We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Confidence in Taoiseach and Government: Motion (Resumed).

Contributions 116–267 of 267. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

And one of these did a double shuffle.

Comment on this

There are 75.

Comment on this

Some bright young men who changed their minds overnight.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Desmond should cease interrupting.

Comment on this

There is no way of knowing how we can measure the extent of the support for the Taoiseach within the Fianna Fáil Party. Obviously, there are those within the party who consider that the unity of the party — whatever they mean by that— must be achieved with the removal of the Taoiseach. They wish to do it, however, without the intervention of a general election; they wish to keep their assassination within the party and away from the people. They do not wish to consult the people on this matter but to do their own assassination——

Comment on this

In our own good time we will do that.

Comment on this

Perfect.

Comment on this
A Deputy

That is the best admission we have heard.

Comment on this

After the vote.

Comment on this

In opening this debate the Taoiseach said that there was now a volume of opinion abroad that this would be a propitious time for Fianna Fáil to go to the country. He said that last week. It may be. Nobody in the Opposition, as far as I know, knows the mind of the electorate. We are quite modest in our demands tonight: we merely ask the Government to give the people an opportunity of judging these late events, judging their confidence in this Government. The Taoiseach may well be right: we know the excellent intelligence service at his disposal. It may be a propitious time for him. We invite him: please, in the name of democracy, go before the people and let us have authoritatively the voice and mandate and wishes of the people. We are not saying there will be a victory for any element of the Opposition in this general election. We are merely making the request in the name of the people and saying: "Let us have this general election; let the people decide".

After the verdict the kind of Government that finally emerges will also be decided by the people in its shape and composition and if the cynical estimate of Fianna Fáil is correct, that what has been exposed in the past few months, is not remarkable — the loss of £100,000 voted in this Parliament and gone God knows where under false names, scrambled telephone conversations and all the sordid manoeuvring and intrigue that has been regurgitated in the press in recent weeks, and all these events — if it is their cynical estimate that the people take that as a matter of course, and that such is their attitude to standards in public life, Fianna Fáil will be returned here and some people in the Opposition may be surprised.

The democratic system and the Parliament of which we are all Members is also based on a matter of trust. The authority we gain from the people is a fragile thing. It is trust between the elected representatives and the people and it is my opinion that the fragile bond has been broken by this Administration and that in fact they must now renew their mandate in a general election.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

It is not enough that the Government have this majority, that they have these reluctant voters—that in fact is what they are — here tonight. I do not know of any better name for the kind of voting the Taoiseach will get here tonight than simple political blackmail. That is what these Deputies are subjecting themselves to tonight. Fianna Fáil is a party expert in formulae. Traditionally, it has managed to wriggle through many formulae and still see integrity at the end of the tunnel. I understand that. Theology has been a strong point with that party but I put this to them. Deputy Boland, a member of their own party, a pillar of their organisation, architect of their victory last year — the Taoiseach was not the architect; the man who got down into the earthworks and arranged the contested areas and carved up the country was Deputy Boland — spoke here clearly and said that he could see no way out of his dilemma: he could not see himself voting for this Administration, either for the Taoiseach or the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries. Did none of those present hear his heart cry yesterday when he said: Give me a good reason. I do not wish to depart from this Fianna Fáil Party where I have worked for so many years. I would still like to continue supporting this party. Please give me some evidence why in fact I should continue to do so. Give me some proof that the Fianna Fáil Party is the party I worked in, day in, day out, month by month and year by year?

The Taoiseach will totally demean his office and this Parliament if later tonight he comes here and gives us another soft-spoken alibi and once more evades the questions raised in this debate. I do not know what the inner planners — if there are any left in the Cabinet or party opposite — have dreamed up for either tomorrow or the next few months but I say that at some stage the party will have to face the electorate. This majority will not go on indefinitely and the mutiny in the party will not be stilled by any formulae or votes of confidence. If they have decided to fight this out among themselves at some stage an election will interrupt their quarrel. At some stage the people's voice and judgment will be heard on all these events. I recommend to the party opposite a saying taken from—I could probably nearly say the New Testament—"The One Hundred Best Sayings of Éamon de Valera: letter to John Dillon, January 30th, 1918"—those blooming days when all was integrity——: "We ought not allow ourselves to be manoeuvred into professing a loyalty which we cannot feel —" words from the master.

I would recommend to those followers of Éamon de Valera, if there are any in the party opposite, those words: "We ought not allow ourselves to be manoeuvred into professing a loyalty which we cannot feel". Deputy Boland does not intend to be manoeuvred into a loyalty he does not feel. I do not know how many Deputies in the party opposite, because of the double-barrelled threat of a general election, will allow themselves to be manoeuvred into a loyalty they do not feel to the Taoiseach, his Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries and other members of his Cabinet. I recommend to them that statement by the founder of their party. They may save themselves from a general election. They may troop faithfully into the Division Lobby, but finally it is the people who will judge the kind of loyalty they have to the Taoiseach. It is time we had a cleansing operation. It is time the people spoke. It is time their verdict was heard. It is time to end this circus.

Comment on this

It is provided by the Constitution in Article 28, sub-paragraph 10, that a Taoiseach who loses the confidence of the Dáil shall resign. There is no question of his having a discretion as to whether he does or does not do the honourable thing. The Constitution—and, in this regard, there was a repetition of a provision which is as old as parlimentary democracy—makes it clear that once a Taoiseach, a Prime Minister, is seen to have lost the confidence of the elected House, then out he will go. It is well to remember this Constitutional provision because the reality of this motion, which Dáil Éireann will decide tonight, is that the present Taoiseach, realising that he had lost irreparably the confidence of a sufficient number of Deputies in his own party, sufficient to bring into operation the Constitutional provisions requiring him to resign his office, is now forcing the dissidents, out of fear, to behave like mice instead of like men.

