We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 42: Posts and Telegraphs (Resumed).

Contributions 111–238 of 238. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

——but there is only the one way of dealing with it and that is to do away with this kind of thing. I have seen this sort of thing happen in my own county, for instance, in Collinstown and in Castlepollard, where married men had done the job for three or four months on a temporary basis, but when the permanent appointments were taking place, members of the local Fianna Fáil club got the wink to leave their jobs, sign on for a week at the exchange and these were the people who got the permanent appointments. It is time that this type of corruption was wiped out of this country.

I should like now to deal with what the Minister stated in his opening remarks, as recorded at column 1884 of Volume 238, of the Official Report of 27th February, 1969, when he spoke about the weaknesses of human nature and defects in the social and economic structure leaving

not an impression of constructive policies to be pursued but a cynical and destructive impact on the viewer and listener.

I agree with the Minister in his remarks and in his castigation of Radio Telefís Éireann in that regard because I believe there is much good in our people. A large section of our people are engaged in voluntary organisations such as the Cancer Fund, taking care of the old folk, the Rehabilitation Institute, housing for old people, tourist organisations, Muintir na Tíre and numerous other organisations. It would be a good idea if we had more programmes in this country about the excellent voluntary work being done by these organisations.

We are told that our people are becoming cynical. Perhaps a section of them are, and there is a certain attitude of "I'm all right, Jack"; but there is a section of our community who are good Christians and do excellent work. I do not think they get the amount of publicity they should on RTE. The agitators and such like get much more publicity than they are entitled to. I agree with the Minister in that regard. The Minister continued and stated:

I understand also that the Authority has taken steps to modify the recent trend in interviewing persons of all political and social opinions in a manner which has aroused the strongest criticism.

Deputy Briscoe referred to this interview a few minutes ago and stated that the Minister was talking about rudeness in interviewing. There is not a word there about rudeness. The Minister mentions the word "trend" in interviewing people of all political and social opinions and states that the Authority has taken steps to modify the recent trend. If there was occasion for having to do this—and I do not believe there is—I feel it is wrong that the Minister should broadcast this to the whole world. I should like to know from whom has come the strongest criticism. I should like to know what political Party or what people have objected. So far as we are concerned, I do not think anybody in our Party has objected. Many of them have been on television. We have been questioned and put through the mill. That is part of the work of those professional people. It is their duty and we do not condemn them for it. Deputy Andrews at column 2385, Volume 238 said:

These people should be allowed to continue but should be requested to engage in unprejudiced and unbiased interviewing, if at all possible and, if they do not do it, then the answer is to tell them to bring their contracts to an end.

That is very harsh language from Deputy Andrews. These people should be allowed to continue. Why should they not be allowed to continue? I think that is a very dangerous trend which should and must be resisted by the Deputies in this House and by the people in this country. I want to say here that anybody as deeply seated in politics as the present Authority are not interested in persons, to quote the Minister, "of all political and social opinions". There is too much at stake for them and their friends. They are there because of Fianna Fáil and their main interest in life is to keep Fianna Fáil in office and not let the Irish people know the truth of the arrogance, the dictatorial methods and the corruption of the present Government. Their motives and the motives of the Minister are suspect, especially as this is an election year, when Fianna Fáil again want to try and brainwash the Irish people as they have tried to do for so long. I know, and those of us in politics who know Fianna Fáil well enough know, that that is what they want to do. I know their methods. I know that there are certain members of this Authority, if not the majority of them, who would stoop to anything to keep Fianna Fáil, their friends, in power.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I would draw the Deputy's attention again to the fact that the people the Deputy is mentioning are not in the House and have not an opportunity of defending themselves.

Comment on this

I have not mentioned anybody's name. I understand that in Parliament one is entitled to attack the Authority that has been set up by the Minister. I do not think there is anything wrong in attacking the Authority or in attacking members of the Authority.

Comment on this

Has the Deputy nothing constructive to say?

Comment on this

I say what I believe to be true.

Comment on this

We want constructive suggestions.

Comment on this

I remember Deputy Donogh O'Malley telling me that people have very short memories. He said only the last three to six months before a general election counted.

Comment on this
A Deputy

He cannot defend himself anyway.

Comment on this

I would not say a derogatory word against Deputy Donogh O'Malley, the late Minister. He was an excellent man, God rest his soul. He believed that the last three months before an election was the time that counted. It is the last three to four months that the people remember. That is why Fianna Fáil are trying to make certain now that no adverse publicity will be put across on RTE.

Comment on this

The last furlong.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Estimate for Posts and Telegraphs is before the House and the Telephone Capital Bill.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil should have no complaint to make against RTE. On average, if you look at the news any evening at 9.30 p.m., there will be shots of at least three to seven Ministers or Parliamentary Secretaries appearing in different parts of the country. The Government are certainly getting their share of publicity on RTE. The people should have a chance of viewing and hearing the public representatives and should see them and hear them as they really are.

I have spoken to many people and I have not heard that the interviewing that has taken place has, to use the Minister's words, "aroused the strongest criticism". It may have aroused criticism from certain Fianna Fáil people, but not from the ordinary people who view television. I have been interviewed, and interviewed vigorously, on television. I was put through the mill on television on two or three occasions. I was interviewed on one occasion when I was put out of this House and the questions were thrown at me as quickly as they could be. They were awkward questions. That is the duty of the professional people. I did not object and I do not see why I should.

I have seen the late President Kennedy; I have seen Governor Nixon when he was Governor and going for the office of President of the United States and I have seen him as President; we have seen the Prime Minister of Britain, Mr. Wilson; we have seen Mr. Heath and we have seen many others interviewed on television. They have been vigorously interviewed. I think that is only right and I do not think any of them have objected or should object.

I think, too, that indeed the public are entitled to see each and every one of us as we are, with all our faults, our peculiarities, our idiosyncrasies, with all our warts, if you like. We are human beings, every one of us, with all the faults of humans and the majority of us are trying to do our best. Fianna Fáil people have mentioned a "trend" here. The Minister never used the word "rudeness" of interviewers: he talked about the "trend", which is a completely different thing. Does the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs only want Ministers, Parliamentary Secretaries, politicians, to appear on television with their speeches already made out for them and prepared for them by civil servants? Does he want them to come on, then, and to deliver their little Party bit, to smile and then to leave the scene? If he does, I do not think that that is the type of television the Irish people want and that the Irish people are interested in.

Comment on this

That would be ridiculous.

Comment on this

It would. However, we are entitled to be told what we shall get. That went on for years. It is only for the past two or three years that we have had what might be called, if you like, vigorous questioning of politicians. If the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, or any of us, enters public life, then, as well as having our duties and responsibilities, I believe we must take the risk of having to answer awkward questions.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

If a politician or a political Party is honest with the people and has nothing to hide and to cover up, they should never be afraid of the most probing questions. I am a hard-hitter. If we are hard-hitters, we should be able to take it on the chin and come back smiling. A few moments ago, speaking about the lack of respect for authority, we were treated to talk about rudeness and ignorance. There is nobody ruder nor more ignorant than a few of the Minister's own colleagues. We see it reflected here in this House, in the Parliament of our land, in rude and ignorant answers—and those are the servants of the people. Those people are paid to give at all times good example. They do not give it here in this House. The Minister should put his own house in order and ask his own colleagues who are Ministers not to be as rude and as arrogant as they are and as they have been in this House for a long number of years in their answering of questions and in their approach, also, to the Irish people.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

This is not relevant to the debate before the House at the moment.

Comment on this

If there is this trend in questioning politicians on Radio Telefís Éireann that the Minister is talking about and as we have been told by other speakers, I think we should remember that politicians are not tin gods and that we should not expect to be treated as such. We had Deputy Blaney, the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, leaving Radio Telefís Éireann at Montrose in a huff recently because he was messed about. Imagine anybody messing about the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries. He was not allowed to read a transcript of what Mr. Maher intended to say. Think of a man being messed about because he was waiting for ten minutes—a servant of the people, a man who kept the farmers of this country waiting for 21 days on the steps of his Department and was not even polite enough to meet those particular people.

