Committee on Finance. - Vote 3—Department of the Taoiseach (Resumed).
Contributions 1–151 of 278. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
May I remind the Chair that I should be in possession and I will stick out for permission when the Minister finishes.
Comment on this
I should like to emphasise in regard to the matter just raised by Deputy Dunne that the previous two speakers were speakers from the Fine Gael Party in this debate. Deputy Dunne's attitude is the same form of inertia rather typical of the Labour Party which he represents——
Comment on this
The only way the Minister could be here this morning was by staying up all night. Everybody knows his form of inertia.
Comment on this
Yesterday evening we did not have any contribution from Deputy Dunne, but in due course, I have no doubt, we shall be hearing from him in his usual cliché style. However, coming back to the important matter of the debate — a review of the economic and social programme of Government activity in the past 12 months—the emphasis should be laid in a certain direction. First of all, Fianna Fáil have proved that as a Government in the 1960s, as they did in the 30s, the 40s and the 50s, they are a Party of social progress.
Comment on this
The first time Fianna Fáil were allowed to implement their policy was in 1932 and since then they have shown themselves to be a Party of social progress. Now that Deputy Harte has interrupted me, it might be no harm to refer to a question which he put down recently in regard to the Vote for Education and to which Deputy Cosgrave referred yesterday. The total Vote for Education in 1930-31 was £4½ million, in round figures.
Comment on this
I am coming to that. The total vote for Education—I gave the figure in reply to a question by Deputy Harte recently—was £4½ million in 1930-31. The total Vote for Education in the current year is £54 million.
Comment on this
I would not have raised the matter if I were not aware that Deputy Harte might make this brilliant point which he made in the course of supplementary questions. Deputy Harte sought then to make this point and Deputy Cosgrave sought to lay emphasis on it yesterday—the point that the Vote for Education then was a high percentage of the total net expenditure in that year. The total net State expenditure in 1930-31, of which education occupied £4½ million, in round figures, was £20 million, again in round figures. That is what the State was spending on the whole range of social and public welfare in 1930, the year in which the old age pension was cut, the year of recession and retrenchment, the year in which Cumann na nGaedheal withdrew from their responsibilities and decided to cut back in public expenditure in respect of the less well-off.
Comment on this
Deputy Harte may not interrupt in this manner. The Deputy will have an opportunity of replying to the Minister.
Comment on this
The Minister would be serving the House better by telling us what the Government are doing now for education. The percentage for education is less——
Comment on this
Keep you quiet. If your ambitions had been successful, you would be sitting over here.
Comment on this
If Deputy Harte continues to behave in this disorderly fashion, I must ask him to leave the House. The Minister is in possession——
Comment on this
I take it the whole purpose of people coming here as representatives is to engage in ordered debate. However, Deputy Harte has not learned that elementary lesson.
Comment on this
If Deputy Harte wants to indulge in flights of fantasy, he is welcome. Meanwhile, I want to come back to the point on which emphasis was placed by Deputy Cosgrave yesterday and of which Deputy Harte tried to make play. It is that in 1930-31, £4½ million was spent on education. What we are spending this year is £54 million and Deputy Harte sought to make the point that this represented a percentage——
Comment on this
Deputy Harte sought to make the point that it represented a higher percentage of the total net State expenditure in 1930-31 than the Vote for Education in the current year. What I am trying to say is that the total net State expenditure was in the region of £20 million in 1930-31, a year in which there were practically no social welfare benefits of any kind, a year in which even the meagre social welfare benefits there were were cut.
Comment on this
The total net expenditure last year came to £290 million odd. Up to date there has been a jump from £20 million in 1930-31 to £290 million odd and this explains my whole point. Since that period, since taking over the Government, Fianna Fáil have consistently been responsible for social progress on all fronts, for progress in social welfare, for progress in health, for progress in education, for progress in regard to the relief of land congestion, for progress in regard to every conceivable development and Deputy Harte certainly had some temerity in coming into the House, and Deputy Cosgrave had some temerity in coming into the House, to lay emphasis on the most depressed year in our country's history.
Comment on this
Maybe, but we spent 50 per cent more on education than the amount being spent today.
