We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

An Bille um An Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1968: An Dara Céim (Atógáil). Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968: Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 132–311 of 311. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968
Rejected

No. 5 of 1968 ›

Do you want to be the Opposition?

Comment on this

Members of your Party have indicated that you have not the capacity to govern. You want to remain a weak Opposition and that is not in the best interests of the country. Give us something we can fight. Give us a reasonable Opposition.

Comment on this

Were you in Wicklow?

Comment on this

I was, and in Waterford, Cork and Limerick.

Comment on this

And will be again.

Comment on this

He is like The Fugitive—hopping about all over the place.

Comment on this

The western world is at it again. Fine Gael spoke about bargaining for power by irresponsible groups. This meeting took place some time ago between certain members of the Opposition Parties who spoke about a merger but the little meeting collapsed and they came back dis-illusioned. I will not bore you with a lot of quotations.

Comment on this

That is our good luck.

Comment on this

I have a lot of quotations. Deputy Dillon said in 1947 that PR had been foisted on us by a collection of half lunatics. It will probably be said in time, if it is retained, that its retention was supported by half lunatics. The remarkable situation is that it is the back-benchers of Fine Gael who opposed this, not the leaders. Even the leader of the Late, Late Show himself decided that he was in favour of the straight vote system. Other people were silenced when they indicated that they were going to speak out in favour of the straight vote system. I wonder how this decision was arrived at because it was generally believed that the Fine Gael Party themselves would, by their own supporters outside, support this.

Comment on this

Is that why you brought it in? You made a big mistake.

Comment on this

I am told that there was a deputation received from a section of Fine Gael who cannot devote full time to politics but can only appear in this House from 7 p.m. to 10.30 p.m. and that this particular group said: "For heaven's sake, do not take government; we could not devote the time to it." I do not know if it is true that it was due to the pressure of this particular group that this decision was arrived at when they said: "We can only be available in this Dáil from 7 to 10.30 p.m."

Comment on this

I wish to God you would get a job that would keep you out of here until 7 o'clock.

Comment on this

Naturally.

Comment on this

It would be a wonderful relief.

Comment on this

We find, and the public will find if they are in the Gallery, that certain people appear here only from 7 to 10.30 p.m.

Comment on this

You could lay that on all sides of the House.

Comment on this

Do you mean your own people?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

I am not like the rest of men.

Comment on this

I am sure that this was the reason. Those gentlemen do not want to accept power. They do not want to accept responsibility. They just want to be ornaments in this House. Fair enough: carry on. With the present system, they will remain ornaments.

Comment on this

Whom is the Deputy referring to?

Comment on this

Do you want him to spell them out?

Comment on this

You do not want names, do you?

Comment on this

Whom are you referring to? Are you referring to your own members or to our members?

Comment on this

I am referring to your members.

Comment on this

Put your own house in order first.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would Deputy Harte keep in order for a few minutes and allow the Deputy to make his speech?

Comment on this

Impossible.

Comment on this

It is not right that the record should be put out of order by him.

Comment on this

I would appeal to the Labour Party——

Comment on this

Good man.

Comment on this

——even at this late stage to examine their conscience.

Comment on this

They are throwing out the lifebelts.

Comment on this

Are you inviting us to get where you have got yourself. God forgive you.

Comment on this

I just want to protect you lads. You are likeable fellows and I want to protect you from this particular group. I know that it was this particular group that made you sell out before; they made you sell the aeroplanes and close down the factories and do all these things which you did not want to do. I know you do not want yourselves to be mixed up with a group of men who do not want power, only destruction, and who will force you into a situation where you will have to go to the people and answer to the people. I am trying to protect you. I know the workers themselves want strong government, and I am sure that if you decided even at this late stage to support a system that will give you some hope of survival, some hope of Government even in the distant future, the workers will respond and you will probably find that they are more reasonable than you think they are at the moment so that you can carry on as responsible and honest politicians who will be known, loved and honoured in time to come.

I know that it is difficult for you. I know that at this stage you have thrown your hats into the ring and it is difficult to pull out, but I believe that there are members of the Labour Party who believe in the Labour Party, who believe in its survival, who believe in a strong Opposition, and I am quite sure that if they had their way, they might be prepared to support this particular line just as the trade union to which I belong and many other unions use this system. The workers would not support a system they do not believe in.

I have dealt with the question of strong Opposition and simplicity of voting. The people are not mathematicians. This is a simple and straight-forward system whereby people can make up their own minds in a short space of time and decide on one man and vote for the best man, and that is the only vote. I believe that the people on this occasion will not be misled as they were on the last occasion but will, as they have done on many other occasions in the past when a reasonable case was put before them, measure up to their responsibilities, meet their responsibilities in full and vote for the system which they know is best in the interests of the nation. There will be fewer elections.

It has been stated here that this referendum will cost a terrible amount of money. Deputy Ryan spoke about spending the taxpayers' money, and the new Deputy also.

