We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Financial Resolution No. 13: General (Resumed).

Contributions 152–314 of 314. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

This Budget debate will proceed next week. The Fine Gael Árd Fheis can proceed as usual. They can go through their resolutions. Let the young tigers wag their tails again this year. Let the Fine Gael Deputies come back to the House again next week and we will continue the Budget debate. We will continue to do the business that has been ordered. We will carry on with our work as well as we can do it and the election will come in its own good time.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

Can the Taoiseach make up his mind on anything? He cannot make it up on that simple question. The Cabinet are divided on it. Half of them want an October election and the Taoiseach cannot make up his mind.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order, order.

Comment on this

The country wants leadership

Comment on this

Now he can be called Stonewall Jack, Sir.

Mr. Haughey rose.

Comment on this

He is trying it on again. Fugitives from public opinion.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

I was about to preface my remarks on the Budget by saying it was rather a strange affair, and I had made that note before the intervention of the Taoiseach. Now, there will be others who will deal with the Taoiseach's intervention more adequately than me, but nevertheless there are some remarks I cannot help making about it. I do not quite know what the Minister for Local Government and his general character have to do with the Budget but I am sure the Chair will forgive me if I follow the lead of the Taoiseach in this respect. The Taoiseach complained that the Minister for Local Government had got a bad Press particularly from the Irish Independent. I seem to remember, however, during the past few days reading an article in the Irish Independent, a long one, on the Minister for Local Government. The gist of it was that he is not such a bad fellow, after all. The article stated that he is a man of tenacity of purpose and of integrity.

I am sure he is a man of integrity, and we had an example of his tenacity of purpose in the referendum last year. On this side of the House, and indeed in the country in general, we think that that tenacity of purpose was extremely ill-advised on that occasion. I mention that only to show that, when the Press praise a Minister somewhat, the Party opposite hug their insult to themselves and pretend to appear as if they were being insulted. So much for that aspect of the Taoiseach's speech.

The Taoiseach gave close argument on figures and so on, and without the printed word I cannot follow the various figures given. However, the gist of a great deal of the Taoiseach's speech is that the Government are taking steps to resist the inflationary tendencies and inflationary pressures which arise and have arisen in the country's economy. He made particular reference to the trade unions, and so on. One of the greatest reasons for the inflationary tendencies which exist at present is the very large measure of Government expenditure which we have. In fact, the Government could, if they so wished, do away with a great deal of the inflationary tendencies because those tendencies have come largely, indeed mainly, through the enormous volume of Government expenditure—I hope I am not making a nonsensical speech. These inflationary tendencies which exist in our economy are measured in the economies of many countries in Europe today. Therefore I do not expect the Minister for Finance to stand up and with one wave of his hand to sweep away a lot of those inflationary tendencies.

What I do expect him and the Government to do is to exercise a great deal more care than is being exercised in Government expenditure. There was a time when Government expenditure was considered, not entirely but largely, from the point of view of the capacity of the country in general, of industry and commerce in general, to withstand the rate of taxation. Now, one seldom hears that mentioned: in Budget speeches most Deputies do not take it into consideration. As a result of this pressure of public opinion, we have an inflationary tendency all the time and I urge on the Minister the very real danger that is being brought nearer and nearer through increasing Government expenditure.

There is little point in appealing to the community to exercise spending restraints in view of the fact that the direct opposite is being done by the Government in relation to their expenditure. Very often that is expenditure which is undertaken or appears to be undertaken largely for political purposes.

The Taoiseach also said that this was not an election Budget, that of course it was a Budget in an election year and therefore that criticism would be levelled at it. Of course, it is very largely an election Budget. Can anybody really pretend that £100 for triplets or £150 for quadruplets——

Comment on this

I have been thinking of doing this for years. I meant to do it last year.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

I do not object to it and I do not want to sneer at it, but it is just a little gimmick.

Comment on this

It is a very humanitarian thing to do. Admit it.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

I agree.

Comment on this

Quite honestly, I meant to do it last year.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

But it is hardly worthy of inclusion in a Budget. In fact, what I was going to say was that if triplets warrant £100 quads would really warrant about £1,000. Have we any quads in Ireland at all?

Comment on this

I do not think so.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

No, we have not. Very few quads survive. However, the point I am making is that the inclusion of this is more in the nature of an election gimmick than a real alleviation of the expenses incurred for triplets. The expenses for triplets must be crushing for the average family and, happily, there are many sets of triplets in the country. While on items in the Budget which are small in themselves, I am glad to see what the Minister has done in relation to works of cultural merit and that he is not subjecting these people who produce such works to ordinary taxation. However, I can see very great difficulties arising in interpreting what is a work of cultural merit. It will be extremely difficult to differentiate between, say, journalists and journalism and writing for artistic purposes. Also, what is going to happen if a work is banned here and yet the writer can claim that it is a work of cultural merit and claim from the Revenue Commissioners? Will there be a conflict between the policies of different sections of the Government? However, I suppose that can be sorted out in time, but it is something over the interpretation of which there will be difficulty.

