We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 37—Agriculture (Resumed).

Contributions 112–233 of 233. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Notably by Deputy L'Estrange.

Comment on this

You were caught canvassing for Colley and Lynch.

Comment on this

You had not the guts to go outside the House and repeat the allegations.

Comment on this

You came up to join Fine Gael at the time of the election and would not be taken into it and I met you outside the door with Dinny O'Sullivan.

Comment on this

These are more of your character assassinations.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Will Deputies desist from interrupting? Deputy Dowling is in possession, on agriculture.

Comment on this

He is looking for the job of Parliamentary Secretary.

Comment on this

Deputy L'Estrange is put in here to mouth these obscenities and there is no better man.

Comment on this

You were suckled on them. That is why you are so stout.

Comment on this

You should be ashamed of yourself.

Comment on this

Thanks be to God, everything I say is the truth. The Government that stoops to it should be ashamed of itself. They should allow it to be investigated.

Comment on this

Repeat the allegations outside the House.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Dowling.

Comment on this

Like many other Deputies I feel it is time that this row, as it has been called, between the NFA and others should come to an end and that the farming community should come together and, in the interests of the housewives, present a comprehensive and balanced policy to the Government so that it can be examined in great detail. It is regrettable that the farming organisations have not met the situation up to now by presenting a unified approach to this problem. As a housewives' representative in the city and as a workers' representative, I would urge them to see that the interests of the farming communities and of the nation, which includes the housewives of the country, receive the consideration to which they are entitled. In this may well lie the key to the prosperity both of the housewives and of the farming community. It is regrettable that the dispute has been so prolonged. Again, it is outside my scope but, nevertheless, I feel that the fault does not lie with the Minister, the Government or the Taoiseach. A unity of purpose is required such as we feel is required in everyday life in relation to long-term planning. In any sphere it is necessary that a comprehensive picture be presented so that one can see into the future in depth and in that way meet many of the problems and examine them on a long-term basis rather than a very short-term basis just to satisfy some particular groups.

Unification at this stage is absolutely essential. The longer the rift continues the more difficult it will be to reach a solution and the more people will be disappointed and hurt in the process. It is in the interests of the nation that there should be fresh thinking on the part of the farming organisations and when they do submit a comprehensive scheme no doubt it will receive the consideration of our very worthy and courageous Minister. Some of the accusations that have been hurled across the floor from time to time by Front Bench members of the Fine Gael Party at very competent and capable Ministers, especially at the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, are very regrettable and hurtful. This, of course, is not a new tactic; it is one of the tactics employed by character assassins in order to discredit honourable men and to colour the picture which they want to present to their flagging organisation in an effort to stimulate interest. It is well known that when there is a collapse within the Fine Gael Party they are pushed into this type of disruptive action which has recently been a feature of this House.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Will the Deputy come back to the Estimate?

Comment on this

I am just defending the Minister because it grieves me to see an honourable man treated in the manner in which he has been treated on this Estimate and on other occasions.

Comment on this

The Deputy is not outside Lecken Church now.

Comment on this

I dealt with the situation there and I will be outside many another church gate. The Deputy knows I was very effective on that occasion.

Comment on this

No doubt.

Comment on this

I should like now to deal with the question of exports. We are aware of the wonderful efforts being made to export many of our commodities in recent times and the attention that has been given to the export of agricultural produce by the Minister and by the Government. Deputy Foley mentioned that the export of live animals and of carcase beef was very satisfactory in 1967. In that year 620,000 stores were exported to Britain and the Six Counties. This shows the efforts made to increase exports and to ensure that cattle and beef, whether in dressed or in carcase form, will be exported in greater quantities to Britain or to the United States.

I hope that this very valuable market in the United States will be further explored as well as markets elsewhere in order to ensure that exports in the years to come will be increased and that we will have the necessary return to ensure the nation's progress. It is interesting to note the development that has taken place in regard to the US market to which exports of boneless beef were valued at £12 million. This is a market which should receive additional consideration on a sort of crash programme basis so that we can be well prepared for a long term market for whatever we have available.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy is only talking this out until the Minister can get in. It is a wanton waste of the time of the House.

Comment on this

It is important that the people should know what is being done and not be misled by the misrepresentations which we have heard in this House over the last few months. We are aware of the confusion which exists in the minds of Fine Gael Deputies and, indeed, Labour Deputies. We heard Deputy Coughlan lecturing us tonight in great detail. Indeed, it would be interesting to know when he is lecturing again because I should like to hear his intelligent approach to agricultural problems, an approach worthy of consideration even by Dublin Opinion. He dealt with the pig industry and bacon production and this is an item about which I should like to say a few words. It is like the production of the cutlets and steaks about which I have spoken and which cost the housewife so much. We should look at the route that these commodities take in going from the producer to the consumer, so that the situation which has developed over the years can be corrected, the situation which has caused the housewife of this city to pay so much for her rashers and bacon and even her Christmas ham. The housewife and the worker of the city who pays income tax on earnings over £6 5s or, if he is married, on earnings over £294, should get consideration. These are the people who pay for the fertilisers that are used.

Comment on this

Do they use them in Dublin?

Comment on this

We do. We pay through the nose for anything we get in Dublin. It is easy for the country Deputy to sit back and laugh, but it is no laughing matter to the housewife in the city.

Comment on this

If the farmers down the country heard the Deputy talking about agriculture they would laugh.

Comment on this

The ground limestone, the fertilisers, land reclamation, byre grants, all these are paid for out of taxation by the woman who has to buy the end product at a very high cost.

Comment on this

Has anybody a brief for the Deputy?

Comment on this

I have enough material to go on for a month, but as my time is limited I want to give the Minister the benefit of my assessment of the situation in great detail and great depth. I shall not deal with it in the depth with which Deputy O'Donnell dealt with it earlier on today, but there are important aspects of agriculture on which the people's views must be conveyed to the Minister.

