Committee on Finance. - Financial Resolution No. 4: Wholesale Tax (Resumed).
Contributions 1–130 of 245. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I have listened carefully to the debate on the Financial Resolutions and I must say that I was very surprised to hear the Fine Gael Deputies say that the supplementary Budget had been introduced as a result of the incompetence of the Fianna Fáil Government. On the other hand we had the Labour Party saying that the supplementary Budget was introduced as an election gimmick. I, as a member of the Fianna Fáil Party, believe that these unpopular measures had to be introduced in the national interest and that their introduction goes to prove that the Fianna Fáil Government have never flinched from their duty where the national interest is concerned.
I may add that I listened carefully to Deputy Dillon speaking here on Thursday morning and was surprised that a person with the reputation that Deputy Dillon has should have engaged in swiping the House, as it were, with broad sweeping statements of corruption on a large scale amongst the members of the Cabinet. This does not serve any purpose except to cause a lot of bad talk. I was pleased, however, to hear a member of the Labour Party taking Deputy Dillon up on this and asking Deputy Dillon to be more specific in his charges and, if he had any proof of these charges or any facts that were not known to the Taoiseach and the proper authorities, to lay these facts on the Table so that they could be examined. This is how it should be done. Instead, we had these charges of a general nature which, incidentally, may not be denied by the Taoiseach until such time as he gets in to reply to the debate.
This sort of approach is typical of Fine Gael. It is an approach that has always been used by them down through the years. They have used this approach time and again. They have picked out individual members of the Government, not alone of this Government but of other Governments, and have tried to blacken their characters and to do them as much harm, personally as they possibly could. This has happened, as I have said, not alone in the case of this Government but in the case of other Governments. There were many wild charges, charges that were never substantiated, laid against the former Taoiseach, Deputy Lemass, and it is well known that on one occasion the present President of Ireland, Mr. de Valera, had to bring his birth certificate into this House in order to prove that charges made against him by the Opposition were completely false. I might add that these charges came not alone from the Fine Gael Party but from the Labour Party also.
Comment on this
I listened here to a younger member of the Labour Party on the same lines. Deputy Dr. O'Connell launched a very unfair and unwarranted attack on Deputy Kevin Boland as Minister for Local Government. Of course, this is typical. This is what one expects from the Labour Party. This is what they thrive on. No doubt, this is the approach they will have to the electorate at the next general election.
Comment on this
I honestly believe that this approach will fail, that the people of Ireland will not be swayed by these unfair tactics of Fine Gael and the Labour Party.
Comment on this
Without wishing to deal at greater length with these charges, I will say that, when the Taoiseach takes up the charges and asks the Opposition spokesmen, Deputy Cosgrave and Deputy Corish, to put up proof of these charges or to shut up, it is plain to be seen that they have to shut up.
Comment on this
I want to have it on the record that I did not make any charges of the kind he alleges I did.
Comment on this
I will refer at a later stage to charges made by Deputy Dr. O'Connell last week or the week before last. If the Leader of the Labour Party doubts what I am saying, he is welcome to look up the records and see what he said.
Comment on this
If the Deputy is interested in finding out, he can look up the records.
Comment on this
The other day we had the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries speaking on this matter also and I am glad to say that he laid bare the slander being thrown at him when he was Minister for Local Government, the charges that were made against him in this House by Deputy L'Estrange and others. I was very glad to see Deputy L'Estrange sitting in the front bench on the Fine Gael side of the House, with Deputy Oliver Flanagan, with his tongue in his cheek. This is certainly a change for Deputy L'Estrange. When he was faced with it and had to listen to the truth Deputy L'Estrange had to keep his tongue in his cheek and was a very mild, quiet boy.
Comment on this
The benefits given in this Budget have been ridiculed, laughed at and scoffed at, not alone by members of the Fine Gael Party but by members of the Labour Party. They have been referred to as sops. They have been referred to as if they were no use to anybody. Personally, I agree that the 1d given to the farmers was a very small increase. I say this knowing the farming problem and coming from a great dairying area. I know that the 1d increase is small but I am very glad to see the 1d going this time to the 7,000 gallon man. The 7,000 gallon limit is a very good thing. I sincerely hope that, when increases are being given in future in connection with the price of milk, they will be given again to farmers under the 7,000 gallon mark and the increase next time may be 2d or, indeed, 6d. I firmly believe, and always have and always will hold the view, that the small farmer is the person that we should help most. This two-tier price system is, certainly, a step in the right direction. I do not think it is anything to be scoffed at or ridiculed, as Deputies, particularly Members of the Labour Party, have been doing.
We have been told these measures were taken in panic by Fianna Fáil— that we had been taking things easy until the next general election, whenever that may be. Of course, I do not agree. We had to do this: we had to take all of these unpopular measures to safeguard our high rate of economic progress. This cannot be denied by any Deputy.
We have been told that we are on the way out, that we are breaking up, left, right and centre. Now it is our turn to laugh and to scoff, because nothing could be further from the truth. Labour have been saying that public opinion is so much against us that at the next general election they will be given the opportunity of taking over Government. They say that they will put forward enough candidates for every seat. So well they might, but this does not indicate the number of seats they will win. They certainly have nothing approaching a Party big enough to form a Government.
During the debate, Deputy Dillon compared the record of Fianna Fáil Governments to date with the things he did and the things his Party did when they were in power. He spoke of the formation of the IDA in his time and he hoped, of course, that it would wipe out all the other sins which Fine Gael, in co-operation with Labour, committed while in coalition. Deputy Dillon thought that the foundation of the IDA would gloss over the mortal sins committed in his time— sins like the effort to close down Shannon Airport, the selling of places, the closing down of hotels, the closing of the chassis shop at Inchicore, as Deputy Dowling pointed out.
I do not for a moment believe that the Irish public, the electorate, when we face them before April, 1970, will have any difficulty in comparing the record of Fianna Fáil government with the only record of Fine Gael and Labour available for comparison— their record in coalition during the years 1948 to 1951 and, secondly, 1954 to 1957. The progress and the achievements made by Fianna Fáil Government from 1957 onwards are obvious and plain to be seen by anybody who wants to see them with a fair and open mind. The record of the coalition Governments is not something to be proud of. They have told us there was no housing problem in 1957. Certainly, there was nothing then like the housing problem there is today, for the simple reason that there were not the people for the houses. It is a fact that in 1956 and in 1957 our people had to emigrate en masse, not alone single members of families but entire families and therefore we did not have a housing problem.
Nowadays, it is heart-warming to see that the population has increased, that emigration is slowing down considerably. I do not think anybody in any Party would like to see emigration figures again reach the level they were at in the Coalition reign. Emigration figures in that period had not been so high since the Famine, more than 100 years before. During this debate we have been charged with attempts to gerrymander.
Comment on this
We cannot have a discussion on this matter. It would anticipate the discussion on a Bill shortly to be before the House.
Comment on this
I did not intend to discuss that Bill but I should like to deal briefly with the charges of attempted gerrymandering which were thrown out during this discussion. We were told we would have gerrymandered under the revision of the constituencies proposal. I should like to ask the Opposition if it is now their opinion that we will try to gerrymander under the PR system as they said we would under the straight vote system. They seem to think we would do so in either case.
Comment on this
They have accused us of fixing things to suit ourselves, and that sort of business. Later, there will be opportunity for debate on this and then I should like to deal with Deputy Belton.
Comment on this
The question does not arise on the Financial Motions: it has nothing to do with finance.
Comment on this
I will not have any difficulty facing my constituents because I know they have confidence in Fianna Fáil, because I know they will elect candidates of Fianna Fáil and that they will return Fianna Fáil to Government after the next election, whenever it may be.
Comment on this
We will take to the hills when the Taoiseach decides when we should do so.
Comment on this
We will not be chased to the hills by Deputy Dunne or anybody else. It is for the Taoiseach to decide when we shall go to the country and, being the good leader that he is, he will pick the most suitable time between now and April, 1970. Mention was made of the alleged small amounts from the Exchequer being given to agriculture. I should like to remind the House and the public in general to look at the Fianna Fáil record on the question of subventions to agriculture and to compare particularly the amount of money being given this year to agriculture with that given in 1957 by the Coalition. It does not take much addition or subtraction to reckon that the figure in 1957 was £17 million whereas this year agriculture has been given approximately £80 million. This is a huge increase, something which I believe all farming sections will appreciate when it comes to the election of a Government.
