Committee on Finance. - An Bille um an gCeathrú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1968: An Coiste (Atógáil). Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968: Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 148–308 of 308. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 6 of 1968 ›
We are providing that the constituency which elects a Ceann Comhairle will have an opportunity of electing a Deputy in the next election.
Comment on this
It is clear that it is the intention of the Government, as was forecast, not alone to keep the status quo in regard to the number of Deputies but to increase the number by one, although the population has been substantially reduced.
Comment on this
No; I beg to differ from the Minister. In the Minister's words, Donegal is not now capable under the present Constitution of returning six Deputies. He now proposes to bring in either North Leitrim to South Donegal or to put part of South Donegal into Leitrim.
Comment on this
The Constitution requires me to do this and Deputy Harte wants to ensure that I will have to do it.
Comment on this
Surely the Constitution is dictated by the population? Despite this, you propose to increase the membership of the House by one?
Comment on this
But if he opts to continue in the next election. If any particular Ceann Comhairle decides to retire, then there will not be this extra seat.
Comment on this
Let us suppose that a vacancy arises for the position of Ceann Comhairle, then the Dáil will choose another Ceann Comhairle, and we will be back to the 144 until the next election.
Comment on this
It is possible in those circumstances, but if we wanted to retain the present position in which the Ceann Comhairle does not contest an election, we would be providing that in a single-seat constituency, there would not be any election for a Deputy.
Comment on this
Would the Minister agree that this is another method of exercising what he calls tolerance?
Comment on this
Is the Deputy only discovering this now? That there will be an extra seat for the Ceann Comhairle?
Comment on this
Yes, but the Bill has gone through its Second Stage, and the Committee Stage is nearly over and has Deputy Harte only discovered this now?
Comment on this
The Minister stated that it was important that he should clear up this issue. It is this point we are discussing. I am asking the Minister, even though I discovered this a long time ago——
Comment on this
——does he not agree that this is another method of gerrymandering? He calls it tolerance.
Comment on this
It is a question of ensuring—and I think Deputies will agree with this—that under the single-seat constituencies, we retain the position whereby the Ceann Comhairle does not have to contest an election and also that each of the 144 constituencies will have effective representation and an opportunity of electing a representative at each general election.
Comment on this
Would it not be just as reasonable to let the outgoing Ceann Comhairle contest the seat?
Comment on this
That is a point of view, but it has always been assumed that it is undesirable that the Ceann Comhairle should have to contest an election.
Comment on this
Yes, but the question is, is it desirable that the Ceann Comhairle should have to contest an election?
Comment on this
Is it desirable that the Ceann Comhairle should have to carry out all the activities of an ordinary Deputy, including activities on the part of his own political Party, in a constituency? It has always been assumed that that was not desirable and the provision up to now in fact reduced the representation of the particular constituency by one. In Britain there is no such provision, but there is a gentleman's agreement that the Speaker's seat is not contested. In fact, it has only been contested once, and not by a representative of any of the political Parties, but by somebody——
Comment on this
I do not think so, but he was dealt with in a rather derisory manner by the electorate.
Comment on this
Could we not have 143 constituencies and have the Ceann Comhairle elected instead of increasing the Dáil?
Comment on this
Yes. In the early stages, the Minister stated quite categorically that it was not the intention of the Government to increase the membership of the House. The Minister is pedalling backwards this week. He had a rough time this morning in the Party room.
Comment on this
There is no retraction. It has been quite clear all the time. I assume Deputies, particularly those on the Front Bench Opposition, have read this Bill. I know Deputy Fitzpatrick did because we discussed this on the Third Amendment and, on that, I accepted Deputy Fitzpatrick's amendment providing for a different definition of the national average. He and I had quite a discussion on it and I pointed out to him that some further amendment might be required to clarify the position with regard to the provision to be made for the Ceann Comhairle's seat. It was on that basis I accepted Deputy Fitzpatrick's amendment to the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill. I think Deputy Fitzpatrick will remember that.
Comment on this
Other Deputies apparently cannot remember because they had not sufficient interest to be here, but Deputy Fitzpatrick and I discussed this and I know that at least one member of the combined Opposition Front Bench was aware of the provision.
Comment on this
The provision is there in the Bill and we assumed, up to now at any rate, that it was accepted as undesirable that the Ceann Comhairle should be put to the necessity of keeping himself in a position to contest successfully the next general election. That has always been the assumption. To provide merely that the Ceann Comhairle's seat should not be contested, which is the present position, would in fact deprive the electorate in the particular constituency of the opportunity of electing anybody at the next election and that is why this provision has been inserted. It was reasonable to assume, I think, that it was accepted by all Parties.
Comment on this
No; there will not be two representatives. The Ceann Comhairle will not have a constituency.
Comment on this
Then he will have to take his chance in some constituency if he desires to continue as a Deputy.