Comment on this
It was a year in which there was massive unemployment, a year in which there were no conditions of employment, a year in which social welfare benefits were cut, a year in which there was depression all over the land. That is why, in 1932, the Irish people decided to put Fianna Fáil into Government to embark on a policy of social progress. This drew some comment from Deputies Cosgrave and Harte and I want to emphasise again——
Comment on this
I want to repeat my warning to Deputy Harte for the last time. If he wishes to remain in the House——
Comment on this
To bring the debate up to date further from the period Deputy Harte has been dwelling on, to bring it up to 1957——
Comment on this
From 1957 I propose to bring it up to 1968. The figure spent on education in the last year of the Coalition was £15 million. The figure in the current year's Estimate is £54 million. In other words, we have jumped State expenditure on education from £15 million in 1957 to £54 million in the current year, which, allowing for the fall in money values in the meantime, represents three times more. Of all topics, this is one that should be avoided by Labour and Fine Gael because if ever there were famine years in regard to Irish education policy, the famine years were during the last Coalition period of office, when there was a complete lack of thought, when there was a complete lack of investment, when there was a complete lack of policy in regard to the development of education in general. Indeed, when Deputy Sweetman, as Minister for Finance, was applying the axe all around the place in various spheres of public administration in 1956 and early 1957, education suffered more than any other aspect of public administration.
Comment on this
I do not blame the Minister for Education at the time. The poor unfortunate man was in the hands of an ultra-conservative Minister for Finance who at the time not alone applied the axe to the Fine Gael Minister for Education but applied an even stronger axe to the Labour Minister for Social Welfare.
Comment on this
Certain facts of life should be brought to bear in this debate. The last act of the Fine Gael Minister for Education in the last Coalition Government——
Comment on this
You are spending less on education than was spent in 1930-31. Those are your own figures.
Comment on this
The last Fine Gael Minister for Education, under the axe applied by a Fine Gael Minister for Finance, which axe applied equally to the Labour Minister for Social Welfare at the time, when the Coalition Government finally foundered in the early spring of 1957, cut the grants for vocational schools by six per cent.
Comment on this
The total State expenditure in 1957 came to £15 million. The total State expenditure this year comes to £54 million. All we had at that time were percentage cuts in education and this at a stage, mind you, where you had this cut of ten per cent——
Comment on this
I have warned Deputy Harte to cease interrupting. I will now ask Deputy Harte to leave the House.
Comment on this
Before I go, I wish to say that the figures I have been quoting are the Minister's figures.
Comment on this
The Deputy may not make a speech. He will please leave the House.
Deputy Harte withdrew from the House.
Comment on this
The Deputy used to be Trotsky but now he has gone respectable. There was a time when he was not. The cut of ten per cent in secondary school grants in 1957 is not the whole story in that at that stage you had no assistance whatever towards secondary school education in the form of reconstruction and construction of secondary schools. What Fianna Fáil have done in the past two years is to introduce a comprehensive scheme of 100 per cent loan and grant assistance towards reconstruction and construction of secondary schools. Now there is a scheme of 70 per cent grant and 30 per cent loan assistance towards secondary schools. That was not in existence at all until the last two years.
As I say, the meagre grants available to education in 1957 were then cut by the Fine Gael Minister for Education by ten per cent. It is fair to say that those were famine years in regard to education in this country. There was no thought, no policy, no thinking whatever on the importance of education as having a fundamental place in our social development. Of course, there is one thing that can be said, that is, that there was one good idea which came from Fine Gael. I am going to pay a compliment here to the Fine Gael displaced Leader, Deputy Dillon, in that he in this House, despite the actions of his various cohorts in the Party who co-operated to stir up trouble, consistently advocated a cause for the amalgamation of schools into larger school units so as to provide a wider range of teaching subjects in those schools.
I believe that the broad curriculum in our primary schools will be the best way of educating and training our young children and that the abolition of the primary certificate, which we have now done, will ensure that there will be less pressure on concentrated and narrow subjects in the future and that we will have a broad range of subjects in our schools so as to give a broadly-based type of education to our boys and girls. I deplore the Fine Gael running away from the admirably progressive policy adumbrated by Deputy Dillon in years past. They have gone away from that in the interest of hunting votes but that is not the way to achieve government in this country or any other country.