One Fine Gael trend I have noted during this debate has been that more money should be given and less should be taken in. I agree that benefits should be increased, but the Fine Gael people seem to think or to imagine that far less should be taken from the people. We must realise that we can give out only that which comes in— that there is not a big gold mine at the back of Leinster House into which the Government can dip their hands and pull out money for all benefits. Anything that is given out has to be taken in.
Comment on this
I sincerely hope that in the next Budget, there will be a surplus, that more money will have been brought in to provide for many more increases. Particularly I should like to see social welfare benefits increased substantially. Our achievements in the sphere of social welfare is something of which Fianna Fáil can be justly proud. I hope we shall be able to provide more money for education and in this context I express the hope that the Government will be in a position to give us the university we are seeking in Limerick.
Comment on this
I hope this will come and I hope it will be in the near future. I have no doubt the Government will give it every consideration and that if money becomes available the university will be provided in the near future — that they will give us the OK, that the button will be pressed and that a university in Limerick will be real. It has been said — I do not agree with it for a second — that this Budget is the price of the failure of Fianna Fáil. It was said this supplementary Budget indicates that there has been no new thinking on agricultural policy. I have already dealt with this, which is completely untrue. I was surprised to hear a Deputy from a dairying constituency saying this. I refer him to the figures I have given for agriculture — £17 million, only, out of the Exchequer in 1957 and approximately £80 million in 1968. This should clear up any doubts the Deputy may have with regard to lack of thought for agriculture by Fianna Fáil.
It was said by, I think, a Labour Deputy representing a Dublin constituency that the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries should be removed from his Cabinet post because, the Deputy said, the Minister has refused to meet the farmers. This is not true: the Minister has never refused to meet them.
This allegation brings to the surface again the attitude of Dublin Deputies who are not familiar with the problems of the dairying areas which Deputy Crowley and I represent. That Deputy expressed the hope that the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries will be removed. Of course, they would like to see him removed because they see in him a strong Minister whose record in respect of agriculture is something he can be proud of during his short time in that Department. It is the known habit and the practice of Opposition Deputies to single out for attack on his personal character any real good Minister who has ever sat on the Fianna Fáil Front Benches. They resort to rumour and to scandal and to vile propaganda to cause as much trouble as they can for Fianna Fáil Ministers.
I have heard it said that any Minister who was not as brilliant as his colleagues was always left off the hook, that he was not faced with the charges made against his colleagues who might be top-class men in their own right. All these charges, such as those made by Deputy Dillon the other day which he refused to substantiate and by people like Deputy L'Estrange in the past, will have no effect whatsoever on the electorate when they have to decide in a short time who they will elect and what Party will have to look after their affairs and the country. I have no doubt that when the people are taking their decision, as I have already said, they will have little difficulty in clearly indicating their preference for the Party to carry out the job for them.
This Budget is certainly not a popular one. We will have to face the electorate in a short time but we can face them proudly because we will ask them to judge us on what we have done. We will ask them to judge the alternative to Fianna Fáil on what they have done and the possibility that we will have a Coalition.
Comment on this
What policy will the Opposition present to the public at the general election? Will they come on their own under the Fine Gael flag hoping to get a Fine Gael majority or, knowing they will not get it, will they rob the Labour Party of their policies and come together forgetting their differences in policies and be commonly united? The one aim they have is to put Fianna Fáil out of power.
I have heard it said that you have one Party, Fianna Fáil and those who are against them. I should like to clearly define to the electorate what our policies are because it is the obligation of all Parties to let the people know what their policies are before they ask the electorate for their votes. We have always done this in the Fianna Fáil Party and we will do it in the next general election. We will have the people in our favour and we will once again be returned to Government.
Many charges have been made in newspapers that there have been divisions and splits in our Party. As a younger Member, I am glad to say that, as far as I am concerned, there is no split and no evidence of a split in the Party. There is not even a suggestion that there is a split in the Party except when we are told by the Opposition. We are told we are not getting on and that there are elements within the Party trying to get the Taoiseach out of office. As a younger Member of the Fianna Fáil Party, I am glad to say there is no evidence of this whatsoever. We are very proud of, and very lucky to have, the Taoiseach, Jack Lynch, who is leading a united Fianna Fáil Party.
Comment on this
We will face the electorate in the next general election without fear. Possibly I am too young to know, as Deputy S. Dunne says, but I can assure the Deputy that I am able to read and listen to my elders and as such I have got a clear picture of what happened when I was not around to see what was happening.
Comment on this
It has also been said that the organisation of the Party is at a low ebb. I do not agree at all. There is no evidence to indicate that our Party is at a low ebb despite the measures introduced in this Budget or despite the setback we suffered in the referendum. There is no evidence that our organisation will not be in a position to function. If the Opposition believe that we will not be in a position to take them on in the next general election they are entitled to that belief. We on this side of the House have no doubt that during the campaign for the next general election——
Comment on this
I agree that this is probably not in order but I had to say it.
Comment on this
I have a coherent train of thought. I was pleased when the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries said, in reply to a question, that the estimated total increase for the creamery milk cheque this year— for 1968 over 1967 — was £4 million. This is a good thing and a clear indication that the farming community are doing well.
Comment on this
I am sorry for the Deputy; I do not think his mathematics are all they should be. However, we will have a chance of discussing this when the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture and Fisheries is introduced. I shall conclude as the Deputy will not allow me to continue.
Comment on this
This Budget has one outstanding feature in that it is one of which the Government have no reason to be proud. It is a Budget which has the distinction of being the Budget that proposes to impose on the people of this country, the taxpayers, the greatest increase in taxation that has ever been imposed since the Oireachtas was established. I hope to show on a critical examination of these provisions that what they propose is largely, if not entirely, unnecessary. Certainly if the situation that confronts the country at the moment, economical or financial, required certain remedial measures to be taken the results desired could be achieved at lar less cost to the taxpayer and considerably less damage to the economic structure of the State.
Before I go into that examination I should like to direct attention, in order to get a proper explanation from the Taoiseach, to something which I regard as a breach of parliamentary convention, a gross disregard of parliamentary convention and propriety which has been recognised in all Parties since the establishment of the State. The Taoiseach in the early part of his introduction to this Budget referred to the increase in milk prices which the Government propose to allow to the milk producing farmers. He said that the proposals that were envisaged called for a further £625,000 this year and £1.65 million in a full year, in other words he indicated that part of the taxation proposals of this Budget were to raise taxation for the remainder of this year to the extent of £625,000 and in a full year £1.65 million. He then blandly referred to the fact that the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries had announced that the day before.
This is the first time that a Budget secret was announced not merely by a Minister but by anybody before it was announced in this House. The House is entitled to get from the Taoiseach some explanation as to why the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries took it upon himself—if he did take it upon himself and if he did not why did he get authority—to make that announcement in advance of the Budget. This is knowledge that should have been given to Members of this House first. It is the first time that this has happened. No explanation has been given and we are entitled to an explanation, all the more because of the fact that the Minister having announced it before the Budget subjected Deputies to irrelevant verbosities amounting almost to three hours talk last Thursday here in this House. He occupied the House for nearly three hours with what really amounted to a filibuster. One would have thought that, having broken the conventions of this House, he would have been satisfied. At all events we are entitled to get an explanation from the Taoiseach. This has always been a convention that has been very strictly adhered to and rigidly enforced. People have been accused at times of letting out secrets a few minutes before they should have been announced. I see no reason why the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries should be given the permission that apparently he was given on this occasion.
The Taoiseach, as acting Minister for Finance, when he was introducing these Budget proposals in his peroration said that the Government were confident that the House and the people would realise that the proposals were intended and needed to safeguard our economic position. I assert that the people do not take that view at all. I also say, and I hope to prove before I sit down, that the proposals are not, whatever their intention may be, designed to safeguard the economic position of the country at the present time.
The last speaker, Deputy Collins, seemed to take a certain amount of pride in the knowledge that these proposals were going to get the Government some sort of unpopularity. They are going to get plenty of it. The kind of unpopularity they are going to get and the reasons for it were aptly and adequately stated by and on behalf of the Irish Housewives' Association when they made a statement which was published in the Evening Herald of last Wednesday. I quote:
Shock and horror was the reaction of members of the Irish Housewives' Association to the increases in the recent Supplementary Budget, according to a statement issued by the association.
