We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

An Bille um an Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1968: An Tuarascáil (atógáil) agus an Céim Dheiridh. Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968: Report Stage (resumed) and Final Stage.

Contributions 1–167 of 337. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968
Rejected

No. 5 of 1968 ›

Kevin Boland Minister for Local Government (Mr. Boland) Fianna Fáil

I have not much more to say. I think I can welcome the Opposition attitude as disclosed by this amendment as apparently indicating a change in their opposition to these Bills. It is obviously a tacit concession that they now recognise that at least the Third Amendment Bill will be accepted by the people. I think this shows that Deputies opposite have realised that they are wrong in the attitude that they are taking to this Bill. They have appreciated that what they are seeking to do is to perpetuate a system that requires injustices to be done on the people and that they are now inclined to return to what was obviously their original decision to support this particular amendment because, as I pointed out last night there could be no other reason for their demand that we should change this proposal of ours into two separate proposals than that they intended at that time to support one and oppose the other only. It shows that they are now beginning to appreciate that this changed decision of theirs, based on their consistent policy down the years of opposing principles purely and simply on the basis that they were brought in by Fianna Fáil, was a misguided decision.

I wonder is this changed attitude merely due to the fact that those who see the injustice that the Party decision to oppose this amendment would inflict on the people have refused to conform to the Party attitude and that they have refused in fact to conduct the campaign which will obviously in their own constituency result in a considerable injustice being done to the electorate there, or have they actually been authorised to adopt a different attitude from the official Party attitude. I cannot help wondering whether or not this also applies to the almost 50 per cent of the Fine Gael Party who were in fact in favour of our full proposal in any case. It is quite clear that, now that they have come around to tacitly agreeing that the Third Amendment Bill is bound to be passed by the people, we can almost assume that before the debate concludes they will be equally prepared to accept the inevitable and that is that both Bills will be endorsed by the electorate, in other words that they will accept that the Leader of the Fine Gael Party will have his way in spite of the Party which he leads.

In so far as we are concerned we have confidence in the people and we have confidence in the ability of our voluntary organisation to break through the paper wall erected by the Opposition newspapers and to overcome the one-sided propaganda disseminated under the masquerade of factual reports. After all, Fianna Fáil have experienced this right down through the years and we have been successful in spite of this consistent effort to present only the case against Fianna Fáil and against what Fianna Fáil propose. We see in today's papers a foretaste of what to expect, the almost complete suppression of the replies to the Opposition speeches yesterday, and we also see the political correspondent of one of the papers, the Irish Times, resorting to deliberate falsehood.

I quote from the Irish Times of today:

One Bill seeks to obtain a uniform tolerance of about one-sixth as between rural and urban voters so that it might take 23,000 votes to elect a Dublin Deputy and possibly 17,000 to elect a rural Deputy.

Now, that statement, as the gentleman who wrote it knows, contains two deliberate falsehoods. I admit that these two falsehoods have also been uttered here by Deputy Fitzpatrick and other Opposition spokesmen, but it is known that there is no proposal in this Bill to operate a uniform tolerance of about one-sixth as between rural and urban voters or as between rural and urban population as in the census report.

It is known that the Bill in fact lays down certain conditions in which this divergence from the national average can occur and that it is only to take account of those factors that this can be operated, and in any case it is not on the average of voters that the one-sixth divergence can be applied but to the average of population, which is a completely different thing. The gentleman who put those deliberate falsehoods into his papers, following on the same falsehood as was stated here by Deputy Fitzpatrick last night——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Which is true.

Comment on this

——knows it is not correct that anything approaching the figures he gave could result from the operation of this. He knows it is untrue to say it might take 23,000 votes to elect a Dublin Deputy and possibly 17,000 to elect a rural Deputy.

Comment on this

There are none so blind as those who will not see.

Comment on this

That is exactly what is behind the opposition to this proposal, which is merely to re-establish the position that operated here consistently from 1922 until the Fine Gael manoeuvre in the courts in 1959 obtained this legalistic interpretation of the provisions of the Constitution. As I say, this is a repetition of what Deputy Fitzpatrick has been saying but it is something both he and the political correspondent of the Irish Times know to be a falsehood. We are well aware of the policy decision by the Coalition newspapers to resort to every means to try to perpetuate the present potentially dangerous and blatantly discriminatory system we have and we have seen in today's paper a distortion of the facts and in this case deliberate falsehood.