What is the use in talking about rudeness and politeness if our Ministers of State, who are the servants of the people, give such bad example? I am paid by the people of this country. I am a servant of the people. It is my duty to be polite with the people and to meet them. Here was a man who refused to do that and then, because he is supposed to have been kept waiting at Montrose for ten minutes, he was messed about and he left in a huff. Good God, we are not tin gods and the Minister, like anybody else, should be able to take anything like that on the chin and then forget all about it.

I want to say that the staff of Radio Telefís Éireann—as far as I know and from what I hear in my talks with independent people—have done a fine job within the confines, I suppose, of the money available. As far as I am concerned, I believe that the skill and the impartiality of the staff of Radio Telefís Éireann is beyond reproach and I think it is deserving of the highest praise. Those people are becoming more professional at their jobs than they were in the past and it is my belief that they are as competent a staff as is to be found in any television station in the world. I want to say that it is because I have the utmost respect for their professional ability and integrity that I consider it most important that they be free from any intimidation, direct or implied, by the Minister, Deputy Childers, or by Deputy Andrews or by any other little wouldbe dictators in this country. I strongly protest against the continuous efforts of this Government, over a long number of years, to control the Radio Telefís Éireann Authority and to use it as an instrument of Fianna Fáil propaganda. This Parliament, and the Members of Parliament, should be jealous to guard the freedom of the press, of Radio Telefís Éireann and of the whole mass media of communication in this country because I believe freedom cannot exist in this country if Radio Telefís Éireann is to become the plaything of Government Ministers or of Government Deputies.

On a television programme last Sunday night—"The Riordans"—one of the characters, Batty, I think, said that, if there was a change of Government, subsidies might not be paid on milk and——

Comment on this

Get rid of Batty.

Comment on this

No. That is not true. I do not agree with what he said but I do agree with his right to say it and I would defend to the last his right to make those remarks in a play or in any of those things on Radio Telefís Éireann. I do not believe what he said: I do not believe it is true but I believe in his right to say that on Radio Telefís Éireann.

Comment on this

Do not blame poor Batty. It is the scriptwriters.

Comment on this

Wait until Minnie gets at you.

Comment on this

I know. I am saying that I agree entirely with his right——

Comment on this

It is something at which we could take umbrage if we liked but we do not.

Comment on this

The Deputy is getting in his plug all the same.

Comment on this

The scriptwriter got his little plug in, too.

Comment on this

I am old enough to remember when there was little freedom of speech in this country and when meetings were broken up and the people who did that were aided and abetted by others who should have been preaching charity and neighbourly relations. I remember the Taoiseach at that time said that it was no part of his duty to make men or causes popular.

Comment on this

Reference please.

Comment on this

I want to throw those words back into his teeth tonight if he is listening. I say that it is no part of Telefís Éireann's job to make erroneous policies appear attractive or to present favourable images of Ministers who by their deliberate and shady actions have brought odium on themselves and on the Government. If the Fianna Fáil Party wish to be associated with the activities of self-seeking groups in their fund-raising campaign——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

What has this to do with the Estimate and the Bill?

Comment on this

——I will relate this to the Estimate—they must be prepared to take the consequences and to remember that Shakespeare said, "bloody instructions which being taught return to plague the inventor." Each and every one of us in public life should be jealous of the right of free speech which we have so dearly won through the blood and sweat and toil——

Comment on this

And tears.

Comment on this

Yes, and tears too, of past generations. We should certainly do our part to hold on to that. If Fianna Fáil want a private television service let their wealthy backers in Taca and other elements finance it but in the meantime the headquarters of Radio Telefís Éireann will remain at Montrose and not at Mount Street or Oakley Grove in Blackrock either. I want to say to the Minister and to the Government that there should be "hands off" Radio Telefís Éireann. Telefís Éireann is paid for by the taxpayers and not by the Tacateers. During the recent Fianna Fáil Ard-Fheis slanderous statements were made by a lady delegate concerning some members of the RTE staff.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister would have little responsibility for such statements.

Comment on this

You could not control that woman.

Comment on this

In any case——

Comment on this

You cannot control any delegate who wants to speak.

Comment on this

——she made slanderous statements that morning in the presence of witnesses and the same evening the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, displaying a Paisley-like zeal, was on Telefís Éireann defending the worst influence ever experienced in public life in this country, namely, Taca. He may have had second thoughts about the wisdom——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This has nothing to do with the Estimate. The Minister is not responsible for every speech or statement made over Radio Telefís Éireann.

Comment on this

This is the reason, because of the grilling that Deputy Blaney, the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, got on Radio Telefís Éireann that evening when he was trying to defend this organisation, why the Authority is supposed to have warned those people. It is because of that grilling that he was supposed to have got that Deputy Andrews comes in here and tells us that their contracts should be brought to an end. Remember, Sir, this is an important question. It affects the livelihood of those people but it goes beyond that because it affects freedom of speech and there are those of us who remember when meetings were being broken up and we do not want to return to that. As long as the professional staff of Radio Telefís Éireann maintain the high standard they have displayed for the past two years they will get the complete support of this Party and of everyone who respects the right of our people to have minds of their own. I will never forget the Presidential election of June, 1966, when one of the candidates was holding successful meetings throughout the country, making excellent speeches, and yet his name was never mentioned on Telefís Éireann. The other candidate, however, was appearing every night and he had a programme laid on for him deliberately for three weeks, with the connivance of Radio Telefís Éireann——

Comment on this

Disgraceful.

Comment on this

For three weeks or a month he appeared in all newscasts and there were pictures of him here, there and everywhere throughout the country. He has not had such a busy time since nor had he for years before.

Comment on this

Neither has Deputy O'Higgins. He has not been seen in his constituency since.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will the Deputy keep to the Estimate?

Comment on this

We are entitled to compare the good work——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

No.

Comment on this

——and the independence of Telefís Éireann today with two years ago.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is not entitled to go back two years. The Vote is not referred back and we are committed to the past 12 months administration in the Department. Anything beyond that does not arise.

Comment on this

I believe that the day Radio Telefís Éireann becomes the mouthpiece of any political Party it becomes the tyrant of the people and the people will become the slaves of biased opinions. My eyes were opened on Saturday night last by a lady who appeared on the "Late, Late Show". She had lived in Germany before and during the 1939-1945 war and she said she was a supporter and a great admirer of the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, Deputy Childers. She stated that she was, indeed, as many people were, shocked to the core by the Minister for whom she had the greatest admiration. She referred to television as the defender of the people's liberty and she said that any effort to interfere with it was very dangerous and that we were starting on a very slippery slope. Indeed, it is only right to say that the Minister's speech has caused much alarm because it seems that the Government are bent on muzzling any and every medium that is not prepared to toe the Party line in a blind and unquestioning manner.

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this

The people should take heed. They should be warned by this particular lady who appeared on the panel of the "Late, Late Show" because what occurred in Germany had its origin in the suppression of free speech and free commentary on current affairs. Let there be no denying that if it happened in this country and if it were to succeed there is no doubt that the next thing Fianna Fáil would turn their attention to is the political commentators of our national newspapers.

Comment on this

That would be something, would it not? They would be run out of political life in about three weeks.

Comment on this

I remember the 1933 general election and I know there was very little freedom or free speech in this country at that time. I remember the intimidation——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It does not arise in the Estimate before the House at the moment.

Comment on this

We all know that Telefís Éireann was used in the past, and shamelessly used, as a medium for the spreading of Fianna Fáil propaganda. If I have any little fault to find it is this and I had better say it. Even at the recent 50th anniversary meeting of the Dáil the cameras were skilfully trained on the Fianna Fáil benches to the total exclusion of the Fine Gael Party. That is quite true. When Deputy Cosgrave was speaking Senator Thomas Mullins was to be seen in all his glory and the whole Fianna Fáil Party was shown at least six times.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not see how the Minister has any responsibility for the manner in which cameras were used.

Comment on this

If the Deputy thinks I ordered that he is talking nonsense.

Comment on this

I do not know who ordered it. I am only mentioning it as one small criticism of what has happened.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It does not arise.