Comment on this

That was Deputy Timmons from Wicklow. You should not forget him.

Comment on this

I will not forget him.

Comment on this

Deputy M. J. O'Higgins will not forget him.

Comment on this

It was Deputy Paudge Brennan who won that election.

Comment on this

Deputy Ryan spoke about the taxpayers' money. The average life of a Government in this country has been less than three years. Of the 15 elections we had, seven were unnecessary and would probably not have taken place if we had had a better system of voting and it would have saved an enormous amount of money. It was Deputy Ryan who spoke about saving taxpayers' money. He cost the country more money. It cannot be said that he was a cheap politician. He cost the country thousands of pounds on all sorts of gimmicks and dodges over the years. If we knew his surrender value, many a man would buy him out of here. As far as the cost to the taxpayer is concerned, the situation is that more elections have taken place because of PR than were necessary over the years. The average length of a Government was less than three years.

Comment on this

It is two years and five months in England.

Comment on this

Oh, I see. You want that system adopted.

Comment on this

We want stability of government.

Comment on this

What system did you say? This would not necessarily give you stability.

Comment on this

It would, of course. We know that the Irish people are intelligent people and will see this in the manner in which it is presented. This will ensure stability of government on a long term basis so as to protect this nation from all the dangers and the horrors that from time to time——

Comment on this

A few obvious interruptions there.

Comment on this

You should not have interrupted him. He was about to say something.

Comment on this

Deputy Cluskey is a member of a five-seat constituency. Probably other Deputies are members of those large, cumbersome areas.

Comment on this

Deputy Seán Lemass is one, too, and the two fellows he dragged in with him under this system.

Comment on this

Dragged in—I shall deal with that in a minute. I must make a note of it.

Comment on this

Are you afraid of Ben Briscoe?

Comment on this

It may well happen that I will be defeated next time.

Comment on this

You are only trying to build up our hopes.

Comment on this

It may well happen, but there is no guarantee that you will be returned. You have no guarantee about yourself.

Comment on this

What about Noel Lemass?

Comment on this

One of you will have to go.

Comment on this

What about Noel Lemass?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will Deputies allow Deputy Dowling to make his speech?

Comment on this

We are not stopping him.

Comment on this

I wish he would start.

Comment on this

I think every Deputy will agree that the areas are too large and too cumbersome and it is impossible to represent the people properly.

Comment on this

Speak for yourself.

Comment on this

I say that small areas are especially desirable. It is in those areas you can best serve the people. I believe a division of the five-seat areas, the four-seat areas and the three-seat areas will give public representatives more contact with the people. I know that the Opposition do not want to have more contact with the people. They would like to keep as far away from them as possible and that is why they want to have those cumbersome areas. They want to see the areas large and cumbersome so that the people have to take their place in the queue.

Comment on this

What sort of areas would you have in mind?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will Deputy Harte cease interrupting?

Comment on this

I regret that that member is doing his best to embarrass you.

Comment on this

I know from the number of people who come to me, a considerable proportion of whom have been with other parties and have not supported me in the past, that they find it impossible to get anything done and to get any recognition whatsoever from Deputies in other Parties because they find they are overburdened with work. I can well understand their problems because there may be something to be said about this. There is not a single Deputy in the Fine Gael Party or in the Labour Party who does not know the great burden which falls on them.

Comment on this

When you say "single", are you referring to the married state?

Comment on this

I did not get to that: I am not sure whether they are married or not. I am concerned about the single Fine Gael and Labour Deputies. Five-seat constituencies must throw a large burden on them. I have crowds of people coming to see me every Saturday morning, crying about the lack of attention given to them by the Opposition Deputies on the basis that the areas they represent are too large.

Comment on this

You have upset Deputy Cluskey.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will Deputy Harte allow Deputy Dowling to make his speech? He has no licence to interrupt in this manner.

Comment on this

The majority rule. We have heard a lot of talk about dictatorship and it is rather regrettable that this factor was drawn into the discussion. During the past few weeks, we have heard many such charges about this thrown at the Government for introducing the straight vote system, that it was to set up a dictatorship. We all know that some people might be inclined to take this seriously. Some of the younger generation might be inclined to take some of the pronouncements that will come by way of literature seriously, but it must be remembered throughout the years in this country only one Party attempted to set up a dictatorship. The members of that Party now accuse the Government of wanting to set up a dictatorship. I have heard the threat which was made to the people of this nation which is recorded in the Irish Independent in 1934 at the Fine Gael Ard-Fheis. The records show that the majority of the delegates and all the Party Leaders arrived at the Ard-Fheis wearing blue shirt uniforms. The entire assembly stood and gave the Fascist salute.

Comment on this

You supported the IRA and you locked them up afterwards.

Comment on this

Many people were executed in 1934.

Comment on this

The democratic system was protected by Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

Many people were executed in 1934. What about those people?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Harte should behave himself.

