We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Confidence in Government: Motion (Resumed).

Contributions 154–330 of 330. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

I rise to support the motion in the name of the Labour Party, that in view of the Government's failure——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I must interrupt the Deputy to point out that there is only one motion before the House at the moment.

Comment on this

The Chair will appreciate that, in speaking to that motion, I am speaking in particular to the motion down in the name of my Leader and my colleague.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

These motions are being discussed concurrently but there is only one motion before the House.

Comment on this

The purpose of our motion is to draw attention to the failure of the Government in the fields of agriculture, employment, industry, housing, health, social welfare and related policies and to call on the Taoiseach to call an early general election to enable the people to express judgment in all these fields.

Everyone knows the compelling reasons why we should have this debate and why we should call for an early general election. On 16th October the people were asked to stand up and be counted whether they were for the continuance of the present democratic electoral system or whether they wanted to support a totalitarian-minded regime. The people considered in great detail the terrible implications involved in the referendum, the so-called straight vote, the single-seat constituency, the gerry-mandering which went with it and the tolerance vote which destroyed the principle of one-man-one-vote. The Government were given their answer on that occasion and their proposals met with a devastating defeat. It is ludicrous to attempt to justify the attitude of the Taoiseach and his colleagues that the referendum issues were constitutional issues; we say they were certainly political in every sense.

The people voted for the maintenance of democracy and of their fundamental rights, the right of free elections, free association, free speech, a free agricultural council, a free trade union movement. They also registered their opposition to the Government in the other fields of political activity. The colossal majority of 223,000 against the Government's proposals in the referendum represented votes by the mass of the Irish people against the Government's incompetence, dereliction of duty, against their disdain and indifference to the people and the welfare of large sections of them. It was an indication to the Government that the people were fed up with them and wanted to end their regime, that they had been in power too long, had lost touch with the people and had shown arrogance and indifference when we pointed out the defects in our economy which were unpardonable and disgraceful.

Large sections of the people registered their vote in this referendum because they knew the things Fianna Fáil had in store for them if—God forbid—the referendum issues had been carried. If that had happened there would be a different situation in this Parliament. In a very short time we would have had a general election and, according to the indications and forecasts of impartial professors of politics, we would have had at least 100 Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party in this Assembly and the Opposition virtually wiped out. We would have had a government that would prove as overbearing and oppressive as any totalitarian government in the world in recent years with this system of election, the existence of which in north-east Ulster the Taoiseach himself deplored in recent days. We would have seen that kind of situation here: the voice of minorities would not be heard for a long time. The people realised, as did large numbers of Fianna Fáil supporters and Fianna Fáil Deputies, that it would be an intolerable situation if they permitted by their votes any Government to be given so much power that they could ride roughshod over the feelings and requirements of the people.

All sections of the people already had a foretaste of things to come. The farmers assuredly had experience of jackboot government. They had seen the disdainful way they were treated by successive Ministers for Agriculture in recent years. They had seen all their pleadings, hopes and ambitions for a better standard of life contemptuously thrust aside by this Government. They had seen themselves forced to protest by long marches throughout the country and by sitting for weeks on the doorstep of the office of the Minister for Agriculture. They had seen their colleagues in prison and they had seen established here a National Agricultural Council which was merely the plaything of the Minister concerned, a Council which could not be said to be based on the democratic process and one which was, in the main, filled by the Government Party and one in which the proper interests of agriculture were given no adequate voice. No wonder the farmers availed of this opportunity to ensure that democracy would prevail.

The workers also had an indication of things to come in the repressive anti-working class legislation which we know is lined up ready to be implemented, particularly if the Government in the referendum had got the majority they had hoped for. I am restricted in time tonight and I cannot elaborate on the nature of that legislation but it meant, in effect, that the Government were seeking to outlaw the right to withdraw labour, interfering in the trade union movement to the extent of deciding what unions would come into being and what unions would go out of existence, and daring to change the Labour Court from a court of arbitration into a court of law. The workers realised all these things, and in their wisdom maintained their free democratic trade union movement and refused to give the Government the power to shackle them in this manner. They realise that the only difference between the free man and the slave is that the free man has the right to withdraw his labour and the day that right is taken from him he is relegated to the role of serf or slave.

Likewise, the business people saw the significance of the issues involved in the referendum, especially in the emergence of Taca, this outright corrupt practice, the condonation of the acceptance of a political bribe on the understanding that favours would be granted by the Party in power, favours by way of grants, loans or jobs, political kudos of all kinds. The emergence of this despicable organisation conjured up memories of Tammany Hall and outraged all fair-minded people, especially fair-minded business people, and their vote in the referendum of 16th October was a vote for justice, morality, fair play and fair dealing, and equal rights and equal opportunity for all.

We in the Labour Party rejoice in the outcome of the referendum, rejoice that the Government's proposals were defeated in such a crushing and devastating way by nearly 250,000 votes. It will be a long time before any Party or any Government will have the audacity to attempt to interfere with our Constitution and the fundamental rights of our people. I believe that it was the desire to hold fast to those rights which prompted our people to vote in such a determined fashion. The Government now have a responsibility to withdraw forthwith the proposed Criminal Justice Bill because this was an issue which I believe was involved in the referendum. Any legislation which seeks to restrict the right of our people to free association and peaceful protestation will not be accepted. I shall not deal with this proposed legislation in depth or in detail as that would not be possible due to the restriction on the length of speeches but I understand that the Bill seeks to restrict the right to hold meetings or processions and the like. That is clearly an infringement of the rights our people enjoy at the present time. Such legislative proposals are fraught with very great dangers, especially for minorities in our community. They are an affront to our people and should be withdrawn without further ado.

The Budget introduced by the Taoiseach has been described as a mini-Budget. If this is a mini-Budget, I should hate to think what a major Budget might be. This so-called mini-Budget represents for our people a hair shirt which neither the teenagers nor the general public will lightly wear.