Comment on this

It has been shamelessly used and abused by the Fianna Fáil Party for propaganda and for propaganda effects. We all know what happened in the past in Germany. We know that when Dr. Goebbels was in complete control of the mass-medium of radio the people became brainwashed from listening to what Hitler and the Nazis wanted them to hear. The people believed what they wanted them to believe. They became completely brainwashed and they blindly marched to their doom. Six million Jews were annihilated at that time.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This has nothing to do with the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs.

Comment on this

I am not sure and I am not saying it has.

Comment on this

The Deputy is just joking.

Comment on this

I am saying that interference with television or radio can have this effect. The people were brainwashed by Hitler and the Nazis. Six million Jews were annihilated and 90 per cent of the German people knew nothing about it and cared less.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Could we come to the Estimate now?

Comment on this

We do not want a similar brainwashing in this country.

Comment on this

The Deputy has a very poor view of the Irish people if he thinks that any attempt to do that would meet with the slightest success. He has the lowest estimate of the Irish people if he thinks that any attempt to do that would suceed.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil have fooled the Irish people for a long number of years.

Comment on this

Any attempt to muzzle RTE would certainly lose us this or any other general election.

Comment on this

What is wrong with the trend at RTE at the present time that you want to try to muzzle them?

Comment on this

Your are the fellows who used the gag.

Comment on this

If I wanted to muzzle them I would be going in the direction of certainly losing the general election for my Party so why would I do it?

Comment on this

Sure you are going to lose it anyway.

Comment on this

You will talk us out of it

Comment on this

The Minister talked about trends in his speech. I do not agree with what Deputy Briscoe stated tonight about aggressive and bullying methods having been adopted by interviewers on Telefís Éireann. I also disagree with an article which appeared in a Sunday paper of March 2nd but that does not arise on this so, therefore, I will not mention it.

Comment on this

What paper was it? Tell us?

Comment on this

On "Panorama" deep and searching questions are asked of Ministers of State. They are asked questions on policy, on their programmes, on the promises that have been made and broken or have not been fulfilled. We do not see any objection from the Government to this type of television questioning in England.

I want to condemn, as far as I am concerned, in the strongest possible manner the intimidation which has not only been expressed but has been implied in this debate by the Minister, by Deputy Andrews and by at least two or three other Fianna Fáil Deputies. I believe that if an end is not put to this type of intimidation at once the welfare of the Irish people will be at stake no matter what may be said here because no Party or group in this country has a monopoly of wisdom. It is only by a process of discussion and of dialogue that we can arrive at the truth in our time and if there is any attempt by Fianna Fáil or any other political Party to channel discussions along one particular course we are doomed to failure.

In my opinion the Minister's speech and especially the speech of Deputy Andrews are veiled threats to all organs of public opinion. They are an effort to intimidate them from exposing the arrogance, the faults and the weaknesses of Fianna Fáil Ministers on the eve of a general election. It is clear beyond any shadow of doubt, no matter what the Minister may say, that the Government are anxious to curb the lawful activities of RTE and that they are starting by trying to muzzle the interviewers on television. The reason for that is quite clear. In recent weeks Fianna Fáil Ministers have wilted under questioning from those interviewers. One example is the questioning Fianna Fáil got about Taca and other activities on the night of the Fianna Fáil Ard-Fheis.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We are concerned with only one Minister, the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs.

Comment on this

The Deputy is repeating statements over and over again.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy must address himself to the Estimate before the House. What Ministers said or did not say does not arise on this Estimate.

Comment on this

It is a well-known fact that certain professionals in RTE will never be forgiven by the Fianna Fáil Government for their performance throughout the referendum and this is plain to be seen from the attacks that have been made on them by delegates to the Fianna Fáil Ard-Fheis and now by the Minister and Deputy Andrews. If the Minister and Deputy Andrews and some other Fianna Fáil Deputies had their way they would give the nation piped television from Fianna Fáil headquarters at Mount Street.

Comment on this

I intend to intervene very briefly on this. I have a few other things which I might want to mention but I should like to give my own personal views on what seems to be the main topic in this debate and in the newspaper reports and television and radio reports, that of interviewing by interviewers on Telefís Éireann.

Before I go on to that I should like to mention a few other things. At a time when civil servants particularly are being criticised and when Ministers are being held responsible for things for which they have no responsibility, I want frankly to pay my tribute to the Minister as Minister for Posts and Telegraphs and to his excellent staff. It should be said, and I want to say it, that as far as competency in his Department is concerned Deputy Childers is one of the best. Might I qualify that by saying that when he goes away from his Department and delves into economics, social affairs and health, I do not agree with him. As far as his Ministry is concerned he should be paid the tribute that I have paid him because in my dealings with the Department I receive prompt replies, copies of all letters and get general satisfaction. I do not mean to say that I get every telephone that I look for or every postman appointed that I would recommend. No. I do not think we expect all these miracles. We do expect and do not get from other Departments, I am sorry to say, what we get from the Minister's Department, namely, promptness and courtesy. That tribute should be paid not alone to the Minister, who is the political head of the Department, but to his officials and to all the officials down the country whether they be postmasters or postmistresses, postmen or those who work in the telephone exchange. I have no real fault with them. There may be some instances where I might make criticism but this would be exaggerating any type of criticism that might be made against the Minister and his Department.

Before I talk about the subject I mentioned, I should like to raise a few matters, local if you like, that seem to be neglected. Deputy Allen could not understand when I was talking on health and said that Wexford town and county were being run down. I do not think it is quite good enough that we should be left absolutely last in the provision of an automatic telephone service. The Minister did not mention this in his speech. I do not expect him to mention every area. We are still very primitive.

I called to the local telephone exchange recently and was amazed to discover, in a room as big as the room the Minister and his Parliamentary Secretary may have in Leinster House, about 16 girls working. I am quite sure that there was a contravention of the Offices Act which defines the amount of space there should be and the facilities that should be provided. There is some work going on for the provision of the automatic exchange. I would ask that it be expedited and that we would have the automatic exchange as quickly as possible, not only for the convenience of subscribers but, more importantly, for the convenience of the girls who work in the exchange.

In this debate the usual matters that are raised seem to have been forgotten or at least as much emphasis has not been placed on them, for instance, the question of auxiliary postmen, the conditions of sub-postmasters and sub-postmistresses, the giving out of the jobs, the appointments, and all that sort of thing. Practically every speaker asked that some degree of justice be given to auxiliary postmen. Of all workers in the community these are in almost the worst category. They are expected to take on a job, particularly when they are nominated by the exchange, that entails about 20 hours work, for which they get a very small wage amounting, perhaps, to half the normal week's wage in a rural district. When the matter is raised, the inevitable reply is that they should be able to take on other employment. It is not so easy to get other part-time employment to supplement the wages given to auxiliary postmen. There should be some real effort made not alone to provide auxiliary postmen with decent wages but to compensate them by way of pension on retirement. There is no use in talking about the Rowland Hill Fund or about the old age pension or sickness benefit or unemployment benefit. As civil servants, even though not full-time or established, auxiliary postmen are entitled to some consideration in view of the very difficult work they have to do, travelling miles up and down hills and mountains in all weathers, either walking or cycling.

The Minister should also consider the question of congestion in the post offices on certain days, for instance, when the old age pension or widows' and orphans' pensions are being paid. This rush of business on one day in the week or the month does not make for expedition or progress in the post office. There should be a special arrangement for the payment of children's allowances. Accommodation adjacent to the post office should be acquired where children's allowances could be paid.

I should like to comment on Radio Éireann and to congratulate the Authority not only on the extension of programmes but on the type of programmes now broadcast from early in the morning until late at night. When we criticise Radio Éireann or Telefís Éireann we should remind ourselves that we are very limited in that we have only one station. There are some of us who want pop music while others want chamber music, opera, discussion or sport. Radio Éireann has been in a very difficult position because of the fact that we have only one radio station and therefore cannot cater exclusively for one particular taste or choice. In Radio Éireann we have a station that is trying to do what the BBC could be regarded as doing successfully in Great Britain where they have four radio stations and perhaps a few subsidiaries. We can receive classical music and serious discussion from Radio 3. We can get pop music for 18 hours per day on BBC 1, a station that has deteriorated somewhat in my view in that it is devoted almost exclusively to very light entertainment. I listen to Radio Éireann in the car while going around the country. The programmes are good. They broadcast good music and pop music, Irish music, Irish language programmes and sport programmes, particularly on Saturday afternoons. In my view, the programmes broadcast by Radio Éireann are very varied and the station is doing a magnificent job having regard to the fact that we have only one radio station. It is true, of course, that we can receive programmes from the Continent and Britain. Having regard to the resources and the small number of people expected to finance Radio Éireann, the station is giving good value for the money we have to pay in licence fees.

