Nomination of Members of Government: Motion.
Contributions 1–189 of 1,547. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 8 parts.
Tairgim:
Go gcomhaontóidh Dáil Éireann leis an Taoiseach d'ainmniú na gComhaltaí seo a leanas chun a gceaptha ag an Uachtarán chun bheith ina gcomhaltaí den Rialtas:—
Diarmaid Ó Cróinín,
Roibeárd Ó Maoildhia agus
Gearóid Ó Coileáin
I move:
That Dáil Éireann approve the nomination by the Taoiseach of the following Members for appointment by the President to be members of the Government:—
Jerry Cronin,
Robert Molloy and
Gerard Collins.
I may say that, subject to the approval of the Dáil of the present motion and the President duly making the appointments of these additional members of the Government, I propose to assign Departments to them as follows: the Department of Defence to Deputy Cronin; the Department of Local Government to Deputy Molloy; and the Department of Posts and Telegraphs to Deputy Collins.
I shall also make the following consequential changes in the assignments of Departments: the Department of Social Welfare to Deputy Brennan, Minister for Labour; the Department of Finance to Deputy Colley, Aire na Gaeltachta; the Department of Agriculture and Fisheries to Deputy Gibbons; and the Department of Industry and Commerce to Deputy Lalor.
That implies that Deputy Brennan continues as Minister for Labour and Deputy Colley will continue to hold his portfolio as Aire na Gaeltachta.
Comment on this
Would the Taoiseach be kind enough to let us have copies of the appointments he has made because it was extremely difficult to hear them? He spoke rather fast.
Comment on this
I shall. If the House will permit I will repeat them slowly. I have assigned the Department of Defence to Deputy Jerry Cronin, the Department of Local Government to Deputy Molloy and the Department of Posts and Telegraphs to Deputy Collins. These will involve, as I have indicated, consequential changes. As the House is aware, Deputy Boland held the portfolio of Social Welfare with Local Government. I now propose to assign that to Deputy Brennan, who is Minister for Labour.
I propose to assign the Department of Finance to Deputy Colley who, as well as being Minister for Industry and Commerce, is also Minister for the Gaeltacht. He will continue to be Minister for the Gaeltacht as well as being Minister for Finance. I propose to assign the Department of Agriculture and Fisheries to Deputy Gibbons and the Department of Industry and Commerce to Deputy Lalor. The motion, in fact, is for the appointment of the three new members of the Government and what I have said subsequently is for the information of the Dáil.
Comment on this
The motion that has now been brought forward to add additional names to the Government is really of no significance in present circumstances. It does not really matter what Fianna Fáil Deputy occupies temporarily any Department. It is of no significance whether he is in one Department or another but what is of significance is the absolute lack of credibility in what was said here by the Taoiseach on Wednesday night.
I want to bring this House, and direct the attention not only of the House but of the country, through the press and every organ, to the completely false picture that was presented here in the plausible statement that was read out. I want to bring the House back to the remarks that I made at approximately 4 o'clock last Wednesday when I said: "Can the Taoiseach say if this is the only Ministerial resignation we can expect?" The Taoiseach's reply, and I am quoting from volume 246 of the Official Report, Column 519, was:
I do not know what the Deputy is referring to.
I went on to ask:
"Is it only the tip of the iceberg?"
The Taoiseach: Would the Deputy like to enlarge on what he has in mind?
Then Deputy L'Estrange intervened and I said:
The Taoiseach can deal with the situation.
The Taoiseach: I can assure the Deputy I am in complete control of whatever situation might arise.
That statement implies and confirms that the Taoiseach's statement to this House on Wednesday night was not a true picture of the facts. The facts are that according to that statement no other resignations were in the offing; no other resignations had been asked for.
At approximately 8 o'clock on Tuesday night I went to the Taoiseach's room and gave him the facts that I have related to the House. By 10 o'clock two Ministers had been dismissed or an attempt had been made to dismiss them, and at approximately the same time a third had resigned. I want the House and the country to decide, once and for all, if we can believe anything from any Fianna Fáil Minister or Deputy.
The facts are that the Taoiseach misrepresented in that statement the true facts of the situation and the real facts were suppressed from the House elected to serve the people until I felt it my duty to disclose the facts as I knew them. Now we have the statement as reported in today's papers from Deputy Kevin Boland saying: "I am sure that the ex-Minister for Justice was asked to resign." When the ex-Minister for Justice was asked what the situation was, he said: "No comment."
When will we get the truth? When will we get the truth without consideration of face-saving of Ministers or the Taoiseach or of ex-Ministers?
This is the greatest scandal that has hit this State since we won independence. I am not given to verbal exaggeration. In fact, some of my friends in the press have probably thought that I have been unduly mild in my remarks during my political career. I am not given to exaggeration. The facts as presented in this disclose a deliberate attempt to conceal the true situation. It is irrelevant to give the plausible story which was given with such brevity by the Taoiseach the other night.
He gave a short litany of events that concealed the true picture, that is completely refuted by the times and statements contained in the Official Report. This country is entitled to get, and entitled to expect, from whoever is head of the Government and from the Ministers elected to serve this Parliament, at least the truth about their actions. What does it matter what Ministers are added or subtracted from this Government? What does it matter what Department any Fianna Fáil Minister is assigned to? They do not know what is happening. They are not telling each other the truth. One is giving one picture now and another picture at a later stage.
It is no wonder that when the Tánaiste and Minister for Health was on radio and television he was bewildered. He was bewildered because, to put it in his own words, it was a complex problem. He did not know the situation that existed. He did not know what his colleagues were doing. They did not tell him. They did not tell the Taoiseach. When they were asked to resign or asked to explain their attitude, they denied participation and refused their resignations. Two of them refused their resignations. Have the House and the country analysed this? Two refused their resignations and the third resigned in protest because the other Ministers had refused to accept the request of the Taoiseach.
This is a situation, as I said the other night, unparalleled in the history of this country. In the past, in different stages of our history, either during the '98 period or during the period when Michael Collins eliminated those who were informing on the Irish people, at least it was British secret service money that was being used to betray the Irish nation. Today the people who are elected and paid to serve them are betraying them with money provided by the Irish people.
Comment on this
It does not matter to what Department any Fianna Fáil Deputy is assigned. The fact is that a deliberate and calculated attempt was made to conceal the facts from this House and that every Member from the Taoiseach down is involved in that effort.
Comment on this
They were concealing from each other the plots, the intrigues, the subterfuges. I do not ask anyone to accept anything I have said —although my information has been dead accurate. I draw the attention of the House and of the people, and in particular the attention of the press and every organ of communication, to the facts as presented here when I asked at approximately 4 o'clock on Tuesday last:
Can the Taoiseach say if this is the only Ministerial resignation we can expect?
The Taoiseach said:
I do not know what the Deputy is referring to.
and I asked:
Is it only the tip of the iceberg?
As I said the other night it was a modest comment.
The Taoiseach said:
Would the Deputy like to enlarge on what he has in mind?
It was not until I presented the situation as I knew it that the Taoiseach and those of his Ministers who were left with him knew that the game was up and they could no longer conceal the true facts of the situation from the people. The game was up. They had run their course. Now, having disagreed amongst themselves, they are all starting to talk and give different accounts and different reports of what happened, including the concern Deputy Boland has had about 'phone tapping. No one can accept, nobody can believe, a single statement by any Fianna Fáil Minister. I regret having to say that because I agree with Deputy O'Higgins that there are many decent men in the Fianna Fáil Party, there are some decent Ministers in the Fianna Fáil Party——
Comment on this
——but they have not been able to come to the surface. This is not merely a serious question for the Fianna Fáil Party. What is serious is that it reflects on the whole fabric and the whole character of the nation. I want to assure those not merely in this part of the country but in the Six Counties of the north as well, that people need not be unduly concerned. They have here a realistic and capable and patriotic alternative Government composed of men of integrity, composed of people who, totally disregarding self-interest, are prepared to serve the nation.
For the second time in the past half-century, in our long and checkered history, this country and our people may thank God that they have this party to maintain and defend and assert the people's rights.
Comment on this
Only for this party there would be a real danger of civil war, civil war of the worst kind, of a religious character. This Taoiseach and this Government must now resign and dissolve this Dáil and let the people elect a Government in whom they can have confidence and who will guarantee their lives and liberties, their homes and hearts and show to the world that this country, this State established by Griffith and Collins, is fit to and will govern itself.
Comment on this
This country is still in a state of shock over what has been disclosed here during the past few days. The fact that the Taoiseach and Ministers have made statements on radio and television and in the newspapers that there is no crisis only makes the matter much worse. Let me try to put the facts as we see them.
It is alleged that two Senior Ministers of this Government who were pledged to uphold the State and whose job it was to see that the State was properly run, made arrangements to have imported into this country large quantities of arms for the use of an illegal organisation. One of the objects of that illegal organisation is the overthrow of this State. The fact that the organisation concerned have refused to recognise the right of Stormont or Dáil Éireann to govern in either part of the country is known to everybody. The fact that the Ministers concerned have agreed apparently, to help to bring arms into this country to further that organisation's objects makes the statement of the Taoiseach that there is now unity in his party and that those Ministers have agreed, as backbenchers of his party, to uphold the Constitution of the State and to support him as Taoiseach, look very, very thin indeed.
The real seriousness of this case does not appear to have been brought home to the Taoiseach, and I shall endeavour to do so this morning. He has stated again and again that there was an attempt to import arms and that that attempt has been prevented from coming to fruition. Is the Taoiseach prepared to stand up here and say that no arms have been imported into this country by that illegal organisation with the collusion of the Ministers concerned?
Comment on this
Does the Taoiseach say it is a certainty that arms have not been coming in here for quite some time under various guises, and have been channelled through to the people concerned? Would the Taoiseach care to say where the money came from to buy the arms? Surely the Taoiseach should at least know where the £80,000 paid for this consignment came from and who got it? Does that £80,000 represent the price paid for the arms, or is there a further substantial sum involved for the hire of aircraft and to pay agents for the purpose of seeing that the arms came into the country? Would the Taoiseach care to say if that £80,000 and the other money, which assuredly was spent, came from State funds? Does he know whether it was covered up in the Budget passed in this House? Are we paying for ammunition and arms which can be, and may be, used yet against this House and against this country? Would the Taoiseach say whether or not he has any evidence to disprove that suggestion?
Was the money produced by individuals who bought arms, in the typical Middle East way, for the purpose of re-selling them at a profit in this country? Was it just a business transaction? We know some people have been involved in business transactions involving vast sums of money —people who wanted to make a "quick buck" and were not too particular how it was made? Or—and this is a horrible thing, the most horrible thing of all—was this money the proceeds of the bank raids in this country? Was it collected by an illegal organisation in bank raids and raids on the pay packets of workers? Was it handed over for the purpose of supplying arms here, with the collusion of members of this Government? It must have been handed over or the arms would not have been put on the plane. If so, is there truth in the rumour that because of this no effort whatever was made to try to capture the people who so foully murdered a member of the Garda who was attempting to prevent them from carrying out the raid?
Comment on this
The one thing which I cannot take from the Fianna Fáil Party is the suggestion that anybody is acting "disgracefully". Fianna Fáil are the people who, led by the Taoiseach, last year told the people all around Ireland that if the Labour Party got into power and got support, they would bring in what he termed foreign influence. The Taoiseach used the words "alien philosophy". Down through the country, as Deputy M. P. Murphy mentioned, people like him had to put up with the henchmen of Fianna Fáil at church gates saying "Do you want to see your parish priest in chains? Do you want to see people going around carrying arms prepared to hold up everybody and to have an armed uprising in the country"? The Taoiseach stood up the day before yesterday and said—no doubt he will stand up today and say the same thing —there is no crisis in this country. The Fianna Fáil Party talked of an alien philosophy, yet they have in their ranks two people who can only be counted with Carson. Carson was a member of a Parliament which claimed to control this country, yet he brought in arms for the purpose of helping an illegal organisation. I subscribe to the view that, not alone are there decent Fianna Fáil Ministers, but there are very decent Fianna Fáil Deputies here, many of whom I am proud to claim as friends of mine. They are prepared to band together now to hold together an unholy alliance. As far as I can see they are only sticking together now because if they do not hang together, they will hang separately.
The people of the country have had just about enough. I do not know whether the Fianna Fáil Deputies here have had an opportunity of going round and talking with the normal Fianna Fáil supporters. The only word which has been mentioned to me and is repeatable in this House is "disgust". They are absolutely disgusted that the party which they had been supporting for so many years should consider there was no crisis when two of their senior members had apparently accepted the accusation which had been made. They accepted apparently their removal from the Cabinet without any protest about their being framed. They were apparently prepared to agree that they had got just punishment. These Fianna Fáil supporters are disgusted that their party are prepared to accept the support of these men for the purpose of remaining in office.
There is another serious matter affecting this issue: it appears that efforts are being made to smear the police force, the Defence Forces and anybody else, providing the Fianna Fáil Party are not smeared. I think there is necessity for the Taoiseach, who is a man for whom I have high personal regard, to disclose the facts. I think he is attempting to cover up for his colleagues. I regret to have to say that I agree entirely with what Deputy Cosgrave has said. I do not believe we would have heard a word about this, at least not for many months, but for the fact that there was a danger of its being brought out into the open in this House.
There is an onus on the Taoiseach to stand up here—galling and humiliating as it may be—to tell the House whether or not he has told the whole truth. People tell white lies in an effort to try to cover up from time to time. The desire of the Taoiseach not to humiliate his party even more has put him in the position of having to stall. I would not accuse him of being a dishonest man normally, but he is being politically dishonest now in this House because nobody can believe what he said here over the last few days. Nobody is prepared to accept that there might have been a suggestion these Ministers were involved, but no proof.
I was listening to the Tánaiste on television. He used the word "conspirators". One does not lightly use the word "conspirators" unless one is sure what one is talking about. The Tánaiste had not the privilege of the House when he was talking then. He spoke about these young men being carried away by the fear that the people in the Six Counties would find themselves in the position where they could be abused—in the position where they would need guns. The Tánaiste felt that these young men were carried away by that fear and the implication was that it was quite in order to do what they did. No, the Tánaiste did not say that they were right; he said they were wrong. The Tánaiste did not suggest they were wrong or hint they were wrong; he said definitely they were wrong. There was no doubt in his mind that the two Ministers who were asked to resign were involved up to their necks in it.
I am sad that somebody of Deputy Charlie Haughey's ability should be involved in this. He is a man for whom I had great regard. He did things with which I did not agree but, at the same time, he was a man who appeared to be prepared to stand on his own feet. I never thought Deputy Haughey would be a man of whom it would be told in this House that he plotted the overthrow of the Government of this country. There is no other description for this. If one succeeds, or attempts to succeed, in building up an organisation whose object is the overthrow of the Government and to take over completely the State for themselves, then one can only be accused of plotting against the State. The fact that the person concerned was in charge of the Department of Finance makes the matter even worse.