The Taoiseach referred again and again to the increase in exports. In regard to the welcome increases in exports which has taken place in the last few years I would point out that they have come about largely as a result of the tax concessions given to firms engaged in exporting. That policy of giving tax concessions was brought in by the inter-Party Government. Through the help afforded by these concessions many firms have been able to undertake market research and to spend money on developing in fields abroad and the country has reaped a very great reward. This policy was introduced by Deputy Sweetman when he was Minister for Finance.

The benefit that has come from these tax concessions shows what benefits could arise from any alleviation of taxation afforded to firms engaged in ordinary internal trade. In fact, there would be a great upsurge in industrial employment of all sorts if such tax concessions could be introduced and the benefits would be far greater even than the benefits that have accrued from the concessions given to firms engaged in exporting. If we could do that we would get a big increase in our gross national product.

In connection with the gross national product, the figures relating to general taxation given in the Current Budget Tables are very interesting. Since 1963 the total expenditure, which was then £186 million, has more than doubled to £386 million odd, so that over double the taxation is being taken from the citizens. It is interesting to see, under current Government expenditure expressed as a percentage of gross national product, that in 1963 the Government expenditure was 22.3 per cent of the GNP and now it is 28.1 per cent; in other words, that taxation has gone up by 5.8 per cent or nearly 6 per cent, which is a very big increase and is, in fact, more than an increase of 25 per cent. That shows that taxation is reaching levels which both individuals and businesses find completely crushing. I am not exaggerating. I have not the figures for comparable taxation in other countries—I am sure the Minister has—but I imagine the level of taxation here ranks amongst the highest in Europe and possibly in the world.

It is good to see what we do for our less fortunate citizens and to find that any Government here is active in that field, but I should like to see at the same time more emphasis on producing wealth which can go to these people. We are coming dangerously close to a situation in which we shall harmfully affect our wealth-producing units if we do not cut down national expenditure. We must do so. We have seen the effect of the rise in rates and the outcry that has resulted. As the House is aware, the Dublin City Council is now dissolved. I shall not go into that situation but it has arisen because of the enormous expenditure which our local authorities are obliged to make.

We live next door to a very large trading nation. Such nations have wealth that small nations such as ours, which in the past has been mainly an agricultural country, cannot command. Are we cutting our cloth too expensively? I think we are. I have no easy solution to offer the Minister as to the exact ways in which Government expenditure can be pruned but it is something that may prove a great danger to us if we do not solve the problem of production in relation to taxation.

The Taoiseach spoke of an incomes policy and much of his speech was about inflationary pressures. He urged us to keep income increases in line with productivity, something with which we all agree. The difficulty is to bring about that situation. The Government, as a whole, have not given any particular lead in that respect. We had all the difficulties of the maintenance strike which went on for weeks and affected the trade of this country. Many businesses are still feeling the effects of it and neither the Taoiseach nor the Government gave any great lead while it was going on.

Other speakers on this side of the House, as well as the Taoiseach, mentioned the mini-Budget of last autumn. I think it was the Banking Review which commented on the autumn Budget and said that it was of such severity that they could only conclude that there were factors actuating the Government of that time other than the financial position. Of course, the other factors motivating the Government then were that they were entering an election year and that the Budget of 1969 would be a comparatively easy one since the tough Budget was the Autumn one. I mention that to support statements on this side of the House about the present Budget and to point out that banking circles last autumn felt that the Budget then was unduly severe.

I want to reiterate that the burden of taxation falls very heavily on a great many individuals and businesses. There would be a real upsurge in employment if the taxation level could be lowered. That is not easy but it is something that Irish Governments must bear in mind. It is easy to injure, or even kill, the goose that lays the golden eggs.

There is another matter to which I wish to refer in connection with the Budget. I hope I am relevant in doing so. It concerns a man who belongs to an insurance scheme in a business. He dies and his widow then gets the money. She can draw something like two-thirds, as he could if he had reached retiring age before he died. She gets, I think, one-third of the sum with which she can do what she likes. The remaining two-thirds must be invested; an annuity must be purchased. I am thinking of a case which has come to my notice of a widow who is roughly about 50 or 51 years of age. She can purchase an annuity but cannot get as high a rate of annuity as she could get if she bought National Loan. The return on many Government stocks at the moment is 9 per cent. She cannot get 9 per cent in an annuity because she is a middle-aged woman. Is it not rather harsh that she should not only lose the capital, which she does when she purchases an annuity, but is getting a smaller rate of annuity than would be the case if she were free to purchase Government stocks?