The same could be said for Telefís Éireann. Of course, it is impossible to please everybody. I was amused to hear a very responsible and a very intelligent Deputy of the Fine Gael Party saving that he liked cowboy films. This demonstrates the variety in taste. If I can get a football match or horserace meeting on television, that is my cup of tea because I am interested in these sports. I do not think any of us is in a position to criticise. I am of a certain age group. Deputy Kyne is of a certain age group. I have a fair idea — not of his age — but of what the Minister's taste is in the arts and music. I must have regard to the views of my ten-year-old son. He loves Tarzan films and cartoons. My wife may like something else. Other members of my family may want cowboy films or thrillers. We cannot be dogmatic in our criticism of either Radio Éireann or Telefís Éireann. It is impossible to please everybody and regard must be had to the varying ages of viewers. In my view it is abominable that Telefís Éireann should broadcast pop music even for half an hour in the week but my view is not the one that should necessarily overrule others. There are many people in this country, teenagers and those in their early twenties, who want more and more pop music. However, when the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs was in his late teens and in his twenties and thirties I am sure he was a jazz fiend. He would not be natural if he were not. We have all gone through these different stages. There are people of 70 and 80 who love to hear, for example, "The Archers" or "The Dales" programme. What I am trying to say is that we have only one television station. Some of us are very fortunate in that, particularly on the east coast, we have a choice. I can get Welsh Independent or Welsh BBC television, and I can switch to those if I like. However, people in other parts of the country must put up — let me say for want of a better expression — with RTE and they may be annoyed at times.

I do not know whether or not it would be a good thing to encourage the establishment of another television station. I do not know whether it would do any harm. Our responsibility is to the station which was established by the State and for which we as taxpayers and contributors by way of licence fees are responsible. Therefore, as I say, none of us can afford to be dogmatic in our criticisms, to say it is slovenly, that there is a preponderance of cowboys, of pop music, operatic or classical music. As long as we are satisfied that there is a balance catering for all ages from two or three up to 85, then we should be reasonably content.

We could criticise the various shows, particularly the live shows, but it is entering on very dangerous ground because inevitably we must mention names. I remember mentioning in this House the name of an announcer of whom I was being very critical — I forget what his name was but it was a sincere criticism — and the next day, not because of any criticism I made, the man was sacked. I was blamed by my friends and supporters for getting the man sacked, so for that reason I shall not mention people by name except perhaps to praise them, but certainly not to criticise them.

The emphasis here has been on the interviews and politics generally on television. There was a silly suggestion in some of the newspapers that politicians and their wives were invited to go on the "Late, Late Show" and they refused. There was no such invitation. In any case, if I were invited on the "Late, Late Show" by myself I would refuse to go on it if the subject were to be politics. I was asked on one occasion in what circumstances I would go on the "Late, Late Show" and I said if there was no discussion about politics: may be to tell yarns, to talk about football, horses or other subjects of conversation. I do not think the "Late, Late Show," with all due respect to it — it is an excellent programme — is the proper sort of programme for a serious discussion on politics.

It would not be fair to subject any of us in this House to a political discussion, whether it be on the Criminal Justice Bill, the Third Programme for Economic and Social Development, or anything else, with some fellow who was "way out" sitting alongside you, somebody who was trying to be funny. This has happened on the "Late, Late Show." Any of us could try to be honest and direct but the whole thing could be made a laugh of. Public representatives could be brought into disrepute because politics were being discussed in a wrong atmosphere and with the wrong type of people for that subject.

There is one thing which irritates me, and I do not know whether or not the Minister has mentioned this matter. It is not, I suppose, a very serious criticism, but some of our announcers appear to have become somewhat careless in broadcasting the news. Some of them slur their words, and one of the biggest faults I find is that they appear to have no regard for commas or full stops. They simply run one sentence into another. There is no pause at all between the end of one sentence and the beginning of another or between a headline and the first sentence after that. However, that is not a very serious sort of criticism.

On this business of interviewers and being interviewed on television I want to talk about my own experience; I cannot speak for Deputy Tom Kyne or anybody else. Let me say that any time I go on television, for hours beforehand I am terrified. However, that is my own fault. It has been suggested here that the Minister or some other member of the Government might direct Telefís Éireann as to how their interviewers should interview. Under the Act of Parliament we passed to set up RTE, no Minister has the power to tell RTE what they should do. If they attempted it that is one thing but if they succeed it is the fault of the Authority. If RTE take directions from the Taoiseach or any Minister of State or if they are influenced by us it is their own fault. They are operating under a particular Act of Parliament and if they do not adhere to that they should be sacked. However, I do not think they are that weak that they would even be influenced by the comments the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs made here last week.

I do not know how the Minister voices his criticisms in RTE. He should only give advice or, if he veers to within the terms of the Act, give a direction to RTE. However, the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs should have the same right as any Deputy in this House to make his views known. If they give extra weight to what the Minister says it is shame on them. He is entitled to talk about the "Late, Late Show" or any other programme on RTE, but the RTE Authority are weak if they listen to every murmur of the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs or any other member of the Government.

The one criticism I would make particularly about the Fianna Fáil Ministers is that they do not appear often enough on television. There are notable exceptions there who, I am sure, must have been invited to appear on television but have refused because they are afraid they would be exposed. There are some Ministers who acquitted themselves pretty well, but there are others who have not appeared and who, particularly when measures affecting their Departments are going through the House, should be prepared to appear and make their views known to the general public. As I say, there are some notable exceptions who appear to me to be afraid of these interviews about which I will talk in a few moments. There may be some exaggerations as to what might happen in RTE, but my message and that of my Party to RTE is that they should be independent of any influence. It may be I would ring them up and say: "That was a bloody awful thing you did last night." I am entitled to do that, but they should not be unduly influenced by my saying that.

In regard to the visit of the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, Deputy Blaney, to RTE I do not know what happened nor is it any concern of mine, but from the very first time I entered Montrose — I was in the company of Deputy Dillon the first time — I have received the utmost courtesy and help from every single member of the staff in Montrose. I got advice when I asked for it. I was advised in respect of everything important as regards television. We did our best. We certainly were not television personalities, nor are we now, but that is not the fault of RTE because, as far as the politicians are concerned——

Comment on this

It is a wonder you would not learn to smile.

Comment on this

If I had such lovely teeth as Deputy Dillon has I should be smiling all the time. However, we all have different upper lips and some are stiffer than others. Now the Deputy has put me off——

Comment on this

We want you to smile the next time you are on Telefís Éireann.

Comment on this

It does not necessarily mean that I am happy or pleased when I am smiling. My expression is in my eyes. I was speaking about the courtesy and help I always receive in RTE. I have had rough interviews. There was one particular interview in which I was slaughtered. It was not because the interviewer was rude; he was incisive; he knew his job. But he was interviewing me on a subject that was very wide-ranging and I was not conversant with every side of that subject. He took advantage of that and was right to do so. He cut me to ribbons. It was not his fault; it was my fault. I learned a little more from that interview than I knew when I was being interviewed by him. I think there was a slight improvement afterwards. Possibly, I could be accused on occasions also of being rude to the interviewer, perhaps not deliberately. I do not think all the fault is on one side.

If we are to give the impression to the people that we are afraid of Ted Nealon, David Thornley, Pádraig Gallagher or Joe Fahy or any of these, we are showing a weakness that the public in present circumstances will jump on because they will assume we have something to hide.

