We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Private Members' Business. - Control of Imports (Quota No. 54) (Pneumatic Tyres) Order, 1967.

Contributions 132–276 of 276. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

At the moment, my interest is that Deputy Healy tells us that, during the whole campaign in his city and in his constituency, he never mentioned it. Is that not a striking commentary on the standards of public life? Was this whole problem a matter of consequence to Cork city?

Comment on this

May I interrupt the Deputy?

Comment on this

Of course. I am only too delighted.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon said I made the welkin ring with the news. I told him I had not said a word about it. You cannot have it both ways. In the first case, I was to be despised and rejected or, in the second case, I was equally blameworthy.

Comment on this

I am sorry to find the Deputy on the horns of a dilemma. It is not the first time Deputy Healy has found himself in the awkward situation of being on the horns of a dilemma. It is true that he was in a dreadful dilemma. I think Deputy Healy is too honest a man to tell the people a lie but if he mentioned it and told them the truth he would have been torn to pieces by his colleagues and Deputy French, instead of being the minority Deputy for Cork, might not have been a Deputy for Cork at all. Is that true or is it false?

Comment on this

Deputy Barrett did his best to make it an issue in the by-election. We must give him credit for that.

Comment on this
Mr. Barrett

I did.

Comment on this

Who lost 3,000 votes in the Taoiseach's constituency?

Comment on this

Why should Deputy Barrett not do so? What are elections for? Compare what Deputy Stephen Barrett did with what Deputy Healy says he did. Deputy Healy says here: "I never even mentioned it".

Comment on this

I know the Cork workers too well.

Comment on this

He knows the Cork workers too well.

Comment on this

Deputy Healy knew that his colleagues would knock his block off if he mentioned it and so he kept a complete silence. He did not say "yes" and he did not say "no". He talked about the weather, the crops and the blessings of a Fianna Fáil Government. He says he knows the Cork workers intimately and that his friends in the Dunlop factory are legion but he never went to them and said: "Boys, the Minister has provided you with exceptional protection for some months but he has pledged his word and the word of his Government that, this day 12 months, that protection must cease, if only by leave of the British Board of Trade. We hope you will not find yourselves in precisely the situation you were in 12 months ago, six months ago".

Deputy Lenihan, senior, from Westmeath, comes in here and tells us he knows every detail of Dunlops' costings.

Comment on this

In a general manner, I know them.

Comment on this

How the hell one knows the details in a general manner, it surpasses me to understand. Certainly, when he was speaking—nobody seems to have understood him but himself— he said he knew the details of the costings because he supplied the cloth to Dunlops wherewith to make the tyres.

Comment on this

I said I knew the details of the costings from its associate company in England.

Comment on this

I understood the Deputy——

Comment on this

You did not know what I was talking about.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy claimed he knew the details of the costings——

Comment on this

You are wrong.

Comment on this

Deputy P.J. Lenihan is now getting a warning that many a Deputy has got before and that is to "shut up and leave him alone as the more you say the worse you will be".

Comment on this

It was not that.

Comment on this

I am sure it was not flattering. It was designed to get Deputy Lenihan to shut his trap.

Comment on this

It certainly was not flattering, all right.

Comment on this

Deputy Lenihan opened his trap too wide before the Deputy from Carna came in and what opened once cannot be shut so easily. He told us he knew Dunlops costings in detail in a general way. I suppose he knows his own costings in detail in a particular way. His verdict of the situation that called for this Order was: "We in Athlone are doing our part".

Comment on this

I never mentioned Athlone.

Comment on this

Did you not say that you made the cloth?

Comment on this

Years ago we made it.

Comment on this

Did you not say you made the cloth for——

Comment on this

——when they could get their cloth abroad that item of costing would be less. I told you all that.

Comment on this

And the Deputy went on to say that he was supplying the cloth. Dunlops——

Comment on this

Leave it to me. The more they open their beaks the deeper they get into trouble. It we can only get them to open their beaks then they will be in trouble because that is one craft in which they are not skilled, telling the truth. Put them to that job and they will get up to their lugs every time. I will guarantee to get the truth out of them before we finish this debate. Deputy Lenihan says he makes the cloth.