Comment on this

Why does she have to buy an annuity?

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

She has to because that is part of the regulations or of the law in connection with the scheme.

Comment on this

Is this a private insurance scheme?

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

Yes, a business insurance scheme.

Comment on this

A private firm has an insurance scheme?

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

A public company, actually.

Comment on this

Has a scheme——?

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

——for its employees, yes. An employee dies and on account of tax concessions having been given in the building up of the sum of money which the widow will get, she is not allowed to take it all out and the high interest rates which operate at the present moment are bound in the circumstances to mean that the woman will get less.

Comment on this

The Deputy had better send me particulars of it. I do not know if I can do anything to help.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

I do not know if the Minister can.

Comment on this

It seems to be outside the scope of public administration.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

It is more a matter of the regulations, possibly, and the Commissioners. It is an unusual situation which has arisen through high interest rates. I shall look into it and will send the Minister particulars.

That is all I have to say on the Budget. It is an election Budget. It has made small concessions to a number of people. The rate of taxation is mounting every year and I urge on the Minister the very grave necessity of pruning public expenditure as far as possible in order to reduce the burden of this taxation on businesses and individuals.

Comment on this

This Budget has been properly described as an election Budget. We welcome the reliefs given in social welfare. The only trouble here is that they are not as large as we would like to see them. If this were not an election year, would these reliefs have been introduced by the Minister in the Budget? It seems extraordinary that having prepared the country for a harsh Budget, when he came on television last March and spoke of crises, within two months the Minister waves his magic wand and the sun starts to shine again. The only reason that this has happened is that we are on the eve of a general election. The experience is that during election years Ministers for Finance introduce the normal spring Budget and then apply the harsh does in a supplementary autumn Budget. We had a particular case of this 12 months ago when we were facing the referendum. Subsequent to the referendum, in which the people had given their answer, we got the medicine in November. I am afraid that this Budget is another election gimmick on the part of the Fianna Fáil Government.

I am disappointed that the Minister has not seen fit to increase the tax free income of £6 10s. I referred to this matter last year. As prices rise and the cost of living increases, nothing has been done to give relief by way of increased personal allowance.

In this Budget we have the usual hardy annuals. I remember when Deputy Dr. Ryan, now Senator Ryan, was Minister for Finance and was introducing the turnover tax he told us that the taxes on beer, spirits, wines and tobacco had reached saturation point. Yet, in his Financial Statement the present Minister says that as long as these items keep on coming up smiling he is satisfied. I wonder whether the Minister, when giving benefits in this Budget, really gave away anything at all. The old age pensioners got an increase of 10/- a week but many of these people take a pint of stout, which is nourishment for them in their old age, and many of them enjoy a smoke of hard pressed tobacco or cigarettes. If we take into account the amount spent by old age pensioners on such items we find that the Minister is taking back in taxation most of what he has given.

With regard to the increased taxes on petrol and diesel oil perhaps when the Minister thought of taxing these things he thought in terms of people using their cars for pleasure, people using their Mercedes with diesel oil just for pleasure. The Minister should realise that, apart from increasing expenses in industry with this tax, he is also affecting the ordinary working man. Many builders labourers and factory workers must use cars to get to work. They will be hit by this taxation. I know people in my constituency who drive daily from Carlow to Dublin to work on building sites. It will be a hardship on them to pay this increase.

Much has been said about the increase in children's allowances. It is welcome; but, at the same time, where people are in the tax category they are affected and the Minister is giving with one hand and taking back with the other.

We have the increases in taxation that I have mentioned on beer, spirits, tobacco and petrol and yet we have a further increase in the wholesale tax. I admit that the items which have been included under that heading could be described as luxuries but we have apparently reached the point where, no matter what tax is introduced, it must be increased each year.

In this Budget, apart from some small concession to the farming community by way of the mountain lamb subsidy, there is practically nothing in it for the farmers. I know there has been this addition of £1 per hogget ewe introduced. This will be a help but it will affect only certain areas. I hope it will not be as hard for people to get the Department to pay these subsidies as it has been in some other cases. I had a case of a person who had qualified formerly but was told by the Department he did not come within the scheme. These mountain lambs had been raised in the same place as the year before. It was eventually paid but it took a long time.

Comment on this

The Deputy will admit that it is the first Government ever to reach a hand to help the sheep farmer?

Comment on this

Does the Minister not think it is about time after 40 years in office?

Comment on this

This Government are not 40 years in office.

Comment on this

The Minister can have his ideas on that but it is high time and we have been preaching this long enough.

