Nomination of Members of Government: Motion.
Contributions 338–548 of 1,547. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 8 parts.
There were many republicans sent to their death by the rope and bullet and many more thousands incarcerated, especially during the war, by the so-called Republican Party. By reason of their anti-republican attitude during these crucial years, especially the war years and immediately afterwards, there emerged another republican party called Clann na Poblachta which made considerable progress for some time, in order to assert again the true principles of Republicanism. There are still elements of Sinn Féin in this country who would repudiate, and rightly repudiate, any suggestion that Fianna Fáil were the inheritors and the only inheritors of the philosophy of Tone.
For a long number of years the Fianna Fáil Party have forgotten utterly and completely about true Republicanism. The evidence of this is in their actions and attitude towards the elimination of the Border. Reference to the Border has not been made in any world assembly for a long, long time by Fianna Fáil spokesmen, be it the Minister for External Affairs or anyone else. They were as silent as the grave on this issue in the United Nations down the years. It was only when the holocaust broke loose last August, and by reason of the stand taken by members of this party, that they were provoked into taking a stand before the world on this fundamental issue. Republicanism in this context is a sham and a pretext. It will not convince anyone. The reasons for this are deeper and more sinister.
If Deputy Neil Blaney and his Donegal Mafia want to create a private army in Northern Ireland, let them do so and let Ian Paisley deal with them but he has no right whatsoever to involve the Irish people in this escapade. He has no right to usurp the functions of this House or his high office in order to create a private army, certainly not in this part of Ireland, and he has lesser right to use the machinery of State here for this purpose.
The Taoiseach, the Government and the Fianna Fáil Party are now reaping the harvest from the seeds they sowed in the minds of the Irish people, especially prior to the last general election. They are reaping the whirlwind now. In April to June of last year they talked of alien influences in this country, about the security of the State being in danger, about anarchy and, in the main, they sought to impute these things to our party. They sought Reds under our beds. Led by their Taoiseach they embarked on the most vicious and despicable smear campaign ever engaged in in the political history of the country.
Comment on this
Deputy Dowling is a pastmaster at what I shall now deal with—the role of the character assassin, the role of the slanderer and the calumniator, the role of the liar and the deceiver. This was the campaign carried on in the last general election when they told the people that the Labour Party policy was alien to their aspirations, that there was something essentially evil about it, that we were the people who would tear down the pillars of society. Little did we or the Irish people think that within 12 months all the evils that they were attributing to us would be displayed openly in their own party. The Irish people now know who the anarchists are and who are the people who are seeking to tear down the pillars of our society. They know now that they are not in the Labour Party. When the Taoiseach was going on his tour of the country, visiting in particular religious houses, convents, presbyteries and schools, having on his face a sanctimonious expression, he whispered "communists", whispered "anarchists".
Comment on this
He little thought that he would have to be dealing with persons of this ilk in his own party within 12 months. Everyone now knows who the conspirators are and now realises that that campaign was one of vilification. There would not be a God if this did not boomerang on themselves.
Comment on this
That is what Ian Paisley said and Ian was right. The chickens have come home to roost.
Comment on this
I must advert to that campaign of vilification because it was, and everyone now recognises it to have been, a vicious smear campaign. The Taoiseach must have used up many tons of red paint trying to paint our faces. Some of that stuck and very many decent parliamentarians in our party failed to be returned to the House as a result. It was a most dishonest and dishonourable campaign, one of the worst ever carried out in this country.
The mills of God grind slowly but they grind exceeding small. There are now in his own party the alien influences which are seeking to secure arms in communist countries as well as in democracies. They were very close to the Taoiseach himself.
I do not feel the Taoiseach should be exonerated from any blame in this whole matter. The Taoiseach led the campaign of vilification at that time. He made a particular point of visiting convents, presbyteries and schools. He engendered fear in the hearts of many people that the Labour Party were insidious and dangerous, that their ideology was alien and that if elected to power we would nationalise everything. He said all these things and schoolchildren were brainwashed. I know this because I and some of my colleagues suffered as a result.
The Taoiseach and his henchmen talked of many things in that campaign. They used communism, Castro and Cuba. Little did we think that within 12 months we would have a little Castro in the Fianna Fáil Party in the person of Deputy Neil Blaney, seeking to set up a banana republic in this country.
Comment on this
Just a moment—and would the Parliamentary Secretary please allow Deputy Treacy to get on with his speech?
Comment on this
The Taoiseach, with his sanctimonious expression and his veneer of the honest man, purported to be the repository of all that was good and holy in this country during the last general election campaign and the rest of us were all to some degree evil.
Comment on this
We now know the truth. The facts are known. The men who were the real danger to the country and who had no respect for the institutions of the State, or the security of our people, who were prepared to consort with anyone at home or abroad to attain their despicable ends, were the people closest to the Taoiseach himself. It was a particularly despicable campaign of slander and lies.
Comment on this
And it is only fitting now that the party which perpetrated this great fraud on the Irish people should suffer the humiliation of finding themselves hoist with the same ideology themselves. As I said, they used the religious orders——
Comment on this
The Deputy is aware that repetition is out of order. I have allowed the Deputy to make this statement at least four times.
Comment on this
I am not given to indulging in repetition, but I want to assert that not only did they cajole in this fashion, with this mock piety, but they threatened and they intimidated. We know it to be their stock-in-trade. People were threatened that they would lose their jobs and pensioners were threatened with the withdrawal of their pensions. They fastened on the weakest and poorest sections of the people, the people who are drawing the dole, the recipients of old age and widows' pensions, and so on, and they threatened that, if they did not vote for Fianna Fáil, they would lose these pensions and they would lose the dole. All these things were done in the last general election campaign.
Comment on this
They have continually adopted the line that they in the Fianna Fáil Party are the almighty party and, if they think you are in a weak position and do not support them, then you will get nothing.
Comment on this
I have known this intimidation to occur. I have known it to be said: "If you vote for Treacy he will nationalise industry", or "if you vote for him you will lose your job." And it was whispered many times in the ear of defenceless people: "You have a pension, have you not, and mind it."
Comment on this
We know the campaign that was waged in the last general election. It is indeed revealing to find that party, which carried out that kind of campaign, in a shambles today. I have referred to some of the Ministers involved in this sordid matter. I referred briefly to Caoimhín Ó Beoláin, Deputy Kevin Boland. It is pertinent to point out that there is an excuse for the arrogance of this man.
Comment on this
But there is. This man, strangely enough, was never a TD in the strict sense of that word. He had never to do the hard grind of public representation or sit on public boards, such as many of us have had to do.
Comment on this
He came into this House and the first day he came into this House there was placed upon his shoulders the mantle of a Minister of State. He was never allowed to sit here as an ordinary TD and it must be very uncomfortable, indeed, for him, after his long sojourn in the various Ministries of Defence and Social Welfare and Local Government, to sit in the back benches and be a backbencher for the first time in his life, an ordinary rookie TD. I do not want to advert at length to his dereliction of duty in regard to the provision of homes and water supplies and sanitary services and the colossal scandal of housing which he has left behind him, but it is only fair to say that I always regarded him as a most unfair Minister in that, on every conceivable occasion, he gave the kudos to his own political hacks, even though others of us had earned the reward of the reply to or the acknowledgment of representations.
I have already said that he was power hungry and I do not believe he will be content to rest in the back benches without asserting his claims to power again in the future. He is now obviously turning his venom on his own leader. He says he did not agree with the dismissals. Are we to take it that Deputy Boland condones the actions for which Deputy Blaney and Deputy Haughey have been dismissed by their Taoiseach? He also, not having had his own way, resorted to the last desperate act of threatening to resign. He did, in fact, resign. A man who behaves in that fashion towards his leader, adopting a threat of that kind in very difficult and painful circumstances, is a man bereft of reason and I am sure that his plea of loyalty in this House today will fall on very deaf ears indeed where the Taoiseach is concerned.
Deputy Blaney is also a very strong-willed man. If he wants to create a private army in the North let that be, but he has no right to involve the Irish people in this mad gamble. Nor has he any right to use the institutions of State for the purpose of armed rebellion. Deputy Blaney and his colleagues are trying to create a power keg which is bound to blow up and many lives are likely to be lost. If there is bloodshed in the north and guns are used the Taoiseach must realise that responsibility lies on his head. If illegal organisations can secure arms of this kind at the behest of Ministers, the Fianna Fáil Government have much to answer for.
Deputy Haughey's association with this nefarious and sordid business came as a surprise to all of us. In his statement today he claims that he is innocent of the accusation of bringing ammunition into the country. The Taoiseach has an obligation in replying to the debate to give more facts as to the reasons why these Ministers were asked to resign. It is not good enough to say that they disagreed with the Taoiseach and the Government in respect of the attitude towards the Border. The full facts of the whole affair must be made known. It is not enough for Deputy Blaney or Deputy Boland to come into the House and avail of its privileges and in vague generalities and, with pleas of loyalty and adherence to the Republican cause, seek to roll the other fundamental issues under the carpet.
The Taoiseach must be more frank and honest with the House and tell us also of the conflict of evidence between the ex-army officer, Captain Kelly, and the evidence of the Minister for Defence, Deputy Gibbons. We would have much preferred if Deputy Haughey had concentrated more on dealing with the Budget in a responsible manner——
Comment on this
——rather than that he should do the lazy and indolent thing and by one stroke of the pen increase the turnover tax without any serious endeavour to select the luxury goods for taxation and ease the burden on the most necessitous sections of the community.