Over the past couple of weeks, we have heard stories. Perhaps the Taoiseach would be able to give a definite assurance on this. We heard about the boatload of arms at Dublin port, clearance on a note by the Department of Finance and collection by the Army. This is the kind of talk that is thrown about at the moment in relation to the Army. This is the common talk in Dublin. If this talk is incorrect, a definite statement to the contrary should be made.
We heard yesterday evening about arms coming through Dublin Airport and labelled as "Red Cross Supplies". This has been denied by the head of the Red Cross. Would the Taoiseach say if it is untrue? Would the Taoiseach say why the British Army in the north have been searching along the Border over the past couple of weeks? Surely it was not for the cargo of arms which never got into the country. Surely the Taoiseach must know there was a reason for that search, as there is also a reason for the search this morning in County Fermanagh? Surely the Taoiseach must know about the consignments of arms that came in here? He said he knew about it on 22nd April, 1970. MI-5 stated they knew of this conspiracy for the past seven months. They said they knew of an international ring which had arranged to bring arms into this country from a number of continental countries. You cannot do that on peanuts. It brings me back to the question of where the money came from.
The money came from one of three sources. It came (1) from the adventurer who wanted to invest for the purpose of making a quick buck; (2) it came from the taxpayers of Ireland —fiddling the State finances—in which money was transferred for the purposes of this illegal organisation or (3) it came from the bank raids. You do not find money like that on the street. You do not go out and pick up the hundreds of thousands of pounds required. The people responsible for doing that have been referred to by the Tánaiste to this effect: "No offence has been committed in the State. Therefore, no charges will be made against these people".
Comment on this
The Tánaiste was quoted in the newspapers as saying that. Perhaps the newspaper people might be anxious to make the correction. I do not know what one has to do in this country to commit an offence. The fellow who parks his car for an hour on the wrong side of the street will tell you what you have to do. Very definitely, there appears to be one law for the rich and another law for the poor; one law for Fianna Fáil and another law for everybody else.
We had, of course, the statement from Deputy Boland that he was resigning from the Government. He was definitely entitled to do so. The funny thing about it—unfortunately, it is too tragic to be funny—Deputy Boland is not quite clear why he has resigned. Apparently his first reason was as a protest against the treatment of the other Ministers. This morning's newspapers suggest he resigned because the Taoiseach was attempting to find out, on Deputy Boland's telephone, what was happening; in other words, he resigned because the Taoiseach was tapping his telephone. Maybe Deputy Boland had another reason. I am quite sure Deputy Boland would love to be a Minister who could stand up and be counted if there are any haloes for heroes being handed out, particularly if we can shout about what we are going to do in the north.
The Labour Party subscribe to the policy that the Border cannot be removed by force. If at any time the decision in this country is changed— if a decision is taken that other means are to be employed—the place to take that decision is Dáil Éireann. If it is taken in this House, the Labour Party —as they always have been—will be the first in the van. We have always played our part and we shall continue to play our part.
Whether or not it is a ridiculous suggestion, if the Government and the people of this country want to take a decision on that matter, then they are entitled to do so. However, no penny-ha'penny Minister is entitled to come along here and decide, while drawing £6,000 a year salary with all the "perks", to have his own private army for the purpose of, according to what he says, fighting in the north and, according to what the general public says, destroying society as we know it in this country.
When the Taoiseach again goes to the country—it will not be very long until he has to do so—every time the word "alien philosophy" comes to his lips I am sure he will make a desperate effort to check himself from uttering the words. I am sure he will be very anxious not to allow those words to slip out. I am sure he will be equally anxious to avoid all reference to the holding up of anybody, to the imprisonment of anybody, to taking arms against them. In such circumstances, he will surely think of what has happened in this country over the past few days. Certainly, he will lose votes if he does not.
The only people who have been proved to be trying to import an alien philosophy here are the people who, the Taoiseach claims, are loyal supporters of his and who keep him in power. On television two nights ago, the Tánaiste gave me much material for thought. He said that, as far as this country was concerned, it was not the most serious thing that has happened. According to him, the inter-Party Government which he described as "the Coalition Government," had done much worse.
Did the Tánaiste seriously consider that anybody listening to him would believe that the crisis we are now experiencing can be measured in any way against anything that happened during the lifetime of either of our inter-Party Governments? How can we get it home to the Tánaiste, to the Taoiseach and to the responsible members of Fianna Fáil—I am sure there are some responsible members in that Government—that, even up to this minute, there is serious danger of civil war in this? Does the Taoiseach think that the people who swore fealty to him and to this State as recently as last June, on taking office, and now have been responsible for this scandalous situation can be trusted? Is it not a fact that the obvious action for people who have done wrong is to wait for an opportunity until they can get the better of their opponents and that such persons will be quite willing to sit back and to agree to anything in the meantime? If the Taoiseach could not trust these people when they were Ministers of this State, surely he cannot trust them now as ordinary Members of this House?
That brings me back to the suggestion by the Tánaiste that it was quite in order for these people to be Members of this House and that if any action was to be taken it was a matter for the Attorney General—who sat through this debate squirming, I am sure, at some of the things which were said. The Attorney General is a decent man. He must have known he was being put on the "hot seat". Does the Tánaiste or does the Taoiseach seriously suggest that these men should be allowed to remain Members of this House, members of the Fianna Fáil Party, with a possible chance of reappointment? Does he suggest that the Attorney General, even if he had the evidence, would dare to take any action against them? Is it not crystal clear from what the Taoiseach said when he accepted them back as supporters of his in this House that what he meant was "You are now safe. You will not be prosecuted no matter what you did"?
I am not one of those people who would blame a person for holding views. As I have said, I am surprised about Deputy Haughey, but I feel that if Deputy Blaney, in particular, Deputy Boland or Deputy Moran have views they are entitled to them. I suppose a substantial number of people throughout this country hold similar views. They are perfectly entitled to consider that the solution of the northern problem lies at least in supplying arms for people across the Border so that they can fight for, say, a couple of weeks and that it can be said that the Irish spirit is not dead. The fact that they will all be slaughtered a few weeks later is not taken into consideration. But people are entitled to their views.
That is the difference. Deputy Haughey, a few weeks ago, drew up a Budget which some people regarded as being great. On the evening of the day that Budget was introduced spoke to a man who said there was nothing wrong with it but on the following Friday evening, I spoke to the same man and he cursed solidly for five minutes. I have never heard such bad language for such a sustained period. He realised then as did the people that the Budget was aimed at nothing else but to destroy the country and to destroy the Fianna Fáil Government because, having made no attempt to deal with the balance of payments and having made everybody dissatisfied with his lot because of the particular way in which it was dealt with, the then Minister for Finance created the situation, accidentally or otherwise, in which the Taoiseach was put in the hot seat to present that Budget to the country.
Because of what has happened since then the point has been made by a number of people, including some Fianna Fáil supporters, that it would appear that what Deputy Haughey put before the House was the one Budget which could cause the most discontent at any particular time. Of course, the old story is if you want to have a revolution—God knows we have heard enough talk here from certain elements about revolution—the thing to do is to make as many people as possible discontented. Deputy Haughey succeeded in doing that in the Budget that was introduced here by the Taoiseach.
I do not know whether the matter with which we have dealt over the past few days is to be glossed over and an effort made by Fianna Fáil to show solidarity so that they can hold on to the Government of the country. My suggestion to the Taoiseach is that in view of all we have been told and in view of the general views of which he must be aware, unless he is living in some sort of vacuum, that the people of the country are not satisfied with what has happened, the old game of trying to drag in a red herring, or of trying to introduce the question of 'phone tapping or something else as being important, will not work. What the electors want at this time is an opportunity to show Fianna Fáil that they have been caught out. At the conclusion of this debate this evening or, before then, the Taoiseach must make his way quickly to the Park. We shall leave aside the question of the new Ministers. These are decent enough fellows but they are being plugged in as round pegs in square holes, as temporary holders of their respective offices. Everybody, including the President, knows that the resignation of the Government must come so why not do it now?
Comment on this
——I wish to make it clear at the outset that I fully subscribe to the opinion that the Taoiseach has full personal discretion to decide on the members of his Government and to decide on how long they should remain as members of the Government; that he is entitled at his own personal discretion to request the resignation of any member at any time that he sees fit and that, if any such member refuses or neglects to submit that resignation, the Taoiseach is fully entitled to take the necessary steps to secure the termination of the appointment of any such individual as a member of the Government.
I agree that the Taoiseach is entitled to do this for any reason which seems to him a valid one. I wish to make it clear that at no stage have I made any complaint with regard to any decision taken by the Taoiseach in this particular matter. It is his job to choose the members of his Government and at any time that he may feel dissatisfied with the constitution of his Government, it is obviously his right to decide that the Government shall be changed any way that he wishes.
It is completely untrue for Deputy Tully to suggest that I at any time stated that I resigned from the Government in protest at the decision taken by the Taoiseach. Deputy Tully knows that was never said by me and that I was never quoted as having made any such remark. It may be true that the papers reported that I resigned in protest at the dismissal of two of my colleagues but if the papers said so it is a lie.
I resigned as a member of the Government because conditions had been disclosed to exist in regard to the Government under which I, as an individual, was not prepared to continue to serve. If we include the vacancy filled yesterday it has become necessary to replace four members of the Government. I am the only one of the four who was not, in one way or another, pushed out of the Government or, at least, who was not overtly pushed out of the Government. I wish to explain just why I resigned.
I say I was not overtly pushed out because it is a fact that the reasons given and the events that led up to the course of action taken in the case of my other colleagues did, in so far as I was concerned, constitute a significant if indirect push. The position is that two members of this Government have been dealt with on a lettre de cachet basis, the penalty in this case being dismissal from the Government rather than incarceration in a modern Bastille. The Taoiseach has stated that he acted as a result of information received and even if we disregard the unreliability of the source of that information, since such source has established himself clearly as a man of no honour, I find that statement to be a most extraordinary one.
I find the position disclosed by the statement to be highly objectionable not to mention undemocratic and a violation of human rights. I find the conditions under which the Government have to operate to be intolerable in so far as I personally am concerned and, in my opinion, to be inconsistent with the dignity of a free man. Therefore, under those circumstances I could not continue as a member of the Government. What has been disclosed by the Taoiseach is that some person or persons unknown is or are in the position that he or they can lodge secret information with the Taoiseach and with anybody else who can bid enough for it, be he the leader of the Opposition or the leader of the coalition or whatever he may be leader of, in respect of any member or members of the Taoiseach's Government and that this information will be accepted and that the Ministers concerned will be dealt with on that basis as the Taoiseach has said these Ministers were dealt with. Deputies Blaney, Moran and Haughey have been dealt with in this way already and since the source of this information is so obviously unscrupulous no one can say who is likely to be next. There is no question, apparently, of the evidence or the information being evaluated in accordance with the normal rules of evidence or in accordance with the principles of justice. There is no question of the accused being confronted with the accuser. There is, in fact, apparently no question of fair play in this matter. Information can be lodged by some secret individuals, some unknown unspecified individuals, and on the basis of that information at least two members of the Government have been dismissed. I have no objection to make to the exercise of his functions by the Taoiseach. The Taoiseach is entitled to change the members of the Government at any time he sees fit but, so far as I personally am concerned, I would not be prepared to continue in a Government in which these conditions obtain.
I want to be quite fair in this matter. I admit that this is an effective method of establishing control and of maintaining control. It has the merit of absolute simplicity. The informer lays his information before whomever he likes to lay it—before the leader of the Government or before the leader of the Opposition or before anybody else that he likes. The decision is made on the basis of that information and the accused is informed of the decision. While I have no doubt about the effectiveness and the simplicity and the expedition of this method of making decisions I have considerable doubts about its justice.
I have always remembered a small incident from the time when I first spent an annual period of training with the Regiment of Pearse in Finner Camp. A rather famous and, if I may say so, well-loved and respected sergeant paraded the raw recruits, as we then were, and briefed us on the regulations to be observed in the camp and on local leave. We were informed that to get drunk was conduct prejudicial to good order and military discipline. We were a company of university students and we included in our numbers some potential legal luminaries. At the end of the briefing session the sergeant concluded in the normal way by saying: "Any questions?" One of the legal volunteers in the company ventured to ask: "How is it established that one is drunk?" I thought at the time that this was a rather difficult question that would prove not too easy to answer by the unlettered Army NCO but he found it quite simple. He said: "If an Army NCO says you are drunk, you are drunk." That might be a quite reasonable condition under which to expect soldiers to serve. It seemed to me at that time, when I considered it, to have a certain amount of merit. I gathered later from my legally minded and semi-legally trained comrade-in-arms that it was a somewhat different test to the test that would have to be complied with in a civilian court but it was certainly simple, it was conclusive and it seemed to me that if it was administered with enthusiasm it would be quite helpful in ensuring that people like myself and Deputy Loughnane would succeed in living up to the standards of dignity, decorum and sobriety that had been set by our predecessors in the officers' training corps, such as Deputy Pa O'Donnell. While it might be all right to expect soldiers to serve under the condition that if an Army NCO says you are drunk you are drunk I do not accept that it is reasonable to expect Ministers of a Government to serve under the condition that if Mr. Peter Berry says you did a thing, you did it.
Comment on this
The Deputy should not refer to people who are not in a position to defend themselves here.
Comment on this
That if an unnamed civil servant, or an individual employed by an unnamed civil servant, says you did a thing you did it and that the unnamed civil servant will employ an organisation to keep you under surveillance and to be able to report on what you did and what you did not do. I do not think that it is reasonable to expect members of a Government to serve under those conditions. In so far as I am concerned, I am not prepared to serve under those conditions and that is the reason why I handed my resignation to the Taoiseach. If the Taoiseach trusts me he can have me in his Government, if he does not trust me I suggest that the Taoiseach should tell me he does not trust me but I do maintain that if he cannot get people he can trust, without the surveillance of people employed by an unnamed civil servant, then it just does not seem to be possible to form a Government. Certainly, if I cannot be trusted to act as a member of the Government without this surveillance then I am not prepared to continue in the Government.
I have said that the source of this alleged information has established himself as being untrustworthy because trustworthiness involves loyalty but in this case the information, in addition to being lodged with the Taoiseach, to whom presumably the ultimate loyalty of the individual concerned is due, was also given to the leader of the Opposition. The fact that it was to Deputy Cosgrave it was given gives me quite a good hint as to the identity of the individual who was employed by the unnamed civil servant for this purpose. However, I suppose it would not be in order to mention the name I have in mind. As I said, this was disloyalty and it establishes, beyond any question of doubt, the informer as a man of no honour. It establishes that he has been acting in the despicable role of a double agent and it clearly establishes the information, or any information, in inverted commas, coming from this source, as being unreliable information, as being worthless in face of the denial of the allegations by Ministers who, over a period of years, have never disclosed any Government secrets or never in any way betrayed the trust that has been placed in them.