Comment on this

He would not know much about it himself. I know what the Deputy means.

Comment on this

I am sure the Minister, when he is replying, will deal with some of the problems which affect housewives and disturb city dwellers who feel they are being fleeced and that the subsidies are paid at random without any great consideration just because of pressure by particular groups or individuals. I am not greatly concerned about subsidies, because I know that if the middleman, or, as I said, the fiddleman was eliminated the housewife would have the benefit of lower prices for these essential commodities. While she has to pay high prices, the children or other members of the family will have to do with smaller portions than they would otherwise get.

Coming back to Deputy McLaughlin and his bob a dozen eggs, I should like to have the name and address of the producer, so that we can arrange to have him called upon and in that way assist some of our housewives. As I said earlier on, when I was a little boy I always understood it was only the goose that laid the golden egg; now I am sure it is the hens because, judging by the price, the hens are on the gold standard along with the middlemen.

Comment on this

They used to throw eggs that time, now it is tomatoes.

Comment on this

This is Fianna Fáil agriculture we are having.

Comment on this

Tomato growing is a very important section of the horticultural industry. Irish tomatoes are probably the best tomatoes in the world. I prefer them to imported tomatoes and use them whenever it is possible to get them. They are better value, and we should impress upon our people the necessity of producing more of them. Like the cheese, if they are presented properly and at a reasonable price there will be a better do both for the producer and the consumer. I was down in Galway last August on my holidays and I noted the glasshouse scheme there. I realised that, while this is a great scheme, there were a number of problems. I saw some idle glasshouses, and since the State invested some money in them, I thought the problem was worthy of examination.

Comment on this

The Deputy ought to hurry up or he will not have an opportunity of going into it in detail.

Comment on this

I am not going into it in detail. I made some inquiries on my tour of the West on that occasion, and on my return I conveyed the problems to the proper authorities. I felt that in some way I had probably assisted in bringing to light some of the difficulties which affected production and caused these enterprises to go into decay. I know now there is no necessity for this. I know the problems and the defects in part of the system, and I am quite sure these will be rectified in due course.

Comment on this
Neil T.C. Blaney Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries (Mr. Blaney) Fianna Fáil

First of all, I should like to let the House know that their criticism of my absence from the House today was totally misplaced, in that my absence was due to prior commitments to do with matters which appertained to the agricultural community and could not be put off. While I should like to have been here for the entire debate, I think the work I was doing this evening, that is, meeting the committee of the General Council of Committees of Agriculture prior to their annual meeting tomorrow, was important. I met their executives this afternoon. I spent more than three hours with them and I am sure Deputies will agree that this was time well spent, even though it did mean that I was not able to be here for a considerable portion of this debate. Earlier today, too, we had a Government meeting and there was a responsibility on me as a member of the Government to attend that meeting. I wish to apologise to the House for my absence but, at the same time, I wish to point out that my absence in no way reflected on the House. I hope Deputies will understand that this was not of my making and that I regret more than they do that I could not be here.

Comment on this

Why could the debate not have been held over until tomorrow?

Comment on this

The Deputy had a right to be here yesterday.

Comment on this

If the Deputy had been attending the House in the way that every conscientious Deputy should, he would know that it was agreed by all Parties to finish tonight. I have no control over the regulations of the House. As I indicated three or four weeks ago, it was my wish to have been present for this debate but various other business has seen to it that this did not happen and, therefore, I had no choice in the matter. As I have said, the timing of the Dáil arrangements and my prior commitments in relation to agricultural matters in meeting representatives of the farming community of the entire country forced me to be absent during the debate.

The contributions I have heard from the chief spokesmen of the Opposition Parties were anything but critical of the Department, the Government, the Minister or of agricultural policy and out-turn. My sympathy is with these men because of the fact that agricultural policy is going extremely well at the moment. My sympathy is with those on the front bench of the Opposition Party, particularly the chief spokesman for the Fine Gael Party who had to refer back this Estimate and to try in some way to justify his Party's original dissatisfaction with the Estimate and all that goes with it.

Having listened to all of that Deputy's contribution, which was of some length, I came away with the feeling that he had little real criticism to offer. The putting down of a motion to refer back this Estimate is a most perplexing sort of situation for the main Opposition Party to find themselves in and I have sympathy for the man in trying to make a case where he knew there was no case to be made.

In the following contributions, of which I had quite a considerable note taken, I can see little of any worth to comment on so far as criticism is concerned. Therefore, for the next hour or so, the proceedings may tend to be more boring than would be my natural bent. This is not of my making but rather of the Opposition's making in not contributing anything worth while to talk about.

Comment on this

The Minister should have listened to what has been said.

Comment on this

What is the Deputy talking about? He should not be getting upset, but he should go home to where he was yesterday and have a rest.

Comment on this

The Minister was not here to know what was said this morning.

Comment on this
Lionel Booth Acting Chairman (Mr. Booth) Fianna Fáil

We cannot have this debate across the House at this stage. The Minister is concluding.

Comment on this

Deputy Murphy, I believe, had little to say, took a long time to say it and made a hell of a noise.

Comment on this

He did not take as long as Deputy Dowling.

Comment on this

He had not much to criticise, so he made the best of a bad job. As I said, I have nothing of real interest to comment on because there was nothing of any interest contributed to the debate. Deputy Murphy and others would, I am sure, like to have made some big case about agriculture; but he is at a loss because of the really satisfactory situation in which agriculture now is and due to the two very good years that agriculture has had, which, by some strange coincidence, came about with my advent to agriculture. Of course, that is supposed to have nothing to do with agriculture's well-being, but would have had all to do with it if it was not going well.