It was an indolent and irresponsible Budget which did nothing to deflate the economy, a Budget which of set purpose sends costs spiralling again and gives an opportunity to every exploiter and usurer to exploit our people. In the past few weeks since the Budget was introduced every housewife realises that the price of every essential commodity has increased out of all proportion.
Comment on this
I am commenting on Deputy Haughey's Budget vis-à-vis his endeavours to bring in arms here for illegal use as distinct from his primary duty of dealing with the economic affairs of the country——
Comment on this
——and introduce some stability in respect of prices and safeguard the people from exploitation. He failed abjectly in that regard and was seemingly engaged in nefarious activities.
What the people want most of all is to see justice done in relation to this sordid episode. If there is to be any respect for law and order the people who have been guilty of such serious offences, if not crimes, should be brought to the bar of justice where there will be full, fair and impartial investigation into the whole affair so that we can regain some semblance of respect for this House, so that we shall regain our honour and respect for the institutions of State that have been so sullied in recent days by the irresponsible and dangerous activities of Government Ministers. I, therefore, ask the Taoiseach to give us an assurance when replying that he will not tolerate these people in the Cabinet, in his party or in the House but will see to it that for what they have done they will receive the same treatment as any other citizen would receive in the same circumstances. There are at present some men under long and severe sentences in England for merely having attempted to secure arms. It will be interesting, therefore, to know what will happen to these people who have so disgraced this House and society.
Comment on this
I did not intend to speak at all today. I came here at 10.30 this morning to listen and I have listened until 11.30 tonight. One's patience becomes exhausted at times. First, I want to refer to the motion before the House so that those who are listening will understand how far the Deputies who were supposed to be discussing the motion went outside it. The motion is:
That Dáil Éireann approve the nomination by the Taoiseach of the following Members for appointment by the President to be members of the Government—
Jerry Cronin,
Robert Molloy and
Gerard Collins.
I am happy to support this motion and to say that these are honourable men. I wish them the best in the future. I know they will carry out their duties for many years to come with dignity and understanding.
Many matters have been injected into this debate here tonight including the attack on the dead father of Deputy Blaney and the Boland family. It is pretty difficult for one to exercise restraint but these false charges that have been made here tonight will be answered in detail. According to Deputy Keating it would seem that it is a crime to be a republican. We are republicans and proud to be republicans; we will always be republicans and it is no crime to be a republican in this country.
Comment on this
Men have died for this Republic and for the unity of the country. Men were executed because they would not compromise their principles down through the years. We have no apologies to make for being republicans. Throughout the debate we have seen that Fine Gael and the Labour Party can be congratulated as men of great imagination and men with a keen sense of rumour. Through the day they carried on a recital of distortions and lies, of unfounded allegations and character assassinations. We are happy and proud to be with the men on this side of the House and very happy to stand behind the Taoiseach——
Comment on this
Many attacks have been made on him, particularly by the last speaker, and I noted that he did not make those attacks when the Taoiseach was present. The Taoiseach is a man of courage and understanding. He did not run away or would not run away from his responsibilities as he sees them. He had two options on this occasion. One was to do nothing and the other was to run away as you gang did on a previous occasion. He did not do that. He did what he thought was right and proper. We support him as the leader of this party and as the president of our great organisation. We support him for his courage and understanding in doing what he thought was right. He has the right in accordance with the Constitution— and this party agree on this—to hire and fire as he so desires. That is his right and if he decides to dispense with members of his Cabinet that is his affair.
He did what he thought was right and we stand behind him just as the party stood behind him unanimously yesterday. It has been suggested here today that we had no right to speak. We had a right to speak and we did speak. We asked questions where questions were necessary. It was not a case of being brought into a room, as was suggested by some of the Opposition speakers, and told what to do and getting out in a hurry. It may show the efficiency of our party that we were able to deal with the problems in such a short time. It did not take us three or four weeks with hundreds of meetings, as it did other parties to deal with small problems which they had. We dealt with them effectively and efficiently and we pledged our support to the leader of our party and to the party, because we know it is the only party that can do anything or has done anything for this country.
Many matters have been injected into this debate and it is necessary for us to examine some of them in detail. The attack by a new Deputy on the father of Deputy Neil Blaney, on the father of a dead man who was a good Republican and who has a good Republican son——
Comment on this
The father of Deputy Neil Blaney was attacked by a new Deputy from the Fine Gael Party. We know they would try to discredit even the dead. There was an attack on the Boland family when Deputy Treacy said they had a bad record in relation to this nation. Was he referring to Harry Boland? Was he referring to Gerry Boland? Was he referring to Deputy Kevin Boland? He said "the Boland family". The Boland family have a Republican tradition better than Deputy Treacy or any member of the Labour Party or the Fine Gael Party.
Comment on this
The Deputy had his say and he will listen now, and he will not again insult in this House men like Neil Blaney's father or Harry Boland. I am sure that he and the other members of Fine Gael and Labour who spoke here today would not say outside this House what they said under the privilege of the House. I am quite certain they would not, because they are a crowd of cowards. They have always proved that. They have come in here from time to time and made serious allegations that they would only make in this House. When they were challenged outside they would not make them. We are a party with a leader and a policy which I am sure the people of this country appreciate. They appreciate the fact that the Taoiseach took the steps that were necessary and desirable in his opinion. We have a united party and we face the future with a united party. We were told recently of the attempt to overthrow the leader of the Fine Gael Party in May, 1971.
Comment on this
Deputy Ryan was brought in and paraded on a number of occasions and after he got a course of corrective training he apologised to the people.
Comment on this
I was giving them another year to go. We heard quite a lot from the rabble rousers of Fine Gael and Labour. We know they are efficient at this business. They proved it today. The previous speaker did not know what motion was being discussed. He stood up and spoke to a Labour Party motion which proves he was completely out of touch with the affairs of this House. He did not know what motion was being discussed here today. He used Tuesday's speech instead and I note that he did not conclude the speech but put aside the balance for next Tuesday when he can again carry on with the type of character assassination he carried on here for an hour or so.
Comment on this
I will not speak on behalf of Deputy Neil Blaney or Deputy Kevin Boland or Deputy Haughey. They spoke on their own behalf and there is no need for me to say what I think. They have made their statements and that is that. This party stands fully behind the Taoiseach. We are concerned with the unification of this nation. Like many other people in this House I served this nation honourably under arms. Today I was appalled to hear some Members of the House insulting the Defence Forces of this country. There may be one person in that force, or one person who was in it, who broke his oath to the nation but the bulk of those people are honourable and respectable men who are serving this nation honourably under arms and will continue to do so. They have done so with dignity in the Congo, in Cyprus and elsewhere. Nobody in the Opposition can point the finger at the members of the Defence Forces or, indeed, the members of the Garda Síochána who carry out their duties effectively and efficiently.
Comment on this
Order. Deputy Desmond has already spoken at length. He might allow another Deputy to make his speech.
Comment on this
We were accused here tonight of being loyal to Fianna Fáil. This was one of the accusations made by the Labour Party. We are proud to be members of this party. It gives me great pride to be a member of this party, having listened to the boloney preached here by the muckrakers and character assassins from the Fine Gael and Labour benches. They spoke with one tongue today and I am quite sure they will do the same in the future. That is the only way they can possibly survive.
We are concerned about the unity of this nation. I agree with some of the views expressed here in relation to the unity of the nation. I do not agree that any illegal organisations should be supplied with arms. Members of my party do not agree that illegal organitions should be supplied with arms. Each and every one of them stated that today. I am quite sure that our Defence Forces are competent to do their job, that the Taoiseach will do the job for which he was elected, and that the Government will carry out the job for which they were elected. The sooner these three men who are the subject matter of this motion are appointed the better, because the longer the Opposition keep them out of office the longer they are delaying the business of this House in connection with such things as the Housing Bill——
Comment on this
——and all the other Bills that are on the Order Paper. The longer they keep this debate going the longer they will delay the implementation of the valuable and necessary Bills which are going through this House at present. I can well understand their desire to ensure that there will be a delay in putting through effective and progressive legislation but, nevertheless, however long they may like to discuss this motion, the day will come when those young men will take up their duties and prove that they can do the job in a highly effective and efficient manner.
Comment on this
We believe in the complete unity of this nation. We believe in the ideals of Tone and Pearse and Brugha and Liam Mellowes and Rory O'Connor, men of uncompromising principle. They are our ideals and they will always be our ideals. The complete unification of this country is our ideal. We will not allow rabble rousers to insult Republicans or good Republican families. Not alone have they been insulted but members of such families were shot. The wayside crosses in every county are monuments to courageous men who fell at the hands of the assassin whether it was the foreign enemy or the native slave. Many of them lost their lives on the gallows—victims of the British hangman. We will not allow Fine Gael or the Labour Party to insult these people as they have done here today. We know their views on Republicanism for many years. I was not born until 1922. I never introduced this subject in the House before. I have deep feelings for courageous men of uncompromising principles. When I see them attacked by rabble rousers it angers me. Respect for the dignity of the House prevents me from saying many things which I should like to say to the rabble rousers here today.