Comment on this

Preaching is all you ever do.

Comment on this

I do not think anybody needs to be told that the sheep industry had been run down by the Fianna Fáil Government.

Comment on this

Nonsense. We are the first Government to help the sheep farmers and there were plenty of Fine Gael and Cumann na nGaedheal Governments in this country and they never did a single thing.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Governey.

Comment on this

This is the only Government that ever did anything for them.

Comment on this

I wish to put the record straight.

Comment on this

What is the Deputy putting on the record? Tripe.

Comment on this

It is not tripe.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Governey.

Comment on this

Deputy Harte's whole contribution to this House is ignorant interruptions. Let Deputy Governey go on.

Comment on this

We cannot all be intellectuals. The Ministers, when he was in Agriculture, was such an intellectual I wonder why they put him out of it.

Comment on this

I welcome this small incentive and I hope that there will not be difficulty or too much red tape in the Department in paying these subsidies.

The beef incentive, which was increased from £8 to £12, is a step in the right direction and is generally welcomed.

I must say, in fairness, that to budget is not an easy task and the benefits that have been given are welcome. This has been proved by the fact that we did not vote against any of the Money Resolutions. However, I am sceptical about whether the Minister was sincere when he spoke in March. I listened to him that night on television and he struck me as being sincere. I cannot for the life of me understand how, the Minister having issued those warnings and warned the country of a tough Budget, within two months things can have changed so rapidly. We are now on the eve of a general election. This is the type of election gimmickry which is carried on by the Fianna Fáil Party and I hope the people will see through it when the general election comes. There is an old saying: "You can fool some of the people some of the time, but cannot fool all of the people all of the time".

In the referendum last October when the Government Party wasted £100,000 of the taxpayers' money to fight a losing battle, they got their answer from the electorate.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy agree with me that it does seem as if one cannot win a constitutional referendum? This has been proved in France, in Australia, here and in Switzerland?

Comment on this

Why did the Government try it?

Comment on this

Why did Fianna Fáil and some of their Ministers, as we were led to believe, try to push it through.

Comment on this

We tried in all good faith.

Comment on this

If they knew so much, why were they prepared to waste £100,000 of the taxpayers' money?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy will appreciate that we are not discussing the referendum now.

Comment on this

I am merely pointing out that in respect of the Budget, as in the case of the referendum, the public will not be fooled. The benefits have been proposed and the Money Resolutions have been passed, but I wonder are the Minister and the Government living in the belief and the hope that they will be back in office next autumn——

Comment on this

Hope springs eternal.

Comment on this

——so that they can bring in a harsh budget, as they did last year? The Minister says that hope springs eternal but I am convinced that by next autumn we will be sitting in the benches opposite.

Comment on this

Go bfoire Dia orainn.

Comment on this

In his statement the Minister referred to recreational facilities. I should like to hear from the Minister if the money which he is allocating under the heading of recreational facilities is purely for indoor facilities or is there any specification in regard to youth clubs?

Comment on this

There are two provisions in the Budget about recreational facilities. One is an income tax incentive to firms to provide them for their employees. That is not what the Deputy is speaking about.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

He is speaking about the sum of money allocated for recreational purposes. The general idea is that it will help to provide recreational facilities for younger people mainly, through youth clubs and in other ways.

Comment on this

That is what I am interested in because we have approached the Minister for Education about a new club in Carlow run by the Society of St. Vincent de Paul. I am not sure if it would come in under this scheme. It has to do with basket ball and indoor sports.

Comment on this

The Deputy will appreciate that I cannot give an indication with regard to any individual case. The general idea is to help all forms of sport and recreation for young people mainly, but not exclusively for young, people.

Comment on this

The Minister referred in his statement to handicapped children. It is high time that some assistance was provided in this regard. Indeed, tribute should be paid in this House to the many voluntary organisations who are helping in this direction. Any allowance that can be given is very welcome.

I hope I am wrong but I am still suspicious that this is purely an election Budget. I wanted to ask the Minister if, under the heading of social welfare benefits, there will be an increase in insurance stamps. Will this follow, and can the Minister give any indication of what the increase may be? So far as I remember, it was not mentioned in his Budget speech. While we talk of the benefits which come through the Budget, if there is to be an increase in insurance stamps, apart from taxation, the people are entitled to know about it at this stage.

I trust that the public will not fall for the Budget which has been introduced in an election year and that, when the general election is called, they will not be fooled by the Government or by a Minister who one month warns of the state of the economy, of the dangers that lie ahead, of a tough Budget and prepares the people for a shock and, in the next month, comes to the House and performs, to my mind, a political exercise in the interests of the Party to which he belongs. When the general election is called, be polling day in June or not——

Comment on this

What day would the Deputy like the election?