It is unfortunate for the Opposition that they have no case to make. However, I shall have to take all the little points that were raised and try to make the best of them. Deputy O'Donnell spoke about panic concerning surplus milk and said that our dairy products are at premium prices on the export market. I say to Deputy O'Donnell and to the House that we are not panicking but, having said that, I depart from the Deputy thereafter in so far as marketing is concerned. This situation in marketing has been brought about through no fault of our own but has been brought about entirely through the dumping of dairy products by much better off countries and by more highly industrialised countries than our own, in particular by some of the Common Market countries who are practically giving dairy produce away at present. We have to compete in this sort of situation. As I have said, there is no cause for panic but we would be less than realistic if we did not take recognisance of the realities of life. We must realise that butter is being offered and sold at prices in the region of £100 a ton— butter that is perhaps costing £700 or £750 a ton to produce. That sort of situation exists and it will not disappear overnight. Regardless of what steps may be taken, a surplus of milk may build up. There is an over-supply at the moment.

Comment on this

Stocks of milk powder in Europe have already disappeared and the price has recovered.

Comment on this

The Deputy should remember that I did not say there were any signs of panic with regard to milk powder. But I suppose it would have been only natural if I had been inclined to panic when I was told that milk producers in some parts of the country were pouring skim milk down the drain. It is a shameful situation if a product as valuable as skim milk, which can, if fed to pigs in the right proportions, mean sixpence or 6½d a gallon to the farmer concerned, can be poured down a drain. Apart from the damage that this would do to the fish, any farmer who can afford to do this should take a good look at himself and begin to ask himself if this is what the taxpayers of the country are paying for.

Comment on this

The farmers had no way of anticipating this situation.

Comment on this

The fact remains that there are people in this country who are prepared to pour skim milk down a drain. It seems very strange that something was not done with this buildup of skim milk other than pouring it down a drain. If people take this madness into their heads it is a strange comment and a poor recompense to the taxpayer who is willingly contributing towards the support of this very important industry. Whatever little experience there may have been last year of difficult conditions in the disposal of skimmed milk, I would hope it will have taught some farmers that they have in their own farmyards a more remunerative market than any at their disposal in recent years and one that cannot be taken from them overnight. I hope there will be a real effort by farmers' co-operatives and others to avail of the exceedingly attractive pigfattening grants scheme which I announced a considerable time ago and which, so far, has evoked about only seven genuine applications. We badly need that attractive scheme in order to produce more pigs for an industry that can use them and that has a market for more than we are now producing and that, in turn, can utilise the skimmed milk in conjunction with one of their milk-processing plants. The difficulty at this stage in regard to the disposal of these particular dairy products, and the ups and downs of the international market to which we are very much exposed, should ensure that, to the highest degree possible, we make use of native outlets for the by-products of the dairying industry.

Pig-fattening is an outlet that should commend itself in this case not only to the co-operative enterprise but to the smaller farmers and the smaller farm members around that co-op. to go into the breeding of pigs to supply the central stations, to their own profit and to the general profit of all the people in that area. I hope the lessons are being taken and that the new attractive grants scheme, together with a guaranteed loan available from the Agricultural Credit Corporation, will be followed up and that a real effort will be made to get more pigs reared, fattened or turned into bacon or exported for pork, for which there is also an additional market, rather than screaming our heads off about "giveaway prices" which we were doing some months ago. Then, when the scare got really going, we found that the skimmed milk powder was not as plentiful as appeared for the reason that many farmers in milk-processing countries had found another way of converting their skimmed milk rather than, as heretofore, dumping it without thought into powder plants which had resulted in overflooding the markets to the detriment of all. Deputy O'Donnell also said that the price of creamery milk was down because of the increased cost of the levy——

Comment on this

I said it was one of three reasons for the reduction in price the creamery milk suppliers received this year as compared with last year. The other two reasons are that the creameries were unable to take all the skimmed milk and thus the price of skimmed milk was down and, thirdly, increased costs.

Comment on this

That does not take in the slightest from what I was about to say. There are so many variations for various causes from one year to another as between herd owner and herd owner and herd and herd that this can happen regardless of price levels and price fluctuations. There was clear agreement that, in the disposal of our dairy products, any loss accruing in foreign markets would be made up as to onethird by way of levy paid by the milk producers themselves which would be matched as to two-thirds of the loss by the Exchequer. For every £1 that comes by way of levy, the Government contribute £2 to help Bord Bainne to dispose of these various products.

In fairness, that cost should not be used to justify an increase unless the farmers no longer want that sort of operation and no longer want Bord Bainne because, without the function of raising the levy—which the Board does, not the Government—there is little point in Bord Bainne's existence. The board would really be superfluous if this vital job of calculating the levy and asking for it from the producers and the Government were taken from them. Producers should realise that, if there are bad years and good years on the selling market, then there does arise a cost factor by way of a loss which implies a levy. They should take into account that, already, other people are committed to two-thirds of that loss in addition to all the millions already put into the creamery business in order to support the price being paid to the producers.

Let us examine the fluctuations in the price of milk. There are always exceptions which will prove the rule or disprove the rule. This year, our dairy people produced 520 million gallons of milk as against 470 million gallons last year which, itself, was a record. On the best calculations I can find, only 26,000 additional cows went into the herds during the past year and contributed to the total of 520 million gallons of milk this year. If we take the national average yield, it will clearly be seen that the output from the same number of herds in 1968, which produced 470 million gallons in 1967, produced an increase of well over 30,000,000 gallons this year. In other words, the same number of cows, possibly owned by the same herd owners, gave 30,000,000 gallons more of milk this year as compared with last year. I am setting aside the 15,000,000 gallons the 26,000 additional cows would have produced. Surely a Deputy who understands milk, and all that goes with it, must appreciate that 30,000,000 gallons additional milk multiplied by the price people would have got for it represents, in fact, a very substantial increase in the incomes of these farmers this year as against last year? Even if there is set against it some of the costs that have begun to arise this year, remember these costs are not all applicable over the entire area of milk production because some of them did not come in until well through the season. The levy did not come in until the month of July and this, in addition to the penny on the first 7,000 gallons from 1st September directed in a special way towards the smaller producers, and the increased yield of well over 30,000,000 gallons, has done fairly by these people in the dairying industry and there is no depth of propaganda that can get away from these facts, facts staring everybody in the face. The sooner people give up this propaganda, which cannot be sustained by facts and figures, the sooner we will get some sanity into all walks of life where people are seeking more money for whatever their particular line of production may be. The total out-turn was a record in itself.

