Committee on Finance. - Wool Marketing Bill, 1968: Committee Stage.
Contributions 121–261 of 261. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 9 of 1968 ›
I have already referred to this question of the circumstances of any particular case. Why should there be special circumstances and why should there be any particular case? The Parliamentary Secretary said, or implied, that I have one of these haunted minds and that——
Comment on this
I think the Deputy already dealt with that.
Comment on this
In the course of discussing a section that we should not have been discussing because we were on section 5 before we should have been on it.
Comment on this
The Deputy did lay particular stress on the circumstances.
Comment on this
He made the point without moving it. The point has already been made.
Comment on this
Certain references were made by the Parliamentary Secretary about this and he tried to justify this clause (c) which refers to "in the circumstances of any particular case" which the Minister considers relevant. I want to know what the Minister has in mind because when we are producing legislation, unless it is written into the Bill that something means one thing or another, it is of no use. The Minister might decide that he did not like the colour of John Murphy's eyes and that would be "circumstances of a particular case". The House and the people are entitled to know what would occasion these special circumstances. They should be written into the Bill. Even if the Minister explained what he has in mind, it is not good enough.
Comment on this
The only reason it is there is to ensure flexibility in the insertion of particulars in the register.
Comment on this
Would that not be achieved by accepting this amendment? If the subsection were to read "such other particulars as the Minister considers relevant", would that not still allow the flexibility? It would be of general application. It is wide open to the Minister to supply what is necessary.
Comment on this
The Minister in section 5 (2) (c) has sufficient power, even if these words were deleted. Surely he can get all the particulars he wants?
Comment on this
A register has to be set up and the Minister prescribes certain particulars which must be entered into the register, the names and addresses, sufficient particulars to describe the premises and so on, and then we have this omnibus clause, which is obviously intended to cover anything else that might occur and which the Minister might not have listed already but which might be relevant for the purposes of the register. Normally, one would expect that this would read "such other particulars as the Minister considers relevant". If it read like that, it would cover anything the Minister considers relevant. By putting it that way, it is of general application and the same rule will be applied to every entry in relation to the register. It will be the same for everyone if it is "such other particulars as the Minister considers relevant".
The Parliamentary Secretary asks what is the objection to retaining the words "in the circumstances of any particular case". Surely it is up to him to make the case why it is necessary to put in those particular words when the sub-paragraph contains sufficient without them to deal with cases on a universal, general basis? Why is it necessary in those circumstances to refer to the circumstances of any particular case?
Comment on this
The reason is that in the course of time you will find isolated cases which would involve grave hardship. Surely it would be better to have provision made to cover these rather than to be compelled possibly to put people out of business altogether or give them no opportunity of converting what may be unsuitable premises into suitable premises? The more sinister fears of the Deputy can be allayed by the knowledge that the register will be open for inspection during office hours at the Department so that there cannot be any peculiarities in particular cases.
Comment on this
The names of those who are on the register. If he has any particular case in mind, he will be able to see forthwith that the person has been registered and he will know the reason in fairness——
Comment on this
Perhaps the Parliamentary Secretary could give us an example? There may be a good reason for this but certainly it is not an obvious one. One would imagine that when a register of this sort is being established and when the Minister is prescribing that particular information be entered in it, it should be the same for everyone rather than that there should be power to say: "Well, in relation to A, I want to know his name, address and his premises——
Comment on this
——and in relation to B, his name, address, bankers, the number of children he has, and so on."
Comment on this
You will find that 95 per cent of the cases will pass muster on the first occasion and that probably 4.9 of the remainder will be able to adapt themselves but——
Comment on this
This is not a case of passing muster. This is a case of prescribing what is to be entered on the register. The case of passing muster will come along in section 6, as regards buyers, and in section 7, in regard to exports. This is only settling the form which the register is to take and surely one would expect that to be the same for everyone?
Comment on this
It gives flexibility as regards the insertion of particulars in the register and from that point of view it is well worth retaining.
Comment on this
But that flexibility is still given if you leave out the words which the amendment proposes should be left out.
