Criminal Justice Bill, 1967: Second Stage.
Contributions 74–178 of 178. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 18 of 1967 ›
Deputy Andrews had the courage to declare his views in relation to — while he did not acknowledge the fact — the Fine Gael amendment. He was a precursor of so many others not inside this House.
Deputy Andrews declared on television that he would not support sections 30 and 31 of the Bill. The strange thing is that after Deputy Andrews had so spoken, if my recollection serves me correctly, the Minister went on television irate and angry, full of conviction for the cause which he was supporting, which is this Bill, and he declared he was being opposed by traducers and a whole lot of other adjectival persons of a variety of hues and colours, but that he would not budge one inch. Then, I recall, the Minister travelled south to Cork and delivered another declamation to the people of the south and of Cork that this Bill was necessary and essential, that it was not an infringement in any respect of the rights of the people and that it would not be changed.
It is now being changed. In what way it is not quite clear, but it is perfectly clear that the climate of the people is at last being assessed, that the Government appreciate, that they have begun to understand, that at last people are beginning to speak in Ireland and that they will no longer accept decisions being handed down from any group of people, Government or otherwise, and so certain sections of the Bill will be changed. It is good to see that in this respect as in many others the people of Ireland are beginning to follow the lead of Fine Gael.
This Bill can be condemned on many other grounds. It is the child of the bureaucrats in the Department of Justice who have taken a long time to conceive it, who have been in labour and who have produced it. In each section it bears the scars arising from some difficulty that a bureaucrat has come up against. It is another example of the kind of legislation that we, the people's representatives, are forced to entertain, which comes entirely from the Civil Service, passes through the hands of an indolent Minister who scarcely bothers to read what is involved, who trots it before an inefficient Government, who pass it, and it becomes a legislative proposal in this House.
This Bill would have been passed by this House were it not that a Fine Gael Party are here to make sure this kind of legislation will not pass without examination. The Labour Party, no doubt, would not have been here. The Bill would have passed through this House if this Party had not been here.
Comment on this
Nonsense is nonsense no matter who gives it out, no matter how long he has been here. Do not be talking moonshine.
Comment on this
The Labour Party have been in this House and have never changed their name.
Comment on this
You are the disappointed Party. If you are to get a Fine Gael Government, do not come in here like a scorned woman.
Comment on this
This Bill, coming from the Civil Service, passing through the Minister and through the Government, might well have been passed through this House and have become the law of the land, were it not for the fact that there is a watchful and vigilant Opposition sitting on these benches.
Comment on this
I advise the Parliamentary Secretary to contain himself. Shortly, he may well find himself to be the only Fianna Fáil Deputy in Laois-Offaly.
Comment on this
Fan go bhfeicir. Part V gives rise to a personal objection I have got to make. It deals with proof by written statement. Deputy Booth may appreciate what it contains and so may Deputy O'Malley. The lawyers in this House may perhaps be particularly attuned to section 24. I do not wish to make this a lawyers' debate——
Comment on this
It is great that it is being discussed at night.
Comment on this
——but here is a proposal which is a repetition of one disgraceful episode or incident in the legal history of this country. Many years ago, almost three decades ago, an unfortunate man was charged with murder before a special criminal court. An Emergency Powers Order, or an Order under the special powers the Government had at that time, was passed making a statement made in a Garda station evidence at his trial before the Special Criminal Court. That man subsequently was convicted and executed, there being no evidence other that that against him. I am happy to think that the conscience of those concerned did not allow that statement, which was authorised by the Order then made, to be used at his trial. But somebody had a bright idea, and in section 24 of this Bill we have a repetition of the same kind of legal device — that you may have in criminal proceedings proof by written statement, that you may now have in a criminal trial a statement handed in and accepted as evidence at the trial, the only condition being that the statement purports to be signed by the person who made it, that it contains a declaration to the effect that it is true to the best of the person's knowledge and belief and that he made the statement knowing that, if he stated something wrong, he might be prosecuted, that before the hearing a copy is served on the other parties — presumably that is the defendant, the accused — and that nobody objected to the admission of the statement.
Comment on this
If the defendant does not object, where is the injustice? Perhaps I am confusing the Deputy.
Comment on this
I appreciate the Deputy's point. I accept that he makes it bona fide but may I assure the Deputy — I do not want to go into percentages — that large numbers of people who find themselves in the dock are illiterate; they are, in fact, of lowgrade mentality and intellect. Many of them require the positive protection of the law. There may be a percentage — I do not say there is not — who are quite capable, more than capable — I give as an example Doctor Singer — of demonstrating a legal acumen which is not possessed by the entire legal profession; but a very large proportion would not appreciate what is involved even if they were served with a notice such as that mentioned in this section.
Comment on this
Many of them do not have legal aid because they do not appreciate what their rights are. Apart from that, here is a proposal to fill a gap, if you like, in relation to the evidence necessary to lead to a conviction by handling in a document signed by a person whose evidence has not been tested on oath and through cross examination in the witness box before the jury trying the case. This is the beginning of a trend which, if it continues, could lead to a situation in which people could be convicted on evidence adduced in their absence. A statement given — it does not matter in what circumstances it is given — which is sifted and tested at the trial of the person charged is surely the only basis upon which a charge should properly proceed.
The other section in Part V to which I should like to refer is section 26. I am sorry the Minister is not here because I should like to know what the purpose of section 26 is. The section provides:
A previous conviction may be proved against any person in any criminal proceedings by the production of such evidence of the conviction as is mentioned in this section, and by showing that his fingerprints and those of the person convicted are the fingerprints of the same person.
Does that mean, as it seems to mean, that if there are fingerprints, and a person has a previous conviction, his fingerprints may be handed in? Or is it subject to the general rule that a previous conviction may not be the subject of evidence? What is the necessity for this elaborate section?
Section 27 appears to me to be merely a restatement of what I understand the law to be at the moment: in criminal proceedings previous convictions may be given in evidence if they are tendered merely to prove a course of conduct or a particular knowledge relevant to the offence being investigated. Section 27 does not appear to declare any new law. It appears to declare the law as it is. I am puzzled, however, as to the reason for the inclusion of section 26. I do not want to turn this debate into a lawyers' debate and so I shall pass from these details.
As one goes through this Bill — the provisions for appeals, the provisions in relation to majority verdicts in criminal cases and a variety of other provisions with which we shall deal in more detail on the Committee Stage — it becomes more and more apparent that this is a Bill designed to counter many of the difficulties which bureau cracy has encountered in the actua conduct and prosecution of criminal cases in the courts. Why should the provisions in criminal cases in regard to majority verdicts be different from the provisions in regard to verdicts in the case of a civil jury? I do not know why. I have no strong view about it but as one who has appeared for the defence in criminal cases I know well that, generally speaking, the odds are against the unfortunate defendant. The scales are weighed against him. The forces of the State are arrayed against him. He may have to depend on the services of an advocate who may or may not be satisfactory. The one thing — I do not think it has worked any injustice over the years — which has righted the balance to some extent is the fact that the jury must be unanimous in their verdict. I do not think that has worked any great wrong on society. It may have meant that in some cases the jury were not able to agree. There is, of course, the obligation to prosecute such a person again and he is involved for a second time in the anguish and anxiety of a trial. Often he may be convicted on the second occasion, or often the jury again may have valid and significant doubts about his guilt or innocence. Generally here he is not prosecuted a third time and generally in those circumstances the State enters a nolle and leaves it so.