Comment on this
The overall importance of education is now regarded by our community as fundamental. This was an aspect ignored by Fine Gael and Labour over the years.
Comment on this
It was ignored by Fianna Fáil until the late Donogh O'Malley pushed it through, despite the conservative elements in the Fianna Fáil Party.
Comment on this
There is one thing we will not do here, that is, engage in clichés. I want to refer to figures I mentioned earlier on to show that there has been a planned policy in education since our return in 1957 and that this has taken place under successive Ministers for Education. First of all, there was the Taoiseach himself, then Deputy Hillery, then Deputy Colley, then Deputy Donogh O'Malley and now I am here in this position. There has been a planned, coherent policy on the part of Fianna Fáil since 1957 in education. Our investment in education has jumped from £15 million to £54 million in that period.
Deputy Cosgrave, as well as Deputy Harte earlier on made reference to the position in 1930 and 1931 but I wish to put certain other facts on the record which show that the total number of students attending primary schools in 1931-32 was less than 37,000 and that the figure for this year is over 160,000. In 1930-31 the population of institutions of higher education was less than 5,000 and it now stands at about 18,000. I want to see that go up to about 30,000 in the next ten years.
Comment on this
——but with the very practical help of post-primary education introduced by Fianna Fáil last September, despite the allegations that this particular aspect of education improvement would not take place, that it was impossible, despite the wails one heard here on several occasions from Deputy Ryan, Deputy L'Estrange and others.
Comment on this
It was the policy we advocated before yours, as far back as 1961. It is there in black and white to be seen.
Comment on this
Prior to the general election we had the policy document, Towards a Just Society, in which there was the most perfunctory reference made to education and educational policy and, indeed, in their anxiety to jump on the bandwaggon of a just society, the Fine Gael Party ignored the most central and basic fact in our society, that we must have equality of opportunity and must provide the educational facilities needed to develop the talents of our people to the fullest extent. This was ignored by Fine Gael in their policy document before the last general election. It has been also a topic ignored by the Labour Party in their various conferences in recent years seeking to achieve a degree of socialism, which term is now dated and outmoded.
Comment on this
Obviously the Minister is unacquainted with the fact that we were the first to produce a comprehensive document on education. I will supply the Minister with a copy. I do admit that before he would understand it he would have to learn the alphabet.
Comment on this
I would refer Deputy Dunne to the last Labour conference in which socialism was resurrected from limbo and adumbrated as Labour Party policy in 1968. Senator McQuillan has shown us the depth of Labour's attachment to socialism but socialism was resurrected from the limbo of the 1930s, the salad days of Deputy Dunne, and put forward as a practical policy in 1968.
Comment on this
Fianna Fáil have always believed in practical socialism. We have been the Party of social progress in action, not in talk. If the Labour Party and the Fine Gael Party want the facts of life——
Comment on this
——the facts of life are that in 1954 to 1957, during the last Coalition period—it is no harm to remind people again of this because the spectre is raising its ugly head once again——
Comment on this
Tell us about the future. The young people want to learn about the future, not about the past.
Comment on this
It is no harm to think in terms of socialism in action as against socialism in talk. We have had the just society in talk. We have had socialism in talk from both Fine Gael and the Labour Party. Let us go back on the record, on the fact of what, in fact, was achieved by them in combination between 1954 and 1957.
Comment on this
What, in fact, was done for the achievement of a just society during that period and towards the achievement of a socialist society? One sees there, again historically right for the record, to be checked and counter-checked—I know I cannot be denied in this fact-that Deputy Corish, Leader of the Labour Party, happened to be Minister for Social Welfare during that Government. Deputy Sweetman, now opposite, again a potential member of some sort of opportunistic Government in the future, was Minister for Finance in that Government. Deputy Corish's sole contribution towards socialism between 1954 and 1957 was one halfcrown for all our social welfare recipients.
