Financial Resolutions. - Confidence in Government.
Contributions 106–230 of 230. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I have no hesitation in saying that the Minister for External Affairs will also frame it.
Comment on this
I do not think anyone can say that the leading article in today's Independent was written by a member of Fianna Fáil, a member of Taca, or by any other person prejudiced in favour of the Fianna Fáil Party. Let us get this clear. This decision at the referendum was the decision of the people to maintain the status quo simply because they were not sure what a change might entail. Every conceivable means was used to create doubts in people's minds as to what the result might be. Only the future will show what the actual result of their decision will be but my experience so far has been that many people have spoken to me and have stated quite openly that they voted “No”. They have stated, however, that they are now beginning to wonder if they should have voted “Yes” and that certainly they will vote Fianna Fáil in the next election.
Comment on this
I thought the Deputy was going to say the next referendum.
Comment on this
We had the introduction today of certain financial measures. The Budget was not a very mini, mini one but some financial measures were obviously necessary. Neither do I, personally, nor does anyone, welcome increased taxation. As Members undoubtedly know, I have declared a personal interest in regard to high-priced articles, subject to turn-over tax, in the motor trade. This increase is certainly no gift to the motor trade, nor is it of any benefit to the motoring public. Probably something like that was necessary but I would ask the Minister for Finance, through the Taoiseach who introduced the measures on his behalf, to temper the wind a little towards the motor industry and the motoring public.
The selective wholesale tax will now go up from five to ten per cent. On top of that we have the turnover tax which is heavy and, in addition, we have heavy import duty on material coming in for assembly of vehicles or on completed vehicles assembled in fully built-up condition. Even the material coming in for assembly is liable to duty at 7½ per cent which, together with wholesale tax and turnover tax, totals about 14½ per cent. While I feel that I may be prejudiced—in fact I undoubtedly am —it would not be right for me not to let the Minister know that I am of the opinion, as many others are also, that the time has come to have another look in future at increased taxation and not to go too heavily on the motor industry. This industry is a very big employer and it will suffer very seriously if taxes are raised too high.
There is no question of a stop-go policy. Even though these measures are necessary, there is no question of putting our economy back. I agree with the Taoiseach that we are making progress. We have made progress and the only danger signal is that the rate of progress has been a little too fast and there is a very real danger of inflation. This is not a question of stop-go. This is a question of real measures being taken to counteract the present rate of growth. We will go on expanding, but we must go on expanding within some sort of control so that the whole system does not run riot. If it does run riot, we are heading for disaster.
We have been told by Deputy Corish that the Government should have taken some action to avoid this situation. How naïve can one become? The root cause of this situation is the sudden rise in personal incomes which are well ahead of the increase in the growth of national production. What were the Government supposed to do about that? It ill behoves Deputy Corish, who claims to be the champion of the working man and a champion of the free collective bargaining system, to speak like this. Would Deputy Corish and his Labour Party colleagues prefer a repudiation of free collective wage negotiations?
Comment on this
We should have an investigation into the £24,000 given to the Deputy's directors last year. That sum was set aside last year for the directors of Booth Poole. How many directors are there?
Comment on this
This is typical of the ignorance and personal animosity of the Deputy and I shall not rise to it.
Comment on this
The Deputy asked a question about our attitude to incomes. There is a question for him.
Comment on this
The affairs of the company of which I am chairman have nothing to do with the Deputy.
Comment on this
I am sorry if I got under the Deputy's skin. The Deputy is walking on water when he talks about income.
Comment on this
I am not walking on water but I will refrain from making any personal remarks about the Deputy.
Comment on this
This is a sure sign of the bankruptcy of the Labour Party and its enthusiastic but irresponsible spokesmen. I cannot think of any reason why the Deputy indulges in a personal attack?
Comment on this
——I suppose the Deputy must grab at anything that occurs to him, but the fact remains that the free collective bargaining process would result in a very rapid rise in personal income and the only action that could be taken by the Government would be a wage freeze, which is not the sort of thing the Labour Party claims to be in favour of.