Members, the statement said, could not understand how the Government could call for restraint in wage claims to 5 per cent while increasing postage rates by 20 per cent and public telephone calls by an "iniquitious 50 per cent".
The statement also criticises the wholesale tax because it "hits hardest at fixed income groups and lower paid workers, while doing little to curb the spending of the really affluent sectors".
That summarises the popular reaction to this Budget and if Deputy Collins and his friends in the Government take some pleasure in the fact—a sadistic pleasure I suggest—that they are going to be unpopular as a result of this Budget, then their satisfaction will be met to the full.
The policy underlying this Budget is one of diminishing incomes and thereby diminishing purchasing power and, as a necessary consequence, puts certain sections of the community in jeopardy of their jobs. This Budget is belated in its introduction and its real effect is intended, and obviously intended, to be prospective in its operation. It is done deliberately to get comparatively little money in the remainder of this year and to get a very substantial amount of money in the course of the next financial year. I shall have occasion to deal with this aspect of the case later in more detail.
The outstanding criticism of this Budget appears to me to be its timing. The timing is very significant. We waited until November to bring in this additional Budget and it is now clear that only one-quarter of the produce of this taxation can be obtained in the remaining months of the financial year. We can only get, I think, £4.2 million in the remainder of this year, although, according to the Taoiseach, in a full financial year the produce of taxation will amount to £15.4 million. It is obvious that this is done deliberately in order to gain the advantage of this additional taxation next year to the political advantage of the present Government. That is the position— £15.4 million to be obtained by this taxation in a full year but only £4.2 million to be got in this year. The Taoiseach in his introductory statement appears to found—although curiously enough he does not go into any very great detail in connection with the matter—his case on the paper which he refers to at column 2053 of the Official Report, No. 12, Volume 236. I quote:
A paper recently published by the Economic and Social Research Institute foreshadowed the possibility of a deficit of over £50 million in 1969 unless policy measures were taken to prevent it.
The House is entitled to expect and have their expectation realised that the Taoiseach should have gone a little bit further into the detail in that paper justifying the proposals which he referred to and on which he appears to found the case that he makes here for those drastic and very onerous proposals in this Budget. At all events we can all agree that this Economic and Social Research Institute from which this paper emanated is doing excellent work and first class research for the benefit of this country. We are entitled to look at this paper, examine it, and see what is proposed in it. We are entitled to ask why the Taoiseach did not refer to it at all and never mentioned in the whole course of his speech the proposals and recommendations made in that paper to deal with the situation created by the possibility, if not the probability, according to the author of the paper, Mr. T. J. Baker, of a deficit in the balance of payments amounting to £50 million and upwards next year. The Taoiseach did not agree with that estimate of £50 million. He said, and I think the majority of economists would agree with him, that £50 million is too pessimistic and that £30 million is what he accepts. However, taking that £30 million which the Taoiseach accepts and examining what the author of this paper, the distinguished economist, has to say in reference to his proposals for dealing with the situation that would be created if there was a £50 million deficit in the balance of payments next year, it is worthwhile reading for the benefit of the House some of these proposals. The House can consider how far the Government have approached in the proper way the problem they say they are faced with and to what extent they have really come to understand that problem. I think the House will conclude that what they have really done is to misunderstand the problem and recommend the wrong remedies.
This is a paper from the Economic and Social Research Institute by Mr. T. J. Baker published in September last. It is relevant to note the date but there is internal evidence which I should point out to the House that this paper was written long before September and that the contents of the paper were in the hands of the Government and certainly within the purview of the Department of Finance long before September and, at the very latest, in August.
One distinguished representative of the Department of Finance is mentioned by name in a note underneath the contents at the beginning of this paper where it is stated that helpful criticism was received from him and others. The House may take it that in considering the timing of these proposals the Government, and certainly the Department of Finance, had ample notice long before September and certainly long before the present time, of the problems that were likely to face the country in the immediate future but they waited until November. The House is entitled to an explanation as to why they did wait having regard to the fact that they had the notice of this particular paper and the warnings that were in it at the very latest in August and, I am sure, long before that.
The Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries wasted the time of the House last Wednesday night talking almost without stop, demonstrating how he could not know what was going to happen with the milk-producing farmers and the wheat-growing farmers and, therefore, he could do nothing before this. They knew the problem and it was not a problem of milk or wheat but a problem of a £50 million balance of trade deficit anticipated in the year 1969. That is the problem they have to meet at present. That is the problem, according to the Taoiseach in introducing this Budget as Acting Minister for Finance.
I want to refer Deputies to the very first page of this paper where the author states the problem and suggests what is to be done and also to subsequent pages. In the last paragraph on the first page he says:
Thus the time appears ripe for the responsible authorities to decide whether they can tolerate the probability of a large deficit on the Balance of Payments in the coming year. If they decide they cannot, then some modest action very soon to lessen the rate of growth of private consumption and of total building would appear appropriate. Slowing down the boom now should avoid the need to halt it altogether later. The possibility of taking appropriate action is not, of course, confined to public authorities.
I emphasise, and endeavoured to emphasise it in reading, this passage from the paper where he, first of all, refers to the decision being in the hands of the responsible authority, namely the Government, and then states what they have to decide, whether they can tolerate a large deficit in the balance of payments for the coming year; if they decide they cannot, as they have now by their action in bringing in this Budget decided, all that is required, according to this distinguished economist, is modest or moderating action. You will find afterwards he called it moderate action. That is what this man says is required to deal with what he says will be a £50 million deficit in the balance of payments but which the Taoiseach says will be only £30 million. Can anybody say the action taken in this Budget we are discussing can be regarded as moderate action—this Budget that imposes the greatest amount of taxation imposed by any Budget in the last 50 years since the State was established? Can that be regarded as modest action when it is described by people who are going to feel its full effects as producing reactions of shock and horror? It is certainly not modest action and I think it will be found by the time we are finished with this debate that it is not appropriate action.
He said that £5 million possibly or probably would be the deficit on the balance of payments and that modest action must be taken soon. We did not take action soon; we waited until midNovember until this kind of action was taken and that is not taking the action the man who drew the attention of the Government to the problem recommends should be adopted.
I turn now to page 23 of this publication and again he has some very significant recommendations to make which have not been adopted. Having analysed the position of certain imports and the balance of payments deficit he deals on page 23 in paragraph 3.14 with "Policy Implications" and says:
If the foregoing analysis is accepted, the decision as to whether or not to initiate changes in the policy of demand management depends on the relative weight attached to different policy objectives.
It may be felt that in the light of the present state of the external reserves, and the possibility of an increase in the long term capital inflow as private investment grows and corporate profits improve, the likelihood of a very substantial current account deficit is a worthwhile price to pay for rapid economic growth and a substantial increase in nonagricultural employment. If this view is taken, no action is necessary at the present time, and the period of high deficit can be endured in the hope that exports will subsequently resume a more rapid rate of growth.
This means that this economist dealing with the problem and analysing it says it was within the competence and reasonable discretion of the Government to decide what to do, that they could take the view that even if there was this £50 million deficit in the balance of payments that he says is likely to arise it would be open to them to say, having regard to certain matters which he refers to and to which I shall refer in a few moments, that it would be a worthwhile price to pay for rapid economic growth and a substantial increase in nonagricultural employment. The Taoiseach has not dealt with that. What is his answer to that? Why did he not accept that it would be a worthwhile price to pay for an increase in nonagricultural employment and rapid economic growth, that you could put up with the position and endure it having regard to our external reserves and the growth in the economy at present?
He goes on to give the alternatives —put up with the £50 million deficit; we are well able to stand it having regard to the economic position. You could take that decision if you liked. He does not say it is a wrong view to take. He says you can take it.
Then he goes on to say:
On the other hand it may be considered that the probability of a deficit in the region of £50 million, with the possibility that it could be even worse, cannot be regarded with equanimity.
That is the view that the Taoiseach has taken, as acting Minister for Finance. The writer goes on to say:
In this case it is almost certainly better that some moderate action be taken now——
I emphasise that he had spoken in the beginning of his paper of modest action. He said some moderate action should be taken now and he goes on:
——to curb the rate of expansion, particularly with regard to private consumption and building activity, rather than delay until the middle of 1969 when much more drastic steps might have to be taken. If it is decided to restrain the growth of demand, action to moderate the apparent rapid increase in private credit, particularly consumer credit, would appear to be the most sensible first step. If, through such measures as mild hire purchase controls and Central Bank advice to the Associated Banks, the rate of growth of consumer credit were held to half that assumed in the projection for 1969, it seems likely that the result would be a rise in current price Gross National Product of around 8 per cent rather than 10 per cent, a growth rate of perhaps just under 4 per cent rather than just over, a slower rise in prices, and a balance of payments deficit of around £30 million rather than £50 million. On this calculation quite modest action, taken soon, would suffice to keep the situation well under control.