At present, despite all our efforts, the reputation of politicians is not very high. I do not mean Fianna Fáil Deputies or Ministers; I mean that there is a trend of thought in the country that is not so good for politicians. Perhaps it is not peculiar to this country. If we appear to want to dodge these people or ask them to be easier on us, the public will put a different interpretation on it. It is up to oneself; one does not have to go on television. I must at times: I am the Leader of the Labour Party for the present. The Taoiseach, Deputy Lynch, must be subject to this interviewing and so must Deputy Cosgrave and various other Members of the House. I do not think there is any real complaint against the interviewers. Perhaps they have something to learn also. If I had any complaint against Telefís Éireann interviewers it is that they do not leave enough time to the interviewee to talk, as compared, say, with the BBC or Independent Television.

Comment on this

That is a very formidable indictment.

Comment on this

What is?

Comment on this

That the interviewer does not leave the person being interviewed sufficient time to talk.

Comment on this

I think if the Deputy looks at the BBC or Independent Television he will find the interviewer asks his question and the interviewee is given sufficient time to talk out; he is not interrupted. I have not the slightest complaint against our interviewers. If we come badly out of the interviews it is our own fault. The public image of the person is damaged and, worse still, the image of the Party he represents.

There has been a discussion here about the coverage of the annual conferences. I do not know how one can measure that or if anybody has ever attempted to measure it in seconds and minutes. I can only speak for my own Party — the Fine Gael Ard Fheis has not been held yet. I have seen all the interviews and the coverage of the Fianna Fáil Ard Fheis. I could not complain about the time that was given to the Labour Party. We were extremely pleased. There are risks that one must take. Some member of the Minister's Party may say something outlandish, some well-meaning man. That does a little damage to the Fianna Fáil Party. One cannot help that; he said it; he is entitled to say it. Probably he does not know what he is talking about, but he says it. There were some such things; there always will be. It will probably happen in the Fine Gael Ard Fheis also, that somebody will say something and be in a very small minority as regards what he says, but you cannot avoid that. We have been a little unfortunate in our conference that some few things were taken out of it also; I do not object to that. I think it was a bad thing for us that what was said was attributed to the whole Party but Fianna Fáil suffered in the same respect, I think, as far as birth control and the pill were concerned. As regards coverage, I have no complaint to make of Radio Telefís Éireann.

Deputy L'Estrange mentioned the coverage, I think, of the Mansion House. I did not see it. I was there with the other Members of the Dáil and Seanad. I did not hear many complain. I think RTE would be very conscious of the risk they were running if they gave undue coverage by picture or words to any Party. I know the criticism has been made to RTE — perhaps by the Fianna Fáil Party; it was certainly mentioned to me — that the Labour Party were getting an undue amount of time on Telefís Éireann. I do not think this is so.

Neither do I complain about the referendum. All I ask is that RTE should behave as the BBC and Independent Television behave at particular times. In a general election the Tory Party, the Socialist Party, or if you like the Conservative Party, the Labour Party and the Liberal Party get equal time. I think the Liberal Party at present consist of about nine or ten members while the Government Party have well over 300. It is believed there that at election time there should be equal advantage for all Parties. Nobody can foretell the result of the election. If any yardstick should be used it should be the number of candidates put forward. We find that of about nine political telecasts we get one, leaving the balance for Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael and, of course, Fine Gael get fewer. Telefís Éireann should seriously consider giving equal time to all recognised Parties in the House. This they do in Britain, even apart from election time. They have what are called political broadcasts and all take their turn and have equal time, the Liberal Party, the Conservative Party and the Labour Party. I can see no reason why, because they happen to be the biggest Party now, Fianna Fáil should get, say, four times what the Labour Party get or four times what the Fine Gael Party get.

Perhaps the Minister would refer to this matter when replying. It is the influence that is used by advertisers in Telefís Éireann or Radio Éireann. I cannot say that I have any concrete evidence that there is influence, but it has been said to me — do not say: give us the evidence and we will talk about it — that the advertisers have an influence on the type of programme put on. I should like to know that was not so. I know they have an interest in the matter; they pay money for advertisements. They believe that Telefís Éireann is a good medium for the display or advertising of their products. There should be no element whatever of influence used by any advertiser or group of advertisers in regard to RTE programmes, which should be put on for the benefit of the public and not for the advertisers.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Malley

First of all, I want to refer to something that affects my own constituency. It was mentioned by Deputy Corish. It is the fact that those of us who live in the south and west have no choice of television channel. That is felt very deeply by Limerick people and by others in the south and west of Ireland. The attitude they take — quite reasonably, I think — is that they pay a £5 licence fee the same as those in the other half of the country but the latter have a choice of three and sometimes four channels. Almost the whole of Leinster and the three free counties of Ulster, which together comprise half the population of the country, have a choice of channels. This is understandably a cause of great annoyance to those in the south and west who have to pay just as much by way of licence fee to receive only one channel.

There are two possible ways in which the difficulty could be overcome. The Minister could make some arrangement to provide booster stations which would enable the BBC and ITV to be picked up by those who live in the south and west of the country or the Minister could give permission for a communal aerial which would enable BBC and ITV to be picked up in the south and west. The Minister has ruled against these aerials. I could not quite understand the Minister's reasoning for not allowing them. They are allowed in every other country. They are an aesthetic asset in any group of houses at all and I cannot understand why they should be disallowed here. One tends to think that it may possibly be to try to preserve something of a monopoly for RTE. That would be quite wrong because RTE does not have a monopoly in half the country and it is, therefore, wrong to inflict a monopoly on the other half who, because of their geographical location, find themselves in this difficulty. The argument may be put forward that it is better to have a national station only available but it must be borne in mind that anyone living in the south or west of Ireland can receive the majority of radio stations broadcasting in Europe. They can certainly receive every British radio station. Likewise, they can buy every British newspaper or, indeed, European newspaper if they are sufficiently interested. Television is simply another form of the dissemination of news and views and the people in the south and west are annoyed at being deprived of a choice.

I do not think the Department pays sufficient attention to philately. In recent years, fortunately, increasing attention has been given to it. A great deal of money could be made by the Department, money which would be almost exclusively earned from abroad and which would beneficially affect exports. If we concentrated, as many countries throughout the world do, on pushing our stamps abroad we could achieve very, very high sales indeed. The money received for stamps sold to philatelists is almost entirely clear profit and it is almost entirely an export profit as well. Many countries make hundreds of thousands of pounds every year from philately.

I am glad that the old definitive issue which survived here for upwards of 40 years has at last been got rid of because the design was very unsatisfactory. I think those stamps were designed in a hurry. There are a great many people, however, who are not at all happy with what has replaced them because some of the designs are extremely esoteric and I am not at all sure that they convey the image of the country here or abroad which they may have been intended to convey. The Minister will have to redesign these or issue a further definitive set of stamps in 1971 when decimal currency comes into operation. I would urge him to consider redesigning some of the more obscure of the present issue because the value from a national point of view of an ordinary definitive issue of stamps is immense. For 40 years we lost a great deal of goodwill and a great deal of advertising in our stamps. I should like to see the opportunities that are available to us being used to the full as soon as possible.

A great deal of this debate has been directed towards Radio Telefís Éireann. I do not want to go into details about particular programmes, though I may have views on some of them. I merely want to make a few general comments. One of the things that struck me in the Minister's speech and in the RTE report was that there seemed to be an effort to soften up the public so that the public would accept without protest an increase in the licence fee. I would oppose any such increase very strongly. It can hardly be justified when one remembers that Telefís Éireann made a surplus last year of £660,000. Part of that was offset by the loss on radio but, at the same time, Telefís Éireann is in what must be an almost unique position in that it has an income from licence fees and an income from advertising. Its income from advertising is very, very substantial. It has a monopoly of advertising on television. Its charges are understandably high. Its profits are equally high. I know it needs a great deal of money for capital investment but most of its capital investment must now be completed. It would impose a considerable hardship if the licence fee were to be increased above the existing figure of £5, which is, in my view, rather high. An increase is not justified in the case of people who are confined to one rather than three television channels.