Comment on this
If the Budget of last April had been introduced properly——
Comment on this
If the Deputy wants to do it on that basis, I must inform him that no directors fees have been paid in the company of which I am chairman during the past two years. The Deputy should get his facts straight. He is as ignorant——
Comment on this
The Deputy does not know how to read the annual report of the company—he does not even know how to read. No fees were paid to directors in that company during the past two years.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Leary may not continue these arguments. If he does I shall have to ask him to leave the House. This is not a court room.
Comment on this
Perhaps we can get back to the point at issue. We have enjoyed in this country under Fianna Fáil Governments a steadily rising standard of living but we are not satisfied with what we have got so far. In spite of what Deputy Corish has said, we do not get any joy from imposing taxation. We do not impose taxation just for the fun of it. Nobody ever does. No Government will introduce taxation unless it is absolutely necessary and in the public interest. But here again, as the Taoiseach has said, when we find there is an absolute necessity we do not flinch from doing it. Even at a time like this, we do not hesitate for a moment to take action which we know will be unpopular but which we know to be absolutely necessary.
Comment on this
Let the public remember there is a great difference between the Government and the Opposition. The Opposition are always in the happy position of being able to advocate any sort of policy they like under the present régime because they know there is not the slightest danger they will be asked to carry it out. That is the difference. People will say why is the Government not more adventurous and why do they not produce more policies. They can only produce policies from this side of the House when they can see their way to carrying them out. It is fine for the Labour Party to say that the social welfare benefits should be higher and that education should be free and that everybody should have free entry to the university.
Comment on this
I said so far as social welfare was concerned we believe the employer should pay more on the stamp.
Comment on this
Obviously everybody is trying to do his best. It is typical that we advocate everybody doing better for everybody else.
Comment on this
You see now the obvious difference between good housekeeping by Fianna Fáil and bad housekeeping by the Government of which Deputy Corish was a member. It was great fun for them and they thought Deputy Lemass had grandiose ideas about transatlantic airlines and subsidising the purchase of Constellation aircraft so they said: "Let us sell these aircraft and distribute the funds." That is just like a profligate father of a family who says "Let us cash all the savings and have fun. Let us go away for a holiday, and spend all the money." Then he comes home and says "How are we going to get through the rest of the year? How are we going to pay for clothes for the children? We have run out of reserves."
Comment on this
I did not realise I had been appointed to the board of Potez. I was not conscious of running it at all.
Comment on this
There are a number of Labour people who have at various stages opened various buildings. I am sure it does not necessarily mean what they opened became the property of the Labour Party.
It is essential in any question of good housekeeping to retain reserves. So far as international finance is concerned, it is wise to spread reserves as widely as possible. We do not believe in giving extra cash out of reserves or giving an extra 10/- a week to old age pensioners——
Comment on this
You do not do it from that sort of money. It is used for capital purposes. You do not starve your children with money in the bank.
Comment on this
Let us get to this capital fund and State investment in industry. Deputy Corish declared his abhorrence of our undue reliance on private enterprise. I remember not so long ago Deputy Corish getting up and castigating the Government for its wickedness in setting up a State industry in Dundalk, the Dundalk Engineering Company.
Comment on this
Dundalk Engineering was entering into competition in the manufacture of agricultural equipment in competition with Pierce and Company of Wexford which happens to be in his own constituency.
Comment on this
That is a sign of his sincerity in regard to the interest taken by the State in the industry. Mr. Corish was afraid of losing some votes amongst the employees of Pierce and Sons of Wexford.
Comment on this
I will. I applauded the Government for establishing Dundalk because it was the first time they ever did anything in relation to unemployment.
Comment on this
A point of order. Is this Deputy talking to a time limit? I want to know does this time limit rule not apply to the Right Honourable and gallant Member from the Royal Borough?
Comment on this
I am not trying to fill up time. I am merely giving my own views but I am not surprised they are most offensive to members of the Opposition because I am trying to keep to facts and it has always been a noticeable feature of the Opposition that facts confuse and annoy them. There is no lack of confidence in the Government as such or of Government policy as such.
Comment on this
Surely no Deputy in the House, either inside or outside this House, agrees with the Deputy that there is not a general outcry for a general election?
Comment on this
There are two people at least who believe that the people do not want a general election—the editor of the Irish Independent and myself.