I cannot feel that the need to provide for a majority verdict in criminal cases has been established. Again I feel this is another example of bureaucracy saying: "We will stop another gap", and so on. In many of the other sections there is a variety of other provisions in relation to appeals which also indicate that this Bill has emanated to make more efficient the prosecution of accused persons. I am all for efficiency in the normal activities of the State, but I would suggest that efficiency in the prosecution of offenders may, if you start to streamline it, lead to a miscarriage of justice. It is better to have many miscarriages the wrong way round — in other words in relation to people getting off — than a miscarriage which results in an innocent person being found guilty.
Deputy Andrews referred to Part IV of the Bill which relates to offensive weapons. Deputy Seán Dunne also referred to this part of the Bill. It contains provisions which have been the subject of many Parliamentary Questions from Deputies on all sides of the House. In fairness, it is right to recall that not only did Fine Gael Deputies raise this matter from time to time and Labour Deputies, but I also recall that Deputy Vivion de Valera raised a number of times the problem of flick-knives and so on. This has been worrying the people in this city for well over the past decade. It is a little bit thick that it is only now in 1969 that this legislation should come before the House. It should have been passed a long, long time ago. When we realise that people with criminal tendencies or habits that can lead them into difficulty or danger can go around with flick-knives, and having weapons of that kind in their possession and committing no offence, it is appalling to think that it has taken so long for legislation to deal with this problem to come before the House.
I do not want to refer to recent happenings but it is true to say that there have been a number of deaths in this city in the past five or six years that might not have taken place had legislation of this kind been passed by the House. It seems to me to be a great pity that this Bill should have been so delayed in coming before us because so many people were concerned to deal with other aspects of criminal prosecution rather than in dealing with the things which matter. Legislation to prohibit the possession of knives could have been passed through this House ten years ago without the slightest difficulty. General legislation prohibiting the possession of any offensive article could have been passed through the House ten years ago, but it was held in suspense while this enormous Bill was being built up depending on current and crude and different experience being learned in relation to the prosecution of offenders.
Comment on this
I am most interested. Obviously Deputy Booth has a long memory. I do not recall it. Perhaps Deputy Booth does. So far as I can recall the flick-knife has been a phenomenon of the past decade or so. Perhaps Deputy Booth knows more than I do. May I suggest that if in the experience of the ordinary affairs of the country something such as the flick-knife menace becomes apparent to the Minister for Justice — the flick-knife problem will not arise again but some such problem such as the problem in relation to drugs: have I Deputy O'Leary's attention?— a situation should not be allowed to develop in which the responsible Minister has to sit down and wait. That is the kind of legislation which the House would receive quickly and be glad to see passed through. It may be dealing with a small problem but it is a very real problem to the people. The flick-knife menace has certainly been known to people for the past ten years and this legislation should have been through a long time ago.
The objectionable provisions of the Bill which have been the subject of so much comment were recognised by the Fine Gael Party in the motion in the name of Deputy Michael O'Higgins which was tabled some months ago. We understand that some of the objectionable provisions are to be deleted, but in what sense it is not quite clear at the moment. The majority of the provisions of the Bill are worthwhile. No doubt one can criticise particular sections but, generally speaking, the Bill has been in preparation for a long long time. It is a bureaucratic measure designed as such and I suppose, like the curate's egg, it is good in parts. We will deal with the parts that are not good on Committee Stage. We feel, however, that the public attention which has been focused on this Bill has been a good thing. It has been a good thing that people not normally concerned with political affairs have reacted when there has been an apparent infringement of their rights as individuals.
I do not know to what extent the sections of this Bill intended to prohibit meetings near this House are at all desirable. It may be that at times this House has been out of touch with people outside. It is not a very good thing that, merely because there has been a breakdown in communications between the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries and the farmers, the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the electricians and the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs and the postal workers, and these affected people seek to bring their grievances to the doors of Leinster House, the Establishment react and say "We are going to banish you at least half a mile from any sitting of the National Parliament" because that is accepting a breakdown in communications. It is something that one must approach with suspicion realising that the Parliament in our sister island, the Parliament of Westminster, has no such legislation and operates to provide merely the ordinary law in relation to unlawful or riotous assembly to deal with situations of that kind. It is a poor thing for us that we must seek these special powers in a Criminal Justice Bill to insulate this House from people affected by the decisions of elected Government by their decisions outside and that we must put a ring of steel around Dáil Éireann if it is sitting.
However, there it is. Those are some of the provisions in this Bill and it seems to me again indicative of a point of view in which the Civil Service say "Well, we are going to get new powers to prevent people doing things which have been a source of annoyance to the Establishment in the years gone by". This is largely a Committee Stage Bill and we will deal with many of these things in Committee. I have no doubt that many Deputies will vote for the amendment we have proposed to this Bill and which will become the first matter falling to be voted on at the conclusion of the Second Stage.
Comment on this
At the outset I should like to say that the issue in this Bill is too important and the Bill has implications which are too serious for any Party to claim sole authority for raising opposition to the Bill. The Labour Party give second place to none in their opposition. Our opposition to this Bill led to the opposition shown by other organisations and it is pathetic for politicians to come in here and to say that they are the commanders-inchief of the opposition movement to this Bill. I am glad that Fine Gael oppose this Bill; I am glad of any support from Government Deputies in opposing this Bill but the Bill is too important for any of us to start claiming that we are responsible for the opposition which there is to it.
The variety of organisations opposing this Bill indicate the wide cross-section of emotions which have been aroused by the Bill in all parts of the country and prove conclusively that the opposition to it cannot be confined to that mysterious and favourite target of Fianna Fáil Ministers: some sinister organisation. There is nothing sinister about the NFA, nothing sinister about the tenants' organisations or the residents' associations. Certainly there is nothing sinister about the Gaelic League. These, together with the General Council of County Councils, are among some of the organisations which have come out in total opposition to the Bill. To take refuge in some mysterious knowledge which the Minister says he has about certain subversive groups in the country and to claim this as the basis for attempting to put forward this ridiculous Bill is not being honest with the House and is not doing a good job for the reputation of justice in this country. After all, that is what is at stake in the passage of this Bill.