The severity of the Budget has shocked all of our people. It is a vicious Budget. This Budget has increased the price of a packet of cigarettes by as much as fourpence, the price of the pint by twopence and the price of spirits by twopence. The price of stamps will go up. Telephone charges will be increased. There will be an increase in wholesale tax. Typical of Fianna Fáil, this is an unimaginative Budget. All the hardy annuals— tobacco, beer and spirits—are again selected for increased taxation. There is no question in this Budget of taxing the furs, jewels, costly cosmetics and luxury cars that we heard of some years ago from one Minister of the Government. No thought has been given to alternative means of raising revenue—from, say, amusements, sports and so on. Our people would not begrudge paying from such sources taxation that was properly required. It is a bit much that increased taxation should continually be imposed on cigarettes, tobacco, the pint and the "half-one", the price of which affects most of our people, including working-class people and the very poor. It is time to cry "halt". We heard a former Taoiseach saying a number of years ago that taxation on these commodities had reached saturation point and that he could not hope to secure further revenue from them. Nevertheless, once again, these commodities have been hit with a vengeance. In my opinion and in the opinion of my Party, this is a vicious Budget, an anti-poor and anti-working-class Budget because it affects commodities which our people avail of in very great measure and from which they derive a great deal of enjoyment— tobacco and drink. In taxing these commodities the Taoiseach is removing them still further from the poor people, to many of whom a "half-one" would be a joy indeed.

It is the lack of imagination in the Budget, its severity and above all, the falsity of this mini-Budget which have appalled our people. Clearly, for the purposes of the Budget of last April a deficit of the kind that has arisen should have been foreseen and provision should have been made for the extra millions required to tide us over the full financial year but, as has been said by other Deputies, the Budget of last April was deliberately drawn up with a view to courting popular support in the referendum. This is the rub. The revenue has now to be provided by this Budget and, most assuredly, there will be a popular Budget introduced next March or April in order to create the favourable climate of public opinion which the Government desire to cultivate in order to secure votes at the next general election or, perhaps, in the by-elections.

The people can very easily see through this subterfuge, this deceit, this fraudulent approach to balancing our Budget. Fianna Fáil need not think that they are codding the people by gimmickry of this kind. Any idea they had of codding the people must surely have been eclipsed by the votes cast on the 16th October. Our people are a very sensible people, an intelligent people and common sense prevailed in the referendum. Our people have long memories and they will not forget that the bribe they got in the Budget of last April was given in order to secure their votes in the referendum, which anyway they did not give. This Budget, then, is the in-between piece of vengeance preparatory to a popular Budget being introduced before Fianna Fáil go to the people on the next occasion.

Inherent in this Budget through the increase in purchase tax and the over-all attempt to damp down consumption in so many fields of activity is the real fear of further unemployment. We in the Labour Party are concerned that at a time when we did have some buoyancy in industrial output from which it was hoped new jobs would be provided we now have a situation in which these restrictions are bound to curtail consumption and to place jobs in jeopardy. No one need try to tell us otherwise. A short time ago we had the Minister for Transport and Power, who has a holy horror of workers possessing money, saying that for every pound they spent 8s 6d goes for the payment of imports. This is one good reason why the Minister for Transport and Power hates to see any person spending a pound at all. His ultra-conservative approach most assuredly must be a product of the Manchester school of economic thought. He will see to it that very few pounds are left to spend because he alleges that 8s 6d of every pound goes to pay for imports.

Comment on this

The Deputy thinks it should be more?

Comment on this

I do not believe it is a fact. If it is, then the Minister has an obligation to try to ensure that many of the things which are imported will be manufactured here instead or a reasonable substitute found for them. Many of the things which we do import are things which we could well do without.

It is a pity that no worthwhile reliefs were granted in this Budget. The Taoiseach must be aware that there is a great need for relief in regard to income tax and especially for a more generous allowance in regard to dependent allowances. For a number of years there has been no improvement whatever in regard to these allowances especially under PAYE. Large sections of our workers are being scourged by the income tax which they have to pay every week from mearge wages amounting to £8, £9 or £10 a week. Everyone is aware that for unmarried workers the income tax rates are essentially disincentive and must affect productivity. Workers are disinclined to avail of new incentives for increased productivity or to work overtime because they are simply working for the taxman. Every £1 that is earned over some £6 a week is liable for income tax and we are concerned about the disincentive aspect of such a system and the unfairness of it for there has been a steep rise in the cost of living since PAYE was first introduced.

I trust that in next year's Budget a positive attempt will be made to give the working classes a better deal in regard to income tax relief. It is well known that other sections of our community have ways and means of avoiding the payment of income tax and do so but the great mass of working-class people are caught under the PAYE system and have no way out. It is intrinsically wrong that they should be forced to pay 7/- in the £ from meagre wages of £8 or £9 a week. I am sure the Taoiseach will have regard to the effect this is going to have on the economy if some incentive is not provided. It is also ironical to think that no income tax allowance is provided for a single man in respect of a housekeeper. There is no allowance for a car which may be essential for a man to get to and from his work, even though such an allowance is available to higher executives. Anomalies of this kind infuriate the working classes and it is high time they got a better deal.

Our motion is not so much concerned with this so-called mini-Budget as it is a condemnation of the Government's dereliction of duty over a long number of years especially in the field of employment. It was disturbing in the extreme to hear the Minister for Transport and Power a short time ago allege that full employment was virtually impossible to attain in this country. It seems as if Fianna Fáil have abandoned any hope of providing employment for our people. All their sunny promises of some years ago of providing 100,000 new jobs seem to have gone by the board. Indeed, it was quite evident to all intelligent people in this country, from the manner in which they introduced the issues involved in the recent referendum, that they were a government bereft of any policy whatsoever.

The Government had hoped to get into the Common Market by 1970 but this ambition was frustrated by General de Gaulle. The Government depended too much on the astrologers for advice and all their plans for economic progress went by the board. They were disastrous. The First Programme for Economic Expansion was a failure. Instead of the 100,000 jobs it was intended to provide in that period of five years, 170,000 of our people were forced to emigrate.

The Second Programme for Economic Expansion collapsed before it got off the ground at all and is a completely dismal failure. We now have talk of a third plan for economic expansion. The Government have clearly neglected their duty in respect of the provision of jobs for our people. They themselves have always said that the real test of any good government was whether they could provide jobs for the people. In this fundamental area they have failed abjectly.

The exodus from the countryside is running at more than 10,000 people a year. No less than 50,000 people have left the land of Ireland in the past few years. Little has been achieved in absorbing these people into industry. Agriculture is static. If it has increased at all, this increase has been about only one per cent. There has been no appreciable increase in the provision of jobs in industry. While the NIEC Report, which we read recently, indicated that during the next 15 years we would require to provide 230,000 jobs, the fact is that for many years the number of jobs provided each year has amounted to not more than 2,000 or 3,000.

We see clearly the gigantic leeway we have to make up in respect of employment. This is where this Government have failed. In this atomic age, this vast technological and scientific age, this vastly enlightened educational age, when it has been demonstrated in so many countries that it is possible to have good government, to provide work for people, to provide rising standards of living, to provide good welfare services, good education and the like, we find here that despite the long sojourn in power of the Fianna Fáil Party during the past 30 years, we are still not providing well for our small community of people. By reason of the extent of the haemorrhage of emigration which has gone on under this Government, we have come to be regarded as a vanishing race.