I cannot see any possibility of a second Irish television channel being established. The cost would be utterly prohibitive. I do not see any immense problems in the way of a second radio channel, and I hope the Minister will be able to bring that about quite shortly because the cost of radio transmission must be quite limited in view of the large number of local stations that are being set up, or are about to be set up, in Britain and the enormous number of local stations which seem to be able to operate satisfactorily on advertising alone in the United States.

One aspect of the RTE programmes in general that has disturbed me is that they have tended to show, to a great extent perhaps through economic necessity, an enormous proportion of foreign programmes. I agree that through economic necessity only 25 or 35 per cent of the programmes shown can be home produced. At the same time, they might be more selective in what they buy from abroad. What they buy and show to viewers here is, over a period of years, in danger of undermining the whole national outlook and national culture of our people and replacing the old traditional values that our people have always had with a completely foreign and alien set of values, which would horrify those of a previous generation.

Comment on this

Over 50 per cent is home produced.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Malley

I am glad to hear that. At the same time, the proportion of foreign produced programmes is so high that RTE should make every effort to try to improve the quality of what they buy. One can notice in recent years in this country a different attitude to money and a more material view of life than existed hitherto. In some measure at least RTE must share the blame for bringing about that regrettable change in the situation. I appreciate that the economics of the thing make is quite impossible for them to have 100 per cent home produced programmes but I renew my plea to them to try to be more selective in what they import.

One noticeable example in recent months was that RTE insisted, on several occasions, on presenting at length a gentleman from Northern Ireland who is probably the very antithesis of everything we in this part of the country stand for. It is noticeable that RTE produced that man on several occasions, although apparently he finds difficulty in being allowed to appear on television stations in his own part of the country.

There are two ways of looking at that perhaps. One is that it is a good thing to see such freedom of speech in this part of the country and on RTE, but that is something that could be overdone in regard to this individual and his various side-kicks who appear with him. It would be very regrettable if this violently anti-national attitude portrayed by him continued to be given excessive coverage by RTE. The intention of RTE in presenting him may not have been so much to present him on a political level as on an entertainment level. I do not deny that he has a great deal of entertainment value. At the same time, he has made himself very clear on many occasions as being utterly opposed to the basic political and religious tenets of practically everyone in this part of the country. Therefore, it is extraordinary that he should be presented on RTE so frequently.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy referring to poor Mr. Paisley?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Malley

I am, yes.

Comment on this

God help him.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Malley

On this Estimate, as I suppose on practically every Estimate, one tends to pick out the things one feels could possibly be improved upon. It is perhaps a bit unfair to this Minister, or any other Minister, to do this. It is particularly unfair to the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs because his opening statement on the Estimate, and on the Bill which we are considering, is perhaps one of the most comprehensive and most helpful and in many ways most cheerful that can have been presented to the House for many a long day. It is a very extensive and thorough record of the tremendous progress which has been made in the Minister's Department in recent years.

I should like to add my very sincere personal congratulations to those which the Minister has received from every side of the House. I am very glad to see that his good work and the good work of his Department have been acknowledged on every side of the House.

Comment on this

I have been greatly derided in certain quarters for recalling the mind of the Dáil to the fact that television has inherent in it greater dangers for society than the atomic bomb. However, fundamental truths remain true even when stupid men do not understand them. It is fundamentally true that, while the atomic bomb can destroy our bodies, television is capable of destroying not only our minds but our children's minds. Therefore, the responsibility for its wise user is a very heavy one.

It should never be absent from the minds of any of us here in the Oireachtas, or anyone in Montrose responsible for the day to day administration of RTE, that the programmes enter the domestic hearth of very nearly every family in Ireland now. Inasmuch as the family means so much in our society, that which is spoken and seen in the family circle carries far greater weight than anything that can be communicated by the written word, or by the words spoken in any other medium.

Taken by and large, I think RTE do a good job. You have to ask yourself the fundamental question: what is the prime purpose of television from the point of view of the director of a television station? To that we must answer "to entertain" for the simple reason that if he does not entertain his audience will cut themselves off. It is no use broadcasting to television screens which have been turned off or switched to another channel. Therefore, to retain his audience the director of television must entertain. I will return to that topic in a moment because I think it is necessary to say some things in its regard.

We ought to bear in mind when we are discussing the Estimates for the Department of Posts and Telegraphs, that they make provision for things other than television and radio. Something we have reason to be proud of in this country is the record of the Department of Posts and Telegraphs for uniform courtesy to the community they serve. If anything goes wrong, if anybody's feathers get ruffled, people are very given to rushing in here to proclaim their woes; but if the Department perennially serve the public courteously and well, only too often we take it for granted. Therefore, it is well from time to time to remind the Dáil that the Department of Posts and Telegraphs get their work done with comparatively little mandatory power, and I often compare them with the ESB.

The ESB have all sorts of strange powers under the Acts enacted by this House. They have power to put a pole in your front garden, or, indeed, in your drawing-room if they think it necessary — a power sometimes ruthlessly used by them. The Post Office cannot put a pole anywhere or cannot stay a pole to any adjoining fixture without the prior permission of the owner. Yet they get them erected and get them stayed to buildings. I had the extraordinary experience of being notified that they entertained the idea of planting a pole right in the middle of my yard in Ballaghaderreen. I remember going out in a towering rage and meeting a most reasonable official who said they would not dream of putting a pole anywhere on my property without my consent. They ended up by putting the pole precisely where they wanted to put it — in the centre of my premises — but they arranged things without any inconvenience to anybody.

I have seen that going on for years. It is something we should be proud of. It is an expertise only too rare in this modern world. They transact their difficult business with the public courteously, patiently and they secure effectively what is necessary without unduly ruffling the feelings of the people of whom, I am happy to think, the Department of Posts and Telegraphs are proud to be the servants.

There is one problem which is perennial in regard to the Post Office and it is the trunk telephone service. I must say that in the last 12 months there has been considerable improvement in the ability of the trunk telephone service to answer "10". I have noticed, however, that in the last month or so the delays have been becoming longer again. I wonder is that associated with very large main operations in the centre of the city. The delay is without doubt beginning to manifest itself again.

Secondly, there has been in the last month a marked difficulty — with which the Minister may find himself in sympathy — in getting a line to the County Monaghan. Having got ten, and indicated the number, the number of times we are told the lines are engaged is more than it should be, particularly in the off-tourist season. I should be interested to hear from the Minister how he finds himself in relation to the trunk dialling service — if he has had complaints recently that lines are not available as readily as they should be, particularly if we hope to cope with any kind of adequacy with the additional burden that must fall on us at the height of the tourist season. It strikes me as peculiar that this should have emerged particularly now with so many exchanges on automatic operation. I should have thought that this would have relieved trunk lines to which one might get access by dialling "10". It does not seem to be so and it is a matter which the Minister should look into.

Now I return to the more popular topic of Telefís Éireann. First of all, though, I wish to say that I think Deputy O'Malley was right in expressing his interest in philately. The trouble is that the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs is interested in philately but the Minister for Finance is not. When I was a member of the Government there was always a running war against the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs who was trying to get good stamps printed by the Minister for Finance who did not want any stamps printed. I could never make out why because it seems to me the Minister for Finance always made money out of the stamps. However, there seems to have been a general feeling in the Department of Finance: "To blazes with those artists. Give them some kind of a stamp to stick on an envelope". The result was that the standard of the stamps issued by the Post Office did not even approximate to the standard that should obtain.

I have complained on several occasions about the great blankets produced. You would be poisoned licking them and when you had stuck them on the envelope there would be no room for the address. To my horror that has now been changed to the other extreme in our recent issue. You now try to find the stamp, which is like a scrap of paper, and when you look at your sixpenny worth with the bird on it you can barely see it. It is liable to fall from your fingers before you get it to your tongue. I should like to see some moderation in this matter — some excellent philately which will neither poison you with excess of gum or slip from your fingers and become invisible on the floor due to its diminutive size and its odd coloration.

