Committee on Finance. - Prisons Bill, 1972: Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 141–292 of 292. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 9 of 1972 ›
If the Deputy knows that then he knows he is out of order. He will desist from that.
Comment on this
They can promote a district justice and at the same time——
Comment on this
The Deputy cannot proceed on that line. The Chair will not allow the Deputy proceed on that line and will ask him to resume his seat.
Comment on this
I remember the decisions of the IRA courts in days gone by. I do not know whether this is relevant or whether it is not.
Comment on this
This Bill is brought before us because certain people have thrown before the Irish people a threat of civil war. There is no country in the world in which there was ever a second civil war. I got more medals for the people who fought in the last civil war and the War of Independence than all the Deputies here ever bought at a stand in Knock. There will never be a second civil war in this country.
Comment on this
I am not sectarian. I could not be. There are only two Protestants in the territory in which I live and they are the only two decent people in it. They are certainly as decent as any of us. I could not be sectarian. I have no opposition except when I come in here.
Comment on this
There are a couple. Allegations have been made against the Border. Some of the people who made those allegations belong to the same party which in 1923, 1924 and 1925 appointed sergeants in my area of the country who could neither read nor write and Fianna Fáil were not in power at that time.
Comment on this
These things happen and today we have people in the Opposition coming in and telling the Fianna Fáil Party that their attitude towards members of the Garda Síochána is not right. I have seen cases where people have applied for membership of the Garda Síochána and some of them have been too thick to get in and some of them have not been thick enough. It has nothing to do with education. People can be taken into the Garda Síochána simply on the basis of being too thin or not being thin enough.
Comment on this
There is nothing in this Bill about taking people into the Garda Síochána. This Bill has to do with the prisons.
Comment on this
They are the people who will deal with the people who will be rammed into jail. These people should not be rammed into jail. In 12 months from today this Bill will be absolutely irrelevent because it is not in keeping with EEC regulations. I do not know any country outside the Eastern Countries where that type of Bill would be acceptable under EEC regulations. I am sure you have read that Bill and I am sure you will agree with me that next January it will be completely irrelevant. Deputy Barry asked that it be suspended three months after it is passed. I do not think we will have to wait that long. We are told that it will take 12 months to repair Mountjoy. There must be good contractors in Dublin if they can repair it in that time.
Comment on this
The board of imagination. That Bill will be completely irrelevant in 12 months time. That is why I advocate it should be accepted at the moment because it will be completely irrelevant when we enter the EEC. The people of this country have given an 82 per cent vote for entry into the EEC.
Comment on this
Yes. I am a bad counter. I am not a mathematician. They gave an 83 per cent vote to accept the regulations which will be imposed by the Treaty of Rome. Is their word to be accepted? I presume it is, no matter what Deputy O'Sullivan is smiling about. It will mean that that Bill is not worth the paper on which it is written. For that reason I would advocate accepting it at the moment and there should not be much trouble afterwards. By the time they have taken it to the President we will probably be in Europe and that will be the end of the Bill. However, I support it.
Comment on this
The position is clear in relation to this Bill. You either vote for it or against it. There can be no half measures. The Minister has explained the new situation which brought about the need for this type of legislation and blame placing is no solution to this problem. The solution lies in the legislation. Many people who have spoken here today want to be on both sides, they want to be both for and against the Bill. That cannot happen. You either vote for or against. No doubt we will have other speakers who will want to whitewash in the same manner as did Deputy Thornley and others who have spoken. Deputy O'Sullivan spoke about the Blueshirts and about other periods and never mentioned the Bill or the present situation. There is a situation here which demands that remedial action be taken to ensure that lives and public and private property are adequately protected. The release of many prisoners, it was indicated, could take place if this Bill was not enacted. People who are already sentenced for offences could be released and would be a danger to the social order. This Bill is necessary and desirable. Some doubts have been expressed about the situation in Mountjoy by Deputies who spoke here, about the period it would take to repair the premises. I wonder would the Minister consider allowing a committee of this House to visit Mountjoy or indeed to visit the Curragh at a later stage when prisoners are housed there——
Comment on this
——particularly Mountjoy, in order that we could see, at first hand, whether the extent of the damage is as reported. I am absolutely satisfied with the Minister's word but there are certain Deputies who have some doubts about the situation in Mountjoy, about the amount of damage that was caused there during the riot. It is depressing to think that even the dental service unit and the kitchen were destroyed. This type of vandalism could not be tolerated. I should like to see, and I am sure other Deputies would also, the extent of the damage there. I would ask the Minister to consider seriously allowing Members of this House, as a committee, to visit Mountjoy and see for themselves that there is no exaggeration. I have absolute confidence in the word of the Minister. I congratulate the Minister on his courage in dealing with the many problems with which he is confronted.
