Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 13—General (resumed).
Contributions 90–221 of 221. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
On a point of order, I do not want to attribute to the Minister any male fides in this matter but it appears to me that his speech is more like a speech concluding a debate on the Estimate for the Department of Local Government. There is supposed to be a general discussion on the Budget. The Minister is now speaking for 1¾ hours.
Comment on this
It is perfectly apparent that this is an effort to prevent other Deputies from speaking tonight.
Comment on this
It is not. I am dealing with points raised by Deputy O'Donnell in Fine Gael and Deputy Micheal O'Leary in the Labour Party.
Comment on this
There should be general references, not detailed references, to matters peculiar to one Department. The Minister is going into detail on all aspects of local government at considerable length.
Comment on this
I am trying to show how this Budget refutes the charges made here tonight—quite apart from the rest of the Budget debate—by Deputy O'Donnell on behalf of Fine Gael and by Deputy O'Leary on behalf of the Labour Party.
Comment on this
Surely the Minister is not entitled to go into such detail on a general Budget debate?
Comment on this
As the Chair understands it, the Minister has been dealing with the outlook in regard to housing in the light of the provision for it in the capital Budget. Therefore, the Chair understands that the Minister is developing that theme.
Comment on this
For one hour and 45 minutes, the Minister has been going into the most complete detail on grants, housing and so forth. That, I submit, is out of order.
Comment on this
It is for the obvious purpose of keeping everybody else out of the debate and so that the Minister will have the last word in this House before the general election.
Comment on this
I have no intention in the world of doing that. I shall give Deputies opposite plenty of time——
Comment on this
No. I am nearly finished about housing. But Deputies opposite also dealt with water. Deputy O'Donnell was very critical of the group water schemes and regional water schemes. Surely, in view of that, and in view of the record of Fine Gael, I have a right to refer to that also?
Comment on this
When he proceeded to refer to water, Deputy O'Donnell was ruled out of order because it was not relevant to a general Budget debate.
Comment on this
That is not so. He was not. He dealt with both group and regional water schemes. The records will show that he was not ruled out of order.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Higgins could not know, because he was not here. He never is here at that time of night.
Comment on this
I was in this House before the Minister and I shall be in it after him. I have been in the House, contrary to the Minister's information.
Comment on this
Yes. I submit that, in view of all the adverse references that have been made to the housing achievements of the Government, in view of the suggestions that this should be dealt with by way of a crash programme, I, as Minister for Local Government, am compelled to show how it is that this Budget provides the framework for the meeting of our housing needs——
Comment on this
——and to show that it arranges to provide for the final year of the White Paper issued in 1964 and for the initial stages of the White Paper now in course of issue. Quite apart from the two contributions we had here this evening from Deputy O'Donnell of Fine Gael and Deputy O'Leary of Labour, the whole trend of the debate indicates that, before the debate could be said adequately to have been dealt with, it is necessary to show just how this Budget in itself gives the lie to the charges that were made and the ridiculousness of the things that were said by the Opposition with regard to housing.
Comment on this
I was pointing out that, in spite of that, it will obviously be possible to keep on increasing the amount of the community's resources available for housing. If we are to succeed in meeting our housing needs by 1975, it will also be desirable to try to ensure that this amount of money is spread over the provision of a greater number of units of accommodation. Therefore, it would appear to be desirable to increase the inducements to provide the smaller type of house, the type of house that is required by the people who avail of loans under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts——
Comment on this
——and to divert as much as possible of the capital from the larger and more expensive type of house to this type of house which is our main need. I want to point out that, at present, we have the same rate of grant available for houses up to 1,500 square feet, whereas our main need is for the smaller type of house, the house up to 1,250 square feet and 1,050 square feet which is the type of house that is mainly sought after by people who most need help for the provision of their own houses, those who apply for SDA loans and who, in most cases, also qualify for supplementary grants from the local authority. There are a great number of people who are anxious to provide themselves with their own houses, who feel themselves capable of meeting the outgoings on a new house, of meeting the cost of the loan and so on but who find this one great difficulty of accumulating the deposits that are required for new houses. One of the results of this difficulty is that many of these people who are anxious to undertake the solution of their own housing trouble have been left with no option but to apply to the local authority for housing.