Comment on this

It is terrible to listen to him.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has a remedy.

Comment on this

You are excused.

Comment on this

That is more than I could say for you.

Comment on this

You will have a front bench seat soon.

Comment on this

The Wicklow by-election was mentioned by one or two Deputies. We had the type of propaganda in Wicklow that we will probably have again during the referendum campaign. I listened to Deputy Ryan of the Fine Gael Party speaking in the most disrespectful terms of our candidate, indicating that she was a woman of 73 years, 70 years, 69 years, 65 years.

Comment on this

Bingo.

Comment on this

This was the type of propaganda the Opposition seemed to favour during the election campaign. They tried to paint a picture of a situation which is not factual. We know that during the coming referendum all sorts of gimmicks will be used by the big Molotovs of today and tomorrow, the no-men. We see one big building now carrying "Vote No" on it. The question of how that sign is produced, who produced it and whether in fact they have proper authority to put it there should be considered.

Comment on this

Why not inquire into it? Let the Minister for Justice inquire into it.

Comment on this

It will wipe itself out.

Comment on this

He has no head for heights.

Comment on this

It will wipe itself out. I do not mind it being up there.

Comment on this

What are you talking about it for?

Comment on this

It is questionable whether it is permissible or not.

Comment on this

You should report it.

Comment on this

I will be dealing with it at a later stage, not in this debate but in another debate where I will deal with it more fully. I would now ask this House and the Labour Party, before I depart, in the interests of your own Party and the interests of the workers to give them some hope for the future. Do not bury yourself in the same grave or the same rut as the Fine Gael Party are about to bury themselves in. Give the people who support you some hope for the future. I am quite sure that this is the last chance you will have.

Comment on this

We have heard it before, Joe.

Comment on this

You will hear it again now. This is the last chance you will have. I am quite sure the people know this. The Minister also realises this from contacts he has with people who have in fact opposed us in the past. They now indicate they are in favour of stability of government, economic development and economic advancement when it comes to entering the Common Market or any other market we may enter.

Comment on this

Where was all that support during the by-elections?

Comment on this

They supported us in five constituencies out of six. That is not too bad—the straight single transferable vote. That would do just as good. I do not favour the single transferable vote. The straight vote is my line.

Comment on this

Are you going to oppose the other?

Comment on this

Where the Party goes I go. I should like to read two or three extracts from the Labour Party contributions.

Comment on this

Take your time.

Comment on this

You said "in conclusion".

Comment on this

It might take a long time to conclude. It was suggested by one of the Opposition speakers that there were not so many splinter groups in this country after all. The political cannibals have gobbled up many of these Parties over the years and the reason they gobbled up the Labour Party was given.

Comment on this

Tell us about that.

Comment on this

Since 1948, 22 parties have contested elections: 12 were elected. A party or two were put out of office and the entire control of the nation rested at one time in the hands of two people.

Comment on this

That was Lenehan and Sherwin.

Comment on this

It burst up the coalition on two occasions.

Comment on this

Lenehan and Sherwin kept you in office.

Comment on this

We do not burst up.

Comment on this

We will be here for a long time as predicted by Deputy O'Connell. He gave us 20 years. He guarantees 20 years but I am sure this is a conservative estimate. We might be able to give him that guarantee.

Comment on this

Did you not say that before?

Comment on this

I want to emphasise it in case the Deputy did not hear. I want to ensure that the public know that the Labour Party spokesmen feel that we will be here for 20 years, and rightly so. Deputy O'Connell made probably the most intelligent speech from the Labour benches. I agree with him. I do not always agree with him. But I agree with him just as I have to agree with Deputy Hogan who said they were a poor Opposition.

Comment on this

Does Deputy Dowling want a strong Opposition? You will be safe here after proportional representation.

Comment on this

I dealt with that some time ago. At column 1240, volume 223 of the Official Report, Deputy Hogan of South Tipperary said:

Fianna Fáil are now urging us to provide a proper Opposition. I believe we are not providing a proper Opposition.

He admits that he may be disloyal to his Party in saying this. Nevertheless, he is honest enough to admit that you are not a proper Opposition. You will have to get together and provide a unified Opposition to justify Deputy Hogan who wanted a guarantee that we will not present the country with proportional representation for 12 years, as predicted by members of the Labour Party.

We say we are good for 20 years anyway. At least you still have time to change your minds, to show the people that you have confidence in yourselves, in your Party and in the future of the country. I would suggest that you get Deputy Hogan and Deputy O'Connell together in some quiet corner tomorrow and let them work out a solution because they alone seem to have grasped the significance of this delicate situation.

There has been a suggestion that this system was not imposed upon us by the British. I should like to quote from information at my disposal. Following the Sinn Féin general election victory of 1918, the British Government brought in PR first——

Comment on this

What is the Deputy quoting from?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Will the Deputy give the source of the information?

Comment on this

It is from the Attorney General, Mr. Samuels, in 1919.