I do not want to see a blood-bath. The only possible solution at present appears to be the policy enunciated by the Taoiseach and by the members of the Fianna Fáil Party as endorsed at the Ard-Fheis. One has only to read the constitution of Fianna Fáil to know what we stand for. We stand for each and every one of those aims and ideals. There are many young men in this country motivated by a desire to free the nation. This terrible picture stems from the infamous Treaty for which so many courageous men lost their lives.
Comment on this
That is my view and I have the right to express it just as the Opposition have the right to express their views. We heard references to the Irish Independent. One knows the type of stuff the Irish Independent has printed over the years. It was quoted by every member of the Labour Party and the Fine Gael Party in relation to the attacks on honourable men in this party. Since I came in here tonight the Taoiseach has been referred to in a variety of ways in his absence.
Comment on this
The previous Labour speaker was pulled up by the Ceann Comhairle for repeating himself several times. He was using the one speech over and over again. When the Taoiseach came here tonight to put the position before the House he had taken a number of decisions. He put his future at stake on the basis of decisions he had made. This is the action of a courageous man and not the type of man Deputy Tracy depicted on a number of occasions. I shall not go into details because of the type of filth the Deputy poured out tonight. The Taoiseach will lead this nation for a long time to come. The people are satisfied and will respond when they are called on to respond in his favour again.
We heard references to a statement supplied by the police to Deputy Cosgrave. It was indicated that this was on headed Garda paper. It would appear that there is a double agent in the police. This House should demand the name of the man who signed the document given to Deputy Cosgrave. How much was that man paid for the information? Let us examine the situation and see was he paid for it. The Deputy is under an obligation to place that letter before the House in order that it can be examined and analysed.
Comment on this
I disagree with the statements made by some of the Fianna Fáil Deputies here today. If we have a security service it is up to us to use the information as it comes to hand. This is not a State where authority is immune from ethical consideration. Each person is equal in this State. It is up to the Taoiseach to use whatever legal means are at his disposal. We vote money here year after year for this service. I see nothing wrong in the Taoiseach using information supplied to him in this way. Some Members thought this was not right and proper. Money having been voted in this House, the Taoiseach is entitled to use the service and on that score I disagree with some Fianna Fáil speakers.
A foul suggestion about Garda Fallon's murder was introduced into the debate. Indirect efforts were made to tarnish the names of many men here with the murder of Garda Fallon. We hope that every Member of this House knows that the foul and brutal murderers of Garda Fallon will be brought to justice as soon as possible.
Comment on this
That may well be. There are some people in this country who were never brought to justice. They are knocking around since 1922 and before it.
Comment on this
And they are all on the far side of the House.
Comment on this
The Army and the Garda are forces for which I have the height of respect, as has every honourable man here. But references have been made here today by the Opposition casting reflections on the honourable men in the Garda and Defence Forces.
Comment on this
Not alone were the Garda and the Army attacked but the Legion of Mary and the reverend mothers in the convents.
Comment on this
It would appear from Deputy Donegan's remarks here today that we will have to get either the Special Branch to arm or to protect the Garda in the future because he appears to have no respect whatsoever for them. He might do the same thing with them as he did with the tinkers in his gun running escapade.
Comment on this
Deputy Noel Browne introduced a new line into this debate. He spoke about contraceptives, the disabled, emigration, unemployment, care of the aged, housing and a variety of other matters, and divorce. I do not know how all this comes into the motion by the Taoiseach seeking the approval of Dáil Éireann for the appointment of certain Deputies as Ministers. Nevertheless, Deputy Noel Browne injected those matters into the debate.
Comment on this
You are on a winner so long as you stay on the confraternity.
Comment on this
Deputy Conor Cruise-O'Brien in his contribution today complained that Deputy Blaney did not let him know what he was doing in the north. Of course, Deputy Cruise-O'Brien did not tell us what he was doing in Ghana, in New York or in the Congo. Why should Deputy Blaney or anyone else tell him what he was doing?
Comment on this
The ex-Minister is under no obligation to tell Deputy Cruise-O'Brien when and where he goes.
Comment on this
In his speech Deputy Keating referred to the 50-minute meeting. As I said earlier, each Member of this party had an opportunity of speaking. Members of this party did speak and asked whatever questions they desired to ask.
Comment on this
He did not get £50,000 for a fake farm, either.
Comment on this
Earlier today Dr. Noel Browne spoke of the methods we would employ in order to achieve the unity of this country. He says that if they do not come in willingly then we will bring them in at the point of the gun.
Comment on this
This is what Deputy Noel Browne said. Why not send for the record and I shall wait for it?
Comment on this
If the Ceann Comhairle will allow me to go for the record, I am prepared to go for it.
Comment on this
This position has clearly been explained not alone by the Taoiseach but by other Members of the party who spoke here today. They have clearly outlined the policy of Fianna Fáil in relation to the unity of Ireland. They have never indicated that this was the method that would be used for the unity of the country. Although many years ago I believed that physical force was the way, I do not believe it now.
Comment on this
I have plenty of material here to keep me going. Deputy Bruton will have to wait until after midnight.
Comment on this
If Deputies would allow the Deputy in possession to speak, everybody would have an opportunity to contribute to the debate.
Comment on this
They are refusing it to me. When Deputy Keating was speaking, he was judging men by their facial expression, not by what they said. He indicated that Deputy Blaney was a man of hatred; that Deputy Boland was a man of hatred. However, he himself poured out nothing but hatred here for an hour or so. There was no question there of forgiveness. How could Deputy Keating judge on facial expression whether men had hatred in their hearts? Why did he not listen to what they had to say? They had one desire: to see that this country does the right thing and goes the right road. That is what all believe in.
I can quite understand Members of Fine Gael and Labour who are trying to discredit tonight the Budget that was introduced here the other day and to mix it up with the motion now before the House so that they would be able to present a different picture. They are not concerned about the unemployed, about the disabled, or about the widows or orphans. They are more concerned about divorce and contraception and a variety of others matters about which Deputy Dr. Browne spoke for so long.
Comment on this
A nice boy; he was exported from Mayo when he was only three months old.
Comment on this
I shall deal now with the security of the State. I am satisfied that the State is secure although efforts have been made here today by Fine Gael and Labour to undermine that security. There is no need for anybody to be terrorised as was the desire of members of the Opposition. We have absolute confidence in the security forces and we are confident they are carrying out their duties in so far as the security of the State is concerned.
We know, too, that this type of approach by Fine Gael and Labour was an attempt to draw in other forces from outside the State. The suggestion has been made by the Opposition that Deputy Cosgrave informed the Taoiseach of the matter concerning the two Ministers at 8 o'clock in the evening and that by 10 o'clock the same evening the two Ministers had been asked to resign. Of course, the position in relation to this matter was clearly outlined by the Taoiseach and by others. In this connection, may I say that whoever was the renegade or traitor who sold the information must be dismissed from his post if he is a member of the security forces or of the Garda Síochána. It was indicated that the information was supplied to Deputy Cosgrave on franked Garda paper but I know from people who were standing behind the Deputy in the lobby when he read the letter that it was a plain sheet of paper.
Comment on this
I have no time for renegades or traitors whether they be in the Labour Party or the Garda Síochána.
Comment on this
If Deputies will cease this kind of conversation across the House and address the Chair perhaps the Deputy could continue.
Comment on this
It would appear that the Labour Party would like to hear more. While Deputy Dockrell was speaking he referred to cowboys and Indians and to cops and robbers. This was his type of contribution to a debate on a serious matter. I do not know to whom the Deputy was referring because it would appear that the Indians are all on that side of the House.
Comment on this
I would appeal to the House to approve of the nominations as outlined in the motion. I hope that these men will soon be able to take up their appointments so that the work of the country which has already been held up by the activities of the Opposition can be continued. If there are people in the public gallery who have heard the speeches of members of the Opposition I say to them that they need not come back on Tuesday because the speeches have been the same today as they were the day before yesterday and we can be sure they will be the same again on Tuesday.
Comment on this
According to reports in yesterday's papers an officer recently resigned from the Army, admitted that he was involved in the affair which led to the forced resignation of a number of Government Ministers. The officer qualified this by saying that his involvement was only slight, although he did admit involvement. Patrick Kennedy, who is an MP at Stormont, was today reported as saying that Captain Kelly, the officer to whom I refer, is a friend of his and is a good Irishman. Mr. Kennedy said that anything the officer did was done with the full knowledge of his superiors, his superior in this case being the Minister for Defence, Deputy Gibbons.
In this House today Deputy Gibbons denied that he had any involvement in this affair. However, a statement by Captain Kelly to the BBC and as issued by them to press and radio tells another story. I quote from Captain Kelly's statement:
Under privilege of the Dáil, Mr. Gibbons has attacked me. All he has said is a tissue of lies. Any work which I did I brought to the knowledge of Mr. Gibbons at any and every opportunity. He is completely aware of anything I did prior to my leaving the Army.
On May 1st when I was arrested by the Special Branch I claimed privilege and asked for Mr. Gibbons to be called. Mr. Gibbons advised me to tell everything I knew concerning my work as an intelligence officer. I rejected this advice because of the implications involved. It was suggested that I speak to the Taoiseach which I did. In my hearing, Mr. Gibbons, before leaving the office (this is the office of the Special Branch) indicated that I was a competent and respected officer and that I should be treated as such. I found my family in a hysterical condition on account of what had been said in the Dáil.