Comment on this
There will be, as there are in all walks of life, isolated cases and it would be unfair to legislate against a very small minority.
Comment on this
Does the Parliamentary Secretary appreciate that all that this is doing here is settling the form of the register so that it is not a question of particular cases getting in or not getting in. It is a question of information to be given on the register. The cases are in or they are not in. If they are in, they are on the register. If we leave this as it is at the moment, it is deciding what information is to be given about particular cases.
Comment on this
I am not objecting to flexibility because it would be there anyway. It would be flexible for everyone if these words are taken out.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary does not appreciate the significance of the case we are making. He is quite off beam when he says there can be no suspicion about this, that if one wants to know who is on the register, the register is open for inspection. We are fighting for the fellow who is debarred from the register. I can see that the Parliamentary Secretary is not really able to make a case and I would ask him to undertake, on behalf of the Minister, to have another look at this between now and Report Stage.
Comment on this
I can see that the Minister might make a case, normally speaking, that he would only require on the register a person's name, address and premises, but, if there is an application in with a local authority for planning permission, and it has not been granted, he would want that noted on the register; he would want it noted that the premises are subject to planning permission. I could understand it if that were the kind of special circumstances the Minister might have in mind; he would want to make sure that the entry on the register was not going to be taken as presupposing that some consent— for example, Land Commission consent—was needed or permission from some other Department of State was going to be granted automatically because of the entry on the register. If there were a case of that nature put up here, we could consider it. There might be something in it, but, as it stands, there does not seem to be any necessity at all for these words and all we are doing is settling the particulars to be entered on the register and there does not seem to be any reason why they should not be the same for everyone.
Comment on this
The only thing I can say at this point is that the parliamentary draftsman advised the wording and I presume it is a drafting point.
Comment on this
Will the Parliamentary Secretary undertake to speak to the Minister about the deletion of these words?
Comment on this
Normally, we should now discuss section 5, but we put the cart before the horse in your absence and we have, I think, discussed it sufficiently.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 8:
To delete "the Minister" whereever those words occur in the section and substitute "An Chomhairle".
Comment on this
In regard to amendment No. 9, amendment No. 11 is cognate. Both may be discussed together.
Comment on this
Yes. I move amendment No. 9:
In subsection (1), page 5, to delete "may, at his discretion" and substitute "shall, subject to subsection (2) of this section".
Here, again, we see no reason why this discretionary power should be held by the Minister. This deals with the application for and conditions of registration. The section provides:
On the application, in such form and containing such particulars as the Minister may direct, by or on behalf of a person who proposes to carry on the business of a buyer of wool the Minister may, at his discretion, register the person in the register as a registered buyer....
We want "shall" instead of "may"—"shall, subject to subsection (2) of this section". We hold in this case, as in all cases, that the people should know in advance what the conditions are for registration, what they should do, what they should measure up to, and it should be the same for everyone. All should have to comply with the same conditions and measure up to the same standards—minimum standards, minimum equipment, minimum accommodation—below which they must not go. They may go above. But everyone should know where he stands. It is deplorable that the political head of a Department should be in a position to lay it down that something is at his discretion: "I do not like that fellow. He really has everything but he votes Fine Gael. He was very prominent in the last election."
Comment on this
That is not going half as low as certain people have gone. It is totally wrong to have this at the discretion of the Minister. A whole list of conditions is set down under subsection (1) before the Minister registers any person but one is not told the conditions under which a person will not be registered. That discretion is retained by the Minister. This is the big stick, the weapon over the applicant's head and, if the Minister does not like him, down the stick will come. Why should we not know in advance why this discretion is necessary? The same discretion is written in in relation to the granting of a licence for carrying on the business of exporting wool. Surely an exporter of wool should know that, if he does not measure up to certain standards, he is not entitled to be registered as an exporter of wool? If he does something wrong, he should lose his licence. Nowhere in the Bill is it stated that he will lose his licence. If wool is exported under specification, the exporter should lose his licence, but there is no provision to that effect. Yet, the Minister has discretionary powers to continue giving an unreliable exporter a licence to export wool.