Comment on this

What is that about?

Comment on this

What document is it?

Comment on this

I am quoting Mr. Samuels.

Comment on this

He is quoting from Woman's Own.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

If the Deputy is giving a quotation, he must give the source.

Comment on this

We must know the source of this document.

Comment on this

Following the Sinn Féin general election victory, the British Government brought in PR first for Irish local elections and then for parliamentary elections under the Government of Ireland Act, 1920.

What was the reason for this complete break with the long standing British electoral practice?

The explanation was given by the Attorney General, Mr. Samuels, in introducing the Local Elections Bill. He said:

At the general election on the parliamentary franchise, 75 per cent of the representatives has gone over to the Sinn Féin Party. What is the declared object of that Party? It is to make local government in Ireland absolutely impossible and to break down the British reign and rule in Ireland by capturing local bodies...

Comment on this

Does the Deputy want the quotation? I will give it to him.

Comment on this

It continues:

Who are you going to trust the administration of these things to? Are you going to trust them to bodies elected on the present franchise and under the present machinery—bodies which have been absolutely captured by people who call the rest of the United Kingdom "the enemy", and whose object is to break down the rule of the "enemy" and make the whole administration in Ireland impossible.

In other words the policy of the British Government was to make Ireland weak while keeping Britain strong.

Comment on this

You put it into the Constitution 18 years after.

Comment on this

This was the introduction of proportional representation into this country by the British. The object was to weaken our representation here while at the same time they would remain strong. We know that 60 years ago a commission was set up in England to examine the system and after comprehensive investigation they found that there were 300 systems of PR in operation. When they finally reported——

Comment on this

How many systems?

Comment on this

Three hundred.

Comment on this

You must have been talking about the other 299.

Comment on this

In dealing with the question of Government majorities, the report had this to say:

The advocates of the Transferable Vote remind us that the object of a representative body is to represent, but the object of representative government is not only to represent, but to govern.

The greatest evil that can befall a country is a weak executive, and if a strong one can only be obtained at the cost of mathematical accuracy of representation, the price should be willingly paid.

The object of a representative government is not only to represent but to govern. We know that the Parties now in Opposition have deserted their responsibilities, deserted some of their own people, have indicated that they are not prepared to take power, at any price or at any time, that they are prepared only to come together to form weak coalition government whereby blame-placing can become a factor in the future just as it was in the past. They can bring this country, not to the verge of bankruptcy but into bankruptcy and produce a situation which will probably be irretrievable in future.

We know from the statements made by the Opposition Parties that they are no longer interested in government, no longer interested in Opposition. They are prepared to sit and snipe, to make noise and to give the impression that they are the people who are trying to keep the government of the day on the tracks and trying to extract concessions, whereas they have completely failed the people who elected them and have given their supporters no confidence in themselves or in the future. When the next election takes place it will be seen that a very substantial section of the people will support the Party who are in favour of constructive work being done in order to maintain efficiency and the progressive advancement of the nation, the only Party that are prepared to accept their responsibilities and to measure up to them, as they have in the past, and will in future, when called upon to do so, who will never desert the nation, who will never desert their supporters, who will not run away from their responsibilities, as was done by these weak, watery, coalition groups that came together and now see that the only alternative for them in future is a weak coalition.

I am quite sure when I look at the Labour Members now that the only thing left for them if they are ever to be a government is to be a government with a group of people who sit very close to them in this House. I am quite sure that the bulk of their supporters do not want a coalition.

Comment on this

Did you read the Wicklow by-election results?

Comment on this

People are prepared to accept coalition in order to remain in the House under a system that would probably give them some representation in future. They are uncertain about their representation in future. Maybe they will be here for some time but they can be assured that the seats which they now occupy are the seats that they will remain in for all time. Deputy Cluskey says that he does not want to be here on this side of the House. I can well understand why he does not want to be here. He need not have any doubt about it. He never will be on this side of the House. Neither will the Labour Party nor the Fine Gael Party. I hope that at the next meeting between the two groups they will agree to the merger suggested behind closed doors over a dinner plate, that they will be in better form when they come into the House and that at least one thing will emerge, that there will be some sort of responsible, strong Opposition, not the type that we have at the moment that is concerned only about its own survival and not concerned about the nation's survival, as we on this side of the House are.

Comment on this

I am sorry that Deputy Dowling is leaving the House. That is rather unfortunate, particularly having regard to the advice which he attempted to give to this House and in particular to the Labour Party. Just before you took the Chair, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, in the process of advising the House, Deputy Dowling said quite emphatically, "This is your last chance". There is great depth in that. The implication was that the Labour Party should watch itself. I regard that as a threat. We are very mindful of that threat, having regard to the way in which the Fianna Fáil Party has operated since its inception. "This is your last chance". This is what is really behind the move by Fianna Fáil to do away with PR. This, of course, is the people's last chance. This referendum will be the people's last chance to ensure that Fianna Fáil do not get their way.