He goes on to say at page 24:
The decision remains one for the responsible authorities, and according to the relative importance attached to the growth rate, employment, internal prices and the state of the reserves, a plausible case could be made for either taking action or not. One warning however bears repetition. If it is decided that a large deficit is not tolerable, but nevertheless to wait until overwhelming evidence is available before taking any action, the correct moment for that action will almost certainly be past.
That can be summarised by saying that it was open to the Government, having regard to the warnings they have received that there is a possible or a probable deficit of £30 million—if the Taoiseach does not accept £50 million — to take either no action, relying on the reserves and the state of the economy, or to take certain mild, modest action which will not disrupt the economy in the way proposed in this.
All this talk from the Government to the effect that they do not mind being unpopular, that they are the great fellows doing their duty, is all nonsense. There is no necessity to do what they are doing here. The writer of this paper says that the decision remains one for the responsible authorities. However, we are told here by the Taoiseach, and I presume by others, that if this action is not taken the economy will be disrupted and we will face a threat of inflation. This man says it is not so. The facts show it is not so. It can be demonstrated, from what I have just said, that there was no necessity whatsoever for the introduction of this drastic Budget and for the outrageous impositions that it is proposed to place on the taxpayers of this country.
What is the position? It is a remarkable fact that, in addition to allowing the Constitutional convention or political convention to be overridden by the Minister, he does not carry on the tradition that we established in this House, that is, that the Budget was regarded as an instrument of economic policy and should be shown to be such, and that each Budget should give a resumé of the financial and economic position of the country and the policies that were available to deal with the situation.
The speech made by the Taoiseach, as acting Minister for Finance, gives no indication of the Budget being used as an instrument of economic policy. He says, however, at the beginning of his speech that Ireland has had two excellent years and that increased industrial production has made a big contribution to the national progress. He says, and I quote:
The volume of output of transportable goods industries rose by nine per cent in 1967 and even faster in the first half of 1968. Activity in building and construction has been much greater in both years, while agricultural output, which had fallen between 1964 and 1966, rose by two per cent in 1967 and should show a similar increase this year. An important factor in the increase in national output has been the vigorous expansion of exports.
This is all he says about the bright side of the economy. He gives a few outstanding features of the bright side of the economy at the present time. There is no doubt that there have been indications this year of expansion in the economy and improvement in the financial structure of the State. We have been coming out of the inflation of the past two years. We have been overcoming the incompetence of the Government in handling the financial situation and the country has been showing signs of getting back on its feet again. The remedy that is proposed by the Government is to bring forward the proposals which, I believe, will affect and disrupt the economy and slow down the progress that, no doubt, has started to be made. These proposals, therefore, are entirely unnecessary and certainly ineffectual. The Taoiseach, in introducing this Budget, does not show both sides. He says:
There are clear indications that the economy is gathering speed too quickly at present and that if the brake were not applied we would run into trouble in 1969.
As with driving, it is bad to apply the brakes too quickly and too forcibly and that is what is being done at the present time. The vehicle which is carrying the Government is, according to the Taoiseach, gathering speed too quickly. It is being renovated and repaired for the past few years, is being run-in, is showing some signs of improvement and of being able to do its job. That is not a vehicle to which the brake should be applied quickly or forcibly — certainly not to the extent that is being done at the moment.
Let us look at what the final effect of this Budget is. The Taoiseach says that there will be a deficit of £15 million this year, notwithstanding the huge amount of money which will be gathered in from the taxpayer as a result of the April Budget of this year. He then says that as a result of this Budget there will be a collection of taxes for the remaining portion of the financial year amounting to £4.2 million, and in a full year that £15.4 million will be produced from all the taxes including, apparently, the Post Office charges. Therefore, when you add the additional taxes imposed by the previous Budget of £3.5 million plus the £15.4 million and the £3.5 million additional taxation you have the position that the Government next year, when they face the Budget in April or May, will have £22 million in hand before they impose one penny taxation. Yet the Taoiseach says that they estimated in the April Budget for a buoyancy of revenue of £24 million but it is apparent now that they are going to have an increase of £7½ million in that buoyancy so that they will have an unexpected bonus of £31.5 million next year. You will have the £22 million that will be available as a result of this Budget, without an increase of one penny in taxation next year, available to the Minister for Finance to hand out benefits in the light of a general election if it is forthcoming. Is there any doubt, therefore, that the inescapable conclusion of all this is that this Budget has been brought in belatedly not to do what, in fact, it is not doing, meet a problem created by a possible increase in the balance of payments deficit, but for the purpose of putting themselves in a position next year where they will have something like £40 million available to distribute in benefits by way of political expediency to meet a possible general election shortly after the Budget? Is it not an inescapable fact that they are doing that?
The Taoiseach gives five items of additional expenditure in his speech, education, the farmers, milk, and so on, and, of course, the inevitable slap at salaries, all amounting to, and quite rightly, £27 million, but for all that expenditure which he says faces them next year he has about £40 million in hand before he starts to impose one penny taxation to deal with that situation of £27 million additional expenditure and also a large amount to hand out by way of benefits to all and sundry, for political purposes.
That is one aspect of this Budget. The other aspect, perhaps, is to be looked at in a more economic way and certainly in a way devoid of political overtones. I have already emphasised the position as stated by the learned author of this paper from the Economic and Social Research Institute where he said a modest action, or no action at all, if you like, will serve the position sufficiently to enable us to do nothing in order to overcome the possible balance of £50 million. He says £50 million while the Taoiseach says £30 million. He says to do nothing because the position is sufficiently strong to entitle us to do nothing. Some of the items dealing with the strength of the position will corroborate the suggestion made by this economist.
We have in the statistical supplement of the Quarterly Bulletin of the Central Bank of Ireland at Table 7 the figures for our external monetary reserves and it appears from the second column of that table that in September, 1967 the gold reserves were £7.8 million while in December of that year the figure was £8 million. What were they in September of this year? From September, 1967 to September, 1968 the gold reserve rose from £7.8 million to £32.2 million, four times what they were in September 1967. Therefore, the gold reserves have quadrupled in 12 months but nothing was said by the Taoiseach about that. That is one of the matters which you are entitled to take into account in assessing the problem and seeing how you can solve it. Taking all our reserves together, our total external monetary reserves in September, 1967 amounted to £292.2 million while in September of this year they amounted to £295.5 million. In 12 months there has been an increase of £3 million in our external reserves. On top of that the capital inflow has shown a tendency to increase, and, indeed, not merely a tendency but an actual increase.
Taking all together, the substantial amount of gold reserves, our external reserves, and our capital inflow, they all show that the country is doing well and would continue to do well if it was allowed to. We have nearly £300 million external reserves or, in other words, we have 20 times the amount in reserves of our deficit on the Budget which was anticipated for this financial year and we have ten times in reserves the amount of the adverse balance which the Taoiseach put at £30 million. What are reserves for if they are not to meet a situation of that kind? As I say, we have ten times the amount of reserves necessary to meet the situation at the present time and according to Mr. Baker the Government would be quite justified in taking no action and could say: "We will not disrupt the economy any more but give it a chance to get better as it seems to be doing at present." That is what they could have done if they wished to do nothing. We have those reserves and, as I said, what is the use of having reserves if you cannot use them. But what did they proceed to do? They proceeded to increase taxation to the extent of £15.4 million in a full year, to get something like over £11 million from the general taxation, on spirits, tobacco and wholesale tax, and to get in the remainder of the year £400,000 from the post office charges and £1.6 million, I think it will be, in a full year. These are the kind of charges that are being imposed in this Budget.
Take this case of tobacco. We are all familiar with the phrase about the "traditional method of raising revenue by means of increased taxation on tobacco, beer and whiskey". I would remind the Minister for Finance, the Taoiseach and the Government in general that the tobacco people were induced to set up business here because of tariffs imposed by a Fianna Fáil Government from 1932 onwards. These tobacco manufacturers set up their organisations and put themselves in a position in which they had to face, and have to face, all sorts of competition. They give excellent employment to a considerable number of people.