Comment on this
Exactly, and he has no obligation to give any reason and there is no appeal. The Minister has sole discretion. Why is that necessary? We have had this before on several occasions. There is no convincing reason that anybody can advance as to why this should be retained. Therefore, we have the amendment.
Comment on this
On the face of it and looking at things in the first instance, it would appear that there is tremendous merit in Deputy Clinton's amendment but he does not rule out all the possibilities and this is why discretion must be left to the Minister. If the amendment were accepted, the effect would be to compel the Minister to register anyone who satisfied the conditions set out in section 6.
Comment on this
In the normal case, a person who did satisfy fully all these conditions would be registered but there is a very real and positive danger that at some stage in the near or in the distant future someone would come along, a firm, individual or cartel, and monopolise or tend to monopolise the entire wool industry. If the Minister were obliged to register everyone who fulfilled all the normal conditions there would be no way of safeguarding the market against such a monopoly. By having this discretionary power— and the word "may" gives him this— there is such safeguard and he will be able to control the affairs of wool buying and selling and protect against would-be monopolists even though they may have satisfactory premises and competent staff. Such a monopoly, as the Deputy appreciates, would more than likely depress—it would aim at depressing—wool prices here and you would have, as you have in England, this confused situation. I do not think that, on reflection, Deputy Clinton will press this amendment.
Comment on this
I draw the Parliamentary Secretary's attention to the fact that quite a short time ago, on the previous amendment, he said that there would be so many buyers in the country it would not be possible for An Chomhairle Olla to get around them. Now we have reduced them to one. It is now a monopoly of one. That is the great fear and this is the great safeguard being put in here because of a monopoly of one. Surely the Parliamentary Secretary is not making a case there? I draw the attention of the Parliamentary Secretary to subsection (4) of section 6 which reads:
Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act, a person who carries on the business of a buyer of wool and who, immediately before the passing of this Act, carried on that business, shall, if in relation to the premises in which such business is so carried on or any plant or machinery therein, any regulations under this Act and applicable thereto are complied with, be entitled, on payment of the prescribed fee (if any), to be registered in the register as a registered buyer.
There the Minister ties himself to giving this man a licence. He ties and binds himself. That is not a capital sin. I agree with that. If it is not a capital sin to bind himself in subsection (4) of section 6, if certain conditions are fulfilled, to give a man a licence, surely the same should be open to anybody who is capable of doing a good job of selling wool? You may have a case of a first-class co-op which might be set up by a farmers' organisation which the Minister did not like and the Minister would use his discretion and say that he will not give a licence. That is too bad. This is legislation that is extremely undesirable. I should like to hear the Parliamentary Secretary telling us why it is possible for the Minister under a specified set of conditions in subsection (4) to bind himself to giving a licence and will not bind himself anywhere else. He wants this little hammer that he can use or this little carrot that he can hold out.
Comment on this
The Deputy, either deliberately or unwittingly, minister-prets the Minister. The Minister is merely holding discretionary power, not as a carrot or a hammer to induce or coerce, but rather to protect the interests of the wool trade of this country. While the Deputy quite rightly adverted to the fact that I did mention that there were a large number of premises at present in the country, he must concede the point that we are living in the era of monopoly and take-over and joint firms moving in and not only Irish firms but foreign firms could well be attracted if they found that there was an easy killing to be made here.
Comment on this
I hope we will never allow an easy killing on the producers of wool in this country.
Comment on this
It could well be the case, if they got a complete monopoly of the market. The Deputy is aware that no business, trade or industry is so vulnerable as the agricultural community are to the activities of cartels. The Minister must, in fairness both to himself and the farming community, retain the discretionary power to protect the interests of the wool trade of this nation and anyone who advances a theory whereby he would be disarmed of this discretion would be doing a disservice to the agricultural community. Certainly, I would not credit Deputy Clinton with having that in mind. I appreciate that he does not intend to work against agricultural interests here. For that reason I would expect that he would withdraw this amendment.
Comment on this
Would all that danger not be avoided by accepting amendment No. 8, which would leave the power in the hands of An Chomhairle Olla?