In order to try to ensure the greater provision of this type of house I even considered going as far as withdrawing grants for the larger type of house but this I decided against. The fact is that because we have a seller's market there is this tendency by private enterprise builders to go for the maximum standard of house which is reasonably saleable, but if more of the type which is within the reach of the lower income group were available then the available capital could obviously cover a greater number of houses. It has been decided to re-direct the grant scheme towards producing a greater incentive for the smaller type of house. As I said, I considered the withdrawal of grants for the larger type of house but, bearing in mind that many houses up to 1,500 square feet are not necessarily luxurious or extravagant in any way but are purchased by middle income group people who need a larger house and who leave available a smaller, more modest house to fill somebody else's need, we decided to leave the £275 grant as at present available for houses between 1,250 and 1,500 square feet but to increase the grant for houses between 1,050 and 1,250 to £300 and to increase the grant for houses between 850 and 1,050 square feet to £325.
Comment on this
With the addition of the supplementary grant people in the former category, that is between 1,050 square feet and 1,200 square feet, will have an increase of £50 available and for the more modest type house, from 850 square feet to 1,050 square feet, which is the one we are more immediately concerned with, there will be an increased amount of £100 available. This should be a considerable help towards bridging the gap between the necessary deposit and what people find it possible to raise. It should have the effect of more concentration on what is urgently needed and, at the same time, by making it possible for people, who have no alternative at present but to apply for housing to the local authority, to purchase their own houses it should make the local authorities' problem more capable of solution. It certainly should make the achievement of meeting the housing needs within the period covered by the White Paper reasonably feasible.
Unfortunately, I must deal with the question of sanitary services because of the completely illogical criticisms that were made by Deputy O'Donnell. It is a particularly noticeable example of the effrontery of Fine Gael Deputies that we should have raised here again this complaint with regard to the provision of water supplies in rural areas. I know I do not have to remind Fine Gael of the manner in which they greeted the efforts of my predecessor to get local authorities to make an effort in regard to the provision of regional water supply schemes. The then Leader of the Fine Gael Party, Deputy Dillon, described this as a scheme that could not be conceived outside of Bedlam, an insane scheme— to suggest the provision of piped water to houses in rural Ireland. However, despite the antagonism of the Opposition Parties we were successful in getting local authorities to go ahead with these schemes and satisfactory progress has been made.
The provision for sanitary services in this year's Budget is £5.75 million as against £4.5 million last year. In 1968-69 the State's contribution to loan charges for sanitary services works amounted to £1.11 million, an increase of £109,209 over the previous year and this year's Budget provides for a further increase of £90,000, a further record in this regard. It is clear that satisfactory progress in regard to regional water schemes generally is in fact being achieved and that this Budget makes further provision for a continuance of this satisfactory progress. As I have stated in reply to a Parliamentary Question, the total value of schemes that are in planning amounts to £60 million. Obviously, then, it is ridiculous to think of this whole programme being tackled at the same time. I consider that the action I took in calling on local authorities to carry out reviews of the schemes that they have proposed in order to identify the most urgent schemes and the most urgent sections of schemes was a wise procedure. Obviously, with that £60 million worth of schemes either prepared or in course of preparation, if one is to make a wise choice one must have an order of priority established and the most suitable body to establish that order of priority is the local authority. Therefore, I requested the local authorities to arrange the schemes in order of priority and to identify the particularly urgent schemes.
The result of that comprehensive review carried out over the whole country is that it has been established that there are urgent schemes to the value of £20 million and in the last financial year, 1968-69, we released schemes to the value of £5.1 million. That I think was a substantial achievement and the release of these schemes was related to the availability of money to finance them. We took into account the fact that not all of the work in connection with the schemes started in that financial year would be completed in the financial year. We also took into account the fact that the release of these schemes would involve a continuing commitment in many cases in the succeeding financial years and possibly in respect of some of the larger schemes in future financial years.