We condemn the Government in every field of activity, in the fields of health, welfare and education. It is true to say that in the field of health, Fianna Fáil secured thousands of votes on the basis that they would give all our people a really worthwhile health service. We remember the White Paper issued by the late, lamented Deputy Donogh O'Malley, then Minister for Health. It is some years since this White Paper on the Health Services was put to the Irish people. In it Fianna Fáil promised that, within a reasonable length of time, they would provide health services for all. They promised to eliminate to a large extent the odious means test attached to the provision of a medical card, a test whereby our people must expose themselves before the home assistance officer who determines whether one is entitled to a health card and whereby all the family income is taken into account. We were promised that this means test would largely be abolished and that our people would find it much easier to secure medical cards.

We were promised also a choice of doctor and the abolition of the dispensary service, which is an outmoded and archaic system. None of these things have materialised. Our people are still forced to expose themselves to this means test. They still have to go to the one doctor. Whether he likes them or whether they like him, there is no choice offered.

We still have the old red ticket dispensary system. We must challenge Fianna Fáil that, when they make statements of this kind, they are obliged to back them up and implement them. The Labour Party offers every support to them in the provision of a comprehensive health service for all our people. We have always adhered to this.

The same applies in respect of social welfare. Our social welfare services are the worst in Europe. It is true to say that those who are dependent on them, whether they be unemployed, widowed, orphaned or old aged, are dragged down to a miserable level of existence. They are forced to seek other sources of income through home assistance or from charitable institutions. We believe that there is tremendous scope for the improvement of these services.

As it is the ambition of this Government to go into Europe, they ought to remember the high standards in regard to social services which prevail in the countries of the Common Market.

In respect of education appreciable progress has been made, but we still have anomalies such as the one involved in the provision of free books for our children. It was a pity that a worthwhile and otherwise well designed education service was marred so badly by the lack of proper facilities in respect of the provision of free books. The Taoiseach may not realise that many thousands of Irish children are gravely embarrassed by the present system of the allotment of free books and the odious means test which goes with it and which places the headmasters of so many schools in a most invidious position in regard to the distribution of free books. What should be a prerequisite generally for those children who hold medical cards is not, in fact, being implemented. The scheme is not being administered as it should be administered and I appeal now to the Taoiseach to find ways and means of ensuring that free books are granted speedily to these children and that the means test is done away with.

I was agreeably surprised at the attitude of the Minister for Transport and Power here this evening. He tried to find excuses for the recent defeat of the Government. He told us of the many people, obviously Fianna Fáil supporters, to whom he had talked since, who had told him why they voted against the Government's proposals. It is a pity that the Minister for Transport and Power and his colleagues did not consult these people before they put the country to the colossal expense of the referendum and the colossal waste of public time in this House during the months it was discussed here. The major portion of the time of this House was taken up debating the pros and cons of an issue which has now passed into history and which will long be remembered by the Irish people. It will certainly not be forgotten by the Fianna Fáil Party and the man who took up most of the time here, as can be seen from the debates. I refer to the Minister for Local Government.

He held forth here day in and day out, obviously obsessed with the power grab he was trying to achieve. He forgot completely his very important responsibilities in other spheres of activity affecting the interests of our people. He seemed to abandon altogether his responsibility in respect of the housing of our people. It was obvious to us that, waking and sleeping, he thought of nothing else except winning the referendum. He forgot about the countless thousands living in hovels in this city and all over the country. Those of us who are members of local authorities know that the Minister has proved most incompetent; he has failed to provide houses for the people; he has failed to provide sanitary services. In my constituency of South Tipperary, I can say, without fear of contradiction, that all our schemes in respect of housing, the provision of water supplies, sanitary facilities and so on have come grinding to a halt under the administration of the Minister. There are major regional water supply schemes for Ardfinnan and Dundrum in the Department of Local Government since the autumn of 1965, awaiting the sanction of the Minister and the approval of the moneys necessary to implement the schemes.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy's 45 minutes have now expired.

Comment on this

As yet, we have been unable to secure the financial accommodation so urgently required.

Comment on this

I should like to express my sincere thanks to the Opposition Parties for their concern about the future of the Fianna Fáil Party and for their crocodile tears because we, as a Party, are slightly diminishing in the eyes of the Irish people, according to the Opposition. They are wasting their time because, so long as we are prepared to take the initiative and so long as we do not run away from our responsibilities, as the Opposition Party did when they met with crisis in 1956-1957, we will remain the Government of this country. In 1956-1957, the moment crisis loomed, the Opposition Parties in the Coalition Government packed their bags and crept into crevices and they did not emerge again until the dust of political confusion had settled down. The Fianna Fáil Party having returned to office, were faced with a disastrous deficit which they had to rectify by methods which though unpopular, were absolutely necessary to save the country from financial ruin.

We have always had the confidence of the people just as we have always had confidence in the people. Deputy Cosgrave said that the referendum was pushed through by the Minister for Local Government as a delaying tactic and this was a waste of the people's money. His memory is very short because he should remember the filibustering and the delaying tactics carried out by Opposition Deputies. Those of us who spoke on this side of the House spoke constructively and the Minister was given a limited amount of time to reply to each of the amendments put forward by the Opposition. These amendments were themselves designed to delay. Unnecessary debate here is a waste of time and money. The referendum issue could have gone before the people for decision much sooner than it did. Filibustering is part of politics, but one would not expect a man holding the responsibility of leader of the main Opposition Party to get up here and accuse Fianna Fáil of indulging in tactics designed to waste public money. I should also like to remind the Opposition that were it not for a High Court decision in 1961, as a result of pressure by a Fine Gael Senator——

Comment on this

The Deputy's Party did not appeal against it.

Comment on this

——we would not have to apply such mathematical accuracy to constituencies, 20,000 electors per Deputy. The decision will also entail a breaching of county boundaries, as will be clearly proved here when the Minister introduces his Bill to revise the constituencies. That 1961 decision is bearing fruit today. In the majority of the constituencies the boundaries will have to be breached. We and the Opposition know well that that is not desirable from the point of view of the Opposition Deputies who will be crying bitter tears when they realise that they will not be fighting Fianna Fáil but fighting their own colleagues when they are contesting an election. They should accept that situation.

They have consoled themselves up to now with the thought that their proper place is in Opposition — and poor Opposition they are. They do not want to be in Government because the responsibility of Government would rest too heavily on their shoulders. They would not like to have the responsibility of taking the initiative at the right time, and of having to deal with the public in accordance with the wishes and demands made on them. They realise that the security behind which they shelter in Opposition would quickly diminish if they suddenly, by some devious means, became the Government.