The individual or individuals employed by this civil servant, by acting in this totally discreditable way, has or have in my opinion lost all claim to credibility. I have seen newspaper suggestions that the whole fantastic story on which this whole business is based was built up with the assistance of the British secret service. I do not know whether that is true or not. I certainly hope it is not true; but if there is any truth whatever in that allegation then the story is surely still less credible because an organisation that have in the past descended to such vile methods as the forging of diaries in order to secure the execution of Roger Casement are obviously capable of embarking on the concoction of a fantastic story such as this, which lacks nothing except the introduction of a beautiful blonde or two.
Those, then, are the conditions of service under which I as an individual was not prepared to continue as a member of the Government. The reason given by Deputy Tully was never given by me and has nothing whatever to do with my resignation from the Government. I would respectfully suggest that the money spent on maintaining this Minister-watching organisation which, apparently works to two sources, would be more appropriately spent on trying to bring the murderers of Garda Fallon to justice.
Comment on this
When I mention this I cannot help speculating as to why it is that those men are still at large.
Comment on this
I wonder is it a question, as I know to have been the case some time in the not too distant past, of keeping the pot boiling so that the need for and the dependency on this Branch would continue. With regard to the actual story itself is there any reason to believe that it is authentic? I see no reason to believe it is authentic. I do not know if anybody has seen any arms. Nobody has said that he has. If he has seen them, where and when? Can they be produced? Do they exist at all? Does anything exist except certain documents? On the basis of this so-called information from this tainted source working to the Taoiseach and working to Deputy Cosgrave, the Taoiseach has taken what can only be described as drastic action. The Taoiseach's interpretation of this is that the two Ministers concerned did not agree with the Government's policy on the partition of our country, as laid down at the Fianna Fáil Party's Ard-Fheis. I do not believe for one moment that there is any such disagreement. Certainly, in so far as I am concerned I fully subscribe to this policy and I believe my colleagues, whose positions are also being filled here today, also fully subscribe to this policy.
The objective of the party to which I belong is to bring about the re-unification of this country and this obviously involves the unification of the people of the country. This, of course, as anybody with any normal intelligence will see, cannot be done by force. This does not mean that I subscribe to the outburst of Daniel O'Connellism that has marked recent speeches in this House. Neither does it mean there is any acceptance of the right of any section of the Irish people to opt out of the Irish nation. It certainly does not mean there is any acceptance of the right of any foreign country to divide our country, to maintain an army in it or to legislate for any part of it. The fundamental fact is that the British are aggressors in our country and the responsibility for the existing situation of barely suppressed violence in the Six Counties rests squarely on the shoulders of Mr. Harold Wilson and his colleagues. The first requirement for the solution of the problem is that this fact be recognised by the people responsible for it, that the British guilt be acknowledged and that a decision to embark on what would almost certainly have to be a long process of disengagement and reparation should be taken in the place where the crime was committed and where it is continuing to be perpetrated to this day.
This is not the time to deal in detail with the matter of policy. The motion before the House is the appointment of three members of the Government. I merely want to say that while force could never remove the deep, carefully fostered and massively subsidised divisions which exist in our country, and must be ruled out for those reasons as a policy in so far as we in the 26 County State are concerned, this does not alter the fact that the British are illegally in our country, that they must go and that stupid statements by Messrs. Wilson and Callaghan and other members of the Government that Partition is not an issue, indicate where the main difficulty lies in so far as peace in this country is concerned.
While a policy ruling out force is appropriate and almost unanimously accepted as far as I know for this 26 County State—certainly it is unanimously accepted so far as the Fianna Fáil Party are concerned—there is no doubt that the people in the Six Counties are, in fact, in the same position as the people in the whole country were in before 1916, and they are entitled to make their own decisions. While we here are both entitled and, I think, very well qualified to give advice on this matter, and the advice we would give would be that there should be no inclination to utilise force to solve the difficulties which exist there, and to try to secure the acceptance of our approach, it would be presumptuous for us to attempt from the snugness of this 26 County State to dictate to our fellow countrymen who are suffering under British imperialism, because that is what they are suffering under.
It would be unpardonable for us to take any action to frustrate the efforts of our people in the Six Counties to protect their lives and property. The objection I see to the approach of many Deputies who have been speaking here in this matter is the concern for what is described as the freedom we have achieved, the attitude that the over-riding concern must be to retain this State and this Parliament. So far as I am concerned I want to go on record as saying that I reject that attitude, that I do not see a 26 County State as an achievement. I see it as a retrogression. I see it as a situation resulting from the 1922 betrayal. While I recognise it as a situation which exists, and under which we must work, I also recognise that the national objective is to get rid of two States in this country not one. There is here in this part of our country an established situation of a democratically-elected Government operating under a democratically adopted Constitution and no such Government could tolerate the existence of an armed organisation not under the Government's control. No such Government could permit the importation of arms into this country for such an organisation.
I am absolutely certain that no one who was a colleague of mine in the Government believes otherwise. However, while such an organisation is clearly illegal here the position in the Six Counties is clearly different. The solution imposed on this country by the British, in addition to massive subsidisation by the British taxpayer and to the garrisoning by the British Army, requires the discrimination and oppression that is exercised by the ruling faction. This ruling faction must remain if what is called by British politicians "the integrity of the United Kingdom" is not to be disrupted. All the objectionable features that have marked this Six County State since it was set up, including the murderous attacks on the Nationalist population, are essential to ensure that the ruling faction continues in power and, therefore, that the British annexation of part of our country continues.
In so far as this question of the alleged attempt to import arms is concerned—and I repeat I have no reason to believe there has been any such importation—it is our obvious duty to ensure that any such importation to this part of the country is only carried out by official State agencies. However, we have no function in regard to the Six Counties. It is not our homes or our lives that are in danger. Since we are not in a position to supply protection to these citizens of ours and since the United Nations, to which we subscribe, acts like Pontius Pilate in regard to the situation, we have no right to interfere in any efforts our people in the Six Counties may feel constrained to make to defend themselves from the effects of British imperialism in that part of our country.
I know only what I have seen in the papers of these stories of arms importation. However, may I say that I do not believe them for one moment. As far as I am concerned my position is clear. Arms importation into this part of our country by any agency other than the State is illegal and should not be permitted, but arms importation into the part of the country in which the writ of this Government does not run is not illegal so far as I am concerned. It is our duty to advise against it but it is not our business to interfere and any co-operation with the security forces of the country that continues to occuply six of our counties is, in my opinion, intolerable.
The proposal before the House is one which I think should be unanimously accepted. It is a proposal that the nomination of three members of the Government be approved. The nominations are made by the Taoiseach who has been duly elected by this House with the clearest possible mandate from the people of the country. In view of this mandate the nominations should be unanimously approved. So far as I am concerned I consider the three individual Deputies whose names are before us suitable in every way for the positions for which they have been proposed.
Comment on this
There is a certain dreadful fascination for all of us when we hear stories of self-immolation. The absolutely horrifying picture of a Buddhist monk or some other persons of that kind who lies down on the ground, empties a tin of petrol over himself, applies a match and burns himself to death is a fearful, fascinating morbid picture. I do not know whether today we are witnessing the political self-immolation of Fianna Fáil. However, it is certainly significant that the Deputy who has just spoken has told a story I never thought I would hear of conditions which he alleges to be intolerable operating inside the Government of this country. He has told it not only to Dáil Éireann but in the hearing of his own party members and has been accorded a clap of approval by Fianna Fáil Deputies.
Comment on this
In an interview with the Irish Independent of today's date Deputy Boland is reported as saying that under no circumstances could he work in a Government whose leader kept members under Gestapo-type surveillance. He went on to say: “I could not see the events of the last few days happening in any other democratic country”, a statement with which I fully concur as would 90 per cent of the people outside who are watching the amazing developments which are taking place in this House. Deputy Boland stated in this interview that for a significant time past, under the direct order of the Taoiseach, a group of the Special Branch were directed and organised to “bug” ministerial rooms, to engage in phone-tapping of ministerial conversations, to listen to everything his own colleagues wished to say to one another and to others. This was done not by an unknown, unnamed, civil servant but by the leader of Fianna Fáil. No wonder the Deputy said: “I could not see the events of the last few days happening in any other democratic country”.
The other night I said we were in danger of being turned into a banana republic. What have we now? Deputy Boland complains we have not Mata Hari but we have double agents, phone-tapping and "bugging" of ministerial conversations by a secret organisation organised, according to the Deputy, by his own leader. In the name of the Lord, in the interests of democracy and in the interests of common decency, why does the Taoiseach not dissolve this Dáil and go to the country?
Comment on this
Here we have a Government, members of one political party, none of whom can trust the other, members of a political party whose leader has no confidence in them and some of whom obviously have no confidence in their leader. This new Government will be held together by mutual fear, not by trust: mutual fear of one another, mutual fear that their inner thoughts will be known. The present Minister for Defence—the now designate Minister for Agriculture—and the present Minister for Industry and Commerce—the now designate Minister for Finance— will be kept together for fear that in their desks somebody will be listening through a "bug" and that everything they say will be told on them. What damage they will do to the country! What will happen to the Irish pound? What about the harm being done to the savings of our people by the Budget of recent weeks, by the clear lack of confidence in this Government? Having broken that trust they have caused harm to the country, to its savings, to its resources, to its assets, to the way of life, to the jobs and employment of ordinary, decent, harmless people who trusted them last June.
It is a sordid, disgraceful story that will not be solved by Kremlin-like declarations of loyalty after a quick trial and no doubt a public confession in the Fianna Fáil Party Room. This will not be solved by papering over the cracks. There is a responsibility, high and awesome, on any man who is entrusted by the people with leading this nation. That awful responsibility clearly dictates that, in these circumstances, with this sordid story behind—I am not surprised that Deputy Aiken leaves—that this Government, having no authority except such as is given to them by Deputy Haughey, Deputy Blaney and Deputy Boland, should go to the people to seek a renewal of their mandate. If this does not take place, if the people are not consulted, we shall have this Government endeavouring to control a situation which might well become uncontrollable.
We have a situation in which a leader who used to be called "Honest Jack", a leader who rejoiced in that soubriquet, has now clearly lost credibility. We find now from a former member of his own Cabinet, of his own Government, that for months back he had not trusted his colleagues, that for months back he had them spied upon and that for months back he had a secret dossier on each Cabinet Minister. We know now from this declaration in the Irish Independent and the speech today by Deputy Boland that it was not merely on the 21st April that an astonished Taoiseach came to learn that his Ministers were behaving suspiciously, if not disloyally. It was established yesterday that the facts of this attempted gun-running, this conspiracy to subvert the safety of this State had been in operation since last November. It was established yesterday, and referred to in the Irish Press, that this entire story was printed in a newspaper called The United Irishman before last Christmas.
Are we to believe that this could be common property in certain circles, among certain people, and that our Special Branch did not know it? If we are to believe, as Deputy Boland has said, that his leader, the Taoiseach, Deputy Lynch, had the Special Branch reporting directly to him and to nobody else—not to the Minister for Justice, not to the Minister for Defence but directly to the Taoiseach himself —and if, as it is now known since last November a plot was being organised by two members of the Government and their relatives to bring arms into this country, I suggest it stretches our patience far too long to imagine an astonished Taoiseach getting this information for the first time on the day before the Budget. I suggest the Taoiseach has a lot more to say and that the people are entitled to ask him to come clean now. He either knew or had the means available to him of knowing that some of his colleagues were concerned in a sordid plot against the security of this State and he took no action at all; in fact, quite contrary to it, he moved a writ in order to force a by-election in South West Dublin and claimed, having got some 30 per cent of the votes, that he had a renewed mandate for his Government from the people of South West Dublin.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy give way for one second? The first indication I got was Monday, 20th April. I do not know what the Deputy is relying on for asserting otherwise.
Comment on this
If the Taoiseach says that I accept it. The Taoiseach will agree that it is quite contrary to what Deputy Boland has stated.
Comment on this
I have only heard what he said today. I have not had time to read the papers this morning.
Comment on this
That is two days before the Budget. I understood the Taoiseach to say the other night it was 21st April. However, there are very serious matters involved here. If what the Taoiseach has said is correct, the Taoiseach learned of this on 20th April.
Comment on this
I shall deal with the immediate consequence of that. That means he permitted his Minister for Finance to attend a Government meeting and to finalise the last Budget on either Monday or Tuesday or on Wednesday morning, assuming he did not have an accident on Wednesday morning. This colleague, who the Taoiseach was informed was involved in a criminal conspiracy against the State was, nevertheless, allowed to present to the Government of this country this year's Budget.
Comment on this
On a point of order. The Deputy well knows what the implications of a criminal conspiracy are and he should be fully aware of what is involved.
Comment on this
In my considered view what I have said is perfectly justified. The Taoiseach was given information on 20th April which indicated that his Minister for Finance was suspected of being involved in a criminal conspiracy against this State and, nevertheless, the Budget was presented to his colleagues, I assume by the Minister for Finance, a Budget which was dealing with a very grave economic crisis. The Taoiseach has the responsibility to tell us: did the Minister for Finance attend the Government meeting? Did he prepare this Budget? Was it on the Monday or Tuesday? What usually happens, to my knowledge, is that the Budget is presented to a special Government meeting on the morning of Budget Day.
Comment on this
That was one of the days the effort was made to bring in the arms, prior to the 21st.
Comment on this
The situation then is that the Minister for Finance presented the Budget for Government approval on the previous Friday; the week-end passes and on Monday the Taoiseach received information which if correct means that the Minister for Finance was engaged in a criminal conspiracy against this State. What happened throughout Monday? What prevented the Taoiseach getting his resignation there and then and sacking him? Why did not the Taoiseach act on Monday? On Tuesday? We were told at three o'clock on Wednesday that but for an unfortunate accident the Minister for Finance was going to present the Budget to this House. This man, who, if the Taoiseach is correct, was under a sentence of dismissal from the Government, were it not for an unfortunate accident was going to present this year's Budget to Dáil Éireann.
Where is the story going to end? Where lies the truth? I mean no reflection on what the Taoiseach has said but I do suggest that somebody is not coming clean in all this. There are a whole lot of gaps wide open, growing larger. How is it to be explained that from Monday to Wednesday no action was taken by the Taoiseach in relation to the Minister for Finance? All right.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy allow me to interrupt him? I decided to make investigations on the information received.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach will get plenty of opportunity. Nobody here will prevent the Taoiseach from saying what he has to say. I want to repeat— and here is something the Taoiseach can deal with in his reply—that from Monday, throughout that day, throughout Tuesday, throughout all Wednesday morning, the Minister for Finance continued to be the Minister for Finance. We were told that were it not for an unfortunate accident he would have presented this year's Budget to this House. I would be interested to know how the Taoiseach can explain these facts if he were an astonished Taoiseach who had been informed of this serious conspiracy and serious plot.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach says that after his unfortunate accident the Minister for Finance could not be interviewed. I accept that. Every one of us felt very sincere sympathy with Deputy Haughey on the accident and the reported serious concussion from which he was supposed to have suffered. The Taoiseach, I can understand, from Budget Day, midday or whatever it was, until the date he gave the House the other night, the 28th I think it was, could not interview the Minister for Finance.