The Taoiseach never enjoyed the confidence of the Deputies on your right, a Cheann Comhairle. He enjoyed, or appeared to enjoy, the confidence of a sufficient number of Deputies on your left until these events with which this debate has been concerned broke into public notice. Realising what the machinery of the Constitution requires, he is now exercising one of the most contemptible devices known to the frightened politician and that is to spread his fear amongst those who might harm or injure him. Of course it will succeed. No less than an hour ago we saw evidence of that. Behind the Taoiseach tonight, up into that Lobby, will walk men who have conspired against him——

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

——men who distrust him——

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

——men who dislike him, men who even hate him. But they they will walk up behind him into that Lobby tonight. Behind him also will walk men, groups, who have conspired against each other, who distrust each other, who dislike and even hate each other. They will all walk in the same direction with a sick unity of purpose as an united party because, on this one issue and for this one moment, in abject humiliation, they are all together from the Taoiseach down to the lowest Fianna Fáil Deputy: they are all united because of the common fear of a dissolution of this Dáil and being brought before the people.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

And so, tonight, at half past ten, we will have a great display of unity in the Fianna Fáil Party —the dreadful, cold, clammy unity of fear.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

Let those who take part in this charade remember that those who have plotted will continue to plot. Those who have been wielding hatchets and who have ostensibly buried them today will, when tonight is over, brush away the soil and take out their hatchets once the fear is removed. But what is subverted tonight will come inevitably sooner or later.

There is a third party involved in all this. There are the people outside who look to this House and look at it, who look to the Leader of this House and who expect a certain standard of conduct from those who are entrusted freely and honourably by them with the control of our democracy. They have witnessed the sorry, pathetic spectacle of the inner fighting and the inner feuding inside the Fianna Fáil Party for many years now, for so many years that it has become a national scandal. It did not start when, in his dressing gown, Deputy Charles Haughey, without notice to him apparently, but with plenty of notice to the TV cameras and the press reporters, was arrested and brought down to the Bridewell to enjoy the scorn of the ordinary people at an early hour in the morning. The feuding in Fianna Fáil did not start then. It started, and the Taoiseach knows it and every Deputy in his disunited party knows it, the very moment Mr. Seán Lemass decided he was going to retire. Those who saw his shoes and felt their feet would fit them preened themselves for the battle and the contenders were Deputy Haughey and the present Minister for Finance, Deputy Colley. That was the confrontation. Neither was acceptable to the power bosses behind the scenes. Deputy Haughey had not a sufficient Fianna Fáil record or tradition and Deputy Colley was obviously faulted on some other ground.

Let us remember the score. Into the ring came two more hats, one belonging to Deputy Blaney and the other to Deputy Boland. The issue to be decided was the leadership of the Fianna Fáil Party. At the last minute, before the crunch, they decided to withdraw from this particular engagement or fight and to postpone it for another day. They all decided, apart from Deputy Colley, that they would ask Deputy Lynch to become leader of Fianna Fáil and he subsequently described his election, fairly and accurately, as being a compromise and he termed himself a via media.

Compromises, where there are tough, ambitious men involved, seldom solve anything. It is fair to say that in the dying days of 1966 the tough internal struggle inside Fianna Fáil continued to gather momentum. I will not go back over the score. Deputies will remember the jockeying for position by different Ministers of that Government, the unilateral statements by individual Ministers of what they regarded as Government policy, forcing the Government subsequently to endorse what they said. We had full and plenty of this performance by different contenders while all the time they were assuring the Taoiseach that everything was all right.

It is clear now that in this deplorable pathetic period in the last four years the Taoiseach was the captive of his own Ministers and of those who put him into power. He could not control the situation. We had Deputy Blaney as Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, solely in charge of a war against the farmers in which no one could interfere or end because he did not wish to end it. We had a situation in which other Ministers carried on their own particular interests without any interference from the Taoiseach. The fact was that this Taoiseach feared his Ministers. He regarded himself as inadequate in relation to his Ministers and this pathetic Government crawled on from one crisis to another, never coming to a decision and never solving any problem.

Of course, the country suffered badly. Problems were recognised and looked at but never solved. As they were not solved they continued to grow, and in the struggle and scramble for power, place and privilege the problems of the people did not count. Inevitably, the country drifted and has drifted since then and let us make no mistake about it. We have not had any leadership in the past four years. At least in the days of Seán Lemass there were plans, blueprints and programmes. They may not have succeeded but they gave some evidence of a Government that had some ideas about policies. However, since Deputy Lynch became Taoiseach there have been no such plans. There has not been any effort to define Government policy because it does not exist; in order to find out what it is or likely to be one would have to get the Government together and a decision made and that proved impossible.

Of course the country drifted, but who cared? Each element in Fianna Fáil was watching the other and all the time the Taoiseach was being assured that everything was all right. It was inevitable that this country in due course would end, as it has, in a serious economic crisis which endangers the way of life and the standard of living of every decent worker. This has happened because in the last three years we have had a Government of lobbyists, distrusting one another and not concerned to do the job for which they were elected.

Inflation was allowed to spread insidiously because the Government could not make up their mind and in any event was not thinking of doing anything. Those of us outside the Government, on the Opposition benches, had been concerned about the manner in which the Government had been acting in the last three years. However, serious as it appeared to us then, it now seems ten times worse as a result of the disclosures in the recent conspiracy trial. It appears from the evidence given at that trial that the doctrine of collective responsibility has neither functioned nor been preached under the leadership of the Taoiseach. It appears from the evidence at the trial that Government meetings were held from time to time without ever reaching a decision and it is obvious that there was no communication between the Taoiseach and members of the Government. From evidence at the trial it appears that members of the Government regarded it as unnecessary to have any proper control of funds and moneys voted by the Dáil. It was also obvious that not only was there a general grading among Ministers but there was general and widespread distrust among members of the Government——

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

No one was shot like your uncle.

Comment on this

My uncle, I am proud to say, fell in the course of duty and I would recommend that as a proper ordinance for any member of a Government.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

It was inevitable——

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

It is a rogues' gallery.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will Deputy Lenehan please desist.