Comment on this
We are not in a minority. I think it is most unlikely that, when he and I find ourselves in agreement, there are not a lot of other people agreeing with us.
Comment on this
When we are in agreement, I think that between us we represent a considerable body of public opinion. There is no desire for a general election on the Fine Gael benches no matter how much they may whistle going past the graveyard. I do not think Labour are so anxious for it either. In any case, they are not going to get it. Therefore, they can get on with their job.
Comment on this
There is no demand for a general election. There is no swing of confidence away from the Fianna Fáil Government.
Comment on this
Now who is whistling past the graveyard?
Comment on this
I am already past the graveyard. As the editor of the Irish Independent says, there is no call for a general election but there is a call for the Opposition Parties, in particular, to sort out their own policies, to make up their minds and, above all, to realise, in the editor's own words, that any idea that there is a desire to have a Fine Gael and/or Labour administration is completely false.
Comment on this
On a point of information. In the firm of Booth Poole, directors remuneration last year was £22,609. I am sorry. I had to correct the figures. They are to be found in Trade Union Information, October, 1968. You call it “fees”. It is “remuneration” here.
Comment on this
It is good, hard cash whether it be fees or——
Comment on this
Will Deputies please desist from interrupting Deputy Booth? He must be allowed to make his statement without interruption.
Comment on this
I should just like to reiterate one point. The entire bankruptcy of political thought among the Opposition has been revealed, beyond all shadow of doubt, by the fact that this debate is degenerating into the present attack on myself and the company by which I am employed. I myself, and the company, will not be worried by the ignorant interjections of those Deputies——
Comment on this
I would ask them, even at this late stage, to try to confine themselves in this House to matters of public interest rather than to indulge in personal and entirely false accusations against me.
Comment on this
The editor of the Irish Independent will take due notice of Deputy Booth's remarks. The Deputy will probably get a nice headline about that tomorrow.
Comment on this
I was amused by the trend of the debate in the past ten or 15 minutes and the discussion on directors' fees, remuneration, and so on. Without wishing to be offensive about it. I would say, being a company director myself, that the one place I like to be is away from the company and here in Dáil Éireann.
I want now to discuss seriously all that has happened. The mini-Budget today—which I call the maxi-culottes Budget—is the artifice by which the Government have succeeded in getting two motions of No Confidence discussed with it as well as the launching of a new national loan. The practice of this House has always been that, for good productive purposes and the employment of our people, all Parties support a national loan. I point to the artifice of the Government through which the Opposition representatives had no alternative but to agree to a situation in which the Taoiseach was in a position to take the initiative.
Comment on this
We did not agree to the loan being discussed or to the Budget being discussed with the Vote of No Confidence——
Comment on this
This is an example of how the Government are prepared to use and abuse this House for their own purposes. As Deputy Ryan has so well corrected me, the Government are prepared to use and abuse everything for their own purposes. Therefore, it is not unlikely that they would use and abuse this House in the same way.
The question arises as to whether or not it was possible to predict what has happened today in relation to the mini-Budget. I would quote from the Irish Independent of 1st May, 1968, and also from columns 516 and 517 of volume 234, No. 4, of the Official Report of Dáil Éireann, 30th April, 1968. For my purposes, it is necessary only to quote a few words from the Irish Independent and to give the reference in the Dáil debates.
Mr. Donegan said that while the Budget was an easy Budget it was also a challenging one. The Minister had not accepted that challenge. This raised the question of whether it was an election Budget either for a referendum or for a general election.
The headline on that occasion was quite sufficient—"Balance of Payments will not be Rosy at the End of the Year, says TD." I do not want to claim kudos for that. I do not want to take any pleasure out of saying "I told you so".
It is quite clear that the Government are ready to use and abuse everything in this State for their own purposes and included in that are the finances of the State. They were prepared to produce a Budget which, on the information they had—and which we had not and could only, therefore, offer an opinion—was not a proper Budget, which did not face the challenge and in relation to which many people were in a position—I am not a financial expert—to predict what would happen, as has happened today. If it was possible to predict in this way then the degree of error that is here, the degree of discrepancy here between the estimates produced at Budget time both of expenditure and of revenue, is so great as to indicate that it was not a mistake and that these people were prepared to use and abuse this year's main Budget in April for their own purposes, namely, to try to get through the two referenda proposals that were intended to install Fianna Fáil in office for the next 20 years, without a means of getting them out. The degree of error revealed today in the table furnished with the mini-Budget, which I refer to as a maxi-Budget, is £18¾ million in five months.