I do not agree at all that this forms a basis to justify the argument that creamery milk prices are down. This kind of thing cannot stand up for one moment. The argument has no legs— good, bad or indifferent—and the sooner the people over there get wise to themselves the better it will be. The sooner they deal with the factual situation the more appreciated they will become. Let us look for a moment at the penny increase, the penny which has been sneered at, and realise that this penny is costing the taxpayers approximately £1.7 million in a full 12 months. Mark you, the day we reach the point at which the dairy industry, or any other arm of our agricultural economy, can sneer at a £1.7 million increase in agricultural income we will certainly be going places because £1.7 million is a fair few quid. Even if you subdivide it and say it represents only £3, £4, £5, £6 or even £29 or £30, remembering that the yield has gone up from the same number of cows, due to the good weather and due, undoubtedly, to the influence of a good Fianna Fáil Government, it still represents good money and no one can laugh it away. No one can make it disappear by false propaganda, propaganda of the type indulged in since the cows began to milk last spring.

Comment on this

Would the Minister mention the £1½ million he is saving on the heifer subsidy scheme?

Comment on this

The Fine Gael Party are like the fairies or, as we call them, "the wee folk"; they are trying to milk the cows before ever they get into the byres at all, but they will not succeed because these cows gave well over an additional 30,000,000 gallons this year and that is a big increase. Added to that is the fact that in the 12 months starting last September there will be £1.7 million more given by the Government from the Exchequer in particular recognition of the needs of the smaller milk producer. This incidentally establishes for the first time a true differential in price support. This is a policy decision by the Government. It is an indication to the bigger producers that this is the pattern that will be followed in the future. We will no longer have the basis of support fought for on the costs of the small producer and then given without question to every producer, regardless of size, efficiency or profitability. The sooner the big producers realise this is the pattern, the sooner they will get wise to the fact that going into milk on a huge scale is not our policy. We will not continue to pour money into the production of milk on a large scale to the detriment of the taxpayers or to the detriment of the small producer. Four-fifths of all milk producers are small. Four out of every five are under 7,000 gallons. It is to these we are now determined to provide in an increasing way the assistance which has been given over the years, assistance to the tune of £26 million this year. It is to these small producers we are now committed. We are not penalising the big milk producers. We are merely warning them in a very definite way and, at the same time, saying to them that they should get into beef. They can make it profitable. Instead of giving them 1/- a gallon, as we are doing at the moment, for sending their milk to the creamery we will give them £8 for every cow and calf; that is the equivalent of giving them 4d a gallon to keep their milk at home. We want to reserve in a very special way the milk market that is there for the four-fifths of the milk producers whose livelihood is derived entirely from the production of milk. Many of these have been producing milk for generations. We want to reserve that market to them and we are going to concentrate the taxpayers' support more and more in their favour because they cannot go into beef and make a living out of it, whereas the big man can. This is the trend and I hope it will be recognised and understood by those who can profitably engage on a large scale in beef production. Perhaps, they will take warning and leave the restricted market to the smaller producer for whom this is the only worthwhile farming enterprise in which he can profitably engage.

Comment on this

Will the Minister say what he will do with the liquid milk producer?

Comment on this

I will. As I said in reply to a question a week or so ago, I have the matter under examination and, in my examination, I am taking into account a full review of the situation as it now is in regard to liquid milk production in the two broad areas. I am examining very seriously the possibility of discontinuing the entire milk price allowance now paid on surplus derived from that area. This surplus should carry itself within the trade in the liquid milk areas, and not be a burden on the taxpayer as it is now. Likewise it should not be an encouragement to the over-production of milk in those areas to the detriment of the ordinary creamery milk suppliers to whose problems it has added. It costs about £700,000 to the Exchequer and is a levy of approximately £200,000 on the creamery milk producers.

As I say, we are examining this whole problem at the moment, and wondering whether this business of supplying the needs of the cities in question, Cork and Dublin, should not revert to its original position wherein the liquid trade catered for itself and was not supported out of public funds. As I say, it is costing £700,000 in subsidies, and it is costing the creamery milk producers almost £200,000. This matter is being considered and we must seriously consider unloading this burden which is now being carried by the creamery milk producers and the taxpayers. It should be capable of being carried by the trade itself. They should regulate their supplies to their needs rather than allowing their production to reach the point where six million gallons more are being produced than are needed in the Dublin area. This could in the normal way be manufactured by our processors in other parts of the country. All these matters are being taken into consideration and whether there will be a complete change I cannot say at the moment.

Comment on this

The Minister's approach indicates a reduction in price.

Comment on this

Not necessarily. This extra six million gallons could be absorbed in so far as disposal was concerned by the milk boards in question. If there were a little surplus it should be capable of being covered and carried within the liquid milk trade instead of by the taxpayers and the creamery milk suppliers in increased levies. That is now being done and it may amount to £200,000 this year.

Comment on this

It is a reduction to the producer.

Comment on this

I cannot see where else it will be carried.

Comment on this

If the Deputy cannot see I will not tell him. It does not mean a reduction to the producer. It would be a reduction to the taxpayer and would probably be an increase of £200,000 to the overall creamery milk suppliers who would have to pay that much less by the off-levy.