I want to ask the Opposition about one important matter. During the referendum campaign speakers from Fine Gael and Labour went around the country telling the people what they would do if they were in office, and what we were doing wrong. I accept that we are not infallible as a Party. We can make mistakes and we like to be reminded of the fact that we can.

Comment on this

The people reminded Fianna Fáil recently.

Comment on this

We also like to be reminded of the remedies which can come from the mistakes we make. Fine Gael and Labour speakers at church gates and in the propaganda they got out—and for which they got plenty of publicity—condemned the actions of the Government, but they did not say what their policy would be. They did not utter a single word about their collective policy, and that is the only alternative to a Fianna Fáil Government. They did not say what policy they would put before the people at the next general election. I ask them at this late stage to decide whether they are going to join together, and not hide behind a cloak of confusion. Fine Gael say that if they received the support of the people tomorrow they would form a government, but they know that unless there is some kind of a collapse on all sides of the House that is not possible. Similarly, the Labour Party say they will be the next government.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil will not be the next government.

Comment on this

Will they coalesce again? Will there be an inter-Party Government? We would have the same negative results after a very short period. The people will decide to retain in office a progressive government which continue to put their policy before the people, and at all times express their wishes to serve the people in all capacities, and not merely to serve those in the upper bracket of the community as has been alleged by the Opposition.

Deputy Treacy referred to the attitude of the Minister for Local Government towards the referendum. He also referred to the dragging of feet in the Minister's Department. The Minister was not solely responsible for the introduction of the referendum proposals. As a Party we were united on that decision. We decided that the proposals to amend the Constitution were acceptable. We decided to go before the people. Those who are willing to apportion the blame for the referendum to the Minister for Local Government have very short memories. We made it known that we as a Party had decided to go before the people, and that this decision was made by the Party, not by the heads of the Party or the Minister for Local Government. The political propaganda used by the Opposition failed because they themselves are conscious of the fact that Fianna Fáil still stand united on the decision they made.

I might remind the Opposition Parties that Deputy Cosgrave and Deputy Flanagan expressed their desire to have the straight vote system, but when the time came for the decision to be made at the latter end of the referendum campaign, they were prepared to change horses in midstream and go the other way. Deputy Flanagan's recent promotion to the front bench might have been taken away from him.

Comment on this

Recent?

Comment on this

This is his second promotion. He was sitting in the back benches for a long time.

Comment on this

He was not.

Comment on this

If he was not he should have been and it will not be long until he is there again.

We have been criticised with regard to the progress made in the building of houses. There is evidence of that progress. It is there in the records of the House for those who want to see it, and those who are anxious to tell the truth about it. In 1963-64 we built 7,831 houses. In 1967-68 we built 12,017 houses. In the coming financial year it is estimated that we will complete 13,000 houses, an all-time record in the history of the State. This Government and the Minister for Local Government have been criticised by Deputy Treacy for dragging their feet in regard to our housing policy. How can Deputies realistically express such sentiments when they know well that never before in the history of the State were so many houses built? We spent £54 million on the building of houses this year, and that is the largest sum of money ever spent on the building of houses. The Opposition should accept that a certain amount of capital only is available to each Department. That capital can be spent only in a liberal fashion. The Minister for Local Government has done away with precedent, and he has accepted the bit and gone forward with the building of houses.

Comment on this

The bit suits him. I wonder would the Taoiseach put blinkers on him.

Comment on this

I would not interrupt too much if I were you because the Huns put you in your place in their own time and they will do it again. You are very small at the moment and they will take the rest off you if you do not watch it.

Before Deputy L'Estrange interrupted I was saying there was a progressive programme so far as housing was concerned. We have practical theories and progressive propositions and we put them into operation as regards housing in this country. We do not get away from the fact that we could build more houses if we had more money and that even at this stage although we are building approximately 13,000 houses this year we will not have enough houses to meet the needs. This is comparable to the policy of the progressive people. The people themselves have a desire to own their own houses and the economic progress of the country gives them the opportunity to go forward and get married at an early age and accept responsibility at an early age. It falls back on the Government that we should build an estimated 22,000 houses per year. This is the progress we would like to make and which we hope if and when we return to office we will make at a steady and sensible pace.

Our agricultural policy has been criticised and came under very heavy fire here in the Dáil and on the political platforms during the referendum campaign by the Opposition Parties. I want to say that our agricultural policy is a policy for which we ourselves, the farmers of this country, have the deepest regard for the simple reason that the Government are prepared to stand over their policy. It is a policy which we believe is acceptable to the agricultural community and which we have designed to help all sectors of the community and in particular the small farmers. In doing so we believe and are convinced that the welfare of the whole community can only advance on the progress of our agricultural policy. We are convinced that it is one of the most essential industries in the State and that whatever is done to disrupt or confuse in any way the agricultural programme is going to set back the general progress of the country.

It is easy to see why in the years 1958 and 1959 an estimate of £20 million was passed through this House as against £78 million in the current year. This clearly explains the Government's concern for the agricultural community which also is nearest and dearest to the hearts of all Deputies who are agriculturally-minded and who are in close contact with the agricultural community. We realise that there are certain anomalies in the policy of agriculture. We realise also that it is not possible to please all farmers to the same extent. When speaking about agriculture the Fine Gael Party say that if they were in power and if Deputy Clinton were Minister for Agriculture he would give the farmers an increase of a shilling per gallon in the price of milk. It would be very acceptable to the farmers only I do not believe the farmers are gullible enough to believe that any economy could withstand a shilling increase in the price of milk at one "go".

I do not believe that the ordinary industrial workers of this country would accept that in order to support the one shilling increase in milk their pay packets would be depleted by at least one-half again of what we are already taking off. If the Fine Gael Party believe that the farmers are completely dissatisfied with the attitude of the Government towards our policy why do they not put forward a policy which we can scrutinise and which the farmers can scrutinise and can either accept or reject at the next election? They will not do that. They will wait until they see what developments we have and the progress we have made up to the last minute before the election and then they will burn the midnight oil as they did before. They will have Deputy Ryan and Deputy Clinton, the Leader of the Party and probably a few of their law agents from the front bench getting together deciding in the late hours of the night on the kind of policy which would win them most votes in the rural areas.

Comment on this

Would that be preferable to sending cash couriers around the country to the Independents?

Comment on this

I assumed Deputy Lindsay in his interruption was speaking about an organisation we have in this political Party called Taca.