Let us consider why it was necessary to have these Parliamentary artifices. Let us consider why it was necessary to introduce a national loan. Let us consider why it was necessary to mix up the mini-Budget with the votes of no confidence. These artifices by the Government were necessary because they had no answer. Therefore, they would only try to find some bush behind which to hide. The bush, of course, is Dáil Éireann. They want to hide here rather than to go out and meet the people.
I want to suggest to the people of this country and to the Members of Dáil Éireann that they should consider what sort of an uproar there would be in this House if we were sitting over there on the Government Benches and they were sitting over here on the Opposition benches and we were in the circumstances in which the Government are today, namely, that we had been defeated in a referendum by over three quarter of a million votes and refused to go to the country and, instead, proposed a new national loan, a mini-Budget and a motion from our Taoiseach all at the same time. Just imagine the howls there would be in Dáil Éireann today if that situation obtained, howls that would bring down this roof. I have seen in different days particularly the present Minister for Agriculture howl and shout at Deputy John A. Costello; I have seen Deputy Seán Lemass interrupt him 49 times in one speech. What would have happened today if we were over there and they were over here? My friend, the Minister for Health, sitting across there knows exactly what happened in the past. I want to ask how would Fianna Fáil have behaved today?
Does the Taoiseach claim every advancement since 1957? Europe advanced since 1957. Britain advanced since 1957. They have had their difficulties, both of them. The world advanced since 1957. Is every move forward to be produced as a cold, fish-like statistic by the Taoiseach to-day? Does he claim that anything that happened since 1957 is due to Fianna Fáil and that nobody else in this country had anything to do with it? Does he claim he is entitled in his entire speech—mark you, I christened him Honest John and the press changed it to Honest Jack; I think Honest John is more phonetic—if he is Honest John, to use "value" instead of "volume" and to say so much was spent on housing in 1956 and so much in 1967 or 1968, while we all know the pound is worth only half as much as it was then? Is he entitled not to mention the question of emigration? Is he entitled to allow his Ministers, for every one of whom he is responsible, to refuse to answer the questions of Deputy Oliver Flanagan on emigration and to leave us with the impression that he is not interested?
Let us face the fact that our educational system is the worst in Western Europe. Let us remember that Fine Gael produced their policy on this a good few years ago and if it was not stolen it was certainly compulsorily acquired by the Government. We have not got a situation whereby boys and girls, whose mothers and fathers cannot pay for their university education, can avail of such education if they are of the standard of intelligence and education to merit such an opportunity.
Let us also face the fact that we have the worst health service in Europe. I have the greatest pity for the Minister for Health in this instance. Unless we can arrive at a situation in which no further health charges will be put on the rates but that they will be borne by the Central Exchequer, the Minister must keep coming back to the House to say we cannot afford to make proper provision for health services for our people. That is the Minister's position. It is the policy of the Government. It is our job here to state our point of view and to suggest to the people that perhaps they should change their allegiance from Fianna Fáil and give us an opportunity to move over where they are so that we can implement a better policy.
In agriculture 10,000 people are leaving the land per year. We have failed entirely in regard to any intensive type of agriculture, whether it be horticulture or anything else, that would keep more of our people on the land. I agree the Government have provided grants for various aspects of agriculture but they are not adequate to deal with the situation. I was shadow Minister for Agriculture for four or five years, and if I were to have a chat with Deputy Clinton, who now has that job to do, as to what would be necessary for agriculture, I think we would have to agree that it would take as long as three to five years to clear up the appalling mess that has been created by the Minister for Agriculture who set out to destroy the biggest farming organisation in this country, the National Farmers' Association.
The Taoiseach, who has this aura of being apart from the other boys, to use a very kindly term in regard to him, is responsible for this situation. He has supported Deputy Blaney, the Minister for Agriculture, in his efforts to break the NFA. If the gamble failed and if Deputy Blaney had to go to the bookie and pay the price he has only himself to blame. Fianna Fáil and the Taoiseach have similarly to go to the same bookie, the bookie being the people. They do not want to go to that bookie again because they have already gambled very heavily and lost on this occasion.