Over the years they have been made the butt of the Minister for Finance. In every Budget the tax on cigarettes and tobacco is increased, thereby making it even more difficult for these people to carry on business, to make ends meet and go on giving good employment. Because of increased taxation the jobs of those employed are jeopardised. In addition, life is made a little less comfortable for those who are addicted to smoking. Added to all that is the fact that these tobacco manufacturers are now being "hung" in the interests of public health. They will not be allowed to advertise on television or radio. Other steps have been taken to which I cannot refer, unfortunately, since I am professionally interested, steps of a kind of which the Government should be ashamed. The Government are "hanging" these people, the people who were induced to establish themselves here at the behest of the Fianna Fáil Government. It is time these people got some sort of letup.
Beer and spirits carry increased taxes. We have here one of the best manufacturers and employers in the world. I refer to Messrs Guinness. They are doing tremendous good for the country, not merely from the employment point of view but also from the point of view of the cultural, scientific and economic advancement of the country.
What about the manufacturers of whiskey? They are paying a huge amount in taxation. Their product is native to the country. They have been endeavouring to build up an export trade in the United States and elsewhere in the teeth of fierce competition from Scotch whiskey. Instead of helping our whiskey distillers to meet on some terms the proprietors of Scotch whisky our Government hinders the efforts of our distillers by increasing the tax on the product they manufacture. Not until quite recently did Irish whiskey succeed in finding a footing in the United States. Indeed, it was Deputy Norton, Minister for Industry and Commerce in that much maligned, as Fianna Fáil are pleased to call it, Coalition Government, who gave Irish whiskey distillers a chance for the first time of exporting this product. These are the commodities the Fianna Fáil Government tax in every Budget they introduce and additional taxation increases tremendously the difficulties of the distillers in finding and keeping an export market.
We have then the wholesale tax. That was devised by the Government, in their wisdom, and they netted a vast sum of money out of it at the expense of the consumers of ordinary commodities. It is proposed now to double that tax by imposing an additional 5 per cent. There was a pamphlet circulated to Deputies recently dealing with the added value tax. That pamphlet was distributed on behalf of the Minister for Finance. I refer, in particular, to the last sentence of paragraph 13 on page 35:
If food, drink, medicines, clothing, fuel, tobacco, petrol and oil continue to be excluded from the wholesale tax a tax of about 15 per cent should have theoretically produced £25 million——
This is what I want to emphasise—
but a sudden increase to such a high rate might lead to a fall in sales with serious results for business and employment.
It is not 15 per cent. It is 10 per cent, very near the amount which, according to the Minister, might lead to "a fall in sales with serious results for business and employment". What are they doing here in the teeth of their own advice in this document? They have doubled the wholesale tax, with the inevitable result of a fall in sales because of increased prices and ultimate unemployment. That is what the added value tax would have done. That is what this increased wholesale tax will do.
Post Office charges have been increased. Additional revenue to the extent of £400,000 in the remainder of this year and £1.6 million in a full year will be collected as a result of these increased charges. The excuse is the old cliché to which we have listened so often here; the Department of Posts and Telegraphs must be run on business lines as a commercial undertaking; it must pay its way and the taxpayer must not be called upon to discharge any deficit in Post Office revenue. That is the alleged principle of operation. The Taoiseach referred to the fact that there had been no increases in these charges since 1964.
I want to direct the attention of Deputies to what happened in 1964 when charges were increased. We on this side of the House objected to the increases and I put the case that, if these increased charges were being justified on the basis that the Post Office must be run as a commercial concern and in accordance with commercial principles, Deputies were entitled to be assured and given conclusive evidence of the fact that the Post Office was being run as a commercial undertaking would be run and that all possible economies were effected. The Taoiseach, now Deputy Lemass, made his usual flat-footed observation — not merely flat-footed, indeed, but as windy as most of the expressions he habitually used—and said at column 1781 of volume 208 of the Official Report of 15th April, 1964:
The principle that the Post Office should pay for itself and not be subsidised from taxation is not merely sound but, as far as I know, has never heretofore been questioned in the Dáil.
I emphasise the following:
There is, I agree, an obligation on the Government to ensure that the cost of these services is not unduly inflated and the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs is now about to initiate a drive for economies in the Post Office by the adjustment of the services to the reasonable needs of the people and by changes in procedures which will, it is hoped, increase individual productivity.
Following that speech, I made a speech in which I took him up on those matters. I asked why, if the Minister was about to do all those things that day, that Wednesday, had he not done them before. I asked was he really going to do them at all. From that day to this, Deputies have not heard a word about what the Minister was to do —"to initiate a drive for economies in the Post Office by the adjustment of the services to the reasonable needs of the people and by changes in procedures which will, it is hoped, increase individual productivity."
Four years afterwards we are asked to agree to an increase in Post Office charges without any indication that one single thing was done by the then Minister, or his successor, to carry out what the windy Taoiseach said was going to be done that day. We have not heard a single word about whether he did it or not, whether he drove or did not drive, or whether he did nothing which he always does. Now we are asked to agree to an increase in the Post Office charges without any indication that the undertaking of the then Taoiseach has been carried out. I think the House should very seriously consider the position before they do anything of the sort.
In introducing these proposals the Taoiseach said his object was twofold — I am summarising what he said—and that he had to decrease consuming power and encourage savings. At the end of his statement we had the gloomy announcement that there had been a considerable drop in savings. I want to say with all the emphasis at my command that this Government did more than any other Government to prevent people saving. What is the use in giving an increase of half per cent? The Taoiseach said that in order to meet the economic difficulties that still exist they must take the purchasing power out of the hands of the community and get people to save. How they will do that I do not know. How will you encourage people to save when that is the only incentive given in this Budget which apparently will make the Government unpopular and, at the same time, bring disruption and possibly dislocation to the economy?
As reported at column 2059, volume 236 of the Official Report the Taoiseach said:
The intake from small savings has been disappointing for some time. In the current year so far there has been a net outflow of £1.6 million from the Savings Banks. This is a disimprovement of £4.7 million as compared with the corresponding period last year.
That shows a very serious falling-off in savings. Everyone, every economist, every Government, insists that one essential way to build up the economy, and to provide the means whereby the Government can carry on, and whereby there can be expenditure in the interests of the country and people can be saved from increased taxation, is by increased savings. The incentive here is that they decided to increase the rate of interest by half per cent. You could get over seven per cent in a building society, or 7½ per cent in a national loan, but for the Savings Banks the incentive is an increase of half per cent. That may be justifiable having regard to the history of the Post Office Savings Banks. You get a small amount of interest because you are entitled to withdraw your money fairly quickly.
What I object to is that the entire policy of the Government over the past ten or 15 years has been directed, not by accident or mistake but by design, in such a way as to discourage anyone from saving. I have spoken again and again in this House about the plight of people who are self employed. They have to do the best they can by saving over the years to put aside a certain amount of money for their old age, or for their wives and families if anything happens to them. Very frequently when people save it is not for themselves in their old age but their families, but the Government take most of their savings from them. Their policy has brought about a depreciation in the value of money. It has fallen catastrophically in the past ten years or so. If you insure your life you pay a big premium and when the policy matures it has depreciated in value as a result of Government policy, and they then proceed to take a big lump by way of death duties. That is also done by deliberate design.
I think it was in the Budget of 1965 that the Government increased the period during which you would be entitled to transfer certain savings to your wife or children from three years to five years. That was done deliberately in the Finance Act. People asked — and I asked it myself —"What is the use in saving? Why keep it up when the Government will take a big lump at the end in death duties?" I want to insist very strongly on this: unless the Government give an incentive — and not this half per cent which is ludicrous and laughable — by way of relief of income tax, or preferably by way of death duties relief, and people who save, provided they can be established as savings out of earnings during the years, will be entitled to pass their savings over within a year or so at the outside to their wives and children and will not be charged death duties, there will not be savings.
This provision of five years was put in deliberately by the Government at the instance of the Revenue Commissioners. I think it was in the same Budget that the development tax was brought in by the then Minister for Finance who is now the Taoiseach. That development tax had to be repealed this year by his successor, in the Finance (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act, 1968. It was bad and it was proved to be bad. The Minister had to humiliate his predecessor, not to talk of himself, by repealing an entire section of the Finance Act, 1965, which had been recommended to the then Minister by the Revenue Commissioners, and accepted by the Department of Finance without any critical examination. At that time we exposed it in this House and we were laughed at, but subsequently it had to be repealed.