Comment on this

No. I do not indulge in dirty four-letter words.

Comment on this

I want to translate it for you. The particular word Taca means support.

Comment on this

It means rigging.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should be allowed make his speech.

Comment on this

The Opposition Parties have in a most mischievous way by references to Taca made a malicious attack on the industrial people of this country. Industrialists and some well-known people who supported Fianna Fáil long before Taca came into existence will continue to support Fianna Fáil and have contributed to this organisation. Therefore, we can take it that it is corrupt to support any political party by virtue of the attacks made by the Opposition on the industrialists of this country. Every industrialist is now supporting some political party whether it be Fine Gael, which many of them do, or Labour. The Labour Party get their money by devious means, by slitting the corner of the worker's pay packet and letting the odd pence drop out through it. This is their means——

Comment on this

That is untrue.

Comment on this

It is not untrue, and you know it. You shake the packets and slit the corner and the money falls out—and Deputy Corish is down on his knees with the bag to collect the money.

Comment on this

That is not true and even the folk who signed the documents for you in the referendum had not the authority to do it——

Comment on this

This is scraping the bottom of the barrel.

Comment on this

It has been brought out into the open that their means of collecting money is illegal.

Comment on this

Is Taca subject to audit?

Comment on this

That money which the Labour Party get in that way goes towards the support of political campaigns by the Labour Party.

Comment on this

Be fair. This is a maiden speech.

Comment on this

It is a maiden without honesty.

Comment on this

Then they say that this is not blackmail.

Comment on this

What would you know about it?

Comment on this

It would be more honest to take the money out of the pockets of the workers and distribute it but, for heaven's sake, do not——

Comment on this

Violently anti-union and anti-Labour.

Comment on this

——do not take the money by slitting the pay packets of the workers——

Comment on this

I shall deal with you tomorrow afternoon.

Comment on this

I shall be here to interrupt.

Comment on this

You are not often here.

Comment on this

Mind yourself. This particular organisation has been abused because it has come out into the open and expressed its support for the Fianna Fáil Party. They have shown that they believe in the Fianna Fáil Party and in its policies. They are people who have supported Fianna Fáil all down through the years. These people decided that they would openly express their support. Where did the Fine Gael Party get their funds?

Comment on this

It is none of your business.

Comment on this

Cheese and wine parties.

Comment on this

Yes, they got it under the guise of a cheese and wine party. They need not tell us that they collected the funds at the church gates.

Comment on this

They do not get it beforehand, as yours do—the five per cent for the consortia.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Foley must be allowed to make his speech without interruption.

Comment on this

Twenty-one directorships.

Comment on this

The people who support the Fine Gael Party——

Comment on this

They are decent people.

Comment on this

——are hiding under a cloak. They would not come out into the open. They would be afraid to express their support for a Party which has been in the political wilderness for so long. Fine Gael's hopes of being a Government are so remote that the people would surely ask themselves, and ask themselves again: "Where is my money going in the past number of years?"

Comment on this

That is what they are saying.

Comment on this

Deputy Carter is laughing.

Comment on this

At least, we in the Fianna Fáil Party have the courage of our convictions.

Comment on this

You have the audacity.

Comment on this

We accept the responsibility of Government and continue to accept the responsibility of Government so long as the people of this country give us the mandate to rule. We shall stay here and do that because, in 1965, the people of this country elected us as a Government.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

Never again.

Comment on this

We will stay in office until we feel we have served the people and served them well.

Comment on this

Now who is whistling while going past the graveyard?

Comment on this

We never ran away, anyway. You deserted the nation in its hour of need in 1957.

Comment on this

During our terms of office, we have never shirked our responsibilities.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputies must allow Deputy Foley to conclude his speech without interruption. He has not much more time.

Comment on this

We have at all times put the interests of the people before our own individual interest.

Comment on this
Deputies

Ah!

Comment on this

That is the Taca people.

Comment on this

We realise that our purpose as a Government is to bring this country to prosperity.

Comment on this

It is taking a long time.

Comment on this

What about the clouds on the horizon?

Comment on this

The only reason the Opposition have rebelled against this is because they themselves are not interested in the political future of this country. They are not really interested in the economy. However, they are interested in the fact that, for ever and a day, they want to stay over there on the Opposition benches looking at us making the decisions and deciding for the people what the policies will be. In that position, they do not want anyone to point the finger at them and to say to them: "When you were in office you did such and such a thing". Let it be put on the records of this House——

Comment on this

It is well worth it.

Comment on this

——that Fianna Fáil never ran away from its responsibility as far as this country is concerned and will not do so now. The harsh measures we have taken are necessary and were they not necessary, we should not have taken these steps.

Comment on this

You knew them before the referendum but you did not tell the people.

Comment on this

We realise that these particular steps are unpopular with the people——

Comment on this

That is true.

Comment on this

——and with a large majority of the people, for the simple reason that, no matter who you are, if you ask the people for money—I do not care who you are—as a government you will become unpopular. However, it has readily been accepted by the Opposition Parties at all times to be prepared to oppose every step which the Government take.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): It did not make you unpopular with Taca.

Comment on this

They decide, collectively, and they vote collectively in the lobby against every step the Government take in the interest of the progress of this country. When the Opposition go out into the country on their rampage for power, they say to the people: "We are the individual Parties Fine Gael and Labour." When they come back again into this House, up they go in their numbers, through the gateway into the Division Lobby, deciding against every proposition which the Government put forward for the betterment of our country. Would you not think that, at this late stage, after so many years in the political wilderness, they would say to themselves: "At least we will study some of the propositions; there must be some merit in them; as they have been doing so well up to this, there must be some merit in their proposals?" Unfortunately, I do not think they will ever come to that.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

Was there any merit in the referendum?

Comment on this

A Daniel come to judgment.

Comment on this

There is one thing that I can say about the referendum.

Comment on this
Deputies

Say it. Go on.

Comment on this

We went before the people——

Comment on this

——expecting to win.

Comment on this

——with a proposal. That was democratic because we gave the people the opportunity of deciding on it.

Comment on this

You could not do anything else.

Comment on this

The people decided it was not democratic.

Comment on this

We put the proposal to the people as to whether or not they wanted a reform in the Constitution. The people decided they did not want the reform we proposed. We are very much prepared to accept the verdiot of the people.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

Have you any alternative?

Comment on this

You have postponed the butchering of the constituencies for another week.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I must ask Deputies to refrain from interrupting Deputy Foley. He has only a short time left.

Comment on this

——in Government.

Comment on this

We, as a Party——

Comment on this

Which Party? Which Party is the Deputy talking about?