Comment on this
There are many people concerned about freedom and liberty in this nation, about the democratic institutions, about the authority of this House, who have spoken here in a very roundabout fashion. They have spoken about the authority of the House and the maintenance of the democratic institutions but at the same time have not the courage to face up to their responsibilities in this issue. It will be interesting to hear other Members trying to whitewash the situation and ride two horses in this race. This cannot be done and the hypocrisy will be seen tonight and on the other occasions when votes will be taken. If people are concerned about sections of the Bill they have a right to put down amendments and have them discussed at the appropriate time. If the democratic decision of this House is that these amendments are not acceptable then they must abide by the democratic decision of this House. These people want to project a picture of themselves as being something different to ordinary individuals. They want to maintain law and order but, on the other hand, they want to disassociate themselves from this type of legislation. Possibly it is not easy for many Deputies to face up to their responsibilities on this occasion because of the type of support they have been attracting to themselves. It is only people with courage and understanding who will face up to this situation in a genuine and definite way. I should like to congratulate Deputy O'Leary for much of what he said tonight. He made a speech which in many ways was courageous. He had some criticisms of the Department, of the Minister and of some events but he dealt with the situation in a creditable way. This should be the approach of all responsible individuals on the other side of the House. Deputy O'Leary is not the only one. I just mention him as a member of the Labour Party because other members of the Labour Party have devoted much of their time to criticising the Government and the Minister without offering any solution. Deputy Thornley this morning objected to the First Reading but it would appear he got some corrective training and he is now prepared to support the Bill if certain amendments are accepted and certain assurances given by the Minister. If the Minister gave all the assurances Deputy Thornley wanted about the time limit, about exceptional circumstances, about military custody, about the Minister for Defence, these men would still be retained in prison or somewhere. It would not mean liberty for one of these people an hour earlier than they will get that liberty.
In relation to the situation that developed in Mountjoy, I should like to congratulate the gardaí, the prison warders and all those others who assisted. The handling of the situation was creditable in so far as no life was lost when that could very easily have happened in a tense situation such as that. The prison warders and the people responsible for the conduct of the prison deserve to be congratulated on the manner in which some of them restrained themselves.
The situation which developed resulted in the necessity for this legislation. This large amount of destruction which will take 12 months to repair will be very costly. This cost will be borne by the housewives of Deputy Thornley's area in Ballymun. They will have to pay in taxation for the vandalism that took place as will the housewives in Ballyfermot, Drimnagh, Coolock and Finglas. Those unfortunate housewives will have to pay for this vandalism. I hope Deputy Thornley will remember this when he approaches these people in the nottoo-distant future. I hope he will indicate that he was one of the people who supported this vandalism in a roundabout fashion.
I support this Bill. I ask the Minister once again to consider allowing a committee to visit Mountjoy to assess the situation and to assure themselves that the damage is as indicated in the public press and by the Minister. I have absolute confidence in the Minister's word, I accept it fully and without hesitation, but it would appear to me that 12 months is a very long period to take to repair any amount of damage. The damage must be very considerable.
Comment on this
The problem facing us here is one that arises from the failure of the Minister to carry out his responsibilities.
In democratic countries the general practice is that a Minister accepts responsibility for defaults, mistakes and mishaps that occur in the Department under his control. In this country we have gone so far away from that concept of ministerial responsibility that I do not think many people even thought in terms of the Minister being responsible or wondered if he would resign. In any other country in the democratic system a failure of the kind that occurred here with its disastrous consequences would have led to the immediate resignation of the Minister concerned. For example, I could not conceive of a British Minister in a similar position remaining in office. Yet, so accustomed have we become to the abdication of responsibility by Ministers and to the situation where they do not accept responsibility that most people never thought of the possibility that the Minister would resign. This is an indication of how far our standards have fallen under this Government.