Comment on this

As soon as possible.

Comment on this

——the people will not fall for it. The Deputy would like the election any time Fianna Fáil like to call the day, and he will be only too anxious to have it in the month of June——

Comment on this

Fourth June. Dissolve the Dáil today.

Comment on this

——because we are convinced that we shall be returned and will be sitting on that side of the House.

Comment on this

I should like to congratulate the Minister on this Budget which is a typical Fianna Fáil Budget. I have the greatest sympathy in the world for the Opposition Parties who had been looking forward to Fianna Fáil having difficulties in regard to bringing in this Budget.

Comment on this

We believed the Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

They thought the economy was such that we would not be able to continue on our usual road of bringing benefits to the neediest sections of the community, namely, the social welfare recipients. It has been welcomed as a good and sound Budget not only by the public but by the Opposition here.

Comment on this

Who said that?

Comment on this

The Opposition Deputies are jealous of our position and of the fact that the economy is so sound that we are able to bring in these necessary improvements. The very fact that they did not vote against the Budget is an admission on their part that it is a good Budget. Deputy Tierney made that clear in his speech here when he praised the Budget and gave due credit to the Minister for the reliefs he gave to the social welfare section and the farming section of the community as well.

The only course open to the Opposition is to describe this as an election Budget, as a gimmick, to enable Fianna Fáil to win votes and be returned here after the next general election, whenever that might be. We have never attempted to win elections by this method, because we know full well if we did succeed in holding on to office or winning an election, whether it was a Presidential election, local elections, a referendum or anything else, the public would then see that the Fianna Fáil Party was no different from the Opposition Parties, because this is the type of gimmick they have always adopted and relied on to bring them into office. The fundamental difference between Fianna Fáil and the other Parties is that the public have come to realise that we as a Party have always been honest in our approach. They know exactly where they stand with us. We tell them how the economy is progressing. We tell them if we have difficulties and we ask for their co-operation and we have always got it.

In 1966—I was not very long in the House at the time—there were two by-elections pending in Waterford and Kerry. 1966 was a very difficult year for this country as well as for many other countries of the world far bigger and wealthier than ourselves. Unpopular tasks had to be faced up to in order to put the economy on a sound footing. These two by-elections were on the horizon and, on account of the difficulties, the Opposition said that this was an opportune time to have a general election. A challenge came to Fianna Fáil from the benches over there to face the country in a general election in 1966. However, Fianna Fáil faced up to their responsibilities and took the necessary economic steps on the eve of the by-elections. Having taken them, we went before the people of Waterford and Kerry; they gave their verdict in our favour and returned two more Fianna Fáil Deputies to this House. They were, in the main, two rural constituencies, Kerry in particular. At that time there were tremendous difficulties in regard to cattle prices, and so forth; nevertheless, the people, realising that Fianna Fáil was a Government that would stand with them in difficult times as well as in good times, supported that Government. After that we heard very little about a general election nor were we challenged to go to the country. Now the challenge is thrown out again, but it is like whistling going past a graveyard. Their challenge was more sincere a couple of months ago when they thought we were not making the progress we have made and that there would not be the tremendous growth in the economy of five and a half per cent which has taken place in the last year. Now they do not feel too sure of themselves. They know full well that when the general election comes, whether it is in June, October or April, 1970, the people will again stand behind Fianna Fáil and will not be led away by this attempt of the Opposition to treat this Budget as an election Budget.

The year that has just gone, 1968, was, as described by the Minister for Finance, one of the best years of economic growth for this country. Industrial production increased by 11 per cent; the figure for employment in manufacturing industry was 6,400 higher than a year earlier. Of course, employment in agriculture continues to fall. This is due to modern farming methods, up-to-date machinery and better management on the farms. However, we can be glad of the fact that the rise in employment in industry is greater than the fall in employment in agriculture. We are finding jobs for our people here at home and coming nearer the day when nobody will be forced to emigrate due to economic circumstances, when those who go will go only of their own free will. That is the road along which Fianna Fáil is leading, and this is the road from which the people will not want to be diverted.

Social welfare recipients have once again been looked after by Fianna Fáil. Listening to the previous speakers one would imagine this was the first time Fianna Fáil gave increases to this section. That is, of course, very far from the truth. This Government have always looked after the weakest and neediest sections of the community, irrespective of whether or not it is an election year. The governing factor is not, of course, the fact that it may be an election year; the governing factor is the expansion that has taken place in the economy during the year and the estimated growth in the following year. These are the factors which dictate whether the increase to social welfare recipients will be a big one or a small one.