Comment on this
I know that. It is simply relevant to the argument. It would save the Minister embarrassment and it would protect.
Comment on this
It would take the obligation off the Minister and put it on An Chomhairle who are concerned with the trade.
Comment on this
He is concerned as Minister; the others are personally concerned. At least three of them will be representative of producers and three at least will be from the trade.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary has set out to make the case that this is inserted in the Bill to give protection to the producer but he has made no case that I can appreciate for this as providing any protection for the producer. If the discretion is going to be used by saying to a person: "Even though you fulfil the conditions that other buyers of wool fulfil, I will not give you a licence" or "I will not register you as a buyer, even though you have fulfilled all these conditions", what is the reason? Is it that there are too many buyers there already? There is nothing to beat competition if you want to help the producer.
Comment on this
No, that is not his fear. The desire is to maintain the position where one would not monopolise the trade.
Comment on this
Could it not be put in as a condition that the Minister must be satisfied that it is not in furtherance of a monopoly, for example? Would that not solve the difficulty?
Comment on this
The Deputy knows through his own profession that people who set out with malice aforethought can well find devious ways of sidestepping and evading regulations by calling themselves by various names and buying up other companies.
Comment on this
I doubt it very much, not when the personnel would be known, and the names and addresses.
Comment on this
If an organisation are to get the hammer, they should know why. The fact that it is being done through the use or misuse of discretion is not good enough. They should know in what dimension they are wrong. There is nothing in this to indicate what these dimensions are except that there is a set of conditions here that an applicant must fulfil before he will be registered, but there is no similar set of conditions in which he is going to refuse. He shall have regard to them but he shall use his discretion just the same. I cannot see a case made for it on any grounds so far.
Comment on this
In subsection (3), it is to be noted the Minister, where he proposes to reject an application, must tell the applicant the reasons. That surely should allay Deputy Clinton's fears?
Comment on this
That is not the same thing. It does not say the grounds on which the Minister may refuse. It simply says that having refused, the Minister shall state his grounds. The burden of Deputy Clinton's complaint is that people do not know in advance the grounds on which the Minister may refuse other than the fact that the Minister is not satisfied under (b) (i) (ii) and (iii), but people do not know what other grounds might be necessary.
Comment on this
I have given one example of what might be a reasonable case for rejection. The fact that the Minister would have to state afterwards why he rejected any application is a guarantee that it would not be for a frivolous reason, nor would it be one which he as Minister could not justify in the public interest.
Comment on this
Surely Deputy Clinton will concede that no Minister would place himself in the invidious position of refusing an application for some harum-scarum reason but that he would have some valid and cogent reason for doing so? The fact that he has to state afterwards the reason for his refusal is a guarantee that it would be a good and valid reason. I cannot anticipate all the peculiar cases that might arise, if indeed any arise. Certainly the Minister would not go out on a limb to refuse a genuine and justified application without good reason. If there were a good reason for doing so, the application could no longer be justified.
Comment on this
I have seen Ministers doing queer things and making decisions nobody but they themselves understood. It is for that reason I am objecting to this discretionary power without outlining the circumstances in which he will use this discretion.
Comment on this
Might I put this to the Parliamentary Secretary? If this section were reframed in another way, if there were an effort to write into the section the grounds upon which a Minister might refuse an application, even if there were an omnibus reason such as in section 5, it would be preferable to this. I did not hear the entire of the Parliamentary Secretary's remarks and I probably misunderstood him. He seemed to me, when he was arguing about the necessity to have this discretion vested in the Minister in order to protect the wool trade and the producers, to argue that the reason for the discretion— and I thought he meant the sole reason for the discretion—was because we were living in an age of the take-over and so on and that it was necessary to protect our own people against the possibility of take-overs.