I should like to ask the Minister when we can expect the results of the inquiry. The House must be concerned that a situation arose in which, according to reports we have had through the media and the Minister's own report, a prison officer was in the proximity of a number of IRA prisoners carrying with him a master key to all the cells in the prison. That such a situation should arise appears to be an unheard-of thing in the history of the prison service here or anywhere else. One can understand that in any prison prisoners may catch someone by surprise but I should have thought that under no circumstances would a prison officer travel round the prison carrying a master key when the prisoners might well be in a position to surprise him. The Minister is responsible for that situation. He should accept his responsibilities—in fact, he should have resigned. He should tell us when the inquiry will be completed and when the House will hear the results.
I was completely taken aback about a minor aspect of this affair—minor in the overall picture but important to the person involved. I was very concerned to hear from Deputy O'Sullivan that there was some suggestion that the car belonging to the sergeant of the gardaí was destroyed and that he would not receive any compensation. It is inconceiveable that such a defect could exist in our legislative structure, that a member of the Garda could have been put into that position. I should like the Minister's assurance that where a member of the Force suffered a loss of property through his involvement in trying to bring the affair outside the prison to a peaceful conclusion that he would be compensated for any loss. I expect the Minister to answer this point in his reply.
We approach this Bill with considerable suspicion. There are a number of reasons for this. First, there is a record of this Government of trying to introduce unnecessarily repressive legislation going beyond the needs of the moment. On this side of the House we have no hesitation in backing the Government in any measures they may take that are necessary to deal with the situation we face in this part of the country at the present time. However, we will always examine such legislation to make sure it is necessary, that it does not go beyond the needs of the moment, and that it does not extend for a longer time scale than appears necessary. Unfortunately this Government have a record of going beyond the needs of the moment and of being unduly repressive.
On this side of the House we have the peculiar responsibility on the one hand of pressing the Government to take adequate action within the law against forces outside the law which the Government have failed to tackle. At the same time, we have the duty as a vigilant Opposition concerned with individual liberty to ensure that the measures the Government take in pursuance of their duty and in response to our pressures go no further than is necessitated by the situation.
The Government have a record of inaction in the face of serious danger to the security of the State and of a weakness or unwillingness to act; they over-act in other cases where there is no serious danger to the security of the State but where particular forces in the community attract their dislike or hatred. In this case they act against them in a way that goes beyond the needs of the situation.
On this side of the House we have a special problem in maintaining a balance faced with a Government which act so erratically on these matters, which act at times in a discriminatory manner. In this connection I should like to echo what was said by Deputy Thornley regarding the Taoiseach's speech as published in this morning's newspapers. On this side of the House we have been concerned about the way the Government have handled their responsibilities in dealing with illegal organisations here. Some of us have noticed an apparent partiality in the handling of the situation, the tendency to raid more frequently the headquarters and the homes of members of the Official IRA than those of the Provisional IRA——
Comment on this
I understand that the riot in Mountjoy was caused by prisoners of one or other wing of the IRA. We are concerned lest the power given to the Minister to allocate particular prisoners to particular kinds of confinement, which may be more onerous to those prisoners, might be exercised in a discriminatory way in view of the Government's record of apparent discrimination between illegal organisations. This record is reinforced by the extraordinary reference in the Taoiseach's speech last night when he used a phrase which, I think, has been used by the Provisional IRA about the Official IRA. When I hear the Taoiseach and the Provisional IRA using the same phraseology about a group whom both regard as an enemy I begin to wonder if the Government's attitude to the Provisional IRA is what we would hope it to be.
Comment on this
I think I have established its relevance. I do not need to dwell on it any longer because it is so obviously relevant to the debate. I think I have made that clear. We are concerned because there has been clear evidence in this House that members of the Government Party do not accept fully their responsibilities. We had the remarkable case in this House in early February in the debate on Derry when the Tánaiste and Deputy Leader of the Government was speaking. On that occasion a number of Deputies—I am sure they were not representative of Fianna Fáil as a whole, but nevertheless they were members of the Government Party—sat behind him and gave him a conspicuous lack of support in his courageous speech which had the entire support of Fine Gael and Labour. It was so obvious that when the Tánaiste finished his speech he turned back to see who were the Deputies who were so conspicuously unwilling to support him in his courageous stand against the IRA.