Since Fianna Fáil resumed Government in 1957 they have given increases every year. In some years the increases have been bigger than in other years. Last year there was an increase of 7s 6d. This year it is 10s. There is an increase also in the maintenance allowance in the case of infectious diseases. We are proud to be in a position to give these increases to the neediest sections of our community.

The people realise that what the Government can afford to give them depends on the expansion that has taken place in the economy and they also realise that it is only under a Fianna Fáil Government the economy will expand. They realise that expansion cannot and will not take place under a Coalition Government or any other Government of that type. We had evidence of that on two occasions and the people remember what happened. There was only one increase in social welfare benefits; the non-contributory old age pensioner was given an increase of 2s 6d over a period of three years. That works out at 10d per year. I know this is a sore point with the Opposition. They would like us to forget about that. They would like us not to remind the public about that. But we have a duty to remind the people. We have a duty to keep their record before the people. A general election is a very important occasion and the people should be in a position to assess the records of Coalition Governments and the record of the Fianna Fáil Government with regard to the less well-off sections of the community. We do not like speaking about these things, but we have a duty to remind the people and, if we did not remind them, we would be failing in our duty.

I know that this was not the fault of those who took part in that Coalition Government. It was not the fault of the Labour Deputy who was Minister for Social Welfare. I am convinced he would have liked to have given them as much as he possibly could, but the governing factor was the state of the economy and, under that type of Government, the economy did not make any progress. There was utter stagnation. I am sure the Coalition Government regretted that stagnation just as much as we regretted it.

Comment on this

Did the Deputy hear about all the houses we built?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Order.

Comment on this

The Coalition Government were not in a position to give increases and the people know that, if there is a return to that type of Government, they will no longer be able to look forward to increases in social welfare benefits.

The Opposition have said that agriculture is neglected in this Budget. That is not true. We have never neglected agriculture. In particular, we have never neglected the small farmer. We appreciate his difficulties and we do everything we possibly can to help him. As proof of this I need only point to the fact that in the current financial year State aid to agriculture stands at £81 million. In the last year of the Coalition Government, with a Minister for Agriculture we have often heard praised, State aid to agriculture stood at £17 million. There is no comparison between £81 million and £17 million.

Comment on this

The Deputy is talking a lot of tommyrot.

Comment on this

Facts.

Comment on this

Rot.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Order.

Comment on this

Creamery milk is subsidised to the tune of £27 million. The subsidy has risen from £6 million in 1963-64 to £27 million in the current financial year. This is evidence, if evidence is needed, of the desire of Fianna Fáil to help the small farmer in particular. There is the two-tier price now for milk with an increase on the first 7,000 gallons. The Opposition tried to scoff at these increases and to run them down. There are difficulties with regard to the export market and that is why the taxpayer has to subsidise creamery milk. The time this man we hear praised so much was Minister for Agriculture——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Fahey is in possession and Deputies should allow him to speak.

Comment on this

When the Minister for Agriculture in the Coalition Government experienced difficulty with regard to the export market, instead of increasing the subsidy, as we have done, from £6 million in 1963-64 to £27 million in the current financial year, the only solution he could find was to ask the farmers to take a reduction in the price of milk and, mark you, the price of milk was then only 1s 2d a gallon. The farmers can be thankful that that Coalition Government and that Minister for Agriculture went out of office before that suggestion could be implemented. Again, as positive proof of our interest in the small farmer, there is now complete derating of agricultural land up to a valuation of £20. As a result of that only one farmer in three pays rates today.

Comment on this

Copying Fine Gael.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Harte must cease interrupting.

Comment on this

I am keeping the record straight.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Harte can straighten it later in his own direction.

Comment on this

Deputy Harte could not straighten anything.

Comment on this

We hear much talk about rates.

Comment on this

I have had more to do with farming and for a longer number of years than the Parliamentary Secretary.

Comment on this

Deputy O.J. Flanagan will see to Deputy Lalor in Clara.

Comment on this

Is that the Fine Gael Party?

Comment on this

I am in no hurry.

Comment on this

You are stretching the Deputy's speech greatly for him. You are helping him. Would you not allow him to finish?

Comment on this

I think I have lost heart.

Comment on this

Is he still there? Fine Gael will be losing Harte shortly.

Comment on this

So long as it is not a heart attack you are all right.

Comment on this

With regard to the estimates for county councils and corporations throughout the country, we hear a lot of talk from the Opposition Parties about the amount taken in rates and we note their efforts to create an agitation amongst the people in connection with this matter. Fianna Fáil is the only Party that has done anything to relieve this burden of rates on the small farming community. I am sure that, in the County of Donegal, at least 90 per cent of the farmers must be completely de-rated. In my county, over 80 per cent of them are de-rated. This is a wonderful concession which has been given by this Government and for which there is provision in this Budget.