Comment on this

It was inevitable from the evidence disclosed at that trial that such a Government could not continue to operate. There was no collective responsibility whatever. Do Deputies realise that under the leadership of the man who asks this House tonight for a Vote of Confidence three members of the Government were given, in effect, the power of peace and war? Is it appreciated that three members of a Government could have delegated to them unspecified powers in relation to the arming of people in this country without any recourse to any higher authority? That was done by a Government presided over by the present Taoiseach whose only excuse afterwards was: "Nobody told me that anything was wrong". When it transpired that one member of that ministerial subcommittee was a man who frequently and openly had flouted Government policy both inside and outside this House, one can only regard the action, or inaction, of the Taoiseach as being so serious as to be utterly irresponsible. Of course it was to end in disaster. Of course in the end a government so run would find that the bounds were overstepped. I assert, a Cheann Comhairle, that as a result of the intervention and the disclosures of his knowledge by the Leader of the Opposition eventually and finally the Taoiseach was prodded into action.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

We know well what was going on on 5th May. It is perfectly clear now that the Minister for Justice who, on Friday, 19th April, had deserted his post, was sacked by the Taoiseach, not on grounds of health or for any reason of that kind but because he was part of a counterplot inside the Cabinet and the others would have been dealt with on health or some other grounds in due course, but action had to be taken because the information was in the hands of the Opposition. We had the sacking of two Ministers and then the painful pretence for the next ten days until eventually both of them were arrested and brought down to the Bridewell to be charged with conspiracy, in effect, against the State.

I will not go any further into the details of the trial. It has been referred to by many Deputies in this debate. I am not going to express any view as to the verdict one way or the other. I want to say that what has happened before, during and since that trial has besmirched our name and our reputation among the nations of the world.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

That is bad enough but something more serious has happened. The manner in which this Government have been run and led and the way they have conducted themselves have bred among our people a contempt for politicians and for the institutions of the State.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

That is the tragedy.

Comment on this

That is a very serious result. Other things have happened. It transpires now that the misconduct of this Government and its Ministers — and, I assert, of every one of them because each one of them either knew well what was going on or ought to have known what was going on-either by commission or omission has endangered the very security of this State. They have also imperilled the loyalty of our Garda force and our Army. Is it to be forgotten that some weeks before the disclosures of 5th May of this year an unfortunate garda was shot down in the course of his duty and our Garda force, officers and men, who are a disciplined body of men with honourable, proud and courageous traditions, were not allowed to do their duty——

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

——under this weak and vacillating Government because one group of Ministers might be offended if the gardaí upheld the law of the land? What are we to think? Only ten days ago a body of armed, uniformed men marched down O'Connell Street and discharged guns in front of the GPO and marched on with people hurling insults and jeers at the gardaí who were standing idly by, because that is what they were instructed to do. Where are this Government going if we have a government carried on in this way by men without strength or courage, without minds of their own, without aims and ambitions, and above all without knowing their own friends? Where can we go except further towards destruction and harm for the people?

Integrity used to be, and I always hoped it would remain, the one proud possession of anyone who sought the honourable vocation of serving his people in Dáil Éireann or in the politics of his nation. One thing one should always be proud to have is his personal integrity, his belief in the things he stands for and a determination never to dishonour that integrity or that belief. Where is integrity today? What has happened to that kind of personal honour?

The Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries is being talked about. We know the manner in which he deliberately deceived this House. That is a matter for his conscience but the result is something for us because it means that so long as he continues to be a Member of the Government then those who associate with him cannot share a belief in the kind of integrity that should operate in government. What are we to think of the Taoiseach who came into this House on 14th May and said he had made inquiries about the expenditure of money voted by the Oireachtas and that he was satisfied nothing had gone wrong? What kind of inquiries were made? Was it like Nelson looking with his blind eye through the telescope? Was that the kind of inquiry it was? What are we to think of the latest piece of deception when only last Thursday the Minister for Finance, Deputy Colley, was asked about the expenditure of State funds and in particular the lodging of these funds in two bank accounts and he replied:

No money was lodged in my Department to either of the two accounts mentioned.

As the Department of Finance had not any control over and did not exercise any function in relation to, either of the two accounts or any such like accounts, I am not in a position to reply to parts... of Deputy Cooney's question.

This reply was designed to tell Dáil Éireann that whatever money was lodged in a bank in Clones and whatever money was lodged in a bank in Baggot Street the Department of Finance knew nothing about it. I want to assert that that reply was intended to deceive the Dáil.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

The following day the Irish Red Cross who had been mentioned as having received this money issued a statement in which they said they had got the money but it was followed by a written instruction from the Department of Finance to transfer the moneys to banks in Clones and Baggot Street in the names of three persons with whom the Red Cross had had no previous connection. I want to know from the Taoiseach under what circumstances in this hour and in this situation could the Minister for Finance be permitted to answer a Parliamentary Question in the manner in which he answered it, clearly indicating by the nature of the answer a situation which was contrary to the facts.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

Where is this deception to end? We have seen in the past ten days a pathetic performance, already referred to by Deputy Cruise-O'Brien, of the Government, through the Minister for Finance, announcing a policy in relation to inflation followed by a clear statement that these particular matters would not be and could not be negotiated. And then the roar of anger arose throughout the country. Was that the reason, or was it the fact that the following night there was an acquittal in Court No. 1 in the Four Courts? Or was it because immediately following that, across the broad Atlantic, two sections of Fianna Fáil hurled abuse at one another through Telestar, with an astounded world looking on.

Whatever the reason was, we know that on the Taoiseach's return on Monday, on the eve of the Fianna Fáil meeting, after a spontaneous reception at Collinstown, there was a sudden change. "Yes, the 12th round may go on", because, of course, Deputy Haughey, who had got up on a butter box outside the main hall in the Four Courts and addressed those around him as "fellow patriots", had announced that he was opposing the financial measures of the Government. Then we had the announcement: "Scrub it out, boys. The 12th round may go on".

Why? Because the Taoiseach went into consultation with the Minister for Finance in an effort to square it before he went into the party meeting. Then we had the Minister for Finance telling the House: "All right, the final plan now is only 6 per cent from now on and we will stand firm on that." Then we had the newspaper commentators: "Timmons is not certain to back them; Foley is uncertain and nobody knows what Flor Crowley will do." So, lo and behold, during the week-end we had the announcement: "Forget about the 6 per cent, boys."

What kind of a Government have we: no plan, no policy, no leadership, no trust, carrying on from problem to problem and from day to day? The dissidents, God bless them, where are they? Are they outside fortifying themselves for the long walk up the stairs and the turn to the left? One of them, Deputy Boland, more power to him, acted with honour at least, and although I have disagreed with him many times on many questions, and will be proud to disagree with him in the future many times on many questions, I want to say he has and had what I have been talking about, integrity.