Comment on this

Made.

Comment on this

And he says further that if tyres were to come in hereafter at the rate they came in in the past the fault would be with the management of Dunlops.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

He said they had three years and that from his intimate knowledge of the whole position they had exerted themselves throughout the period of three years, and if they could not do better in the next 12 months it was not to the Government they should be running for help but to themselves.

Comment on this

That is what I said. Continue from there.

Comment on this

Now what I want to know——

Comment on this

We are ad idem for once.

Comment on this

Did Deputy Lenihan tell Deputy French or Deputy Healy, or did Deputy Healy or Deputy Lenihan or Deputy French or Deputy Colley, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, tell that to the electorate in Cork city?

Comment on this

We told them the whole story.

Comment on this

And they sent Deputy French in here. There he is sitting over there, in case you do not know him.

Comment on this

Let us face the facts. What I want to know is were the people told? How many Deputies knew when they saw that quota order presented without the Minister's speech that its limit was 12 months from today? Would anybody care to tell me what is going to happen when the 12 months end?

Comment on this

Dunlops' management.

Comment on this

What is going to happen to them?

Comment on this

I do not know.

Comment on this

The Deputy does not know, that is his trouble. The Deputy does not know. Half an hour ago he was telling us that everything in the garden was lovely because he knew that 12 months from now everything would be ticking over to perfection. There was another cheerful Deputy here from Donegal, Deputy Cunningham, who was promising that they will be exporting tyres——

Comment on this

He said they have been. Let us be accurate.

Comment on this

Can anybody explain this phenomenon? This company has been exporting tyres, motor tyres?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Would they tell me where they were exporting them to?

Comment on this

To the EEC countries originally and subsequently, when the Free Trade Area Agreement was concluded, to Britain, because they had no right of entry until then.

Comment on this

Here is this mystery. The Dunlop tyre factory in Cork is exporting motor tyres to Great Britain and lo and behold the people who are rushing to buy the Dunlop tyres from Cork suddenly take it into their heads to ship 15,400 tyres per month, 180,000 per year, to us. Can anyone explain to me how we sell tyres in Great Britain at a time when we are obliged to invoke Article 19 of the Trade Agreement to protect our domestic industry from British exports of tyres for a period of 18 months by leave of the British Board of Trade?

Comment on this

It is an interesting situation.

Comment on this

Is it not fascinating? It is a situation which I do not think is any harm to debate in this House because not until we know how and why this mysterious situation came to pass can we with propriety approve of a quota order which, by the Minister's own statement, ends 12 months from today, subject to whatever rights he may retain to consult the British President of the Board of Trade. By heavens, Deputy Wyse has arrived. This is a most interesting thing. We have been debating this quota order from relatively early this evening and it is astonishing that for the greater part of the debate hair or hide of Fianna Fáil Deputies from Cork we could not see.

Comment on this

That is not correct.

Comment on this

Then Deputy French took his courage in his hands, and I am not challenging him and I hope he does not think I am——

Comment on this
Seán French Mr. French

Cork Deputies are well able to look after themselves.

Comment on this

I know the Deputy will give a good account of himself when the occasion offers. He was followed by that wily old operator, Deputy Healy, who then trickled in.

Comment on this

I blush.

Comment on this

Then at 9.50 p.m. Deputy Wyse is wafted into our presence.

Comment on this

How wise he was.

Comment on this

The Deputy always makes the appropriate interiection. How he must be blessed by his colleagues and what a comfort to them his presence in the House must be. "How wise he was". I would be most interested to hear the Deputy's contribution and I am sorry he was not here when Deputy Lenihan was speaking because I would be glad to hear him on it. I can give him the information in advance because I do not think he was privileged to hear it. When Deputy Healy was speaking, he ignored Deputy Lenihan's intervention and pledged his word that throughout the course of the by-election campaign in Cork city he never mentioned the quota order relating to tyres, so doubtless Deputy Wyse will make his contribution in due time in the light of those interventions.

Comment on this
Seán French Mr. French

We do not use an industry for an election gimmick.