Referring to Deputy Gibbons, Captain Kelly said:
This man is an unmitigated scoundrel and I say this not under the privilege of Dáil Éireann. I met him at his office in Leinster House on April 29th and I gave him a full account of my work. We parted on amiable terms. Mr. Gibbons has often indicated that I was doing an excellent job for the country as an intelligence officer.
This statement clearly implicates Deputy Gibbons in this affair. Now, where do we leave the Taoiseach's statement that not even the slightest suspicion should attach to any member of the Government in a matter of this nature? How is that statement to be applied in this case? The Government may seek refuge behind the line adopted in the current edition of the periodical This Week. They may seek to adopt this story to state that Deputy Gibbons covered himself by telling the Taoiseach at the end of last year of his knowledge of this matter. I quote from the current issue of This Week:
The next development, coming up to the end of the year, must have been a bombshell to the Taoiseach. He was consulted privately by James Gibbons, the quiet, unflappable Kilkenny-born Minister for Defence, who had some very disturbing information.
Gibbons had reports from Army sources that the connection between the IRA Army Council and the two Cabinet Ministers was still being continued. The reports were vague; there were no times, places or hard-and-fast details to back them up.
Unverified, the information he brought could not be acted upon immediately. Lynch was left in a lonely dilemma of doubt, which he had no clear way of resolving.
More concrete evidence was not too long emerging, however. Within the last two months, hints, rumours —and a lot of more factual material —snowballed.
However, this is not conclusive evidence that Deputy Gibbons was not himself implicated in the plot. There is no reason to believe that he may not have been covering himself by going to the Taoiseach while in fact continuing in the plot with Deputy Blaney and Deputy Haughey, backing both horses at once. No matter what way we look at it either of two situations must represent the true facts. Either Deputy Gibbons did tell the Taoiseach at the end of last year as in the This Week story that he knew of the plot, in which case the Taoiseach did nothing about it and has misled this House in saying that the first knowledge that he, the Taoiseach, had of this affair was on the 20th April, or—the alternative—the Minister for Defence himself was involved in the plot behind the Taoiseach's back and did not go to the Taoiseach. In this case the Taoiseach's implication that no further Ministers were to resign when he stated to Tom McCaughren of RTE yesterday morning—excuse me, I had better start that again.
Comment on this
In this case the Taoiseach's implication that no further Ministers were involved, when he stated that no other resignations were anticipated to the RTE reporter, Tom McCaughren, was totally untrue.
Comment on this
There is another copy of This Week. Take a look at it.
Comment on this
Now, what price do we put on the honesty of the Taoiseach? If further evidence were needed of the Taoiseach's deceits we need only look at a recent matter which was raised in this House. The Taoiseach alleged that he asked Deputy Blaney and Deputy Haughey to resign on the 29th April. However, on the 5th May in this House when the leader of Fine Gael asked him if there were to be any further resignations the Taoiseach told him that he did not know what Deputy Cosgrave was talking about.
Comment on this
He stated on the following day, the 6th, that as far back as the 29th April he had asked Members to resign. Yet, he came into this House on the Tuesday and told Deputy Cosgrave that he did not know what he was talking about when Deputy Cosgrave asked him if there were to be any further resignations. Can anybody believe the Taoiseach any more?
Comment on this
I rise this evening for a number of reasons. I did not intend to speak on this motion because I felt it would go on far too long and that many things would be said that people might regret later, but I rise now because, as the day wears on, it has become increasingly obvious to me that most of the statements that came from the Government side of the
Let us examine the position. We are here tonight to approve a motion nominating further new Ministers. The reason House are inaccurate to say the least, we find ourselves in this position is that the Taoiseach says that he believes two of his senior Ministers are involved in a plot. These senior Ministers retaliate and deny it emphatically. This to me is elementary: somebody is telling an untruth. As well as these two Ministers, another Minister and a Parliamentary Secretary resigned. Three of these people have contributed to the debate today. Deputy Boland, who was not asked to resign, he resigned himself, to his credit at least appeared to be sincere. To the other two I could not attribute any vestige of sincerity. The performance of the former Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries in the House this evening was nothing short of scandalous. He came in here and ranted and raved about the Civil War. There are many on this side of the House and on the other side of the House who were not born until after the Civil War. Indeed, there are some on this side of the House, and they must be on the other side too, who were not born until during the 1939-45 war—and after it, Deputy Bruton reminds me. It is time we got away from talk of the Civil War.
Comment on this
People come into this House and boast that their fathers and their grandfathers were great patriots. Maybe they were, but it is no credit to them that they were born into these families. This is an act of the Almighty. Some of us were born into families with national traditions——
Comment on this
——and we can be proud of it but others were not and it is not their fault. For God's sake let us work for the good of this country now. I was taught that one's first duty was to one's God, then to one's country and to one's family. I hope the same traditions were taught to every Irishman in this Parliament. Maybe I was naive when I came into this House and accepted that any Minister appointed by a democratically elected Taoiseach would work for the good of the country. Can this be said of Ministers who are indicted by their own Taoiseach? Can it be said of them that they worked for the good of the country if they conspired to bring arms into this country?
There was a lot of loose talk last Wednesday, today and tonight about patriotism. Yesterday my small daughter said to me: "What is patriotism?" As I hunted around to explain to a ten year old what patriotism is I said to her: "I think the simplest way to say to you what patriotism is is that it is working day in and day out to make a nation strong". Can the Taoiseach and members of his Cabinet say they work day in and day out to make this nation strong? It appears to me some of them have worked day in and day out to bring down this nation.
Comment on this
Those who are guilty have brought shame on this country, shame on their own side of the House and unfortunately shame on the entire House. It might be funny to listen to Deputy Dowling ranting, raving and amusing everyone if it were not for the type of situation we find ourselves in in this country today. For God's sake let us try and retrieve the situation. Let us make ourselves proud to be Irish and let us be able to face the rest of Europe. At the moment we are in a position that we have a Taoiseach and Cabinet who must be in the most disgraceful condition in the whole of Europe. I can say that we must be viewed by foreigners like the banana republics of South America.
I cannot prove who is right but certainly, if the Ministers claim they are not guilty, then the Taoiseach has done them a disservice. Let us remind the House that the Taoiseach is a lawyer by profession, or was before he became Taoiseach and I am sure he did not act without weighty evidence. I am equally sure he would not have acted at all if he had not been pushed by Deputy Cosgrave. A Fianna Fáil Deputy said to me: "I am afraid that only for Deputy Cosgrave we could have got away with it." That is the feeling in this country, that if you are Fianna Fáil you will get away with it.
There must be law and order in this country. If there is to be law and order the same law must apply to Fianna Fáil as to the rest of the country. It must apply to Cabinet Ministers the same as it does to the man in the street. At the moment we do not see this law applying to the Cabinet Ministers and it is time we did. I see in the hasty cementing together of the Fianna Fáil Party loyalty to one thing, loyalty above all else to the Fianna Fáil Party. You are putting your party before your country. In the name of God, let the Taoiseach go to the Park before it is too late, before we are disgraced before the whole world and let us try and retrieve this situation.
We have done harm to the North of Ireland. Fianna Fáil speakers would give the impression that they are the only people who are interested in the North of Ireland. There is not any Member of this House, no matter what side he is from, who is not genuinely interested in a peaceful solution to the problems of the north. Let us not inflate the position any further by lies, untruths and denials from the very highest on the far side of the House. Let the Taoiseach get up and let him assure the House that we will have the truth. Let the people of the country judge for themselves. The only way the people of the country can express their views to this House is by electing a Government for the country. Let them have a chance, knowing the full facts, to choose the Government they want, and I am quite sure they will not return the Fianna Fáil Government who are sitting opposite us tonight.
Comment on this
It is indeed a pity, listening to the references made by Deputy Hogan O'Higgins, that the party opposite did not implement her ideals and carry on with the work of the nation over the past few days. That has not been the case. The party opposite made every effort to panic the nation, to sling every type of mud that could be slung across this House. Nobody can say here tonight that an effort was made by them to face the situation that the nation was facing, to help in this difficult time.
Every effort has been made by the party opposite to make innuendoes about every Member on this side of the House. However, Deputy Hogan O'Higgins said: "Let us get away from the Civil War. It should not be mentioned." I know the people on the far side of the House do not want to hear it mentioned. I heard Deputy Tom O'Higgins mention here the other night that action should be taken and I heard the new Deputy here this evening say that the rule of law should apply. Deputy Joe Dowling made a passing comment here that there were still people roaming the countryside who should have been dealt with by the law a long time ago, who were protected from 1922 to 1931 by the then Government, and who should have been brought to justice afterwards.
I am perhaps one of the few Members of this House who in 1922 stood and saw two of my comrades, two sick men, taken out of their homes, taken a mile away and brutally murdered on the side of the road. The members of the Government of that day condoned that type of thing. They condoned the shooting of another man near Beaufort, they condoned the blowing up of the men at Ballyseedy, the men at Countess Bridge and the men at Bahaghs, Cahirciveen.
Comment on this
I am referring to what took place when you were in Government. Some of your Deputies went back into the past and I am going back the whole way. This is something the young people of this nation should know. As a result of the Nuremberg Trials the leaders of wartime Germany were executed. There were leaders in this country at that time—they are still around—who should be brought to trial for the outrageous, diabolical murders for which they were responsible. I know the people opposite do not want to hear this kind of thing. I never intended to raise it in this House but what happened in those dark days has to be brought home to our younger people.