I am sure no Member of any Party in this House wishes to see the guardians of the peace, the police force, being saddled with an unworkable Bill and our chief criticism is that sections of the Bill are unworkable and place an unnecessary burden on those officers and attempt to enrol, into the position of cumann secretaries, superintendents up and down the country. This clearly is what certain sections propose. I did not even go along with the kind of action mounted by the Minister for Justice at last week's jamboree, the Fianna Fáil Ard Fheis, at which he was reported to have retreated from the ire of the floor delegates. Let it go from this House to these floor delegates and to the people who had some power, so-called, for a few hours last week at the Fianna Fáil Ard Fheis, until they are called again to the next Ard Fheis, that the Minister has not retreated so much from his original position and that several unsatisfactory features still remain and which still imply interference by police authorities in the legitimate right of any group of citizens to hold a public demonstration. Admittedly we are promised that at a later Stage of the Bill the Minister will introduce amendments which go some way to meeting the opposition. He has been good enough to say that his amendments, at least one of his suggested amendments, would have the result that sole responsibility will be placed on the organisers of a perhaps lawful, legitimate and peaceful meeting for any damage that might accrue to public property or any damage that might result——
Comment on this
According to Deputy Booth every speaker who expressed some opposition to the Bill has been wrong. I know that Deputy Booth is an expert in his own kind of revelation but if I have the time I will listen to what the Deputy has to say.
Comment on this
To the suggested amendments. The Minister has been rather coy about the full implications of the amendments, but my reading and hearing of what the Minister inrin tends in the amendments would indicate just what I have said. I am trying to be as fair as possible to a Minister who has presented a Bill to the House which he promises he will amend. I am doing my best to read, according to what that Minister has said, what his amendments will amount to. The Deputy will appreciate the difficulty of any Opposition Deputy placed in the peculiar position that, in what the Minister has put in the Bill and in what amendments he brings in at a later stage, there may be some difference. It is an awkward position for Deputy Booth, too, and I sympathise with his position and my own.
In this very year when other parts of this island have resounded to civil strife, to a great deal of agitation in connection with meetings and demonstrations, and where we have seen a Minister for Home Affairs use in a very biased fashion his powers under the Act in that State to ban a public meeting, it is ironic that the so-called republican party of reality in the South should be attempting to bring in something similar for their area of jurisdiction. It is ironic that, in a year in which we have seen that Unionist administration covered in odium by most civilised nations, people with whom they were shaking hands a year ago should not have learned the lesson of the contagion involved in proximity to such Unionist people and that they are attempting now to bring in legislation that goes some way beyond what the Northern Government have brought in. So here are the strange bedfellows in coercion in Ireland in 1969—Fianna Fáil under Deputy Ó Moráin in the South and Captain O'Neill and his own beleaguered Unionist administration in the North.
I am one of those who always considered that the most eloquent proof of our dedication to freedom for our people in the North of Ireland must lie in our dedication to the same principles here in the South in the area under our jurisdiction and that this is the most meaningful expression of unity we can have at this time with people fighting for such rights in the Northern area.
It can therefore be described as a stab in the back to the Civil Rights movement in Northern Ireland for the Fianna Fáil administration to bring in this unnecessary Bill at this time. I would indicate that I am referring here to the portions of the Bill which refer solely to the right of peaceful demonstration and public meeting. There are other items in the Bill which are certainly necessary and long overdue and it is regrettable that these items should be tied together with such elements as I have described in relation to public meetings and so on.
One fails to see the necessity for the kind of prior information that is called for in this Bill. If people make a nuisance of themselves at a public meeting and break the civil law there is ample power under existing legislation to bring these people before the courts. There is no need to bring in extra legislation. I recall another unworkable Bill brought in here and supported by too many Deputies of this House. I refer to the ESB (Special Provisions) Bill. That was an unworkable Bill and it contributed to the worsening of industrial relations in this country. I am suggesting that this present Bill will contribute to a worsening in the situation of the public versus the public authorities. I do not see it as necessary. I see it as leading to further strife because, if one attempts to implement this Bill, to work it out in all its details, the last section must mean public disorder—perhaps desired by some people but certainly not to the good of the State or of our democracy. There is ample opportunity under existing law to bring before the courts anybody convicted of public misdemeanour. Sections 30 and 31 are unworkable and must lead, if implemented, to further disorder and certainly to further trouble for the police force.
People in this country have a pretty easy rule of thumb in deciding their politics. The present Government Party have attempted by means of the big lie to suggest that a socialist movement must lead to State tyranny. In fact, as anybody who knows the slightest thing about it must know, if there is any weakness in socialist policies it is that they go too far perhaps towards decentralisation of State functions and to too much power being given to the individual and to the subordinate groups in the State.
Comment on this
We do not really have time but, though I am a democrat, I really despair of trying to influence the Deputy's attitude on anything.
Comment on this
I do not wonder the Deputy will not give any instances. I do not know any either. That makes two of us.
Comment on this
Yes. At any rate we did not have to wait for any change in our system here or cite any other system because this Bill in some of its provisions amounts to little more than an extension of State tyranny and inroads into the rights of citizens. No case is made for its necessity in the area of the rights of citizens to come together in freedom of association, in freedom of public meeting. There is really no case built up for limiting this right of public assembly by citizens. What makes one more uneasy is that the Minister presiding over this extension of State tyranny, over this Bill which certainly proceeds some way on the road towards totalitarianism in this country, should be the one who himself has given rather unsavoury evidence of his own crude notions of political matters.
In the late lamented effort of this administration to change the Constitution of this country in regard to the little matter of how people should vote and how governments should be elected, I recall this Minister investigating, accusing, referring to groups he called "political queers". I regret having to use such a term. It is humiliating for any Member of this House to realise that a Minister of this House should use those terms, but that term was used by the Minister for Justice and it is quite obvious that the Minister has rather eccentric views on political matters, to put it very mildly. At any rate, his politics come to him, let us say, neat and very neat at that. It is all the more alarming that a Minister who does not appear to know a great deal about how politics should be organised in a democracy should be presiding over a Bill which has such a totalitarian inspiration in several of its provisions.
I said at the outset that it is in the interests of all political Parties in this House that our police force should be seen to carry out impartially the work of preserving the law in this country, but this Oireachtas has a duty also to the people that we do not pass Acts which will have the effect of making the Garda Síochána unwilling accessories or allies, or giving them the job of carrying out the political Party edict of whichever one is in office at anytime in the future. Under sections 30 and 31 they are given such power. I have heard the Minister express what he may do in the amendments, but the fact is that we are giving to Garda officers the power of deciding whether a meeting should go ahead or whether there are unruly elements in it. The fact is we are now giving into the hands of the guardians of the law the power to make, in effect, political decisions about a meeting which may or may not take place. I believe this is an unnecessary burden to give to them and I believe it is an unfair one.