We are not surprised nor indeed particularly concerned, but since Deputy Fitzpatrick repeated this particular falsehood last night again, it is desirable to put the facts on record so that anyone who is interested in the facts rather than the falsehoods in the Irish Times can obtain them. The fact of the matter is that the total population of this part of the country, as asserted in the last census, is 2,884,002 people and the total electorate, in accordance with the 1967-68 Register of Electors is 1,713,466. That means on the basis of 144 Deputies the national average of population is 20,028 and on the basis of 144 Deputies, the national average of votes is 11,899, so that even if the one-sixth were to be applied to the national average of votes, nothing approaching the figures which are given as facts in the Irish Times and by Deputy Fitzpatrick could in fact result. As everybody who has paid any attention to this proposal knows, it is to the total population per Deputy that this will apply and they also know that it is the retention of the present requirements of absolute equality of population per Deputy which will result in a differential voting power for some parts of the country compared with others and that, generally speaking, the extra voting power will be given to the urban population and not to the rural population, and that the only aim is to correct that to ensure that overall the value of a rural vote and of an urban vote will be almost the same.

The attempt that is being made is to deliberately downgrade the value of the rural vote. Deputies opposite and people like the political correspondent of the Irish Times think the urban people are fools and think that they believe this type of distortion of the facts and of the figures, and they also think that they want to get this extra value attached to their votes as compared to the value of rural votes. We just do not think that. We do not think urban people want to have extra voting power as compared with rural people. Fine Gael, Labour and other people, such as the political correspondent of the Irish Times think they do. I think all anybody wants is that votes generally all over the country as a whole will have the same effect in electing Deputies. I do not think, for instance, that the people in County Louth would be in any way worried if it took marginally more votes in Louth to elect Deputies than in Monaghan, and I do not think the large number of 7,500 roughly transferred from Louth in order to comply with the present constitutional provision and who were uprooted from the county they lived in all their lives and transferred to Monaghan, would believe that they have gained any democratic right by being transferred into Monaghan so that it would take roughly the same number to elect a Deputy in Louth as in Monaghan.

I do not think they are particularly worried because if they were left in their own county they would have been entitled, in accordance with the rigid interpretation of the Constitution to 3.3 Deputies instead of three and that in County Monaghan they would only have been entitled to 2.7. As I say the operation of this maximum divergence we propose all over the country as a whole will only have the effect of equating the value of rural votes to urban votes as against the present interpretation of the requirement in the Constitution, as every Deputy here knows, and as every political correspondent of a newspaper knows, if he has been doing anything to justify his position as a political correspondent.

Some time ago, on Tuesday, 26th March, I gave in reply to a question put down by Deputy Gerard Collins all the figures which are required for anybody who is sufficiently interested in justice to the people as a whole, to acquaint themselves of what must happen now if this change is not made. One of the columns in this statement, which was circulated with the Official Report, gives the electorate as a percentage of the population in each existing constituency. It will be seen there that the average percentage of the population that the electorate comprises in this country as a whole is 59.41 per cent, but that the electorate as a percentage of the population in different constituencies ranges from 50.96 per cent in Dublin North West to 67.74 per cent in South West Donegal. It is obvious that that means that if the present requirement of the Constitution is not amended and if we are required to revise constituencies on the basis of strict mathematical accuracy of population per Deputy in every constituency, this must result in the position that it will take 10,206 voters to elect a Deputy in Dublin North West and 13,567 voters to elect a Deputy in South West Donegal. It is to get rid of that requirement of the Constitution to perpetrate an injustice on the rural voters that this Amendment to the Constitution is proposed, and it is to retain that situation, perpetrating this injustice of downgrading the value of rural votes plus the injustice of transferring population from one county to another, that the Opposition are opposing this and that the newspapers are suppressing facts and publishing falsehoods such as this.

They also know quite well that this maximum divergence of one-sixth which we propose can only operate in certain circumstances which are clearly defined in the Bill and that any revision of constituencies in which it could be shown that this divergence from the national average was utilised for any other purpose would be unconstitutional. It is known then that contrary to what the political correspondent of the Irish Times states today, there may be no question of a uniform tolerance, as he describes it, as between rural voters and urban voters.

