We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Economic Situation: Motion.

Contributions 94–206 of 206. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

When children first start going to school, if they have not been taught their ABC at home before going to school, the first thing they learn is their letters and, having learned their letters, they then in a short time learn to read short phrases. They improve and eventually they read anything they can get hold of. It makes no impression on their minds because they do not understand what they are reading but on every possible occasion they trot out what they read. Being children, they try to impress their hearers by pretending they know what they are reading. My mind went back to schooldays when I listened to Deputy Dowling trotting out figures which, apparently, did not mean one damn thing to him because he did not understand them. Someone gave him a book and said: "Go in and read this." This was a sensible debate until Deputy Dowling rose and it is a pity that it should be impaired now by the introduction of irrelevancies.

I am glad the Minister for Labour and Social Welfare is present because he is a key figure in this whole muddle. I am sure he is not very proud of the situation in which he finds himself. He is a very decent man and I am sure he is as perturbed and embarrassed by the inaction of his Government as everybody else in the country must be. The debate started off with the Taoiseach and some of his Ministers trying to put across that there was no crisis. no problem and no need to take any special measures. The Anglo-Irish Free Trade Area Agreement was not doing anything to spoil the unblemished record and so on, and so on. Even as recently as a week ago we had the Taoiseach at a Fianna Fáil meeting saying there was no crisis and that was repeated here in this House by members of his Government speaking in this debate; in fact, the argument was that the crisis was one which had been created by the Labour Party and, to a lesser extent, by Fine Gael. The Labour Party had wished thousands and thousands out of their jobs. Deputy Joe Dowling in the little bit of what he said that I could understand said that even by this debate we were creating further unemployment.

Let us put the blame now fairly and squarely where it belongs and that is on the shoulders of this Fianna Fáil Government. We were used to a Government controlled by a strong Taoiseach—first of all, Eamon de Valera and then Seán Lemass. Both of these gentlemen in their time had one characteristic which helped them very considerably: they made up their own minds and they had a policy and they insisted on that policy being carried out. Unfortunately, when Deputy Jack Lynch arrived, we had a different set of figures. We had a Taoiseach who was not prepared to "carry the can" himself and who passed responsibility for everything on to his Ministers. They were, in fact, paid to carry that responsibility but they had never had to carry that responsibility before. Then a few calamities struck his Government and he finished up with a rather mediocre type of Government and, when the weight came on them, they started to crack and very soon they fell apart. The result is that 80,000 of our people are now unemployed because of a poor Government, a poor Cabinet and an irresponsible attitude by that Government and that Cabinet to a crisis which has been building up, not this week, or last week, or the week before, but for months past. We could see it. Fine Gael could see it. Fianna Fáil could not see it. Even now they cannot see it. They say these people are not unemployed and there is no crisis.

Dr. Kieran Kennedy, Director of the Institute for Economic and Social Research, said that the economy was in a state of deflation. I assume he is a highly intelligent man and knows what he is talking about. He replaced Dr. Fogarty and Dr. Geary, both of whom had a tremendous reputation. I assume that, when he made that statement, he was stating a fact. Why is the economy in a state of deflation? This deflation is the direct result of the Budget introduced here last year by the present Minister for Finance, Deputy George Colley. Deputy Colley when he introduced that Budget said that he had pared Estimates—those were his own words—in order to keep down expenditure and having pared the Estimates he was very proud of the figure he presented to this House. Since then we have had the situation in which a few months ago £20 million was injected into the economy and a further £50 million was mentioned here yesterday.

So much for his paring of Estimates. His Budget failed badly. He made this mistake: apparently he was under the impression that even if unemployment was created as a result of paring the Estimates it would cause moderation in prices. But all we need to do is look at Britain where unemployment is soaring to the one million mark and ask has there been a reduction in prices as a result. Of course not; nor here either. We knew for quite a time that the unemployment situation was worsening but the Minister for Finance until very late last year was not prepared to face the fact that this was so. He applied a 40 years old economic theory to running the country. Apparently at the back of his mind he had the idea that a pool of unemployment—a phrase used by Fianna Fáil—was useful because it would contain wage demands and keep prices down. Now he knows otherwise. The trade unionists and particularly union officials who were responsible for seeing the agreements through, proved to be very responsible and national wage agreements were made and adhered to despite the fact that the Government did not keep their end of the bargain. The Government made no effort to hold prices at the level at which they were when the agreement was made and the agreement was made particularly on the basis that prices would be held. They were not held and also unemployment was growing. This reminds me of the doctor who makes a wrong diagnosis and the patient dies. Dr. George Colley made the wrong diagnosis and the patient is rapidly dying now. The working class people are suffering most.

It was said by successive Ministers, particularly in the past six months, that the Anglo-Irish Free Trade Area Agreement had no bearing on growing unemployment. Last night we had a grudging admission by the Tánaiste followed by a more forthright admission by the Minister for Industry and Commerce that it had caused some unemployment but had only cost about 1,000 jobs—just like that. Apart from the fact that they are only a couple of thousand out it is an admission that something has gone wrong. These jobs had been disappearing over a period, very much more than 1,000 of them, and only very recently the Government decided to act. They increased by 50 per cent the tariff on certain imported goods. They did not do so until the country was flooded with British goods. An extraordinary thing happened here. Despite all we hear about buying Irish and the need for, and responsibility on Irish people to buy home products, when people began buying British goods they got a taste for foreign goods and began looking for Italian and French goods. At present one can go to any shop, even in a relatively small town, and find a selection of British and continental wares for sale. Apparently this does not worry the Government; it is only ordinary working people who are losing jobs, or so they think. But the position has gone so far that very many more than those employed in the factories are beginning to suffer. If the money is not circulating shops in the area suffer; then all the businesses suffer and around the ring it goes until eventually even the agricultural community will feel the loss of the earnings of the workers concerned.

The economics practised by the Government can only be described as lunacy. One reason I say this is that in a town in my constituency approximately 140 people were employed in a furniture factory at an average wage of about £25 a week. That factory closed. I believe a temporary injection of a substantial sum, perhaps, £60,000 or £70,000 by loan could have kept that factory going. It had been in existence over 40 years. It was modern and could have been saved and much could have been done by the employees to ensure not only a continuing of the home market but also of the export market in which the factory was engaged.

What happened? The 140 workers laid off first got redundancy pay and since they had long service had to get substantial amounts. Since the management knew the facts they gave six weeks notice so that approximately £35,000 or £40,000 went on redundancy pay. The State lost £2 per person per week in stamps, another £14,000, and approximately £15,000 per year was being paid by those workers in income tax. There was also the loss in turnover and wholesale taxes. Then the State, having lost that amount, estimated at about £200,000 in a period of 12 months, pays unemployment benefit to the people concerned and even at an average of £10 per week—it is much more than that in many cases because the workers were entitled to 50 per cent of their wages for a long period—it means that there was a loss in all of possibly £250,000 in a 12-month period. The loss of production represents a loss to the State and there was a loss of earning capacity and buying power amongst those concerned. We end up with no factory and the State suffering a net loss.

I wonder did the Minister for Finance ever hear of cost benefit analysis. Has any effort been made to find out if the closing of a factory could be more costly to the State than subsidising it to some extent to keep it going? I believe a partial solution to this problem must be for the State to set up some type of co-ordinating committee or department that would be able to tell the Department of Social Welfare that a factory is closing down and will result in a substantial net loss to the State and show that by means of a grant or loan at the proper time that factory could be kept going and the workers kept in employment.

An extraordinary thing is that not only does this happen in private enterprise, of which Fianna Fáil seems so proud, but it has been happening in State employment also. It is bad enough to have private employers whose only motive is profit laying people off in order to save their own pockets and to hell with the economy, but we have the State laying off men in the Forestry Division and the Board of Works and anywhere else they had employees. The State paid off these workers to save a few paltry pounds. Those concerned lost employment and income and the State lost their income tax and the cost of insurance stamps and eventually, even in that case, a net loss accrued to the State. Fianna Fáil do not care and they have failed to realise that it is their responsibility to see to it that the country is run properly. They just sit back and say: "There is no crisis, there is no unemployment." The sooner they realise that this will not be taken from them any longer the better it will be for them.