Comment on this
Are we being confused? As I understand it, the person who is elected as Ceann Comhairle moves from a constituency to the office of Ceann Comhairle. The Ceann Comhairle's Office is never in the political arena but the holder of the Office may at some stage have to contest a future election, but he will not contest it as outgoing Ceann Comhairle. He will contest it as an outgoing Deputy. Is that correct?
Comment on this
If the Minister agrees the present system is confused, why does he have to increase the membership of the House?
Comment on this
If it is not considered undesirable that the Ceann Comhairle should have to contest an election like everybody else, then there is no need for this extra seat, but it has always been agreed, I think, that the Ceann Comhairle should not have to contest his seat and this seems to be the only practicable arrangement that could be made to provide for that without, to all intents and purposes, disfranchising the people in one constituency. I should point out that if the Office of Ceann Comhairle becomes vacant and the Dáil selects someone else to be Ceann Comhairle that will not involve a by-election in that constituency. The position will be that the outgoing Ceann Comhairle at the next election will be deemed to be elected and that constituency will have an election the same as every other constituency.
Comment on this
In the event of the Ceann Comhairle resigning, am I right in thinking the Minister proposes there will be no by-election? If, say, a Deputy from Mayo is elected Ceann Comhairle and retires during the term of that particular Dáil and a Deputy from Roscommon is elected to the Office of Ceann Comhairle, am I right in thinking there will be no by-election in that constituency? But, should it happen that the Ceann Comhairle dies and the Office is filled by another Deputy, in those circumstances there would be a by-election in a constituency like Roscommon?
Comment on this
No, I do not think so. This is an extra seat created to deal with the case of an outgoing Ceann Comhairle.
Comment on this
There are certain anomalies here. If the Ceann Comhairle resigns and still remains a member of the Dáil, and if he is replaced by a Deputy from another constituency in that Office, there will be no by-election.
Comment on this
Yes. It will be the same situation as if, after a general election, the outgoing Ceann Comhairle, who is returned in accordance with this provision, is not re-elected Ceann Comhairle. He would remain a Member of the House and the House would elect somebody else as Ceann Comhairle and it would then be he, if he was still in office at the time of the next general election, who would be returned unopposed.
Comment on this
If the Ceann Comhairle of the House died at the moment—and nobody would wish it of the present Ceann Comhairle; we wish him a long life—the House would elect a new Ceann Comhairle.
Comment on this
Yes, and if after the next general election, the Ceann Comhairle, who was returned unopposed, is not re-elected as Ceann Comhairle and if the man who is selected instead died, there would be a by-election in the constituency for which he was elected.
Comment on this
The Minister still thinks it desirable to increase the membership of the House when, in fact, we should be trying to reduce it?
Comment on this
No; I think the practice that has existed here since the setting up of the State whereby a Ceann Comhairle was not required to contest the next general election was a wise arrangement and should be continued but, in fact, the population is increasing, not decreasing.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Supposing the outgoing Ceann Comhairle does not seek election and we have a new House elected and one Member is elected to the position of Ceann Comhairle, that constituency will be represented by the Ceann Comhairle in the Chair until the next general election and there will be two Deputies for that constituency.
Comment on this
There will be only one representative for that constituency. The Ceann Comhairle would not be deemed to be elected for any constituency.
Comment on this
If on the resignation of a Government the Ceann Comhairle decides that he is resigning as a Member of the House, does this mean that you are going to create a by-election in some one constituency?
Comment on this
I am referring to the succeeding Ceann Comhairle, the person who would be elected to the office of Ceann Comhairle immediately after the election, when the House assembles here. The present proposal is that you will have a Ceann Comhairle and 144 Deputies representing 144 constituencies but if at the end of this Dáil— and we know it is not going to happen —the people accept the Government's proposals and the present holder of that office decided that he is not going to be a Member of the House any longer, then you will have 144 Deputies in the House one of whom is a Ceann Comhairle with the added responsibility of watching a constituency. Is that so? Does not that seem to be confused?
Comment on this
No, I do not think so. He will not have to contest the next election provided he is still Ceann Comhairle at the dissolution. During that period he will be the representative of the constituency.
Comment on this
And during that time he would be expected to be the representative for that constituency whereas if a week earlier, before the Government resign, the holder of the office decides that he is going to resign as a Member of the House, that office could be filled by a person who would not have to contest the election and, again, you would have 145 Deputies. I put it to the Minister that, no matter how he may describe the Bill, the position will be more confused under his proposals.
Comment on this
What would the situation be in this case: an outgoing Government and an outgoing Ceann Comhairle; a general election is held; the Government come back and either they decide to change the Ceann Comharile or they come back in a minority and there is a man who has been elected as Ceann Comhairle but yet does not take the Chair; somebody else takes the Chair. What then is the position?
