certain shareholdings. I think there may be something to be said for widening this definition to include companies in which, say, a minority of financial holdings of, say, 25 per cent is held by one company in another. If this definition were to be extended in this way, it would mean that it might be easier to offer employment to otherwise redundant workers in an associated company. It could easily be that it would be an active encouragement to companies to avoid redundancy altogether by means of offering similar work, not in the same company, not in a subsidiary company but in another company with which it was closely associated. If we can give the maximum incentive to companies to cooperate with one another in offering employment to workers who are in danger of becoming redundant, so much the better.
Would the Minister consider widening this definition of associated companies to include companies which have a 25 per cent holding in one another—25 per cent or more?
Comment on this
I have gone through this before outside the House. Each time I am brought back to the desirability of staying with the definition as in the Bill. I do not know of any way we can implement the suggestion. I do not think it would be desirable.
Comment on this
Surely, in regard to what Deputy Booth has said, we are aware that there are a number of business people with various interest holdings, partly in some cases, in others. It has happened that some such business people, when there is redundancy in their establishment, have found it necessary to turn to the question of whom to regard as being a good worker and saying: "As you know, I have a small interest in another firm; I will arrange for you to get employment there." Off he goes and makes such an arrangement. As I see it now, this will not hold good for continuity. It means the worker will have to start off all over again. It would be better to maintain continuity. The employer has been making his contribution and the worker has been making his contribution wholly in this particular place and partly in another establishment. Surely something should be done to cover that type of thing? It is happening every day. The Minister has an interest in this and I am not being sarcastic when I say this. That being so, it should encourage him to meet the situation. If we do not do this, we will end up by having fewer and fewer people obtaining benefit from this Bill. We will end up by collecting money from people and not paying it out. The Minister will have to give this some consideration.
Comment on this
The difficulty is that it would operate to the disadvantage of the worker. If a company wants to declare a person redundant or dismiss a man on redundancy and does not want to pay him a lump sum, all they will have to do is transfer him to an associated company. If you extend the definition of an associated company, you could include a very wide chain of companies and this lower 25 per cent could considerably reduce the number of cases in which a worker would be entitled to lump sum benefit. It would be a weakening from the employee's point of view. Under the Companies Act, the subsidiary figure is 51 per cent. This has limited to some extent the number of companies to which an employee could be sent as an alternative to giving a lump sum. If you reduce it further to 25 per cent, there would be quite a number of alternative employments to which an employee could be sent instead of giving him a lump sum.
Comment on this
Surely the main desire is that we hope as time goes on that there will be fewer and fewer cases of redundancy. We should bear in mind what Deputy Booth said on another section. This is for a short-term payment. We have also to take into consideration whether it is better to give a man continuity of employment or a short-term payment. The kind of case I have in mind is where we should encourage employers to look to their employees and that they will not get away from it. I would regard it as their obligation, rather than by just having them leave the employment and falling back on this short-term lump sum payment. That is what we should do and we would have a willingness on the part of an employer to protect his employees. He does not want it brought about in the fashion of simply having to give redundancy payments and that is the end. He is interested in having continuity of employment recognised.
Comment on this
For example, if Deputy Mullen were employing a person in a factory or in a firm and he had an interest of 25 per cent in another firm, if he is declaring that person redundant, he will have to give him a lump sum and that person could go over to the other company and get a job immediately: whereas, if you reduce it to 25 per cent, he can be transferred to a much larger number of firms and not get a lump sum. With this other possibility for the employer you would be giving up the worker's right to a lump sum in an increased number of cases.
Comment on this
Yes, having got his lump sum. If we change the law as you want it, he would not get any lump sum.
Comment on this
This matter was examined before the present discussion; I have studied it and its implementation would weaken the employee's position under the Bill.
Comment on this
No man wants to have his continuity of employment broken just to get his hands on a short-term payment. A man wants to get continuity of work. I hear people say: "I do not care who I work for as long as I am treated properly."
Comment on this
It depends on the length of service; if you have quite a considerable length of service with a company and you are going to an associated company, you could be entitled to quite a lump sum. You do not want to give that up; all you are losing is continuity of service but you are getting the lump sum. The balance is in favour of the worker.
Comment on this
I shall not press the matter because, if I wanted to press it, I would have an amendment down, but Deputy Booth inspired me.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 18:
To delete subsection (1) and substitute the following subsections:
"(1) An employer who proposes to dismiss by reason of redundancy an employee who has not less than 26 weeks service with that employer shall give to the employee notice in writing of the proposed dismissal and send to the Minister a copy of that notice.