There will be no savings unless there are some incentives. The Savings Committee have done very good work. They deserve the thanks of the public for their efforts but they were up against the impossible almost. People asked: "What is the use in saving because when I die the Government will take one-third and sometimes onehalf of it?" Until that is got rid of there will be no incentives to save, and the Minister for Finance in Budget after Budget will have to report, as the Taoiseach had to report this year, an almost catastrophic drop in savings. That is bad for the country. It is bad for the economy and it is still worse for the individual outlook of people as to whether they should or should not save or spend. It is a matter that requires the greatest consideration from the Government at the present time. As on this question of saving, their attitude on death duties is entirely incorrect. I have listened or heard or read speech after speech on the subject by the Deputies of Fianna Fáil who have spoken on this. There is not a speech made on this or any other relevant matter that does not draw down the abuse they would like to hurl at the Coalition Government. It is no part of my job or duty nor do I intend to occupy the time of the House in going over the record of the Coalition Government. I am proud of its achievements. I am conscious of the lies told by some of the Members now occupying ministerial positions in the Government. During the general election that led to their subsequent occupation they told lie after lie. They told the people of this country the Coalition Government was responsible for the Suez Canal crisis and the petrol position. They persuaded the people by their false propaganda. I would not like to sit here having spoken for only two or three minutes on it.
Any prosperity this country has at the present time can be traced back to the policy initiated for the first time by the inter-Party Government of 1948 and particularly the policies of the former Deputy McGilligan. He established the principle of capital Budgets, the principle of spending by the Government for productive capital purposes, of capital expenditure that had been unknown at the time the Fianna Fáil Party had been in office. They are now talking about it as if they themselves thought about it. We started the export board. It is now called Coras Tráchtála. It was we who gave the incentives for exports which were the foundation of the export trade now in existence without which it would not have been in existence. That is something to be proud of. We never get anything but lies from the Fianna Fáil Party. We do not expect anything else. I am saying this to have it put on the record. We gave them the incentives at that time which laid the foundation of our export trade and if we had not done that at that time Fianna Fáil would not have done it ever and we would have one-quarter of the trade we now have. We have ample export trade. We gave them the incentives and we gave them the markets.
We established the Industrial Development Authority. I want to say to the Fianna Fáil Deputies who cast aspersions on our work that we established the Industrial Development Authority and Deputy Lemass gave a solid undertaking when that Act was being passed that when they would get into office they would repeal that Act and dismiss the people we had appointed. I had the utmost difficulty in persuading the people we intended to appoint that he dare not do that and that constitutionally he could not do it even if he tried. In spite of that threat we set up the Industrial Development Authority and it has been a source, a tremendous source of good to the people and to industry. Deputy Lemass did not change it despite the fact that he gave a public undertaking. He did not do so.
Deputy Collins speaking this afternoon about our record referred to the fact that Deputy Lemass, frequently quoted in this House, acknowledged, when they resumed office after the last inter-Party Government in 1957, that there was no housing problem in the city of Dublin. Deputy Collins tried to say there was no housing problem because there were no people. There was no housing problem because I had to go on the radio and ask our people who had gone abroad to England— tradesmen and skilled labourers—to come back and that we would guarantee them ten years work. We got houses built. We have a record of housing that can bear any scrutiny or any lies on the part of Fianna Fáil.
I could tell how we made the Fianna Fáil Party give the old age pensioners 2s 6d, which they had refused. With the widows and orphans it was the same record. Our record is there to be seen. I was compelled to make these remarks. I did it merely for the purpose of at least bringing some sort of charity into this House in connection with this matter and letting the young people know that what is now being falsely said is quite incapable of being substantiated. In my view this Budget will have the effect of disrupting the economy of the country and bringing about a serious financial situation. It is wholly unnecessary. It is utterly wrong. It may be that there is a case to be made for something to be done. This is not the way to do it. We only come, as I said before, to the inescapable conclusion that they are adopting this device of a prospective Budget to get £11.4 million next year or whatever the amount is in order that, adding that to the amount already imposed by the April Budget of this year and anticipated increases in revenue, they will have about £40 million available to discharge £27 million which the Taoiseach said we will have to pay, and he will have a large amount of money to buy himself votes in the next election.
Comment on this
It is a pleasure to listen to what I regard as a brilliant analysis of this Budget delivered by Deputy Costello. There is no doubt it is only just to have it put on the record. This House does not at the moment have as many Deputies as one would imagine we should have. It is on the record and we hope people will be afforded an opportunity of reading the records of this House. I feel it was a brilliant analysis of the Budget, showing to the people exactly what has happened in a very clear and distinct way. I personally believe while this Budget has been described as a miniBudget it is just an expression anyone could use. In fact, it is a Budget of great magnitude. It is a Budget that could be described as a vicious retaliation on the part of Fianna Fáil on the people because of the way in which they misbehaved in the eyes of Fianna Fáil at the referendum. Fianna Fáil have a record of doing this. They have a knack of being vicious and calculating. They have a knack of coming up with Budgets at opportune times, Budgets away from elections, Budgets on the edge of elections. In this particular Budget they are repeating their previous behaviour and hoping that the Budget's vicious aspects will be forgotten by the people when they come before them. Another Budget and then a general election — but times have changed and the last people to realise this are the Fianna Fáil Party, which the referendum proved. It is not only that the Government are out of touch with the Party but they were found to be out of touch with the people. This Budget is another audacious move far removed from the people's needs and far removed from their desires.
Every single Department in the Government stands accused in regard to the situation that confronts this part of our country. The Department of Local Government have failed to provide adequate housing for the people. The Minister for Labour seems to have forgotten that for quite a number of years we had serious objectives in regard to full employment. This Budget is being introduced at a time when there are more unemployed than there were last year. The Department of Industry and Commerce has failed to control prices. The marvellous system that is in existence—and I do not say this in any sarcastic way—for getting information in this House has brought forward very useful information in regard to the cost of living. If we consider the answers to the questions that were put in connection with price increases we can see how these things have contributed to making the working man's burden greater, apart from the levies that are proposed in this Budget. I shall not delay the House in adverting to the absence of care on the part of the Department of Industry and Commerce in ensuring that money given by way of grants is not squandered and not given out to flyby-nights.
The Department of Social Welfare also finds itself on trial because of the paltry benefits provided. The increases boasted about by the Fianna Fáil Government are still insufficient and do not compare favourably with benefits in other parts of Europe, never mind outside of Europe. Fianna Fáil show their concern for the old age pensioner by putting 4d on cigarettes as against the imposition on hard plug tobacco. Suffice it to say in that connection that 25 cigarettes more or less equate to an ounce of tobacco. We know what the effect will be on the unfortunate users of hard plug tobacco. Who are these people? They are amongst the lowest paid workers: agricultural workers, county council workers, forestry workers, hospital workers; and the old age pensioner— all people on the lowest rung of the ladder. These are the people about whose needs Fianna Fáil profess to be concerned.
The Department of Health stands accused because of the shameful service that continues in existence. There is no indication in this Budget of any serious attempt being made to modernise our health services. The promises have been made, but they remain to be fulfilled.
The Department of External Affairs must cost this country a lot of money, particularly in regard to the movements of the Minister. While he very well knows the national and natural desires of our people, he has ceased for a long time to talk about the issue of civil rights which is now so prominently before us.
We have had an abundance of promises in relation to education. There was a demonstration outside this House today in this connection. More and more people are becoming alive to the need for further opportunity for all types of people to be afforded education. A very significant thing struck me about this demonstration this afternoon, that the people concerned made their protest and came right up to the gates. Not so very long ago organised workers found themselves in difficulty; they were not let next or near the gates and when they picketed outside they were arrested. We can only conclude that this is an indication of Fianna Fáil on the run. In saying what I have said, I am not objecting in any way to people demonstrating, but it is a bit late for the Fianna Fáil Government to realise that there is such a thing as the right to demonstrate. What the people want now from the Government is action. Certainly, if one is to reflect on the activities of every Department in the Government and the behaviour of the Taoiseach as against that of the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, we can only conclude that the Government are in disarray, that they are merely clinging on because of the promises they have made, not to the ordinary voter, but to the people who entrenched them in office.