Without going into detail on certain things, what were the reasons, for instance, for the great increase in the volume of milk produced and the increase in wheat production this year? The reasons were that the general overheads on the farm today had gone to the stage where a man who has to support his wife and children had to select some form of production which would give him a reasonable return rather than continue with other branches of farming which have been neglected and left derelict by Fianna Fáil. Now Fianna Fáil are talking about the production of beef and the production of other things. I have not heard them saying anything about self feed silage units in the last ten years. We must conserve our grass during the wintertime and feed it to our cattle all the year round.
I listened today to the Taoiseach using this trickly statistic of value instead of volume. I should be very pleased if, when he is replying to this debate, he would talk about housing and how much was being spent on houses. Last night I came home from the town of Dundalk having interviewed people there from 9.45 until 12.30 a.m., having been in Drogheda from 7.30 on the same job. I interviewed a young couple in Drogheda who had a baby of one year—they had to bring the child with them—who are living in a shed at the back of a house in Pearse Park. Is that not a horrible situation in 1968, two young people living with their baby in a shed with the water running down the walls? I went to Dundalk and I will resign from this House if anyone can prove this is not true: I interviewed a man who is living in a boarding house and whose three children are incarcerated in the Blessed Oliver Plunket Hospital, a hospital for old people, in Dundalk.
In these circumstances the Taoiseach, whose Party has been in office for ten continuous years, has the gross impertinence to talk about housing and to create that aura of respectibility about himself that he is not associated with Deputy Boland and Deputy Blaney. Let us face the fact that we must get these people out if we are to do anything for the people.
Let us consider the position of Ministers. Can the Minister for Agriculture get any good voluntarily from the farmers? Will he be forever driving them along and must he continue to make violent attacks on them? As regards the Minister for Local Government, will he get voluntary help from the people from whom he needs help in the building of houses and the provision of amenities? Remember the arrogance of Fianna Fáil. This is a man who never served a day as an ordinary Deputy of this House. A man who arrived here today, because his father had been a Minister during 30 years was made a Minister tomorrow. That is an example of arrogance if nothing else.
Imagine the situation in which my colleague in Louth, the Minister for External Affairs, is burning the rubber from my constituency to Dáil Éireann as hard as he can making every effort to save his Party's skin. Maureen Potter in a Gaiety Theatre pantomime was asked if Deputy Aiken was living in the past: "Not at all" she said, "that man is living in New York". This Government have become rancid and they have got to be put out if there is any good to be done for Ireland. They spoke about the Irish Independent. It is my opinion that that newspaper went a long way too far during the referendum and that they have to be nice now. Perhaps, I am saying something for which I shall be sorry——
Comment on this
I never read the thing. A fellow who lives near me buys the thing and he gives it to me but I never read it.
Comment on this
Let us now take the Ministers one by one. The Minister for Education is in open warfare with everybody on the academic staffs of the universities. I seek a denial of that statement from him. Read the newspapers. His merger, which should be to bring together, is dividing in diametrically opposite directions and all he can do is make a speech now and again. Can we get anything good from this man for the education of our children?
The Minister sitting opposite at the moment is a personal friend of mine. He has not reached agreement with the Irish Medical Association or the Irish Medical Union. Reconciliation was attempted many years ago. We had a running battle between Deputy MacEntee, as Minister for Health, and the IMA and the IMU which lasted for years. We had a select committee on the health services on which I served. There was a big "do" in Ivy House the likes of which was never heard or seen before. Every surgeon, every paediatrician, every gynaecologist, everyone who had anything to do with medicine in this country, including members of the select committee, was at it and we had the Army band playing sweet music from the balcony. A nicer night you could not have had.
Then Deputy MacEntee moved out of the Department of Health and we had other Ministers for Health, including the late Deputy Donogh O'Malley, the Lord rest his soul, and we are now back at square one: the doctors have not agreed and I suggest that a further change of personnel in the Department is needed. Affiliation seems to be the only thing that might do some good.