We also have the question of wheat. I believe Deputy Murphy was very good on wheat. At an earlier stage this evening he was very critical of the outcome of the wheat harvest.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

I am not sure whether he was critical because there was a good harvest or because the yield was too big, or whether it was because there was no real row about the handling of the enormous crop of wheat this year. I do not know why he is displeased. No one is displeased this year.

Comment on this

They are displeased about next year and the Minister's arrangement for next year.

Comment on this

There is one thing which farmers really appreciate and that is that you do not worry about next year because it may never happen.

Comment on this

Some things are inevitable.

Comment on this

Perhaps he is hoping it will happen in a disastrous way which is what the Deputy implies so I will say again: "Do not worry; it may never happen". This is purely the Fine Gael pessimistic outlook which they display in the best of times. If things are not good they are crying that they will be worse, and if things are good they are crying that they cannot last. They should not overworry because it may never happen. We are not worried about next year's wheat. I am looking forward to next year's wheat being a good crop again.

Comment on this

Ten shillings a barrel down.

Comment on this

This year on a crop of approximately 220,000 acres we got a return for the farmers of over £12 million——

Comment on this

He got it for himself.

Comment on this

——in that he got away with £1½ million which, according to his own representatives back in 1958, he should have paid by way of levy rather than the taxpayers carrying that along with the rest. This year the levy was not capable of being operated but the principle was there that it should be paid. The system proposed was not capable of being calculated until too late. Next year if there is a good crop and a big return of millable wheat there will be a levy. I will ask Deputy Clinton a question. Which would he rather have—a year in which he gets no millable wheat through and pays no levy, or a year in which he has a phenomenal yield of millable wheat and takes a cut of 10/- in order to spread the loss incurred by overproduction? Which of the two is better?

Comment on this

There never would be a year in which there was no millable wheat. That is an imaginary year.

Comment on this

Listen to the figures. Last year we grew almost 220,000 acres and we produced 385,000 tons of wheat, paid for at millable prices. Some years ago we grew 420,000 acres and got 25,000 tons of millable wheat. Which of the two years would the Deputy choose if he had the choice of paying the levy this year or having no levy to pay three years ago when he got 25,000 tons only out of 420,000 acres?

Comment on this

The Minister has a great imagination.

Comment on this

It is clear that a good year even with the levy would be far more profitable and attractive to the farmer than the disastrous year such as I have indicated and which happened not so long ago. There is no comparison between the profitability of the two. In fact, there was no profit in the year when 420,000 acres produced only 25,000 tons of millable wheat, but there would have been a huge profit this year even if there had been a deduction of 10/-.

Comment on this

Would it not take one to balance the other?

Comment on this

Will anyone say that £10½ million for 220,000 acres of wheat grown this year does not show a good return and a handsome profit. Some of the people who talk for farmers and would like to tell you about the small farmers and how badly off they are this year have themselves drawn over £30,000 under this very good guarantee system that we have. Do you think those people would not have gladly paid a levy rather than have unmillable prices paid for that if it was a bad year? There just is not any comparison and Deputy Clinton well knows it. We are not putting this levy into operation until after the event and only if there is a surplus of millable wheat produced. Then, and only then, will one penny be supplied and if none is needed the entire residue, the entire balance, goes back and the farmers will not have lost one halfpenny on the transaction.

Comment on this

How long will you hold their money free of interest?

Comment on this

I remember a time, Deputy, when there was no money of theirs to hold and if Fine Gael had their way there would still be none to hold because they would have none and the question of tests, acreages, millability, potential or otherwise, would not arise. This is the simplified policy of Fine Gael in regard to this and many other matters. If it causes any sort of bother at all, do not have it. This is the way Fine Gael think, but it is not our way of doing business. We are merely applying the levy as agreed by the farmers' representatives, in fact proposed by the farmers' representatives, back in 1958, incorporated in the 1958 Cereal Act and now, for the first time, being capable of being applied if it is necessary in a sane, sensible, logical, statistical manner. I take some credit for the fact that we have at last found a way of doing this. The farmers who are growing wheat will be delighted to know that we are not restricting their input of wheat, as some people would suggest; we are not putting them on contracts, as some of them feared; but if it comes to the point that we have to choose between the fellow with 800 acres or 900 acres and the fellow with five or ten acres, then I can assure you that, for the first time, we have devised some method of helping the fellow with the smaller acreage. Again, it is not done to the detriment of the taxpayers.

Comment on this

Will the Minister say a word about the effects of the change in the falling number?

Comment on this

So far as the falling number is concerned, this means that in the case of potentially millable wheat—should we have any worthwhile quantity offered next year or any other year—there is a greater likelihood that it can be used for milling rather than when the falling number was at 130 or 120. It is a well-established fact, I understand, that where you have the lower falling number wheat even mixed in a small quantity among the wheat of the higher falling number, that is up to 150 and under 160, it can spoil the whole lot. Therefore, it is not sensible, and indeed it is really foolish, to mix very low quality wheat in with this potentially millable quality and also some reasonably high quality wheat because, when you do, you will use neither.

Comment on this

The Minister would talk himself out of any situation.

Comment on this

It is not a question of talking myself out of it. It is a question of being realistic to the point of accepting what is factual, what has been shown to be the case and what in the ultimate analysis is in the overall national interest. There is no national interest being served by making three heaps of wheat—one unmillable, one potentially millable and one that is millable—and finding that the potentially millable is just a joke because of the fact that the unmillable has been put through it to such an extent that whatever might have been used of the potentially millable is now gone as well. There is no point in that sort of caper and I do not think we should continue to do it. We should move up the quality in order to be able to utilise to a greater degree potentially millable wheat. That is why this has been done. Again, with the excessive increase in yields from 31 cwts per statute acre to the new all-time record of 36 cwts per acre, there is no grower who would give a hoot about the changes the Deputy would make much of at this time, coming on the heels of the greatest bonanza that has ever come out of wheat in this or any other country. That is what the farmers reaped during 1968—including the £1,500,000 that should have been collected. Because of the system that was imposed, however, it could not be collected last year but it will be collected next year, only if there is a surplus. Only if the harvest is good, only if the farmers have got the money, will they be expected to carry some of the load of the loss incurred in making feeding stuffs out of millable wheat. It can be bought back at feed prices and it can be utilised for feeding profitably. This is why this is being done. I think it is a very sensible arrangement and one at which the farmers, the wheat growers and all others in the business, cannot and do not take umbrage, provided they can be assured of getting anything like as good a return in the years ahead as they got this year.