Comment on this

I wonder do you use a quota order under Article 19 as a gimmick?

Comment on this

No, but Deputy Barrett fell for the temptation.

Comment on this

I think Deputy Barrett discharged a very useful public duty, to reveal to the public the true meaning of what this quota order means. Mind you, it is pregnant with meaning because it provides temporary protection for a very great industry which, mark you, was not established today or yesterday in Cork. It is a long time since Dunlops opened their factory in Cork. It is one of the oldest industries in this country. It is not Fianna Fáil that put them there, in case they should be suffering under the illusion it was.

If this device is necessary to save so venerable an industry, so well-run an industry, so experienced an industry as the Irish Dunlop Company, what must we apprehend under this agreement in respect of other industries when their turn comes? I want to speak tonight only of the problems that lie ahead in respect of this Order, which relates to tyres produced by the Dunlop Company. The best hope Deputy Healy and Deputy Lenihan can give us is that in the course of the next 12 months this company will find this kind of protection no longer necessary. Deputy Healy, Deputy Wyse and Deputy French may be nursing to their bosoms the comforting thought that, as the currency of this Order runs out and as the possibility looms above the horizon that the President of the British Board of Trade will say: "No, I will not agree to any extension beyond the 18 months provided in the original agreement for quota orders of this kind," we in Ireland may have recourse to other devices to facilitate the export of the produce of this factory until such time as it can meet the blast of foreign competition, whencesoever it may come.

Have they forgotten that last week we adhered to GATT? Have they forgotten the provisions of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade? Have they forgotten we are only now at the beginning of the exercise of bringing duties down? Have they forgotten that when we devalued our pound to match the devaluation of the British our costs for rubber went up overnight by 14.3 per cent? How much of a tyre consists of rubber? How much of a tyre consists of cotton? Have the Deputies from Cork paused to ask themselves where the cotton comes from? The man who spins it, Deputy Lenihan, has disappeared. They have got him out of the House at last. It is a pity. If he had stayed much longer we would have got closer to the truth. They have sent him home to bed. They did very wisely. Few Deputies realise that in the last two or three days our capacity to compete elsewhere than in Great Britain with a commodity of this kind, all the raw materials of which come from countries who have not devalued their currency, is shrinking hour by hour and day by day.

I imagine it is to meet a situation of this kind, arising from this quota order and its inevitable termination in 12 months' time, that we passed recently the Redundancy Bill. There are going to be more made redundant in this factory. Have they been told, or have they been told on the lines of Deputy Lenihan that: "All is well. You can leave it to the management of Dunlops?" Every trade agreement must of its very nature mean that there is giving and taking on both sides. I believe Ireland is no exception to that general rule. If we want a trade agreement with Great Britain which is the agreement we refer to in this Order, we have to give if we hope to take, just as the British said to us: "We are prepared to give in consideration of what we hope to take." We got very considerable advantages in the Anglo-Irish Trade Agreement. We should not close our eyes to the fact that we got free access to the British market for a variety of products, agricultural and industrial, produced in the County Cork. But one of the things we had to give was access on certain terms to British manufacturers to the Irish market.

I do not in the least regret the decision taken by this House in regard to the Trade Agreement which contains the appropriate provision for this Quota Order. But I do regret the failure to tell the people what it truly meant, the failure to tell the workers —the management already know—in the Dunlop factory that this kind of protection is for 12 months, and the utter failure of the Government to tell either this House and the electors in Cork city during the last three weeks what they propose to do thereafter in respect of the employment provided in this factory down through the decades in which Dunlops have constituted part of the industrial life of Cork. Mark you, I think it rather odd and not in character with Deputy Colley, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, that knowing the quality of this undoubted problem he should have participated in the Cork campaign and, either by silence or by careful ambiguity, withheld from the electors something they were entitled to know. It lowers the whole standard of our public life.

Comment on this

The Deputy should not.

Comment on this

Is it not true?

Comment on this

The Deputy is lowering the standard of public life if he is putting this forward as a serious contention.

Comment on this

Do you really believe you told the workers in Cork?