Obviously, when there is a major regional water supply scheme being constructed it could not be done in the one financial year and when there is a really major scheme, such as the North Dublin Regional Water Supply Scheme, the operations will obviously be spread over a number of financial years. In this respect, I was glad to be able to inform the House yesterday that this scheme, which is the largest ever to be undertaken in this country, is in the course of completion. It is a measure of the success of the Government's economic policies and of the wisdom of the Budgets introduced by Fianna Fáil Ministers for Finance. This scheme involves a cost of £2,000,000 and is now almost completed.
In 1968-69 we released £5.1 million worth of regional water supply schemes and the planning of the remainder of the schemes regarded as being urgent is proceeding. They will be available to be released in the light of the capital position obtaining at any particular time. In addition to this £5.1 million we also released last year a further £300,000 worth of smaller urgent schemes and the pool of work in progress in so far as water supply schemes are concerned on 31st March, 1969, amounted to more than £7 million. All this on a scheme that was described in such contemptuous terms by the Opposition when it was being pressed on local authorities some years ago. They now have the nerve to object to the rate of progress. They have the effrontery to demand that all of the £60 million worth of schemes should be started immediately and, apparently, completed within the financial year.
Once again, I do not think that in this respect, as in any other of the matters that have been raised here and that have been criticised by the Opposition, that the people will fall for this type of thing. They will see the absurdity of the suggestion that all the work should be done immediately and, apparently, the labour force and the constructional capacity that would have to be developed to carry out such an operation would have to be dissipated immediately the schemes were finished. It is quite obvious that this must be a comparatively long term programme but, as long as the economy continues to develop as it has been doing under Fianna Fáil, the substantial progress that has been made will continue and increase in the future.
In so far as Dublin is concerned, it is a fact that the expansion of the city laid considerable strain on the capacity of the sewerage system. This has resulted in a comparative scarcity of building land and has contributed in no small way to an increase in the cost of housing sites. In the Dublin area a number of major sewereage schemes are being undertaken as a matter of urgency for the purpose of ensuring that there will be an adequate supply of building land. These are being tackled as a matter of urgency and will ensure that there will shortly be an adequate amount of building land available.
The major Dodder valley scheme is already under construction and it will provide for the servicing of no less than 8,500 acres. Therefore, the Dodder valley scheme in itself, quite apart from the larger schemes in course of preparation, will make a substantial impact on the scarcity of building land.
These schemes have been put in an orderly manner to establish priority lists so that we can be sure that the available finances will be utilised to the best possible advantage. It is visualised that the local authorities will make regular surveys and may very well find reason for changing the order of priority that they established at the outset. It is intended that this can be done at any time; but it is obvious that, if I am to allocate money in an orderly and in an intelligent way, it would be necessary that local authorities should indicate to me what in their opinion is the proper order of priority of the different schemes that they have in planning.
The group water schemes are also proceeding satisfactorily. It was rather amusing to hear Deputy O'Donnell alleging that these were pioneered by voluntary bodies. They were introduced and pioneered by Fianna Fáil because of their concern for the wellbeing of the rural community and because of Fianna Fáil appreciation of the entitlement of the rural community to have these modern amenities. They were also introduced because, fundamentally, the economy of the country progressed to such an extent as to make it possible for the provision of water by groups of people in rural areas. These are complementary to the regional schemes.
Comment on this
Group water supply schemes have been dead for four years and the Minister knows that very well. The country is bankrupt.
Comment on this
Deputy L'Estrange's colleague, Deputy O'Higgins, some time ago was protesting that I was going into detail but I maintain that I was not going into detail and that I was speaking in a general way at the time about the housing situation.
Comment on this
The Deputy will not be one of them. Deputy L'Estrange is now complaining that I am not going into enough detail.
Comment on this
Group water schemes were dead at the time that the Deputy's Party had anything to do with the Department of Finance or the Department of Local Government.