When did he first interview the then Minister for Agriculture? On the 28th April, according to what the Taoiseach told us the other night. So that, from Monday 20th until the following Wednesday week, Deputy Blaney who was the other person alleged to be involved in this conspiracy had not been interviewed by the Taoiseach. He was summoned to his room on the 28th and asked for his resignation, which he declined to give. No further action was taken by the Taoiseach. A fortnight passes and no action taken until two hours after Deputy Liam Cosgrave went to see the Taoiseach last Tuesday night. I do not think that even in a banana republic this dereliction of responsibility could be tolerated. I do not know what the result might have been if Deputy Cosgrave had not gone to the Taoiseach and if the Taoiseach did not learn, as he did, that a tip-off had currently been given to a newspaper. The story was bound to break and only then was decisive action taken by the Taoiseach. This is a bad, sordid story. We have the background now of this appalling suggestion from Deputy Boland that for months before this——
Comment on this
I am glad to hear it is wrong but I can assure you that I read here before my eyes Deputy Boland saying that under no circumstances would he continue to work in a Government whose leader kept members under Gestapo-type surveillance. He adds that he could not see these events happening in any other democratic country.
Comment on this
He says this earlier —that it has been going on for some time. I just cannot find the reference.
Comment on this
I suggest that Deputy Sherwin, who is a political infant, should not intervene; he will only get burned.
Comment on this
Following the accusation on Monday, I asked for more information on the Tuesday and then I made some inquiries myself.
Comment on this
I am referring here to what I see before my eyes—an interview with Deputy Boland by the Irish Independent interviewer, Mr. Kerry McCarthy and he makes the complaint that he would not continue to serve in a Government whose leader set up this kind of phone-tapping, spying, and so on, on himself and his colleagues.
I say this is a bad story and the more patching that is attempted the worse it gets. There are sitting behind the Taoiseach now groups of his own party who share common ideas, who work together, who are going to fight together, who are going to lobby together. He has Deputy Boland who is endeavouring to set up another party inside the Fianna Fáil Party.
Comment on this
I will say what I have to say because it will come out. I tell Deputy Crowley, who is a member of the three parties inside Fianna Fáil, that is what is happening now.
Comment on this
There is a new force let loose inside the backrooms of the Fianna Fáil Party. There is jockeying for position by cynical and ambitious men. We had this absurd statement the other night. After a short party meeting, after the indoctrination and all the rest of it, the people were expected to believe that this whole thing was a non-event, it did not happen. Deputy Haughey who was sacked and Deputy Blaney who was sacked and Deputy Boland who left coincidentally—he claims to have been the only Minister who was not pushed—and Deputy Moran who he says was sacked, who did not resign voluntarily, all these now continue to be members of Fianna Fáil, continue to serve because their votes are important to the Taoiseach. What sort of a party is that?
There are serious things happening in this country. One reads on the paper today the heading "Saor Éire in £14,000 raid". One reads a statement by this illegal organisation that they will continue to carry out whatever operations they regard necessary to requisition the necessary money to arm the people they wish to arm. Bank raids to get money to buy arms, a bank raid in Rathdrum with an entire village cut off by fellows wearing berets and Sam Browne's and carrying guns, fellows who can go in and hold up defenceless bank clerks, bank raids down on the quays of Dublin city where an unarmed, courageous Garda officer is shot down, bank raids in different parts of the country, raids into business houses seeking pay packets—all done in the sacred name of patriotism and nationalism. When one finds, on top of that, either separately or in unison—one does not know—a suggestion that two Cabinet Ministers are also engaged in this hunt for arms and, when one finds behind that, one who resigns coincidentally, or in sympathy with them, making the charge that his leader has a special private secret service of his own to watch what everybody else is attempting to do, then banana republic, how are you! This is bringing the entire affairs of this State into absolute discredit. It is not even as amusing as a Gilbert and Sullivan opera.
Comment on this
The Deputy spends more time at the opera and in the courts than he does in this House. He should be ashamed of himself.
Comment on this
The last Fianna Fáil Deputy who tried to take me on is no longer a member of the Government. If the Deputy is not careful he will be no longer a member of the Fianna Fáil Party.
This country is facing now a serious economic crisis, a situation in which our balance of payments has grown so wide, so steep and so big that there may be a run on the Irish £. If we cannot instil a belief in our own economy—mark you, we should because it has survived many assaults by Fianna Fáil over the decades—and if we cannot get our people to have confidence in Ireland's ability to pay its way, then we are in very serious trouble indeed. This sordid affair takes place in the middle of a serious economic crisis. I suggest to the Taoiseach that in all decency, out of all consideration for his own high office, the national needs dictate a new mandate to a new Government in this country. Maybe that Government will again be Fianna Fáil. I do not know and I will not make any political prognostication of one kind or another, but I suggest that any man of honour, leading Fianna Fáil in these circumstances, should go to the country saying, if necessary, "Peccavi, I have sinned, or my colleagues have sinned," saying, if necessary, that this country in these needs, at this moment, requires a confident Dáil and a confident Government to face and resolve the difficulties and the problems of our people.
Our prestige and the prestige of our Government at home, and our standing and prestige abroad, have never been more sacred to the future of our people. Outside this country it is essential, if we are to survive, that the word of an Irish Prime Minister, or the word of an Irish Minister, be accepted as his bond. It is essential outside this country that the strength of the Irish £ cannot be challenged, questioned or endangered. We are facing a very difficult three or four years. The very survival of our people is involved. The very wit of our people to control their own destiny, to provide a way of life for the young people growing up, is in jeopardy and in danger.
We need a Government that will be like Caesar's wife, against whom no reproach can be suggested. We need a Government that is clearly not thinking of other things and talking of other things while plotting and planning other things. We need a Government of honour, of integrity, of men who will serve the people and no one else, of men who will give no service to any private masters other than the people. We need a Government that will have that standing both here at home and abroad. I am sorry to have to say it, but this Government cannot come from this Dáil. There are decent men in Fianna Fáil, very honourable men in Fianna Fáil and I am certain that the vast majority of them are men of distinction and honour and dedication, but they have allowed something rotten to happen. They have allowed a canker to grow which has very nearly destroyed the credit of Fianna Fáil in the country. Maybe it was a hopeless effort to mix two brands and two ideals, to mix the captive republicanism of the past, the kind of captive political thinking of Deputy Boland, which stopped in 1922; maybe it was an impossible task to mix that with the modern mohaired approach of others but, whatever it may be, this mixing of water and wine did not produce a good bottle and the result has been internal stresses in the party.
I have sympathy with the Taoiseach, a man who has been trying to do his best to paper the cracks, but the result is that, in the process, he has been obliged to look at too many places simultaneously and in too many directions at the same time. That will not do for Ireland. There are too many things at hazard and too many things at risk and the need of the moment, the requirement of the country, is a new mandate to a new Government.
Comment on this
One would much prefer to opt out of contributing to this debate and I personally dislike having to stand up here to make a contribution on the subject matter of debate here this morning. We have in this State relatively small population by comparison with other countries, a population of less than three million people; in the severed part of the State there is a population of only 1,250,000 people. We are all Irishmen, whether we live in northern Ireland or southern Ireland, whether we are members of Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael or the Labour Party and it is the ambition of all of us to advance the nation and improve the standards of our people.
So far as the Labour Party are concerned, we are very, very sorry indeed that such a discussion should take place and none of us here in the Labour Party has any inclination whatsoever to score any political points. I venture to say that the same can be said of the other Opposition party here. We may have differences of opinion and we may occasionally have wrangles here in debates, but something like this is far above and beyond the kind of minor wrangles that might arise in less important debates.
It is deplorable that this position should arise at this moment. It is seldom a discussion on Government wranglings arises in this House. The only previous discussion that bears a slight semblance to the discussion we have today is the discussion that took place on the alleged wranglings of the inter-Party Government who were moving out of existence in 1951. The statement made by the then leader of the Government in this House after listening to that discussion for some time could apply more aptly to this morning's discussion. That statement was: "We have had enough." This House has had enough of the secret, internal wranglings of the Fianna Fáil Party and Government. It is not we who should be deciding the issue of whether this Government should or should not continue in office by restoring three members to their depleted ranks but the Irish people through the polling boxes.
This debate is more akin to something that could happen in a conspiracy trial in, say, Green Street courthouse rather than the national Parliament. We have some people in the dock charged with serious offences. Is the prosecutor members of the Fine Gael Party or the Labour Party or the Attorney General who usually has the task of prosecuting people who commit misdemeanours? No, in this case the prosecutor is the Taoiseach. He outlined the case for the prosecution last Tuesday night and Thursday morning. He bases his case on the fact that two of the members of the Government, that he, as Taoiseach and head of the Government appointed, and for whom he is responsible, have betrayed him, that they have been guilty of gross deceit so far as he, as Taoiseach, is concerned and that they have allegedly engaged in practices completely adverse to the welfare of this country. I do not want to delay the House by outlining these practices—possibly that is not the most apt term—but it strikes me very forcibly that the alleged offence had its source, as regards the arms supply, in Czechoslovakia.
In the past few weeks we have had reports of criminal proceedings in the British courts against a former member of the Government party there as a result of association with diplomats of the Czechoslovak Government. That man has been found not guilty. I read in the Evening Press, which is recognised as the Government paper and naturally deemed to be more factual in such matters because it would be supposed to have inside information, that the value of the arms, the subject matter of the importation, was £80,000. It told us that the arms were bought in Czechoslovakia, transported overland to Vienna and from there landed at a British airport and were halted there by the British Secret Service.
As this is a point not covered by previous speakers I should like to take up a few minutes of the time of the Dáil on this question. I assume that the Evening Press statement is correct and that the arms were bought in Czechoslovakia. Everybody knows what is happening there at present and that you could not buy a pin without a Government agent breathing down your neck, never mind buy ten tons of arms for £80,000. I assume that no such purchase could be made in Czechoslovakia without the connivance of the Czech Government. Neither could the arms be transported to Vienna without the connivance of the Czechoslovak Government.
What I am getting at should be obvious. I regret in this hour of great danger for this country to have to make these statements but I want the Taoiseach, who has more information than I have, to give the House and the nation in his reply satisfactory answers to my question. What I mentioned earlier I am only elaborating in regard to the case the Taoiseach made as prosecutor. It was he who mentioned that he is satisfied from reports available to him that two of his Ministers were engaged in a criminal conspiracy. Let me digress to say that I have no ill-will against those concerned. I am very sorry that these alleged activities should have been committed by them and that they should be deceitful to their leader. I do not know whether or not the allegations are true. We shall have to come to the case for the defence which has been presented in the front page of the Irish Independent. The Taoiseach should have read this before he came to the House. It is interesting.
Comment on this
I have read it but I did not see any reference to the period Deputy O'Higgins mentioned.
Comment on this
I am sorry to see Deputy Blaney and Deputy Haughey in this situation. I hope I shall not be regarded as boastful when I say that I never hold personal bitterness against anybody, but I am glad that this ill-wind has blown Deputy Boland out of the Government. I am glad there is this small credit side. I am not being personal and not trying to, and would not be associated with a party trying to get political kudos out of this. The Taoiseach and I happen to originate from the same part of the country, not too many miles apart, and although I am not a supporter of the Taoiseach I know the respect in which he is held by the people there, even by those who disagree with his political views. Personally, I have the same respect for the Taoiseach, whether well-founded or otherwise. I am satisfied it is well-founded.
I am perturbed about the Czechoslovakian side of this business because I am against any dealings by any Irish Government with any communist country. We know what happens in communist countries, and there is no need to say what has happened in Czechoslovakia where the arms were supposed to have been purchased. What had Dr. Husak to say last Tuesday or last Wednesday when making a statement in Prague, the capital of Czechoslovakia? He said that the Czechoslovakian people were most grateful and most thankful to Russia and the other countries who came to their aid in August, 1968. Does the House think that represented the viewpoint of ten per cent of the people of Czechoslovakia? Is there any danger that we will have people here in Ireland, who do not represent ten per cent or five per cent of the population, setting themselves up as the Government, taking over, and talking as if they had the united support of the people behind them?
Is not that what happens in communist countries? There is no such thing as a debate such as this. There are no elections. There is no freedom of speech. There is no freedom of movement. There is a takeover; the people have to toe the line and be satisfied; and they have to make statements supporting the Government even though there is little or no sincerity in such statements.
I want to get a detailed account of this Evening Press statement. It is one thing that perturbed me more than anything else in this affair. The Taoiseach said the arms were purchased in Vienna but then I read that they were not purchased in Vienna. They were transported by air from Vienna to London, but they were purchased in Czechoslovakia. We read, perhaps not too carefully, during the past three or four weeks, references to some difficulties which arose between members of a Czechoslovakia trade delegation and members of societies in Ireland who are deemed to be friendly with Czechoslovakia. These difficulties occupied the front pages of our national papers for two or three days. At that time I did not attach much importance to them but, at the same time, taking into account what their activities were in the country which adjoins us, and taking into account what has transpired in the past few days, I should like, and I am sure the country would like, full detailed information about them.
That is part of the Taoiseach's case in the role which he has undertaken as prosecutor. In June after the election this House was asked to nominate him as Taoiseach. This House by a majority vote acceded to that request and he was duly nominated. On him only rested then the responsibility for nominating and appointing Ministers. It was on his shoulders. He was the man to pick from his party or from this House the people he deemed to be reliable and trustworthy, people he considered would serve the Government and the Irish nation. We had no say in that other than that as usual, once he had chosen them, we had to walk through the Lobby in a formal way and say: "Look, we do not like you," but the outcome was quite evident.
Comment on this
We opposed the appointments because we felt that some of the team were not too competent. How right we have been proved since, if the prosecutor's claim is correct? We walked through the Lobbies then and the Taoiseach won the vote.
What obligations are now carried by the Taoiseach? Is he not responsible for the activities of his Government and, if he made a mistake in nominating some of them, if they have now deceived him, if they are guilty of the offences of which he claims they are guilty, surely he must resign? Is not that what would happen in Britain? Is not that what would happen in any other democratic Parliament? He may be excused personally. He may make the excuse: "I made a mistake. I did not know that your opposition was in any way well founded. I had complete trust in my Ministers. It was misplaced trust. I made a mistake." He must pay for his mistakes.
Comment on this
He must resign. I hate to say that but that is the only conclusion one can come to. The Taoiseach, in his prosecuting case, states that on Monday, 20th April, he first heard of the events which led to the dismissal of the two Ministers. That is only a few weeks ago. Apparently the Taoiseach did not read this morning's newspapers but in The Guardian, a British paper, it is claimed, as was mentioned earlier by Deputy Tully, that the British Secret Service were effective in stopping this arms deal and knew all about it as far back as November last. There is a big difference between November last and Monday, 20th April.