Comment on this

Does the Deputy not know—I have already told him—that when this Order was made and published there was a public statement to the effect that this was of limited duration? I cannot say precisely but my recollection is it said "not exceeding 18 months". It certainly made it clear that it was of temporary duration. This is a fact to which I have referred before. Why does the Deputy persist in arguing it and building up a case about lowering the standard of public life? This is an important matter and I do not think the Deputy should indulge in this kind of activity lightly and without regard to the facts.

Comment on this

I agree that if I did, the Minister would be a hundred times justified in reprobating what I did. It would be sheer hypocrisy on my part if I took a lofty line to make capital at the Minister's expense by expounding a falsehood. However, I do not think the Minister is being honest with himself. I do not charge him with being dishonest with us, but he and I are long enough in public life to know that Quota Orders published are understood by 99 per cent of those who read them to represent a physical limitation on the future imports of a certain commodity. They do not read the small print.

Comment on this

The Deputy misunderstands me, I think.

Comment on this

I accept what the Minister says. When he made the Quota Order six months ago, it expressly stated——

Comment on this

No; That is not what I am saying. I am saying a public statement issued explaining this not in terms of a quota period order or in quota order language, but in ordinary language; the matter got a good deal of publicity and was certainly clearly understood by the workers in Dunlops. I am saying this is a fact and the Deputy should be aware of it as a fact before he goes on to build an argument based on a presumption.

Comment on this

I see the force of the Minister's case. He can say: "I feel that when the fact of the strictly limited period for which I have the power to make a Quota Order had been frankly stated last July, it is going beyond the limits of what any ordinary politician should be required to do, that I should go down into the Cork by-election campaign and say: "Boys, did you read the small print?" He is entitled to say: "The thing was done in public. The record is there for anyone to read and it is not a topic on which I propose to dwell." I can understand that, but when Deputy Barrett challenged the Minister and his colleagues, as the Minister says Deputy Barrett did, and said: "As regards the statement you made six months ago, no matter how detailed it was six months ago, the people here in Cork do not know that 12 months hence they are going to meet exactly the same dilemma and you have a duty to tell them if you are in a position to do so." What will the Minister do when this order runs out? He knows I was not at the by-election campaign for reasons into which it is unnecessary to go, but the Minister tells us that Deputy Barrett put this matter in issue and he derided him for doing so.

Comment on this

No, I did not.

Comment on this

He said it ill became him.

Comment on this

No. What I said was he made an issue of it in the by-election. He made the issue clear to the people and we had won the election. That is the point I made.

Comment on this

Yes, but the Minister did not go on to say: "Deputy Barrett urged this view upon the people and I confirm the truth of what he said". I wonder did Deputy Healy get up anywhere in Cork and say: "Have you listened to what Deputy Barrett said?"

Comment on this

I do not think he said what Deputy Dillon says he said.

Comment on this

I am only reporting what the Minister says he said.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

I did not hear or read any report, but like many an old warhorse, I still paw the ground when the bugle sounds, but I did not hear that, as the campaign proceeded Deputy Healy or the wise Deputy Wyse, as his colleagues described him, told his constituents: "Listen to Stephen Barrett. Digest what he has told you. Consider the implication of the warning he has offered." On the contrary, I think they talked of the resolute promptitude with which the Minister for Industry and Commerce acted to protect this industry in Cork. Would that be a fair paraphrase of their speeches?

Comment on this

Part of them, yes.

Comment on this

Did any of them go on to say: "But the Minister was very coy when we asked him the question: what will you do 12 months from today?" Are we not entitled to say to him in the context of this order: ‘You are proposing now a Quota Order the limit of which you state is 12 months more unless the President of the British Board of Trade consents after to extend it——

Comment on this

To be strictly accurate, the first quota period order ends at the end of next month, and this is the one we are dealing with now.

Comment on this

I give the Minister 13 months. Is that the point he is making?

Comment on this

Yes—lest the question of my silence be construed as consent, as Deputy Dillon is inclined to construe silence or words to suit his own purpose.

Comment on this

Both can be eloquent.