This amendment, as I said last night, proposes to have the provision of a constituency commission in each of these Bills with a condition that if the Fourth Amendment is enacted by the people the part of the Third Amendment would not be operative. This is absolute nonsense and I am advised that it would not be in accordance with the provisions laid down for the amendment of the Constitution to put a hypothetical proposal such as this to the people. Any proposal to amend the Constitution must be a definitive one which when approved by the people must become part of the Constitution. Therefore, it is just not practical to ask the people to make provisions for two constituency commissions. We are suggesting to the people that they should support both of these amendments and we confidently expect that they will enact the two reforms to the electoral system which we are putting before them. If they do we will have this constituency commission. As far as has been officially made known to date the Opposition are opposing both of these proposals. Why then, if that is so, do they want to insert this constituency commission into one if they are going to oppose the two. It is obvious that both or neither will be passed. It is obvious that certain of these Deputies who see the injustice that failure to enact this amendment would perpetrate on the people of their own constituencies having refused to put this proposition to their own constituencies, know that we will find it possible, despite the suppression of our case by the Opposition newspapers, to let the people of all constituencies know what we are doing. It is for that reason that the amendment is now proposed by Deputy Fitzpatrick and it is clearly an admission that this proposal will be accepted by the people, and I have no doubt that before the campaign is long under way and possibly before the debate concludes here they will also admit that the people will give themselves the more rational system of election and representation which we are proposing in the other Bill. In other words, Deputy Cosgrave, the Leader of the Fine Gael Party, will have his way in spite of the Party he leads.

Comment on this

The whole purpose of our Party was to ensure that these measures would be brought to the people with the least possible delay. We, therefore, deplore the unnecessary holdup in the proceedings which we have been experiencing here in the past few weeks. I would not have intervened in this debate at this juncture were it not for the off-hand and disdainful approach of the Minister to this reasonable amendment by Deputy Fitzpatrick which made clear to us once again the overall purpose which is intended in these measures.

This is unquestionably a political power-grab engineered by the Minister for Local Government who is dragging his Party behind him sticking them into this referendum, the majority of whom know they will get a terrible thrashing in the process. The request for some semblance of fair play in respect of the revision of our constituencies which must be carried out under our present laws is purely a reasonable request and the fact that the Minister rejects this reasonable request is an indication of his deplorable outlook. He wants to take on to himself the duty and respons bility of daring to carve up our consti uencies in his own way. It is reasonable to suggest that this should be done in the interests of Fianna Fáil and Fianna Fáil only. It will be done to buttress them up in every area in which the Minister sees this possible and it will be done specifically to ensure the annihilation of opposition everywhere this Minister sees it.

We have had evidence, Sir, of this in the past. Prior to the 1961 general election in which I participated and was sent into this House at the head of the poll, you had a taste of what Fianna Fáil could do, and did do, in spite of the gerrymandering of constituencies.

We saw therein their utter disdain and disrespect not merely for the Opposition as such but for the will of the people, for traditional boundaries and the like. We saw the evidence of a ruthlessness that one would only associate with North-East Ulster—a brutal carving up of county boundaries in order to entrench Fianna Fáil in power, in order to gain that extra seat or possibly defeat some members of the Opposition, Labour Deputies or Fine Gael Deputies or Independents.

We know too, that this was done without any regard whatsoever for fair play or for impartiality of any kind. Not only was there not a commission of any kind set up with a chairman who would be a member of the Supreme Court; not only was there not any representation from the Opposition; but we know now what transpired was that maps of the various electoral areas and their hinterlands were hung up on the walls of the Party clubs, in the rooms of the Party in this House, and the Fianna Fáil Members were asked to decide how best to manipulate these areas——

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

——to suit the advancement of their Party. The whole purpose was to try to grab extra power by fair means or foul and the foulest means were adopted. It is an incontrovertible fact that the views of the then Fianna Fáil Deputies were ascertained and he who was regarded as the most ruthless organiser for the Party was charged with the responsibility for the butchering. I know that to be a fact in respect of my own constituency.

Comment on this

And the Minister's own constituency.

Comment on this

The irony of the whole debate——

Comment on this

The Deputy will be in Waterford before he stops.

Comment on this

No matter what the Minister does with me, I will be back in this House and I expect the worst from him in that respect. The most ironic aspect of this whole debate is the reference to tolerance, and the regard which the Minister purports to have for tolerance and for proper representation in rural areas. I do not think I do the Minister any disrespect when I say, from what I know of him in this House, that tolerance is not one of the Christian virtues with which he is endowed.

Comment on this
Gerard Collins Mr. G. Collins

Humbug.