Comment on this

The Minister said they got £1,000,000 too much this year.

Comment on this

They got £1,500,000 more than they needed in the sense that this should have been paid by way of levy, according to the arrangement made by the farmers' representatives who in 1958 proposed the levy principle, proposed a system that was then found to be unworkable, and which we have now made workable. I did not impose the levy. A levy was imposed under the Act of 1958 which was prompted by the proposals of the farmers' representatives in that year.

Comment on this

It is not often the Minister shelters behind the farmers.

Comment on this

You never find the Minister sheltering behind anybody because he has no need to.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

In so far as the wheat element is concerned, I am looking forward to improvements. We hear this year again more money for the farmers, more satisfied farmers and no credit to the Fine Gael people.

We have this matter of the reorganisation of the creamery industry. All I will say there is that a considerable amount of work has already taken place in the midst of the hubbub about how it should be done. There are sensible, logical steps being taken by a number of our creamery producers in the country. Quietly and without any fuss they are moving towards true rationalisation to the benefit of all. All I can say there is we will do everything possible to try to help the acceleration of this where it is now being done. From an examination of the further report we have recently received from the Cooke-Sprague people, together with what we have garnered from all the various reports of surveys and the work study done by my Department seven years ago, we would hope with the co-operation of the dairying people and the creamery groups throughout the country to make real progress in the coming year in regard to finding a fairly sensible overall pattern of rationalisation in this very important industry.

There has been mention here of the gaps between farm prices and consumer prices. While it is quite true that one can quote all sorts of differences between the price paid to the farmer and the price paid by the consumer in a city like Dublin, we ought to remember that, perhaps because of good advertising and publicity, our people have come into an age where they want everything packed. They want it made up and looking nice; and, if you want that, you must pay for it. You are going to pay an additional profit margin to whoever is putting on the wrapping, whoever printed the pack, whoever put the colour on and so on. We must remember that when we start comparing prices. At the same time, there are undoubtedly margins that cannot be justified and should not exist, but they do. However, side by side with that, I deplore the people who get up and talk with some air of authority and quote, for instance, the price of a stone of potatoes in Donegal and then they will quote the price of a pound of potatoes here. Who is codding whom? It is a great disservice to the farming community of my county or any other, that this should be put across as being authoritative in the sense that they quote dissimilar figures.

Comment on this

Is the Minister referring to Deputy Dowling's contribution to the debate?

Comment on this

I am not and well the Deputy knows I am not. In fact, there are a few over there who know very well what I am referring to.

Comment on this

Deputy Dowling is the only one that we heard using these figures.

Comment on this

Do not mind what you heard. I said what I read and heard over these recent weeks, that is, that it is entirely wrong and does no service to the farming community to create in the minds of producers of potatoes that the per stone price of a 14-ton lot ex-farm should be compared with the price of 3 lbs or 5 lbs wrapped in cellophane in Dublin and then they say: "Look at that. Where is the difference going?" This is doing nobody any service but, in fact, is doing harm because it is creating doubts in the minds of the farmers who are selling and in the minds of the Dublin residents who are buying, and creating dissatisfaction at both ends in regard to a matter that is not as profitable as would be shown by the unfair, misleading comparisons that had been made and published with the intention, no doubt, of making somebody squeal somewhere and kick up a row about it, and all that based on wrong information, misleading comparisons which are a very dangerous thing to indulge in.

In so far as the mountain lamb subsidy is concerned, Deputy Meaney suggested that lambs should be inspected for subsidy at the time of dipping. There are about six good reasons why we should not do this and one of the most important is that as soon as lambs are punched in the ears, they qualify. If done at dipping time, when dipped and wet, they are open to the danger of infection of one kind or another, not to mention the fact that to handle a lamb, particularly a mountain lamb, is some job but to handle wet lambs at the dipping tank is more than one could expect our fellows to cater for in any numbers on any given day. Apart from that, I would say to the Deputy that if there are any ways by which we can improve the facilities that we have given this year and that have been generally satisfactory in so far as the administration of this scheme is concerned, we would certainly be open to consider suggestions but to do it at every public dipping tank on dipping day is not "on". It is true that we do a good deal of this at public dipping centres, even as of now, but cannot do it at every public dipping centre for various reasons of staff availability, uniformity of application of our inspection code. These and other things preclude us from doing it in as many places as there would be public dipping centres but where we find that undue inconvenience is being caused, even under our system as operating during the past season, we will do our best to try to rectify that during the coming season if we get details about it.

Deputy Murphy mentioned our adverse balance of trade with the EEC and particularly with the Federal Republic of Germany. It is true that our balances of trade, particularly as published recently, giving the bald statistics, in national newspapers, are anything but healthy in so far as the Six are concerned and this is particularly noticeable in so far as West Germany is concerned but while one would be inclined to say to these people that if they do not buy more from us we will not buy anything from them, if we all did this all the time with everybody, we would very soon reach the stage where trade would become well-nigh impossible, that is, trade either on a continental or a world basis, and you would be certainly back to the old barter system with all the curtailment of freedom of trading that that would imply. This is not to say that some effort in the direction of bringing to the notice of these people who are doing poor trade with us at the moment that we are not at all happy with the position but, far from it, are most unhappy with the situation as it has developed, is not well worthy of consideration and well worth making. Indeed, outside the EEC countries we have made this effort, saying to one country: "If you do not buy some of our produce, we will not buy some of yours." As yet, this has not had much effect in any build-up of mutual trade but there is no doubt that it did make the bees move, as it were, in the hive and there have been certain flutterings around as a result since then which I hope and expect may generate some new additional trading with this particular country. As I say, we have done it only in one case so far but it has been worth doing. To apply it generally would freeze trading to such a degree that probably nobody would benefit in the long run and it would tie world trade to such a degree that we would have gone back a century in time by that exercise and would have lost rather than gained as a result.