There has been reference to the people who interview on television. Every Deputy is obliged to state what he knows. I have never received anything but courtesy on any occasion I went to Montrose. I have never been conscious of receiving anything but all the help it was possible for the technicians in charge to give. I was interviewed many times when I was the Leader of the Party to which I now belong. Once I was interviewed for an hour after I had ceased to be Leader of the Party and my strong feeling was that every technical device was employed to facilitate me in any way the staff at controls could do it. They make you up if you want to be made up. I never considered anything except a little powder in order to keep my head from shining. I would not come in a blue shirt, I should not wear a blue tie and I would not engage in any of the other frills and furbelows. It was there if you wanted it. I would not talk to the camera and I would not talk to the boom. I told them I was not prepared to talk to the camera and the boom, that I would do the talking and it was their job to pick it up. My experience has been that they did it with the maximum efficiency. I think some of the people who are very much obsessed by the delicacy of their treatment are often proved to be their worst enemies and present themselves on a television screen looking like mesmerised rabbits in the presence of the ferret. They should conduct themselves as they would in their own drawing-room or sittingroom and leave to the television people the job of televising the image of their interviewees.

I consider those people do a very excellent job. Perhaps, there is some over-anxiety on the part of the interviewees. It is true to say that the technical staff at Montrose are well aware of the fact that the whole atmosphere of a television studio with all its appurtenances can be very intimidating to certain people but I think they do all in their power to relieve the person who is nervous of the exotic atmosphere of a television studio and who finds it strange. There are some people born into this world who find things unendurable and there is nothing you can do about it. There are some extremely able men who cannot talk and there is nothing you can do about it. Put them on a public platform and they make damn fools of themselves. They gurgle and cough and they are not able to talk in public. That does not mean they are not able men. When you come across such people you simply say that they cannot talk. You say that they are better in counsel than they are on the hustings.

I remember talking to a young person who was remotely related to me and at the end of a television performance in which I took part he said: "Uncle James, you never said `er', `irk' ". I told him I could not say "er" or "irk" and there was nothing in the Montrose television studio which could persuade me to say "er" or "irk" if I was not disposed to say it. It is a disarming experience to see yourself or to hear yourself on television or on radio for the first time. This is not to say that it cannot and has not happened that there is not a charged atmosphere at Montrose. That is not to say that the interviewers have never been rude. There have been occasions on which what seemed to me to be rudeness took place on the part of the interviewer but I want to draw the attention of Dáil Éireann to this unusual fact. So unusual is that that I can recall quite distinctly the two incidents on which it happened in my experience. I must have seen hundreds of interviews on RTE. I think, perhaps, what was the most dramatic aspect of it was the fact that on those two occasions when I heard two interviews on RTE fall below the standards which I have grown accustomed to, I took notice of them. I do not think I could pay the staff of RTE a higher compliment.

We cannot assume because a man works on RTE he never gets out of the wrong side of the bed. We cannot assume because a man works on RTE that he never gets ruffled during an interview. We cannot assume that because a man works on RTE that he does not sometimes annoy his interviewee. I have heard people who belong to various political Parties state that so-and-so is a rosy or a scarlet Communist. I have heard a lady at a public meeting say this. During the immediate period following this observation some lack of courtesy occurred because of the old lady's censure and of the language she used.

I doubt, looking about us here, if any one of us could claim we have been immune to such imperfection throughout our whole professional life. However, I think we are entitled to demand — and I speak as a seasoned and experienced Deputy of this House — that we should not be treated with rudeness. I think I have as much experience as any Deputy of this House. I have been engaged in active politics for close on half a century. I say that people should not be rude deliberately. If they are, they should try to repair it as quickly as they can. In this House, which I have now served for 38 years, it is a very interesting fact that you can divide Ministers of the Government benches and members of the front Opposition benches into two perfectly clear categories, the men who are rude and those who are not. In the rough and tumble and the give and take of politics in my long experience there is no hard feeling as a result of trenchant language but if people are decidedly rude and wounding, then there can arise personal animosity which should not exist in public life at all.

It is the rare occasion on which an interviewer falls into that trap when he goes beyond the limits of common civility that something should be done. I find that, generally, people who conduct interviews do them without rudeness. This is not peculiar to RTE. The same occurred on the BBC but it was corrected. The only stipulation I would make is that people should not be rude but it must be borne in mind that if interviewees have to be treated with courtesy, then they should be prepared to try to be correspondingly courteous with the people who are interviewing them. It would be foolish to pretend that on occasions there have not been lapses. This can occur if they are angels, never mind archangels.

There is another matter with regard to television which is much more difficult to deal with but to which I must refer. I have spoken of the atomic force of television on the minds not only of men and women but, in particular, on the minds of the young. Therefore, one has to consider very carefully the propriety of introducing certain topics for discussion on that medium and, if it is determined to undertake this discussion, the format and the participation in the discussion. If one is going to discuss intimate questions of moral theology and family sociology in every home in Ireland, one will have to be extremely careful if you provide an opportunity for people to put forward a revolutionary view to ensure that what for most of us is orthodox will also respectfully be heard.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

The trouble is that you or I going about our daily business are not news but if you or I throw handsprings down Grafton Street or if we roll drunk down Molesworth Street and break a window, we become news. Therefore, the orthodox view in a matter of acute public interest is very often not news but somebody who advocates the anarchical uprooting of all accepted values is news more especially if he we wears the uniform of a priest, a friar or, most dangerous of all, a theologian — and I leave on one side the psychologists, the sociologists and the si sic omnes who are giving themselves a polysyllabic title to acquire for themselves a degree of public veneration which is conceded by no sophisticated listener. But, whatever the title or whatever the claim to insult or affront the precious convictions of our people, if it is deemed expedient to give them an opportunity of ventilating these views, then the vast bulk of the people have a right to hear the orthodox view as accepted by the vast majority expounded contemporaneously so that truth may have as wide a dissemination as error and that error and truth fall equally upon the same ground whether it be stony or dry or fertile and let them compete on equal terms.

As I have said, if you or I misconducted ourselves in the public streets, we would automatically become news but if we go about our lawful occasions we are not news. This applies to a wider range of population than the Leas-Cheann Comhairle and myself. I remember witnessing a riot, I think in Grosvenor Square in London, when a particularly unattractive looking rioter was interviewed by a servant of the BBC who asked him the pertinent question: "What is the purpose of conducting yourself in this way, in this place, at this time?" and this particularly undesirable-looking specimen turned upon him and said: "Well, we brought you here in any case".

If the Archbishop of Canterbury, the Prime Minister of England or any responsible citizen in Great Britain had gone to that street corner to deliver a homily, you would not have seen hair or hide of the BBC but because someone throws a brick, a gas bomb or kicks a policeman and then hurries to hold a demonstration to protest against police brutality, the whole resources of television and radio appear automatically to be at his disposal.

I do not think that we should suppress views. If somebody voices an unpopular view, let that view be recorded but if someone deliberately goes out for the purpose of stirring up riots and disturbances, does that entitle him to have concentrated upon his person and upon his activities all the resources of television? Does it entitle him to have his picture and his conduct carried into every home in Ireland? Are we to turn the kitchen and every sittingroom in Ireland into a rioters' pandemonium because a gang of thugs go out for no reason other than to create riots for ulterior motives — to upset the foundations not of this State but of any democratic free Constitution under which they happen to live? Are we to collaborate with them by carrying their active riots off the street, where they can be contained, into every home in Ireland?

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.P. Dockrell Fine Gael

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

This is a mistake which is being made not only here but in Great Britain, in the United States of America and in every other free country in the world. You and I, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, could go to Red Square in Moscow in the morning and riot there and somebody might hear that we had disappeared to Siberia or that we had been shot but nobody would see our pictures on the Russian television. That glorious champion of individual liberty, Mao Tse Tung, would not record our activities in Nanking or Peking if we went there to protest. Certainly, our pictures would not be carried into the kitchen of every home in China.

I do not think that a person concerned to precipitate a riot should have his picture carried into anybody's home. If a person has a worthwhile contribution to make to public controversy, let it be noted and commented on. Let it be stated that Mr. So-and-So said so-and-so if it is part of the general news of the day. But let it not be bruited abroad that anyone who riots in a public place is guaranteed unlimited exposure on Irish television or on the television of many nations of the world. Tomorrow morning there will be yelling from all the Liberals, and the Pinks, and the fellow travellers and the pseudo-revolutionaries that here is the voice of reaction echoing through the land. There will be a procession shouting: "Long live Mao" and: "Glory to the memory of Che Guevara", all in the sacred cause of free speech. You know the tragedy is that a number of young people will associate the names of Che Guevara, Mao, Kosygin with free speech wholly unaware of how little they really belong to the freedom into which our young people have the extraordinarily good fortune to be born. Freedom demands that the voice of argument on any cause be heard within the law but freedom does not demand that those who seek to reciprocate with civil disorder should be guaranteed an audience in every home in Ireland.