Comment on this

The only tolerance he knows is the tolerance to let Fianna Fáil lead on. This is a last desperate gamble to achieve that aim. It is a desperate gamble because the Minister has lined up against him — he has castigated them here today—the mass of the Irish people and the united Opposition in this House, and the Press and all the mass media also are against this evil design, which is an affront to the will of the Irish people as registered on this issue only nine years ago. It is an audacious attempt causing widespread indignation among all fair-minded people in this country. They resent deeply this attempt to impose on them a petty tyranny, and this claptrap which the Minister has gone on with within the past week that this is in the interests of the nation, in the interest of democracy——

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

——in the interest even of a good Opposition is poppycock, rubbish. It is merely an attempt to put on this despicable trick the veneer of decency. This amendment asked for some semblance of fair play in the revision of our constituencies — that there would be some impartial observer there to see that what was reasonably fair and just in the circumstances would be done but the Minister would not have that. He has arrogated to himself and to his Party henchmen the right to do this. Let us not forget that in this process of abolishing PR and establishing single-seat constituencies, ensuring that Fianna Fáil are first at the head of the poll, contained in this whole system and device is the secret weapon which the Minister and his Party propose— the weapon to gerrymander. Therein the terrible danger lies, therein the real injustice lies; and therein lies a threat to the democratic way of life. We had hoped the Minister would see the wisdom and the writing on the wall and withdraw these proposals.

He has not done so. He is renowned for his steadfastness, for his ruthlessness, renowned for his arrogance, and all these unsavoury attributes are being demonstrated all the way through in this debate, and indeed outside of these debates on other matters. The barbed tongue of the Minister has indicated his lack of respect practically for God and man.

Comment on this

Every cliche in the book.

Comment on this

It is understandable therefore that he shows a disdain, disregard and hostility to the Opposition in this House. This we expect and understand. He has sought again to infer that the Opposition, by their attitude in this matter are anti-rural, that we seek to disfranchise in some way the rural voters.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

This is patently untrue. Unfortunately our rural vote has fallen drastically in recent years under Fianna Fáil rule and Fianna Fáil now realise these are the political facts and I defy contradiction of them. The evolution of politics in this country has demonstrated that Fianna Fáil are losing power and control in the cities, in the big built-up areas of this country and they want to hold on fast and maintain their stranglehold on the rural areas, especially in the counties of the West. In order to do that, they are now seeking permission to manipulate the voting system in order to maintain the same number of seats in the West at all costs because quite a lot of them are naturally Fianna Fáil seats. They are seeking to ensure to offset the fall in population. They want now to ensure that a lesser number of votes will elect Fianna Fáil Deputies in certain rural areas as against the number of votes required to elect Deputies in the built-up areas of our cities and larger towns. We believe in the principle of one man, one vote.

Comment on this

So do we.

Comment on this

We know no good reason as to why our electoral system should be so manipulated as to confer certain preferences on a region comprised of rocks——

Comment on this

And cows.

Comment on this

——and cows, animals, forests, lakes.

Comment on this

What about giving two or three votes to one man?

Comment on this

Voting is concerned with people, not with animals or even the beauty of our counties. This is a human problem, and if the West is denuded of its population it is not our fault; it is the fault of Fianna Fáil. It is particularly audacious of them now to pretend to try and save the West by this means, by giving to any section of the people a preference that their brethren in other parts of Ireland do not enjoy. The people of the rural areas do not want preferential treatment in respect of votes. The people of the rural areas must be told, as I am telling them now, that this device is not for their benefit or for their proper representation in this House. It is for the benefit of Fianna Fáil, to enable them to continue to dominate people's lives in the rural areas and in the West of Ireland. The people of these parts must ask themselves who is responsible for the situation whereby this manipulation is now taking place. I contend that these people must be fed up to the teeth with this regime and will see through this attempt to fasten themselves on to power in these areas by this unfair means.

The Minister calls our present system a dangerous and a discriminatory system. On what grounds does he contend that this is so? Have we had instability of government here in recent years? Have we had social unrest of a serious kind? Have we had a multiplicity of parties here in this House in recent years? Where is the threat to democracy in this country that the Minister alleges there is in this "dangerous and discriminatory system"? The facts are that, outside the totalitarian states of Eastern Europe, the Minister's Party have fastened on to power here for over 30 years under this PR system. They have enjoyed power in this House continuously for the past 11 years, and basically there are only two other Parties represented in this House in opposition. Far from there being anything dangerous or discriminatory in this system, it is a fair and just system. It is the system best suited to our needs in this country, and we have the say-so of the former Taoiseach, President de Valera, for that fact.