As a result of these resignations Dáil Éireann is faced with a motion to replenish the ranks. What is the case for the defence? What have they to say? We are asked here to replace the Ministers who were dismissed or resigned by other Ministers and, if we accept the statement in the papers today and in the House a half an hour ago by one of those Ministers, what are we being asked to do? I want to quote now from today's Irish Independent in which it is stated:
He repeated again a declaration he had made earlier in the day that he could under no circumstances work in a Government whose leader kept members under Gestapo-type surveillance. "I could not see the events of the last few days happening in any other democratic country. All that was missing was the beautiful blonde spy," he said.
The Taoiseach is there charged by a man who was in the Government from the first day he came into the Dáil, by a man who has the inside information, which we have not. In regard to Garda Fallon's death there is an implication both in his newspaper interview and the statement he made here today. The former Minister said:
... those working in the "Super-Special Branch" would be much better employed tracking down Garda Fallon's killers than spying on those elected to serve the people of the country. He was convinced that these men had to answer only to the Taoiseach.
The people were informed through the national Press and through the national Parliament by a colleague of the Taoiseach that the Taoiseach was not doing what he should do to arrest the killers of Garda Fallon. If that is not the implication in that statement, I am not able to interpret anything. The Taoiseach heard the former Minister substantiating that statement in the House. The Taoiseach heard him ask whether this was a conspiracy to let people who are guilty of offences roam around the country free from arrest and from detention.
The former Minister's statement is quite clear. His statement is that there is no substance in the charges. We have not had anyone giving us the Taoiseach's point of view, other than himself. We have had no supporting speech from the Government benches with the exception of Deputy Boland's speech. Has the Taoiseach been abandoned in his hour of need? Is he left alone to fight this battle? Can the Minister for External Affairs or the newly-appointed Minister for Industry and Commerce come to his rescue? I have great sympathy for the Taoiseach.
On Wednesday at 11.30 a.m. the Taoiseach came into the House when this whole affair had been exposed. He was followed by three or four Ministers. The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs was there. Some other Ministers were within the precincts of the House. The Minister for Defence and one or two other Ministers were not here.
It has been said that a system of phone-tapping existed in certain houses owned or occupied by members of the Government. If that is so, it is not unreasonable for me to conclude that that system is operating on a much wider scale. Is it likely that Deputy Corish's phone or Deputy Cosgrave's phone is being tapped? This issue has been raised by a Deputy who has been a Deputy for 30 years. The defence is that there is no truth or substance in the charges preferred by the Taoiseach. It is said that the Taoiseach has been misled by a named member of our Civil Service. This named member of the Civil Service is alleged to be in charge of the super-Special Branch and part of the duty of the super-Special Branch is to tap the telephones of some of our Ministers. Deputy Boland's words are more eloquent than mine. He does not call them the super-Special Branch but "the ministerial watching organisation". This is a peculiar state of affairs in 1970. It is peculiar that we have this organisation headed by a named civil servant who is a secretary of one of our premier Departments and that he has under him an organisation known to former members of the Government as the ministerial watching organisation and to others as the super-Special Branch.
People are very distressed that the police force are not able to do better in so far as the detection of some of our more serious crimes is concerned. I am casting no reflection on the police force. I am not in any way reflecting on their integrity when I make that statement. I am worried about the implications of the statements which we have had earlier in this House to the effect that the police are being pulled back for some unknown reason. It is hard to understand how criminals can escape with the very limited outlets for escape from justice here in a sparsely-populated country where even in the capital city everybody knows everybody else. It is impossible to escape the law if there is a concerted attempt made to apprehend those who are required. I am making that statement by virtue of what we have heard this morning from the Member in question.
We had an intervention through a radio and press interview from the Tánaiste, Deputy Childers. He made excuses, but one thing he said struck me forcibly and that was that when the Government are in office for a long time they get complacent. Not only did the Fianna Fáil Government get complacent but they have become arrogant and dictatorial and have moved into a position in which they are destroying themselves on their own without any help from the opposite benches. What should the verdict be? The big question the country is asking at the present time is: should the Government continue in office without a fresh mandate from the people? When we here, Members of this House, are expressing our views on this matter and on the need for a general election it is no pleasure for any of us to contemplate an election following this type of upheaval within the party with the main support.
We find no pleasure in that. I am finding no pleasure in it. Neither will I find any pleasure in going around to the church gates in west Cork areas or in moving out to the islands or peninsulas in an endeavour to retain my seat here. We have no alternative. It is not our own security that is in question. The security of the nation is in question. By virute of these major revelations—even alleged association with communist countries—we must have a much wider jury than the limited number of public representatives who have the privilege of being members of this House.
We have this motion for the approval of the nomination of three Deputies as members of the Government. In the light of the present situation, this motion has little significance. I would have nothing to say against Deputy Cronin, Deputy Molloy or Deputy Gerard Collins: they are all men of integrity but the implications of the situation are wider than that. The question is whether the Taoiseach can be allowed by this House to fill his depleted ranks by three Deputies whose names are submitted here; whether he is entitled even to put that kind of motion before this House after having had to tell Dáil Éireann that he had to dismiss three Ministers and has been deserted and abandoned by another Minister.
After what happened here the day before yesterday, and in the light of the amazing disclosures in relation to the activities of some members of his Cabinet the Taoiseach comes here this morning and, in effect, says: "I want this House to give me four Ministers so that I can continue as leader of this this Government and leader of this country". Even if we were inclined to give that approval, have we the right to do so? Has any party in this House the right to give such approval in view of the appalling situation which has been disclosed to this House and to the people of our country in the past few days? In my view, we have not a right to do so because it has been laid down in this House, in times gone by, that the head of the Government is responsible for the activities of his Ministers. It is a well-established maxim here that there is collective responsibility in the Government—all for one and one for all—and that the Taoiseach is responsible for the activities of his Ministers.
Some members of the Opposition seem to have information from other sources: my only information consists of statements by the Taoiseach and other members of this House as well as what I read in the newspapers. Undoubtedly, a very serious situation exists. Some people, either with State connivance, State funds or funds obtained elsewhere, have moved into a communist State to procure arms. It is reasonable to assume that there was not much bargaining about the price of the arms. If we got arms from Czechoslovakia then, if the Czechoslovak Government is in any way involved as it must be if the story is correct because otherwise it could not happen, it is for a very ulterior motive. It could be a matter of some plotting or planning for the overthrow of democracy in this country.
Deputy Tully quite correctly brought my name and the names of others into this debate. He said that I and others had retained our seats in the Dáil despite persistent and violent allegations and imputations by Fianna Fáil against our integrity, motives and objectives. It was alleged that we were trying to put across a policy alien to the view of Irish people; that we were mixed up in some way or another with people far removed from Irish national traditions. I derive no pleasure from the fact that Fianna Fáil are now hoist with their own petard. I recall insidious rumours about the Labour Party in this country and, in the same breath, mention of priests being tortured, bound in chains, and so on.
I would say that a tremendously high proportion of the 224,000 people who voted for Labour candidates in this country are imbued with the best of Irish traditions in every sense of the expression—national traditions and Christian traditions alike. If I thought there was any danger that the Labour Party would undermine this State—as the State is now said to have been the subject of an attempt by others to undermine it and to overthrow democracy here—I would not be associated with that party for 24 seconds, never mind 24 hours. I had to face such charges. I succeeded and was returned to this House. My colleagues, Senator Eileen Desmond, Patrick McAuliffe, Thomas Kyne, and others, did not succeed. The assault was too violent. Despite the fact that the basis for the assault was absolutely fictitious, absolutely without substance, it happened that, sometimes by the shortest of short heads, we lost some seats. That is why our ranks have been somewhat depleted here after the general election.
There is a big difference between the depletion of the Labour Party's ranks here after the general election and the way in which the Government's ministerial ranks have now been depleted. This question is of such momentous importance that it must be referred to the people. There is no use in the Taoiseach's telling the House and the country that the Ministers in question did not measure up to his requirements; that he is guilty of an error of judgment; that it could happen to anyone. I believe the Constitution is absolutely correct in giving the head of the Government the sole right to nominate the members of his Cabinet and the sole right of dismissal. The nomination of the members of the Government must be approved, of course, by the Dáil.
With an upheaval of the magnitude of the one now before us, I hold that the Taoiseach is not entitled to come to this House to ask the man who made the statement for the defence here this morning, and who, by implication, termed the Taoiseach a liar, to keep him and his changed Government in office. By implication, the Taoiseach was called a liar this morning by one of his ex-Ministers in view of the Taoiseach's statement to this House the day before yesterday that the first time he gained any knowledge that a conspiracy of any kind was afoot was on 20th April, 1970.
The man whom the Taoiseach will ask to support him on these motions is the very man who is reported in today's Irish Independent as saying he believed that for some time members of the Government were of the firm opinion that their telephones were being tapped. Deputy Boland is quoted as having said: “In the case of one Minister this has been definitely established”. The newspaper report also quotes Deputy Boland as saying to the interviewer, Mr. Kerry McCarthy, that:
A Super Special Branch has been secretly set up by the Taoiseach, Mr. Lynch, to spy on Members of the Government.
I am saying to the Taoiseach that surely he cannot continue in office with the support of people who have made such statements. That should be clear to all Irish people. Having listened to all the statements made here in relation to this matter, having read all the comments on the matter and having watched an interview with the Taoiseach on our national television network yesterday, I have come to certain conclusions. I accept that the Taoiseach is a man of integrity. It may be that he is too weak, or that he has too much confidence, or maybe he did not have the ability to detect earlier what was going on within his party. However, he did detect what was happening but what hinders me in expressing my personal view is that if the Taoiseach did detect it earlier, has he made untruthful statements to the House?
Comment on this
As I have said, the Taoiseach is a man of integrity who is endeavouring to do the best he can but I am wondering if he had the necessary qualifications to detect the upheaval that was taking place within his party. According to himself, such did not occur to him until he received certain information on Monday, 20th April. Assuming that the Taoiseach's statement is correct and assuming, too, that the statement of the former Minister for Local Government, to the effect that the Taoiseach has under his command a ministerial watching organisation, is correct, the type of assertion that I have in mind to tide us over this major national crisis would not apply. I was thinking that because of the events that could arise in either the northern or the southern part of our country, we should have a national Government of one kind or another. I was of the opinion that if the Taoiseach made such a suggestion, the other parties would not refuse to discuss the position with him and with those Ministers who have shown their faith and confidence in him by remaining in the Government.
Comment on this
I am entitled to personal views. This is not a matter which was discussed at any meeting of our party. I do not believe in being hamstrung and neither do I consider it right that any Member of the House should be hamstrung unless there is practically unanimity of opinion, of party support. There should be a certain amount of flexibility in making personal statements.
All of us wish to avoid trouble in this country and everybody would wish for a solution to our problems, both north and south, by peaceful means. We do not wish to see any of our people dying on the roadside as a result of civil war or strife. Neither do we wish to see any political party trying to get kudos out of internal difficulties within the democratically elected Government Party. Instead of nominating the three new Ministers perhaps the Taoiseach should have filled the ranks with two or three members of Fine Gael or Labour.
Who would have imagined even one week ago that we would have this kind of debate here today; who could have imagined the former Minister for Local Government making the statements that he is reported to have made to a press reporter or who could have imagined, one week ago, that he would be the man to put fuel under the remaining Ministers of the Government in an effort to ignite them and blow them up? We have heard from Fianna Fáil about their solidarity but we have also had to listen to a great deal of criticism about little internal wranglings within our own party but we do the best we can to overcome our difficulties and one recent difficulty has been solved quite easily. However, in order to save himself the Taoiseach was forced to burst forth in publicity. I do not know if this debate would be taking place today if it were not for the revelations made to the leader of the Opposition.
I am of the opinion that when information is available to any Member of Parliament, whether he be a leader of a party or otherwise, to the effect that there is danger to the welfare of the State, there is an obligation on that person to pass that information to the head of the Government of the day. None of us likes to be deemed informers but, where the welfare of the Irish State and the Irish people is concerned, that is the course to take.
I said I should like to see a kind of closing of ranks at this stage when we have so much trouble in Northern Ireland. What a fine gesture it would be if we had more close association down south. I do not think that is altogether unattainable. I feel it could be done and, taking into account what is happening up north, it would be advisable to do so. Now we have the Taoiseach telling us that he will continue in office. We have the introduction of this motion today to appoint three of his own party as members of the Government. My answer to that is that he is exceeding his functions. In present circumstances the Taoiseach has no right or authority to ask Dáil Éireann to nominate these three Members.
It may be, as the Tánaiste, Deputy Childers, told us, that this all arises from being too long in office. It could be. I accept that the Tánaiste knows more than I do. He attends meetings of the Cabinet and he knows about this complacency, this disease known as being too long in office. I do not know how one could describe that ailment. I believe the Government should go before the people. I am quite confident that if the Irish people were consulted now they would recommend a very strong prescription for the ailment from which Deputy Childers told us the Government suffer.
Comment on this
One need not be a prophet to know the prescription our people would recommend for Fianna Fáil at the moment. What do you think, Sir, it would be? It would be a long rest from office. I suppose this could happen any other party that would be so long in office. Fianna Fáil have been in office for 34 years now. It is possibly an ailment that any party in any country would suffer from after such a lengthy period.
Comment on this
The Unionist Party suffer from this ailment at the moment and Fianna Fáil suffer from it. The one thing I disliked, now that you will be moving out of office, was your arrogance. Some members of the Government were, indeed, quite all right. This lack of honour was extending to the Civil Service. It struck me forcibly that some of our civil servants got the idea that Fianna Fáil would be here forever——
Comment on this
——and once they were supporters of theirs it did not matter how they did their work; it did not matter how they treated the Opposition. What are they getting paid for?
However, it is superfluous for me to announce what the Irish people would prescribe for the Government at present. They would prescribe for them a very long rest from office which they need urgently. I am not being sarcastic when I say that I should like to have the Taoiseach down, not too many miles from me, resting peacefully in the nice house he has bought and is renovating near Roaring Water Bay. It would be far more pleasant for the Taoiseach to be listening to the roaring of the Roaring Bay waters than listening to the roaring of some of his colleagues in the Fianna Fáil Party.
Comment on this
Whatever merit there may be in Deputy Murphy's suggestion that the present national emergency calls for a national Government, no reasonable Irishman could entertain for a moment the suggestion that any Government, either a national Government or a Fianna Fáil Government, should be formed under the Taoiseach.