It is time that that problem was faced and that in future the situation will not occur in which the disciples, conscious and unconscious, of anarchy will be heard to say: "If it served no other useful purpose it brought the television cameras and our pictures into every home in Ireland where we would never dare to get but for the fact that we make news". The vast majority of law-abiding people do not make news any more. That whole atmosphere is giving everybody a sense of insecurity and malaise because of the impact of the imbalance between the portrayal of what is not news and what is news in the modern sense and it creates in the general mind an impression of civil disturbance and upheaval out of all proportion to its true dimensions and true significance in the society to which we belong.

Some of the things I have felt constranied to say will not be very popular. I am not very much concerned whether they are or not. They need to be said. They need to be acted upon. We in Oireachtas Éireann should send a message to Montrose that so long as they do their duty faithfully they will find many champions in this House who honestly believe in free speech. There are still sufficient old-fashioned politicians here who are liberal politicians who believe in letting everybody be heard and letting the public at large judge between them when they have all been heard. Rough as our proceedings in this House from time to time may seem to be looking in from the outside, there is a pretty general consensus here that you should not try to say hurtful things, but that does not mean that one should be mealy-mouthed, but we understand the difference between strong, acrimonious dissent and the desire to be rude. Those charged with the responsible task of interviewing public men in Montrose will find that if they are not rude, no matter now searching their inquiries will be, they will find few critics in Dáil Éireann.

Lastly I want to re-emphasise that grave topics if they are to be discussed in the sittingroom of every home in Ireland should be discussed in a balanced way. That is a very responsible assignment. It is one which must throw a heavy burden on those who bear the ultimate responsibility of seeing it is carried out correctly. I do not see any reason to apprehend that it will be misjudged by anyone who wants to make an honest effort to do the job assigned to him objectively and fairly. These are the standards by which to be judged. I could talk almost indefinitely on these topics but I think I have now made the essential points I wanted to underline. I wish Montrose well. On the whole, the service is good and on the whole reasonable men have every reason to be satisfied with it. I would say to Montrose: "Do not be unduly dismayed by criticism. It is a useful thing even sometimes when it is not just. It may give you a point of view which you may not have thought of." I believe in the sovereign rule which rational men and women in this House will ruthlessly enforce and which in the long run is a very simple one: "Do not be rude and do not let anyone be rude to you."

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lalor Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs (Mr. Lalor) Fianna Fáil

I propose to intervene at this stage in the debate which has now gone on for a number of days to deal specifically with a number of matters that have been discussed here in relation to the postal side of the Department. I will not refer to the debate as it dealt with RTE or with the telephone development side. I think at this stage, following immediately after Deputy Dillon, I would be wrong not to refer to the contribution he made in this regard. The comments made by Deputy Dillon were very well chosen and, personally, I would like to compliment him very sincerely. It was wonderful. As he said himself, the things he said needed to be said——

Comment on this

Timeo Danaos et dona ferentes.

Comment on this

——and certainly have been said far more adequately by him than I could possibly say it, in any case. But let me say, in relation to the debate as it has concerned the Department, that it is quite obvious that most Deputies in their contributions here in the House have spent, I suppose, 75 per cent of the time dealing with RTE, with the result that the general administration of the Post Office, in itself, got what one might describe as reasonably scant attention except in so far as a number of Deputies, in their overall remarks in relation to the general working of the Department of Posts and Telegraphs, were most complimentary.

I think it is only right and fitting that I, while not being in a position to take credit on behalf of the huge staff of the Post Office, should, nevertheless, on their behalf, acknowledge the compliments so genuinely paid to them and so merited by them. As everybody is so well aware, the Department of Posts and Telegraphs is the biggest employer in the State. As was mentioned by the Minister in introducing the Estimate, we have somewhat in the region of 19,000 employees in the Post Office. Therefore, it is certainly only right and proper that I should acknowledge the compliments paid to that staff by the various Deputies. As usual, Deputy M. E. Dockrell was quite generous in his compliments. He was followed by pretty genuine and generous compliments from Deputy Corish and Deputy Dillon. As a matter of fact, Deputy Lindsay, before he side-channelled into a pretty serious attack on the RTE side of the business, did say there was very little to complain about from the Post Office side and went on to say that the staff gave a very good display of efficiency in their work. This was echoed and re-echoed by a number of Deputies.

I suppose a debate on the Estimate for the Department of Posts and Telegraphs could not be considered complete without some derogatory remarks being flung about political appointments at the political head, or the political sub-head as the case may be, of the Department. However, quite honestly, for a debate that has continued for so long, and is not yet over, let me say that we did have the minimum of abuse-flinging.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary was expecting much more of it.

Comment on this

It is kind of expected now.

Comment on this

In fact, Deputy Lindsay accepted it in a peculiar sort of way. He accepted it in so far as he said that, if he had the opportunity, he would become involved in it. Apart altogether from the fact that it can be suggested as being accepted, I think that the incidence of complaints of this nature is becoming far less. I am glad Deputy L'Estrange is here so that I can get an opportunity of saying to him that he was bound to criticise various appointments and, generally, to make wild accusations about messing about with postmen who had been appointed for six or 12 months and who then, according to him, found themselves, after a local cumann meeting, out of a job.

Comment on this

That is quite true. Certainly it is.

Comment on this

That kind of accusation should have gone out by this time. Certainly, the question of trying to pinpoint cases of that nature should not arise in this day and age.

Comment on this

It is happening.

Comment on this

The only specific case where any straightforward accusation was flung at the Parliamentary Secretary today — whose responsibility it is — was when Deputy Dr. O'Connell and, in a much milder way, Deputy Seán Dunne, spoke about the appointment of a sub-postmaster, or the non-appointment of a sub-postmistress, in Lissadell Avenue here in the city.

Comment on this

I am sure they were appointed on merit.

Comment on this

Some Deputy pointed out today that, arising from previous difficulties of this nature, a former Minister had appointed a selection board. I repeat that a former Minister had appointed a selection board.

Comment on this

We know what happens when a cumann dictates.

Comment on this

It is unfortunate that we have not a Labour Deputy in the House at the moment but let me here and now say that the only thing that was wrong with the Lissadell Avenue appointment was that it was a non-political appointment. I do not want to fling it at anybody else. I have discussed this appointment with a number of Labour Deputies who — maybe I am wrong — accepted the position. The allegation flung at me was that I accepted the person recommended to me by the selection board but apparently did not accept the person who might have been recommended to me by the Labour Party.

Comment on this

Does that mean that the Parliamentary Secretary does not always accept the recommendation of the selection board? Is that what he means?

Comment on this

Let me be quite straight and frank about this. If more than three people are nominated, the selection board comes up before the Minister or the Parliamentary Secretary with the possibility of three names for selection.

Comment on this

Does the Parliamentary Secretary not think it is time that that was changed?

Comment on this

I do not think so. While we all know and accept that maybe the Minister might not be infallible, neither is the selection board infallible — maybe yes, maybe no.

Comment on this

Then it is serving no purpose. It is giving the Parliamentary Secretary three out of five names.

Comment on this

It is. On a number of occasions, we may have nine or ten applicants and they will be short-listed down to three. This is only proper. I do not think there is any necessity to make mischief out of it because, in fact, there is very little mischief in it.

Comment on this

But it is quite. open to the making of mischief out of it. The Parliamentary Secretary can solve it now by accepting one name from the board.

Comment on this

This I invariably do.

Comment on this

A few moments ago, the Parliamentary Secretary said he got three names.

Comment on this

He selects one——

Comment on this

——out of three, but it could be No. 3.

Comment on this

I very often have only two or one presented to me.

Comment on this