The dangerous system is the one which the Minister is now seeking to impose upon the Irish people, the system of the single-seat constituency, the straight vote, and the right which he allocates to himself to gerrymander. Herein lies the threat to our democratic way of life. Other Members much older and wiser than I, like Deputy James Dillon, have forewarned the Minister, and I myself in my contribution on the Second Stage of these Bills also pointed out the dangers inherent in a change of this kind. If, heaven forbid, the designs of the Minister were carried by the people and we did have an overbearing Government in power to the exclusion of minorities in this House, it should clearly be understood that the Irish people, being a freedom-loving people, would never tolerate a situation in which there was being imposed on them by unfair methods a tyranny, whether Irish or foreign, and they would take upon themselves at the first possible opportunity the ways and means of overthrowing that tyranny. I contend that it is the Minister, by his arrogance and his disregard for fair play, his tampering with the pillars of our society upon which democracy and liberty are founded——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I should like to hear something about the amendment before the House.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): That has been forgotten about for a long time.

Comment on this

He is not even dealing with the proper Bill.

Comment on this

I am dealing with Deputy Fitzpatrick's amendment.

Comment on this

He has been dealing with the Fourth Amendment Bill.

Comment on this

I have asked the Minister to ensure that the Opposition will have some reasonable say in the revision of constituencies——

Comment on this

The Deputy does not know what the amendment is about.

Comment on this

——and he has said "no" to that. This is an indication again of the real designs of the Minister and his Party, that this is a power grab at all costs, and the people in the Opposition are not to have any effective say in it. These are the views I wanted to convey in the dying hours of this debate, and it is simply not good enough for the Minister to say that we are all out of step except himself. It is not good enough for the Minister to castigate the Opposition, to castigate the Church, to castigate everyone who dares challenge him or dares show him any opposition. That is typical of the whole intention and purpose of this measure. It has all the ingredients of ruthlessness and tyranny, through which the Irish people have seen. We await the opportunity when the Irish people will be asked to decide on this matter, and they will give back the answer to the Minister in most telling fashion. It will be made known to him that liberty is a precious thing in this country, that people have been properly alerted to the threat, that this last desperate gamble of his will founder on the rocks, and that Fianna Fáil will have to face the consequences of going into the wilderness for a long number of years in Irish politics. I would hope that the Minister would show some regard for the consensus of opinion on this amendment and the fact that he has confirms in our minds the feelings and fears we have about his intentions in this matter. He has confirmed the fears we had in that regard.

Comment on this

I was rather amused listening to the last Deputy.

Comment on this

Deputy Burke is now getting afraid.

Comment on this

No. There is not any fear in my bones at all.

Comment on this

Deputy Harte is the one who is afraid. He is getting afraid and that is responsible for his change of attitude.

Comment on this

Deputy Burke is saying : "God save me from my friends. I know my enemies."

Comment on this

Deputy Burke should not turn his back on the Minister.

Comment on this

I listened very carefully to the last speaker and he used nearly every phrase in the English language——

Comment on this

I did not use any bad language.

Comment on this

——to say that there are a lot of tyrants over here, that we are not to be trusted, that they are the saviours of democracy on the opposite side of the House, and that anything we do on this side of the House is designed for our own purposes. I want to tell the last speaker that we have always put the interests of Ireland before the interests of our own Party.

Comment on this

The Deputy should bless himself after that.

Comment on this

What was the line the founder of the Deputy's Party took?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would Deputy Harte please restrain himself. Deputy Burke is entitled to speak without interruption the same as other Deputies.

Comment on this

I am grateful to Deputy Harte for his help.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair is not grateful to Deputy Harte.

Comment on this

I am putting Deputy Burke on the alert.

Comment on this

The last speaker said we were responsible for all the ills possible, and that pure democratic Irish politics remained only with the Opposition. He would get it very hard to sell that one at any church gate in Ireland. On all occasions the Irish people have been very shrewd. They have returned us here for years. I have been here for almost 25 years.

Comment on this

If the Minister gets his way the Deputy will not be here for 26 years.

Comment on this

The Minister is a good colleague of mine and we pull our weight together.

Comment on this

The Deputy pulls too much weight and that is the trouble.

Comment on this

I do not need to say any more. I want to ask the Opposition would they really seriously consider disfranchising the remainder of rural Ireland, giving rural Ireland very little representation, and giving top-heavy representation to the cities and towns. In the great United States there is a great history of democracy and in their wisdom they decided to have two Senators for each State irrespective of population.

Comment on this

Is this relevant to the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill?

Comment on this

I am answering a point which was made.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

An amendment on Report Stage of the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill is before the House.

Comment on this

It is the 11th Commandment. Man mind thyself.