Nevertheless, it would be quite wrong if this or any other Party were to move along in the old Annie-Get-Your-Gun fashion of saying: "Anything you can do I can do better". I do not think that is good enough. If the people of Ireland wish to change their Government, they should be given the opportunity to do so. They should be told what they are getting by way of government. I eschew the line Deputy Seán Lemass followed. He had two slogans, one being "Wives put your husbands to work," and the other, "Let us get cracking".
Comment on this
"Give us a blank cheque," they said. "Do not worry about policies, vote for Fianna Fáil. Was not that poor devil always a decent man". Deputy Cosgrave today mentioned political sophistication. The people are sophisticated enough now to vote in the referendum as they thought fit. Now the challenge is here for the Opposition Parties to put their policies before the people to work like niggers from now until the next general election, which I hope is not long away, to try to let every person in their constituencies, in the country, know their policies, to let them be judged by these policies.
I wish to mention a few of the things that matter in this respect, but, first of all, let us consider the suggestion of the Taoiseach—it was a rather sly suggestion—that there is no hope of any other Government as an alternative to Fianna Fáil—that there can be nothing but a Coalition Government or a Fianna Fáil Government. I should like to refer again to something I mentioned during the past six or nine months and which I hope I got across.
On the count in the local elections last year, if there was a general election under PR the result would have been about 60 to 65 seats for Fianna Fáil, about 53 to 58 for Fine Gael and 20 to 25 for Labour—something of that order. That was the first break. It indicated that Fianna Fáil would be in a minority position.
Let us then go straight to the referendum. Deputy Booth suggested that a large number of the people who voted against Fianna Fáil on this occasion would revert and vote for Fianna Fáil again. To my mind it is clear that Fianna Fáil cannot get an overall majority. It is clear the challenge is there and let the best horse jump the ditch. The position now is that Fine Gael can get an overall majority in the next election and if, perchance, they are not in an overall position, they probably will be the largest Party in this House and in that situation, as statements of intent have been announced, it is my opinion that Fine Gael will be the next Government.
As that is so, we have a responsibility to enunciate policy. The time is too short to do so here this evening but it will be done in the next weeks or months. We will see to it that by our energy and effort everybody in the country will know Fine Gael's policy if they do not know it already. Let us mention that in agriculture it will be our job to salvage the Fianna Fáil wreck and it will be a very tough salvage operation. In the Department of Industry and Commerce we have an extraordinary situation. During the past three years, Fine Gael have been saying that existing industry was not getting its fair share, the only grant being given to it being for adaptation. Besides, an industry had to be an exporting concern before it got an adaptation grant. Large spectrums of industry were disqualified being completely at a disadvantage in comparison with Northern Ireland.
Then, three years ago, Fine Gael produce their policy at their Ard-Fheis and after we had hammered it home we had a change of mind and now we are giving re-equipment grants to manufacturing industries. The grant is 25 per cent for existing industry and there is a grant of 50 per cent for new industry. In parts of the country, such as in the area of the Minister for Health, it is Fine Gael policy—I want to emphasise that—where existing industry's need for major re-equipment is of such magnitude in relation to the size of the industry as to constitute an entirely new departure to give existing industry the same treatment as industry from abroad. We do not want to have a situation such as I had in my town where somebody came from Germany and got £60,000 and somebody else who employed 16 girls more got £16,000, notwithstanding the fact that they had to build not far away from the German industry. Many of these people are members of Taca and many of them followers of Fianna Fáil but they can look to us to give them what they require.
Let us look at health. The Minister for Health is present and I do not want to offend him. It is Fine Gael's policy to produce a health scheme based on insurance, to stop forever the horrible situation whereby, for instance, two old age pensioners living in a house with three or four children cannot get a green card even though every one of their children can apply and get medical cards on their own account. This is an example of one of the extraordinary anomalies of the 1963 Health Act. A health service based on insurance with coverage for those not insured is the policy of Fine Gael, a different policy from anything enunciated by the Minister or his predecessors. I am aware that both his predecessors, not forgetting the wonderful coming-together we had between Deputy MacEntee and the doctors, failed to reach agreement with the medical profession in this matter. We worked it from 1953 to 1957 and they came along then and failed to work it. It is time they moved over and gave it to somebody else.