The Minister for Home Affairs, it has been said, gives such decisions in Northern Ireland. But here we are prepared to hand over to police officers up and down the country the power to say whether such meetings should take place. Reference has been made to meetings near Leinster House but I think we may exaggerate this. I, for one, am not afraid of any group holding meetings near Leinster House. I do not believe any of the meetings which have been held by farmers or others over the last year or two have in any way been a threat to the deliberations of this House. All of us who believe in the democratic system must be jealous and always vigilant about the important position of this House in the country. The real question we should ask ourselves is: if large demonstrations take place, from whatever section in our community they may be —whether they are farmers or otherwise—and if those people feel that their problems are such that they have to demonstrate outside Leinster House, then surely the Government of the day have not being carrying out their mandate in the correct fashion? Government Deputies and the Government of the day must look at the kind of legislation we are passing in this House.
I believe if a democracy is unable to absorb and unable to live with the right of citizens to parade when they feel like it in the streets or elsewhere, then that democracy is in effect showing lack of confidence in its own future. This Bill, it seems to me, represents a lack of confidence in the permanence of democratic rule in this country. I have this confidence in the permanence of democratic rule in this country but I do not believe it will be safeguarded by Bills such as this.
There are several features in the Bill we have praised, which have been called for and which are long overdue. The matter of offensive weapons has often been referred to. The only regret is that legislation which was necessary on the possession of offensive weapons should be a part of a Bill such as this. There have been several tragic incidents over the last year or two. Possibly, if we had hurried up with our legislation in the matter of offensive weapons, the incidents which have occurred could have been avoided. At least it can be stated that there was no need to delay the bringing in of legislation to deal with offensive weapons until it had become part of the relatively irrelevant Bill which we have before us now.
We consider that sections 30 and 31 are unworkable. I would appeal to the Minister to bring in honest amendments, in fact to delete from this Bill those sections dealing with public meetings. I am mystified as to where the edict for those sections came from. Some people think it came from the bureaucracy of the Department of Justice which has spawned rather curious events, and which certainly has given strange manifestations of its idea of public good. It is one Department of State which I think would do with a spring cleaning. I do not know whether it would be asking too much of the present Minister to look about him in that Department and see whether some officers in that Department——
Comment on this
We cannot discuss the officials of the Department. The Minister is responsible for the Bill before the House.
Comment on this
The Minister is responsible for the Bill but he has given his surmise about where this Bill is necessary and it should be open to Deputies in this House who find his surmising in this manner unsatisfactory to direct the Minister's attention to his own Department and perhaps to suggest to him that it could do with a spring cleaning.
Comment on this
Or allow the members of the Department to intervene in our debate and point out where it can be done.
Comment on this
We had an incident recently in regard to interference from this Department where precedent was interfered with.
Comment on this
I am not to be taken as assenting by my silence with regard to that. I do not think this is the appropriate time to discuss this.
Comment on this
I would hope the Minister would delete those sections which I consider inappropriate in this Bill. There are several other aspects in it which other Deputies have referred to and it would be only repetitive to refer to them again. However, I am more concerned with the kind of statements which have already been made by the Minister for Justice. I am not confident that he will accede in his amendments to the undoubted opposition that there is across a very wide section of opinion from the Gaelic League to the NFA. There are several matters in this Bill where the rights of many of those people would be limited in the matter of public demonstrations.
I do not believe any Bill in recent times has had as much opposition as this Bill. I do not know whether the present Minister or the administration realise the extent of the opposition there is in this country to the Bill. There are several examples in recent months of their inability to grasp what opposition there was to matters which they felt were important and matters on which they felt they had the support of the country. On those other matters they did not accept the views expressed in this House. They considered it was merely party prejudice when public opposition was pointed out to them. When a Bill like this can unite opposition such as tenant organisations, farmers organisations and the trade union movement, it must be very seriously examined.
I hope there will be a free vote of the House, that it will not be allowed to become a matter to be decided on by the Whips and that the Government will not see this Bill purely as something in which their own sense of righteousness is involved, but that they will see that a Bill with such complications as this Bill should be left to an open free vote of the House. If it is, it will be a mark of the maturity of this House if we are wise enough to change the Bill. Otherwise it will be a mark of the increasing irrelevance of this House if we allow this Bill to go in the shape the Minister has presented it here or in the direction in which his suggested amendments lie. I would appeal to the members of the Fianna Fáil Party and to Fianna Fáil Deputies who may have begun to question the infallibility of commands from the Cabinet to be on their guard in accepting advice from on high in this particular Bill because more than a few amendments may be involved.
Comment on this
I am one of those who were not opposed to this Bill from the beginning. I was never very happy with sections 30 or 31. I felt they were rather unworkable but I did not fall for all the propaganda which poured out from individuals and organisations who had not taken the trouble to do as I have done and read the Bill and the explanatory memorandum and try to understand them both.
Initially, the reaction to the Bill was that it was an intolerable extension of the power of the Garda and that there was an overpowering tendency to amend the law. These criticisms came from people who, if they had read the explanatory memorandum, would have seen from the outset that this was largely a consolidation Bill dealing with existing legislation and really a giant tidying-up operation. As is the case in any tidying-up operation, there has to be a certain amount of polishing, a certain amount of discarding and of bringing matters up to date. I agree with the Minister when he says that most of the opposition which has been voiced in public has been based on a complete misconception of what is involved.
The first section which gave cause for comment was probably section 12. This was the one which came under comment from the Irish Association of Civil Liberty. I cannot imagine that this very respectable organisation could really have been advised, as they claim, by a legal committee consisting of university professors of law, distinguished members of the Bar and practising solicitors when they came to submit the memorandum on the Bill. Incidentally, as an ex-solicitor myself I always take exception to the fact that members of the Bar are always referred to as being distinguished members of the Bar while solicitors are referred to as "practising". That, however, is only a technical objection which does not come under the heading of the Bill.
In this memorandum which the Irish Association of Civil Liberty has produced reference is made to section 12 (4). They claim that a Garda will be empowered to arrest without a warrant a person who, no matter how long before, has committed a breach of the peace. As the Minister pointed out, that is nonsense. Section 12 (4) says no such thing. It says that a member of the Garda Síochána may arrest a person without notice where he is satisfied that the person has committed an offence, if he has reasonable grounds for belief that the person is likely to engage in further conduct whereby the commission of an offence may occur and it is not reasonably practicable to apply for a warrant. The member of the Garda Síochána has to be satisfied on the first two points. He must also be able to justify in court that he was not reasonably able to apply for a warrant before carrying out the arrest. This criticism shows the complete superficiality of criticism by an association which numbers among its members some very responsible people. I do not know who produced this memorandum but whoever did should be ashamed of it.
Section 12 (7), they say, would empower a garda to arrest without warrant any person whom he suspected of being guilty of an offence under section 59, that is, possession of a thing obtained in contravention of the criminal law. I do not think one needs to be a lawyer to read section 59 and see what is actually involved and what is behind this section. Section 59 says that a person who knowingly and without lawful authority has in his possession or on his premises or conveys in any manner any thing obtained (Whether by himself or any other person) in contravention of the criminal law shall be guilty of an offence. That is clear to me. It means a person who has knowingly and without lawful authority in his possession stolen goods.