When the late Seán Lemass was sitting on this side of the House he said that the way to gauge whether a government were doing their job properly was to look at the number of people employed and the number unemployed and there you had the answer. The present Taoiseach has a different answer. He tells us: "Look at England." The unemployed are committing the cardinal crime of not emigrating. It is being asked why they do not emigrate because if they did this they would not be entered on the unemployment register here. Did anyone ever hear such a ridiculous statement from a Taoiseach? It is utterly stupid to point to the number of people who have not emigrated.

I should like to comment on one or two points the Taoiseach made in his speech. On a number of occasions I have said that Fianna Fáil are masters of the half truth. They are the best people I know to say something which, while it cannot be pointed out as being a deliberate lie, if one goes close enough into the matter it can be found to be half true. Of course, we can be told that there are two ways of looking at it. I should like to put another way of looking at some of the things the Taoiseach said yesterday.

The Taoiseach spoke about the necessity to reduce the size of pay increases and he suggested, as did the Tánaiste in his speech yesterday, that the cause of the trouble was that workers were looking for too much for what they are doing. As I have pointed out already, the workers have shown a tremendous restraint and have honoured their guarantees. It is an example I would recommend to the Government that, for a change, they might honour their guarantees.

The Taoiseach said that the level of employment showed little change from 1970. Later in the day we heard the Minister for Industry and Commerce boasting about 8,000 additional jobs that had been created in industry. Both the Taoiseach and other Government spokesmen, and particularly Deputy Colley outside this House, time and again have attempted to prove that a man or woman engaged in agriculture who becomes unemployed is not an unemployed person. The sooner it seeps through the brains of these gentlemen that whether a person is working in agriculture or industry if he loses his job he is unemployed the better it will be.

The Taoiseach said that the 77,801 who are unemployed were not all looking for work and he proceeded to slip in the half-truth. He said about 5,000 of them were over 65 years. No one knows better than the Minister who is present now, Deputy Brennan, that the 5,000 people referred to by the Taoiseach are on retirement pensions, they are over 65 years, and therefore do not appear on the unemployment register. The Taoiseach would be well advised to stick to the full truth because we can check on these figures and we know a little about how they are compiled. In the Adjournment Debate before Christmas the Taoiseach mentioned that there were between 4,000 and 5,000 people who were receiving retirement pensions. Those people do not appear on the unemployment register and anyone over 65 years who is signing for unemployment benefit or assistance is doing so because he wants a job.

The Taoiseach spoke about 11,000 farmers and their relatives and he suggested that these people are not unemployed. Have they full-time jobs, because if they have they should not be drawing unemployment benefit. I know that Fianna Fáil, in an effort to buy votes on the western seaboard some years ago, introduced a system which allowed these people to draw unemployment assistance while they worked their own farms. At the same time the Government deprived people with families of assistance. I know of a man who had 15 children and who lived in the midlands: a few years ago he was refused benefit although he had been charged for insurance stamps. Either people are unemployed or they are not. May I point out to the Taoiseach that the figures he gave were in respect of last year and if we have a comparison with this year it is obvious that these people are unemployed and he must accept that fact.

The Taoiseach referred to young married women who were signing for benefit. The Minister for Labour, who has just left the House, complained here when answering a question I put to him that even in his own constituency married women whom he thought were entitled to draw benefit were refused it because of the way some official worked the slide rule they operate with regard to unemployment benefit. Nobody signs at the employment exchange unless they are looking for a job. Accepting insurance stamps from people and then refusing to meet the commitments is a dishonest practice which should be stopped.

The Taoiseach spoke about the chronically unemployed—the unemployable. The Tánaiste went further and told us that in a survey carried out in Britain it was found that 46 per cent of those who were signing for unemployment benefit were people who were unable to work. In view of the fact that the number of people signing here for unemployment benefit as distinct from assistance is about 42,000, surely neither the Taoiseach nor the Tánaiste would suggest that the percentage shown in Britain applies to this country. They should check their figures before they trot them out in this House; if they do not, somebody else will.

If there are people who are unemployed because of illness or age or who suffered the heartbreak of going year after year to a labour exchange looking for the job that was not there, we should put these people into a special category and give them disability assistance and take them off the exchange books. Either these people are there or they are not. If they are there, it is legitimate to count them.

Redundancy has been mentioned and it has been suggested that even if there have been 8,000 redundancies it is not too bad because the people concerned are getting paid. What good is redundancy pay to a person of 50 or 60 years who has lost his job? Such a person knows that when he goes home with his insurance card and with the few pounds of redundancy pay he will never see a day's work again if this Government remain in power.

We have a Government Party who years ago stated that people over 40 years of age could not apply for a permanent job in State employment, even as a labourer. That has now been taken up by private enterprise and the position is that people who reach 50 years of age have no hope on earth of being re-employed. These people suffer tremendous heartbreak when they are forced to go home and tell their wives and families that they have lost their jobs, that they have no hope of getting other jobs and that they may have to emigrate. Then the Taoiseach tells us that, of course, they are not doing this, they are not emigrating now. However, it will be all right because when we enter the EEC they can go to Germany, Holland or some place else where there may be jobs available for them.

What about the break-up of family life as a result of all this? Nobody seems to worry, most certainly the Government do not worry. However, the Labour Party, whose main job it is to see to it that the ordinary people get a fair deal, will do everything in their power to prevent that from happening. We will do everything we can to put Fianna Fáil out of office. It is long overdue.

The Taoiseach spoke about retraining. Would someone tell me if any effort has been made to retrain anyone? Where has this retraining taken place? At the present time in my constituency work is commencing on the biggest mine in Europe, perhaps in the world. One would think that with so many people unemployed this would provide an opportunity for training people to take up well-paid jobs within the next two, three or four years, jobs which possibly they could hold for the rest of their lives. What is happening? This has not been suggested. Neither the educational authorities, nor the Department of Labour, nor anybody else, suggested that any effort should be made to train people for this work. When the time comes they will go in as unskilled labourers and bit by bit they will pick up the skills that are needed and, perhaps, in four or five years time they will be able to earn as much as they could earn at the start if they were properly trained. Is this not the Government's responsibility? Apparently they just do not care. They are not unemployed yet.

We must make sure that employment is made available for those who are prepared to accept it. The Taoiseach suggested yesterday—and at first I thought I did not hear him aright— that an extra £50 million was being made available. He said that next year's capital programme was being brought forward and that the figure to be made available as from now was £240 million. Is this some trick-of-the-loop for which Fianna Fáil are famous? Is he telling us that the money which is now being made available will be available for a period of 15 months? Is he telling us that from now on the money will be spent and that later on, if the money happens to run out, that is just too bad? Is he telling us that the schemes which have been in the Department of Local Government, the Department of Health and the Office of Public Works, some of them for a year and some of them for two years, will be undertaken immediately and that money will be made available for housing schemes in, for example, Athboy in my own constituency? Is he telling us that the sewerage and water schemes—for example, in Mornington in my own area, in Navan and all over the country—will be undertaken? Will the money be made available for schemes that are already planned, or will we have the trick which has been played on these people so often of saying: "The money is there. We will sanction the scheme," and six months later they are still considering whether they will allow a loan to be arranged for the purpose of carrying out the work?

Is the Taoiseach saying to us that any local authority who apply for money for a scheme which they are ready to start can have that money? If he is, let him say so. Let us have no more shilly-shallying. The situation is similar with regard to schools and hospitals. Many improvements and additions are urgently required. Are we being told that the money is now available and that work can start on them? We should be told these things. We do not want a situation to arise in which in six months time the officials of the Departments will be sitting around discussing whether they will sanction payment for the jobs which should be started now. They will not be started and everybody in the Department will be hoping that the fact that sanction was promised will be forgotten and somewhere towards the end of next year the money might be spent if the Government are still in office. I should like definite assurances on those matters and I think we are entitled to them.