(2) The notice required to be given by an employer in accordance with subsection (1)—
(a) shall be not less than one weeks notice if his period of continuous employment with that employer is less than two years; and
(b) shall be not less than two weeks notice if his period of continuous employment is two years or more but less than five years; and
(c) shall be not less than four weeks notice if his period of continuous employment is five years or more."
We have put down this amendment, which proposes to give certain notice periods to employees who may be given dismissal notice. We have been talking about the employee's right in his job all morning in terms of his redundancy payment. The employee also has a right in his job—a right to a certain period to be given to him before his dismissal from the job.
The Minister's proposal in the Bill merely recognises a right to a dismissal notice after four years service. Our amendment proposes that after six months in a firm an employee should be entitled to not less than one week's notice; that after six months and up to two years service, not less than one week's notice; not less than two weeks' notice if his period of continuous employment is two years or more but less than five years, and not be less than four weeks' notice if his period of continuous employment is five years or more.
We should take the opportunity in this Bill to tie in as much as possible with decent conditions of employment. Certainly the periods of dismissal we are looking for—the notice period to be given to an employee who is to be dismissed by his employer—are not in the least extravagant and are periods which anybody looking at impartially must accept. We know we have a very big job before us in civilising the employers of this country when it comes to dealing with their employees in a courteous fashion. This is one of the things which Irish management has not learned: they will believe that the right to hire and fire must have no qualifications whatsoever and must be absolutely the unquestioned prerogative of Irish management. What we are seeking to do is to bring some civilisation into this attitude of too many employers in this country. We are aware of cases where employees, after many years service, have been given an hour's notice, not to speak of a week's notice.
We wish to change this state of affairs by our amendment. We think it a reasonable amendment and we consider that if the employee has rights in his job for other payments under this Bill, then, most certainly, he deserves that good manners be exercised by his employer when it comes to the tragic position of having to let him go. We must see that the same rights which appertain to other grades of employment in this country, in many clerical and professional grades, obtain all round. Anybody would look askance at a person who would think an hour's notice adequate. A man beginning at one end of the scale after six months in a job should not have his plans disrupted by being told at six o'clock on Friday that he will not be required on Monday morning. Bearing in mind the financial commitments an employee enters into, such as hire purchase and so on, his employer, least of all, has the right to say to him blandly on a Friday afternoon: "We will not be requiring you on Monday morning". We would suggest it is downright barbarian behaviour on the part of any employer today not to give sufficient notice to his employees.
We would hope the Minister would accept this amendment, which seeks to bring some decent notice period in relations between employers and employees. We suggest one week's notice at the beginning of the scale, up to a maximum of one month's notice at the top. These are very small concessions but certainly should be embodied in this Bill.
Comment on this
The sentiments expressed by Deputy M. O'Leary are something which came under discussion here previously on the establishment of this Ministry. Good relations are the important thing and one of the things which would lead to good relations with regard to employees being laid off is that they would have some kind of reasonable notice given to them so as to re-arrange their affairs. I rise to ask the Minister to accept this amendment as being a reasonable proposition.
Comment on this
For the purposes of this Bill, the time I put down does not reflect my general thinking of what would be adequate notice of dismissal at all. For the purposes of the Bill, we settled on two weeks, to give replacement officers and administration time to take care of a person so made redundant. Later on in the Bill we have an incentive to people, a two and a half per cent increase in the rebate of lump sum payment for each week further of notice given.
I would ask the Deputies who put down this amendment to accept the time I have in this Bill. I agree with a lot of what has been said here about notice. It is a matter which has to be considered separately and will belong to separate legislation. I will undertake to do this if the Deputies will withdraw it from this Bill.
Comment on this
Is the Minister indicating he will include this amendment, or the terms of it, in other legislation?
Comment on this
I have not got as far as drafting the legislation but I shall have what has been brought up on this amendment included in other legislation—the giving of adequate notice.
Comment on this
Are we to understand it is the Minister's intention to bring in a Bill which will compel all employers to give a week's notice for a period of service?
Comment on this
Consideration of the matter is not far enough advanced for me to say what I would put in the Bill.
Comment on this
I feel strongly about this amendment for a number of reasons but, in particular, to keep lines right in industry. It has been the practice for a long time now to draw up agreements covering the situation where at least one week's notice must be given by one side or the other. The trade union movement has advocated this and organised employers subscribe to it. You have other cases where two weeks notice is given; others where a month's notice is given and yet in others where three months notice is given.