Comment on this

In the United States they elect two Senators for every State, irrespective of population. I am sure the Opposition would not like it to be known in rural Ireland—and I think they will find it very hard to defend themselves as a result of their action in this House——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Would the Deputy deal with the commission?

Comment on this

I will deal with the commission. I am answering a point which was made by the previous speaker and I think I am in order in trying to criticise constructively what was said. There is a provision for a commission. Surely the Opposition must have some faith in their own ability to put their case to the public. They are adopting a very pessimistic attitude. I am very sorry for them.

Comment on this

We also have the Deputy's interests at heart.

Comment on this

A majority of one. We know what the Leader of the Deputy's Party wants.

Comment on this

He is too strong for the Minister in the constituency.

Comment on this

Why are Opposition Deputies afraid of the straight vote?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That does not arise.

Comment on this

I know it does not.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

May I point out to the Deputy that the amendment deals with the insertion into the Bill of a provision relating to the constituencies commission.

Comment on this

Deputy Burke is now worried about his own Minister.

Comment on this

Is not that a reasonable request? Is it not reasonable to have a commission?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Hear, hear.

Comment on this

The Minister has already agreed to that.

Comment on this

The Deputy will not be on it.

Comment on this

Not on that issue. Why are Deputies so afraid of this proposal? Why are they alleging all these things? The previous speaker could not say enough against what we are trying to do. The people of Ireland must have wanted Fianna Fáil or they would not have put us in.

Comment on this

Why do Fianna Fáil want to change the rules now?

Comment on this

Because they are losing.

Comment on this

It is his surplus which brings the Minister in.

Comment on this

That was a long time ago. All the Deputy is interested in is a cushy seat.

Comment on this

I will take a cushy seat anywhere if the Minister will give it to me.

Comment on this

The Deputy does not mind about the people who elected him.

Comment on this

Put my part in with County Dublin and I will beat the Minister to a frazzle in his own constituency.

Comment on this

That is more than Deputy Dunne can do.

Comment on this

I will do it.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the interruptions are now at an end perhaps Deputy Burke who is in possession would continue. I would ask Deputy Burke to relate his remarks to the setting up of a commission.

Comment on this

I am very sorry that this debate has become personal. There is no need for personalities. This is a national issue and people are bringing in personalities which I deplore. I have never been personal and I will not be drawn into being personal this morning.

Comment on this

Hear, hear. We have the utmost respect for Deputy Burke.

Comment on this

The feeling is mutual.

Comment on this

I would advise the Opposition to accept the Minister's proposals and to stand by them, and I am sure posterity will be very grateful. We always did and we always will put the national interest before the interest of our own Party. What we are doing here is in the national interest and the people of Ireland will realise that it is in the national interest.

Comment on this

The same as Taca.

Comment on this

We want stability of Government whether it is Fianna Fáil Government, Fine Gael Government or Labour Government. We want that stability and we want to have continuity of prosperity——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We cannot discuss that on this amendment.

Comment on this

We want to see a continuation of the national prosperity which was so ably initiated by Fianna Fáil over many years. It is for that reason that we have taken this action on this side of the House.

Comment on this

Like Deputy Treacy, I did not propose to intervene in this debate——

Comment on this

Until you were told to delay it.

Comment on this

Having listened to Deputy Burke and, indeed, considering the position in which Deputy Burke will find himself, should the Minister succeed in having this Bill passed in the House and leaving Deputy Burke without half of the constituency, not alone are we concerned about Deputies on the Fine Gael Party benches and, indeed, on the Labour Party benches but, being fair-minded, we must also consider what will happen decent, honest to goodness Deputies on the Fianna Fáil back benches, such as Deputy Burke——

Comment on this

He would be elected in any part of Ireland.

Comment on this

That is something I would agree with but it is not something the Minister could do.

Comment on this

It would not be possible to keep Deputy Burke out of this House. He could not be kept out of it in any part of Ireland.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Minister will be glad of Deputy Burke's surplus the next time.

Comment on this

I was elected with a surplus of my own.

Comment on this

The Minister got a fright in the local elections.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I do not think the Minister's prestige has gone up since the last election.

Comment on this

That remains to be seen.