Yet this memorandum accuses the Minister of putting forward legislation which would make it possible for a garda without a warrant to arrest a person who had in his possession a bottle of brandy which a relative brought back from abroad the year before without declaring it to the Customs. I never knew that was a criminal offence. I do not believe it is, nor do I believe that the possession of a banned book would be a breach of criminal law. This is the sort of superficial, stupid and, in fact, irresponsible criticism which has come from a body which should be a responsible body. When this association produces and publishes criticisms like this, it is no wonder that more gullible people begin to feel that this legislation is essentially sinister. They go on to talk about protective custody, where a garda is entitled to arrest a person he is satisfied has committed an offence and has reasonable grounds for believing the person is likely to engage in further conduct whereby the commission of an offence may occur. A garda may arrest a person without notice where he is satisfied there has been some sort of row in which this person has been involved and which has caused a breach of the peace or was likely to lead to it, and where his conduct is such that he is likely to engage in further conduct leading to a breach of the peace. The Explanatory Memorandum gives the case of a person involved in a fight and where it is possible he is going to get into another fight. It is not protective custody; it is a matter of trying to preserve the peace. In that case a garda is not able to go looking for a warrant because John-Joe has already been in one fight and is about to get into another fight. By the time the garda gets the warrant for an arrest John-Joe will be in his second, or even his third, fight. It is in the interests of John-Joe and of the public that he should be taken into custody quickly before another row develops.
It is time we looked at this Bill in a commonsense, reasonable way, as I believe the Minister himself has done. There is nothing sinister in it. Deputy O'Leary keeps on saying that there is no necessity for introducing this bit of legislation. What the Minister is doing is modifying the existing law into one Act. He is tidying it up as it were. Deputy O'Leary asks why there should be this provision about the creation of disturbances at meetings and he asks why we could not rely on existing legislation. That is precisely what we are doing. Under section 33 we are simply re-enacting the provisions of the Public Gatherings Act of 1908. There is nothing new in that.
That is one of the things that always disappoints me about Deputy Michael O'Leary. He does not do his homework but prefers to talk off the cuff. He is saying that the Minister and the Government are doing something dreadful but he has not checked up to find that they are not doing any such thing. There is always the danger with Deputy O'Leary that he feels it is unwise to search for facts because these may only confuse him. His prejudices and his tendency to bring Northern Ireland into this debate is typical of his approach, as there is no connection and no comparison to be drawn whatever.
Comment on this
I suppose when one fails to find facts which correspond with one's arguments, one must rely on emotional appeals. We come now to section 15 and the business of searching premises. We find that Deputy Dunne is strongly opposed to this section and, I suppose, for his own good reasons.
Comment on this
On a point of order, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, I should like Deputy Booth to explain what he means.
Comment on this
Deputy Dunne was very honest about it when he stated that his only experience of courts was when he was sitting in the dock.
Comment on this
As a political prisoner, but the Deputy knows that as well as I do.
Comment on this
Deputy Booth is trying to make out that a Member of this House is a law breaker.
Comment on this
If the Deputy would like to check with the official records he will find that Deputy Dunne said he had been in the dock on a number of occasions for minor offences but he said that he would rather forget about the serious charges. It is not unreasonable that, under the circumstances, Deputy Dunne is not prejudiced in favour of the Garda Síochána since he has been on the other side of the fence. He went on to say, however, that the main responsibility of the law was to protect the individual against the State. I have never understood that to be a cardinal principle of the Socialist Party policy but I am always willing to get further guidance in the matter.
Deputy Dunne then went on to describe the present state of the country, the present unrest and the tendency towards protests and he made one remark with which I entirely agree. He said that if we go on like this we may be led into some form of Nazism or Fascism. With that, I entirely agree. I am not very worried about the existing tendency to protest but I am very much worried that, if this continues to become worse and worse, some Government will be forced to take excessively repressive measures which will mean a serious deprivation of liberty for one and all. This has been the inevitable experience of countries in the past and is the experience of countries like Greece where a state of anarchy and chaos had reached such a degree that the people actually welcomed the military dictatorship which is now governing ruthlessly in that country despite the fact that it is about to be thrown out of the Council of Europe. That ruthless and tyrannous Government is supported by a tremendous number of people in Greece simply because it appears to be the only way in which the country can be saved from complete anarchy and chaos.
There is a danger there and if the Government do not take some action to restrict this disruptive element in our society, they will be storing up trouble for themselves and this Government or its successors will be faced with a situation where they will have to be much more ruthless than this Bill, even in its original form, ever intended to be.
I am not resentful about the extension of the power of the Garda Siochána to enter my private property and to search it. It is absolute nonsense for people to get up on their high horse and say "My home is my castle and I will not allow the Garda in to make investigations in defence of the community and in their efforts to deal with crime." If a crime has been committed and a member of the Garda Síochána comes to my door and says he is making investigations in connection with a certain crime, whatever it may be, I would welcome him in and say "There are no stolen goods on the premises as far as I know but you may make your investigations." I believe that any normal citizen would do the same but we have this tendency, which the Minister referred to, of regarding the detection of crime as a sort of game hunt having an element of chase about it—the keepers of justice being the hunters and the evildoers being the hunted. There is also this curious quirk in our own makeup that makes us want to give the maximum help to the hunted.
I have very little respect for these pompous individuals who say that this business of having the gardaí come in without a warrant is an intolerable imposition or an infringement on their liberty. That is absolute poppycock. The only people who would object to a member of the Garda Síochána entering his premises would be those who have guilty consciences. Citizens should co-operate in every way.
There has also been the question of the desperate infringement of individual liberty by the taking of fingerprints. Why should the taking of fingerprints be an infringement of one's independence any more than the taking of a photograph? If fingerprints are taken from a witness and if there is no conviction of the accused person and he is acquitted, the fingerprint records must be destroyed and will be destroyed. Why should anybody be afraid of having his fingerprints on the records in Dublin Castle or wherever they may be? I am not afraid of them, and I cannot think who would be. Why should anybody be frightened of having his fingerprints taken? If this procedure will help the forces of law and order to protect the majority against the minority I am all in favour of it. The late Deputy Hogan referred in one of his statements from the Chair to the fact that the majority has rights as well as the minority, and it is the duty of the forces of law and order to protect the community against the infringement of liberty by a minority of criminally and evilly disposed people.
I do not pay any attention to people who get up on their high horse and say there is something sinister going on. There is nothing sinister. I have never been aware of any secret planning among civil servants in the Department of Justice. Deputy O'Leary said this was an effort by civil servants to interfere with the administration of justice. With the worst will in the world no civil servant can interfere with the administration of justice. The administration of justice is, and very properly so, entirely in the hands of the judiciary.