Comment on this

He may say that because I did not say this I misled the House. I would like to keep the record straight.

Comment on this

A very prudent precaution, because I want to keep the record straight, too, and the record I am trying to keep straight is this: what are the facts? Does anybody know? I would have thought from what the Minister said and from the statement he was good enough to hand us—it was very short—that the sum and substance of this order is "quota protection for a period of 18 months beginning the 1st of last July, but not thereafter except subject to the consent of the President of the Board of Trade in the event of my being authorised by the Government of the Republic to approach him again." Is that not a fair representation of the Minister's statement? I think it is, in fact. The Minister has an understanding with the President of the Board of Trade that there may be three quota periods each of six months.

Comment on this

That is not quite accurate, but I shall deal with it when I am replying.

Comment on this

I would be sorry to cross-question the Minister, but if the Minister reads his own statement, he will agree that is the impression it would create on the minds of most Deputies.

Comment on this

I agree that is the impression that appears to have been created.

Comment on this

I would have said this Quota Order operated for the last six months, will operate for the next 12 months and that at the end of that period further consultations will be had with the President of the British Board of Trade and if he enters an absolute caveat under the Anglo-Irish Free Trade Agreement, the Minister will feel himself debarred from having recourse to quota protection after the approved 18 months. It would appear from the Minister's interjection that that is the position, that he has secured the agreement of the British Board of Trade to a six months quota and that he anticipates that the agreement with the British Board of Trade will be forthcoming for two further quota periods of six months each, each permitting the import of not more than 65,000 articles, but that thereafter he can give no warranty, or even an informed prophecy, to the House as to what the situation is likely to be I wonder did Deputy Healy know that until I managed to extract it. Certainly Deputy Lenihan said in the House that they have had three years and now they have another year to get their affairs in order. He rebuked Deputy Flanagan who, he said, appeared to pass the responsibility to the Minister. He said it is not his responsibility, that he has done his part and that it is now for the management of Dunlops. Who is speaking the truth?

Comment on this

I do not understand what the Deputy is talking about.

Comment on this

I think Deputy Lenihan honestly believed that the Minister had made a Quota Order covering the period from 1st July last up to 31st December next.

Comment on this

Let us grant that assumption. What is wrong with the statement that the responsibility was that of the management?

Comment on this

The Minister told me not to make that assumption.

Comment on this

It is not relevant to the point the Deputy appears to be making.

Comment on this

Is it right or wrong?

Comment on this

I will explain that when I am replying.

Comment on this

We are in this deplorable situation. I read—not only heard but read as every other Deputy did— the Minister's statement introducing his own Quota Order. Certainly Deputy Lenihan, his own supporter, does not understand it. It appears now that I do not understand it. Poor Deputy Healy is looking bewildered because, I suspect, he does not know either. I look across to wise Deputy Wyse and he is looking at the ceiling because, like me, he does not think he knows either.

Comment on this

I do not go around ringing a bell about what I do.

Comment on this

Wise Deputy Wyse does not go around ringing a bell.

Comment on this

It must be the night of the full moon.

Comment on this

No; it is the night of revelation. This is a matter about which Deputy Wyse does not ring a bell. There are other topics on which he has been ringing a bell for the past two days. If this were a permanent quota protection for Dunlop's factory, I wonder would Deputy Wyse's bell have been so silent? On the contrary, it would not be a handbell he would be ringing. He would be swinging out of a rope. The Bells of Shandon would have nothing on him. Now he is not even able to borrow one from an altar boy because this order is not one about which Deputy Wyse desires to ring a bell. Why? Why does he not desire to ring a bell? Is it because he is afraid the people might understand what it means? Why does Deputy Wyse not ring a bell about this order? Was it not his duty as a Deputy for Cork, asking the people to vote for Deputy French, to ask them to come and listen to him while he expounded to them on this order which is so vitally important to the people whose votes he sought? Why did Deputy Wyse not ring a bell?

Comment on this

Is it the Cork by-election, or the Fianna Fáil Ard-Fheis, or what the Deputy is talking about?