There has been criticism by a number of people, and particularly by the Taoiseach and the Tánaiste, about what the Taoiseach called the scare stories of the Labour Party. I want to put this on record. Is it not a fact that because of the pressure which the Labour Party put on the Taoiseach and the Government, this debate is taking place? Is it not taking place because we insisted that these matters should be discussed here? We read in the papers that a reprieve has been granted, even for a month in some cases, to workers who were to be laid off. Must the credit for that not go to the people who requested a debate here and particularly to the Leader of the Labour Party, Deputy Corish, who insisted that it should take place? I do not want to take from the Fine Gael proposals because they were equally interested. The only people who did not seem to be interested were the Government. I hope they will be interested when the debate finishes.

There is one aspect of the reprieves I have just mentioned on which I should like some information. We have been criticising and condemning the fact that the Government do not seem to have made any arrangements for what they call fire-brigade action for the industry that is likely to fail. As far as I understand it, the instructions issued many years ago by the Fianna Fáil Minister for Finance, and repeated at intervals since, that those who are responsible for doling out grants or loans from the State must do so in a most conservative way, and that the profitability of a company is the first thing to be taken into consideration, are still in force. I want to know if there has been any change in those instructions. Has there been any suggestion that the question of the social good of continued employment in an industry should get priority?

I hate referring to individual firms here but in Dennys in Waterford notice was issued without any consultation. Have the Government any plans to provide employment for those workers who have now got a reprieve of one month? Can the 300 workers in Dennys be assured that the Government are attempting to find alternative employment for them, or is this reprieve intended to get them over the evil day until this debate is over in the hope that everybody will then forget it? Unlike other parts of the country where there might be some prospects of employment even in a couple of years time, I cannot see 300 workers finding re-employment in Waterford unless a big effort is made and unless the money is made available to reemploy them.

The Government have the old capitalist notion that the profit motive is the prime objective and that if a firm make a profit they are entitled to live, and that if a firm do not make a profit, and are just ticking over, even if they are keeping a substantial number of people in employment, they must die. This seems to be the Government's attitude. I suggest that they should change that attitude as quickly as possible. Rethinking on their role is definitely needed in the Department of Finance. I cannot see any way of getting out of the morass in which we are at present except by making a lot of money available to ensure that industries that have been giving big employment and whose social benefit to the country is tremendous are enabled to remain in existence. If they cannot it is the responsibility of the State to take them over, to give adequate compensation to those who own them, and keep them in existence because otherwise we will have continuing unemployment.

Lest I forget it, yesterday afternoon when the Taoiseach was saying 5,000 people were unemployed last December, and almost the same figure the previous year, he conveniently forgot the extra 9,000 who had gone on to the register in the previous year. He did not want anyone to remember that. I should like to remind him of it now. In addition to the 5,000 there are 9,000 more. Can he explain those figures away as glibly? Indeed, with regard to any plans which the Government may have for industry, I have grave doubts as to whether they are really serious at all.

To take rationalisation, for instance, we had guarantees that no unemployment or redundancy would result from rationalisation. While we all favour rationalisation, it must be said that the people who gave those guarantees had no idea what they were talking about. Certainly, these people were not prepared to stand over what was happening. We know that so far as creameries are concerned rationalisation will be responsible for the loss of 500 jobs during the next 12 months, that in the flour mills it will be responsible for the loss of 100 jobs, and that in the fertiliser industry it will be responsible for the loss of 200 jobs.

Regarding fertilisers, I might say that, despite the fact that Albatros have 50,000 tons in stock, a licence for the importation of 9,000 tons was granted during the past week. Is that the way the Government intend living up to their responsibilities? Is that what they mean when they talk about guaranteeing further employment? Apparently all that is at the back of their minds is the question of expediency—how to get out of an awkward corner at a particular time and while so doing to help their friends. The question of issuing licences is one that will have to be investigated since apparently there is "something rotten in the State of Denmark".

The Government give the ordinary people of the country credit for much less intelligence than they actually have. I meet many people and, unlike Government Ministers, the people I associate with are those who live in labourers' cottages, as they are called, or those who live on small farms— people, perhaps, who do not live in what could be described as very nice housing conditions. When I talk to these people I am amazed at how much they know. Ten or 15 years ago the propaganda meted out to them might have been accepted but that situation no longer exists and people realise what is happening. I warn Fianna Fáil that, unless they make a definite effort to improve the present situation, not only will they be defeated at the next election but many of them will never be heard of again.

No matter what happens now, it is the responsibility of the Government to find employment quickly. The Taoiseach told us glibly yesterday again that an extra 3,000 people would be recruited to the Garda and the Army. This is the first time I have ever heard of any Government offering recruitment to the Army as a solution to the problem of unemployment, although one country which shall remain nameless at one time solved her unemployment problem by introducing compulsory military service for everybody less than a certain age. Is that the suggestion here? I was surprised that the Taoiseach did not give a breakdown of the 3,000 and tell us exactly how many people are to be taken into each force. I am aware that extra gardaí are needed urgently but I would suggest that if the available gardaí were not employed to such an extent on the protection of blackleg lorries from Northern Ireland who come to this part of the country and strikebreak, more gardaí would be available for ordinary duties. I should like to know, too, if the Government have forgotten completely what is happening with regard to tourism. The amount being made available for tourism at present is about £4 million. The industry earns for us about £100 million. Can anybody suggest seriously that an investment of £4 million so as to earn £100 million is a reasonable investment?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Donnell

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

The amount should be trebled. This would mean more jobs in the industry and would mean also the consumption by tourists of much more of our food products, not to mention the consumption of drink. The Government, also, must make an attempt to spend money on television advertising in Britain if they wish tourists from Britain to come here. If I had sufficient time I would speak about a particular programme that I saw recently on the BBC 1 channel. That programme, undoubtedly, was more effective in promoting this country than anything I have seen on any other station, including our own.

Number one on the Government's programme must be the question of public works. This is the quickest and the easiest way of relieving the situation, but there is no point in waiting. Action must be taken immediately and the Ministers responsible should be given the OK to make the necessary money available. This must be done now before the people lose heart completely in the country. I am thinking in particular of roads, schools, the housing industry and hospitals. It is necessary also that an effort be made to ascertain which industries are in trouble and whether, on a cost analysis basis, it would be better to retain them in operation than to let them go by the board. Let us not have poker-faced young men sitting across a table quizzing unfortunate managers who call on them for the purpose of ascertaining whether there is any hope of borrowing more money so that people might be kept in employment. We have had enough of that during the past few years. Tourism must be used for the purpose of trying to increase employment. There is vast potential in that regard in the industry. Those who say that the troubles in the North are responsible for all the difficulties are being nonsensical. There are many people who would be glad to come here on holidays if only they would be given a fair deal and one of the means of offering potential tourists a fair deal is by subsidising the air fares between Great Britain and here. If Aer Lingus or BEA will not do this, the Government should do it because the cross-Channel fares are scandalous and this applies to some extent to the sea route, too.

These, then, are a number of ways of creating employment. Many people have either been laid off or are under notice by the local authorities. County managers should be issued with orders that there be no further redundancies and that those who have been laid off be re-employed. If necessary the money could be made available at a later date but the instructions should be issued now. With the exception of those who have retired on the grounds of illness or age, there should be re-employment, too, in the Forestry Division. I understand that the Board of Works in particular got only a very small amount of money. Let there not be expensive machines eating up the money which is made available for employment while unfortunate men and women are queuing up outside the employment exchanges. Anyone who has passed by any one of the exchanges during the past week will have seen the unfortunate people standing outside in heavy rain. Those people would be happy to find employment but they are being denied the opportunity to work because of the mismanagement of this country by the present Government.

Comment on this

This debate was requested for the purpose of drawing attention to the gravity of the present situation. In consideration of the problem it would not help either to exaggerate or to minimise the situation, but obviously there is an urgent need for long-term planning and not for ad hoc measures. The seriousness of the present situation, resulting in the highest numbers on the unemployment register for much more than a decade, highlights the urgency of dealing with the problem. Because of that urgency and because of the numbers who are unemployed. We have approached the matter without making any attempt either to exaggerate the difficulties or to minimise the consequences of having so many people on the unemployment register. It was, therefore, a surprise to us that yesterday the Taoiseach endeavoured, by using certain statistical data, to play down the actual figures on the unemployment register. He sought to do that by two main examples, one the 11,000 persons on the unemployment register who are married women registering for work and the other the figure of 5,000 persons who are over 65 years of age. These numbers have been on the register constantly this year, last year and a decade ago. There might be a minor change of a few hundred here or there but that is a constant factor.