But what about Deputy Haughey, the man who addressed those outside the Four Courts as fellow patriots? Is he just a verbal warrior, a verbal patriot? What are we to think of Deputy Haughey? During the weekend he issued a statement and he announced that he was going to pledge tonight by the way he voted his confidence in the Taoiseach and in every member of the Government, including Deputy Gibbons, his confidence in Deputy Colley and in all the rest of them. Why? He will do so because "the only alternative to a Fianna Fáil Government at the moment is political chaos". He went on: "In the best interests of the country, therefore, I believe I must put aside all other considerations at this time."

Comment on this

A suspended sentence.

Comment on this

The alternative to Fianna Fáil is political chaos. What have we now? What do we look forward to under a continuance of this Government? Chaos. There is not one single thing that this Government now agree on except their determination to stay in office. "The alternative... is political chaos." The impertinence of that little man. How dare he say that there is no alternative to Fianna Fáil? On this side of the House, I am proud to say, there is a tradition of service to this nation, even at the cost of a man's life, and I think it is fair to say of most parliaments freely elected throughout the world that there is a large share of talent and of men dedicated to the task.

Who is this man, Haughey, who dares to say there is no alternative to Fianna Fáil? If the people want the alternative they are entitled to it and no group of scheming politicians will stop them from getting it.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

You will be there until you are sick.

Comment on this

It was a sick party that took you in.

Comment on this

Is this sordid story to end tonight? It will if there are men of honour still left in Fianna Fáil. Or is this merely the beginning of chapter two while we wait from now until the Fianna Fáil Ard-Fheis when we will watch with shame—let me say it—the lobbying and scheming and the operations of the Letterkenny parliament on Leinster Lawn? Is this to continue while those men whose votes the Taoiseach purchases by fear tonight continue their scheming and plotting against him, all because men are forced to act as mice and are not prepared to stand on their own feet?

Is this to continue? I do not know. If it does, our democracy will suffer because, let there be no doubt about it, parliamentary democracy based on our Constitution depends on a very clear high standard in high places. The sustenance of parliamentary democracy depends on an understanding by the leader of a government that the government are bound to have a tight majority behind them and can, therefore, decide things which are subsequently legislated here. It is very essential to the proper functioning of that democracy that whenever it appears the government have lost the confidence of the people, whenever it appears the government have a serious loss of credibility, the moral clear sanction of an election should occur. Is there anyone in this country outside the sullied and batterd ranks of Fianna Fáil who can deny that everybody in the country is demanding a general election at this moment?

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

All political parties, except Fianna Fáil, all the newspapers, including the Irish Press, every organ of opinion believes that the time has come to dissolve this Dáil, because everybody knows that we have reached not merely an economic crisis but a crisis of confidence between the people and the Government.

A well-known columnist has called the Taoiseach "Honest Jack." Personal probity is one thing and a very valuable thing: political honour is another thing, also valuable and at times difficult to retain. Deputy Haughey, who joined in the condemnation of the Taoiseach as a felon-setter and so on, will support the Taoiseach tonight as will the other dissidents, whoever they may be. They are all going in to express confidence in this Government and in the leader of the Government. Can the Taoiseach say honestly to himself that they are doing this out of conviction because they believe in him? Can he, with honour, say after this vote tonight that he has the confidence of Dáil Éireann and of his party? Does he not know that he is getting a vote from frightened men who have been forced into a situation which they are not big enough to withstand? "Honest Jack" is the name that has been applied to the leader of Fianna Fáil. If he is honest he must realise that he heads now the greatest mixum-gatherum of a Government that has ever been known.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

I have no wish to swap insults but I suggest that a better team and a better Government can be found from the other side of the House.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

Which side?

Comment on this

I want to make a recommendation to the Taoiseach: Be honest, Jack, stand up to your responsibilities; stand up to the trust that was placed in you by the people of this country. Now, when you have no mandate, when it is clear that the Government have no mandate, when behind you are those who seek to tear down the very edifice of this State, be honest, clear out the Augean stables, dissolve Dáil Éireann and go to the country.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I do not know whether Deputy O'Higgins expected to terrify me or the members of this party by the ranting and raving speech that he has just delivered. However, it is often a good point when beginning a debate to refer to some of the remarks of the last speaker. I shall do this although there are many others on which I would like to comment in the course of my reply.

Deputy O'Higgins suggested that for the past four years this country has had neither leadership, policy, control nor confidence. I should like to throw Deputy O'Higgin's mind back a little, as well as the minds of many of those behind him, and the minds of some outside observers. I became Taoiseach in 1966. I continued as Taoiseach during 1967, 1968 and up to the middle of 1969—that was almost three years continuation in office — but much to Deputy O'Higgins's surprise and disappointment I was returned in 1969 with a better majority than I went out with.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

If there was this lack of trust, this lack of control, or this lack of policy, what were the people doing in June of 1969? What were Fine Gael and Labour doing then? Were they so inept as a possible alternative Government, either alone or together? Were they so inept or incapable of forming a Government that they could not convince the people of that lack of confidence or of that lack of leadership? Is it not obvious that Deputy O'Higgins was braying to the stars when he suggested that the set-up was as he tried to paint it? This was the period when there was the so-called war between our Government and the farmers. On occasions during that time there were by-elections which we won one after another. Yet, Deputy O'Higgins has the gall and the cheek to suggest that the people did not have confidence in that Government or did not have confidence in me. He need only cast his mind back to his disappointment and his dejection on the 18th June, 1969.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

At the outset I want to refer to the policies that we have put forward for dealing with the present economic situation. I want to say that our objective is, first, to reduce and eventually halt the continuous rise in prices. As part of the measures— part but an important part—to achieve this result the Government announced statutory proposals to regulate prices and incomes. The legislation to give effect to these measures will be debated in this House next week.

Since the measures were announced the Government have made two alterations in the proposals. The first was that wage agreements already entered into prior to the 16th October, which still had some time to run and which embodied some further increases, should be allowed to run their course. This change in particular has been interpreted as a sign of weakness on the part of the Government. I assert emphatically that that is not the case. Our policy objective of securing the earliest possible end to inflationary pressures remains unaltered. Neither has the need to achieve an early improvement in any way diminished. What the Government have done by the announcement of these changes is, first, to moderate the impact and hence the speed with which the measures will remedy the position and, secondly, to provide a limited period within which the unions and the employers can secure a more acceptable formula for moderating the rate of income increases than that which was proposed initially by the Government.