Deputy Cosgrave proudly boasted the other night that from 1922 to 1931 they served this country faithfully. I was subjected to violence by the security force of those days. Our ordinary work was held up. You could not go outside your door at night because armed police and armed detectives were about. That is the kind of law that existed in the dying days of the Government of that day. The people of Ireland in 1932 put that Government out of office, and, but for two short periods, they have kept them out ever since.
Let us face facts. I am not in here to rake up the past. I believe that we in this House have a duty to the nation, that we have a duty to our country to build it up. We have enough trouble trying to develop our western counties and give a livelihood to our people. We should not listen to the kind of contribution made by Opposition speakers in the past two days.
In his opening speech this evening, Deputy Keating commented that the first thing he noticed when he came to this House was the hatred that existed. That hatred comes from the far side of the House; and it is obvious from the contributions made in the past few days that the people opposite have not changed. They are still saying the same things. The Irish people are evaluating what they have said in the last few days. Any ideas the Opposition might have that they would get the support of the nation if we went to the country tomorrow morning are incorrect. They would find themselves in the same position as in the past. However, the Opposition need not worry because we will not be going to the country. When we came into this House yesterday the longest faces were on the Opposition back benches. They were the most relieved people when they found out after our meeting that we were all solidly behind the Taoiseach and that Fianna Fáil still existed as strong as ever.
Let us face up to the situation and try to regain the confidence of the nation because we have much work still to do. We will always have plenty to do in this country to build and extend. Great opportunities are open to us in the next few years. We should try to build up a country which would show any foreign industrialist the many advantages of siting industries here. We should try to do all we can to build up the kind of country for which the men of 1916 laid down their lives. All our people have the right to live in this nation and it is important that we provide the necessary way of living to enable them to do this.
If the people opposite tried to help us in this way rather than trying to get the nation into a state of panic they would be doing a much better job and they would be seen by the people of the country in a much better light. By making contributions similar to what they have done in the last few days they certainly will not further their own interests. For as long as they continue with this type of contribution I consider it my duty to keep before the people the background of the Opposition Deputies and of their friends, many of whom are still around and who should have been brought to justice for the atrocities for which they were responsible.
I should also like to refer to a remark made by Deputy O'Higgins the other night that a senior Garda officer was prevented from carrying out his duty. This is my interpretation of what the Deputy said. I am not too sure that he was not referring to the death of Garda Fallon. However, as I understand the position, a Garda officer is bound by his oath to carry out his duty. If there was a Garda officer who was so prevented it is the duty of Deputy O'Higgins to report that fact to the Garda Commissioner. That fact should be laid before the commissioner and the Government, and any officer who has been found wanting in the execution of his duty should be dealt with immediately by his superiors.
In conclusion, I would ask all people here not to send out from this House confused ideas to be published by the Press and radio. Certainly, the utterances of many Deputies in the past few days will not be of any help to the people of the country, and certainly will not help Fine Gael. That party must realise that they are not getting the message across to the people. They are still making outdated contributions which are of no help to the nation.
Comment on this
Like previous speakers on this side of the House I am intervening in this debate not just for the sake of speaking or merely to prolong the debate but because I consider that no Deputy should cast a silent vote on this important question now before the House. The magnitude and importance of this affair should not be overshadowed by references to 1916 and 1922 or any other part of our history. That history has its place in Irish life but it certainly does not have relevance to the important subject of this debate.
I disagree with speakers who have tried to overshadow the serious matter of this debate by emotional references such as we have heard from Fianna Fáil speakers. We are dealing with allegations here that affect the lives of people now living in this country. We are dealing with allegations of interference in the democratic process of this nation and with the grave allegation of people in authority betraying the high trust placed in them. These are the things on which we should be concentrating in this debate. It is important for all Deputies to let their opinions be known on those matters. We represent the country as a whole and we should let the people know our attitude to what has been disclosed here by the Taoiseach in the last few days.
It is not enough for a party to meet behind closed doors and to come out with a decision after a mere 50 minutes. Deputy Dowling may congratulate himself in this matter of reaching a decision in such a short time, but that will not be sufficient to satisfy the people. Each member of the Fianna Fáil Party should let us know if he intends to vote in favour of this motion. Even though the terminology of the motion in one way is misleading, the essence of the debate is that either we agree with what has happened in Cabinet circles over the past few weeks or months or we disagree and denounce the conduct that has been brought to light in this House in the Taoiseach's statement. This is basically what the vote at the end of this debate will be about and nothing else. Therefore, if Fianna Fáil members are voting in support of that kind of conduct they should let their reasons be known to the people who elected them.
There is no doubt that the rank and file of Fianna Fáil members of this House were in a state of shock when this news became known to them. We know they were suffering from shock, but it is very difficult to know whether it was the shock of having to face a possible general election or shock at what was revealed. I do not know which really shocked them more. However, when they found they were able to close the ranks and that there would not be a general election, they recovered from the shock. Perhaps it did not concern them or shock them at all that these revelations by the Taoiseach should have been made. Of course, the decision of the Fianna Fáil Party on this matter is quite beside the point. It was not a condemnation of the activity of the dismissed or resigned Ministers. It was a decision giving the Taoiseach power to appoint certain people to the Government and that was the decision that was conveyed through the Press to the public.
We do not know yet whether the Fianna Fáil Party accepted the allegations made, whether they have said they are right or wrong. What we want in this unfortunate affair is the truth. We have heard many versions. We have heard further statements here quoted by Deputy Bruton which differ from statements made from the Government benches even this evening. We have heard the Taoiseach's statements. We have heard the statements of the dismissed Ministers and the resigned Minister. They are completely at variance. Either the Taoiseach is wrong or the former Ministers are wrong. According to the Fianna Fáil Party both groups are right. Nobody is wrong in Fianna Fáil.
The Taoiseach says the Minister for Justice was not asked to resign, but Deputy Boland says he felt the Minister was asked to resign. Then the Fianna Fáil Party say they are both right. There has been this attitude right through this debate in which the Taoiseach was acclaimed for his statement. The former Minister for Local Government received claps—of approval, I presume—this morning. The former Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries received claps of approval this evening. Therefore we wonder what kind of spell is hanging over the Fianna Fáil Party at the present time. The statement made by the former Parliamentary Secretary was probably the most straightforward and honest statement of the lot, when he came clean and said he resigned out of loyalty to the strong Republican principles of the dismissed Ministers.
What amazes me is the smugness and glibness of the Fianna Fáil members in this whole affair. They seem to think nothing has happened, that nothing wrong or bad can happen in Fianna Fáil, that they are infallible and that the public have a very for giving attitude to them. It may be that the public have a forgiving and forgetting attitude to the actions of Fianna Fáil but on the present issues I do not think the public will have such an attitude to them. That is what frightens the party at present and holds them together, saying: "We will cling to one another. If we let go we will drown." That is indicative of the present mood of Fianna Fáil.
When Fianna Fáil are really in trouble Deputy Joe Dowling is thrown in to divert attention. This happened again tonight. With his usual farseeing intellect he tried to make light of the situation, tried to attribute false motives to people on this side of the House. He also referred in a critical way to the Garda Síochána. He seemed to be very annoyed that, according to him, a member of the Garda Síochána betrayed the Fianna Fáil Party.
The Garda Síochána belong to the nation, not to any party, be it the party in power or a party in opposition. I was frightened by the attitude of Deputy Dowling on this question. He seemed to be of the opinion that a member of the Garda Síochána who, in the pursuit of his duty, co-operated in any way with anybody other than the Fianna Fáil Party was betraying the force. This is a very sad commentary. This is a comment that should not have been passed and that should be withdrawn by the Deputy. He went so far as to accuse a member of the Garda Síochána of selling information. Of course, this is so ridiculous that I suppose I should not refer to it at all, but the fact is that it has been placed on the record of the House and it should be categorically denied that this is so. This is another attempt to divert attention from the real issues involved in this case.
Deputy Dowling also spoke of important social measures being held up by this debate. This debate is not of our making. It arises because of the alleged activities of members of the Cabinet and it is our duty to get the full facts, the real truth. I am certain that if we had got the real truth this debate would not have been so prolonged. Unless we get the real truth damage will be done to economic, industrial and tourist development. These accusations, left without proper and full explanation, will damage the country.
Therefore, I would impress upon the Taoiseach the importance of letting us have all the facts, all the truth. I would impress also on all the rank and file members of the Fianna Fáil Party that they should realise the issue they are voting on when eventually they go into the division lobbies. It is not simply a question of appointing certain Members to be Ministers. The question is far deeper and graver than that. There are some aspects even of the appointment of Ministers that should be and could be discussed in the House but all these matters are overshadowed by the facts revealed by the Taoiseach.
There is one thing that strikes me in the appointment of Ministers and the reshuffle of Ministries. I find, possibly in the confusion and hurry, the Department of Social Welfare is reconnected with the Department of Labour. We spent hours debating in this House and it was agreed on all sides that the Department of Labour should be separate from the Department of Social Welfare. After hours of debate and agreement on this vital question of divorcing these two sections of the Administration we find that in this confusion a backward step is taken and the Departments are linked once again. That is only a very small matter vis-à-vis the major issue before the House. We will welcome another opportunity to talk about that and other shortcomings in the Cabinet changes. Deputies should not cast a silent vote on the issue before the House tonight but should let their voices be heard.