Comment on this

The Taca Party.

Comment on this

We as a Party——

Comment on this

Which Party?

Comment on this

The Fianna Fáil Party. Fine Gael do not know where they are because most of the time they depend on the support of the Labour Party. Deputy Harte was not here when I was talking about the procession up and down the Lobbies when they are deciding against Government proposals and then when they go out into the country, up to the hills of Donegal, they say they are a separate Party and they will be the next Government.

Comment on this

That is where you got your biggest majority.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Foley must be allowed to proceed without interruption.

Comment on this

In conclusion, let me say that we in this country have achieved a considerable measure of progress over the last 10 years. In supporting the motion put down by the Taoiseach, I believe our policies show foresight and will gain the confidence of the people. I am confident that when the next election comes the people will put Fianna Fáil back into office.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

If there is one great achievement of the referendum which has been fought it is the fact that it gave Deputy Foley such a fright that he came into the House and made a speech after three years.

Comment on this

That is a lie.

Comment on this

That should be taken off the record of the House.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Deputy Foley has been so seldom in the House that he could not tell whether I was in the back benches or in the front benches. The Taoiseach must be impressed by the manner in which his backbenchers are presenting themselves. This presentation in the House is the effect of the shock results of the referendum. The last general election was held in 1965, and the figures revealed a considerable falling away of support from Fianna Fáil to Fine Gael. The campaign of bluff which was conducted by Deputy Lemass, who was then Taoiseach, was responsible for getting together a sufficient number of votes to leave a Fianna Fáil Government in office. Promises were made by the then Taoiseach which he had never any intention of honouring, and when the votes were counted the Irish people were saddled with a further term of Fianna Fáil administration. Then came the Presidential campaign, as a result of which the Irish people decided in a very definite way against the very best Fianna Fáil candidate that Ireland could produce: again there was a swing away from Fianna Fáil to Fine Gael. In the following year we saw an extraordinary swing from Fianna Fáil to Fine Gael and Labour in the local elections. This year we witnessed the spectacle of Fianna Fáil getting a defeat at the polls such as no government in any democratic country in the world ever suffered, so much so that it drew a comment from Captain O'Neill.

The Taoiseach knows quite well that, although he is the head of this Government, at no time did he get a mandate from the people to rule them for 24 hours. The mandate was achieved by Deputy Lemass, not on merit or by honesty, but by deceitful means and by bluff. However, the present Taoiseach has no authority from the Irish people to remain in office. He never sought the support of the people. Therefore, the plea that has been put forward by the Labour Party to the Taoiseach to get out should be heeded. If the Taoiseach had any decency, knowing he is in office under false pretences, he would consult the people, particularly after the falling away in the last general election, the falling away in the Presidential election, the falling away in the local elections, and the disastrous results of the referendum.

It is very clear to everybody, to business people, to investors, to people who are planning for the future, that here we have a Government that has lost the confidence of the people, a Government that has been limping from crisis to crisis, a Government which even the dumbest in this country know will not be in office after the next election and that the only means they have of remaining in office is to try to put off the evil day as long as they possibly can.

When Deputy Corish asked the Taoiseach a fortnight ago when the Wexford by-election would take place, he said he could not tell. The word "election" is able to send such jitters up the spine of every Fianna Fáil Deputy that he hates to hear it mentioned. The word is able to bring a terrifying spell of nervous jittering to the members of the Government. They are all men bound together by loud talking, big mouths and empty heads, sitting there endeavouring to answer questions, not knowing how their Departments are being run, each Department being allowed to run amok.

The main reason why the Taoiseach should go to the country is because his own good name is at stake. If you sleep with dogs you are sure to get up with fleas. The Taoiseach has a bad crowd around him but there is no such thing as one being better than the other. They are all in this kettle of fish together, the Taoiseach being as dishonest as the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries or the Minister for Local Government. As I have said, they are all in this together; they are all part and parcel of an extraordinary set-up based, I am sorry to say, on bribery and corruption which is undermining the democratic institution of this State. Every voter is looking with suspicion at Fianna Fáil, thinking that there is something dishonest associated with them.

For confirmation of this idea of dishonesty, one can look at the organisation Deputy Foley mentioned, Taca, every member of which has the confidential telephone number of every member of the Government. They have them in their diaries, the confidential lines that get them right through to the Custom House, to Merrion Street, to Industry and Commerce—numbers that the general public have not recourse to, numbers listed confidentially for members of the Government. Taca are allowed to have these confidential numbers.

Does not anybody know that the surest way of getting planning permission today is to be a member of Taca? If a local authority refuse planning permission, the one way to get the Minister to grant the appeal is to present the Taca certificate. The good deed is done, the cheque book is presented either to Senator Mullins or whoever is in charge in Fianna Fáil. This kind of Government must stop. The people have found them out. They were tried on 16th October, convicted, found guilty and sentenced and they are awaiting the sentence to be passed in a very determined way on whichever date the Taoiseach chooses for a general election. There is one thing the Irish people will not stand for and that is cheating, dishonesty, bribery, corruption.

There we have, in a few words, the type of administration run by Fianna Fáil. Is there any democratic country in the world which would have a Minister for Local Government like the one we have here at a time when thousands of our people are homeless with no prospect of houses, no prospect of money to purchase houses, no loans from local authorities to help them to buy houses? Here we have a Minister charged with the responsibility of providing houses for all our people but what does he do? He spends eight or nine months talking about changing the electoral system in order to rig constituencies, in order that he might continue as he has been since he came into this House. He was never a Deputy. He walked into this House, signed the roll and two hours afterwards he was a Minister. In order that that situation should continue, he spent thousands of the taxpayers' money, not a penny piece of his own: these people do not spend their own money: when they are not spending other people's money they are busy telling the people how their money should be spent.

Today, we had Deputy Childers, the Minister for Transport and Power, saying he does not like a worker to spend £1 because out of every £1 he spends 8/6d is spent on imported commodities, so workers should not have £1 to spend as far as the Minister for Transport and Power is concerned. The Minister for Local Government has failed in and neglected his duty and he has been the subject of a serious rejection by the electorate who have recorded a vote of no confidence in no uncertain manner. I am ashamed of the Taoiseach for not having removed the Minister for Local Government. If he had a spark of honesty or a decent drop of blood in his veins he would not sit in any government of which that Minister was a member.