Comment on this
The events of the last week, his protestations of innocence ever since he became Taoiseach, clearly prove that it is no longer possible to believe daylight from the Taoiseach. We now know that he tried to cover up treason. He tried to conceal what he knew was taking place, the putting of arms into the hands of some Irish people for the purpose of murdering their fellow countrymen. He endeavoured to keep from the Irish nation the fact that the institutions of this State were being undermined by Members of an Irish Government and that Members of an Irish Government were endeavouring to build up and maintain an army other than the army authorised by Oireachtas Éireann.
His only reaction in the face of this appalling situation was to remain silent while one, if not two, of the members of his Cabinet had diplomatic illnesses or coincidental accidents. Kremlin colds and feverish attacks of the flu in Moscow have nothing on the farce we have witnessed of the miserable efforts at covering up and providing an escape hatch for members of the Government, who deserved, from the moment that the knowledge of their activities came to the Taoiseach, complete condemnation, expulsion from the Cabinet and being arrested and charged with the most serious offence which can be committed by any man against his own country—the offence of treason. Any man in a position of trust has an obligation to act with speed and decision in an emergency. The Taoiseach holds, under the present——
Comment on this
On a point of order the Deputy used the word "treason" and he stated that two Members of the Government were guilty of treason. I want to state that I took action on the grounds that not even the slightest suspicion of the activities I referred to should attach to a member of the Government. I think, Sir, that the Deputy should not be permitted to allege treason against Members of this House or anybody else.
Comment on this
If the Taoiseach prefers it, I will say the Taoiseach failed to act when he received information——
Comment on this
The Deputy will appreciate that it is not in order to say that Members of the House are guilty of treason.
Comment on this
Sir, I was about to say that I will amend my remarks by saying that information has been furnished to the Taoiseach which indicates that Members of the House have been guilty of treason.
Comment on this
That is a fair interpretation for any person to put on the information at the disposal of the Taoiseach, the information which he disclosed in this House within the last 48 hours. The Taoiseach had a clear obligation to act with speed. Even if it were only suspicion the matter was too involved and the consequences too terrible to suffer any delay. Instead of acting the Taoiseach allowed two days to pass by before he resolved to question two of his Ministers who had been named to him. He gives as an excuse for not pursuing one of them the fact that he had an accident. He did not pursue the other who had no accident and who continued to represent the Government in this House, who continued to attend Government meetings, who continued to attend his office, who continued to use all the lines and power of communication, knowledge and influence available to him in it without even calling him in and requesting him to absent himself from his office or absent himself from the Dáil. He allowed him to continue for at least nine days after he had reason to believe that he might be associated in some way with treasonable activities. I am in deference to you qualifying my remarks in that way although I will have no hesitation in expressing them elsewhere without any qualification.
The former Minister for Finance was allowed 48 hours after the knowledge came to the Taoiseach to remain Minister for Finance, to prepare his Budget speech and to commit this nation financially and economically to a certain course of action at a time of financial and economic crisis, at a time when the Taoiseach knew that the same man was endeavouring by force of arms, or by association with people who were prepared to use force of arms, to pervert the whole destiny of this country. That clearly indicates, whether it be a coalition Government or a one-party Government, the present Taoiseach is wholly and totally unfit to occupy his present position. Anybody who puts any other interpretation on the events of this week is naive indeed.
I am frankly worried that so many people feel relieved that the Fianna Fáil Party have for the time being found a solution to their current problems. The effect of it is only to make the position ten times worse. It is only about further evidence that Fianna Fáil are concerned, not with the national welfare. If it were they would get rid of a Taoiseach who suffered this situation to exist for so long, either through his inability or through his reluctance to disclose the truth. Any head of a Government is clearly under an obligation to put the national need before party interests. How can anybody believe that the Taoiseach put national need before party interests when he procrastinated for days on end and did nothing of any worth in this matter until he was confronted by Deputy Liam Cosgrave, the Leader of the Opposition? What disturbed the Taoiseach then was not the fact that the leader of the Opposition knew but that there was then the possibility that other people would know. Deputy Cosgrave could have caused a dramatic crisis in this House, could perhaps have drawn the full blaze of glory on himself by revealing it in this House, but in a statesmanlike way he went to the Taoiseach and gave him the information hoping he would take steps to examine whether or not the information given to Deputy Cosgrave was true.
What did he find? He found that the head of the Government knew that all the information Deputy Cosgrave had received was true and was doing nothing about it; that he had not then done anything about it; that he had not then dismissed his Ministers who were suspected of acting in this particular way. This to my mind is criminal negligence on the part of the Taoiseach and far from anyone believing this country can now go forward with any confidence under him it seems to me that the people of this country are now aware they have a Taoiseach who is totally and completely unfit from the point of view of ability and integrity to occupy the position of head of the Government for one moment longer.
Any head of a Government once he is elected to that position should act without fear or favour. Can anybody say that the Taoiseach acted without fear when this information first came to him? He did not act on the 20th April or on the 21st April before any accident or any illness coincidental, diplomatic or otherwise, occurred. He did not even send for those whom last night he called his able, brilliant and dedicated colleagues, to discuss with them in the national interest the information received. He did not do it. Why? He did not do it because he feared them; he feared their wrath; he feared the number of supporters they might have in the Cabinet; he feared the number of supporters they might have in the Fianna Fáil Party; he feared their associates outside; he feared the IRA; he feared other illegal organisations; he feared them all and was hoping that this dreadful thing, this nightmare, would dissolve or that somebody else would find a solution without involving him.
That was a cowardly Taoiseach not fit to occupy the position of Taoiseach for one moment longer once that fear and that cowardice became known to the people. That same Taoiseach was under an obligation to act without favour. What did he do? He showed favour, he showed understanding, he gave consideration, he gave time to the people who were mentioned to him as being involved in this alleged criminal conspiracy. What did he do when ultimately he got over his fears and faced his obligation? He went and discussed it with them and they asked for time to consider their position. The Taoiseach did not say then that the position of the nation comes first, that the position of the Government comes first.
Comment on this
This is most serious. The Taoiseach said that those people asked for time and he gave it to them.
Comment on this
I am quoting from yesterday's paper. I am sure if it was wrong the Taoiseach, or his minions in the Government Information Bureau, would have taken care to state it was not true. I certainly am prepared to rely on this until it is proved it is wrong. The Official Report is not yet available for Wednesday. I am reading from yesterday's Irish Times in which it stated on the front page, column 5, that having spoken to the two Ministers named each of them denied attempting in any way the importation of arms. It says here: “They asked me for time to consider their positions.”
Comment on this
Thank you. I can certainly understand with all the things that are being said and because we are only getting pieces of this jigsaw gradually that it is very difficult to follow the thing line by line. I am endeavouring to be careful in what I say and to make my comments measured but it seems to me I would be failing in my obligation if I did not draw attention to those specific things so that the facade or umbrella some people would draw around or put over the Taoiseach will be seen to be wholly unjustified. He has failed entirely under every test you apply to a man holding a responsible position, such as was entrusted to him. Above all, if one is in a position of trust one must never abuse that trust. That trust requires that the interests of the people be served before any personal inclinations or preferences. Clearly, that has not been done.
One wonders why Ministers should have been involved, as apparently they were, in this frightening transaction. One wonders at their recklessness. One could understand that people with a firm conviction that the minority in the North should be armed would take steps to arm them but one would be amazed, as we all are, that Ministers of State should act in this way as apparently we were led to believe two, if not more, Ministers acted. It points to one simple fact which we have asserted here for a long time and which the Taoiseach has repudiated as being without proof; members of Fianna Fáil would do anything if they could get away with it. The view of many of the people who voted the other night for the election of Deputy O'Malley and who may vote today and other days in support of other members of the Cabinet would be that the only sin committed was that they were found out. That is the reality of the situation. The other night they won a Pyrrhic victory and while they may rejoice in keeping their sordid conspiracy intact, it will not conceal the fact that there are no longer any principles or standards worth accepting so far as the Government are concerned.
Gun-running is one of the most lucrative international practices. Profits can be made more quickly from gun-running than from any other traffic and the profits derived from gun-running are as great as those derived from drug-trafficking. However, two things are necessary for gun-running— the capital to buy the guns before profits can be made and the incitement of people to the use of arms so that they will buy the guns.
It is with a terrible sense of alarm that one now appreciates what happened. Last year immediately following the dreadful outburst of violence in the North, a newspaper started circulating in the North particularly in those areas where the minority lived lauding Deputy Boland and Deputy Blaney. It perpetually quoted their speeches, many of which were regarded by the Taoiseach as inflammatory and designed to incite. Recently I read a report on gun-running in which it was pointed out that it was not profitable unless you incited people to purchase guns. It now seems it was all part of the master-plan to incite the people of the Bogside, the Falls Road and other areas in the North to seek guns so that the traffic would be profitable. I do not have to mention which member of the Government would have been in a position to furnish the capital to purchase the guns——
Comment on this
The Chair will appreciate that I have not named anybody. If the cap fits let it be worn. On one of the documents which has been received regarding this matter mention is made of the name of two Tacateers as being associated with members of the Government. In deference to the rule that we must not mention names in this House, I do not propose to name the persons concerned. The whole story was so wild and incredible that it seemed improbable at first. One of these gentlemen accompanied the former Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries when he arrived at the House here the other day and he accompanied him brazenly and brashly throughout the House and the precincts of the House. Other members of the Taca organisation were also seen accompanying Deputy Boland and Deputy Haughey was brought to his about-to-be vacated office by another member of Taca.
All of this alarms one particularly when some of the men who were mentioned, and who were in the company of the suspected persons the other day, own ships that cruise in Irish territorial waters. One can fairly ask whether there is any link between this and the trawler that was seen in Dublin Bay on the morning after the murder of Garda Fallon which took two people from a rowboat and sailed away in the grey mists of dawn. Many questions still remain to be asked——
Comment on this
——and a great deal more information requires to be supplied before the full truth of the appalling——
Comment on this
If the Deputy has evidence of this he should give it. If he has not, he is not entitled to make such a charge about people outside this House. The Deputy clearly implies——
Comment on this
I have not named anybody. The former Minister for Local Government, Deputy Boland, complained that so far there is no question of the evidence being evaluated in accordance with the ordinary rules of justice. We say let the evidence be evaluated in accordance with the ordinary rules of justice. Let those against whom charges have been made, let those named as being involved in a conspiracy to import arms into this country for goodness knows what purpose, be charged with the offences. Let the evidence be assembled and tested as Deputy Boland wants done in accordance with the ordinary rules of justice. We will abide by the verdict so long as we are satisfied that the law officers are in no way curtailed in the presentation of their evidence and as long as we do not have any further efforts to pervert the course of justice. We would welcome this and all the information which is available to the Taoiseach and to anybody else to be tested by a full inquiry or by the proper weight of investigation of criminal charges. That is the only way it can be done.
May I ask a simple question to which the Taoiseach must give an answer? If an ordinary person was discovered to be involved in a plot to import arms without licence and without payment of customs duty, would it be regarded as an innocent activity? Would an ordinary person be permitted to do this or would he be arraigned before the court? Is it open to anybody to conspire with others to import arms without licence and without payment of customs duty? If not, let those who are known or suspected of being involved in this matter be dealt with in the proper manner.
For a long time we have known and heard of many attempts to pervert the course of justice, to obstruct the Garda, the Army and customs officers in the due execution of their duty. Have we any reason to feel confident that while the present administration remains in power there will be an end to this? Far from it. We have had the appointment this week of a man to the office of Minister for Justice who threatened to take steps to dismiss from the Garda Síochána a mild and harmless garda who was executing his duty.
I have grave reservations about the impartiality or appreciation of principle of some of those who were nominated by the Taoiseach today for new ministerial responsibility. Collective Government responsibility is necessary to rule fairly and efficiently. That responsibility is equal and joint; it lies on everybody as an individual and must be shared by each member of the Government with others. Quite clearly the people who have resigned from or have been dismissed from the Government do not share that feeling, and it would appear to us that the Taoiseach does not accept the obligation of collective responsibility. As far as the Taoiseach is concerned, if any member of his Cabinet is no longer of use to him or is an embarrassment to him he can be disposed of. Ministers are simply disposable bits of the Lynch capsule, just jettisoned into space, discredited and dropped and others substituted as though nothing had happened, as though there were no crisis, no cause for concern; the mighty ship with the pilot Lynch is still on course——
Comment on this
——with Taoiseach Lynch is still on course. This we are told is the situation of calm which should make the country content that all is well, that the Taoiseach is in charge of a ministerial observation post, that Ministers and, I suppose, their associates are being spied upon. We have had and no doubt will continue to have a Government in operation in a kind of James Bond complex with phone tapping, double agents and so forth. The resigned Minister, Deputy Boland, said he objected to the simple and effective ways of gaining control by a number of nameless people, and then he went on to name one of the people whom he considered to be involved.
I believe the overwhelming majority of the people would far prefer to be protected by the members of the Garda Siochána and by our national Army than by any of the people whom Deputy Lynch as Taoiseach had in his Cabinet or indeed any of those who may still remain there. The people need protection. One of the most fundamental reasons for the existence of the State is protection from violence from without and within, and the army that gives us that protection is the Army and the Garda Síochána. This must not be tampered with or interfered with, and there is ample evidence that it has been tampered with and interfered with, and again this is inexcusable.
We are asked to accept apparently that Deputy Haughey, Deputy Boland, Deputy Blaney and Deputy Moran are now without influence, that they are now people who will no longer obstruct the Taoiseach or no longer be in a position to interefere with him and the great Fianna Fáil Party in running this country. That is a foolish claim to make and it would be folly to believe it for one moment. On 18th January last Deputy Kevin Boland was elected honorary secretary of the National Executive of Fianna Fáil and he remains honorary secretary of the party today. On the same date Deputy Neil Blaney was elected honorary treasurer of the National Executive of Fianna Fáil and he still is the honorary treasurer of that party. On 18th January last Deputy Charles J. Haughey was nominated by the Taoiseach as a member of the National Executive of the Fianna Fáil Party and he remains so today. On the same date Deputy Paudge Brennan was elected to the National Executive by the Oireachtas Party.
This morning we heard Deputy Kevin Boland making his apologia and one would have thought that as he was speaking with such condemnation of the Taoiseach and was speaking on a line which was clearly at variance with his stated view of the Fianna Fáil Party, his remarks would have been received without approval by any of his Fianna Fáil colleagues. But when he sat down so many applauded him that it was impossible for us to collect the names or identify them all. Those who gave support by their applause this morning, to the consternation of the Taoiseach, are the newly elected Deputy Sherwin, Deputy Loughnane, Deputy Briscoe, Deputy O'Leary from Kerry and Deputy Power from Kildare. Deputy Crowley applauded until he saw he was being watched; then he copped himself on and folded his arms.
Comment on this
The Deputy will realise that Deputy Boland said many things which could well be applauded.
Comment on this
Those Deputies who were supposed to be 100 per cent behind the Taoiseach, who were supposed to be unanimous in the view that the Taoiseach was right, applauded the man who denounced the Taoiseach for what he had done——
Comment on this
——who disagreed with the Taoiseach's outlook, who felt that a great deal of wrong had been done. The great united party was divided. True, some of them put their hands in their pockets and did not applaud. However, they are far from united and the disintegration of the party is only about to begin.