In a situation where a Government Party have such supporters in their ranks, where we have the Taoiseach making a speech which seems to distinguish so carefully between two wings of the IRA—the "alien ideology" group, and these nice local boys who murder only Protestants—we are entitled to be suspicious of a measure which puts into the Minister's hands powers that could be used in a discriminatory way between different groups. We want both wings of the IRA dealt with. We do not want any discrimination or choice between them; we want both dealt with with even-handed justice of a kind which we have not seen in this country recently.
In the Bill there are grounds for reasonable suspicion, quite apart from the background I have outlined regarding the Government's handling of the current security situation in this country. First, we have had the remarkable statement that it will take 12 months to repair the damage in Mountjoy. Mountjoy is a building with fairly strong walls and I have not heard that any of them were knocked down in this riot. The damage that has been caused is damage that could be repaired in a much shorter period; damage to windows, to wash-hand basins, to some doors and locks. There was some damage to the roof which might take slightly longer to repair but it would not take anything like 12 months. The speed at which building works are carried out here for private profits—sometimes for the private profit of people not dissociated from the Fianna Fáil Party —suggests that if the Government wished to repair Mountjoy quickly they could do so.
There has been some suggestion from the other side of the House that the Government want to take this opportunity to effect useful improvements in Mountjoy. We should not try to fool ourselves about this. Many improvements are required but, had the prisoners not wrecked the prison, these improvements would have had to be carried out in the ordinary way by dealing with different parts of the prison stage by stage and making the improvements while the prisoners still inhabited part of the prison. I do not see any reason why the immediate damage could not be repaired quickly and the prison restored at least to partial use. Then the further improvements that need to be carried out could be carried out in the same way as they would have been carried out had this damage not been inflicted. The fact that there is this extraordinarily long period of 12 months creates suspicion. However, one would not be too worried about that were it not for the fact that this long period is associated with the total absence of any time limit on the Bill itself. The Bill itself introduced as an emergency measure, drafted hastily and with defects in it, as the Minister has just admitted on television a few minutes ago, is a measure which one could justify as an ad hoc measure to meet an emergency if it were to be confined to that emergency. The Government have not done that. What they have done is to introduce a Bill which purports to be permanent legislation to be implemented sporadically as and when needed. The Bill is not designed solely to deal with the Mountjoy situation but is expected to deal with future situations which may arise.
Why should it be necessary to make this permanent legislation? Of course one recognises that the situation which has arisen has shown up a defect and that if this Minister or a future Fianna Fáil Minister fails equally in his responsibility and if there is a recurrence of this situation, further legislation will be necessary. We on this side of the House will accept that there must be permanent legislation to ensure that, in the event of a prison or prisons being damaged, prisoners are kept in custody, but that legislation should be carefully considered, brought into this House and debated at leisure. It should not be introduced in such a way that we only have a couple of hours to read the Bill before debating it, in such a way that we have to draft the amendments during the Second Stage debate and try to listen to the debate and listen to the Minister on television simultaneously. It should not be done in such a way that the entire range of amendments—and there will be many —will have to be debated through Committee Stage and through Report Stage in a period of five hours in this House. This is no way to draft permanent legislation.
The fact that the Minister has sought to make this permanent legislation and has introduced it in a form that will enable it, once it has been implemented by way of resolution in this House, to remain in force indefinitely long after, perhaps years after, Mountjoy has been restored, gives grounds for serious suspicions about the Government's and the Minister's intentions.
Again there is no provision in this Bill to limit the number of prisoners to be accommodated in military custody to the minimum number necessitated by the legislation at any given time. Under this Bill as I read it—and I am open to correction if there is something I have missed—the Minister could, once this Bill is through, put the entire prison population into the hands of the Defence Forces on the grounds that various prisons are in some way or another unsuitable, because the wording used is so vague and general that, in fact, given the present poor condition of our prisons today, he could probably justify closing all the prisons and handing all the prisoners over to military custody. The provisions of section 2 (3) refer to prison accommodation or prison staff being insufficient to provide secure and resonable conditions of custody. As I understand it, the present prison accommodation is insufficient to provide reasonable conditions of custody anywhere in the country. We understand the prison staff is inadequate in number. Then the Bill goes on to make provision that the relevant sections of the Bill can be put into effect if the accommodation "is insufficient to provide such conditions without serious detriment to the maintenance in prisons of the normal arrangement for the rehabilitative treatment of prisoners..."