There have been comments, too, on this question of the double peril, putting a man in danger twice on the same charge. I would be the first to support the view that, if a man is given a full trial and acquitted on the merits, on the facts, of the case as disclosed, he should not be liable to be tried again. However, what is being envisaged here is a situation where the case has not fully gone for trial at all but where, on a legal technicality, the case has either been taken back from the jury or dismissed outright by the judge. That has not been a complete trial. What we are interested in here is the full implementation of justice in the community. There is not a full implementation of justice where a crime has been committed, a person has been indicted and he has still not been tried but the case has been dismissed against him without a full trial.
Then there has been the argument about the admission of additional evidence after the prosecution case has been closed. That does not alarm me because it is still a matter entirely within the discreation of the judge. He may allow the prosecution to bring further evidence after the case has been closed where there is a gap of proof, but if it is a case of irresponsibility by counsel, where he obviously should have done something and where through sheer carelessness he did not, I cannot imagine any judge in this land looking kindly upon him and saying "Well, my learned friend has dropped a very large brick here and I shall help him to pick it up". Those who are promoted to the Bench in this country are men of whom we should be very proud. They are men of very high standing and men who are wellknown for their impartiality except in so far as their main objective is to enforce justice with all the benefit of the doubt being given to the accused in every single instance. I can see no way in which this could possibly react unjustly on the accused.
Deputy Tom O'Higgins referred to section 24, "Proof by written statement". He made a tremendous appeal there for the complete elimination of this reprehensible provision because he said it was completely unjust that a written statement should be accepted in court with the same force as a verbal statement. I was glad to see that he was slightly embarrassed when I referred him to subsection 2 (d) of section 24, where it refers to the admission of the signed statement where:
none of the other parties or their solicitors, within fourteen days from the service of the copy of the statement, serves a notice on the party so proposing objecting to the statement being tendered in evidence under this section.
Deputy O'Higgins was trying to convince himself—I do not think he did, and he certainly did not convince anybody else—that this was a section which would allow the prosecution to rely on signed statements instead of the production of witnesses in court, whereas, in actual fact, as again is made perfectly clear in the explanatory memorandum, this is only to speed up a hearing in court by allowing the court to accept a signed statement where it is admitted by all parties to the proceedings. It does speed up the proceedings tremendously, but where any one party, whether it be one of the defendants or all the defendants, whoever it may be —objects, it is out. It is only a matter of expediting proceedings, but poor Deputy O'Higgins tries to work this up into some fearful infringement of the natural law. There is nothing sinister about it.
Dealing with sections 30 and 31, I have never seen anything sinister about them, but I do feel, as originally drafted, they were probably unworkable. We are faced with the situation where there are many small disruptive elements in society who are not interested for one moment in peaceful demonstrations or peaceful protests; all they are anxious to do is to create a row and make sure that the TV cameras are trained on them. In this way they get publicity far beyond what they could get by any normal means. One cannot get this publicity by peaceful protest. One has only got to consider a recent case of protest through the city by the employees of the fertiliser factory. It was an enormous march, and it went round in a most orderly manner. I saw it go up Dawson Street, then along Saint Stephen's Green then down Kildare Street and stop for a moment outside the Department of Industry and Commerce while a deputation handed in a letter, then down past Leinster House here and then off into the blue: I do not know where they finished up. However, it was an entirely peaceful procession and nobody paid any attention to it. It got very little press coverage and very little television coverage. However, if one finds three men lying across O'Connell Street in front of a bus they get television coverage, press coverage, radio coverage, photographs—the lot. It is exactly the same with a Teachta Dála. Nobody knows it better than Deputy Seán Dunne. If he wants to get publicity he does not have to make a good speech—nobody bothers about that. He knows that if he gets himself expelled for disorderly conduct he will get publicity.
Comment on this
Some Deputies have not the guts to do that. They are much better at criticising people in their absence.
Comment on this
A Deputy will get publicity if he rides roughshod over the customs of this House. The people most vociferous in their pleas on behalf of the right to peaceful public protest are those few people who——
Comment on this
On a point of order. Is it fitting that the Deputy should sneer at Deputy Seán Dunne in that fashion and impute motives to him? I am serious about this. It does not matter what Deputy Seán Dunne may say, it is not right to speak about him in that fashion in his absence.
Comment on this
One may or may not agree with what Deputy Seán Dunne has to say on any particular matter—I agree with a lot of what he says and I disagree with him on certain points—but he certainly has the courage to say it and to say it here. I do not think it is right to speak about him like that in his absence.
Comment on this
The people most vociferous in defence of this right of peaceful public protest are the people who are least interested in any peaceful meeting whatsoever. They are people who are interested only in creating the maximum amount of disruption of society, of obstruction of traffic and generally of causing chaos. To say that they are defending the sacred right of peaceful assembly is the most hypocritical nonsense. Nobody wants to stop people from peaceful assembly and from giving peaceful expression to their opinion but that is not what is going on in the world today, and we know it.
If we do not deal with this in some way—and I do not know what the answer is—we shall find such a reaction against authority of any sort that we shall be faced with anarchy. We see it happening right beside us at the moment in England where students are demanding the right to appoint their own professors, to set their own courses and are insisting that any member of the staff of a college—not necessarily the teaching staff, even, but the maintenance staff—should have a say in the running of an academic institution. This is not a serious proposal: it is a reaction by young people, and other disruptive elements playing on their emotions, to disrupt society. Small pressure groups, who know well enough how to bring public opinion with them by ordinary democratic methods, are trying to force the majority to agree with them simply by obstruction, by causing the maximum amount of trouble. I am not going to stand for that.
I believe that, as a Government, we have a very heavy burden laid upon us to hold all the elements of society together as far as we can, to hold a balance between conflicting elements in society and, above all, not to allow the ordinary forces of law and order to break down—which would leave the power in the hands of the few strong ruthless men who might grab it. That is the thing we have to face. Once we allow people, under the guise of peaceful protest, to hold the whole community up to ransom, we are taking a first, if not a second, step on a very slippery slope. We have got to do something about this right of public meeting. We do not want to restrict any peaceful demonstration or any gathering of people together for free exchange of opinions: that is a very healthy sign in any community. However, once it comes to the question of breaking up private property, of smashing windows, of bursting into shops, of burning buses and then of turning on the police whom they immediately accuse of "police brutality", we are on very dangerous ground altogether.
One has only to look at television to note that almost every night we see an almost identical demonstration of disruption maybe in Japan, Czechoslovakia, Great Britain, America, France, Italy—anywhere. The pattern is identical. Everybody has learned it from the television. You start off with a peaceful protest. Then you gather and link arms, then you start blocking the traffic and then you lie down. The policemen try to lift you up so that the traffic can move. You kick the policeman in the teeth if possible. If he reacts, you immediately say "police brutality", and you hoist the banner you have carefully minded and hold it up in front of the television camera. It is an absolute routine. We have to get some sense into the people. We have to get them to realise that this is not the way to make their views known.