Deputy Dowling went on to talk about the advent of small groups. He said there were 22 of them since 1934, as if this was a crime. When it suits Fianna Fáil, they shout about upholding democracy. Surely, it is the right of people to form a party that they see fit to form. Surely, the time has not come when the situation is that parties will be allowed to come into existence only by permission of Fianna Fáil.

Deputy Dowling produced a ballot paper in this House which he said he got from his union. It is generally found, when a person gets a ballot paper, that he uses it. It would appear that Deputy Dowling had not got the courage to use the ballot paper that he produced in this House. Perhaps, he pretended it was a ballot paper. He suggested that that ballot paper showed that there could be a straight vote system in operation for something. He did not say whether it was in connection with a wage increase or the creation of a new post in his union. We know, of course, that Deputy Dowling can safely be described as a disappointed trade union official. He tried to become an official of the union to which he adverted, of which he says he is a member, and was rejected. It is only fair to say, when talking about trade unions and their operations in the context of PR, that there is no denying the fact that the Irish Congress of Trade Unions has an annual convention at which every union affiliated to it is afforded the opportunity of changing the executive for the coming year. The system of voting used on these occasions is the system of proportional representation. This is done deliberately with a view to ensuring that the small unions will have a say in the running of the affairs of the Irish Congress of Trade Unions, as the big ones will. That system is also operated in the various centres where there are what are called trade councils. These are bodies to which various unions are affiliated in their area.

The Dublin Council of Trade Unions, to which Deputy Dowling is duly affiliated but to which, for obvious reasons, he has never been selected as a delegate to represent his union, elect their executive annually by means of proportional representation. That is very important when one talks about how the trade unions behave in this matter.

It is typical of Deputy Dowling to mislead and to say things that are incorrect or half-true. He talked about holding the balance of power and conveniently forgot that a few Independents kept the Fianna Fáil Government in existence for a number of years and allowed the Fianna Fáil Government to perpetrate the turnover tax on the people. We know what happened at the next election as a result of the action of these people.

Deputy Dowling told us he had nothing to fear from the single-seat constituency and pointed out what a great idea it was. However, it is only reasonable to try to ascertain why this is being done. For example, in Dublin South-West, the constituency Deputy Dowling represents, there are at present three Fianna Fáil Deputies. Having regard to all that is happening around us, common-sense tells us that, if there was a general election tomorrow under the PR system, some of these would go. Whether it would be Deputy Briscoe, Deputy Noel Lemass or Deputy Dowling himself remains to be seen. Perhaps this is the reason they are looking for a change—in order to avoid the back-stabbing that would go on amongst the Fianna Fáil group on the occasion of the next election under PR.

A similar situation exists in County Dublin. Undoubtedly in the next general election under PR, someone there would fall by the wayside. Fianna Fáil attempted before to ensure that Deputy Boland, the Minister for Local Government, would head the poll—the bright young man in place of the old dog for the hard road. Still, Deputy Burke headed the poll. Then we had Deputy Foley coming along. Who will be knocked the next time? Surely these are the things that are exercising their minds? Then you have the remnants of the succession stakes in Dublin North-East. Who is going to be cock of the walk there under the PR system? These are indications of the real reason why this proposal is being brought forward —this lust for power, this impudent suggestion that it is wrong to form Parties.

Something new has emerged in the course of this debate. Heretofore we have had one Fianna Fáil speaker after another referring to coalitions and talking about them as if they were terrible things. Now their spokesmen are suggesting that Labour and Fianna Fáil should get together to form a coalition.

Comment on this

Labour and Fianna Fáil?

Comment on this

Fine Gael and Labour.

Comment on this

You joined with Labour before.

Comment on this

Labour joined with us.

Comment on this

It is extraordinary how forgetful some Fianna Fáil people can be. To the discredit of the Labour Party perhaps, we voted on one occasion and created a Fianna Fáil Government.

Comment on this

May the Lord forgive you.

Comment on this

We brought the Fianna Fáil Party into power. Of course, we also have the proud record of being the Party that formed the first Opposition in this House, when it was not very healthy to form an Opposition and when many threats were issued to members of the Labour Party if they discussed forming an Opposition. Why did we do it? Because the Labour Party was in existence before ever Fianna Fáil or Fine Gael were thought of. This Simon Pure talk on the part of Deputy Dowling will not wash. He talks about people queuing at clinics looking for assistance. It could be that they find it difficult to see him or some of his colleagues.

The Taoiseach introduced these Bills in his usual way, reading his speech, not making a case for it and appearing as if somebody else had formulated what he was uttering. Certainly, an examination of his speech proves conclusively that no case was made for either of the two measures he placed before us. Subsequent speeches of Ministers had the same effect. It is interesting to bear in mind what the Minister for Industry and Commerce said on 5th March at column 150 of the Official Report for that day:

As I said, the situation, therefore, is that any realistic assessment of the situation will show that there can be no alteration in the political system in this country under PR except Fianna Fáil going out through some kind of combination of Fine Gael and Labour and we know that in the next election Fianna Fáil will come back again. I am human enough not to want to see Fianna Fáil going out of office but I am also sufficiently concerned with the welfare of my country to know that for any Party, Fianna Fáil or any other, to be in office for ever would be a disaster for this country.