Does anybody think that in any Irish prison today the conditions are such as to permit the normal rehabilitative treatment of prisoners? I do not think that any court in this country, if it were put to it as an issue under this legislation that the Minister wished to transfer all prisoners over to the Defence Forces on the grounds that in no prison were the arrangements for the rehabilitative treatment of prisoners normal or adequate, could hold against him and say the conditions were adequate and normal. Therefore, the Bill as drafted does enable the Minister not just to transfer 40 prisoners for whom he cannot find a home in an ordinary prison to the Curragh but to transfer the entire prison population, if he wishes to do so, into the hands of the Defence Forces. We must look at this Bill and see if it tries to do more than needs to be done. To the extent that under every heading it does so much more than needs to be done we are entitled to regard it with considerable suspicion.
There is also the argument for security. The curious introduction of the concept of security here is not merely a question now of not having room for prisoners but a question of the prison not being secure enough, and the suggestion has been made in this debate by several Deputies that with the kind of behaviour that went on in Mountjoy last Thursday and Friday perhaps it will no longer be possible in future to house IRA prisoners in a prison because they cannot be secure there and therefore in future they will have to be in military custody. The introduction of the concept of security rather than the availability of prison accommodation introduces a new and other sinister element into this Bill. This has not been explained by the Minister and is another good reason for being suspicious of the Bill.
Therefore this Bill is one which requires intensive and extensive amendment, and we face a problem of having to do this in a few hours tomorrow. That is most unsatisfactory and I think the Minister was wrong to bring into this House a Bill which is expressed to be permanent legislation, which of its nature raises so many problems and requires so much amendment and which he tries to bludgeon us to accept in a few hours.
In addition to the matters I have raised, there are other matters which in the course of the Committee Stage we shall have to deal with. I find no provision in this Bill for setting out who will be the responsible officer or how one can identify the responsible officer in charge of the prisoners. It is a feature of the prison system that prisoners are put in charge of a named person, the governor of the prison. It is the governor of the prison who is responsible to the courts. It is he who has to produce a prisoner if there is a habeas corpus action. The courts know to whom to go in such circumstances, but there is nobody responsible here. Will it be the officer in command of the camp or will it be a prison officer, as we feel it should be, who will be put in charge of the prisoners of the camp? Will it be the Chief of Staff of the Army? Who will be responsible? To whom do the courts go? Who do they demand should hand over the body of a prisoner so that he may appear before them and so that the authorities concerned can give an account of themselves and state why he should not be released?
This Bill to my mind is full of uncertainty because of the absence of any provision as to who would be in charge of the prisoners and we shall have to insist on the Committee Stage on the acceptance of an amendment to nominate a responsible official and to provide some means through which he can be nominated. In my own view which is, I think, the view of my party, such an officer should not be a military officer but a governor of the camp who would be a member of the prison service seconded, if that is the appropriate word, for that purpose. We do not think it satisfactory that prisoners should be taken out of the control and away from the authority of the prison service the staff of which have the training in duty and in skills to look after prisoners.
We have heard from Deputies in the House, particularly Deputy O'Sullivan, how within the lifetime of this State he found himself in a military prison. He told us of the conditions in which he found himself. That prison was not under the civil authority of the State He made it clear that not because of any particular ill will or ill treatment of a positive kind on the part of the military authorities but simply because they were not equipped to run a prison. he found himself year after year housed and living and accommodated in appalling conditions. It is not to be expected that the Army, whose job it is to maintain the security of the State, to deal with internal and external security, would be in a position to provide the kind of skilled service that the running of a prison requires, including the many provisions a modern prison should offer in respect of the rehabilitation of prisoners. It is clear that the officer in charge must be an officer of the prison service and that he must be certified as such so that it will be quite clear who is in charge of the prison.
I support Deputy Dowling in his proposal for an Oireachtas committee of inspection. I realise there is provision in the Bill for a board of visitors but I am not satisfied that is sufficient. This House has a very special duty here. We are rushing through this legislation to meet an emergency. If, as a result, any prisoner suffers, we are responsible. We must in the discharge of that responsibility have a continuing direct interest until a normal situation is restored. It would be intolerable if we should find ourselves in a position of finding that prisoners might be living in conditions which we could not stand over and indeed that we could not find out for ourselves if we had put them in that position. That would be an abdication of responsibility on the part of this House, and Deputy Dowling was quite right to press that point, to require that we should have the ability to inspect any such prison.