Comment on this

I am talking about Deputy Wyse's bell. Do I depart by a hair's breadth from relevancy? Deputy Wyse says that this order is something about which he did not ring a bell.

Comment on this

I did not say that.

Comment on this

What was the reference to ringing a bell about?

Comment on this

If the Deputy is trying to make a speech on my name, he can go ahead. He should not invite interruptions. I am not in the habit of interrupting.

Comment on this

No more courteous Deputy ever sat in the House but he was good enough to say, while I was speaking, that this Quota Order was a matter about which he did not ring a bell.

Comment on this

I did not say that.

Comment on this

He did not say that.

Comment on this

I said I did not go around ringing a bell about what I did.

Comment on this

Is a discussion on bells in order?

Comment on this

I see. It was Deputy Wyse who persuaded the Minister to make this order.

Comment on this

If the Deputy wants to think that, he can. I had no intention of interrupting.

Comment on this

I assure Deputy Wyse that he has never interrupted me at any time discourteously or offensively. I am full of interest: I do not deny that. I have pressed not only him but Deputy Healy also to render an account of their stewardship.

Comment on this

The Deputy is so eloquent and able to put his case that it might be more satisfactory if he told us what his view is instead of asking us what our view is. We can make our contributions in due course.

Comment on this

I am giving my reaction to this order. Unfortunately I have to employ certain circumlocutions to express it under the rules of order of this House. My interpretation of this order is that they are unscrupulous traversers of the truth. If they wish to substitute the common word for "sanguinary" and the common word for "traversers of the truth," they will have correctly interpreted my judgment of their conduct in connection with this order. That is my reaction.

Comment on this

This will have a tremendous impact on the Dunlop workers.

Comment on this

Lest Deputy Healy might misunderstand me, I said they were traversers of the truth, explaining that the rules of order of the House would not permit me to employ the term "bloody liars".

Comment on this

That is what I gathered.

Comment on this

Having made that positive contribution to the debate, the Deputy will no doubt now go on to say why he thinks so, and let us get on with the business of the House.

Comment on this

I do not find fault with the Minister for his reaction to the dilemma in which he finds himself, but I do find fault with him because I do not believe he took the precaution of telling the people the true significance of what he was doing, or what he was in a position to do. I do not think the Deputies who support him from Cork were honest with their supporters because I do not think they told them either. If you went to the ordinary workingman in Dunlops tonight, he would say: "What was all the talk about the Quota Order? What was all the debate in Dáil Éireann about the Quota Order? Everyone appeared to want to save our jobs. Why talk so much about it?" None would know that the reason is that the Quota Order drops dead 12 months from today——

Comment on this

They do know.

Comment on this

——or 13 months, and that thereafter, according to Deputy Lenihan, their livelihood depends on the capacity of the management of Dunlops so to revolutionise the situation in the factory in Cork that they can trade hereafter without protection from that order any more. Does the Minister believe they know?

Comment on this

I know they know a great deal more about the whole situation, about what has been done by the company to prepare, about what is being done—a great deal more than the Deputy obviously.

Comment on this

I do not think that is quite true but I invited the Minister to answer. Do the people whose livelihood is to be affected by this order appreciate that it comes to an end 12 months from now, and that thereafter, according to Deputy Lenihan, let nobody look to the Minister for Industry and Commerce to take further action; the responsibility of providing continued employment on a remunerative basis rests squarely on the management of Dunlops.

Comment on this

They know this. They have been told this in public. I do not know where Deputy Dillon was when this happened but his whole case is based on a false premise.

Comment on this

I know the management of Dunlops since before the Minister was born and I am as certain as I am standing in this House that there is no more efficient management in Ireland than the management of Dunlop's factory. Let us be clear about it. If the management of Dunlop's factory is not good enough for the world in which we live, then there is no management in Europe with any prospect of survival. I do not believe that the kind of management Dunlops has sat on their hands for the past three years, trusting to God, like Mr. Micawber, that something would turn up. I do not believe that the management of Dunlops never spent a penny in order to enhance the competitiveness or the efficiency of the factory over which they preside and of the factory which provides the livelihood of hundreds of workers in the city of Cork. I am perfectly certain that the management of the Dunlop factory did all that reasonable men could possibly do to meet the requisitions made upon them by the Minister and his predecessor and those who spoke for the Government.