Comment on this

Do they not pay rates at all?

Comment on this

Even Deputy Dunne is shocked at this concession which Fianna Fáil have given to the small farmers.

Comment on this

There are no farmers in Ballyfermot.

Comment on this

What about Kinsealy?

Comment on this

I do not think Deputy Dunne should grumble about the concession given to the Donegal farmers.

Comment on this

What concession? You did not give them a Minister who pleased them.

Comment on this

I just wanted the Deputy to inform me.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

At this stage, I must urge Deputies to restrain themselves from interrupting. I would ask them to refrain from remarks and interruptions.

Comment on this

Provision is made for a beef incentive bonus. It has been said, again, that this is of no benefit to the small type of farmer. It has been said that it is something that will benefit the large ranch holder, the man of broad acres. I have heard it said by Opposition speakers——

Comment on this

Whatever suits the Deputy, he hears.

Comment on this

It is not a big enough bonus.

Comment on this

We have increased it from £8 to £12. It is typical of Deputy Harte and of Fine Gael to say that it is not big enough.

Comment on this

If you sell one pint of milk, you do not get it. It is only for a few farmers——

Comment on this

Anything given is not big enough.

Comment on this

For a Party that jeopardised the agricultural community in 1931 and 1932, you are not giving enough.

Comment on this

I want to deal with this beef incentive bonus scheme. I think this will be a tremendous help to the small dairy farmer as well as to the farmer on the broad acres. I have pointed out that creamery milk is subsidised to the extent of £27 million and this is a considerable contribution from the taxpayers. The beef incentive bonus scheme is brought in to encourage the farmer who is not in milk production to stay out of it. It is brought in, also, so that the farmer who is half in milk and half in beef will go over entirely to beef production. In turn, this means that there will be more money available to the small family farmer who has to supply milk—either the liquid milk trade or the creameries—in order to eke out a living for himself and his family. Of course, we hear a lot of lip service being paid to the small farmer: I have to say it again. However, it is an extraordinary thing that when any concession is given to the small farmer we immediately have an agitation to extend it to the larger farmer. A typical example is that when this provision is made for de-rating of agricultural land we have all sorts of requests to extend the concession to the larger farmer as well. It has also been suggested that there should be a £50 employment allowance rather than £17 at present.

Comment on this

This is the only country in Europe which pays rates on agricultural land.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy suggesting that all our farmers should be de-rated with a consequent change in the taxation system whereby they should be required to keep books and to have them audited and to pay income tax, the same as other sections of the community?

Comment on this

Mr. de Valera promised complete de-rating for years and years and years.

Comment on this

The second mischief-maker has arrived.

Comment on this

Surely the Parliamentary Secretary should be more orderly?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair will have to insist that Deputies will refrain from these remarks and interjections.

Comment on this

Perhaps it is that I am annoying the Opposition too much by the facts which I am giving. After all, we know that last year—we do not know what they will do this year—they indicated their interest in the 100-cow farmer and forgot entirely about the small farmer to whom so much lip service is now being paid.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach against Colley.

Comment on this

That was their policy last year. We must wait and see what their policy will be this year.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

The Parliamentary Secretary was not one of the nineteen.

Comment on this

I am sure they will change their policy so as to appeal to the masses in rural Ireland——

Comment on this

Hear, hear. That is what you did. "Minis" are becoming unpopular now.

Comment on this

They might be naked shortly.

Comment on this

The taxpayer will be naked before long.

Comment on this

A minor-mini.

Comment on this

A political "mini" is a very unattractive sight.

Comment on this

I am in no hurry whatsoever. I do not mind if I am speaking here in April, 1970.

Comment on this

The Deputy will probably be over here.

Comment on this

I want to point out that the concession to increase the employment allowance from £17 to £50 would cost £2 million. If we had this money, it would be much better to use it to try to encourage employment on agricultural land, such as by giving an exemption to the agricultural worker in respect of income tax. Employment on the land is falling drastically. We can be thankful that we have this Fianna Fáil policy which seeks to ensure that they are being absorbed into industry and which seeks to find employment for them in this country. We should also like to welcome the increase of 3s a barrel in the price of barley which plays a very important part in the economy of our working farmers——

Comment on this

More porter.

Comment on this

——in whom Fine Gael showed, at the last Ard Fheis, they are no longer interested. Fianna Fáil have always looked after the weaker sections in the community whether they be among the farming class, the social welfare class or any other class and we shall continue to look after their best interests. We will continue to do that.

Comment on this

You left them squatting outside Merrion Street for 21 days.

Comment on this

In their own interests.

Comment on this

They would love to hear that.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Order. Deputy Fahey.