It is also a constant factor that on the unemployment register are those who are incapable of work or chronically unemployed. In other words, these are not variables. It indicates the complacency with which the Government face this grave situation that faced with these facts the Taoiseach should have endeavoured to minimise the gravity of the situation by picking out a number of persons on the register who have been on it in similar numbers for years, indeed, for decades.

This situation has primarily arisen because of two or three principal factors on the economic scene. It is now apparent that the unemployment numbers in Britain are the highest for 30 years, that they approach approximately 1,000,000 unemployed, that that had an effect on the numbers emigrating because of the lack of job opportunities in Britain. At the same time, the numbers out of work in the United States and, indeed, in other countries is the highest for many years.

Coupled with that there is the fact that the Government themselves have operated here a series of stop-go policies over the past number of years. We have only to look at the very recent budgetary proposals. In the autumn of last year a budget was brought in which was designed initially as a package deal. It had two sides to it—a heavy increase in Government taxation on companies and otherwise and a proposal to operate a prices and incomes policy. Because of the opposition to the prices and incomes policy that portion was scrapped but the company taxation provisions were continued. That resulted in problems for a number of factories.

I want to advert now to the number of cases where it was known for a long period that problems would arise for industry. These problems were known to the Government, to the Department of Industry and Commerce, to AnCO and to the other State organisations dealing with these matters because they were the subject of CIO investigations in a number of instances many years ago. One example that has been referred to here repeatedly is the bacon industry. We have been told that it faces a period of rationalisation and that we have too many bacon factories because of modern methods of production. One of the major problems the bacon factories have is to re-equip, redesign and modernise themselves. The difficulty of doing that for industry has been increased by the increase in company taxation imposed in the supplementary budget last year which the Government themselves recognised at the end of last year as a mistake and made a modification in it.

We have put forward a number of proposals, all of them designed to ease the situation and to provide a solution to the problems that at present face the country. We have listed them under nine headings or so. The first is—and this has been reinforced by comments that have been made this week at the first annual economic conference of the Confederation of Irish Industry—that if we are to plan ahead effectively and if we are to have long-term planning and not ad hoc measures then the first step is to convene under Government auspices a meeting between employers and the trade union organisation, first of all, to deal with threatened redundancies, to ensure that there is a postponement until the position is examined as a matter of urgency and, secondly, to review with the employers' representatives and the representatives of the trade unions the immediate wage and salary situation, the income situation for the coming 12 or 18 months and to review in the light of that the problem of rising prices and rising costs, to review in conjunction with the IDA and AnCO an expansion of alternative employment in areas that are affected and to introduce, if necessary, legislation so as to minimise and to provide adequate notice, not less than a month, in respect of redundancies. We have recommended that there should be, as a matter of urgency, discussions between the Government and the trade unions and the employers.

At this juncture I want to ask what has happened to the NIEC. That body has been dormant because of disputes and dissensions. Because of the attempt by the Government some years ago to nominate hand-picked representatives of the farming organisations it failed to get off the ground. The time has now come to revive the NIEC on a properly representative basis or to establish a new body with comparable responsibility representing adequately and with authority to speak and act for industry, for the trade unions and for agriculture. In conjunction with a body of that sort discussions must be held with a view to recognising the weaknesses in the economy and taking the necessary steps to deal with them.

The result of the stop-go policies has been that there is uncertainty and confusion. Why does it get to the stage in which the unemployment register is swollen? Why does it get to the stage when local authorities cannot get sanction for housing schemes? Why does it get to the stage when school managers, religious orders and other bodies cannot get sanction for schools? Why does the crisis have to be reached or near crisis conditions before the Government is jerked into action? That is bad economically; it is bad socially, and it is bad no matter what angle it is approached from.

This capital programme of building and construction is not a thing that can be turned on overnight. You cannot suddenly build schools, build houses, build hospitals or complete or develop extensions to them on a few hours' notice or a week's or a month's notice. If these plans were properly co-ordinated, if it was known in advance where the likely slack would occur, where it was obvious that housing schemes were being completed, and that within a measurable distance of time work would cease then it would be possible for those concerned or those directly affected, either the local authorities in the case of housing or the Federation of Builders, to discuss with the appropriate Departments when work was likely to cease in particular schemes and when it would be ready to proceed in other schemes.

Look at the situation in the schools. There is nothing but chaos and confusion about what will happen. Nobody knows whether they are to be community schools, comprehensive schools, vocational schools. Sanction cannot be given for them because nobody knows what will happen. In my constituency of Dún Laoghaire/ Rathdown the people concerned want to go ahead with plans for primary schools, secondary schools, vocational schools, both in regard to new schools and extensions, and in nearly every case they are held up because the Department have not made up their minds whether they will have a community school here, a comprehensive school there, or what numbers are involved. That is an intolerable situation which is imposing an unfair burden on those responsible for the schools and on parents and pupils. This must be resolved and resolved quickly.

Everybody knows there has been a go slow on sanction from the Department of Local Government. Plans go up, come back, are re-examined and re-submitted. That has been the continual pattern not in the past few months but during the past few years. There has been an intolerable delay in getting sanction for building in relation to houses. The same is true in relation to hospitals. Nobody knows what the policy is in regard to new hospitals. Nobody knows anything about what their grading will be or what their status will be.

No politician is preventing these decisions. No member of the Opposition parties is involved in frustrating these decisions. This must be a matter for Government decision. Perhaps it is that the Minister for Health cannot make up his mind because of the mistaken decision to establish regional health authorities which are now incubi of bureaucrats and semi-bureaucrats, people remote from contact with the people, who cannot make up their minds either among themselves or in regard to medical authorities about where hospitals are to be located and the numbers they are to cater for.

That is an intolerable situation and it has arisen not because of any criticism from this side of the House or from any groups but from the absolute incompetence of the Government to make up their minds. This has caused immense problems for the people concerned, this failure to take a decision one way or another. The late Seán Lemass, either in Government or in Opposition, always preached that any decision is better than no decision, but he has left behind him a team who cannot decide anything on any matter, great or small, except to keep one eye on a colleague and the other on the electorate. We have a pitiful pedestrian team of incompetents unable to discharge the duties for which they were elected. That is a fact that no amount of talk or statistics can camouflage or hide.

Look at the Department of Finance. We are told there will be a go ahead in regard to schemes of development. We all know there are hundreds of workers, retired State employees, the people who retired a month ago, six months ago or nine months ago, who are still waiting for their pensions or gratuities. There is not a Deputy who has not been approached by those people and the volume of correspondence from the Department of Finance that goes to and fro is an example of the dead hand of that Department in regard to the weakest section of the community. I know of cases from the Board of Works in Dún Laoghaire. Everybody else knows retired State employees, whether from the Post Office, the Board of Works or elsewhere, who have had to wait for months to get a decision in regard to a gratuity or pension.

The facts in relation to these men should have been known: one does not need a computer to assess what they are entitled to, the amount of gratuity they are entitled to get when they retire. It is possible that, because of illness or delay in ascertaining their service, there would be some delay in ascertaining the full amounts; but surely a decision could be taken to pay them a certain amount now and the balance later. If the Government are unable to come to a decision in regard to these small things what can we expect from them in regard to major matters?

There is no section of the community who have been affected more by the rise in the cost of living than pensioners and others on fixed incomes. They have been put to the wall in the last few years. I want to reemphasise that in the last three years the increase in consumer prices here was substantially higher than in any other European country with which we have trading relations. In the three years it went up here by 29 per cent, substantially higher than in any other country. That is a phenomenal increase from the point of view of people with fixed incomes.