I dealt with local government last night. Fine Gael policy is that if you build houses, industry, employment and everything else follows that. In the inter-Party Government days, which are sneered at today, we built more houses than are built to-day. Housebuilding has been reduced from 11,000 per year to 4,000 per year. What was wrong with the Government when you had houses falling all over this city? You had women and children in Griffith Barracks and the husbands getting in for half an hour each evening to see the children. If the Government gambled from 1957 to 1961 at not building houses it is time they paid the bookie and went to the people who will deal with them.
I should like to mention something else—the disgraceful situation in relation to compulsory Irish. That will cease under a Fine Gael Government. I just love to get publicity for that. It is wrong to say that we have a small minority of people who are profiting by the language, who are profiting from what should be a cultural attribute and which is in Scotland and Wales a highly cultural attribute. It is Fine Gael policy to end compulsory Irish in the Civil Service and other places There is benefit and advantage for those with some knowledge of the Irish language. I knew a dispensary doctor who was earning a very high salary as a specialist in England. He was single and his mother was old and back he came to take on a lowly dispensary job. He had spent a few years in England and was a specialist in his own right in a certain branch of medicine. However, he had to study Irish for nine months before he could get his dispensary.
There is another case to which I should like to refer. On the first occasion that Ireland won the Triple Crown in Belfast after the match we sang the Soldier's Song in English and every Welshman there sang the Welsh national anthem in Welsh. What is wrong with the language in this country is that Fianna Fáil have prostituted it for their own ends. That goes under a Fine Gael Government.
I should like now to turn to something else. Under a Fine Gael Government we believe that social welfare payments should be increased. They are too low. Our policy for a just society is to increase social welfare benefits for the people who need them.
We hear a lot of talk about doctrinaire capitalism, socialism and private enterprise and a lot of such cod. If you want a different situation go to southern England and there you will find many people who did not make their money in the last five years, people with vast incomes. There you will find a situation where there is a need for doctrinaire socialism. We in Ireland have no such society. There are few rich people here. Most of the people who are doing anything are doing it on overdrafts. In Ireland a private enterprise economy harnessed to social justice, harnessed to a just society will suit this country so long as the Government of the day will not flinch at going in and employing people in industry where private enterprise has failed or is not suitable. This talk about doctrinaire capitalism and throwing out of cliches is of little consequence. A Fine Gael Government would have a just society, a Government that would encourage private enterprise and, at the same time, if private enterprise failed or was unsuitable we would inaugurate another Shannon Scheme. That is commonsense. I do not think anyone would cavil at the definitions I have given, people in private enterprises, small proprietors, some large, very few wealthy, some wealthy and some who became wealthy in this generation or in the last. Surely the people can see the need for a Party who can proceed towards a just society and use every opportunity for the advantage of every one of our people.
Let me pass now to something that has not been mentioned in this debate today and which should have been mentioned. When I came to look at the debate on last year's Budget in the library, I went through this issue of the Dáil debates and for every title on every cover that related to ordinary parliamentary business there were six, seven or eight titles relating to the two referenda. Facing this Dáil or the next Dáil if this Dáil is dissolved there is at this moment a vast amount of parliamentary work that has been thrown aside by the Government. The Minister for Industry and Commerce has passed re-equipment grants months ago. He has produced a press report which shows that he is going to amalgamate the Industrial Development Authority and An Foras Tionscal. He has issued grants. The company I am involved in has got one of them. The legislation still has to go through. We are still waiting for this legislation.
What is the position of the Minister for Health? How much legislation has he waiting in his Department? What is the position of the Minister for Local Government? How much legislation has he got in his Department? What about the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries and the Taoiseach himself? I want to prophesy to you that whatever government is formed from the nineteenth Dáil when the Cabinet sit down there will be more prospective legislation waiting to be passed, most of it non-political, than would paper the walls of the Cabinet room and that the whole work of the next Dáil is going to be rendered completely and absolutely ineffective for the first two years by the nefarious attempt of Fianna Fáil to take power for 20 years, when they were prepared to throw aside all the parliamentary work in which we should have been engaged. This I believe to be a serious criticism. This I believe to be something that will affect this country this year, next year and the following year. I believe it to be evidence that the Government will cast aside everything no matter what it is for their own preservation. I believe in collective responsibility and because of the institution of parliamentary democracy that operates here and in England and various other places collective responsibility is vested in and the criticism of it is vested in the Taoiseach. He is responsible for every Minister. So far there have been no dismissals.