Comment on this

Due to no fault of my own, I was absent a fortnight or three weeks ago when the Minister went into great detail in regard to Donegal as a county. I wonder what the position will be in County Donegal, immediately after the referendum, if this amendment is not accepted and if the Minister for Local Government should find himself in an unhappy position. with Deputy Burke as a colleague, and he wanders up to carve a constituency for himself in County Donegal. I wonder whom he would be thinking of. Would he be thinking of the Fine Gael Deputies? Whether or not he likes it, two Fine Gael Deputies will be returned from Donegal. There are six Deputies from Donegal—two Fine Gael Deputies and four Fianna Fáil Deputies. No matter what way the Minister carves up that county, there will still be two Fine Gael Deputies. The one that will drop out will be a Fianna Fáil Deputy.

Comment on this

We all know that Deputy O'Donnell is one of those coming to Dublin. That is why you want to get rid of half his constituents.

Comment on this

I do not know whether the Minister wishes me to say there are more Fine Gael votes in South West Donegal than Fianna Fáil votes but, if the Minister uses the iron fist to suggest to Donegal people that a thousand Fine Gael votes will disappear from there to North Leitrim——

Comment on this

I said "constituents". Deputy Harte is on record as demanding that.

Comment on this

It is between the Minister for Local Government and the Minister for Social Welfare because he is the man who will drop out.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Order. Would Deputy Harte please relate his remarks to this amendment?

Comment on this

I submit I am being relevant. The amendment is that the Opposition have some say in the drafting of constituencies: this is what the amendment is. I am pointing out to the House and taking the Minister to task and, indeed, trying to enlighten Deputy Burke as to what the position will be, should the Minister refuse to accept this amendment. I am pointing out to the House that, when the Minister for Local Government, Deputy Boland, was speaking here a fortnight ago, keeping very true to form since he first introduced these two Amendments, he confused the issue. He is trying to persuade the people of Donegal that, should we not go along with this pure thinking, everything evil will happen in County Donegal, particularly in the very southern parts of the county.

Comment on this

He is trying a spot of blackmail, the same as everywhere else.

Comment on this

We shall let the people know exactly what you are trying to do.

Comment on this

The people will show what they think of you, if they get the opportunity.

Comment on this

If the Minister for Local Government could have his way, not even Deputy Burke would be sure of his seat in this House——

Comment on this

Now, now.

Comment on this

——because pride——

Comment on this

Great things have happened in our time.

Comment on this

Maybe in his time but not in the time of his Government.

Comment on this

Deputy Burke could get elected in Donegal, never mind in Dublin.

Comment on this

I know that the Minister has been using tactics in this debate, inviting Deputies from different sides of the House to express their views——

Comment on this

Deputy Norton invited the Leader of the Fine Gael Party to express his views.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Deputy Norton was not here to express them at the vital time.

Comment on this

He was. He was tricked——

Comment on this

If he was tricked, the Minister tricked him. I pointed out to the Minister yesterday evening that we should not resume until 7.30 p.m. but he had not the decency to do that. The records of the House will show that that is so. I pointed it out to the Minister and I asked him if he would be agreeable that the House adjourn until after the tea—but he would not. He thought he was clever but, as usual, he fell down on the job.

Comment on this

Deputy Tully was pressing that the question be put as I was running down the stairs into the Chamber.

Comment on this

The Deputy need not worry. On Report Stage, I shall say what I have to say.

Comment on this

Of course, the Deputy is perfectly entitled to do so— and, if he can get four people to stand up with him, he can get a vote: otherwise, he is on his own.

Comment on this

I spent three years practically on my own in the Labour Party. It is not a new situation.

Comment on this

He did not say very much when he was here.

Comment on this

Last week, when the Minister for Local Government wished to——

Comment on this

We all know that the Fine Gael Deputies will not come in here before 2 p.m. You cannot get them up out of bed before that hour.

Comment on this

While the Minister's Party were hatcheting for his scalp in the Party room, deciding whether or not to accept Deputy Norton's amendment, messages were coming down to the Minister that the debate was going one way and the other. Finally, when the Minister discovered that the Party had reached some sort of a decision— one which Deputy P.J. Lenihan, Deputy MacEntee, Deputy Booth, Deputy Andrews and a few other Deputies whom we do not want to mention——

Comment on this

All the Deputy wants to know is how many Fine Gael Deputies are up out of bed.

Comment on this

——even challenged that decision——

Comment on this

I did not know Deputy Harte was at the meeting.

Comment on this

Does Deputy Norton not know that if the Minister for Local Government had any respect for his amendment, he could have kept the debate going yesterday evening for three-quarters of an hour?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): He could have kept it going for three weeks.

Comment on this

You let Deputy Norton down because you have no further use for his amendment.