Yet we had Deputy Dowling telling us they were going to be here for the next 20 years or 80 years. Who is right— Deputy Dowling or the Minister for Industry and Commerce?

They have all this concern about the Opposition, but it is only natural to query its sincerity. Surely their advocating of a fusion of Fine Gael and Labour is not realistic? Surely it would be more realistic to have a merger of Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael? In column 151 of the same volume, the Minister for Industry and Commerce also said:

Surely Deputies know very well that the situation in Northern Ireland is quite different? Why get up here and tell us about the dictatorship we would have in this country? Why do they not have dictatorship in Britain, Canada, the USA with this system of election? This kind of thing is not helpful.

Because of that we are supposed to forget about the system of election in Northern Ireland.

This new change on the part of Fianna Fáil, which I consider to be the brainchild of the Minister for Local Government, will never be accepted by our people. We know the Minister's way of introducing anything and we can compare his advertence to this matter with that of his colleague, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, and see that it differs very much. The Minister for Local Government is well known for his intolerance, indeed his arrogance, and the contempt he has often displayed in this House for matters introduced by Deputies. While there have been some interruptions here tonight during the course of Deputy Dowling's speech, they are nothing to the many interruptions that have taken place from Fianna Fáil during this debate. This is a fearful thing. It is a bad sign. It does not augur well for the future and should make us more cautious about changing the system of election.

I submit that it would suit the Minister for Local Government better to tighten up the manner in which elections are conducted rather than proposing to change our system. At the last election in Wicklow we had the situation in Bray—and it was subsequently admitted in this House—where members of the Fianna Fáil Party were arrayed right in front of the booths setting out to ascertain from the people their names and numbers, with a view to ensuring that they had not already voted. At the same time, they were setting out to find out who had not voted and got on the ball. That is a form of intimidation utilised by the Fianna Fáil Party. I submit that is the type of thing we should look into— checking registers outside polling booths.

Comment on this

Good organisation: jealousy is at you.

Comment on this

It is not jealousy. The polling booths should be left to the people to vote in. There should be no sign of interference when the people are going to the polling booths to exercise their franchise.

Comment on this

No one interfered. We were encouraging them.

Comment on this

Encouraging, and holding the hammer over their heads. The strange thing is that some of the people conducting this exercise outside the booths were well-known employers. Heaven help the employees if they did not respond in a civil manner. The Minister should also concentrate on the misuse of State cars during the course of elections.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil are good employers.

Comment on this

Personation should also be attended to.

Comment on this

Did the Parliamentary Secretary say Fianna Fáil are the Party of the employers?

Comment on this

I said Fianna Fáil are good employers. Does the Deputy not want people to get employment?

Comment on this

I know a number of them and they are bad employers.

Comment on this

We had Deputy Dowling here tonight going back to some Attorney General in England. The period which he was talking about was when PR was being introduced——

Comment on this

Foisted.

Comment on this

He neglected to say that it was Fianna Fáil who put it in the Constitution which we operate. So much for his worry about the British Attorney General. Of course, as time goes on, we learn a lot. There was a time when Fianna Fáil advocated that we should burn everything British except their coal. Now there is a different state of affairs. We cannot get close enough to Britain so far as Fianna Fáil are concerned.

Comment on this

They have a Labour Government.

Comment on this

It suits the Fianna Fáil Party very much in this House in snide remarks to refer to the British Labour Government. At the same time, when the occasion presents itself, they go over and are all palsy-walsy with members of the British Labour Government. We all know there are faults which need to be remedied, especially if we are going into the Common Market, or if we are to play a greater part in Europe and the world. These are the things we should be looking into rather than dilly-dallying with the system of voting.

I should imagine that I am expressing a fair consensus of opinion when I say it is not the system of voting which is worrying our people today. They are preoccupied with hosts of problems: housing, rates, insufficient social welfare benefits, a continued rise in the cost of living and unemployment. These are the things we in the Labour Party would like to see the Government getting their teeth into. If they set about doing that, they would not have to turn to these benches and tell us what to do or ask us what we would do. We would give them every assistance.

Comment on this

We would not want to follow your example: 10d a year for the old age pensioners.

Comment on this

Under the PR system no constituent is at the mercy of one TD or one Party as he would be, if PR were abolished. I am sure the Parliamentary Secretary will agree that in his own Party there are activists and inactive people. Surely he is not suggesting that would be changed completely by making this change? If there is only one TD in an area, what about the inactive TD? Do we have to wait for another election for matters to be remedied?