Comment on this
Could we ask the interrupters in the Fianna Fáil Party to try to measure up to the importance of this occasion? The fortunes of Fianna Fáil or of any other party, Fine Gael or Labour, matter absolutely nothing. The fortunes or reputations of Deputies in this House matter not a whit. What does matter is whether or not we shall have a Government who are united in their determination to execute agreed national policy.
I would again challenge the Taoiseach, as I challenged him the other night, to accept for debate in this House without further delay the Fine Gael motion which says that Dáil Éireann "repudiates the use of force to effect the end of Partition". That is a perfectly simple request to make and if he dithers or delays one moment longer on that he will continue to be questioned by the nation for his lack of conviction and it will be quite clear that he is, as I said earlier, a coward who is unfit to hold Government office.
Pretended unity is a spurious unity, but in so far as it does exist let us question why. It is conceivable that men of principle in any political party in any Government would be in disagreement with their colleagues. It is possible that even a man of principle would feel that the end justified the means and that he would try to use the powers of Government available to him to achieve those ends. However, any man of principle who had such strong convictions, if dismissed from the Government, would refuse to lend further support to that Government, to the head of that Government or anybody associated with it. Therefore we cannot accept that those who have been dismissed or have been forced to resign are men of principle, for if they were they would not, by their votes or by their silence, be lending support to a policy with which they are or pretend to be in such strong disagreement.
Once again we have proved that self-interest is the only guide of members of the Fianna Fáil Party, the self-interest of those who do not want a general election because the Fianna Fáil Party would suffer considerable losses which would entail the departure of some of the Fianna Fáil members from this House, the self-interest of those suspected of the conspiracy who appreciate that it is only by the preservation of the Government in office that they are immune to prosecution. This sordid self-interest is one of the most despicable reasons behind this spurious facade of unity, not the interest of the nation because the nation's interest requires that the Government would resign from office and particularly that the Taoiseach would resign and resign quickly.
It may well be that some of those still in the Taoiseach's Cabinet, still giving him support, anticipate what the nation anticipates, and that is, that the Taoiseach will not be Taoiseach much longer and therefore they remain within the party or even, like Deputy Boland this morning, they profess allegiance to the party while all their actions are in conflict with their profession because the day will come when again the pack of cards will collapse and there will be more shuffling and bargaining for position. Therefore the sordid bargain is made: it is better to keep your powder dry because the real battle has not yet begun.
The purpose of an Army is to protect a people against external and internal violence and our Army is responsible to all our people through Dáil Éireann. What then must we think of anybody who has attempted to pervert Army officers in the execution of their duty, who has endeavoured to get or persuade members of the Army to act contrary to their oath to serve Oireachtas Éireann and no other group? We must condemn such people. Such people have committed criminal offences. It is quite clear that evidence has been given to the Taoiseach which links certain names with such activities not related alone to the attempted importation of arms from Vienna but related also to training which was given in at least one Army camp to civilians in the use of arms.
Comment on this
It seems that this crisis is so grave that the Taoiseach—the present one or whoever shortly succeeds him—has a clear obligation to take the whole Dáil into his confidence. There is provision in the Constitution for the holding of a secret session of the Dáil in case of national emergency. I believe we are in such a position at the present time——
Comment on this
——that we are in a state of national emergency and if there is information available which the Taoiseach believes it would not be in the public interest to reveal he can call that secret session. As far as we are concerned, we have no wish to have it discussed in secret. We believe the whole nation would be the better to have the information fully and freely disclosed so that the people might know what they are entitled to know, in whom they can place their trust.
An attack was made this morning by Deputy Boland on a senior civil servant of long standing. He mentioned him by name. It is fair to remark that the man in question loyally served Deputy Boland's father for very many years during an extremely difficult and embarrassing period.
Comment on this
What a terrible thing it now is to hear Deputy Boland making snide remarks and identifying a senior civil servant in this House because of the fact that in continuation of the long and dedicated service he has given to this country he has been obliged in the execution of his duty to name some of Deputy Boland's friends. Thank God that we have such a public servant. Thank God that the commissioner of the Garda Síochána was not prepared to accept a direction to admit arms without customs formalities. Thank God that the Garda Síochána refused to be a party to this until they got clearance at the highest level and thank God that, although efforts were clearly made by members of the Government to keep the knowledge from the Taoiseach, it ultimately reached him and thank God we had Deputy Cosgrave to force the Taoiseach's hand when he was prepared to lie in wait and hope the crisis would pass off.
Comment on this
This is a matter upon which Deputies wish to speak and I have no wish to detain the House too long but there are a couple of points in what Deputy Boland said this morning that I must take up. I am not going to condemn Deputy Boland for resigning from the Cabinet. He did it for what he considered to be correct reasons, although I cannot see how he can possibly continue to lend his support to a Government with which he is in so much disagreement. But he spoke about trustworthiness involving loyalty and he suggested that whoever gave the information to the Taoiseach and to Deputy Cosgrave had acted wrongly and he said that Deputy Cosgrave's informer was a man with no honour. To whom is the loyalty owed? Is it owed to a political party? Is it owed to a Taoiseach who, having the information, refuses and fails to act in the interests of the people?
It seems to me, Sir, that there are occasions when the normal traditions of preserving secrecy and conducting one's office only in direct relationship to the Government are transcended by the obligations of emergency. This was clearly a case in which any person loyal to the people of Ireland whom he served had an obligation to communicate that information to a quarter which he knew would not be tainted and to a quarter which he felt would live up to the obligation which lay on any person in a position of trust who had such information. That is why Deputy Cosgrave was given that information, because he was known as a man who would use the information, not for personal advantage, not for party advantage, but for the sake of the country. That is why he telephoned the Taoiseach and having got an appointment with him went in confidence. Had he not done so we would still be a Dáil with a Cabinet that was acting disloyally to the Taoiseach and the Taoiseach afraid to do anything about it.
Deputy Boland also spoke about the long delay in bringing the murderers of Garda Fallon to justice and he suggested that this was the Taoiseach endeavouring to keep the pot boiling in order to justify the surveillance of his fellow Ministers. We do not know the truth of this. There has been so much allegation and counter-allegation that the position is becoming more and more bewildering rather than clearer after a couple of days debate, but the Garda are certainly all complaining of the fact that they have not been given the facilities and the scope necessary to bring the murderers of Garda Fallon to justice.
Comment on this
This is a situation which is terrifying in the extreme. It is a situation which must be remedied and the Taoiseach and his new Minister for Justice have a fundamental obligation to see to it that all restrictions on the Garda in the pursuit of the criminals involved in that sordid offence, and many others, are brought to justice. We even had the ex-Minister suggesting that the efficiency of the Garda Síochána would have to await the outcome of the implementation of the recommendations of the Conroy Commission and so on. The situation is far too serious to be trimmed to administrative convenience. It is much too serious and all the resources of the country and all the money available must be used to restore order in the affairs of the country and to provide the guardians of our peace with the security they deserve in their highly dangerous task.
Deputy Boland also rejected what he called an attitude that some people in this House had to our overriding obligation to preserve this State. He said our obligation was to remove two States. I had hoped that we had left the thinking in that sentence behind us many years ago. Can any sane person expect that Irish unity can come about other than by building a united country, with this State of ours, which represents 3,000,000 people and covers 26 counties, being bonded and welded to the six north eastern counties? There is no other way of doing it and anybody who speaks as Deputy Boland did, suggesting that the destruction of this State is equal to the destruction of the statelet in northern Ireland and that, only by destroying both, can unity come about, is talking like a madman or a fool. We know that Deputy Boland is no fool and we must, therefore, fear such a man, so long in the Cabinet and, now that he is outside it, still in a position of power in the Fianna Fáil Party, for he is still secretary and he still has his followers in the party whom we heard applaud him this morning after his highly dangerous and emotive speech. Unity will not come until the fears of the Protestant majority in the north are overcome. It is as simple as that. I thought, after last autumn's debate here, that this was accepted by all parties and by all members of all parties but now we know that that is not so. The fears of the Protestant majority in the north are again being exacerbated by Deputy Boland——
Comment on this
——who says he had no part in this and he does not believe others had either—all their hands are clean. He protests he had not any part in it, but he believes it would be correct to have arms imported into the north of Ireland by one side, which he supports. But there is no use in giving arms to anybody to play with, for people just do not do that. The purpose of arms is for use against others and there is no point, except the point of mischief, in saying that it is permissive to exacerbate the situation in the north of our island by encouraging, or facilitating, the importation of arms.
It might well be that if any emergency arose and it appeared that the military and police forces in that quarter were unable to afford the necessary protection we would then have to use whatever forces were available to us to preserve life. But that is a totally different thing from supplying people with arms now. If such a situation arose again I believe that what would occur would be that the United Nations, which certainly proved rather unsatisfactory in its attitude last autumn, would be forced by the pace of circumstances to move. One would not wish a tragedy in order to bring about this movement but, nevertheless, the remedies suggested by Deputy Boland and others would only make an appalling situation even more appalling.
The Taoiseach should now, I think, quietly reflect on his own position. He should realise that the stresses and the strains of government are too much for him. He did act all right, slowly, belatedly, with reluctance, and only to avoid the greater shame that would lie on him and the greater disgrace that would arise if, having been made aware of the fact that Deputy Cosgrave knew he was not acting responsibly in the matter, he continued to behave in the way in which he did. The Taoiseach should go and with him should go all the people he selected as his Ministers. He was clearly very wrong in some of the selections he made. Will we need another crisis, a new emergency, to show that there are still people left in the Cabinet who are in disagreement with him? He has transferred the Minister for Defence to Agriculture and Fisheries. One may wonder why. Would you not think that, if Defence were properly conducted and everything was in order there, this was not the time to move the Minister for Defence? But he was moved and there has been mention of his name in association with the affairs that have taken place.
Comment on this
This is more of the allegations the Deputy has been making. There is no basis for that allegation.
Comment on this
Deputy Ryan's name might be mentioned in connection with something, but that would not necessarily mean that Deputy Ryan was involved.
Comment on this
These denials will not be listened to. Three days ago the Taoiseach said he did not know to what Deputy Cosgrave was referring when Deputy Cosgrave asked a mild and simple question: "Can the Taoiseach say if this is the only resignation we can expect?" The Taoiseach did not know. Poor simple Jack! He did not know. What he did not know was that Deputy Cosgrave knew what was going on. He did not know, but he knows now, that Deputy Cosgrave and a Dublin newspaper received Garda Síochána notepaper with the name of Deputy Gibbons on it, associating him with this sordid transaction.
Comment on this
This is the reality of the situation and denials and accusations of scurrility will not dissuade anybody on this side of the House from exposing it. Threats, either verbal or physical, will not dissuade anybody on this side of the House from discharging his duty to the nation.
Comment on this
This change has taken place. We regard it as a very wise change, but the fact is that there is reason to believe that the last Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries did not keep his hands out of army affairs, or out of Garda affairs, or out of customs affairs. What guarantee have we that this Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries changed, under suspicion, from the Department of Defence to the Department of Agriculture and Fisheries will keep his hands and his opinions to himself in future? The minions of the Fianna Fáil Party, who are literally hoping for more heads to roll so that they can get promotion, like some of their colleagues, should hold their silence. The days are numbered—I thank God for it—of corrupt and unprincipled Government in this country.
Comment on this
We know now that Deputy Browne disagrees with me. He believes that the days of corrupt and unprincipled Government are going to last forever.
Comment on this
I am telling the Deputy to make the statements outside that he is making here. If he had any principle he would do so. He was being put out of the party a few weeks ago.
Comment on this
The days in which Ministers believe they can do anything they like are also numbered.
Comment on this
I challenge the Deputy to make outside those cowardly statements that he has been making here for the past half-hour.
Comment on this
I have been in the House slightly less than a year and I have never risen to participate in a debate yet with greater regret than I do now, nor with greater pain. Much of the business of the House is necessary but mundane but moments arise when we have an obligation to the Irish people to recognise the historical importance of certain events and of what we are doing. To me this debate is, without hysteria or exaggeration, perhaps the most important debate that has taken place in Dáil Éireann since the Treaty debates. Deputy Tully opened his remarks by saying that he felt the nation was still suffering from a sense of shock over the events of the past few days. That is perfectly true. I think this House is suffering from a sense of shock and, personally, I am suffering from a sense of shock and pain at what has recently occurred and a sense of outrage which I think is shared by every decent person. I am also suffering from a sense of pain because of some of the things that I, for one, will have to say in my contribution here.
Comment on this
I do not wish to interrupt the Deputy but, in view of the fact that Fianna Fáil are in the dock, it is disgraceful that there are so few of them in the House and I ask for a quorum.
Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted, and 20 Members being present,
Comment on this
I have been representing my constituency here for many years and not doing like the Deputy's colleagues have been doing.
Comment on this
When I first entered the House I made a personal resolve, as I said before, that I would not indulge in personalities and, on the whole, I have adhered to this. Unfortunately, the nature of this debate is such that it is impossible not to enter into personalities because certain members of the Government have, by their actions, stepped across the boundary which separates private and public life. In so doing they have brought the whole Government and parliamentary process into disrepute.
When we speak of people being in the dock and this sort of thing we must recognise that what is being debated today is not the individual aberrations of two members of the Fianna Fáil Party but a whole style of Government for which everybody sitting on that side of the House must take collective responsibility, a style of Government which has finally found itself out in the most glaring light of publicity it is possible to imagine and in so doing has made the whole nation a mockery in the eyes of international political opinion.
One thing about the—I regret to say it—bogus republicanism, in my opinion, of Deputy Boland is that there is some danger that this sort of republican sentiment may be found in the country and that the people who allegedly have taken part in this extraordinary deal may be represented to the country as brave boys and republicans and so on. We on this side of the House have as long and as honourable a republican tradition as Deputies on the Government side. It was not without considerable reflection and considerable risk to our political positions that we came out in the terrifying days of the late summer and autumn of 1969 and deliberately stated our policy to be the rejection of the use of force. This does not make us O'Connellites, whatever that terminology means in Deputy Boland's history reading. His history reading may be more extensive than mine but I was not aware that to be an admirer of Daniel O'Connell was necessarily a form of political opprobrium to be thrown at one. It does not mean that we are O'Connellites but that we recognise the inexorable fact that the provocation of the use of force in Northern Ireland can only precipitate the kind of bloodbath in which both sides, Unionists and Nationalists, must inevitably suffer. We have the strange, quasi-logic by which Deputy Boland is apparently able to reconcile being a member of a Cabinet which avowedly will not countenance the use of force in the north and, at the same time, he gets up to make in this House what I regard as quite the most outrageous speech I have ever heard in my life, and say that if guns are to be smuggled into the North, if that is what they want, "fine", "fair dos"; he does not see anything wrong with it. That is a most provocative, dangerous and appalling statement for an ex-Minister to make in the House and particularly appalling when you consider that he is only an ex-Minister of 24 hours duration. Presumably, he held the same views as a member of a collectively responsible Cabinet.