Then there is, of course, the fact that if we were completely free to go into these markets and if there were no supports either from here or there for our agricultural produce, in particular, it is not clear that in all cases we would be just up to competing and might not have it all our own way if the gates were fully opened both ways. This must be kept in mind also when we talk about gaining access and forcing our way on the basis that we buy from them and they do not buy from us. I deplore the situation where that arises, particularly in relation to the Six Common Market countries, because our trading has been going down and down. In so far as the balance of trade is concerned we have been on the losing end, progressively, during these recent years and, short of gaining membership of the Common Market, it does not look as if there will be any great change, although we are hoping for some improvement, but I do not think there will be any really outstanding change short of our entry to that market as full members in due course.

Deputy Clinton raised the question of brucellosis eradication and said that there should be some facilities for farmers who want to proceed on their own. We have a number of things that I am sure Deputy Clinton is aware of. The brucellosis certified herds scheme has been available in all counties since June, 1965. Under this scheme a farmer who clears his herd of the disease at his own expense and who satisfies the Department as to his management of his herd and premises, can have further tests arranged free by the Department and any reactors to those tests taken up at market value.

Comment on this

But he gets nothing until he has the job done.

Comment on this

This new scheme has not met with a great deal of success. In fact, there has been very little response. Only a very few herd owners have, in fact, availed of this scheme. However, we are considering a further scheme for herd owners outside the area where full-scale eradication is in progress. Under this scheme a herd owner who discovers infection in his herd and who sends the animals for slaughter would get a grant payable when the herd is eventually certified to be clear of the disease.

Comment on this

What percentage grant is that?

Comment on this

I do not know what the actual percentage would be but it is intended to be an assistance for those people who are not yet within the overall scheme. It is to help them to some considerable degree to get clear of infected animals where they are anxious to do it, to clear their herds.

As a further aid for farmers in the main dairying and breeding areas, we have also the milk ring test. I should say that one round was completed in the autumn and a further round will be completed in 1969. Herds found to be clear in each test will give very little risk. It is hoped in the third round to organise special sales from these herds. It is also hoped that further efforts in these areas will be of some considerable assistance in the eradication of brucellosis by these progressive herd owners even before the overall clearance scheme would have got to their areas.

We also heard much about farmers' organisations and we have had rather woolly talking, not only from the Opposition benches, I might say, confusing the situation as to farming organisation relations with the Government and with me, whereas the only difficulty in this realm relates to one farming organisation and to no other. There is no problem about communication, discussion or dialogue with all organised farmer groups bar the NFA. This should be kept clearly in mind and no confusion should be allowed to exist that there is any overall breakdown in communications between the Department, the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries and farming organisations, bar one. In regard to that one, the situation has been and still is and will undoubtedly continue to be that the Department and the Minister are available to them in the same manner as they have been available to all other organisations over the years. This is on the basis that if they have a problem and want to discuss it they come along to make their case and put their points and listen to the Minister's difficulties in the situation. Then, having heard the case and discussed it, the Minister goes from that discussion— which in all probability will entail expenditure—and processes what he heard from the group and since, as I said, it will invariably involve policy or money he must go to the Government and there fight the case that he believes in or has come to believe in. He utilises the case that has been made to him by the various interests and tries to convince the Government to introduce something new or to increase something. He may succeed wholly or he may succeed partially or he may not succeed at all, but having reached a conclusion whatever it may be, that is then conveyed back to the organisation or organisations and to the general body of farmers, informing them what has happened. This is the situation and this is the system of our Government and of our democracy. It is collective Government responsibility and neither I nor any other occupier of this Ministry has had or will have, unless we change the system radically, the power to sit down with any group and make decisions involving policy or spending. He must go back to his Government to get their consent. This is available to the NFA.

Comment on this

It has not been available to them for the past two years.

Comment on this

It has been available to them and available in a particular way through the National Agricultural Council.

Comment on this

On the Minister's terms.

Comment on this

They were the only organisation of any size which did not welcome it despite the fact that they had said that they would like a council of this type. As I said then and as I have said many times since, if they or anybody else did not like the manner in which it was set up there was nothing inflexible about it, that it could be changed and that time might show that it should be changed, that we were always open to suggestions and proposals from within the NAC to change its nature. That has been the case and nobody can deny that that was not known. I want to say again that the facilities that I have mentioned are available to this organisation to come to the Minister——

Comment on this

Through an imaginary NAC.

Comment on this

——wait now——to discuss these matters but they chose another way. They chose to show that, in fact, they would have to have it their way. Although I have had four, five or six invitations in the last two or three months, and these invitations were in the final analysis invitations without any preconditions, I have had the sort of reply that I got to the last of these which I made last September. Some of the reply which I got to my invitation of the 20th September asking without conditions that I might meet the NFA and the ICMSA leaders together, has been published. It contained seven conditions under which normality would be regarded as having been restored and which provided that there should be a categorical assurance from me on behalf of the Government that the seven conditions were being granted as a prerequisite to meeting. Obviously, there could not and would not be a meeting. These seven conditions are as follows:

(a) Recognition by Government of the proper role of NFA—representing 130,000 farm families—in our society and under our Constitution as one of the most important instruments in substantially and materially aiding agricultural and general economic progress.