Comment on this
As I explained, the Deputy who is elected to the position of Ceann Comhairle has, in fact, been elected as a representative of some particular constituency and that will remain the position; he will be representing that particular constituency until the next general election and if he is still Ceann Comhairle at the next general election the constituency will elect a new Deputy and the Ceann Comhairle will be returned unopposed but not for any particular constituency.
Comment on this
Supposing the outgoing Ceann Comhairle is not, in fact, re-elected as Ceann Comhairle following the general election?
Comment on this
On the point which Deputy Dockrell has raised, does this not mean that one constituency can, in effect, have two representatives and that another constituency will have no representative unless it claims the Ceann Comhairle? Does it not also mean that in the event of the Government coming back with 50 per cent of the seats, undue pressure could be used on the holder of that office to resign his seat and thereby give the Government a majority,
Comment on this
Of course, it can. It was alleged that an effort was made not long ago to create that position.
Comment on this
That was when you brought in the turnover tax. If it had been possible to defeat the turnover tax, we would have asked the Ceann Comhairle to leave the Chair.
Comment on this
It would have been justified and the country would have agreed with us.
Comment on this
The Fianna Fáil Party did it in order to get into office. They took Frank Fahy from the Chair in order to get them an extra vote to get them into office.
Comment on this
I am saying that what Deputy Harte is saying can be done under the present system. He says it cannot.
Comment on this
——he should remember that people who live in glasshouses should not undress with the lights on.
Comment on this
This is dealing with Deputy Harte's point. I am suggesting that what Deputy Harte says may happen could also happen under the present system and I suddenly recalled that there was speculation about the possibility of doing it a few years ago.
Comment on this
Is it not more likely to be an added advantage where you can have 144 Deputies elected with 72 on one side?
Comment on this
It has the merit of ensuring that the people will still have the same representation.
Comment on this
In a set of circumstances such as this, where you can have of 144 Deputies, 72 elected on the Government side and 72 Deputies elected on the Opposition side, the outgoing Government usually have the controlling of the Chair. Therefore, it is reasonable to expect that the holder of that office would be a Government Deputy. The Government could ask that Deputy to resign as Ceann Comhairle and that would give them 73 and reduce the Opposition to 71.
Comment on this
I knew a lot more about it before you tried to mix yourself up. You are only wasting time. You are getting more ridiculous and more stupid.
Comment on this
Nobody knows better than I do how difficult it would be to educate Deputy Lemass. If in the set of circumstances where you have 144 Deputies, it can be that 71 Deputies are elected, as has been the case. But with the Ceann Comhairle holding the status quo the same pressure might not be exerted to have him resign. Is this not a move by the Minister and the Government to further the act of gerrymandering in the new Electoral Bill?
Comment on this
Deputy Harte assumes that the Government can also compel a member of the Opposition to accept the position of Ceann Comhairle, which of course they cannot.
Comment on this
We are getting rid of what was imposed on us by the British. In fact, the Irish Free State Constitution did provide for the return unopposed of the Ceann Comhairle.
Comment on this
If producing the system in Northern Ireland and in Britain is getting rid of the British system, it is a queer one.
Comment on this
The first meeting of the Dáil after the 1965 election was on 21st April. Therefore, the latest date for dissolution is 20th April.
Comment on this
The Minister wants to be right for once.
Cuireadh agus d'aontaíodh an cheist.
Comment on this
I have already given a ruling to Deputy Fitzpatrick that there could be no further discussion on the Schedule.
Comment on this
For the convenience of Deputies, the Schedule was broken up and each subsection of it discussed and agreed to.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I have been told on numerous occasions—and the record will show it— that there could be no further discussion on the Schedule, and I accept that. But I was also told that the question will be put that the Schedule, as amended, stand part of the Bill. I await that.
Comment on this
I have already pointed out we have treated the Schedule as if it were a series of sections to the Bill. These sections have been debated and agreed to and we cannot debate them all over again.
Comment on this
(Cavan): We discussed the sections and the Schedule together, on the assurance that there would be a separate vote on the Schedule, as amended. If we get that, we are satisfied.
Comment on this
Deputy Fitzpatrick endeavoured to prevent further debate but was blocked by the Minister.
Comment on this
No.
Cuireadh an cheist: "Go bhfanfaidh an Sceideal, mar a leasaiodh, ina chuid den Bhille."
Comment on this
Rinne an Coiste votáil: Tá, 65; Níl, 50.
Do you agree with this result?
(Cavan): On the question as to when the next Stage should be taken, I propose that it be taken this day week for two reasons: first, I want time to consider a proposal by the Minister to meet me on a very important section of the Bill; and, secondly, the Taoiseach has made it abundantly clear to the House and to the country that he does not propose to hold the referendum until the autumn, so there is no hurry about it.