Comment on this
I rise to contribute to this debate because I represent a constituency that contributed in a big way to the freedom we have in this country today, suffered a great deal and did not get much satisfaction. Did I ever think that a situation would arise in which the people would be sold down the drain by an Irish Government? Did I ever think that a Government, full of power, full of arrogance, that controlled every issue in the country, that controlled the Civil Service, the Garda Síochána, the Army and the Fianna Fáil people, would be in this position? All that they went in to govern were the Fianna Fáil supporters. They never thought anything of the rest of the people who in their eyes were West Britons, people with whom they should not be concerned, people who should not be here, who should be exported. Their sole aim was and is to govern on behalf of Fianna Fáil. We find them at the height of their power, with everything under control, and now the bubble bursts.
What do the Irish people think today of a Government having that power putting the people in this position? Wherever we go we see that the people are stunned. It is no wonder that they are. They are stunned because they thought that the Government, 50 years after we got our freedom, would not let the country slip into this position. Surely the Government had experience. They had the example of other countries. They had the power. They had the influence. It has come out quite clearly now that members of the Government were well aware of what was happening, not today or yesterday, but months back. I am very sorry to say that they neglected to do their duty to the people. They have done untold harm to the country, to its economy, to its tourist industry and to everything on which it depends. They have, for their own ends, sold out the country. No wonder they are afraid to resign. They know full well that, if they faced the people again, the answer they would get is "No". The people are no fools. They gave them a chance. They took the chance and they played with the people's interests.
Comment on this
I do not think I have ever interrupted a speaker here and the Deputy from the Atlantic shelf can keep his mouth shut while I am speaking. Here we have a case of the highest Ministers of State involved in the sordid affair of buying arms from a communist country. What links do they have with that country? The members of the Labour Party spoke the truth when they said at the last general election they were painted pink and even red; it was said they were not fit to be in control of the country. Here we have Ministers of State, or their agents, going into Czechoslovakia and buying arms for importation into this country. For what reason—to start a war that would ruin the country for generations to come? These same Ministers and this same Taoiseach at the Fianna Fáil Ard-Fheis recently adopted a motion whereby they agreed that the only way left to bring in the North was through tolerance and agreement. They did not keep to that motion very long. Not alone did they deny the party the right it had, but they took the very ground from under it.
I listened to Deputy Blaney speaking here today, a solid Republican. I remember for over 40 years, before every general election, we had them marching on the North. It was always the day before the election. Nothing ever happened after the election. They were marching for the North every general election with the glint of battle in their eyes, but it was like the old song—tomorrow never came. I wonder if Deputy Blaney would have been half as aggressive in the Bogside as he was down in Killarney with his supporters the night of the election. Killarney was a safer place to do battle than inside the Bogside.
I heard an ex-Fianna Fáil Deputy boast recently about how they got into power. It was no news to me for I was well aware of it. He said: "I went into my local booth in the morning and I asked the presiding officer how many votes were cast and he said ten. I got the block and I stamped the lot and put them all together and put them in. `Come out now,' sez I, `and I will stand you a drink. Your job is done.' "
Comment on this
They got into office by intimidation and personation and that is known to the people.
Comment on this
I know what the Deputy is wearing all right and I am telling him that the people of this country will know what he and every one of the Deputies over there are wearing before the week is out.
I am sorry that Deputy Haughey was involved in this. He has denied it and I will not prejudge him. I am sorry he is involved. He was an excellent Parliamentarian and a likeable man. He will be a great loss to this Parliament, but I can tell some of the others that I am not a damn bit sorry for them because, when I put down a question last week here about a gentleman who was taking out nationalisation, and the only qualification he had was vilification of one of Ireland's greatest men, I got no satisfaction of any kind; he got his nationalisation but I can assure you he is not a Republican.
The people will judge Fianna Fáil on what Fianna Fáil have done. They gave Fianna Fáil power. Fianna Fáil told them it was the only party fit to rule. What will the people say now? What can they say? The answer is there in front of them in black and white. Fianna Fáil are not capable of ruling. Fianna Fáil has done something that this country will never forget, something never done in this country since it achieved its independence.
Comment on this
The best thing to do with the like of the Deputy opposite is to ignore him. I would ask the Taoiseach to consider seriously the position. I would appeal to him not to prolong the agony for himself and his party but to go up to the Park while there is yet time and not keep the poor old gentleman up there waiting for him. I appeal to him to hand over his seal of office and let the people decide forthwith what type of Government they want.
Comment on this
Go dtí seo a dhíospóireacht tá daoine ag caitheamh droch-mheas ar a chéile agus sin á dhéanamh acu in ainm na tíre. Ó thosnaigh an díospóireacht seo táthar á rá gur ceart grá a bheith againn ar na daoine sna Sé Contaethe, gur ceart aitheantas a thabhairt don Phrotastúnach, don Chaitiliceach, don duine bán agus don duine gorm. Ar an dtaobh eile den scéal, níor stad lucht an Fhreasúra de bheith ag masladh na dTeachtaí atá ar na bínsí seo. Conas is féidir leo a bheith dáiríre faoi thuiscint nó faoi ghrá, grá pearsanta nó grá tíre, muna mbíonn ar siúl acu san am gcéanna ach an masladh? Glacaimse go bhfuil gach éinne anso chomh díograsach liom féin maidir leis an tír. Glacaimse gurb é mian gach Éireannaigh saoirse a bheith againn lá éigin agus go dtiocfaidh an tsaoirse sin go síochánta. Nior mhaith liom go ndoirtfí fuil ar bith chun an tsiocháin sin a bhaint amach. Bá mhaith liom féin siúl síos Sráid Uí Chonaill leis na daoine is dúire mBéal Feirste agus greim láimhe againn ar a chéile.
I have listened with as much patience as possible to the many contributions that have been made to this debate which on the surface would appear to be on a motion regarding the appointment of new Ministers but which, for reasons best known to other speakers, they have utilised to indicate their ideas of what Irish freedom should be. We have had long journeys into genealogy, history and party affiliations each man trying to establish, he would have us believe, what he thought should be done in the cause of Irish freedom. I have heard speakers indulge in what they called charity; appealing to this side of the House for tolerance, telling us how intolerant we were, trying to convince us that they were the sole guardians of minorities here, there and everywhere while simultaneously indulging in a form of intolerance and cruelty to people who sit here such as I have never heard before. There is not much point in talking about tolerance and preaching about it when by your very utterances you show you have no interest in it.
I only mention this as an indication as to why I cannot accept the contributions I have heard. I see Deputy O'Higgins opposite me now and he reminds me of his contribution which, in the main, was fair political comment. On the other hand, in a situation where he was preaching about the tolerance and concern and the regard which we should feel for our fellowmen in the North I do not know why he should have pointed his finger towards Deputy Boland and expressed what I consider to be rather personal ill-will and an ill-wish, politically at least.
I listened to Deputy Keating who stood up full of self-righteousness and would have us accept him as the custodian of all that was proper in our attitude towards our fellowman and at the same time I heard him indulge in a form of cynicism and criticism that gives me to think he is well versed and educated in the art of doing the mean thing gracefully. I saw him, during Deputy Dowling's contribution, sitting back, sneering and sniggering and looking to the gallery and looking around trying to make little of Deputy Dowling.
I cite these instances, not in any special criticism of the Deputies concerned, but as indications of their insincerity and reluctance to practise what they preach. Unfortunately, I missed Deputy Bruton's contribution but I am sure that like other members of his party he told us how concerned he was for genuine Irish freedom. I imagine he would associate himself with his fellow-speakers who told us how concerned they were about removing Partition. Mentally at least, I am sure he agrees with all the heroic offerings we got from that side of the House.
As an indication of Deputy Bruton's insincerity I refer to the debate on the Estimate for the Department of Justice when he endeavoured to make the point that it was a waste of time for members of the Garda to have to learn the Irish language. He said this after making a rather elequent and telling case for persons needing psychiatric treatment, such as prisoners. He told us how we should be organised to look after them and protect them. But during his contribution, especially when he said he did not see why gardaí should have to know the Irish language, I interrupted, as reported at column 131 of the Official Report of 2nd December, and asked what I hoped was a reasonable undisturbing question and to me a very important one: "Does the Deputy deny me my Constitutional right to talk to a garda in the Irish language?" There was nothing emotional, passionate or incorrect about that. I suggest I was speaking on behalf of many Irish people.
Comment on this
Knowledge of Irish is not required for entering this House. Why should it be required for entering the Garda Síochána?
Comment on this
Deputy Bruton replied: "I deny the Deputy the right to expect the garda to have to listen to him." He was followed, as I said before, by his foster-father, Deputy Garret FitzGerald, with a resounding "Hear, hear." These are the people who will tell us of their interest in the North, tell us the great heroes they are, how they are hungering for Irish freedom, for tolerance and for the day when we will have a 32-County Republic. What are they hungering for if in that Republic a citizen cannot, if he so desires, at least speak to a member of the Garda in the Irish language?
The Taoiseach indicated to this House that because of certain information he had to hand he felt obliged to take certain action. That to me was a very responsible statement by the Taoiseach. I do not think he prejudged the situation in any way. It is quite obvious from the contributions made by the Opposition that they prejudged it. They have already convicted. I am surprised that the Opposition with so many legal men, having regard to the special circumstances of the announcement, did not hold their fire until they had more information.