These modifications came about by due democratic process and by the process of discussion and consultation. The Executive Committee of the Irish Congress of Trade Unions sought an interview with me and my colleagues who had responsibility in this field and we met them in this House after the Dáil had adjourned last Thursday. They put forward to us the suggestion that even though the Employer-Labour Conference had failed to come to a satisfactory agreement, or settlement, over a period of six months negotiating in working committee and in plenary session, they said they could try again to reach a satisfactory settlement provided the Government withdrew the 6 per cent ceiling from the legislation we proposed to introduce. It was for that reason, to produce if possible an acceptable agreement between employers and workers within the limits of what the Government regarded as feasible in the present situation, we decided not to proceed for the present with the 6 per cent ceiling. Nevertheless we are determined to fix an appropriate ceiling by ministerial order, and will do so whether or not it is possible to reach an acceptable agreement.

The scope for these actions arose because it emerged that the Government's attitude to inflation had advanced at a faster rate than that thought to be correct, thought to be appropriate, by sections of the community.

In the case of the 12th round agreement already negotiated, for example, the opposition to our original proposal largely centred on the point that it was unfair to go back on existing agreements. We agreed it was unfair. The Government's view was that continued inflation would eat away the real gains so that the larger money wage would go in higher prices. I wonder which is the more unfair? Which is the less damaging to the recipient of increases? To tell people openly that their real living standards cannot rise as quickly as they might wish and to indicate realistic figures for worthwhile income increases, or to say nothing—say nothing and have the same result achieved by the more silent but equally certain mechanism of price rises? Since there appeared to be a strong attachment to getting money increases even though part of the money might be swallowed up by inflation the Government agreed to allow existing agreements to run their course. One result of this change will be that it will take longer than we originally intended to bring inflation under control.

The second change, postponing the decision as to the amount of permissible pay increases, is, as I said, designed to provide the Irish Congress of Trade Unions and the employers with every possible opportunity to produce a pay formula which would conform with the country's requirements. The Government, however, will still insist on income increases of a size that will contribute to a substantial easing of inflationary pressures in 1971. That was our intention with the figures that we originally produced and that is still our intention. At the same time the Government recognise that the suggested figures are not the sole or unique ones to achieve the required result. If there is some alternative combination of figures which produces the same result but in a more acceptable manner then by all means let us have it. I assert that the willingness to discuss or recognise the possibility that a scheme may be capable of improvement is not a sign of weakness or uncertainty; on the contrary it is only those who are unclear about their views or uncertain about their capacity to advance them who must fear discussion or any alteration of them.

I said earlier that our prices and incomes policies were part of our programme for dealing with inflation. The budgetary measures which we introduced last week were another important part. I should have thought that it would be unnecessary for me to make this point but Deputy Cosgrave saw fit to describe them as irrelevant when he was speaking in this debate last week. What an amazing statement to come from Deputy Cosgrave. Here we have a man who would claim to form a Government, one who earlier had seen fit to criticise the Government's handling of the economic situation, making a statement which displays either a total misunderstanding of, or a complete lack of interest in, our economic affairs. Perhaps Deputy Cosgrave might have swallowed the line put forward by some newspapers that our economic problems have been manufactured and trumped up by the Government in order to divert public attention from other matters. Perhaps he might consult with his colleague, Deputy Garret FitzGerald who, I am sure, would quickly disabuse him on that score.

I said in opening this debate that it was likely that its true purpose would be lost sight of, that we would be debating not confidence in the present Government but the difficulties in which the Government in which some Ministers were replaced found themselves. I still think that what we must debate and must vote on tonight is the confidence and the credibility of this Government.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

"Hear, hear" from Deputy Cruise-O'Brien. He said that our credibility was shattered. The first essential to have credibility shattered is to have credibility and Deputy Cruise-O'Brien has none.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I want to deal with what inevitably became one of the main themes of this debate, the recent arms trial, but only in matters of some detail. I am not going to comment otherwise. I want to say that it was not my desire that the prosecution would take place and I want to say too that it was my duty when certain information was available to me about an alleged breach of an Act of the Oireachtas that I should have placed that information at the disposal of the Attorney General. The Attorney General as was his duty considered that information at the disposal of the complete sought further information and had further investigations conducted. The prosecution has now taken place. In the course of it all the relevant evidence concerning the attempted importation of arms, all the relevant evidence that it was possible to produce, has been made available to the court and to the public.

I would refer only to some aspects of that case. In the first place, as the House is aware, during the course of the evidence it was stated that some portion of the £100,000 which the Government decided to make available, and that this House voted for the relief of distress amongst people who were victims of that distress in the north of Ireland troubles, was used to pay for the arms in respect of which an attempt was made to import. Yesterday, Deputy FitzGerald accused me of misleading the House in a reference I made to the means whereby these arms were purchased, the reference I made in this House during the course of the long debate on the last Confidence Motion that we had. Deputy FitzGerald quoted from that debate. I think I shall do the same. I said, in winding up the Confidence Motion:

I want to add that I made specific inquiries as to whether any moneys could have been voted or could have been paid out of Exchequer funds or out of any public funds in respect of a consignment of arms of the size we have been dealing with and I am assured that there was not nor could not have been.

So, that was a statement of fact. I challenged the Deputy yesterday to indicate in what way I misled the House. He immediately said that if I did not mislead the House I was putting up an alibi of incompetence. Deputy FitzGerald went on to say:

All the Taoiseach had to do was to ask the appropriate officials of the Department of Finance and they would have told him where the money had gone.

I want to tell Deputy FitzGerald that that is exactly what I did. I caused an examination to be made, before I made the statement in this House, as to how these arms might have been paid for. The Department of Finance having examined all the relevant papers, gave me the information on which I based that statement. So, I take it that if that is the basis on which the Deputy charged me with incompetence he can withdraw that charge too—or does he want to allege incompetence——

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

——against the officials of the Department of Finance on whose examination I based my statement? Let me say, however, and without in any way trying to evade this issue, that it was during the course of further investigations and, in fact, from that very day on which a statement was taken from one of the witnesses in the arms trial when suspicion for the first time came from that statement that some of the money voted for the relief of the distress might have been used for arms, it was only in the course of those further investigations and ultimately in the course of cross-examination of one of the defendants in the trial that the evidence came that it was so used.