If that is the reason behind it, it would be very easy to write that into the Bill and to put down in subsection (2), as one of the matters about which the Minister must be satisfied before he gives a licence, the fact that there is no question of a monopoly being established. If there were other reasons of equal importance that the Minister or Parliamentary Secretary felt would justify the refusal I do not see that there is anything against writing those into subsection (2), listing them and at the tail-end of the list if necessary, if the Minister, the Parliamentary Secretary or their advisers felt there was something that might be listed, I would think then that even the inclusion of an omnibus clause such as "for any other reason which to the Minister or to An Chomhairle seem reasonable" or something of that sort would be preferable than leaving it in this vague way where there is no substantial guideline laid down other than the vague generality of Ministerial discretion.
Comment on this
I should certainly weigh in with Deputy O'Higgins if I could think of all the devious routes people would eventually discover. There is no doubt that people out to get around regulations seem to be much more adept at discovering all the ways and means than those who try to protect normal relations and standards and even legalities. No matter what legislation is introduced people will find some easy way out of the regulations as such. Leaving it to the discretion of the Minister is the safest way to ensure that no matter what route is taken or what subterfuge is adopted, if it does come to light, it can be halted straight away. I do not think anyone in this House or outside it could elaborate all the devious ways that could be adopted by any person desiring to depress the price of wool or gain advantage for themselves, or even decry the wool industry of this nation for peculiar reasons.
Comment on this
Before we leave the amendment, I would ask the Minister why in the case of subsection (4) of section 6 the Minister considered it was all right to bind himself, subject to certain circumstances and conditions being complied with. If he can bind himself in this way for existing people, surely it is unfair discrimination against people who will, we hope, come into the business in the future, co-operative societies and so on? Why should he add an additional dimension or qualification in their case? Why should he hold this over their heads and say: "Even if you do comply with all the conditions I have outlined in subsection (4), while I bind myself to give it to the existing people I do not necessarily bind myself to give it to you"?
Comment on this
All the arguments we have put in moving amendment No. 9 equally stand against the section. I do not want unnecessarily to delay the House. I am anxious that some sort of legislation in relation to wool be got through this House as fast as possible, consistent with trying to make it good. But I am afraid we are failing rather badly tonight. I have no further arguments to advance against the section I have not advanced in moving amendment No. 9. I should like the House to take it that I have the same objection I expressed on amendment No. 9 to the section.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 10 was dealt with with amendment No. 4 and amendment No. 11 was taken with amendment No. 9. Amendment No. 12 falls.
Comment on this
Again the discretionary powers are given here. At line 39 we see "at his discretion grant or refuse to grant a licence." Here we have the same sort of argument. If I want to get a licence to export wool, I know there are certain conditions which will normally have to be fulfilled. Before I make that application, I must set up, so to speak, as an exporter. This involves considerable expense of one sort or another. Before I embark on this expenditure, I am entitled to know that if I do certain things and comply with certain conditions, I am then entitled to a licence. That is what is really in our amendment. We are looking for nothing more or less. Section 7 leaves this so open that after going to all the expense and all the trouble of making the necessary arrangements, the Minister may use his discretion and say: "No, you do not qualify; we cannot give you a licence." I think this is a very objectionable section and it should be amended.
Comment on this
I want to call attention to the fact that, quite apart from the discretion in section 7 in regard to the granting of a licence, there is also in subsection (4) a provision that the Minister may, if he so thinks fit, amend or revoke a condition attached to a licence, and you have in subsection (3) the provision that the Minister may, at the time of the granting of a licence under this section, attach to the licence such conditions as he shall think proper and shall specify in the licence.
It seems to me, that, while this is perfectly reasonable, and while no very great objection will be taken to the idea of the Minister being entitled to attach conditions, provided there were some general guidelines as to the circumstances in which the conditions would be attached; if such guidelines are there in relation to subsection (4), there should be spelled out in the section the particular circumstances in which the Minister may revoke or amend or vary the conditions attached to the licence.
The point I am making in relation to subsections (3) and (4) is that people will not know where they stand unless the Minister is prepared between now and Report Stage to amend this in some way which will give definite guidelines to people as to the particular circumstances which will require to be in existence before (a) conditions are attached or (b) conditions are altered or varied.