We have discussed this not only on the annual Estimates but in Budget debates when the usual annual increases are given to pensioners. We know that the giving of these increases always has been postponed for six months and sometimes nine months. We know that the increases given have applied only to certain categories. I now urge immediate action to deal with pensions of State employees, ex-Army personnel, exgardaí, ex-civil servants, retired employees of the Board of Works and the Post Office, whose pensions were fixed when wages, salaries and the cost of living were lower. Army pensions were fixed many years ago and many of them have not qualified under changes made and increases given in recent times.

I want the Government to further consider getting an arrangement in which the changes in salaries and wages will be operated to give a larger increase to pensioners and lower paid workers and a smaller one to those whose incomes are higher. I appreciate that this will require time and would undoubtedly meet with certain difficulties, but I am convinced it would be in line with the generally accepted aims of social justice that those worst off would have their situation taken into account.

I want to repeat that it is essential there should be a conference between all interested parties. By all interested parties I do not mean politicians. I mean the Government, the trade unions and the employers. The purpose of the discussions would be to work out arrangements. We are all involved in this because it goes to the heart of the problem of arranging not only wage and salary adjustments but the entire income situation during the next 12 to 18 months.

Recently we had a lengthy conference on a number of aspects of the economic situation. It was attended by people who are not, as we are, directly concerned in politics. A number of sober facts were produced at that conference by people who had examined the matter, people who were not speaking as politicians. Some of them were neither businessmen nor trade unionists. They had no particular viewpoint to express in the sense of representing one section or the other. They adverted to the fact that salaries and wages here had risen in 1970 by 13 per cent and the profits in rents had gone up by 9 per cent and the conclusion that the reader of this paper came to was that if we continued to take more out of the economy than we were putting into it the problem that was created would be created for everybody. It was not a problem for one section or the other. The reader of the paper took both sides and the fact that one section got more than the other was not the real point. The real point concerned both sides.

When we examine further the speech made by Mr. Carroll, a former Governor of the Bank of Ireland, we see that he referred to the same problem and said what we have repeatedly said and what is now being reinforced by the facts not only of the bacon industry but of many others. Mr. Carroll said that it is obvious that profit must be made after wages and salaries are paid and enough profit must be made and enough money left in the business to re-equip and modernise. It is obvious that the decisions taken by the Government were not correct.

A policy was adopted 12 months ago and was reversed within a year. There was lack of thought behind that policy. It increased company taxation here to a level higher than in Britain. It also made such tax retrospective. Firms that had closed their accounts had to reopen them. Firms which had already entered into commitments and were in difficulties with regard to the cash to meet them had to go back over their accounts, reopen them and take money that would have been available for re-equipment, readaptation and modernisation and pay it to the State. The decision to make the tax retrospective was unique not merely in this country but in any of the countries with which we trade on a large basis. The decision was reversed within a year. Steps were taken to go the other way. This problem goes to the root of the present situation in respect of many industries.

One of the difficulties in referring to this situation is that nobody wants to make it any worse. If industries are mentioned we mention them generally rather than mention specific units. The textile industry is another case in point. Readaptation and re-equipment are positively and inevitably necessary. The relocation of workers and factories will be required if that industry is not merely to preserve employment but in some cases even to continue in existence. These decisions should not have been postponed. There was no justification for postponing them. The CIO investigation showed years ago that the problem would arise and was arising. Failure to take decisions has now precipitated a crisis in respect of employment and workers.

We have advocated public expenditure in the knowledge that expenditure of a public character is paid for by money raised from the people. Such money does not come from Ministers' or Deputies' pockets, except as ordinary taxpayers. Because public money is raised from the people it should be spent wisely and not wasted. Decisions should be taken in the light of the best opinion available.

I emphasise the absolute confusion that exists in respect of schools and hospitals. At a number of points in each constituency there is confusion over the schools situation. In every health authority there is lack of decision. There has been failure to take decisions in respect of the hospitals. This is responsible for wasteful expenditure because a number of schools are proceeding with plans and wish to implement them. In some cases they are going ahead under their own auspices while waiting for a decision on policy from the Department of Education.

We have advocated a number of other changes in respect of specific details. We have proposed that there should be a review of the redundancy situation. The Government surely know what will happen about the meat subsidy in the light of possible EEC membership. The subsidy arrangements require to be reviewed as a matter of urgency. If we go into the Common Market a great deal of the present problem will disappear. There is a strong case for anticipating that situation and taking remedial action. It is tragic that meat factories are laying off staff when the industry is likely to expand. If there is one factor which emerges more than another from the economic statistics of recent times it is the unprecedented demand for livestock. Prices are rising and reaching heights which are causing concern to those in the trade as well as those outside it. There is an obvious need for an urgent investigation in order to evolve a system which would prevent the laying off for what must be a temporary period of workers. The workers must be tided over the immediate future. Arrangements should be made for action to be taken so that when the trade develops in the changed circumstances it will be in a position to meet it.

The other major action which should be taken concerns the Anglo-Irish Free Trade Area Agreement. There is no doubt that we are entitled to take action. Such action should be taken vigorously and assertively. A few years ago the British were quick enough, in breach of the agreement, to impose a levy. They imposed a special import deposit levy on goods from abroad going into Britain. We should not wait until workers are being laid off, and until they are suffering uncertainty and anguish, before taking action.

The announcement made a few weeks ago by the Minister for Industry and Commerce came far too late. It was another example of how slow the Government were in reacting. This particular aspect was mentioned in the course of the speech made earlier this week by Mr. Carroll to the Confederation of Irish Industries. He said :

For years past there appears to have been little in the way of a strategic plan for the economy; all the evidence suggests that political considerations were in the ascendant and that the time scale of thought in Government circles related to the old adage that a month is a lifetime in politics. So much Government action appears to have been a grudging response to events rather than a firm, clear intent to pursue a broad consistent strategy towards some defined objective.

That criticism pinpoints the failure of the Government, in the light of the information available and in the light of the CIO investigations, to take action. Certainly action should have been taken immediately the situation showed signs of deterioration. Our priorities in this matter should be made absolutely clear in any discussions with the British Government.

In regard to developing the economy, we have advocated that bank interest rates should be reduced. They are now higher here than in Britain. All industries, but particularly the construction industry and industries that wish to expand or are involved in capital development of one sort or another, find that the present high interest rates are a deterrent, that they are a limiting or inhibiting factor.

We also advocated—and it is my view that it is a sound national policy —the strengthening of the Army and the Garda. We have advocated that for years but not as a means of solving the employment problem. There is a case on its own for increasing the strength of the Army and the Garda. This time two years ago in my own constituency and later in this House I advocated a massive increase in the number of Garda, that it was essential for the protection of the public and for the effective and efficient carrying out of their duties.

The same applies in respect of the Army. This State owes a great deal to the Army and the Garda. They should be properly paid, and it is ludicrous to suggest that persons who are going to be recruited into the Army and the Garda are suddenly going to be clothed because they have not been clothed before, as was suggested by the Taoiseach yesterday. They would obviously require uniforms.

The other requirement is the stepping up of State investment. This does not merely apply to housing, to schools and to hospitals. There are many schemes for drainage, for afforestation, for land reclamation, for local authority works schemes, schemes that were abandoned, schemes that were rejected. These schemes provided, particularly in the off season, work in rural areas, drainage work ancillary to arterial drainage. They did a whole lot of work on schemes ancillary to land reclamation and on ordinary farm drainage schemes. These schemes should be re-examined and, with the co-operation of the Office of Public Works, the Department of Lands or the Department of Agriculture, work initiated on them.

We also believe that the decision to increase company taxation should be reversed quickly and notice should be given in advance that it is proposed to reverse it. We should achieve a position here in which our tax structure is at least as favourable as it is in Britain. We have many disadvantages because of the size of our market, because of structural problems of one character or another, that make it much more difficult for industries here to compete with industries in Britain or on the Continent. The fact that there was no justification for this decision is reinforced now by the evidence of workers being laid off in a variety of industries and by the problems that have been created for industry. As has been said here, it is necessary to put money back into industries to enable them to re-equip and modernise themselves. We could take three major cases at the moment: the milling industry, to which Deputy Tully referred, the bacon industry, and the textile industry. In all of these cases, not in every factory, not in every town or district but in the industry as a whole, there is a need for re-equipment and modernisation. Unless adequate profits can be earned and are permitted to be earned, the proprietors of these businesses will not have the wherewithal to modernise.