Comment on this
Tenpence, tenpence and tenpence per year. Our contribution as regards social welfare during the past three years has been in the order of 5/-, 7/6d, 10/-. This has been Fianna Fáil's contribution over the past three years.
Comment on this
These are irrefutable facts to show that Fianna Fáil is concerned about the less well-off people, about practical socialism rather than socialism in talk——
Comment on this
——whereas in the last three years of the Coalition Government the sole contribution towards recipients of old age pensions and unemployment assistance was 2s 6d.
Comment on this
During the past three years our contribution was 22s 6d. These are the sorts of basic facts which show what was the Party of social progress. I mentioned the figures in regard to education already. These figures in regard to social welfare bear out what I am saying. As regards the present point of time, prior to last year the annual increase in numbers attending post-primary schools averaged about 5,600. This was the average increase until last year. The numbers last year increased by over 18,000. So, with the jump from 5,600 to 18,000 in the numbers attending post-primary establishments, it is no harm to reiterate that this was Fianna Fáil policy and Fianna Fáil in action as a Party of social progress. It is no harm to emphasise that this was made possible because we initiated last September free post-primary education and initiated free transport of boys and girls in rural areas towards post-primary education in their local centres. This was done at some cost and as a result of Government decision based on a rational assessment of the cost involved and on a Government commitment towards investment in education as the most important field of investment as far as social progress in future is concerned. This was based on a planned policy of improvement in education by Fianna Fáil over the past 11 years under successive Fianna Fáil Minister for Education. This is an example of a Party of social progress in action. This is socialism in practice. This is the just society in practice and not just in talk.
Comment on this
He is trying to get around that. All this is camouflage that he has been going on with up to now, trying to circumnavigate this very tricky promontory that yet lies ahead.
Comment on this
As far as the Minister is concerned, it is a case of "physician, heal thyself" first.
Comment on this
I have no time for fading socialists. I am concerned with practical socialism today.
Comment on this
In the field of post-primary education, steps have been taken which have led to the increase in numbers to which I have referred. Our next problem is to ensure that these boys and girls can go on to higher education at third level stage.
Comment on this
And then export them to England because you have not jobs for them here unless they are members of Taca.
Comment on this
In this respect, the new Higher Education Grants Bill, which has passed both Houses of the Oireachtas, is a significant step forward in this direction. Again, coming back to practical socialism and practical facts, last year, the local authorities were able to provide 275 scholarships in the field of university or higher education. This year, the figure we hope to achieve is 1,000. We have a jump from 275 to 1,000 boys and girls participating in higher education, so that we have 725 extra boys and girls who heretofore, by reason of their economic circumstances, would not be in a position to participate in higher education who will be enabled to do it in the coming months. I am not satisfied, and the Government are not satisfied, with that figure. I regard the Bill which will be law inside the next few days as the first step forward in this direction. We want to do far more so as to ensure that there is complete equality of opportunity for all our boys and girls.
I would regard the most fundamental social principle in 1968 as equality of opportunity and this is basic socialism and this is the basic thought which every civilised country today recognises as important, that every boy and girl in the community will get an equal chance to make his or her place in the world, that the community as a whole, apart from the people concerned, can only benefit if talents are maximised to the greatest extent in this manner. The way to achieve this is to provide a ladder of attainment to all levels of education, and the way to do that is to ensure that the boys and girls who heretofore could not do so by reason of economic circumstances can get into higher education, no matter what the circumstances of their families.
We have in the Higher Education Grants Bill, shortly to become a statute, a flexible statutory framework within which we can increase that figure of 1,000 in the years ahead. There is ample power given to future Ministers for Education, and indeed if Deputy Dunne happens to occupy the seat, he can wield this legislative measure with the required degree of flexibility to ensure that socialism is put into practice rather than all this talk of socialism from the Opposition.
Comment on this
As I say, in the coming 12 months we will bring the figure of student-grant holders up to 1,000. There will be a legislative framework which any succeeding Minister for Education can expand by way of relaxation of means tests or new standards equated to the needs of the community or by an extension of the spheres of higher education to which the Act will apply.