When I returned from New York last week I held a press conference. I was asked about that particular money. I told the press that a more intensive examination had been ordered in the Department of Finance; that, as well as that, during the course of the getting of evidence for the arms trial, the gardaí investigated as well the accounts and other matters relating to the disposal of these moneys. I said to the press conference and I repeat here tonight that the gardaí inquiries were inhibited because of the bank strike, that inquiries are not yet completed but that they are continuing. I do not know what result they will produce. Whatever result they will produce, if it indicates a course of action then that course of action will be taken. But I want also to say that, irrespective of what action might be taken, I fully acknowledge and I accept completely that the Committee of Public Accounts of this House is a competent and is a right body to deal with that matter.

Comment on this

When?

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

We will await the outcome of the investigation to which I have referred. I hope it will not be long more. I have no desire whatever in any way to keep the facts of this transaction from the House or from the public.

During the course of this debate some rather contemptous remarks were passed, even tonight by Deputy M. O'Leary, about my non-availability at crucial times all during this particular period that we are dealing with. Deputy Haughey stated in evidence that, in the week he was contacted in relation to the difficulties with customs officials, that were encountered by those importing the arms he had learned from my office that I was not available. I want to say that Deputy Haughey was mistaken in his evidence: I will say no more than that because I have no intention of making any more of it.

However, I want to say, in relation to Deputy M. O'Leary's charge, that I was in fact available. I was in my home on the Saturday and again on Sunday and I was in my office on Monday and at a Government meeting on Tuesday. I was available for any contact that was required to be made with me.

I want now to put on record something I have already stated in relation to this trial. One of the defendants, John Kelly, stated in unsworn evidence that, from the Taoiseach down, no member of the Government had refused their request—the request of deputations that had seen members of the Government—for the supply of arms. I think that evidence referred, in particular, to a delegation that came to this House and saw a number of Ministers on 3rd March last. I think I was the first member of the Government to be seen; I remember it well because I was asked to see them. I was engaged most of the afternoon and I left this House during Question Time. I saw them during Question Time and came back again for the Order of Business because I expected there might be some difficulty about ordering the business. I told that delegation, and every other delegation that came to me, that the Government could not overtly or covertly make arms available. That is an incontrovertible fact.

I want to come to some parts of the statement made by Deputy Boland here yesterday. He announced his intention of resigning his seat because, amongst other things, he could not vote for this Motion of Confidence nor could he abstain. At the end of May, Deputy Boland made what I could only describe as an unwarranted attack on me, an attack in which he described me as a felon-setter and said I was guilty of unparalleled treachery.

He did so because he apparently thought that I was responsible for the arrest of John Kelly of the Belfast Citizens Defence Committee. I pointed out to Deputy Boland and anyone else who cared to listen that at the time I handed the papers in my possession to the Attorney General, which contained all the information I had about the matter at that time, I had no knowledge of any involvement of John Kelly in an attempt to import arms.

I have already told the House that I took no further part in any investigations or in bringing a prosecution. It was only after that time, after my handing over the papers and further investigations, that it came to knowledge that John Kelly was involved; but I want to assert again, Sir, that I took no part in the arrest or prosecution of John Kelly. If Deputy Boland felt he had to resign his seat because he could not accept my leadership and because he disagreed with my policies, that I could understand, but when he talks of resigning his seat as the only way to save his honour, that I do not understand. Honour is not the exclusive right or possession of any one man.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Others treasure their honour, too, and I certainly do mine.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I consider his reasoning as a reflection on my personal integrity and on my motives and as a reflection, too, on the honour of all those others who support me. If this is the inference to be drawn from his action and his statement, then I completely reject it.

I want to make one other reference to Deputy Boland's statement. He said that the jury decided that Deputy Jim Gibbons had perjured himself in court. Deputy Jim Gibbons, Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, is able to defend himself here in this House and he has done so ably. Deputy Boland went on to say—and say in the privileged position of a Member of the House—that the jury by implication decided that Mr. Berry, Secretary of the Department of Justice, had also perjured himself. Mr. Berry unfortunately is not in the same privileged position as Deputy Boland is in this House and he is not in the same position as Deputy Gibbons, Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, to defend himself, but he is entitled to be defended. I believe Mr. Berry to be a conscientious and dedicated official, who would not and did not commit perjury. I want to say, too, Sir, that the jury did not so find. I have complete confidence in Mr. Berry's integrity.

I regret that Deputy Boland went on to attack the Attorney General, another person not in a position to defend himself in this House. He spoke of the Attorney General's determination and mine to secure a conviction after the abortive trial and said that determination was such that another trial was proceeded with. He went on to say that our determination, that is the determination of the Attorney General and myself, was such that we made unfair and unworthy preparations and perhaps tried to improve on the performance, and I quote, Sir, "that created such a bad impression on everybody who read the report of the first trial".

I want to say again that I had nothing whatever to do with the course of the first trial. I had no say of any kind in the decision to commence the second trial and no influence on the course of the second trial. That decision was made by the Attorney General personally, after consultation, I presume, with his other legal advisers. I am certain that any decisions he took were in accordance with the highest standards of the legal profession and the highest standards of his office and without fear, favour or malice. Knowing the Attorney General as I do, I know that had I tried to interfere I would immediately have had his resignation.

Deputy Boland said he recognised a well prepared and baited trap in this motion of confidence. I want to say, Sir, that I prepared no trap for anybody. Deputy Boland would have had to come to the same decision as he has had to come to apparently on the motions already before the House in the names of the leader of the Fine Gael Party and the leader of the Labour Party.

One more thing, Sir, about the trial: I have been accused of bringing the prosecution for political reasons. I want to assert that I have no interest in political power for its own sake. I believe that is readily accepted throughout the country. My only interest is to make whatever talents I have available to the service of my country.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

It is regrettable that Deputy Boland, a man whose ability and dedication have for so long been given wholeheartedly to this country, a man I held in high esteem, should have used his sterling qualities for division and not for cohesion at this juncture. In the course of the debate on the confidence motion of last June, to which I have referred already, references were made to the alleged complicity of Deputy Gibbons, then Minister for Defence, in this affair. Standerous attacks have been made on him in this House.