Let us face the fact that the selective wholesale tax has been doubled, that the selective wholesale tax is an extremely tough tax and that what the selective wholesale tax means, for instance, is that if you made a door for a new house on the site you would not pay selective wholesale tax but if you bought the door and the door-knob and everything else in a builder's providers or had it made off the site in a carpenter's shop you would pay five per cent and you are now going to pay ten per cent. I do not want to go through the whole spectrum of selective wholesale tax but I want the House and people to know just how serious this is.
I want to point to the fact that there is nothing for the social welfare recipients in this mini-maxi-Budget. They are being left in exactly the same position as they were. They suffered the impositions of the Budget last April and they had to wait until 1st August for any little relief they were getting. Now the Taoiseach at page 4 of the circulated version of his speech says that we were gathering speed too quickly in our economy and that the brake had to be put on. The brake has been put on the social welfare recipients, the recipients of health benefits, just as it has been put on the company director or the monied man.
Let us remember also that postage charges are something that strike everybody. It may take a little while. Somebody may notice that the amount of money being spent in a business on postage charges has now gone up by 25 or 30 per cent and they will try to get their money back, otherwise they will go out of business.
I want to suggest that a penny a gallon on 7,000 gallons of milk proved one thing: the Government are completely out of touch with the people. I went down for my Irish Independent this morning. Being a politician and having heard the news the night before I rambled over to the boys on the milk stall. I want to assure Deputy Blaney, the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, the Taoiseach and the Government that this was their greatest political mistake of all recorded time. A penny a gallon on 7,000 gallons is something less than £30 a year. It has been taken by the farmers of Ireland as a studied insult and if one were to talk entirely in the political way in which the Fianna Fáil mind addresses itself to problems of this kind Fianna Fáil would, politically, have been far better off if they gave them nothing. Let us face the fact that the people who went in for milk and the people who went into wheat did so because their fixed, unavoidable, overheads had reached a stage at which they needed a large gross return. They did not go for milk because they wanted to milk cows twice a day seven days a week. Many a farmer finds that a very big burden, especially in later years. They went in because their overheads were so large that they could not run their farms and feed their families any other way. People did not go into wheat because they wanted to grow wheat and run the risk of a rejection at harvest time and this does apply to the growing of cereals in this country. They went in for the same reason. They went in and now the taxpayers have to pay £1½ million in this mini-Budget towards getting rid of losses on wheat. There is the only reason why the Minister for Agriculture did not put a levy on wheat this year. He looked over at me today and he said: “Deputy Donegan knows”. I know I could not say it politically. I thought about it since and I know that the only reason a 5/- levy did not go on this year was that the Government were heading for a referendum. Let us face that situation and let me end as I began. Last April it could be foreseen. I said, and I am no pundit at all, that this was a Budget either for a referendum or a general election. I have been proved correct. We now have a mini-Budget and it is going to crush the poorer people of our country. We have a list of Ministers whose names I have mentioned and whose hard work I have discussed. I think the House and the people will agree that there is only one hope for Ireland now and that is to give them a change. I am asking Fianna Fáil now to come out to the country and give them that change because that is what will happen.
Comment on this
Sir, I have to ask once more where is the Minister for Local Government because he has replaced surely in the Fianna Fáil lexicon the place that used to be taken by Britain as the never-ending source of all their evil. He has not appeared in the House as far as I can see to support the Taoiseach in his very weak effort to justify the continued existence of this caucus as a Government of the Irish people. Mind you he should appear because he had a big hand in bringing the worried frown to the brow of Deputy Dowling and others and placing on their shoulders the burden of concerning themselves with that disagreeable task, ascertaining the will of the people, in the very near future. He should appear. Let us hope he will be here at a later stage in the debate when we shall have some words to address through you, Sir, to him on the part he has played in attempting to defy the will of the Irish people and in attempting to suborn the democratic institutions which we have inherited.