Comment on this

That is a regular thing with the Minister, anyway. We are used to that in the past few months.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Order. Will Deputy Harte please come to the amendment? These disorderly interruptions must cease.

Comment on this

You cannot come back to something you were never at.

Comment on this

Deputy Harte and Deputy Fitzpatrick are getting tired and irritable because they are the only two Members of the Fine Gael Party who could be persuaded to make any attempt to discuss the Bill. The rest of the Party, who do not believe in what you say, have gone away.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

Deputy Cosgrave did not vote.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): We come in to attend to our amendments.

Comment on this

Deputy Harte would not be talking nonsense in this House now unless——

Comment on this

Everything Fine Gael say, Deputy Norton now disagrees with as nonsense.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Fianna Fáil have been arguing this over the past six months but they decided upon it only yesterday.

Comment on this

What Deputy Sweetman told him yesterday was also nonsense.

Comment on this

What Deputy Sweetman suggested is nonsense and I challenge——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

This whole matter is completely irrelevant at this stage.

Comment on this

I challenge you to ask the Leader of your Party.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Fitzpatrick's amendment; anything else is irrelevant. Deputy Harte.

Comment on this

Any embarrassment you are causing is to your own Leader.

Comment on this

Deputy Norton should remain in the House more often, even when his amendments are not being discussed. I did not particularly wish to speak on this debate because all this was discussed nine years ago. The tactics of the Minister, however, are designed to keep it going but Fine Gael are anxious to put the matter before the people. Then we can go on building more houses and preparing legislation which will be of greater benefit to the community. Deputy Norton said that what I was discussing was nonsense. Deputy Norton usually maintains, when a Deputy is criticising him or using language he does not like, that it is nonsense.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

At this stage again——

Comment on this

We know that Deputy Norton invited Deputy Sweetman to lunch with him in order to discuss the ways and means by which Deputy Norton could join the Fine Gael Party.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Harte will speak on the amendment before the House. Anything else is irrelevant.

Comment on this

Why does Deputy Harte not ask——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Norton, I presume, will have the opportunity to speak but at this stage Deputy Harte is speaking.

Comment on this

If the Minister does not accept this amendment, if Deputy Norton does not use the opportunity to vote for it, Deputy Norton will be out of the constituency immediately after the next election because just like Deputy Burke, Deputy Norton will be bushwhacked as quickly as any man ever was, in the true sense of the Wild West.

Comment on this

I am only trying to save Deputy O'Donnell from being bushwhacked.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Donnell knows his friends and his enemies.

Comment on this

He knows what you are trying to do with him.

Comment on this

Deputy Brennan wants to watch the Minister because the truth of the matter is that Donegal's population, because of Fianna Fáil administration, has fallen in the past ten years from 124,000 to 108,000. Because of this, the Minister now wants to have further power to gerrymander as did his colleague, the former Minister for Local Government, Deputy Blaney. He gerrymandered that constituency to such a degree that he almost left the Ceann Comhairle without a seat. However, no matter what way he tried to gerrymander Donegal, the past is rapidly catching up on the gerrymandering tactics employed by Fianna Fáil since 1932. A three-member constituency used to be the Fianna Fáil desire. They believed that a Party with one vote more than 50 per cent could get two seats out of three. This is a straightforward mathematical calculation. They believed that in an area in which the Opposition could get one vote more than 50 per cent the best thing to do was to make it a four-seat constituency so that this would neutralise the support of the Opposition Parties when it came to voting in this House. This just does not suit. The wheel is turning the full circle.

I must here disagree with Deputy Burke. Because they believe more in Fianna Fáil than they do in the country there are fewer people in the west of Ireland now, where Fianna Fáil had more strength than in the cities, it is now necessary to amend the Constitution to give the Minister power to perpetuate the position in spite of the fact that his Party have let down the people in the western areas miserably, particularly the people in Donegal. If this amendment is not accepted by the Minister, no one, particularly an Opposition Deputy, will be safe in this House. There will be no guarantee that if Fianna Fáil are returned to office with the strength that political commentators suggest, further legislation will not be enacted to make this an elected dictatorship instead of a free democratic society for which people paid the supreme sacrifice. These are the reasons I rose to speak briefly on this amendment and not for the reasons Deputy Norton suggested. I do not have to invite any member of my Party to speak his mind.

Comment on this

There would not be much point in inviting the Deputy's Leader.

Comment on this

Any member of the Fianna Fáil Party, and particularly the Minister, who suggests that his Party is united on this score is either a lunatic or is codding himself but he is not codding us.

Comment on this