Comment on this

And outside.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Deputy Cruise-O'Brien has not made one outside, I am sure. I invite Deputy Cruise-O'Brien to make one of those charges he made inside this House outside it.

Comment on this

Statements have been made about the Taoiseach's colleague outside this House and outside privilege to which the appropriate response has not been made.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Taoiseach.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Deputy Cruise-O'Brien levelled the foulest charge of all at him as being a convicted perjurer which is untrue, but would Deputy Cruise-O'Brien have the courage to repeat that outside or would he have the conviction to repeat it outside? I know he would not.

Comment on this

It has been said outside.

Comment on this

The judge's speech can be read outside.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I am dealing with the references made here last May to the alleged complicity of Deputy Gibbons, then Minister for Defence, in the arms importation affair. I told the House then that I had no information on this at the time I took action against two other Ministers. I also told the House that I subsequently had inquiries made following which my confidence in him had not changed. Evidence has since been adduced that Deputy Gibbons, on learning of the attempted importation of arms, not only took steps to try to stop it, but refused specifically to sign a certificate that would have facilitated the importation of these arms.

I do not propose to deal with the trial to any other extent even though there are many other things I might well have said about it. I want to come to more general matters. Deputy Richie Ryan, whom I heard yesterday evening, alleged that I had absolved Britain from any responsility for the division of our country. I have said again and again that Britain has a responsibility but I have stated my confidence in the genuine desire of the British Government to achieve the necessary reforms and to see them implemented in the North of Ireland. Where the pace or quality of these reforms would not measure up to the legitimate expectations and entitlement of the minority in the north it will be our responsibility as a Government to ensure, in so far as we can, that the British Government will have this done. This is a responsibility that we do not intend to neglect or renege.

I think the time has come again for me—although I should have thought it would be unnecessary—to state again Fianna Fáil's policy for the reunification of our country by peaceful means. That has been Fianna Fáil policy ever since the foundation of our party and Fine Gael can claim no credit, as they seem to be doing of late, that it was they who suggested that this was the best means for securing reunification. I want to say too, Sir, that I have never, nor will I ever, acknowledge the right of a minority, who happen to be a majority in a small part of our country, to opt out of our nation.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I want to be as clear and as unequivocal as I can about that because suggestions have been made that I think to the contrary. But we have the factual situation that our country is partitioned and that one and a half million of our total population are outside the jurisdiction of this national Parliament and that approximately two-thirds of that one and a half million at present wish to remain outside the jurisdiction. I have said, and I recognise, that we cannot have a lasting and meaningful reunification of our country until we can persuade that majority that their place is with their fellow countrymen in a united Ireland.

Perhaps I could at this stage refer to some remarks of Deputy Cosgrave in this context. He chose to sneer at the republicanism of the Fianna Fáil Party. But one thing is certain, and it is time the Fine Gael Deputies opposite were reminded of the fact—Fianna Fáil succeeded in making republicans of the lot of you——

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

They gave us stepping stones, but they would not walk on them.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

——and you dare not ever again retreat from republicanism, as your predecessors did 50 years ago, because we will never let you.

I was really amazed to hear Deputy Cosgrave make the brazen claim that Fine Gael always had a consistent policy on partition. If Fine Gael or Cumann na nGaedheal or whatever one likes to call them were consistent, if they were firm, if they were strong, if they were truly republican 50 years ago, there would not be any need now for the same kind of policy on partition that we have.

Comment on this

Was that when you tossed the coin to see which side you would take?

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

That is an untruth.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Taoiseach.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I will tell the story about that.

Comment on this

What about the Government of Ireland Act?

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I never supported any political party but Fianna Fáil. One of my earliest recollections of a political party meeting was when Éamon de Valera came into Cork in 1932 and I carried a torch beside his carriage and I was only a young boy then. I will tell you what I did do. When I was first asked to stand, I did toss a coin as to whether I would stand or not for Fianna Fáil. That is the truth of that position.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Deputy Seán MacBride, as he was then, approached me through a legal colleague in Cork to stand for his party and I completely rejected him. If you want to draw more of these facts out of me you are quite welcome.

Comment on this

What did Gerry Boland think of you?

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

What did the German to whom the Deputy sold his land think of him?

Comment on this
A Deputy

An Egyptian.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

As I said when opening this debate, much of the discussion which we have had both inside and outside this House in the past few months arose from the novelty of my action in dismissing Ministers. Yes, that is the word. I want to repeat, therefore, that there is no reason why changes in the composition of a Government itself or should ever, in themselves, be a reason for changing the Government itself or for calling a general election. Those Deputies on the other benches who are wont to quote for us the example of Westminister will, I am sure, be able to confirm for their colleagues that there have been numerous Cabinet changes carried out by both Conservatives and Labour Governments in mid-term without changes of Government or without a general election in the United Kingdom.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

Not for the same reason.

Comment on this

They do not usually arrest them.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

The Deputy might think and look at his records more closely.

Another basis which Opposition Deputies and, indeed, outside commentators profess to see as justification for the calling of a general election is the differences of opinion between members of the Fianna Fáil Party. I said candidly at the beginning of this debate that we had our difficulties. I do not deny that. In opening the debate I said that there were no differences on any fundamental policy matters among our party and I went on to point out that differences have existed, do exist and, no doubt, will always exist as to the most effective means by which we can achieve our policy objectives. I wonder what is the terrible thing about that. Why should any party rush to the electorate every time there is such a disagreement—a disagreement, I emphasise, that is not about policy as such but about the means of implementing that policy. If we were to do so the country would be faced with continuous general elections unless, of course, the party were to prohibit the expression of views by its members; but then, I suppose, we would be accused of totalitarianism, dictatorship, fascism, or whatever other smear the Opposition would like to apply to us.

Perhaps we could again look at the Westminster example so often quoted by Deputies opposite and recognise that there, within each of the major parties, there are very severe critics of party policy and of party leadership. No one suggests that in so acting these critics are behaving dishonestly or that they should resign their seats or that the leader of the Government party should call an election. Yet, people reading some of our newspapers recently are being asked to accept that there is something wrong in Fianna Fáil Deputies behaving in this way, that there is some danger to democracy if they do so, that there is something unhealthy in a parliamentary system where such action takes place or that some form of mysterious purification process—I think that is the word used—at the ballot box should be called for. My impression is that the only thing wrong with such behaviour, or the only real objection to it, is that it is being done by the Fianna Fáil Party. Apparently it would be perfectly all right if any one of the other parties opposite chose to do so and perhaps we could examine what they have been doing among themselves.