Comment on this
I think Deputy Clinton made the point earlier that anyone who did anything to discredit Irish wool should be penalised. This section deals effectively with that. A person can be made amenable to the highest discipline and standards by virtue of the fact that he may lose his licence.
Comment on this
If a licence were to be granted on each individual consignment, there would have to be an inspection. It should be incumbent on the exporter rather than having an inspection of each lot.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 15:
In subsection (4) (e), page 7, line 24, before "of" to insert "or solicitor".
This amendment speaks for itself. Section 9 provides that, if certain things happen, the Minister shall appoint a person who is a practising barrister of at least ten years standing to hold an inquiry. I hold very strongly that a practising solicitor of ten years standing would be just as well qualified to do the same job and he might cost a bit less. That is the only point. There will probably be no objection to the amendment. I imagine the Parliamentary Secretary will at least be empowered to accept this amendment on behalf of the Minister. It is so obvious that a solicitor of the same number of years standing would be equally well qualified.
Comment on this
I should love to oblige the Deputy but I would have all sorts of people after me, including the legal profession who, I am sure, are guarding this very zealously. The view of the parliamentary draftsman is that it is a well established precedent that inquiries are held by barristers only. For that reason I regret I cannot accept the amendment.
Comment on this
Is there one good reason which the Parliamentary Secretary can advance why a solicitor would not be competent to hold this inquiry?
Comment on this
I am sure there are solicitors who would be as competent as, and more competent than, barristers. There is no precedent that I know of where solicitors adjudicate on these inquiries.
Comment on this
Is it seriously advanced that this House should accept a position merely because the Government are advised by the parliamentary draftsman that the usual thing is that inquiries should be conducted by barristers? That does not seem to me to be any adequate reason why a particular precedent should obtain for all time. Surely we have not arrived at the stage here where the Minister or his Parliamentary Secretary are simply going to take what is dished up to them as precedents without applying their own minds to it and without being prepared to have a fresher look at it?
I could understand and excuse the Minister's coming into this House with the Bill in this form because that is what he is advised but, when an amendment is seriously moved by Deputy Clinton, I do not think it is an adequate answer to say: "This is what we are advised is the precedent: this is what the parliamentary draftsman tells us has always been done". I do not think that that is an answer to an amendment of this sort. Surely some fresh thinking is required? It seems to me that this would be an appropriate amendment for the new Deputy from East Limerick to make his maiden speech on.
Comment on this
I shall bring this to the attention of the Minister before Report Stage. The only cogent reason I can give is possibly that the wig is made from some wool and that it might be discriminating against the customer.
Comment on this
Section 10 reads:
(1) The Minister may, if he so thinks fit, by regulation grant exemption from the provisions of this Act in relation to businesses of a particular class and to which this Act would otherwise apply.
(2) This Act shall not apply in relation to a business of a class in respect of which an exemption under this section has been granted and has not been withdrawn.
(3) The Minister may at any time withdraw an exemption under this section.
This is something we have had in previous legislation and, in my view, it is most objectionable. Here we are, producing legislation and setting out a whole list of rules and regulations that must be adhered to—statutory regulations—and, at the end of all of these exercises, we read that the Minister can flout the lot. He can exempt any friend of his, for any reason that he does not have to give. Surely this is the type of legislation that is most undesirable?
We have the political head of a Department putting himself in the position that, regardless of anything written into this measure, seeing somebody he wants to befriend, he can say: "To hell with this Act. I do not care whether or not it is in existence. You are a pal of mine. You are exempted. You may carry on and buy or export wool. You may do it with wool of any description so long as you are a friend of mine." How can the Parliamentary Secretary get on his feet and make a case for the retention of section 10——
Comment on this
"The Minister may, if he so thinks fit, by regulation grant exemption from the provisions of this Act....": what is the sense in having an Act with provisions in it if the Minister reserves to himself the right to dispense with all the conditions in a particular case? Surely this is wide open for exploitation by any Minister or any head of a Department?
Comment on this
It is classes of wool that will be exempted in this instance. The main concern is with the purchase of wool, with producers. Take, for example, the buying of skein wool. Skein wool is not normally bought from producers. That will be exempted.