There are a number of categories of workers excluded from this Bill. Earlier this morning I referred to the Civil Service. It is my understanding that in the matter of notice in the Civil Service, they do not have to wait for four years to qualify for reasonable notice. On the other hand, we have the continued behaviour of some employers who go along with giving one hour's notice. Because of all these happenings, we formulated this amendment. This Bill has been described by more than one Fianna Fáil Deputy as being progressive legislation on the part of Fianna Fáil. I hold that if you do not accept our amendment, you are taking a backward rather than a forward step, because people will read into this an intention of the Minister. Employees, when dealing with a situation such as has been described, will look for a week's notice after six months service. They will say: "What about the latest Act put through the Dáil in connection with notice to employees in which the period is much longer?" Those are situations we cannot afford to ignore. Though a trade union can protect the interests of their members to a great extent, there are still a lot of employees in the country who are not members of any union.
Comment on this
I do not think the case mentioned by the Deputy would be covered, even if we made the amendment suggested. I will undertake to the House to have the whole matter reconsidered with a view to promoting new legislation——
Comment on this
The Minister misunderstood. We are anxious to set a good example and that is what we should be doing by adopting the method we suggest.
Comment on this
I should hope to set a good example in separate legislation, not in this Redundancy Bill.
Comment on this
The point we are making is that if this amendment is accepted, it will not impose any hardship on an employer but will stop a fairly widespread practice among the less decent type of employers of giving a man extremely short notice. This legislation is to deal with people who may become unemployed due to redundancy and there is no doubt that there is no firm which will find itself suddenly in a position of having to lay off workers because of redundancy: the management must have advance notice of their situation—they must know of its imminence for some time— and what we are asking is that by legislation we do away with the practice of less considerate employers who, though they are fully aware of the situation that is developing, wait until the last moment before giving any indication to their employees that they are to become unemployed.
If a man has been working for a period of from six months to two years for the same firm, surely he is entitled and it will not impose any hardship on the employer, to get a week's notice. Neither do I think it unreasonable to ask that a man who has given from two years to five years service to a firm should be given a fortnight's notice of the firm's intention to dispense with his services. We are not unreasonable in asking that after five years service, a man should be given four weeks notice in advance of the intention to dispense with his services. What we are suggesting in the amendment does not present any great difficulties to any employer. All we are asking is that a man be told a reasonable time in advance that he will become unemployed —that he be given a reasonable opportunity to look around and find out his prospects for future employment in another firm or industry. On reflection, I hope the Minister will see this is a reasonable amendment. All we seek is that by legislation we should bring less considerate employers into line with common decency.
Comment on this
Though I agree that the general principle in the amendment is desirable, there are difficulties in the way of administering it. Take one of many firms in this city. It has to employ a certain amount of day-to-day labour. Would this amendment not militate against employment of men on this basis?
Comment on this
I realise it would be a desirable thing to bring about but the Minister has said there would be difficulties. I agree with Deputy Mullen that we must set a good example.
Comment on this
Yes, to go forward, not backward. What the Deputy wants to do is to set a bad example.
Comment on this
The Minister said he was not sure we could cover the points in the Deputy's amendment under this legislation. I agree that some employers in this city are brutal in their practice of dismissing people at short notice. I agree that practice should be stopped, but because the Minister cannot agree to accept the amendment, we shall look forward to his promise to bring in legislation——
Comment on this
For the purposes of redundancy payments legislation, what I propose here is adequate. What the Deputies seek to deal with is not appropriate for redundancy legislation which is limited in its coverage. People with shorter service than the qualifying period specified in the Bill would not be covered. This is a very important consideration and I undertake to have the matter dealt with but, as I have said, I do not think it would be appropriate in redundancy legislation. It would be appropriate to separate legislation and I undertake to the House to promote this.
Comment on this
Would the Minister not agree it is most appropriate in so far as it gives a man a reasonable opportunity of looking for alternative employment as a result of which he would not be a drag on the redundancy fund?
Comment on this
Two weeks is adequate to the needs of the redundancy scheme but if we must tackle the general problem of notice which concerns people other than those who will be covered by this Bill, we shall have to do it separately. I have undertaken to do this by promoting the necessary legislation.
Comment on this
If the Minister deals with that problem separately, will he not have to come back and change this legislation which will then look out of place? I am speaking now about this section. What is preventing the Minister from doing what we are advocating? Who would be injured by it?
Comment on this
I do not think we have given it sufficient consideration as a broad principle in all employments. This is a Bill which requires a specific notice for administrative reasons. I have spoken about the amount of time necessary for the administration of placement services and otherwise for the normal functioning of this scheme. I am aware of the problem the Deputies have described, I have promised to consider that problem and to promote the necessary legislation to deal with it.
Comment on this
Does the Minister accept that adequate notice should be given? If so, he should accept that every piece of legislation, including this, should make adequate provision for such notice. We submit that the provision in this section is not adequate. The Minister has not made a case for it.
Comment on this
Is the Minister saying he will favourably consider this problem and introduce legislation in the immediate future?