We have been sitting here for the past three days receiving a battering from the parties opposite about alleged disunity. That it is only Fianna Fáil who are to be denied any freedom for different views can be seen quite clearly if we contrast the position in the Opposition parties. Take the Labour Party, for instance. We have Deputy Browne and Deputy Thornley publicly exposing and debating their differences on real policy matters. Is that not healthy, I would like to ask the members of the Labour Party? Is that any reason why one or both of those Deputies should be expelled?

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

It is very good for you.

Comment on this

Resign like Deputy Boland.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

What about Deputy Coughlan who is playing away out on the right wing of this left wing party?

Comment on this

The same as yourself.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Deputy Michael Pat Murphy and Deputy Desmond for that matter who are flouting the party conference——

Comment on this

The Taoiseach has only one minute left. Why does he not address a word to Deputy Blaney and Deputy Haughey?

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I will go on if the Opposition give me more time.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach can have all the time in the world if he will address his remarks to Deputy Blaney and Deputy Haughey.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Taoiseach must be allowed to make his statement without interruption.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Deputy Michael Pat Murphy and Deputy Desmond flout the annual conference who made the sacrosanct decision some years ago about coalition. I would like to remind Deputy Corish of what he said about it himself. He was quoted in the Irish Times of 25th January, 1969:

I am against Coalition. In the present context we will never be accepted as equal partners and we will not be able to get our Socialist Policies through a Government dominated by Conservative Ministers. I am looking to the future and I cannot see how, after a Coalition Government, the Labour Party could fight an election as a Party with a separate identity. Coalition would lead to another sterile contest between Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael. Last years Annual Conference rightly decided, in my opinion, against participating in Coalition Government in present conditions. This was a democratic choice of the entire party, which at the time I supported and will continue to uphold so long as I am Leader of the party. If conference should in the future decide by democratic choice to change its mind, I will, as I have consistently done since I became a member of the Parliamentary Labour Party 24 yeas ago, accept that decision.

This is the crunch line:

But the Party must appreciate that to me this is a matter of conscience and that in such an eventuality my continued support for Socialism will be from the back benches.

I invited Deputy Corish in my opening speech to comment on that but he has not done so.

Comment on this

I will do that at the proper time. Would the Taoiseach comment on Deputy Blaney and Deputy Haughey?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): He is supposed to be Honest Jack.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Deputy Corish did not answer me when he had the chance.

Comment on this

Get out, you fraud.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

That is typical.

Comment on this

That is what you are.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I seem to be getting under the skin of the Labour Party.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Will Members on all sides of the House allow the Taoiseach to continue with his statement?

Comment on this

Deputy Boland is enjoying it.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Interruptions are disorderly.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

This debate has been about disunity.

Comment on this

It was about what Deputy Blaney and Deputy Boland said about it.

Comment on this

It is confidence in the next Government.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Could we ask Fine Gael what about the birth pangs of its Just Society image? We know there were disputes and differences on all sides about those policies. We know too many of the young tigers on their socialist democratic platform were ultimately emaciated into tired old rabbits.

Comment on this

It did not take a hair out of you.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I have said that the greatest problem facing our country at the present time is the economic one.

Comment on this

As a matter of fact, the Taoiseach is the greatest problem.

Comment on this

He is a problem child.

Comment on this

His own leopards are changing their spots.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair must again point out that interruptions are disorderly.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

The smart alecks of the Labour Party seem to want to get their cracks in—loquacious, Deputy O'Leary and others. The threat of inflation is the greatest problem that we have to face.

Comment on this

Why does the Taoiseach not do something about it?

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I am coming to it.

Comment on this

Get back to it.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil created it.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

There is a danger that it will submerge us. I suppose Deputy O'Donovan will tell us that we created world inflation.

Comment on this

You certainly did.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Will Deputy O'Donovan tell me of any progressive country in the world at the present time that is not suffering from inflation?

Comment on this

The Taoiseach will blame the world any way.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I am not blaming the world at all but I am not going to accept a naïve suggestion that we created inflation in our own country much less world inflation.

Comment on this

Did you not give £25 million to the banks last March?

Comment on this

That is what the banks are for.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

The task of overcoming inflation will be difficult and the measures that we propose will, I know, be unpopular.

Comment on this

They will be changed week after week.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I am not going to run away from those measures, difficult and unpopular though they are. That is not my form and that certainly is not the tradition of Fianna Fáil. It is a tempting thing to bury those problems in the turmoil of a general election, but the time to tackle and overcome the problems is short. In fact, it is now. Necessary measures had to be introduced at the beginning of this term of the Dáil and we are determined to implement them during this term; otherwise, we believe it will be too late. No matter what Government might emerge from a general election that would be held in the weeks between now and Christmas it would not have the time to tackle those problems. We all know of the wage claims which are being made now for implementation as from the 1st January. We know the size of those wage claims. Therefore, I believe it would be totally irresponsible of me, in the light of the economic situation, to seek a dissolution of the Dáil at this juncture and I do not propose to do so.

Comment on this

Why did the Taoiseach wait so long?

Comment on this
A Deputy

They are all happy now.

Comment on this

The fixers and the Tacateers have done their work.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I am seeking in this motion, therefore, a vote of confidence in responsible Government, ready, willing and able to meet and tackle our difficulties. I say "able" because I think this Government is as able, vigorous and determined as any of its predecessors.

Comment on this

That is not saying a whole lot.

Comment on this

Deputy Charles Haughey said the Taoiseach should do the honourable thing.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

A vote for this Motion of Confidence in each member of the Government as well as in myself will mean what it says without prevarication, without equivocation. I do not want any Deputy to go into the Lobby with me in order to buy time because I am not in the market for either the buying or selling of time.

Finally, the internal problems of our party—and I am not denying that they are there——

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

——will not deter us from taking the right course at this time. The economic, social and political progress of our country is our sole object as a political party. The road ahead we know will be a difficult one and a challenging one. My Government, unified as it is——

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

——and my party, in mutual trust and confidence, look forward eagerly to meeting this challenge and overcoming whatever difficulties lie before us.

Comment on this