I remember in the late 1950s, when I was not in politics and had as little sympathy with the IRA as I have now, being very concerned about the conditions in which they were housed at the Curragh. As an ordinary citizen at that time I did not know how I could do anything about it but I must say it was on my conscience. As an ordinary citizen, however, I did not know how to set about taking action. I am not an ordinary citizen any longer in that I am one of the 144 Members of this House who have a special responsibility. I am one of those Deputies who support this Bill and who therefore will be one of those Members directly responsible for housing prisoners in circumstances other than normal. I therefore have a responsibility to ensure that they will be housed and looked after properly and that they will not suffer as a result of the action of a small group of prisoners—only a group are involved in this. I can exercise that responsibility only by ensuring that this Parliament has a committee of inspection who can inspect these establishments and make sure conditions in them are satisfactory. That is something on which we must insist on Committee Stage.
Moreover, we must insist that normal prison rules will apply. The provisions of the Bill are entirely inadequate and they have been stigmatised by what Professor John Kelly, Professor of Jurisprudence and Roman Law, said on television in the last hour. He said these provisions in their present form are unconstitutional because the Constitution does not permit—if I understood him correctly this has been established in a certain case within the history of this State—a Minister to vary adversely the treatment of a prisoner by discriminating between prisoners. Therefore, if the Minister does not ensure absolutely that the treatment of prisoners in these camps, or whatever they may be called, will be identical with and certainly no worse than the treatment prisoners normally undergo, and if he selects prisoners to go to a place where conditions are worse, he would be in breach of the Constitution and the Act which we will have passed will therefore be unconstitutional. We do not want to find ourselves in the position of being called back some weekend if the Supreme Court takes action——
Comment on this
Sorry, I am just about to conclude. We do not want to be coming back here again because the Supreme Court has found that what we have done is unconstitutional. We must therefore amend the provision including the words "have regard to the desirability of ensuring". These words are totally inadequate for this purpose and we must ensure that normal prison rules apply in these camps.
Comment on this
I am glad that on this occasion I have Deputy FitzGerald partly on my side—only partly, but at least he views this Bill with suspicion. That is a good sign. I am delighted that the Fine Gael Party are moving towards us. Indeed most members of the Labour Party view this kind of legislation with detestation, not because there is more than one Army in this country. As far as I am concerned at any rate there is only one Army in this country. Going back to 1922, always there has been only one Army here. I will say no more about that. I should like to say, however, that apart from the point raised apparently on one of the media, as they are called, by Professor John Kelly, there is a question which I must raise on this Bill. Because I am not a lawyer the question I am about to ask may not be relevant but I should like to get an answer from the Minister. I raised a few such points recently and I was treated with scant courtesy but I was later vindicated on them.
The point I am making is that I cannot see any provision in the Bill to bring the Act into operation. In his opening speech the Minister said subsection (1) of section 2 provides that the Dáil may at any time decide that the section should cease to be in operation and the Dáil may, by resolution, declare that it is satisfied that the section should cease to be in operation, but that in certain circumstances the Dáil, also by resolution, might decide to put the section into operation again. The words of significance there are "put into operation again". I hope the draftsmen are sure about their drafting this time. We had this type of legislation previously. Every occasion on which this House hurried to do something it was at its worst.
Why do I look on this kind of legislation with detestation? It is because I get the odour of internment from it. Let us be quite frank about that. To put into military custody persons convicted under the civil laws of the country without the most serious reasons cannot be justified. As regards riots in prisons and that sort of thing, we have had them not alone in uncivilised countries such as South Africa and the United States, but we had a major one in Italy in the last 12 months. Riots in prisons are not grounds for putting people into military custody. The Government were faced with a problem and they took rapid action. I appreciate that they sent prison officers to the Curragh with the group of prisoners.
In a sense, there are two different sections in the Bill. Section 3 has very little to do with the previous section which relates to military custody and does not at all mention military prisons or anything like that. Section 3 states that the Minister may from time to time specify a place or places to be used as a prison or prisons but I cannot understand why the Minister did not get around this problem by specifying some places, not necessarily a military barracks at the present time. There are such places in the country which had been used as military barracks and which are now unoccupied. I cannot understand, in view of its past and extremely bad history, why the prisoners should have been lumped down to the Curragh. Deputy O'Sullivan spoke about what happened to him. I do not think that the military were in any way responsible for that and I do not think they will now be responsible for anything that may happen to these prisoners.