The Minister for Transport and Power is a very lone gentleman who spends most of his time pontificating as to how things should and should not be done in this economy. He is the person who purports to know all the answers. Within the last few weeks, apart from other occasions, he has proved himself to be absolutely out of touch with what is going on within the confines of his Department. He had not got a single clue about what was happening in the B & I. He knew less about the deal that was being conducted between Ryans and Aer Lingus. This is the man who talks down to the workers and tells them: "You should be careful or you will bring about a situation that will not be good for the nation."
This is the same gentleman who is responsible for the Department of Posts and Telegraphs. Deputy Costello mentioned the Post Office charges already, £400,000 for the remainder of this year and £1.6 million for next year. We have the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, Deputy Erskine Childers, who behaves like a Jekyll and Hyde, telling working-class people to behave, to be careful of the nation's economy, who blandly refuses to afford the workingman an opportunity of really saving and benefiting from the saving and continues to refuse to introduce the Giro system, although it has been repeatedly advocated by representatives of the working classes.
Another thing which I think is a disgrace is this increase of 2d on each public telephone call. I defy contradiction when I say that in budgeting for an increase in telephone calls and all the other provisions to meet the commitments, an increase of 1d per public telephone call would have sufficed. But it would have cost too much to adjust the public telephones to take up to 5d and it was simpler to use the "tanner". This is another way of codding the people. This shows conclusively the sincerity, or supposed sincerity, of this man, the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs-cum-Minister for Transport and Power. If it costs too much to adjust public telephones to accommodate a 1d increase and provision is made to increase the charge by 2d because the coin boxes can take sixpences, what will the situation be when we change over to decimal currency? We have heard nothing about this. This will involve further expense. The only conclusion I can come to in that regard is that a big "fiddle" has been perpetrated on people who can ill afford it because, in the main, the public telephone boxes are used by people who cannot afford to have private telephones.
Something which often surprises me in connection with budgetary provisions is that there is no indication given as to how, in fact, they will operate or what control will be exercised to ensure that this is all the increase there is. For instance, take the price of the pint. It has happened in the past, and I have no reason to believe that it will not continue in the future, that it is left entirely to the publican to determine now much he will put on the half-pint. In most pubs in Dublin now the price of a half-pint is nearly two-thirds of the price of the pint. This is an example of the Fianna Fáil Government seeing fit to leave things in the air.
As Deputy Costello has said, this constant attack on drink and tobacco can be overdone. It is easy to say that but, at the same time, it would appear that the Government have decided for some time to ignore the effect of increases in the price of drink, cigarettes and such commodities, on the tourist industry. If the Minister for Transport and Power were "with it" and were in sufficient contact with Bord Fáilte they could give him facts and figures that would show clearly and distinctly that the price of cigarettes and drink is used by many tourist countries for the purpose of attracting tourists. We are at a stage where we describe our tourist industry as being the second largest industry in the country, and some people are inclined to believe that this industry is as big as the agricultural industry. In my view, the care that is being taken in this matter is not sufficient.
The wholesale tax has been doubled. That could be described as a hidden tax because the man-in-the-street knows more about turnover tax that he does about wholesale tax. However, he will very soon awaken to reality when he finds that the wholesale tax has been doubled. It is another indication of Fianna Fáil's attitude towards the people and their contact with the needs of the people.
This knowing Minister for Transport and Power and Minister for Posts and Telegraphs talks down to the workingclass people whenever he can get the opportunity and requires them to make sacrifices. If we are going through bad times, surely it is not impossible to ask these patriotic Taca boys or those who have been canvassed to subscribe, outside the Fianna Fáil Party or any Party, to make sacrifices? An increase in the price of cigarettes, spirits and even of the pint will mean nothing so far as most employers are concerned but it certainly will hit the working man.
If the Government are serious about what is likely to happen, if they know how to take stock, if they do not continue to be unmindful of what is happening around them, the obvious thing for them to do is to get out as fast as they can because this is what all sections of our people are crying out for. The Government stand accused. The people are absolutely dissatisfied as a result of what the Government have continued to attempt to put over on them. The people will not forget this so-called mini-Budget. The memory of this Budget cannot be cast aside by another Budget introduced on the eve of a general election. We are dealing now with a different type of person in this country. We are dealing with people who have forgotten the wrangling that went on in the past. We are dealing with people who can judge matters in the same way as people outside Ireland can judge matters. Our people are not going to tolerate this solidifying in place and place-hunting. They will take steps at the first available opportunity to ensure that the nation gets a proper Government and that, when sacrifices need to be made, they will be properly apportioned.
In conclusion, I want to say that during the course of this debate it was alleged that some people had been making quite a considerable amount of money by various means. This is a fear which has been expressed throughout the country. It should be investigated because perhaps they are the people who should be highly taxed to raise the amount of money being sought in this Budget.
Comment on this
The last sentence of the speech of Deputy Mullen typifies the attitude Opposition Deputies have been adopting during this debate. They have been speaking in vague generalities to cast aspersions on members of Fianna Fáil. Indeed, it was typical of the example set by Deputy Dillon last week— his undisciplined arrogant attitude towards various Ministers. That was one of the most irresponsible outbursts I have heard since I came into the House. One would have thought that, with all his years in politics, Deputy Dillon would have tried to engender a sense of order, a sense of decorum and courtesy in political debate and commentary. He told us he had been weaned and reared in the political tradition.
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon was guilty of a distasteful and arrogant outburst. Coyly and piously he told us that he was nurtured and reared in the political tradition. If that is Deputy Dillon's idea of a responsible political tradition, I certainly do not want any of it. The truth of his claim, the veracity of what he claimed to be in true political tradition, can be gauged from the contents of his statement. He was churlish, offensive and denigrating in every possible way. He does little to elevate the role of politics and the function of politics in this country. It is not Deputy Dillon's first time in the House to adopt the role of the political gargoyle, giving us his political obscenities and vulgarities, deliberately setting out to sneer at and to slander Ministers who have made fine contributions to the welfare of the country.
The whole kernel of Deputy Dillon's outburst lies in his jealousy of the achievements of those Ministers, of their being encompassed by a fortress of integrity and genuine achievement. In this way, Deputy Dillon thinks he can penetrate this fortress; but the Irish people are intelligent enough to bear with Deputy Dillon in his outbursts and in his crying for the lost years. None of us, in Cork, particularly, will ever forget his political outbursts of foolishness and ineptitude in connection with the setting up of the Verolme dockyard in Cork. On that occasion, we were given in the House a lecture on the imagined piracy and lawlessness on the high seas being carried on by the Verolme directors and by Fianna Fáil Ministers. At that time the Deputy deliberately set out to attack, malign and pillory an industry that has brought tremendous employment to Cork. On that occasion the people of Cork, in their charity, granted Deputy Dillon a fool's pardon; but they did not forget to mete out punishment when they returned Deputy French here, another Fianna Fáil Deputy for Cork.
If that is what Deputy Dillon means by being reared in a political tradition, he is welcome to this type of political tradition. It took his colleague, Deputy M.P. Murphy wrom west Cork, to challenge him to substantiate his allegations, to get positive proof of the allegations he had levelled against Fianna Fáil Ministers. If one does not accept the situation that proof is necessary or that proof can be given, then Deputy Dillon's arguments fall and are condemned as a piece of nefarious political buffoonery. Certainly, Deputy Dillon has done nothing to elevate the tone of the debates or of the House.
Comment on this
You are very fit for that. One cannot leave this matter without referring to the attempted character assassination by Deputy Lindsay, the supposed shadow Minister for Education. We have come to expect this type of attack from a politician of Deputy Lindsay's calibre. He has endeavoured to turn this House into a veritable Vulcan's stithy.
Comment on this
The Deputy got plenty of opportunities to throw political dirt during last week but when contradictions come back from this side which might not suit their colours——
Comment on this
Deputy Crowley will appreciate that we are discussing the Budget and that the matters for discussion are taxation, expenditure and financial policy. Anything else is irrelevant.
Comment on this
I would agree completely, but having listened to some of the debate last week I imagined that everything was being discussed but the Financial Resolutions. However, I bow to your ruling. You are perfectly right that only the Financial Resolutions should be discussed.
Deputy Costello spoke about the wonderful years of Coalition Government. He said they had done a great job and, between "hear, hears" from his Front Bench, he referred to savings. Does he realise that savings during the period 1954 to 1957 made up seven per cent as an expression of gross national product and that now they make up 12 per cent? Is that an achievement for Deputy Costello to be proud of and to boast of? Does he remember that when he was Taoiseach in a Coalition Government there was a growth rate of a half per cent by comparison with three and three-quarter per cent now? Is that something the coalition can be proud of?