Comment on this

The increase in the small farm incentive bonus scheme is also welcome. This scheme is proving to be of tremendous help to this particular type of farmer in whom we have an interest. We would like to see the scheme being availed of to a greater extent than it is. It has not been long in operation yet and perhaps it is not appreciated as much as it should be but interest will be created through the increased grant. This serves a twofold purpose, it brings the agricultural advisory service into close contact with the farmer and thus he will be able to make a reasonable living from his agricultural holdings. We have always tried to keep the incomes of the agricultural community in line with the incomes of those employed in industry and this is part of that policy being implemented.

The increases being given for buildings, silage and dry stock houses, as well as the increase in grants for the provision of water supplies, are also to be welcomed. These are all very necessary in order that the farmer may be able to expand to the point where he will be able to have increased numbers of stock on his farm. This will mean an improvement in farmers' incomes and it will also be to the national advantage to have this kind of activity created on the farms. I do not see how the Opposition will be successful in convincing the farming community that they have been neglected in this or in any other Fianna Fáil Budget.

Comment on this

The leader of the NFA, Mr. Maher, said it on the night of the Budget.

Comment on this

He is leading you. Everything he says you want to say it after him.

Comment on this

The agricultural community will also benefit from the tremendous increases in social welfare benefits that we have given once again, especially those with young families who are trying to bring them up on a limited number of acres.

Comment on this

It is a pity they are not all listening to the Deputy.

Comment on this

There is no need for me to say anything more about the benefits contained in the Budget for the agricultural community, as they will be appreciated. The farming community, just like social welfare recipients, have always appreciated what they have received from the Fianna Fáil Government. I should like now to deal with health services the provision for which this year is £30½ million, which is an increase from £9½ million in 1961-62. We can, therefore, see the tremendous expansion that has taken place and this is as it should be, because what could be more important than the health of the people? It is important that they should be adequately catered for and this has always been the policy of this Government and will continue to be. Again, the impression is being created that Fianna Fáil have done nothing to relieve the burden on the rates of the health charges. This is completely unfounded because we have set ourselves a policy of putting more and more of the cost on central funds each year and we will continue to do that. The Opposition Parties have made many suggestions about how the health services could be financed but their suggestions would mean that the lower paid people would be asked to contribute for some service which at present is being provided free.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

It is absolutely true.

Comment on this

The Deputy should study these things. I will send the Deputy a copy of the Fine Gael policy on this.

Comment on this

Which one?

Comment on this

The one to which the Deputy is referring.

Comment on this
A Deputy

What about next week's one?

Comment on this

I have seen so many policies that I do not know to which one the Deputy is referring.

Comment on this

The farmers heard about the one at the Ard Fheis when your Party was talking about the 100-cow farmer and they will note the change in policy in 12 months. If we are to have an election this year they will have to play up again to the small farmer who is in the great majority, especially in constituencies like Donegal and Tipperary.

Comment on this

"What about the working man"—the Fianna Fáil catch-cry?

Comment on this

If my advice to the Fine Gael Party is worth anything they should continue to concentrate on the larger farmer, as they did at the Ard Fheis last year, and not turn around now and try to win over the small farmers who are in the vast majority because then they will not have the confidence of either the big farmers or the small farmers. By trying to play them both up they lose the confidence of both and——

Comment on this

As long as the Deputy keeps speaking for Fianna Fáil we will not have to worry.

Comment on this

——they will continue to lose and this suits us fine. Nevertheless, I do not like to see you going entirely wrong. If the health charges were taken over completely as a national charge, as advocated by the Opposition Parties, it would take a huge amount of money from central funds and this in turn would mean that there would have to be a huge increase in taxation; we would be unable to find the money to provide benefits for the less well off sections of the community in whom we are sincerely interested. You would also be relieving of rates the large farmer and the large business man. This is not our policy and it never will be.

Comment on this

It is not ours.

Comment on this

It is the policy of the Fine Gael Party but we will make sure that the people will see it for what it is. I do not think we will have a hard job getting this message across.

Comment on this

Keep him at it. Every time he opens his mouth he is getting us votes.

Comment on this

That could not be said for the Deputy.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary could not even get me a telephone.

Comment on this

I must also express thanks to the Minister and the Government for remembering that section of the community to which we all owe so much, the Old IRA, and we welcome the increase these people have got. We also welcome this £25 burial grant because we know that nothing is more disappointing than to find one of those who did so much for the country dying in distress and a collection having to be made for his burial. This will no longer be the case. It has always been Fianna Fáil policy to look after the Old IRA to whom we owe so much. We would like to do much more but we are the only Party to have done anything for them at any time and what we can do depends on the expansion that takes place in the economy. That must be the guideline for any Government.

Comment on this

The Government are subsidising their burial.

Comment on this