I have been in Mountjoy on a couple of occasions. I went there to bring books to the library. The warders in charge of the library told me that prisoners like reading books about crime. I would have thought that they would have been interested in something else.
When internment was mentioned in this House by the Taoiseach at the end of 1970 we in this party would not agree to it. At the time the Government were making a great show of putting through the Prices and Incomes Bill. We said we would not give internment in exchange for the Government dropping the Prices and Incomes Bill. A different situation arose subsequently and the Government dropped that Bill. The history of this party has been against internment. I do not mind what arguments are advanced or what grounds are stated, there is definitely a smell of internment about this Bill. I take it this is why Deputy FitzGerald is suspicious of the Bill and I agree with him 100 per cent.
I also agree with the point made originally by Deputy Cooney, repeated by Deputy FitzGerald, and supported by members of the Labour Party, that there should be a time limit on the Bill. I would be much happier to see the skids put under the Office of Public Works or the "office of no works" as they have been frequently called. There is no reason why the kind of damage that was done— breaking washhand basins, breaking lavatories, breaking windows—should not be repaired within a reasonable time and three months would be reasonable. My objection to the Bill in principle would still exist even if there were a time limit. I do not agree with transferring civilians to military custody, not because I am suspicious of the Army, but because of a basic objection in principle. Therefore, regardless of what anybody else does, I will vote against the Second Reading of this Bill.
If the Bill consisted of sections 1, 3 and 4 I would see no objection to it. Section 3 provides:
The Minister may from time to time specify a place or places to be used as a prison or prisons and each place so specified shall be a prison to which the Prison Acts, 1826 to 1970, apply.
The Government could also without difficulty transfer people on special leave from the Army to act as warders. I do not see any reason why some of the many large edifices in the country could not be called prisons. I do not know to whom the Government are making a bow. I am not making any allegations, but they must be making a bow to somebody. There is a touch in this Bill of the Offences Against the State Act. I am not being unduly suspicious. I will not take up any more of the time of the House because there are many other Deputies who would like to speak on the Bill and I have said what I want to say.
Comment on this
This Bill arise out of the trouble in Mountjoy on Thursday night last. The Minister has to transfer a number of prisoners to other parts of the country. There are a number of prisons in the country and it would appear to me that there is something radically wrong if we have to introduce a Bill of this kind to give the Minister power to put some prisoners into military custody. There must be something wrong with our whole system if we cannot cater for these prisoners in our other prisons. I gather from what was said here that all the trouble has been caused by the Provisional IRA prisoners in Mountjoy.
We have had a very wide discussion and Deputies referred to sympathisers of the Provisional IRA or the Official IRA in one party or another. I think it was Deputy Cruise-O'Brien who said that this Bill would be an embarrassment to some members of the Fianna Fáil Party who were in sympathy with the Provisional IRA. He was followed by Deputy Briscoe who assured the House that nobody in Fianna Fáil was in sympathy with the Provisional IRA, that he certainly was not, but that there were people in Fine Gael and in the Labour Party who were. If we are honest with ourselves we will admit that in all the political parties there are Deputies who have been in sympathy with the Provisional IRA. Some Deputies were prepared to be a little more outspoken than others. I suppose no Deputy would agree fully with all that has been going on in the recent past. When the vote is taken tonight I will vote for the Bill although I have had and still have sympathy for the Provisional IRA. There are a number of other Deputies who will vote for the Bill who are still in sympathy with them.
It is a pity that there was not some other way to overcome this difficulty but I suppose this is one way to try to create an atmosphere of emergency. I do not know whether there is an emergency, but it would appear as if there is a colossal emergency. When there is an emergency we find that we are short of something. Over the past few months we found there was a shortage of gardaí and we had a special recruitment campaign to increase the numbers of that body. We had a shortage of Army personnel and we had a special recruitment campaign to increase the numbers in the Army. We seem to have a shortage of prison warders and we have to try to do something about that. Now we have a shortage of prison space. All this would suggest that over the years we have not had our priorities right. We should not have allowed ourselves to get into a position like this.