In this connection, I believe the trade union and employers' organisations have a duty and an obligation to get together. There is no conflict of interest here. As a number of speakers have said, it does not matter whether we operate an extreme leftist communist society or an extreme rightist capitalist society; whatever system is operated wealth must be created before it can be distributed. Yesterday I got replies to statistical questions which indicated where our trading interests are, which indicated the magnitude of the problem we have. What cannot be emphasised too strongly or too clearly is that specific measures must be implemented in order to reverse the present weekly rise in unemployment. As long as some action has not been taken which can be taken and which should be taken to put people back to work, then the Government are failing in the discharge of their duty.

Another consideration I want to emphasise is that no one owes us a living or will provide it for us, that we shall have to earn it. The realities of the trading world are that it is a competitive world in which the rewards go to the energetic and enterprising who show skill and initiative. There is no simple solution, but the worst state of all would be to do nothing about it; the worst state of all would be to get into the position this Government is in, impotent to act until, as was said so often, events are upon us.

Any Government on top of the job, any Government having available as much assistance as this Government have had, the reports of a variety of bodies, having the co-operation and goodwill of everyone interested in the welfare of the country and whose only limiting factor is their own inability to work together——

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

Shut up.

Comment on this

——and evolve a plan that will be effective and purposeful——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy may not refer to any Member of the House in such terms. The Deputy will withdraw that phrase.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

I asked: "What did you do?" Nothing.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy will withdraw that phrase.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

What was it?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy does not want me to repeat it. He knows quite well what it was.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

If you mention the phrase I will withdraw it.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy used a derogatory phrase.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

I do not know what the phrase was.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy referred to a Deputy of this House as an idiot. The Deputy will withdraw that phrase. If the Deputy does not withdraw it the Chair will ask him to leave the House. Is the Deputy withdrawing it?

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

I suppose I will.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

There is no supposing. The Chair insists.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

I suppose I will. I will.

Comment on this

As I was saying, there is no easy solution to this problem, but the worst attitude of all would be to do nothing and hope that something will turn up and that things will improve in Britain. The economic indices and the forecasts of changes in Britain are more optimistic than they have been for some time. That does not mean that our problems will be solved by them. It may make the economic climate easier and the going more progressive, but what is now required is action, positive and progressive, designed to provide sound, realistic schemes for steady economic development, schemes that will result in action being taken to expand the public works programme; to discuss, as I have said, with the employers and trade unions concerned the prospects for the next 18 months; to discuss, in conjunction with the interests concerned, a plan that will prevent the continuous recurrence of stop-go policies, the salient feature of the last two years. It is interesting to note that the one over-riding, consistent theme which emerged from the discussion with the Confederation of Irish Industry was that the present problems have arisen in the last two years. Possibly some symptoms emerged at the end of 1969 but the bulk of them were prevalent in 1970 and 1971.

During that period—I have avoided making any criticism or suggestion about the Government—we know the situation which existed. We know the Government have been preoccupied with internal problems and the lack of effective, purposeful leadership is obvious in the present serious economic situation in which we have a steep rise in the cost of living, a steep rise in unemployment, in which there is uncertainty, a lack of confidence and a lack of a common economic plan.

Reference was made to the production of the first economic plan which arose out of the decision of my colleagues and myself to establish the capital, advisory and other committees. The result of their deliberations was the basis for the first plan which was produced. Since then nothing has happened. The present situation, the continuance of stop-go policies, is neither in the interests of one section of the community nor another. Even at this stage the Government should take the necessary measures. There is ample co-operation from every side of the House, from employers and from trade unions. The need is for leadership. If the Government cannot give it let them make way for those who will.

Comment on this
Joseph Brennan Minister for Labour and Social Welfare (Mr. J. Brennan) Fianna Fáil

I should like to refer to some factors which in the long term, anyhow, would be calculated to improve the general situation. I do this for the purpose of answering those who said, which of course they do not for a moment believe, that the Government were simply doing nothing. It is a very simple phrase, very easy to express. If there is a bit of adversity around it is always good to blame it on the Government.

The situation regarding the unemployment register is that we have 77,891 unemployed this afternoon, which is an increase of 90 compared with 351 for the corresponding week of last year. This is the situation in which we have devoted two days to discuss, ostensibly, what should be done or how grave the situation is. I was naturally most interested in the debate and I listened carefully to all the speakers. While all of them started off by saying it was not an occasion for playing politics, the main purpose of all Opposition speeches was to point out that the Government were doing nothing, that the leadership was wrong, that we had two great leaders in the past in the persons of Mr. de Valera and Mr. Lemass and that we have not such leadership any more. I do not intend to pursue that theme but I was in the House during the periods when those men held the office of Taoiseach and I listened to debates during that time. They were of the same type we had here today and yesterday. I did not hear one single word of praise from people who poured filth and scorn on the same two leaders on every occasion they could. What was not said about them was not worth saying. When you are dead it is a different thing. People, in order to try to denigrate the efforts of somebody, compare him with those whom they know are gone.

Comment on this

Only one of them is dead.

Comment on this

Both are gone from here. The Taoiseach announced a number of measures that will be taken in the short term to alleviate the position regarding the rise in the figure for unemployed which is greater than the rise has been for some time. However, this seasonal increase was at all times, and should have been at all times, a cause for serious concern. If we look at the figures for various years we find that in springtime the figures rose to their highest and around June they were down to their lowest figure. We find quite a number of years worse than the one we are now discussing.

I do not intend to pursue that theme either. Deputy Corish anticipated me when he was speaking. We set out to compile figures for unemployed in 1933, when the Unemployment Assistance Acts were brought in, and for the first time tabs were put on unemployed people, people who expressed themselves as being available for employment and who were unable to obtain it. The figure at that stage, shortly after Fianna Fáil took office, was a colossal one.

Comment on this

What was it?

Comment on this

It was 133,000.

Comment on this

What was the percentage?

Comment on this

Of the work force at the time it was a much higher percentage than it is now.

Comment on this

It was 5 per cent of the work force and it is now 10 per cent.

Comment on this

It was 5 per cent of a practically non-existent work force. The work force at present is 1,134,000. This is the last official figure issued by the Statistics Office, for April, 1970. The employed are in the following categories: mining, quarries, turf, 10,000; building and construction, 74,000; electricity, gas and water, 13,000; commerce, insurance and finance, 172,000; transport, communications, 60,000; other non-agricultural activities, 169,000—those not mentioned in the categories already given; total, other domestic, 555,000; manufacturing industries, 220,000; agriculture, forestry, fishing, 291,000; total: 1,066,000.

Comment on this

Is there not a monthly figure which could be added to or subtracted from that figure?

Comment on this

The figure of unemployed at that time was 68,000 which is a serious one at any time. We are all supposed to be striving to reach the stage of full employment. Deputy Cosgrave spoke for a long time about everybody getting together and working out a plan for what should be done and could be done at this time. Surely to goodness neither he nor any other Member of this House believes that that was not done 100 times in this country.

I have in my hand the 18th report of the NIEC on full employment. The NIEC was constituted by men fully competent and capable of examining the situation. There were members from the top echelon of the Congress of Trade Unions, from the FUE, from State bodies. There were also Government appointees. They did an excellent job. They laid down in black and white the essential concomitants to full employment and they mapped out the course we should follow. They did not come up with any instant solution. I think Deputy Cosgrave read one paragraph from the report that he did not really mean to. At page 110 of the report the views of the NIEC are summed up:

In our view, there is no recipe for reaching full employment easily, quickly and painlessly. The other major objectives of economic policy must be related to the achievement of full employment, and the full employment perspective in Section III shows in broad terms what could happen if this were done. The main characteristics of the perspective are a continuing increase in the numbers employed at rising standards of living, soundly based on a price and cost structure which is competitive, and with the economy increasingly capable of maintaining full employment and sustaining the expansion of output from its own resources. If all these things are to be achieved, there must be substantial annual increases in output per worker, in the productivity of investment, in savings and exports, and probably in the net capital inflow—and these, in their turn, will be difficult, and will take time, to achieve.