I do not understand this exuberant republicanism which is used on that side of the House to justify this alleged arms deal. We have all been hearing about arms deals for months, long before this one broke. I do not understand this alleged republicanism being put forward to provoke sentiments both south and north of the Border when it is put forward by men who are apparently quite willing to countenance the passage of information to the British police so that young Irishmen can serve, as they are serving at the moment, harsh and onerous prison sentences in Britain. I do not quite reconcile this brand of republicanism, so flaunted here today by Deputy Boland, with the practical actions of the Government in respect of these young men.
Deputy Boland said something to the effect that in the North they face the same situation as we did before 1916. Apart from the fact that this is contrary to his own Government's policy I see two essential differences: first, there is the difference that at least in the 26 County section of Ireland we have a lawful Irish Government and we have here what Deputy Boland himself described as a democratically chosen Constitution which binds Ministers of State to certain obligations towards their colleagues and the country, obligations which in this instance, if the allegations are correct, have been blatantly broken by at least two of them, if not more.
Deputy Boland said that it is not our lives that are in danger. This is true. It is not our lives but the lives of the people in the North. If guns have been or were to be, brought into the North with the concurrence of members or ex-members of the Cabinet, it is those lives that are being put in danger, and the Government cannot claim to speak for those people. They have their own spokesmen who have made quite clear to us that the one thing they do not want in the context of a possibly dangerous summer in Northern Ireland is the importation of arms. We are rendering them no service and doing nothing to satisfy their needs by acting in this way.
With some personal regret I want to take up a line of argument developed to some extent by Deputy Ryan. The ultimate person who must take responsibility for the appalling situation in respect of public morality in which this Parliament now finds itself is the Taoiseach himself.
The House must ask the question: when did the Taoiseach first hear of these rumours of gun-running? Some of the versions circulating in the Press imply that knowledge of this sort of activity goes back months. The Taoiseach has denied this, so far as he is concerned. Accepting his denials—and it is very difficult to accept anything he says now—the fact remains that he admits himself that this information came into his possession on Monday, 20th April. For a further 16 days the two Deputies in question remained members of his administration. For a long period of this time we were debating the Budget and the Taoiseach sat over there, standing in for one of the two now dismissed Ministers. He sat there with an inscrutable mandarin-like expression even when quizzed about possible Cabinet changes by Deputy Cosgrave and, I think, Deputy O'Leary.
How long did he know and why did he make this concealment? I do not know if I am in order in saying this: I regret to say that I regard the silence of the Taoiseach in those 16 days as being, effectively speaking, a deliberate deception of the national Parliament, and a deplorable one. When in England a few years ago the scandal broke over Mr. Profumo—a much smaller scandal if the facts of this case are as the allegations state them—the ultimate thing which broke Mr. Profuma was not his extracurricular aberrations but the fact that he had told lies to the House of Commons. This fact over one indiscretion on his part, which it was never seriously suggested imperilled the safety of the State, drove Mr. Profumo not merely out of office but out of public life and utimately brought down an administration.
The far greater scandal, if the allegations are correct, of the behaviour of two Cabinet Ministers in this instance has resulted only in their retiring to the back benches of the Fianna Fáil Party where they continue to exercise and exert the influence and pressure and strength which we know them to hold throughout the country and they continue to hold, as Deputy Ryan pointed out, the offices in the Government Party which they held before.
I venture to suggest that in any sophisticated and honourable and responsible democracy those men, if the allegations are correct, would be hounded out of public life. No other conclusion is possible. The events of the past few days have reduced the standards of Irish political practice, therefore, to lower than those in Westminster and have reduced them to the standards of a banana republic.
It is all part and parcel of a larger picture of which we had heard rumours. Now these rumours must come again to the surface. We are entitled to cite rumours in this House since we have no firm statement of the facts, no firm assurances in which we can believe. Now the alleged role of the former Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries in the North over the past 12 months takes on a new light. We must ask ourselves again is this true. The alleged utilisation of Fianna Fáil money in a provocative manner in the North through the intermediacy of a certain journalist, whom I shall not name, now takes on a new relevance and we have to judge these rumours afresh and think about them.
Again, here the Taoiseach stands condemned. It would be a national tragedy if a picture were to emerge from this of a nice, kindly, absentminded Taoiseach who had facts brought to his attention and then behaved with stern, ruthless, moral integrity. I am afraid this really is not good enough. It is not the picture as it really is. The Taoiseach sat there for 16 days, if not longer, knowing that these accusations existed and he produces the feeblest of medical evidence for his failure to interview one of the Ministers concerned and no evidence at all for his failure to interview the other. The same Minister whose life would have been jeopardised by discussions was able to come in and clear out his office papers very rapidly within a short space of time which, I understand from one of my colleagues, would have been medically impossible if the circumstances were as described by the Taoiseach. Can we have any further credibility in what the Taoiseach says to us?
I do not understand the legal terminology of Deputy O'Higgins and Deputy O'Kennedy but, if the allegations are correct, the Taoiseach is an accessory before the fact and must stand and take the blame with everybody else. I hate having to say this but, a few moments ago, when Deputy Ryan was speaking and there were some interruptions on a point of fact, one of the Fianna Fáil Deputies said, as if it concluded the matter: "The Taoiseach told you it is not true." I am very sorry to have to say that it is no longer good enough to say that the Taoiseach told us, because the Taoiseach has concealed facts in this House and has made conflicting statements in this House at a point when he knew them to be in conflict with the truth. I shall adduce the evidence of that shortly.
In this context, declarations of Fianna Fáil loyalty to the Taoiseach settle nothing. Enthusiastic telegrams from cumainn around the country settle nothing either. The crunch is the Taoiseach's and his colleagues ultimate loyalty to this House and to the constitutional processes which put them here, constitutional processes which, if the allegations are correct, they have outraged. Here is where the buck stops. If there are to be arms in this State this is the place to decide it, not outside. The guilt firmly rests, if the allegations are correct, on the Taoiseach himself who has acted at best in a dilatory, irresponsible manner.
I want to say something about the subject of Cabinet responsibility. I am not very long in practical politics but I know something about political science. The practice of political science in respect of Cabinet responsibility is laid down with absolutely unchallenged clarity in every textbook of politics and in the procedure of every civilised democracy. Turn to Dyce, Bagehot, Jennings or Erskine May and you will find firmly enshrined the principle that action taken by a Cabinet Minister of a major or serious national kind is in effect, action taken by the entire corporate body of his colleagues and they therefore share his responsibility.
The Taoiseach in simply relegating two of these Ministers to the back benches and then endeavouring to proceed, as I have no doubt he will be quite unable to proceed, as if nothing had happened except a little rumble in the intestines of the body politic, is flouting all the conventions of Cabinet responsibility and he compounds his contempt, his arrogant contempt for the decencies of political life, by rising after the event is over, after the sackings have taken place, and referring to the sacked Ministers as able and brilliant and dedicated colleagues. Really, he is trying to have it both ways.
He sacks them, because whatever the allegations are they are evidently strong enough for the Taoiseach to feel that they should not hold office any longer and, having sacked them, he calls them able, brilliant and dedicated colleagues. Dedicated to what, might I ask? Dedicated perhaps to the Fianna Fáil Party as their spurious unanimity shows, but certainly not dedicated to the Constitution of Ireland, certainly not dedicated to the national Parliament, and certainly not dedicated to the normal ethics of public life.
Are we furthermore to believe that these strong men, able men, and one man in particular for whom I have the highest admiration, Deputy Haughey— the House knows I am not being insincere in saying that because I said it in this House before anything like this arose—were led astray in some strange way and that, in a moment of romantic nationalism or bravado or something like that, they put their initials in effect to procedures totally at odds with normal ministerial and Cabinet practice? It is quite incredible, utterly incredible. No serious adult could believe that this was merely an aberration.
It has become quite clear now that what we all suspected on this side of the House over the past 12 months, and further back, was true: that there was an extremely effective junta in the Cabinet which, effectively some people say, ran the Cabinet over the head of the Taoiseach and certainly was so strong a junta that it was able to go behind the back of the Taoiseach and start, if the allegations are correct, organising a private army of its own. This junta is now out of office, but it is not out of Parliament and it is not out of the party. In this context the meeting of the Fianna Fáil Party unanimously pledging loyalty to the Taoiseach and to the party becomes positively sickening.
I understand that Deputy Haughey's statement this morning was, broadly speaking, to the effect that he denied the allegations and pledged unswerving loyalty to the party as the only possible hope for democracy in Ireland. This statement takes on a hideously cynical and selfish light. Loyalty to the party is placed before all eyes. There is no question of generalised loyalty to this House or to the people of Ireland. Even in their departure from the front ranks of public life these former Ministers demonstrated their arrogance. They demonstrated it to the Taoiseach by refusing to tender their resignations until they were forced to do so by the Taoiseach's action under the Constitution. I am reasonably well versed in the history of Irish political practice since 1922 and I do not think a precedent for conduct of that nature exists. There is no precedent of anyone having the sheer neck to say: "I will not give up until I have to."
Something happened between the morning and the evening of last Wednesday. The heads were counted and it was seen that they had to go. This was a despicable way of demonstrating collective responsibility or loyalty to their leader and to the House. The arrogance was again demonstrated in the fantastic and astounding attack by Deputy Boland this morning on the processes by which the misconduct of these people was discovered. There was an onslaught on the Special Branch and it was implied that the people who had given information to the leader of the Fine Gael Party were by definition dishonest men.
Does Deputy Boland know anything about the traditional impartiality of the Civil Service or about the traditional impartiality of the police? Does Deputy Boland honestly think that it would be more desirable to have a situation in which the Special Branch and the Department of Justice followed me, Deputy O'Higgins, Deputy Corish, or tapped our phones or opened our letters but that members of the Cabinet should enjoy special immunity? Does he think that members of the Cabinet should enjoy unique right of access to facts of public import collected by the police in the discharge of their honourable duty and, having got those facts, have the right to suppress them in the teeth of public interest? This is a despicable view of the impartiality of the administration of this country. This demonstrates the historic importance of what we are talking about today. When we are all dead historians will write about this episode as a case history of abuse of the traditional relationships between the Executive and the Legislature.
Deputy Boland's speech was shot through with funny stories, which were laughed at. I do not think this is a day for funny stories. It is a day of tragedy. Statesmen should be above reproach and should be seen to be above reproach. The projection of a private citizen into public office, so far from rendering him immune from inquiry into his private life, as Deputy Boland seems to argue, renders him all the more subject to inquiry. If I were in the position of holding office, I would fully accept that I had lost privacy rather than gained it and that my actions would be subject not merely to the same scrutiny as other citizens of the State but to even more excessive scrutiny. If the civil servant whom Deputy Boland named in this House acted as Deputy Boland implied he acted, then the House and democracy in Ireland owe him a warm vote of thanks, and owe the Civil Service of this country a warm vote of thanks. At least, he demonstrated that, 48 years after we got our freedom, even if our politicians have not yet learned to have respect for the decencies of public life, the Civil Service have retained that tradition and have rescued us when we needed it.
In speaking as Deputy Boland did and in acting as the Government have acted, a further question mark has been cast on the credibility of the Civil Service. This is to be regretted. Deputy Boland has dragged the name of a senior civil servant into this House and has made an implication about the role the Civil Service should play. It has been implied that the Civil Service should be subservient to Government Ministers. A great disservice has been done to an honourable institution in Ireland.
I do not understand how a Government as ready as this Government have been to utilise the facilities of the Special Branch resent the Special Branch in this instance. I know that if I had behaved as it is alleged Deputy Haughey and Deputy Blaney behaved I would not have been given 16 days in which to make up my mind about what I felt like doing. My door would have been locked when the Special Branch arrived. Does Deputy Boland mean that there should be one law for the ordinary people and another for senior Ministers of State? If these allegations are correct, the proponents of this conspiracy should not even be allowed to take back seats in the House. They belong in prison where I, and any ordinary citizen, would be if we had done the same thing.
The Taoiseach cannot escape this obligation to make facts known. Facts must come out. Facts cannot be suppressed. Deputy Boland said something about the allegations not having been put forward in accordance with the normal rules of evidence. Not long ago an extremely expensive inquiry was instituted in this State into a certain television programme. When it was argued in this House that there was a difference between journalistic standards of truth and legal standards of truth, this point was lost on the then Minister for Justice. In the light of subsequent events all the actions of the then Minister for Justice, including those in relation to that controversy, must now have a large question mark over them.
When this issue arises here, the Government not merely fail to see a distinction between the high standards of morality demanded of politicians and those demanded of the ordinary people, but they inverse it and decide that politicians are entitled to have lower standards. Deputy Boland said this morning that what happened was that the penalty had been: "dismissal from the Government rather than incarceration in a modern Bastille". What a frivolous way to view the consequences of improper parliamentary action. Dismissal from the Government is not an adequate punishment. It is not adequate in my eyes and will not be adequate in the eyes of the Irish people. A great fog of distrust now hangs over the Government and over the Taoiseach in particular. We must ask whether the Taoiseach is telling the truth when he says there was no other attempt at gun-running except this one. I am sorry to say that I do not believe this was the only attempt which was made. I am sure my views will be vindicated when the whole story is known. It may seem that I should not attack the integrity and credibility of the Taoiseach. That was pointed out to me a while ago. The Taoiseach said in the Dáil on Wednesday night that there had been no suggestion that the Minister for Justice was involved. The Taoiseach repeated that Deputy Ó Moráin's resignation had been tendered on health grounds. His information was from an eminent doctor and was to the effect that the Deputy would have to have some further months of treatment. Deputy Boland, speaking this morning, said that Deputies Blaney, Haughey and Ó Moráin had been dealt with. Somebody is lying. Who? I want to know.
Comment on this
The Deputy has a preconceived idea. If he would try to get rid of that preconceived idea, and if he would look objectively at the matter, he would find that it presents a different aspect.
Comment on this
I have no preconceived idea. All I have is a pair of ears and a capacity to understand the English language. How a Minister has been dealt with, when his resignation has been accepted on health grounds, I cannot understand, particularly when he was bracketed with two other Ministers who were forcibly ejected from their Cabinet offices——
Comment on this
I took a note of what he said here today. He said he was one of the four not overtly pushed out of office. I do not know if the Minister was pushed or not.
Comment on this
Is Deputy Colley in possession of the full facts? Has he been in possession of the full facts? Is Deputy Colley one of them? That is what he is now implying. Does Deputy Colley know what has been going on? Whose side is Deputy Colley on?
Comment on this
The Taoiseach said the information available to him confirmed that Deputy Moran was in no way concerned with or implicated in the allegations made against Deputy Haughey and Deputy Blaney.