During his period in office, exports went down at a rate of £2 million per year and they are now increasing— they have been since 1957 — at the rate of £16 million per annum. When Deputy Costello spoke about the achievements of the coalition he should have explained the facts, which completely contradict any claims Deputy Costello made for the performance of coalition Governments. During their period there was a capital outflow of £1 million per annum as against an average inflow since 1957 of £21 million per year.
That is an achievement of which any Government can be proud. Listening to Deputy Costello, one did not know which side he was on. One moment he was talking about the inefficiency of the handling of the finances of the nation over the past two years and the next minute he was talking about the tremendous buoyancy of £31½ million. Surely you cannot have it both ways?
Comment on this
You were Fine Gael that time. Deputy J.A. Costello was always on the one side, from the foundation of the State. He stood by law and order.
Comment on this
The Deputies know very well that I never had anything to do with their miserly Party.
Comment on this
I think Deputy L'Estrange will find it difficult to keep quiet. He was under orders a few weeks ago to keep his mouth shut. It did not last long. I do not know who ordered him but certainly one or other of his leaders ordered him to keep quiet.
Deputy J.A. Costello spoke about cigarette manufacturers and the whiskey industry and the tremendous effect this tax will have on export. He talked about taxation being put on the whiskey industry and preventing that industry from entry into any sort of export trade. Surely this taxation has nothing to do with exporting? Of course, it has not.
Comment on this
No amount of character assassination will bring about the fall of this Fianna Fáil Government. We are asking the people who are making these allegations to substantiate them. To give Deputy L'Estrange his due he apologised last week——
Comment on this
It is there that the man got the cheques. What I said is on the record of the House. It came up in the courts.
Comment on this
Will Deputy L'Estrange let Deputy Crowley continue his speech? These are disorderly interruptions.
Comment on this
Can you prove what you said in the Dáil? When you were asked to say it to the courts you had not the proof.
Comment on this
It is on the records that Kelly got £1,000. They are post-dated cheques. He took an action. If the Government have an inquiry they know too well that too much will come out.
Comment on this
If Deputy L'Estrange refuses to obey the Chair I will ask him to leave the House. The matter is totally irrelevant and does not arise on the Financial Motions.
Comment on this
The Deputy came in here to make these allegations and he is doing his job of character assassination.
Comment on this
You should repeat your allegations outside the House and not abuse the privileges of the House.
Comment on this
Getting back to the Financial Resolutions the measure of the understanding of the Opposition about our external assets position is borne out by the fact that under a coalition our external assets were allowed to go down from £241 million to £183 million by the end of 1956.
Comment on this
There were plenty of houses and at this time the external assets of £183 million handed to us in 1957 now stand at £295.5 million, and Deputy J.A. Costello said that we should use them. We know the use to which the coalition put these external assets. We know of their importance and value more than the coalition knew. They could not get credit from any financial institution and that was because they let their external assets run down at a rate which alarmed these financial institutions who considered them a bad risk and unworthy of any credit.
Comment on this
That is bunkum. The only time the county councils could not get credit was when you could not give them the money.
Comment on this
Deputy J.A. Costello said that we should "blow" our external assets. He talked about our gold reserves at £9 million last year gone up to £12 million. He talked about the whole of our external assets going up to £295.5 million. Of course they have gone up because we have a thrifty, efficient and professional Government managing the country. This does not happen by accident or by waving a magic wand, as Fine Gael think.
Comment on this
Deputy L'Estrange knows as well as I do that the referendum was a completely different issue. It was a national issue. We are now talking politics and in the next 12 months we will know who is right or wrong.
Comment on this
There will be a few people ruffled in Longford and Westmeath. I do not think it is any wonder the Opposition feel grieved and peeved. Those are statements coming from people who should know better about external assets and about our trading interests in general. The other allegation talked about was that the budgetary proposals of last April were dishonestly conceived and deliberately fabricated to suit the political climate in order to win the referendum and that the Government deliberately misread the economic barometer to seek short-term political gains. The Opposition must have a "cow radar system" of some description. Apparently, they were able to foretell that 50 million more gallons of milk will be produced in the 1968 milking season over that produced in 1967. Of course, the gift of hindsight is a great gift and one which Fine Gael have in abundance. They have so many legal men in their Front Bench that they were able to twist what they said four or five months ago to suit the figures and make them out as projections.
Comment on this
Yes, a man we are proud of. The Government instead of employing a lot of statisticians and economists will use the Fine Gael "cow radar system" which is able to foretell the future. All this chicanery and talk cannot take away from this fact. It is a fact that the farmer, especially the dairy farmer, has had good increases this year. He has had good increases——
Comment on this
——not only because of the foresight of the Government in pouring money into his coffers but also because of the aids given to him to make himself more efficient and more productive on his land.
Comment on this
If one member of your Party had his way we would have nothing but 300 and 400 acre cow-farms left and I would say we would have a few more people leaving the land then. Of course, it is convenient to forget this sort of statement at times like this, is it not, Deputy L'Estrange?
Comment on this
The farmers are alive to the motives and political knavery that make Fine Gael and Labour men make this sort of statement. The essential fact is that £4 million extra is needed for milk on this occasion and £1½ million extra because of the bumper return we had in wheat. These are some of the reasons why it was necessary to introduce a Budget at this stage. These are the facts that the Deputies on the opposite side cannot fight shy of and cannot run away from. They can give all sorts of other reasons but the fact is that because of increased production, because of increased yields, the Government found it necessary to impose extra taxation in order to finance the farmers. When you deduct the cost of production and overheads from the figure of £6 million that is being given to the farmers you will find that there is a net increase of nearly £2.5 million already gone to milk suppliers this year. On top of that £2.5 million you have the extra penny a gallon which the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries gave a few weeks ago.
The Opposition, I know, do not like to be reminded of those hard economic facts. They like to go around preaching gloom and doom, that the farmers never had it so bad but in actual fact they know and we know and everybody knows that they never had it so good. There are certain sections of the farming community that we would like to see doing better and all the powers and all the energies of this Government will be devoted to ensuring that everybody in the farming community has an adequate living, for example, by putting an industry near him so that he can subsidise his income from farming with a job in industry.
Comment on this
Not as many as went in your day when we had the greatest spate of emigration since the time of the Famine.
Comment on this
1,225,000 since you came to power. There will soon be as many Irish in England as at home.
Comment on this
Of course, the Government's record in the field of social legislation is very much envied by the Opposition Parties. As everybody knows, every bit of social welfare legislation has been introduced under a Fianna Fáil Government. The question now is not will we get something but now much will we get? We are very conscious of the needs of older people and the IRA veterans and we gave them free electricity and free transport.
I am glad that the Minister for Education is here because I have one plea to make and it has to do with a section of our community that deserves our sympathy and assistance. We have some excellent young people who take courses at night in universities and in various other institutions in order to further their education and employment opportunities. I would ask the Minister if he could intervene with the Minister for Finance to alleviate in some way the tax burden on these people. They are doing a productive and a good job for themselves and ultimately for the country and they deserve some consideration by way of tax relief. Every encouragement should be given to encourage young people like this because they can positively contribute to the nation's wealth in the future.
Comment on this
If you saw them outside the gate today it is a little more education some of them want.
Comment on this
Yes, but you know they would not be outside the gate if this Government in their wisdom did not see fit to give grants to those who had four honours in their leaving certificate this year. The Minister for Education is very well aware of the problems of the people involved in education. He is also trying to solve these problems and trying to alleviate hardship where he sees it. We took we step in the right direction when we gave free university scholarships to those with four honours. I can see a time in the future when that standard may be lowered but the mere fact that there were so many out there this afternoon is indicative of the trend of thinking in Fianna Fáil. We want as many people as possible to go to university and we do not want the poorer people kept out of universities. For that reason you have so many going to university and so much agitation because people see that these are opportunities for, perhaps, getting a bit more and you cannot blame people for trying. I promised that I would not be very long. I am sorry I upset Deputy L'Estrange.
Comment on this
It does not do his constitution any good. In regard to the taxes we know that these are unpopular measures but we know also that these are necessary measures and because they are necessary we have imposed them. The Fianna Fáil Government have always taken the long-term interest rather than the short-term in imposing taxes because we know that ultimately the beneficiaries are the Irish people themselves.