Later, at paragraph 151, they point out:

If sectional interests are not to be pressed to the point where national loss outweighs sectional gain, there must be a deeper sense of personal and corporate responsibility... Full employment will not be achieved without a fuller sense of social interdependence and national identity... In the past a coherent sense of national purpose has developed only rarely, and then only for short periods and under stress of adversity.

A coherent sense of national purpose— was it, I wonder, a coherent sense of national purpose which dictated the debate that has taken place here over the last two days or was that merely an attempt to label the Government with responsibility for the situation? These people on the NIEC knew as much about how to tackle the economy as anybody else. They were the leaders of trade unionism, leading employers, personnel from State-sponsored bodies and Government appointees and they pointed out that there is no immediate solution and full employment can be achieved only by the co-operation of all concerned—the workers, the employers and the Government.

We have a system of free collective bargaining in our wages and incomes structure. That has been held out as an ideal system and we have been careful in the Government not to interfere unless interference is absolutely necessary. We have made institutions available to process difficulties and arrive at an amicable solution. The system has been worked. How it has worked is another question. After the last war we started what are called "rounds". We had the first, the second and the third round and then we began to wonder in which round we would be knocked out.

Comment on this

Does the Minister mean the Government started?

Comment on this

We, the people. We adopted a system of rounds.

Comment on this

After a Standstill Order.

Comment on this

Yes. We had the seventh, the eighth, the ninth and the tenth rounds. We were talking in terms of 10s then and eventually we got to £1.

Comment on this

Five shillings for road-workers and Mr. MacEntee took 6s off them.

Comment on this

I listened patiently to the Deputies. These later increases were pretty heavy at a time when the economy was not as buoyant as it was afterwards when we injected more money into industry. Up to the eighth and ninth rounds the increases granted were more than absorbed by increased output and by increased production.

Comment on this

That was the 12 per cent recommended by Seán Lemass.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Order.

Comment on this

At the beginning of the last decade, when the economy really began to move, demands began to increase. Each time the demand was for more and more. People like Mr. Don Carroll generalise; he talked in a general way but he did not suggest any remedy. In fact, the employers were not too helpful in many cases and, as the demands became bigger and bigger, the large firms settled with comparative ease because they had the market power; they could sell anyhow. Many of them had protected markets. The smaller firms had to follow suit though they could not afford the increases. Time and again we pointed out that these increases, not justified by increased output, could not go on for ever. One did not need to be an expert economist to know that. One needed to know only the rudiments of economics to realise that this kind of thing could not continue. Sometimes when I reminded people of that across the table I was accused of crying "Wolf" and I was told that the wolf had never come. My reply was that it would be too late when he did come. Indeed, many people issued serious warnings. Even the Congress of Trade Unions issued warnings. They had Professor Fogarty to address them at Dún Laoghaire in March, 1970 on a prices policy. He pointed out in unmistakable language that unless wages and incomes were restrained and kept in a proper relationship to productivity prices could not be curbed.

Comment on this

But machines and management determine productivity now.

Comment on this

I am trying to explain to those people who have been saying that the Government are doing nothing and were not seeking advice that we had an overdose of expert advice from all the top economists of the country. Even in that report on full employment, one of the signatories was Garret FitzGerald.

Comment on this

What is wrong with that? That was five years ago.

Comment on this

He signed it five years ago and nothing was done about it.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Minister without interruptions.

Comment on this

Do not be worried about it. That report makes it perfectly clear, when Deputy O'Higgins says we did nothing about it, that it is mainly addressed to the people responsible for fixing wages and incomes by free collective bargaining.

Comment on this

Five years ago Dáil Éireann unanimously adopted a resolution from these benches——

Comment on this

That was given as a criterion to those in a position to deal with it. It was not the Government's job to force that down anybody's throat.

Comment on this

The Government have nothing to do with it; blame somebody else.

Comment on this

Absolutely nothing. I could quote from some of the Opposition statements in the House at the time when the Government brought in legislation to fix the amount of increase that was to be accepted that year. I know what they said then.

Comment on this

Is it the Minister's case that the trade union movement is responsible for the present number of unemployed?

Comment on this

Yes, the workers are responsible.

Comment on this

Those interrupting had their opportunity and made very little of it. They will listen now. I was tracing the history of the different rounds and the advice we got in regard to them. The advice of many people, including the Central Bank, the NIEC, the Government itself, the Economic and Social Research Institute, was available to all people at all times in regard to what should happen and very little heed was paid to it. We finally reached the stage when demands were so much out of line with anticipated production—I want to say this in relation to the First, Second and Third Programmes—

Comment on this

For God's sake, do not mention that.

Comment on this

It is all very well to make a horse laugh out of the Third Programme

Comment on this

You scrapped it long ago.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Minister must be allowed to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

You must have a programme; you must have targets and objectives. Every single programme points out, if anybody bothered to read it, that it was subject to reasonable restraint being exercised in the matter of incomes. The last programme makes it perfectly clear on either the front or the second page that inflationary tendencies could push it completely off course. It is not claimed for any programme that it is a target that will be directly hit. It is a plan containing realisable objectives which we justifiably set ourselves and without which no Government can work and without which it would be impossible to have a strategy by which to operate Government policy. That is what the programme states.

I was dealing with the trend in increases and wage rounds. We finally reached the stage where there were rumblings about an increase of £20 per week in the papers which appeared one day with headings to that effect. At that time, the management-labour conference were brought together and an effort made to get them to find a realistic figure which would not throw the economy completely out of line. They worked hard for some weeks and had many sittings but were unable to come up with an acceptable figure. At that stage the Government decided that there must be legislation.

Legislation came before this House and was being processed. We know the assistance we got from the Fine Gael benches which were saying: "What have the Government done about the Report on Full Employment? What have they done by way of getting advice?" We got no co-operation then from anybody on that side of the House. While the legislation was going through we had several approaches from the ICTU to withdraw the legislation——

Comment on this

Or else.

Comment on this

They did not. I want to say something about the withdrawal of that legislation because it has been used in different ways in this House. The Taoiseach, the Minister for Finance and I, met ICTU at least twice and they explained to us that it would be much better to have an agreement freely entered into and they would undertake to ensure it went through. One thing they said was: "Do not worry that it will be said that you are showing weakness in withdrawing that legislation." We were not back a week in the House when it was being thrown at us across the House that this was the sign of a weak government——

Comment on this

And correctly so. You ran away from it.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Minister, without interruptions.

Comment on this

Look at Deputy Haughey up there—what did he say?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Minister is entitled to be heard without interruption.

Comment on this

What did Deputy Ryan say?

Comment on this

I have only a limited time in which to speak. I allowed everybody who was speaking to do so without interruption.

Comment on this

Fair enough.

Comment on this

The Opposition made an effort and a damn bad one. They should not now try to cash in on my time. I remember when Deputy Dillon and other speakers on the benches opposite accused us of being an over-strong Government equivalent to a dictatorship. De Valera was a dictator, it was said, and it was the sign of a bad Government when it could not change a decision and listen to public appeals. That was the worst possible sign of a dictatorship. Now, it comes to a Government that listens to what the ICTU had to say. We told them to go back and discuss the matter at management-labour level again and if they could produce an acceptable figure and see it through as a national wage agreement, we would withdraw the legislation in toto. I was very much in favour of withdrawing it completely lest it would be said that having any vestige of it hanging over their heads would encourage somebody to break the line and say they were not free to negotiate.

We withdrew it completely. That was the first real effort that I remember to restore some sanity to the economic situation in regard to wage rounds since 1955. This was a real gettogether effort as we would have wished it to be. Remember that the amount agreed to was much more than the Government would wish it to be at that time because, as we pointed out, it had an inflationary element already in it. We also agreed that the previous wage round had not fully worked itself into the economy and that price increases must occur during the year. There was a clause written into the agreement to make provision for an automatic increase when the index went over a certain number of points.