Bad and all as the Minister for Local Government is, the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries is worse. He has been responsible for the agricultural chaos that exists because he refuses to nod at the people, he refuses to pass the time of day, he refuses to speak to the people and he is prepared to allow them to sit in the gutter outside his door. It reminds me of the man in the parable who was left outside the door of the rich man to seek the crumbs that fell from the rich man's table. We have a Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries who will not talk to the farmers, who will not listen to the farmers, who will not be advised by the farmers, who will not consult with them as to the best ways and means of solving problems.

Surely the Taoiseach knows that no Government can endure in these circumstances, that no people will tolerate such conditions. Now, the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, after long and serious thought, has decided to make a statement which will bring prosperity into Irish agriculture. The greatest degree of prosperity he can promise is the stimulation of milk production by a penny per gallon for 7,000 gallons, which means that dairy farmers will now receive from Fianna Fáil approximately £35 a year. The day following that announcement by the penny Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries came a new Budget by the Taoiseach in which there is the extraordinary admission that though this supplementary Budget could not have been foreseen in the spring, the last Budget was not a properly estimated one and that consequently there was a sum of £18 million required. So, in order that Fianna Fáil may remain in office, the Taoiseach has produced a new Budget described by some as mini but really major——

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

——in which beer, cigarettes, wholesale tax, telephones, postage stamps and the entire cost of living in this country will seriously be affected In other words, the Government have now decided again to dive their hands down deep into the trousers' pocket of every taxpayer in the country, of every smoker and of every drinker to try to take a penny profit from every publican and everyone engaged in the licensed trade in this country, to deprive the businessmen of any little profit that he may be anxious to make by wringing more in telephone charges from him, from every professional man and everyone who must have a telephone service—and we were told that the Post Office was paying. Here we find that, in order to write an ordinary letter, it will now cost the Irish taxpayer sixpence.

We already have possibly the dearest motoring in the whole world. Then the Taoiseach and some of his members have the nerve to get up and defend the policy of the present Government. Surely, Sir, there is not one single item of policy which will reflect credit on the Government. There are thousands of our people still unemployed and in search of work with no hope or prospect of getting work. There are 53,000 that we know of and probably another 30,000 that we do not know of. We find that the flow of emigration, while it is mentioned in every important debate that takes place here, is freer from this country today than it ever was and that there has been complete failure on the part of Fianna Fáil either to provide work for our own people or even stem the tide of emigration. They have done nothing but have failed disastrously and hopelessly. They have failed to give our people proper social welfare services. There is nothing in this Budget which gives one penny piece relief to the widows and orphans, to the old age pensioners, to the aged, the blind, and the sick.

This is a Budget which takes all and gives nothing. We have the worst health service of practically any country in Europe. We have been promised before every general election better and improved health services but, like the draining of the Shannon, the health services never came. They are always around the corner and expected but we never have them from Fianna Fáil.

Surely the Taoiseach cannot stand up in this House and say that this Government has made headway when there are today practically no proper industrial relations. The amount of time that has been lost by strikes week after week and month after month has been colossal and has been the subject of mention on Continental newspapers. We have strikes and more strikes which means that there must be a complete breakdown in industrial relations and a complete breakdown between employers and trade unions. We have a Minister for Labour who was appointed by the present Taoiseach to deal with all these matters and I have yet to hear what the Minister for Labour has done to justify his existence since the day he was appointed.

Surely everyone knows that industrial strike after strike cannot go on indefinitely without some positive and practical action being taken. In all these cases the demands of the workers appear to be reasonable but after long periods with loss of time and loss of production without settlement arrived at eventually strike action is taken. There should be negotiations around the table at least 24 hours before a strike can take place.

We have seen in Bord na Móna a fabulous loss this year and the main cause we are told from the report of Bord na Móna was a strike. If a strike in Bord na Móna did not take place the losses revealed would not have taken place. I charge Bord na Móna with deliberately dragging on the strike and not properly entertaining the just claims made by the workers' trade union, because the well-to-do employees of Bord na Móna, the office men who were bogging down in four-inch new carpets were not concerned with the men who were out in the bogs working the machinery, cutting the turf and looking after the peat harvest. The result has been it has been a very considerable loss to the Irish taxpayer and to Bord na Móna. We will have another opportunity of dealing with Bord na Móna, which is a hive and a nest of Taca and Fianna Fáil men.

The results of yesterday will have serious effects on employment. I venture to say that the distilling and the brewing industries, which contribute generously to the pool of employment in this country, will seriously be affected by this Budget of yesterday. In the licensed trade, in the brewing and the distilling industries it will certainly lead to unemployment. Expressions of opinion on that have already been made. I think that the one way this Government can at least appear to be straight with the people is to resign and get out. The Taoiseach seems to be extremely worried as to what government will follow Fianna Fáil. Every member of the Fianna Fáil Party knows they will go out at the next general election. We on this side of the House are not concerned whether the election is in January, February or March or this time 12 months. It will be all the same when the election comes. People have their minds made up. The Taoiseach seems to be extremely worried as to the type and nature of government which will take office immediately after the next general election. The Leader of the Opposition said here last night that the next government will be a Fine Gael government. Fine Gael will have sufficient candidates contesting every constituency at the next general election so that if the Irish people want to give us an overall majority there will be nothing to stop them from doing that. I am convinced that that is what will happen. There is support rallying round Fine Gael now as never before.

Comment on this

Even in Donegal. No—88, Yes—85, in Rossnakill, polling booth, the Minister's own polling booth.

Comment on this

You cannot even count.

Comment on this

Where you were born.

Comment on this

They claim that they got 88 and we got 85 but it was we who got 88 and they got 85.

Comment on this

250 voted.

Comment on this

176 voted, 88 "No", 85 "Yes" and three invalid votes.

Comment on this

Do not be interrupting your Minister there.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Flanagan.

Comment on this

When you did not win there you will not win anywhere in Ireland.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

These interruptions must cease.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I am endeavouring to demonstrate, for the information of the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries particularly, that after the next general election we will have in this country a Fine Gael Government and that before the general election the Fine Gael policy will clearly be put before the people.

Comment on this

I heard you have another one. Deputy Donegan told us.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

It will cover every aspect of life in this country— health, agriculture, industrial relations, social welfare, taxation, education——

Comment on this

Another few yet.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

——housing—

Comment on this

Do not mention housing when the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries is in the House.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

——and every single national problem.

Comment on this

And the Just Society.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

And the Just Society because we have in this country, as the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries knows, a vast amount of hidden and concealed poverty suffered by people who are probably on fixed pensions and fixed incomes.

Comment on this

Like the Fine Gael—

Comment on this

What about the rate collectors in Donegal?

Comment on this

They are O.K.

Comment on this

You were not too satisfied with them. You expelled one from your Party.