People may say: "This is the only way in which these unfortunate people can make their views known. If you restrict them in that way you are only putting a cork into a bottle and there will be an explosion when it blows out." There are plenty of ways for people to contact the Government, if they want to do so. There are plenty of ways for people to influence public opinion by normal peaceful means if they want to do so. We are up against a situation now where people do not want to do it by democratic means. They want the short cut simply by force of numbers or force of violence. In that situation, no Government can stand idly by. It would be most irresponsible for us to say to the Garda Síochána, in effect: "Keep the peace, boys. We will not give you any authority. Do not use your batons. Do not use your boots. Wear bedroom slippers and soft gloves. Treat everybody nicely." That would only hamstring law and order and create disorder and there would be nobody but ourselves to blame.
I am not in favour of ruthless oppression. I never was one for that. Possibly because of the Army training which Deputy James Tully and I share, I have a respect for discipline. I know the value of it in any community. I know that a well-disciplined unit is a happy unit and that an ill-disciplined unit is the worst in the world. Discipline in a community is not a burden. It is something which can free every one of us to express ourselves properly and as we would like to. It is only when we get these forces of disruption acting in a community that people are afraid to express themselves. The only people who are expressing themselves are those who have thrown caution to the winds and are out for trouble.
I see nothing sinister in this Bill. It does need tidying up. Sections 30 and 31, I think, were clearly misconceived and unworkable. That has been admitted now and we are seeing what we can do better. I would hope for some co-operation from the Opposition in this so that together we can work out an even better scheme than was originally suggested because we must realise that this is a very real problem. Let us not fiddle around with little objections to small sections like this business of transferring of prisoners from civil to military custody. The Minister made it perfectly clear that this is something that, we hope, will never have to be invoked but which we cannot say will never happen. It could be that a large number of people would have to serve short prison sentences all together at one time. Let nobody say that military custody is the very last thing in brutality. The idea of the military being "the brutal and licentious soldiery" is long gone. A military prison is not any more fun than a civil one. I admit that, but it is no worse. You are locked up and that is the beginning and end of it. Nobody will be hammered or flogged at the stake. Those things do not happen. Where a man or a large number of men have to be kept in custody and the ordinary prison system is unable to deal with the situation you may have to transfer them to military detention barracks, whether at Arbour Hill, the Curragh or Athlone, Custume Barracks has one also and there is one in Cork. There are various Army detention barracks where these sentences could be served and nobody would be any the worse for it.
I deny any suggestion that the military police—and I hope Deputy Tully will back me—will beat the brains out of people coming into their custody. Neither Deputy Tully nor I ever loved the military police very much, but they are not as bad as we made them out to be and they are certainly not savages. There is quite a lot of unnecessary and quite unfounded criticism about this Bill. I hope more attention will be paid to it on the Committee Stage. There are matters which are of significance mostly to the lawyers but the main problem of the Bill—we are all agreed about flick knives, offensive weapons and so on—is what we are going to do to preserve society from disruption through the actions of irresponsible people who, by the exercise of what they assert is their inalienable right, would tear the community apart.
As the Minister said, there is no unqualified right of public assembly in the Constitution simply because the Constitution was drawn up by realists who knew what they were at. The right has to be qualified to some extent. Nobody may exercise his right to the extent of infringing on the rights of others. I hope that, sooner or later, we shall get round to the point of view that we shall talk less of our rights and more of our duties. We all have a duty to the community, to serve it, to build it up and bring it together.
References have been made to Northern Ireland already. The only reference I want to make is this: there is a society which is flying apart and where anything now may happen, a terribly dangerous situation, no matter what politics you have. Everyone realises that something catastrophic is happening in Northern Ireland at present where everything is flying apart and you have this complete disintegration.
Comment on this
(Cavan): If measures such as some of the provisions of this Bill counted for anything Northern Ireland would be the ideal state.
Comment on this
That is utter nonsense and well the Deputy knows it. There is no comparison between anything in this Bill and what they have in Northern Ireland.
Comment on this
What the Deputy is saying is untrue. It is utter nonsense. You are giving them fodder to use. It is typical of the Deputy's Party's attitude. He wants to give them fodder to use up there. He sold it out to them in the first place.
Comment on this
I shall give Deputy Fitzpatrick the benefit of the doubt. I do not think he is as stupid as he pretends to be. I do not think he really believes what he says. I hope he does not because if he does I am very sorry for him. There is no comparison whatever——
Comment on this
——but there is a danger in our own society, which we see breaking out on all sides to a comparatively small extent at the moment in this business of sitting down, lying down and obstructing traffic. It is a mercy that so far we have not got around to burning buses or actually beating the gardaí or breaking up private property. If we honestly believe that in this holy island that we shall never do these things I believe we are codding ourselves. The infection is spreading. It will only be a matter of time. Unless there is some control we shall find certain elements in our society desperately trying to get a grip on it in order to tear it apart and destroy it.
I do not want to mince words about this. I do not want to restrict the right of expression of opinion as I have said before, I am one of the few in the House who can speak as one who is congenitally in a minority. I know what it is like to be in a minority since I was born and brought up in a minority and I am conscious of the necessity to safeguard the rights of minorities all the time. But there are rights of the majority also and I should be the last to allow a minority to exercise its rights to the extent of endangering society. We are facing that. If we regard this in a cool quiet way we ought to be able between us all to frame legislation which will give sufficient power to the forces of law and order and command sufficient public support to prevent these disruptive forces gaining control. I am not afraid of a defeat for a political Party.
Comment on this
I am afraid of the disruption of a complete political system, a political system which has been built up over the years and which has safeguarded the rights of minorities and given a stable society. Let us not throw that to the winds. I do not say that the ultimate disaster would have occurred if an alternative Government were put into power. I do not believe that, but I do believe that all of us are guardians of a system which has been established and has worked well and kept this society coherent, and if we throw that to the winds and allow this disruptive element to gain control, all the blood, sweat, toil and tears will have been in vain.
I think this is a good Bill basically. It has done a good deal of tidying up and codifying. When you go through the list of repeals you can see that an enormous amount of research must have been done. It is obviously a good idea to get as much as possible all together in what will be one Act. This is a good effort. It is not the final answer to anything, not even flick knives. The fact that we make it illegal to carry them in certain places does not mean that nobody will ever again be found carrying a flick knife in a dancehall. All it means is that if you are caught with a flick knife you will get the hammer and that is right and proper. We have got to show our teeth as legislators: we will not tolerate the flouting of the forces of law and order and sit idly by. We cannot do that. We have too heavy a responsibility.
I commend this Bill to the House. I had been reasonably happy with it, with small reservations. They have now gone because sections 30 and 31 will be rephrased in a more workable way. I never objected to them because I thought they were wrong. I thought they were right in principle but hard to make practical. I sympathise with the Opposition because they were all geared up to make a big issue of this, but when sections 30 and 31 were so readily conceded by the Minister, they were left with very little to bite on. Even poor Deputy Michael O'Higgins had to go back to the Association of Civil Liberty and to quote their nonsense from their memorandum. It is a pity for them, now. They had made a tremendous effort to defeat this Bill, to oppose it tooth and nail. They discovered that there were virtually two sections which they opposed and they are now under review. Even the Civil Liberty Association approved of the Bill but suggested that another look be taken at these two sections. We had a rainbow or a mirage, but now there is nothing contentious in it: most of it is a re-enactment and a recodification of existing legislation. I did disagree with Deputy Andrews—he and I have had many arguments—but we have come more closely together on this. There has been give and take, which is a healthy sign in any political Party. We are determined that we shall get this Bill.