I am submitting that under the present system—and Deputy Dowling verified this—a constituent who finds he is not getting anywhere with a problem can go to another TD. Deputy Dowling admitted this. This is a good thing. This is the proper way of servicing our people. This element of competition is useful. I do not think there are people in any walk of life who do not need to be checked, watched and pulled up at times. We can all do with being checked and pulled up. Under the multi-seat arrangement with PR, there are three, four or five TDs in an area and this affords the people an opportunity of having matters being put right. It does not enable a person to say: "All right; you voted for me. I will forget about you until the next election." Perhaps a few months before the next election he is heard from again.

It would seem that one of the reasons given for the abolition of PR is to avoid having dissident groups. The Government cannot deny there are dissident groups in existence, and where they are in existence, the obvious thing to do is to encourage them to come into this House, to get elected and then express their point of view rather than producing some measure which will make it more difficult for them to come into the House. If there were no dissident groups in existence, it would be pertinent to inquire: why the continuation of the Emergency Powers Act? Does it mean that the Emergency Powers Act is being held in readiness for trade unionists only, these dissident groups about whom Fianna Fáil seem to be worried? I continue to maintain that they have a right to express their point of view and to appeal to the people and to hope to be elected.

There was a time when Fianna Fáil did not follow that line of reasoning. There was a time when Fianna Fáil did not recognise authority in Parliament. We are satisfied that authority emanates from Parliament and this is what the Labour Party, to its eternal credit, brought about in this country. It was the Labour Party who introduced an Opposition at the inception of this Parliament. Very often, when it suits ourselves, we prate about democracy and about the right of people to express themselves. At the same time, we have this talk about taking steps to ensure there will not be the irritation of the emergence of dissident groups.

The Irish have been more than anxious to show themselves to be a people who believe in free expression of thought so long as it is done in an ordered fashion. The case has been put for and against the abolition of proportional representation. A study of Deputy Boland's contention that proportional representation is wrong reveals that the case he makes does not ring true. When we think in terms of giving people a voice we must come to the realisation that people are entitled to a preference.

Almost everything is influenced by the existence of alternatives. Our purchasing power is influenced by the existence of what we have and what we have not got and by what is on offer as compared with what we have. Here, also, the operation of alternatives comes in. The same applies to wage negotiations. A claim is made for increased wages and it ends up in a bargain, which is an alternative. It is synonymous with the system of proportional representation which is not a dogmatic system of vote "I" and forget the rest.

I have already made the point about what would happen to the people in relation to the single-seat constituency system as compared with the multi-seat constituency system. I now submit that the people who would be the worst affected would, in the main, be those who, of necessity, must obtain social welfare or health benefits. Every active Deputy can verify that a goodly portion of his work consists of making inquiries about the operation of the social welfare and health services systems. They are both deplorable systems. If the Fianna Fáil Party get their way and introduce the single-seat constituency, then the pensioner on 57/6d. a week will be left to the mercy of this one individual and will not have the opportunity he formerly enjoyed of going to one of the other Teachtaí Dála in the area to seek immediate action. His only remedy will be afforded to him in the next election, a long-term remedy, typical of the way Fianna Fáil do things—the long finger.

In my estimation, the Taoiseach is seeking a blank cheque from our people. He cannot point to instability of government. Never has it been said and never could it be said during the lifetime of this Government that any Minister was unable to do this or to do that because the Government had not an overall majority. Neither can the Taoiseach give any one instance that, during the lifetime of this Government, proportional representation held up the introduction of legislation. These are proper remarks and personal points which highlight the importance of ensuring that proportional representation be retained.

The Taoiseach cannot assert that the single-seat constituency will produce a better Deputy unless he has in mind a better Fianna Fáil hack or backbencher who will shout for his Party when the opportunity presents itself—perhaps that is nearer the mark. I do not believe the back-benchers have any voice on this proposal. Why do the Taoiseach and his cabinet want to alter the rules? Are they afraid the fruits of Fianna Fáil Government will have an effect on the people—unemployment, rising costs of living and the bringing of international combines to our country? Are Fianna Fáil afraid that these undesirable trends will turn a large proportion of their supporters away from "the grand old Party" that is so frequently talked about? The people want an opportunity to give Fianna Fáil their answer. Deputy Dowling said Fianna Fáil will be in office for the next 20 years——

Comment on this

He was quoting Deputy O'Connell.

Comment on this

Deputy Dowling did not say that. Furthermore, Deputy Colley said it would not be good that Fianna Fáil should be so long in office. There is a contradiction there which is typical of Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary knows better than Deputy Colley.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Connell did not say what the Parliamentary Secretary has attributed to him. I understood him to say that an attempt should not be made for another 20 years to bring about in this country a different system of election—and that is a different thing.

Comment on this

For the past six weeks we have listened to attempts by the Government to justify the introduction of the proposal to abolish proportional representation which is nothing but a malodorous red herring in this deliberative Assembly. The red herring has now begun to stink in the nostrils of the people of this country who are well aware of the Government's motives in trying to induce them to agree to the abolition of proportional representation.