(b) Participation by the NFA in the formulation and implementation of agricultural policy——

Comment on this

Does the Minister consider that to be reasonable?

Comment on this

Wait now, there is another wee bit there. Do not take umbrage. It continues:

——always conscious of the authority of the Government and in the ultimate of Dáil Éireann in finally deciding on and sanctioning national agricultural policy.

(c) Immediate renewal——

I am not too good at reading this one because it is rather difficult. However this is what it says:

Immediate renewal—extraneous to the Minister's proposed meeting on the milk price issue—of NFA/Minister/Government negotiations in the nature of productive dialogue on the many issues which confront argiculture in general and farmers in particular—memoranda have been submitted to the Government, the Minister and his predecessor on these issues, the latest of which was submitted to the Taoiseach and the Minister on April 9th, 1968, prior to the 1968 Budget.

(d) Agreement on the necessary constructive meetings between the Minister and/or his officials and NFA Commodity Committees on problems and suggested solutions to same relating to all agricultural commodities individually and collectively.

(e) Constructive discussions between the NFA and the Minister on closing the "income gap" (presently £5 per week) between farmers and workers in other sectors.

(f) Ministerial permission to his officials to enable them to have free and frank discussions with NFA officials by mutual agreement on items of day to day importance.

(g) Recognition by the Government and the Minister for Agriculture of those selected by organised farmers for appointment to Marketing Boards, Commissions, Study Groups, etc.

(h) The abolition of discrimination against the Irish Farmers' Journal by having general Departmental advertising restored in the Journal.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

Hear, hear, except for the fact that this journal is avowedly not belonging to the organisation that allegedly has a dispute with me and, therefore, why be so concerned to put that in along with all these other weighty conditions? It is my firm intention to put them back on the gold standard about which Deputy Dowling was talking earlier tonight in order to take this irrelevant matter out of it.

Comment on this

Surely it is not irrelevant to the farmers' organisations.

Comment on this

Do not let us have a row.

Comment on this

It is not a row.

Comment on this

I want to get that out of the way. I do not want a row on what is the irrelevant matter and the one out of context with these conditions.

Comment on this

Are they not all reasonable conditions?

Comment on this

If the Deputy regards these preconditions as reasonable, all I can say to him is God help him if he ever happens to become Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries. He will be crucified, and he will be lacking in responsibility to the Government and the people who put him there.

Comment on this

The Minister must be misreading the whole thing.

Comment on this

I asked for a meeting on more than one occasion without conditions as a solution to the internal, inter-organisational strife that is the root cause of the problems of these farmers' organisations. This is what I got back, and this is the last long bulletin I have got from this source. It is very difficult to feel anything but baffled by the attitude of people here who should know better than to say that, broadly speaking, there is a row and that as it is Christmas there is goodwill about and there should be a reconciliation. The reconciliation is there, and it will continue to be there under our democratic organisation. All other organisations will be free to come to my Department and all other Departments in the knowledge that there may be no decisions made there because it is not within the competence of any Minister of any Government in this State to make such decisions on his own, whether he be with that group or any other group; in the knowledge that he is one of a number of people who control the matter, and that he cannot dispose of that responsibility by saying to anybody: "Come in and I will make the decisions with you." I cannot do this. I have not the authority to do it.

I could not do it because I could be rejected the following day by my own Government colleagues, and would that not be right? Is that not the way our Government must operate? If that is only appreciated, then there is nothing between the members of the NFA and the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries. This I have told to the leader of the NFA who, remember, I invited to a meeting within 24 hours of his election as president, and I invited him to a meeting again. The last time I met him I told him as plainly as I could: "I do not care whether you call it negotiation, discussion, dialogue or anything else, so long as it is within that context it is freely open to you or any other organisation at least to recognise that this is not of my making, that it is the basis of our Government, and that the whole system of government and of democracy in this country would have to be changed to make it otherwise."

Having said that, I chide those who talk about this matter as if there was a war on with all the farmers' representatives in the country. In fact, as I said earlier, I spent almost three hours in the deepest conference this evening with people really representative of the farmers, the executive committee, numbering nearly 30, of the 27 agricultural committees throughout the country, the General Council of Committees of Agriculture. It was time well spent. There was good contact with them and there were good relations with them. I hope this continues as it always has been, so far as my predecessors and myself are concerned. Only a couple of days ago the ICMSA were up here with me as they have always been over the years. Naturally, they make their case and, like other organisations, they will be looking for their pound of flesh, but they still come and still have contact with the Minister and there is no problem about it. There are the other organisations in the country, whether they be sheep representatives, cattle representatives or whatever organisation they represent, they are all there available and I will be available to them, and they know this.

I just want it to be plainly and clearly understood that in Ireland there is only the one organisation representing farmers who do not see their way to have the same sort of contact with the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries as every other organisation is prepared to have. I only wish it was different; I hope the time is now arriving when it will be different.

Comment on this

I hope this will be the last Christmas that we shall have under Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

You will not only have a good Christmas this year but farming-wise a better one still next year, provided you are fortunate enough to have the same Government and the same Ministers.

Comment on this

That will leave us with a very unhappy Christmas.

Comment on this

Do not worry about next year. It may never happen. The attitude of Fine Gael has always been if it is a bad day today it will be worse tomorrow and if it is a good day today it will be bloody awful next week.

I am only sorry that due to these arrangements I have not had the time I should like to make a real speech about agriculture instead of talking about the carping criticisms made by the Opposition, who had nothing else to talk about, there being no real criticism of the Party or the Government at the moment. However, there will be another day when we shall have more time to discuss this very important matter in greater detail than it has been possible to do tonight. I can only say to the farmers that they had a great year, and may they have a very happy Christmas as well; I think they could not help it.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Question: "That the Estimate be referred back for reconsideration" put and declared lost.

Comment on this