Comment on this

You cannot afford to expel any one out of yours.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Flanagan.

Comment on this

He was your best friend during the Roscommon by-election.

Comment on this

Look over your shoulder.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I am glad the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries asked a question about the Just Society because it shows his conscience is disturbed.

Comment on this

He has no conscience.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

When the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries speaks of the Just Society it is most certainly a display of emotional disturbance, because he knows very well that under the Fianna Fáil Government there is no such thing as fair play and justice for our people and, above all, for the old and the homeless who have not alone got the blind eye but also the deaf ear from Fianna Fáil. Surely the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries must know that in this country today, while there may appear to be a great amount of high spending and prosperity, there is also a great amount of hidden poverty.

Comment on this

Take a bob off the old age pension.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

There was never a shilling taken off the old age pension in my time in this House and, thanks be to God, I am going on 26 years in this House. I was in this House with the Minister's father——

Comment on this

I know you were.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

——who was a more decent man than the Minister, a very decent man

Comment on this

I do not dispute that at all.

Comment on this

Many a good father reared a bad son.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I am afraid I will have to seek your protection, Sir.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

You are having great difficulty. Deputy Flanagan.

Comment on this

You know what happens the rats.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

The Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries asked a question about some old age pensions or other that were reduced some time in the history of this country. I do not know anything about it but I heard about it——

Comment on this

Deputy McGilligan will tell you.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

——and that this reduction in the old age pension was carried out by a man called Ernest Blythe who was a Member of this House and who was then a Minister and who is now in the ranks of Fianna Fáil——

Comment on this

He is not in the ranks.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

——and who was one of the principal advocates of Fianna Fáil policy with the Taoiseach, Deputy Lynch, and the Minister for Local Government in the recent referendum. I understand that this former Minister for Finance is the same person who is now commonly identified with Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

Would this be his Budget we are discussing?

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

If Fianna Fáil have any questions to raise in connection with the reduction of a shilling in the old age pension they have the man who took the shilling in their own ranks now and they can get all the information they want from him. He is one of themselves.

Comment on this

He is one of the brass hats. He is not one of the ranks.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

The Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries need not address a query to me about this incident which is now part, fortunately or unfortunately, of Irish history. I am sure neither he nor I remember it. I do not think the Minister is as old a man as I am. He is wearing his years well despite——

Comment on this

I remember it, believe it or not.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

If you do you are an older man than you look.

Comment on this

No, I had a conscience then which the Deputy had not.

Comment on this

Which you have not got now.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Fianna Fáil have many new found friends in recent years. God knows none of us envies or begrudges the Fianna Fáil Party the association with the former Minister that they are so found of quoting at times.

Comment on this

They had Paul Singer before. He set up Taca for them.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Since the Taoiseach is responsible for the conduct of all his Ministers some suitable reference will have to be made to the Minister for External Affairs. It is time the Minister for External Affairs was relieved of his responsibilities.

Comment on this

Send him to the moon.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

God knows, when we all grow so old that we will not be able to undertake our work, I do not know how we will feel about it; but I am sure there are numerous other people who share my view that the Minister for External Affairs has reached the stage commonly described in the country in relation to old people as doting. The Minister for External Affairs has reached that stage. If the Taoiseach is to do as he says he is doing—bring a new image of youth and life and vigour to the country— for God's sake, let him get rid of this doting old gentleman who has served the country as well as he could but, when in 1968 that Minister is devoting most of his time to affairs outside the country, it is time that something was done.

Comment on this

He is like "The Fugitive".

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

When I asked what the Government's proposals were in relation to an emigrant service the Minister for External Affairs did not reply very suitably. I asked him when he last met any of our emigrants in London, Manchester, Birmingham, Coventry, Bristol or Newcastle or any important centre. One would imagine the Minister would be most anxious to help our emigrants. Most Deputies keep in close touch with emigrants from their constituencies. I visit the emigrants from my own constituency in London, Birmingham, Leeds, Bradford and Coventry each year. Thousands of our people are forced to emigrate because they are denied a living at home. They do not go for adventure or love of Britain but to get a better standard of living. They have many social problems. Representations have more than once been made to the Ambassador in London. The Minister for External Affairs has never displayed a really keen interest in the welfare of these emigrants. What is happening? The Irish Government appear to be washing their hands completely of their own citizens the moment they go abroad. That is wrong.

It is right to put on record that the new Fine Gael Government will courageously tackle the problem of putting into effect a proper welfare service for our emigrants. This has been too long deferred by Fianna Fáil. The new Fine Gael Government—this is more important still—will make a serious effort, with energy and determination to stem the flow of emigration and provide work for our people at home. The Department of Lands, for example, employs a total in forestry of approximately 4,500, while a proper forestry development drive should provide employment for between 15,000 and 20,000 in that sphere alone. These matters have been neglected because the Government is too old and too long in office.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy has two minutes left.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

In those two minutes I want to say that nothing would be better for Fianna Fáil than a good rest and nothing would be better for the country than a new, energetic Government which would be responsible for a complete revival in every aspect of national life.

Comment on this

It has plainly been shown in the referendum by the people who matter that the people of Ireland do not want to be taken over by the cheque-book brigade now running this Fianna Fáil Party. This gang of racketeers or tacateers are trying, not alone to feather their own nests but to buy out the whole country for no other purpose than to better themselves. I am surprised that a man of the reputed integrity of the Taoiseach should allow himself to be tossed about like a cork at high tide by the winds blowing from the gangs in Fianna Fáil. We all know they are split into about six different parts, not only nationally but locally. In my own city they are split right down the centre and that split goes right up to national level.

Comment on this

They are split in Donegal also.

Comment on this

If there was any honesty in Fianna Fáil or in the Taoiseach he would take heed of the lesson given in no uncertain manner in the results of the referendum. The Taoiseach has taken no action, nor have the courts, to charge the Minister for Local-Government with fraudulent conversion of taxpayers' money, the amount of which we shall, please God, know next week, the amount the referendum cost.

No matter what our way of life we must all make speculations but in this tremendous gamble that the Minister for Local Government took in regard to the referendum he jeopardised the whole nation by the attacks he made on the clergy and on the press. It would be better for the country and the ordinary worker if the Minister were relieved of his post. The civil servants who have now introduced this mini-Budget must administer chastisement to the workers who came out in the referendum and said: "We shall not put up with this. We shall not have the Taca gang taking over the Government." What did the civil servants who compiled this mini-Budget do? They hit the worker, his pint of stout and cigarettes——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Budget is introduced by the Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance, God help him, has my best wishes. Unfortunately, he is laid up.

Comment on this