Comment on this
These schemes were introduced by Fianna Fáil because of the improvement in the economy and Deputy L'Estrange does not like them.
Comment on this
In reply to a Parliamentary Question, I gave Deputy L'Estrange the facts about the increase in the indebtedness of local authorities. It is £111.22 million. That is a measure of the increased prosperity of the country under Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
It is the result of the investment by Fianna Fáil in order to provide these services for the people.
Comment on this
Before I was interrupted I was dealing with the question of money. As Deputy L'Estrange says, we will require posterity to pay for the services they are enjoying, for the houses which are being built and which will continue to be available, and for the water supply services. Deputy L'Estrange's colleague, Deputy Dillon, describes this as an insane scheme. It is the policy of Fianna Fáil to provide these things from borrowed money. Does Deputy L'Estrange say that is not Fine Gael policy?
Comment on this
Where is the money to come from for the provision of the houses? Where is the money to come from for the continuation of the regional water supply schemes?
Comment on this
Fianna Fáil borrowed money. Is Deputy L'Estrange saying that this is not Fine Gael policy?
Comment on this
It is Government policy. The Fianna Fáil Party borrowed money. Money will not be available to pay for the increased children's allowances in August next. The Government are running away from their responsibilities tonight. The Government know the money is not there.
Comment on this
The Chair must intervene again to say that the debate must be allowed to proceed. The Minister is in possession and the Deputy should cease interrupting.
Comment on this
We will have to start praying for him if he continues much longer. I take it that the Minister has concluded?
Comment on this
I wish to speak on a point of order. The Minister should sit down while the Chair is speaking.
Comment on this
Those of us who survive in this House are faced with the tedium of listening to the Minister. I ask for a quorum.
Comment on this
The Minister put the rates sky high. They are three times as high as they were ten years ago.
Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted, and 20 Members being present,
Comment on this
I am sorry for bringing Deputies in but they may as well share our purgatory. The Deputies should stay there now.
Comment on this
I have now been asked by the Fine Gael Party to deal with the question of the increased indebtedness of local authorities because of the increased investment in the provision of houses and water and sewerage services. Judging from Deputy L'Estrange's attitude, it is apparently the intention of the Fine Gael Party to base their campaign, or part of it at least, on this figure of the increase in the indebtedness of local authorities of £111.22 million. The peculiar thing is that we intend to base part of our campaign on this figure also. We are on common ground there.
Comment on this
We look on this as an indication of the success of the Fianna Fáil policy and a clear indication of the proper direction of Fianna Fáil policy.
Comment on this
First of all, Fianna Fáil increased the community's resources and, secondly, they utilised those resources for the benefit of the community as a whole.
Comment on this
We think it is good public policy for the Government to take into its hands a certain amount of capital that is available each particular year and utilise it——
Comment on this
——for the provision of houses and of water and sewerage services. That is Fianna Fáil policy. Fine Gael's is the opposite. So, let no one ever say again that there is no difference between Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael. There is. This is our policy and we look upon this £111.22 million as a measure of the success of our policy. I want to extend to Deputy O'Donnell the courtesy of completing my reply to his reference to group water schemes. As I said, the group water scheme plan is part of a tripartite approach by Fianna Fáil to the provision of water supplies in rural areas. There is the regional water supply scheme, the group water supply scheme, and there are grants for individual installations.
Comment on this
All these are complementary and it is through this comprehensive approach to the provision of water in rural areas that we intend, over a period, according as the economy expands, to bring this essential modern amenity to every house in the country. The regional water supply schemes are intended among other things, to provide the source for group water schemes. The intention is that the regional water schemes would provide the main lines and that the extension of water to areas off the actual route of the schemes would be done through the medium of group water schemes. That is an obvious way to tackle this and Deputy L'Estrange, apparently in a search for more detailed knowledge which I did not think it appropriate to provide in a debate on the Budget, alleges that group water schemes have practically stopped. The fact of the matter is——
Comment on this
——that last year there were 2,389 grants paid for group water schemes. This was a record and the fact is that this record will be improved upon this year. Much as I should like to facilitate Deputy L'Estrange, I do not think it would be appropriate to detail where all these group water schemes are for which these 2,000 odd grants have been paid, but if Deputy L'Estrange would like to put down a question next week I will give him that information.