This is the whole essence of our thinking at present. We cannot look at education as a compartment in any particular sphere. Primary, post-primary and higher education are all parts of the unit. There must be a flow from one to the other, accompanied by the most expert advice for pupils in regard to career guidance and how they can be trained and adapted for the community into which they are moving. For this reason we at present have 60 teachers on a crash course in career guidance. We hope to double that figure next year so as to ensure that in all the large centres of post-primary education, we will have teachers available trained in career guidance who will be able to advise boys and girls along the right lines and to direct them towards where their talents should lead them. We will also have in operation in the coming year eight trained psychologists who will be travelling psychologists linking up with the career guidance teachers and able to give further more specialist advice.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I have heard innocent backbenchers being called to order when they were not going into anything like the detail the Minister is now going into.
Comment on this
Deputies will be entitled to reply to the Minister. The Minister is permitted to speak on these lines and Deputies are entitled to reply.
Comment on this
I am modest enough to suggest that I am trying to make a serious contribution. This matter is of importance to the Irish public and to parents and of great importance to the boys and girls pursuing education. It is a matter of far greater weight than some of the mouthings that may come afterwards from Deputy Dunne. Let us get down now to facts.
Comment on this
The point is you are getting away with something denied to the ordinary Member of the House. You are imposing yourself on the House and have done so.
Comment on this
This is a charge against the Chair which the Chair cannot allow. The Minister is entitled to speak on education as Minister for Education. Deputies will have an equal opportunity of replying to the Minister.
Comment on this
Replying to the Minister? On a point of order, I want to be clear as to what the rights of an ordinary Member consist of. The Chair now says that Deputies have a right to reply to the Minister. Is that our function—to reply to a Minister? Surely we have the right to criticise the Minister's Department?
Comment on this
That is not a point of order. The Deputy is long enough here to know what the rights of Deputies are.
Comment on this
I am. I am long enough here to know what is happening here this morning and I am pretty sick of it. I do not object to giving the breath of freedom to any Member of the House, but let it apply to everybody. That has been denied.
Comment on this
Last night people here were told they could not deal with individual Departments. The Minister can do it but a Member of the House cannot.
Comment on this
I am talking about how best our boys and girls can be fitted into our society today. I am talking about practical socialism and not Deputy Dunne's theoretical kind. The ordinary Irish people are tired of listening to clichés about a just society or clichés about socialism. They are concerned about what is going to be done. We are concerned with what needs to be done. As far as we are concerned, investment in education is the most important commitment in our society.
Comment on this
If you think you are codding anybody but yourself by that, you are making a big mistake. We know very well what you are concerned with. It is not education but holding on to where you are sitting.
Comment on this
Deputy Dunne is a tired man, a sick man, a man not really "with it" in regard to what needs to be done today. Senator McQuillan exposed the basic cancer in the Labour Party.
Comment on this
Fundamentally, they are a Party of individuals. Fundamentally, they are a Party not concerned with social principles or socialism. Fundamentally, they are a Party who run away from any practical application of socialist principles. Fundamentally, they have shown themselves in the House and in their treatment of Senator McQuillan, Deputy Norton and Mr. Mac Aonghusa to be a Party concerned with narrow principles——
Comment on this
Put them on your free transfer list. You can have them. You usually pick up flotsam and jetsam.
Comment on this
Any analysis of the situation will show that the Labour Party are more conservative than the Fine Gael Party. They showed themselves as such during the previous Coalitions when they merged themselves with and lost their identity to the conservative Party. We are concerned with the practical progress that is required to be made in education.
I was referring, before Deputy Dunne interrupted me, to the emphasis on career guidance in our post-primary establishments and said that we will have 60 such teachers in those establishments in the coming 12 months. From this year out these teachers will have available to them record cards from the primary establishments from which the boys and girls come setting out the primary schools' assessment of the work, ability and aptitude of these boys and girls, so that proper advice can be given to them at post-primary level to guide them in the right direction.