Comment on this

Good man.

Comment on this

The Government's proposal will get a State funeral when it is put before the people. It will then be buried so deep in the ground that never again will our people be asked to agree to that proposal. If the people were foolish enough to agree to the straight vote then I could see the day when, with the Irish temperament, it would take the bullet to change the system.

Let us have more of democracy. Let us have proportional representation which is democracy in full. We have heard talk about tolerance for the West. My colleague opposite has not offered to support this, nor has his colleague in my constituency. Maybe he is thinking: "If the Big Chief thinks it, we will all say it."

The Minister for External Affairs told us this was imposed by the British. I wonder if they are imposing anything on us now. He reminds me of Rip Van Winkle. He has been asleep for 46 years since the British left this country and he now wakes up suddenly in his latter days here to realise that we have been held down by the British. I wonder if they imposed sterling on us at the moment would we refuse it, or the ships off the Wexford coast at present? Does he call that being imposed on? That old cock will not crow any longer. This proposal shows that we have a power-drunk Government in Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

It is hard to get that old cock to crow now. It has been crowing a long time.

Comment on this

Yes, but his head will be pulled soon.

Comment on this

Let us probe the real reason for this proposal which I have not yet heard; why they are trying to put this across the people. We have a group known as Taca——

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

This is a puppet Government because Taca pull the strings and dictate policy. It is a sad day when power is being taken from the people by the gangsters. We had gangsters in Chicago——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy should keep to the two measures before the House.

Comment on this

I am pointing out the underlying cause is that those backroom boys want to keep control. They never had to stand on a public platform. They remind me of the gangsters in Chicago who at one time pulled guns. These gentlemen pull chequebooks and the one hundred pound note. That would not be a cheque, which might be noted. They want to ensure that the paw-greasing backhanders will have full control and will continue in power. The Government are only a face for these gentlemen. At one time we condemned, or were prone to condemn, free-masons——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I have already asked the Deputy to keep to the Bills before the House.

Comment on this

I am getting to them. To be a freemason, you had to have some background; you did not have to be a blackguard. I know some of them. It is sad that we have in our public galleries, coming to the front gate and putting up his hand, a man who spent two years behind prison bars through corruption, one of the he-men and key men of Fianna Fáil, the greatest fixer who can fix anything anywhere anytime. These are the gentlemen I want to point out as being the string-pullers of a puppet Government.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair must point out that the Deputy is not in order in discussing such matters. We are discussing the Third Amendment and Fourth Amendments of the Constitution.

Comment on this

Why should we change the Constitution so as to take power from the hands of the people and give it to the backroom boys? This gentleman has been the fall guy for the Front Bench of Fianna Fáil and he has them blackmailed today and they must cough up. This is the type of government we must guard against, government by remote control. Let us have government for the people by the people but not government by the backroom boys.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy criticising the present system of election?

Comment on this

I suggest the Parliamentary Secretary should leave it to the Chair to decide what I am criticising. He should listen and learn. Let us get our priorities in order. If we have £100,000 to spend for a referendum, let us bring down some of the gentlemen in the Bentleys and Mercedes and so on—my own is only an old Ford but it will do; we make them in Ireland—to places where the Bentleys cannot go, where there is muck and slush and floods and where people must come out in wellingtons. If we have that sort of money to spend, let us spend it on back roads and on building houses for poorer people who have to pay high rents and cannot afford them.

People are being asked to hand over their powers now as the gunmen once asked them to hand over their money. Unless people have the full power of their vote, they are, as we have said, handing over to a Taca-backed government, that is only a face for the gangsters we have. The sooner the people wake up to this and express that view the better. They will express it, as I have said, when they give this proposal a State funeral and deep they will bury it in the bowels of the earth.

Fianna Fáil Deputies have made milk and water statements. Deputy Dowling came here to-night but he did not have his own speech. He was handed a statement to get across. We knew from the way he spoke that he did not mean a word of it. He was just like the man on television—is it Charlie McCarthy—the ventriloquist. It was not himself who spoke but his statement, most of which he read when he came here trying to put this across and keep on the right side but he failed miserably. I know that Deputy Geoghegan would like not to be asked to speak but if Deputy Geoghegan is prepared to stand up and defend this proposal—he has been honest enough so far not to do so—I am prepared to give way because I know that Deputy Burke is eager to go. If Deputy Burke agrees now to let Deputy Geoghegan defend this proposal, I will give way to him, but I think he is honest enough to remain seated keeping his mouth shut, since a shut mouth catches no flies.

Comment on this

I shall deal with the Deputy at the church gates and at the crossroads.

Comment on this

I can stand at any crossroads and I can say that my people stood at the crossroads when it was dangerous to do so and were elected for Sinn Féin before either the Deputy or his colleague was heard of.

Comment on this