It was an inflationary amount but it was worth going for because it represented the first major effort on behalf of the people concerned to have a national wage agreement. It must be said that all the parties to the agreement have made a serious effort to hold the line. I should like to say that, while it was not as low as would be necessary in order to curb inflation, it was an important step in the right direction.

There are people in this country, sections of the white collar workers not affiliated to Congress, who think they are above and beyond national agreements and that such agreements should not apply to them. The time has come when everyone, particularly those in responsible positions, must realise that a national agreement applies to everyone irrespective of whether they are affiliated to Congress. If this kind of agreement had been entered into years ago, if everyone had foreseen the gravity of the situation, we would not be discussing 70,000 or 80,000 unemployed.

Comment on this

Nobody got 10 per cent who was not included in the agreement?

Comment on this

I am not an economist but I have had occasion to listen to and read enough about them. Nobody has been able to point out to me how any country with a progressive economy can avoid the stop-go situation. If we had listened to reason in the past, in the years when things were going well, if people had not rushed into try to get too large a slice of the national cake, if we had allowed reason to influence our decisions, we would not be in this position now. If adversity will tend to bring about a situation in which we will listen to reason, the debate we have had in the last two days will have done some good.

There was talk about the damage done by the Anglo-Irish Free Trade Area Agreement. All speakers admitted that the industry most affected was the textile industry——

Comment on this

And footwear.

Comment on this

If the deterioration in the textile industry is due to the Anglo-Irish Free Trade Area Agreement, can Deputies explain why some of the biggest textile mills in England have closed in the last two years? Surely the serious textile recession in England was not caused by the agreement with Ireland? No matter how much political capital people try to make out of it, no matter how much we would like to minimise the situation, a good deal of what has happened was completely unavoidable so long as we are a country depending on exports. The best thing we can do is to use our common sense in order to cushion ourselves against these inevitable recessions that will occur from time to time.

Comment on this

Can the Minister state the reason for the recession in the textile industry in this country?

Comment on this

The same reason that was the cause of the recession in England and the United States. The shelves are full but the purchasing power is not there——

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

What about company profits tax?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Minister should be allowed to make his speech without interruptions.

Comment on this

I should like to mention company profits tax——

Comment on this

May I ask the Minister a question?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Minister wishes to make his own reply without interruptions.

Comment on this

Company profits tax is being blamed for everything——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I have said that the Minister must be allowed to make his speech without interruptions.

Comment on this

I asked if I might put a question to the Minister.

Comment on this

I was dealing with the 58 per cent company profits tax——

Comment on this

Can the Minister explain why the imports in textiles are fivefold since the Anglo-Irish Free Trade Area Agreement?

Comment on this

The imports in textiles are not fivefold. The import of clothing might have been up. We put a duty on garments. Clothing and textiles are listed separately. The Deputy is speaking about a different matter when he refers to garments. I was asked about the 58 per cent company profits tax. We took off the tax to make it easier but it was not the cause of the trouble, no matter what Mr. Grey or anyone else may say. I discussed this matter with some of the best industrialists in the country. It was a tax on profits——

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

Retrospective profits.

Comment on this

If the profits were reinvested the tax would not apply. It is as simple as that. It was a good tax from that point of view and one that was calculated to obviate the increase in unemployment rather than to create it. It was an incentive or a measure to goad industry to reinvest the profits in industry. For that reason the present situation is not attributable to it. At the same time a measure allowing for an improved appreciation which more than offset the effects of the 58 per cent company tax was introduced.

I thought Deputy Cosgrave was rather subtle when he referred to the meat industry. This is a serious and difficult problem. I had to sit down with the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries and listen to decent people who have lost or are about to lose their jobs in the meat processing industry. I listened in this debate to see who would come up with some panacea or remedy——

Comment on this

That is the Minister's job.

Comment on this

Deputy Cosgrave referred to this matter. He spoke about the complexity and the need for finding a solution but he made no attempt whatever to suggest what might be done.

Comment on this

What about using some of the subsidies fixed this year?

Comment on this

The subsidies are available if prices drop below a certain figure. However, in the last year prices have not dropped below that figure and the subsidies came into play only for a few weeks. Prices for cattle on the hoof have reached an all-time high. In addition, they were not very plentiful on the market because there was good winter grass. If we give the meat processing people a subsidy it will put them into competition with export buyers, who will merely put their price up and still buy cattle on the hoof. In Deputy Cosgrave's speech there was a rather veiled suggestion that cattle prices should be fixed. That is something nobody in this House would attempt.

Comment on this

It was never suggested from this side of the House. That is typical.

Comment on this

I would ask Deputies to have a look at the record. I was straining to hear a solution to this problem because we want one.

Comment on this

That is the Government's job.

Comment on this

If he suggested anything at all he implied that something should be evolved because people were complaining that cattle were too dear and the thing would be to fix the price. That is not the solution. I am not saying he said that, but he rather implied it. These are some of the difficulties. I should like to say to those people who are blandly accusing the Government about what they did or did not do regarding the meat processing industry, that we virtually made the meat processing industry in the past few years.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

You certainly did not.

Comment on this

We put them really into business and they are the first who will admit that. They have had the bonanza and it will be a pity if it does not continue because it gives employment rather than walking cattle off on the hoof. It has been said by virtually every speaker, perhaps without any conviction or perhaps without giving serious thought to it, that the Government are doing nothing.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Minister.

Comment on this

In the Department of Labour we have been making this serious effort to organise our manpower services in a way that would spell efficiency from the start by concentrating on getting the best personnel and doing as good a job as possible.

Comment on this

You proved it.

Comment on this

As Deputies know, we have appointed some regional directors and a number of placement officers. Any Deputy who has come in touch with them will admit that they are doing a good job and that they know their job.

Comment on this

To create more unemployment.

Comment on this

They have placed quite a few people in employment in their short time in existence.

Comment on this

Where?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Minister must be allowed to speak.

Comment on this

When redundancies are pending we get advance notice. We actually pay to get advance notice. The refund and the lump-sum are more generous if notice of more than the statutory two weeks is given. We then send in some members of our manpower service to discuss redundancies before they occur, and any training that is required. We have AnCO schools in Galway, Waterford and Shannon providing places for a yearly turnover of about 1,200 students.

Comment on this

They are only kindergartens.

Comment on this

There is one due to open in Ballyfermot which will have 400 places on a six months basis. This will be a turnover of 800 a year. It will be opened next month, I hope. We have one in Cork with some 130 places, and there is one due to open in the Gaeltacht in Donegal in a few months.

In addition we are providing a mobile training service. The first mobile classes will be established in Tralee, Athlone and Ballina. This is a very interesting experiment because it is by way of being an itinerant service which can be despatched to any area to do a specific job. It is a particularly useful type of service. I am not merely repeating this because it is well known to the House already, but I want to put it on record as against the rash statements made that we were not bothering about the overall long-term situation. We are very much concerned and we are becoming very well organised progressively to deal with the long-term situation.

Comment on this

Live horse.

Comment on this

Deputy Corish anticipated me at the start. I do not want to hark back but it is only natural that we should take some guidance from past events. I have said this often before. In the present situation a number of things have contributed to the increase in the unemployment figure, things which the Coalition Government did not have to deal with in their time. We have no emigration at present.

Comment on this

Is that not disgraceful?

Comment on this

In ordinary circumstances, as the Taoiseach said yesterday, we would say: "Thank God." At least this is realistic. We are not boasting about it. It is a simple fact which the Opposition cannot contradict. The Coalition Government had no redundancy to deal with when they ran into serious trouble. I am referring to February, 1957, when 95,000 were unemployed and sweet damn all was done about it. Nobody mentioned it as a crisis or a problem. There were 50,000 people going abroad annually at the same time. They did not have to deal with redundancies because they had no industries from which they could become redundant. Now they come into this House with the cheek to attack the Government which built up industry and created thousands of new jobs since then.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

There are fewer people at work now than there were in 1964.

Comment on this

They now have the audacity to say the Government are doing nothing about it.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 67
·
Níl 62
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?