I regret if anything I said disturbs anyone on the Opposition benches. That was not my intention. My intention was, if I could in my inexperienced way perhaps, to give them my honest reaction to what I heard since the debate began. They expressed certain fears about the situation as they saw it, about what would happen in the country and about the dangers and damage that might ensue. I could read in quite a few of their contributions what I consider to be wishful thinking rather than any genuine fears.
I do not know what happens in the field of politics. I do not understand the situation in which a special licence is given to a politician to twist certain words and to denigrate virtues. I do not think that should happen. That has been happening.
Deputy Pattison suggested that we seem to fear a general election arising from what has occurred. I personally have no such fears nor do I imagine there are any such fears on these benches. From my chats with people around the House before this debate took place I consider that the round of applause which was given to the contribution made by the leader of the Opposition was given because no general election will take place. That was after they had heard that the Fianna Fáil Party were united, as they feared ultimately but hoped not for the present, and that there would be no general election.
Comment on this
The disclosures of the past few days will stand forever as a shocking indictment of the Taoiseach and his management of this country. These events will stand as a monument of inefficiency and mismanagement. I say this with regret. Indeed, in his present dilemma, which is most unenviable, the Taoiseach has my deepest sympathy. Under his leadership lawlessness goes unchecked and revolutionaries are proving an ever-growing menace to our society.
Within the short space of three years our balance of payments has swung from a surplus of £15 million to an estimated deficit of £60 million. Prices are increasing more rapidly than in other OECD countries with the exception of Iceland, Yugoslavia and Portugal. Our national debt stands at the highest ever peak at nearly £1,100 million requiring nearly £100 million to service it annually. Now our Government are disgraced in the eyes of the world. There are allegations of conspiracy and counter-conspiracy. There are plots to import arms illegally and these plots involve Cabinet Ministers.
The Taoiseach tells us that they have unanimity within their ranks. Fianna Fáil say this after their famous 6 o'clock party meeting. Members were supposed to have given their leader a unanimous vote of confidence. What hypocrisy. It is obvious that at that famous 6 o'clock meeting the gauntlet was thrown down. The ultimatum was issued. They had to stand together or face political suicide by going to the country. At that meeting the strongest of all animal instincts prevailed, the instinct of self-preservation. Self-preservation was the order of the day and the dissident groups concurred.
Why did they do so? Because if their own party could cling to power they would still be Members of this House of the Oireachtas. They would be backbenchers in the Government party, ideally situated to continue their intrigues and their plots. If there were a general election I do not think there could be any doubt but that the Fine Gael Party would be returned to power and a full-scale investigation would be carried out. These men who are alleged to have betrayed this country would stand subject to the laws which they themselves enacted. No man can stand above the law. No man can flout the law.
The Taoiseach above all men must show total and absolute respect for the law. These men must be arraigned before the courts of the land. They must be judged on the allegations and the prima facie case now held against them. What is happening at the moment? There is a total lack of credence in most statements that are being made at present. The Taoiseach tells us he has a prima facie case. The former Government Ministers involved refute this categorically.
In this evening's edition of the Evening Herald the former Minister for Finance is quoted as saying:
I have not had the opportunity to examine or test such information or the quality of its source or sources.
In the meantime, however, I now categorically state that at no time have I taken part in any illegal importation or attempted importation of arms into this country.
Where is the Taoiseach's prima facie case? Why was the former Minister for Finance, Deputy Haughey, dismissed from his Cabinet post? The allegations too have been denied by the former Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries. Again the Taoiseach maintained that he had a prima facie case against these people. It would now appear that the Taoiseach has known of these developments within his Cabinet and within his Government for a considerable time. I quote from This Week. In the edition of 15th May it is alleged that the Taoiseach was told some time in August or September of last year that Deputy Blaney was in close contact with the northern command of the IRA. The Taoiseach apparently ignored these intelligence reports. It is stated that the next intelligence report which reached him was more alarming. It indicated that men who were known to be members of the IRA council in Dublin had been in consultation with both Deputy Blaney and Deputy Haughey in the city, not once but several times, and that they had met the two Ministers separately and together. It was also alleged that Deputy J. Gibbons had reports from Army sources that the connection between the IRA council and the two Cabinet Ministers was being continued.
Captain Kelly, who resigned his commission, has stated this evening that Deputy J. Gibbons was totally involved. He said that Deputy J. Gibbons was aware of his work and commended him for it. The Taoiseach, who has made no statement whatsoever about Deputy J. Gibbons, intends to appoint him to a very senior Cabinet position. The Taoiseach is asking us to support him in that move. Until the Taoiseach comes out and categorically denies that Deputy J. Gibbons was in any way implicated in the alleged importation of arms I shall certainly oppose him. This matter appears to me to be much more serious than would appear from the way in which it was being treated by certain Members of this House who have indulged tonight in a comic opera. I ask the Taoiseach whether any of these arms have been imported. To whom were these arms given? Were they given, as has been alleged, to subversive groups who were determined to disrupt the organs of State and the whole structure of our society?
We have been told that all the attention has been directed towards the defence of our defenceless people in Northern Ireland. Was it intended to send armed members of an illegal organisation over the Border? Was this the intention of the dismissed Cabinet Ministers? Has any consideration been given to our Army in case of such an eventuality? Were the Army lines to be infiltrated before this was to take place? One might ask which was to come first, the north or the south. Was there, and is there, a plan for a massive military coup in the Republic to be followed possibly by armed intervention in Northern Ireland? Perhaps it was to be vice versa. Maybe it was to be simultaneous in both places.
These are serious possibilities which must be examined. What action has the Taoiseach taken against these people in respect of whom, he maintains, he has a prima facie case? He has allowed them to continue as backbenchers in his own Oireachtas Party. I should like to ask the Taoiseach to give this House and the people an assurance that a full, relentless investigation will be carried out and that, if these men are guilty of treachery, they will face the courts of the land. These ex-Ministers have not admitted any culpability. Instead they have made speeches in this House to whip up misguided, emotional Republicanism, to which youth is particularly susceptible. I submit this exploitation of the youth of our country is misguided. They are inexperienced and irrational. Many of them are going through a phase that most of us with very proud republican traditions went through when we were young. Most of us had the intellectual capacity to reason out our Republicanism and to realise that the day of the gun was gone. Nothing can ever again be achieved in Ireland at the point of a gun.
It is frustrating to try to analyse the motivation for these plots and intrigues on the part of former Ministers who have been charged, not alone by Deputies but also by their own Taoiseach, with these activities. If this is what they call Republicanism, then to me it is perverted Republicanism. If this is what they call Nationalism, it is perverted Nationalism. How can they reconcile Republicanism in the purely Irish context of complete and absolute separation from Britain with our total, absolute and ever-growing monetary dependence on Britain? I should very much like to hear them give an explanation.
These ex-Ministers, if the charges are true, would arm a certain section of the community in north-east Ireland. I firmly believe they would do exactly the same here in southern Ireland: they would arm subversive groups bent on the destruction of all the organs of our State. Those of us who are rational about north-east Ireland can well appreciate that many of our people in that area do not wish to join us at the moment—some of them, because they belong to a privileged class, a class of vested interests, others because they have been alienated by the bitterness, hate, bigotry and prejudice instilled into them for over half a century. Still others have been alienated because they enjoy far better social services there than we can offer them here.
What, if the allegations are true, would these ex-Ministers have us do? Force them down to come within our jurisdiction at the point of a gun—and they would do this in the name of Republicanism. They would do this in the name of Nationalism. What a perversion of those two glorious words.
I do not think the Taoiseach should be exonerated of all culpability because, to me, he is guilty by association; he is guilty by default. He made no move against those ex-Ministers until he was forced to do so by the leader of our party, Deputy Cosgrave.
The Taoiseach, I submit, has become contaminated by the arrogance of his own Cabinet. It is quite disgusting for me, as a new Deputy in this House, to witness the disdain and the contempt with which even supplementary questions are treated in this House. It is an appalling spectacle because, no matter how simple they appear to be, particularly in the context of the national scene, they are important to some people—people in many cases merely looking for their rights.
The Parliamentary question is, for most of us, the only means we have of making serious inquiries in this House. These, as I said, are very often treated with contempt. The Taoiseach has tolerated this attitude. He has tolerated this behaviour since I have come into this House. I must say I am most disappointed in him. He had many warning signs of impending events of a very serious nature and he failed to take any action whatsoever. Now, he continues to keep these men, who may, as I have said, and not with any levity, be guilty of treason. I understand treason to be such a serious crime that the death penalty still applies.
The Taoiseach owes a responsibility to the people who have placed trust and confidence in him. This responsibility can only be fulfilled by going to the people and letting them decide whether or not they wish him to continue with the mandate they gave him in the last general election. For the moment, the troubles in this country are being pushed under the table. They are being sneered at; they are being made a joke of. I submit that this country at the moment is in a very serious plight—and the crisis has not passed. There is no doubt about it but, under continued Fianna Fáil Government, it will again raise its ugly head.