Comment on this
In the United Kingdom, the purchase of skein wool is not controlled. Control was tried there and subsequently dropped. This provision for exemption was contained also in the Livestock Marts Act, 1967.
Comment on this
Nonetheless, all the terrible dangers Deputies opposite see embedded in this have not come to light nor is there any danger that they would ever——
Comment on this
It seems to me an atrocious provision to write into any Act. Certainly, the fact that a similar provision is in the Livestock Marts Act does not justify it. It pinpoints the danger of what I referred to a few minutes ago—the question of what is or is not a precedent. We make our precedents as we go along. If we use this sort of provision as a precedent in the future—apparently we are agreeing to the Parliamentary Secretary's remarks that the precedent is in the Marts Act—there is nothing at all to prevent the Minister for Local Government, the next time he is introducing a Road Traffic Bill, from putting in a section to say that "the Minister may, as he thinks fit, grant exemption from the provisions of this Act to any particular driver or classes of drivers or for any particular vehicle or classes of vehicles." I think the Government are opening the door to a very dangerous type of precedent.
I accept what the Parliamentary Secretary says that these particular types of businesses, such as skein wool and that kind of thing, are what are in question here, but that is not clear and there is no reason why it should not be written into this section, once that is the kind of provision the Government want. Remember, the phrase used in section 10 is "in relation to businesses of a particular class...." This whole Bill up to now has been concerned with two businesses, the business of buying wool and the business of exporting wool, and it would seem to me that anyone reading this Bill would automatically assume that the businesses referred to in section 10 are either the business of buying or the business of a wool exporter. The Parliamentary Secretary tells us in effect that is not so. Why not write into section 10 just what is meant? Why have this general provision that is going to lead to confusion particularly as we were already in the Bill talking about dealing with and thinking about particular businesses, or classes of businesses, because the two are separate.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Higgins has made the case that this Bill to date has been concerned with two groupings, the producers and the wool traders and buyers. The purchase of skein wool is made from butchers and is not direct from producers as such. However, this is by way of regulation which may be revoked by the House and so there is no need for undue worry on the Deputy's part.
Comment on this
Would the Minister explain in subsection (2) whether it is a misprint where it says "in relation to a business of a class"? Should that read "or a class"?
Comment on this
No, I think it is correct, "... of a class in respect of which exemption under this section has been granted and has not been withdrawn."
Comment on this
Could the class there not be the business of buying wool? Is there anything to limit it or to exclude either the buying or exporting of wool in this section?
Comment on this
There could be further development in the use of wool that is not normally saleable at present.
Comment on this
What I want to know is, if subsection (2) as it stands, can apply to the business of a registered wool buyer or can it apply to the business of wool exporting? If it can, even if it is not intended to, then it means in effect that section 10 could be applied for the purpose of scrapping the application of the Act to particular people in those businesses?
Comment on this
I think it is terrible to hear the Parliamentary Secretary trying to make a case for section 10 on the ground that there is a similar section in the Marts Bill, an Act that was guillotined through this House and one that is at present listed for testing in the courts as to its constitutionality.
Comment on this
Do not worry; it will come and it is the opinion of one of the most eminent constitutional lawyers in the country that it is unconstitutional. This is what the Parliamentary Secretary is advancing as a good reason why this section should be retained. This is the precedent, one that we all deplore.
Comment on this
Is the Parliamentary Secretary in a position to answer my queries? If he is not, would he have the matter dealt with by the Minister? I think he appreciates its importance. It goes to the root of this. I do not know how we can get around this. I should feel more comfortable, and possibly the Parliamentary Secretary would also, if we could get an answer to that query before passing from this section. Could we, by agreement, leave this section over until we get an answer?
Comment on this
I appreciate that the Parliamentary Secretary is not in a position to answer it now but I do not want to leave this section until it is answered.
Comment on this
Obviously we are not going to complete our business tonight on this measure. Could it not be deferred until tomorrow morning?
Comment on this
Is it the wish of the House to end the discussion at present and take the question of the Adjournment?