I hope inside the next 12 months to have published in conjunction with the Department of Labour an overall assessment of the manpower requirements of our community in the years ahead. In this way every parent will know where the job opportunities are going to be. They, in conjunction with the school authorities and on the basis of the assessment made by the school of their children's aptitudes, can make a responsible decision in regard to how the children should be educated and in what direction they should train them in order to secure the jobs that will be available. This assessment to which I have referred will outline precisely where we are going in regard to education and show how education can be geared to the manpower requirements and job opportunities available in our society.
I mention this because it is a topic in which I think the greatest interest should be shown. If there has been weakness in our educational system in the past, it lay in the direction of creating job dissatisfaction. Too often in the past boys and girls emerged from the educational system not properly slotted for their jobs in our community. We had too many square pegs in round holes. With a proper intensive career guidance service, proper advice between parents and teachers and proper advice from expert psychologists, we can, as far as possible, guide boys and girls along the lines on which their aptitudes should lead them. This is a very important matter because if you have the greatest possible degree of job satisfaction, not alone do you get personal problems at family level settled as satisfactorily as possible but also from the community's point of view you have the greatest possible number of people making the greatest possible contribution through their work to the welfare of the community at large.
I mention this because I think that education as a whole should be recognised as a community obligation. The State is spending a substantial amount of money in the coming year on education and there will be recognition at all levels, from primary school to higher education, that education is fundamentally a community obligation. This is the thinking behind the new scheme of re-organisation in regard to higher education as a whole. We propose to establish a Higher Education Authority to supervise all higher education in the country and ensure that funds are allocated where they should be allocated and that students and faculties are developed and allocated in the areas where they should be allocated.
In this connection we propose to amalgamate the two university colleges in Dublin into one University of Dublin. We propose to have separate universities in Cork and Galway and we are considering higher educational establishments elsewhere. We also propose extensions in regard to technical and technological education. We have just opened a new technological college in Kevin Street and an extension at Bolton Street, Dublin and there will be a new technological institution at Ballymun, also in Dublin. These, together with the nine regional technical colleges throughout the country, will have their own field of higher education in technological subjects which can be administered in an overall capacity by the Higher Education Authority. However, their main function in the future will lie in the field of higher technician training.
The thinking behind this is that we should regionalise education along with various other aspects of regional development which have taken place here in the fields of tourism, industrial and agricultural development. We propose to have nine regions centered on these technological colleges outside Dublin and in each region there will be higher education in technological subjects related to the industrial requirements of the particular area. To give one example, in the Carlow College of Technology, we propose to have an advanced Faculty of Food Technology related to the needs of Erin Foods and the requirements of the Sugar Company in that area. In each area there will be emphasis on a particular high-level field of technology related to the industrial requirements of the area. We propose similarly to rationalise the situation in regard to the technological colleges in Dublin. They have already gone a considerable distance in this direction themselves and we propose to further that rationalisation programme. Thus we have overall supervision on the part of the State of higher education and we hope to rationalise higher education in the academic and technological fields according to the requirements of our society this year and each year in the future.
This is practical planning and practical socialism in action. It shows appreciation on the part of Fianna Fáil of the needs of the community today and in the future. We get very little thinking of this kind from the Fine Gael Party or the Labour Party. If a community has to adjust its people to the needs of the day, planning must take place. Fianna Fáil have shown since 1957 their belief in planning ahead and the first attempt ever made in this direction came about in the First Programme for Economic Expansion in 1958 which was the first attempt by any Government since the formation of the State——
Comment on this
——to introduce planning to this country on proper planning lines. It is one particular aspect on which the socialist Labour Party fell down——
Comment on this
That was not a Fianna Fáil production: it was Whitaker's Almanac. His name was on it.
Comment on this
If Deputy Dunne wants to put the record right as to how Fianna Fáil thought when we were in Opposition, about the time when we would come into power, in order to do something practical, he will recall that there were other documents on economic development, a foretaste of what was to come, documents published by Deputy Séan Lemass in 1955 and 1956. There were two documents, one is 1955 and another in 1956. These documents were amplified in 1957 when we returned to power. These showed our concern about planning for the future rather than merely holding on to office.
Comment on this
What I am saying is that the so-called First Programme was a Civil Service production produced by Mr. Whitaker and Fianna Fáil had nothing to do with it.