The Taoiseach now has a glorious opportunity of explaining fully the state of this country. The people, I am sure, demand it. If we are to make any progress, this absolutely revolting mess must be cleaned up once and for all. If we are to make any advancement whatsoever the co-operation and goodwill of every working man and woman must be sought. The true state of our economy should be exposed, no matter how painful it may be. The people should be told—not in a hypocritical way—what disasters are pending. The Taoiseach should tell the country—indeed he should tell the world—what has in fact happened. He should stop the speculation which is rife at the moment. I sincerely wish he would do it for his own sake, for the sake of his party, for the sake of all parties in this House—indeed, for the sake of the country as a whole.
Comment on this
I rise to speak at this somewhat late hour because I feel that everyone in this House, no matter to what political party he belongs, should express his opinion, on what has happened here. Let us make no mistake about what has happened here. It will have vast repercussions on us in every sphere. Anyone who has been abroad as much as I have—surely the Minister for External Affairs, Deputy Dr. Hillery, will agree with me on this—knows that many people regard Ireland as just one unit. Already the repercussions of what has taken place in the Six Counties have had a considerably adverse effect on us here. On top on that, suddenly this explosion bursts on the country—not unexpected from this side of the House but certainly unexpected by the followers of the political party in power today. The thoughts of many people must be directed to the fact that what has happened in the Six Counties is likely to happen here. Already, not having escaped the repercussions of the disasters in the north, we place ourselves in a very perilous position here. I belong to a political family who have had the honour of representing this country formerly in the British Parliament before we had our own Constitution and Government here, and subsequently here, since the inception of this State.
This is one of the most serious issues to face the country. Like other speakers, I do not think we have seen the end of the revelations and the disasters. I do not think that any Fianna Fáil Deputy knows exactly the extent to which this rot has permeated the Government. It is all very well for the Government to say they are a united party, but this morning we witnessed what, in my opinion, was a most disgraceful exhibition when two former Ministers came in here and practically accused the leader of their party of telling lies. One could put no other construction on the matter but that either the leader of the party was telling lies or they were, because both had a different story. What are we to believe and what is the country to believe? However, this is not the real issue. The real issue, the important issue, is that the prestige of this Parliament has been lowered not only in this country but throughout the world. Like everybody belonging to me, I am, and always have been, a constitutional Nationalist. I would do anything to defend democracy, to defend the right of free speech and to defend the right of individuals to live their lives in peace.
We reached a dangerous situation—the Government may deny it if they wish—when the Garda Síochána were afraid to act because they had not the force of authority behind them. We reached a situation in which members of the Government in a position of trust were at variance with their leader, although I am glad to say that both men came in here today and attempted to make an amende honorable by saying that they do not believe in physical force. However, there can be no doubt but that the statements made by them have been conducive to revolution. In such event, it is the ordinary people of the country who suffer. I know that because, as I have said, all my people were constitutional Nationalists. We were caught in the 1922 split of the physical force movement when there was pillage, plunder and lack of order. It was then that the late Mr. W.T. Cosgrave, the former President of the Executive Council, took charge and re-established law and order. Forty years later it fell to his son to discover what was going on within the Government and to make that information known to the Taoiseach. If it were not for that, I am convinced that the Government would not have gone so far as they have now gone and that they had no intention of doing anything.
I do not accuse the Taoiseach of being a dishonest man but I accuse him of being a weak and complacent man because he allowed these happenings to build up gradually under his control. One can only hope that, having at last decided on what is necessary, the Government will eradicate these festering sores and endeavour to govern. One can only hope, also, that the Taoiseach will have the force of personality to continue to govern.
Many speakers have suggested that the Government should resign. In that case we would be faced with a general election. I wish now to express an opinion, but I must make it clear that this is my own personal opinion. I and as I am sure, in their own way, the majority of Deputies in the House place or should place the nation before a party. They should realise that, above everything else, the safety, the life and the freedom of the individual must come first. Although the full facts are not at present available, I believe that underground forces may still be at work and that, if Dáil Éireann were to be dissolved, we could face an election such as the election of 1918, which I am old enough to remember. At that election the gun was used; people voted under the threat of the gun. As a youngster at that time I was a supporter of the Redmondite Party, the party which upheld constitutional methods. If Dáil Éireann were to be dissolved at this time I can envisage the use of the gun again, but this time the gun would not be used against the Redmondite Party but against the Government and against all lawfully constituted candidates seeking election to Dáil Éireann.
The Taoiseach has acted, but he acted belatedly. I would ask him now to show the courage of his convictions, to have the moral courage to govern, because it is no use trying to cover up the irregularities that exist.
Our Parliament and our nation are in danger. The prestige of this Parliament has been greatly lowered by the vacillating action of the Government. I hate speaking on a debate such as this and I hate referring directly to individuals but I consider it to be the duty of every Deputy to assert the right of a free people in a free Parliament. In the world of today, where there are so many disturbances and revolutions, such as they have on the campuses in America, all the people have to fall back on is a democratically elected Parliament. Therefore, I say to the Government that they should have the guts to govern—they have not shown them so far—and to honour the memory of all who served and fought in the past for freedom. They should remember that the fight for Irish freedom did not start in 1916. There is no monopoly of patriotism on the Fianna Fáil benches, because there are as good and better Irishmen on this side of the House as ever sat on the Fianna Fáil benches.
Although I am a constitutional Nationalist, I honour the memory of people like Collins, although such men were physical force men. At the same time, they laid down their lives so that this Parliament could be set up and so that the Irish people could live in peace and comfort.
Let Fianna Fáil take heed of what has happened. I do not know for how long they will be able to continue in power, but I express the personal opinion that it is their duty to stay in office and to govern, as it is also their duty to clear up the mess that exists and thereby ensure that all those who have contributed so much to this country may raise our Parliamentary standards again, so that Ireland may continue to be in the future as she was in the past: a democratic Parliament, upholding the rights of the individual regardless of what may be his political affiliations.
Comment on this
I have had the honour of being a Member of this Dáil since 1961. At all times I have been very conscious of the special privilege which membership of this Parliament confers on anybody who has been fortunate enough to have been elected to it. I have listened in this debate to passionate and emotional speeches from the opposite side of the House in which the words "Republicanism" and "patriotism" have been bandied about. There has been a deliberate attempt by the Fianna Fáil Party, not for the first time, to convey to the people the impression that patriotism and nationalism are virtues to which only Fianna Fáil can lay claim.
There are Deputies in this party who can validly and rightly lay claim to close family associations with the struggle for freedom and independence. There are Deputies in this party, like the distinguished leader of this party, whose father and close relatives were members of this Parliament, who helped to lay the foundations of this State, who helped to lay the foundations of the democratic institutions which we enjoy today. I am proud to be one of those Deputies who have family connections right back to the early days of this State and to this Parliament.
I regarded this Parliament as a serious place where serious business was to be transacted and during almost nine years membership of this Parliament I have never indulged in personal abuse nor in any type of mudslinging. I have deplored it on many occasions because I felt that Parliament was a place where the nation's business was to be transacted and where the Members were expected and obliged to devote their time, their attention and their energies, whether as ordinary Deputies or members of the Government, to this task.
I have been shocked, dismayed and disillusioned that such things as have come to light over the past few days could happen in a free Parliament in a democracy such as ours. I am particularly shattered to find, and it is a tragic and terrible thing, that there are men who have been elected to membership of this Parliament, who have occupied the highest office in this land, who have abused their rights, their privileges and their power in the manner in which these men have done.
I was in my own constituency of Limerick city yesterday and the reaction there of the ordinary person was one of shock and dismay. The reaction of the citizens was well expressed in a banner headline in this weekend's issue of our local newspaper—the Limerick Leader. The banner headline contained only three words: “The Nation Reels”. People have been shocked and dismayed by the terrible things that have come to light. The reaction of the ordinary person—and as I have often said I regard myself as being privileged and honoured to represent, as an ordinary plain person myself, the ordinary people in my constituency —was “How could such terrible things take place? How could such things happen? How could men who have been elected to the highest office in this land stoop to such folly?” These were some of the reactions which I found among ordinary men and women in the constituency I have represented for almost nine years.
The extraordinary thing is that the two members of the Government who have been dismissed from office—Deputies Blaney and Haughey—were two members of the Government who had built around them the aura, the mystique and the glamour of the modern whiz-kid, leaders of the jet set, outstanding men who have been held up to the people and particularly to the youth by the media of communication as being outstanding examples of modern, progressive, hard-headed, nononsense politicians, men who have been able to manipulate the media of communication in such a way that they projected an image of modern Irish patriotism. One of them was described on many occasions as "the golden boy of Irish politics". The same man was recently described in this House by a former journalist who is now a member of the Dáil as "a much maligned man". I refer to the former Minister for Finance, Deputy Charles Haughey.
It pains me to think that we have reached the situation that we have reached here tonight. No matter how we may dislike the uglier aspects of public life or politics facts are facts and we must state our views. I believe the Taoiseach stands tonight before this nation as the leader of a Government irreparably discredited and holding on to office now through fear. The Taoiseach must remember that for a number of years now he has been the leader of a Government which contains members whose names have been synonymous with high living, with high spending, with land speculation and with property deals. This has not just taken place in Dublin. We know all about it in Limerick too. The Taoiseach has been the leader of a Government which has operated the diabolical patronage system known as Taca. The Taoiseach has also, as we have learned in the past 48 hours, been the leader of a Government which contains men who have now been exposed by the leader of this party as gunrunners. It is a well-known philosophical dictum that power corrupts but absolute power corrupts absolutely. I believe this is what happened in the present case.