Comment on this
There is only one other matter I want to deal with which was raised here, that is, the question of the rates and the irresponsible manner in which the Fine Gael-Labour Coalition in Dublin Corporation brought about the dissolution of Dublin Corporation.
Comment on this
What has that got to do with the Budget?
Comment on this
The fact is that a number of Opposition speakers not only today but on other days when the Budget was under discussion, criticised us on the ground that the Budget did not provide for the transfer of what is described as the rates burden from the shoulders of the ratepayers to this mysterious thing called the central fund. Since that criticism was made so often here by Deputies from the Labour Benches and the Fine Gael benches, I think that as Minister for Local Government——
Comment on this
——I am called upon to deal with the matter. I hope to deal with it reasonably briefly.
Comment on this
The Minister has been finished for a long time but he does not realise it.
Comment on this
As I said, the criticism is that this was not transferred to the Central Fund. It is quite obvious that certainly in so far as Dublin city is concerned—and that seems to have been the main bone of contention— what the Labour Party and the Fine Gael Party, in combination, are trying to do is to relieve the large commercial ratepayers of their share of this burden and transfer it to the shoulders of the small individual householders.
Comment on this
In this city of Dublin 50 per cent of the total rates raised in the Dublin Corporation area is paid in respect of commercial property. Obviously then, if we respond to the Labour Party demand and the Fine Gael Party demand to transfer this to the Central Fund, it means——
Comment on this
——that the result would obviously be to relieve the large commercial ratepayers of the contribution they are making towards——
Comment on this
——the provision of essential services for the city of Dublin and to require that to be paid by the ordinary worker and by the ordinary householder instead. That is the demand the Labour Party and the Fine Gael Party are making, because what would happen is quite clear——
Comment on this
To transfer this from the rates to the Central Fund would require an increase in turnover tax of from 5 to 6 per cent or an increase in income tax of 4/-, or an alternative method might be only to double turnover tax and to increase income tax by 2/-.
Comment on this
I do not know which of these methods Deputy L'Estrange is advocating, or which of these methods the Labour Party are advocating, but this is the magnitude of the transfer of the taxation that would be involved in meeting this demand of the two Parties opposite to relieve the large commercial ratepayers of their contribution and to make it instead payable by the ordinary householder.
Comment on this
No more suitable undertaker for this Dáil! The tug of war is off. You called it off. We know the dates. If I tell you the exact dates you will not be pleased. You called off the tug of war. I am not talking to the Minister but to the man behind him.
Comment on this
Deputy Flanagan expelled his colleague from Laois-Offaly and gave him such an impetus that he reached South County Dublin before his brother who had only to come over the border from Wicklow, and now he has expelled him from the House.
Comment on this
Peter Pan, the eternal youth. When the Deputy decided to keep his votes in the family he exported his former colleague to South County Dublin——
Comment on this
——and he came with such speed that, although his brother was half way across the border, he got there before him. Now Deputy Flanagan has chased him out of the House as well.
Comment on this
If, on the other hand, the demand is not to transfer the whole of the rates contribution to the Central Fund but instead to transfer the whole of the health charges to the Central Fund then what would be required——
Comment on this
The Minister spent six months gerrymandering the constituencies but he will be beaten despite that.
Comment on this
——would be either an increase of 3.3 per cent in turnover tax or an increase of 2/3 in income tax. Through the machinations of Fine Gael and Labour members of the Dublin City Council the decision was taken not to provide the revenue to finance the services that they had already decided to provide to reduce the amount of revenue by £870,156. Having already met in committee and decided to provide these services, having agreed on the cost of them, they then decided not to provide the money. What could the Minister for Local Government do only take the necessary steps to ensure that the citizens of Dublin would not be deprived of these essential services?