Is the case made here tonight that this whole problem of the arrival of tyres in this country at the rate of 15,400 a month is due to any laches or failure on the part of the management of Dunlops? Is that the Fianna Fáil case? If it is, it is time they made it. If that case is to be made, let it be made so that it can be challenged. The Minister for Industry and Commerce has recently referred to the eloquence of silence and compared it with the eloquence of words. Up to now the only positive explanation of the situation that has been provided has been provided by Deputy Lenihan, senior, and he says he supposes that Dunlops did what they could in the past three years, "for they have had three years" he said "to adapt themselves, and doubtless they will do still more in the year that lies ahead".

Let us all agree that the management of Dunlops did all that a competent, diligent, effective management could do for three years. Deputy Lenihan, who claims to know the inner workings of the Dunlop factory says that, to his knowledge, they were keenly aware of the problems that lay ahead and that, to his knowledge, they were doing all in their power to adapt themselves to that situation. Let us all agree that this is so. Deputy Wyse is here from Cork to correct me if I am wrong, and Deputy Healy is here. Do they allege that Dunlops did not do their part? All my information goes to show that the management of Dunlops did all in their power to bring the efficiency of that factory up to the highest level to which it was possible to bring it and they were dealing with a situation in which they had not an inexperienced staff. They have as well trained a staff as there is in any part of Ireland, France, Italy or Britain. I mention the three larger countries as the three great tyre producers in Europe: Goodyear, Dunlops and other British combines in Britain. The net result of the three years exercise which we all agreed had been made was that tyres were coming in at the rate of 15,400 a month. What does Deputy Healy or Deputy Wyse——

Comment on this

And Deputy French, the victor.

Comment on this

He did not like to mention him.

Comment on this

I told Deputy French that it is the customary courtesy of this House, while experienced swordsmen exchange what we may describe as legitimate political taunts—it is our hospitable habit not to expose a new and welcome colleague to the rigours of debate until he has grown accustomed to us——

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

——until he gets to know that, though we say rough things, we do not mean them personally; they attach to a man's policy rather than to his person.

Comment on this

I can even remember the time when Deputy Dillon treated me in the same kind manner.

Comment on this

Yes, but the Minister Colley and I have grown older since those happy salad days and I am on the way down and, I hope, he is on the way up.

Comment on this

That is a very nice thought.

Comment on this

Which I feel sure Deputy Healy shares, or is he afraid of the fate that overtook his colleague who nearly got his block knocked off for backing both Deputy Colley and Deputy Haughey for the same job on the same night?

Comment on this

That is only imagination.

Comment on this

However, I shall talk about tyres. We all agree that Dunlops did what they could, the management and the men, and are faced with a crisis now. Deputy Lenihan, speaking for Fianna Fáil says: "Let the management do their best for another 12 months and if they do not succeed then, do not blame the Minister. Do not ask the Minister for an explanation." What I want to know is: have the men been told? Are they going to be told, because they will want an answer to this question. It is not enough to tell us at the end of 12 months when this Quota Order reaches its conclusion. We want to know what is going to happen hereafter, and when you prepare your story, do not forget that full publicity has been given to our adhesion to the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade but it is not understood in all its details by every workman in Dunlop's factory.

Whatever we propose to do when this Order comes to its end, we will have to do in the context not only of the Anglo-Irish Free Trade Agreement but of GATT as well. I have not heard anyone tell me here tonight, and I am as quick to hear as the next one, what the Government proposes to do. I think so large a body of men, so large a number of old established families in Cork are entitled to have at least 12 months notice wherein to plan their future. If we are in the position to give them the good news that there is no abridgment of the permanence of their employment and that they can plan on the assumption that no lesser volume of production or employment will be available in the Dunlop factory than has been heretofore, then we ought to give that assurance here and now, because nothing can be more cruel than to hold such people in the unendurable suspense as not knowing from month to month or from week to week what their future and the future of their families is to be.

Comment on this