Comment on this
(Cavan): A three-card-trick on the people of Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown: one supports it, the other opposes it.
Comment on this
It is better than the other Deputies there who never open their mouths. I am determined that we shall get some replacement for sections 30 and 31 which will give power—I deliberately use that word and I do not make apology for it—to the community to defend themselves. Let us stop talking about giving power to the Government, to the State. This is giving power to the agents of the community, to all of us, to protect ourselves against violent minorities. We have examples to follow from other countries, but do not let us follow those examples all the way. Let us act now while we still have time. If we do not, either this Government or their successors will be forced to take the most brutal measures which will kill freedom for many years.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I rise to support the amendment standing in the name of Deputy M.J. O'Higgins, which proposes:
To delete all words after "That" and substitute: "Dáil Éireann declines to give a Second Reading to the Bill on the grounds that certain of the provisions contained in PartVI and Part VIII constitute an unnecessary interference with long established democratic rights of citizens and may involve An Garda Síochána in matters of a party political character."
I believe that the Bill, as drafted and brought into this House, represents the climax in a dangerous trend in Government thinking and legislative proposals which has been apparent here for some time. I refer to the trend of using a sledgehammer to kill a fly. That trend has been most apparent in many Bills brought into this House by the Government in recent years. For example, we have the power conferred by the Road Traffic Act of arrest for dangerous parking. This is the sort of unnecessary proposals I have detected in Government thinking since I came into the House.
Deputy Booth made a song and dance about this Bill and about the virtues of many of its sections. He skated very lightly around sections 30 and 31 and more or less dealt with them as if they had never been intended by the Minister to come into effect. These sections are still in the Bill and they represent Government thinking and Government proposals up to a very recent date. They represent the thinking of the present Minister until he was forced and coerced by the Fianna Fáil Ard-Fheis into giving in on these sections. These are the sections we are against and I can only discuss this Bill and approach it with the provisions of Parts VI and VIII in it.
We are in the strange position of having to give a Second Reading to this Bill, not as it stands but on the vague assurance contained in the Minister's speech that on Committee Stage it will be a different Bill. It would have been a decent thing for the Minister, when he saw the light and when he got the message from public opinion, which has been in the air since this Bill was circulated, to withdraw the Bill and redraft and reintroduce it into the House so that we would have a proper discussion on the Second Reading.
I ask myself why did the Government bring in this Bill with sections 30 and 31. I do not believe that it was introduced by the Minister's predecessor after mature consideration; I do not believe that these sections were written into this Bill in the Minister's Department after prolonged consideration and after full assessment of their effect on conditions in this country. I am convinced that these and other objectionable sections in this Bill were written into it in a fit of bad temper by the Minister for Justice on the direction of the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, following the dispute in 1967 with the farmers. I think that within this Bill, and the White Paper which accompanies it, there is ample evidence that these sections were written into the Bill in pursuance of a war being waged by the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries and the Government on the organised farmers in this country because Deputies will note that this House ordered and gave permission for the printing of this Bill as far back as 22nd June, 1967. We all know that in the ordinary course of events a measure is circulated to the public and the Press, very often within a matter of days and, usually, within a week or two. What happened here? The First Stage of the Bill was taken on 22nd June, 1967. From the explanatory memorandum we learn that the Bill was not released for public consideration until nearly 12 months later in May, 1968.
What happened in the interval? We know that the Government and the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries went to war with the farmers. We know that members of the NFA were taken off State boards. We know that Government advertising was withdrawn from the official organ of the NFA. Between June, 1967, and the circulation of this Bill in May, 1968, these obnoxious sections were written into the Bill, the sections which the Minister is now compelled by the strength of public opinion to withdraw, the sections from which he is now running away. Simultaneously, and with quite indecent haste, the Marts Bill was introduced. That Bill had to be rushed through this House. Everything else had to be dropped in order to get a crack at the farmers and the NFA.
Comment on this
On a point of order. The relevancy of the Marts Bill or the NFA on this Bill is not apparent to me.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I want to relate the reasons for introducing this Bill to the contents of the Bill. I say this is not a measure introduced in good faith, after mature consideration, for the protection of the majority; it is introduced as part of a private vendetta between the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries—the Minister who has been disowned by the Taoiseach, but not sacked—and the farming community. I submit that that is relevant.
Comment on this
(Cavan): The arguments adduced in favour of this Bill have not convinced me. Is it suggested that existing law is not sufficient to enable those responsible to achieve the alleged objectives proposed in this Bill—the preservation of law and order, the maintenance of the freedom of the roads and streets? I suggest that existing law is sufficient to achieve all that. Indeed, during the dispute with the farmers in 1967 the Minister and his colleagues had enough machinery under the existing law to preserve peace and the freedom of the roads and streets.
I suggest that this measure has been introduced in bad faith. It is quite unnecessary. I should like the Minister to "come clean" with the House and tell us now whether or not he approves of the Bill. As far as I can ascertain, the Minister stands over every syllable in the Bill, though he has been somewhat reluctantly compelled to amend it. The Minister stood over the Bill on television. He is reported at a meeting in Cork as strongly defending it. He attacked every newspaper that disagreed with him. He alleged that those who opposed the Bill were professional agitators who had no interest in the welfare of the country, who were interested only in creating disturbances. I should like to know if those are still the Minister's sentiments. Are the views he expressed a month ago his real views on this Bill?
At the Ard Fheis, as far as one could gather from television, he seemed to resent deeply the reports in some of the papers and the challenge laid before him at the Ard Fheis. He was compelled to defend the Bill. The chairman at the Ard Fheis sought to avoid a democratic decision on the Bill.
Comment on this
(Cavan): It was a study in democracy. It was a study in handing down decisions. I should like to discuss it, but it would be a lengthy discussion.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Indeed, we had one newspaper reporting the delegates as unanimous in favour of Taca and also unanimous against it. I am sorry for discussing parts of the Ard Fheis which are not relevant to this Bill, but the Minister more or less invited me to do so.
The Minister should have withdrawn this Bill and introduced a new measure, a measure we could discuss on Second Stage and amend on Committee Stage. Instead of that we have here the most objectionable sections being, as it were, ditched; we have vague assurances. I have read the Minister's opening speech carefully and I do not believe that the Minister himself believes in these assurances he gives that he will amend the objectionable sections.
When will we have the Committee Stage? Will we have it before the general election? Or will the Bill be shelved? If we do not have it before the next general election I shall be quite happy because then we will never hear of it again; it will fall with the Minister and his Government.