I gather that the 30 or 40 prisoners who will occupy the barracks in the Curragh will be political prisoners, or people who are in for that type of offence and, if they are on remand, I would ask the Minister to make that period as short as possible. If he can make the charge stick, they are no longer on remand and have become prisoners proper, but it seems to me that a number of people have been arrested and charged and are on remand for one reason or another on what would appear to be very flimsy charges because I do not think that up to now very many of them have been made to stick. We do know that if a crime is committed down the country, the Garda may have a suspect but they must be fairly satisfied that they can make the charge stick before they take it to court, and these would appear to be flimsy charges, with the result that these people are on remand for a long time and eventually, in most cases I have read, they all seem to be acquitted. It is a pity that they have to be three or four months on remand. If we could get the thing over and done with as quickly as possible, we might not have the kind of trouble we had in Mountjoy last week.
Like other Deputies, I would like to think that this piece of legislation will be in existence for as short a time as possible. We must be realistic and we must appreciate the fact that when we have people in prison and something like this happens, we just cannot open the gates and let them out. We have to have our prisons and our security, but a number of Deputies have asked the Minister to give some assurance about getting rid of the measure as quickly as possible. There has been some talk about the length of time it is expected to take to restore Mountjoy and to make it habitable. If the matter comes to the Office of Public Works and architects are sent up to the prison, it could easily be 12 months, but a lot of this could be short-circuited and a staff sent in there and Mountjoy could be back in habitable condition in a very short time.
I intend to support this Bill. Deputy O'Leary, in speaking, seemed to know quite a good deal about the Provisional IRA and the Official IRA. He told us the Provisionals wanted internment retained in the North and wanted internment introduced down here, that this was likely to be their life's blood. There is one way in which we can disappoint the Provisionals, that is, not to introduce internment, and I would be a happy man and very pleased if we did not because I doubt very much if I would support the Government if they attempted to introduce internment. It is a great pity that Mr. Whitelaw, Secretary of State for Northern Ireland, would not do the same and end internment up there. It would take the carpet from under the feet of the Provisional IRA and they would have no grouse. If it is as simple as that, it does not make sense that Mr. Whitelaw should continue internment and that we should even contemplate introducing it down here.
Some Deputies are suspicious of this piece of legislation but I hope the Minister is being realistic about it— that he finds himself in a difficult position and there is no other way out. I hope that is so and we must accept what he says in relation to the condition of and damage done in Mountjoy, except that Deputies at a later stage may go along and find out for themselves. In the meantime, this piece of legislation is necessary. That we are introducing a sledgehammer to crack a nut I do not agree. There is one thing I would like to see as soon as possible, and in this way the Minister would be meeting the wishes of the vast majority of the Opposition, that is, the removal of this measure from the Statute Book.
Deputy Dowling says we must go all the way or not at all but I do not fully accept that. When legislation is introduced, it is only good legislation if it is passed by the majority of the House and when Deputies have had an opportunity to get their teeth into it and make amendments to it. I do not think we should dig our feet in and I would hate to think the Minister would do so but would try to meet the Opposition. In that way he will have the full support of the House for this legislation which he thinks is so necessary.
Deputy Moore rose.
Comment on this
I have two minutes and I am not going to give a dissertation on democracy. I merely want to say publicly that I support the Bill which I think is necessary and I support the plea made by Deputy Dowling that the Minister would consider appointing a Committee of the House to visit the prisons and in this way demonstrate that the Minister, the Government and all who support them do not support the Bill for any vindictive reason but simply because they believe that democracy is on trial and we might well be faced with having to pay a much higher price in future unless steps are now taken. At the same time, we sympathise with the people who are suffering all over the country and we say that if this Bill will save the life of one Irish man or woman, it is quite justified. All people who believe in the democratic system will support the Bill and to bring up technicalities and to suggest that this is penal legislation is entirely wrong. It is brought about by the tragedy in our country and the Government, rightly, I believe, have decided to tighten the regulations in order not to penalise people but to bring home to those who are flouting the laws of the country that there is no future in their activity, that the vast majority of the people are determined that the democratic way of life will survive. Therefore I support the Bill in the belief that democracy will triumph over the present opposition and that eventually people will see the wisdom of both the Government and the Minister.
Comment on this
May I point out that there are many many other Deputies who wanted to speak on this Bill but, because of the rush of the Government, we have been prevented from having our say and putting forward our opinions on this very important piece of legislation at this stage.
Comment on this
Approximately 20 Deputies, or possibly a few more, have spoken on the Bill and these constitute a very large and representative number.
Comment on this
I doubt if there can be any valid complaints that all points were not put and put quite adequately. I think that on the whole it is fair to say that this debate was a responsible debate and while there were a lot of perhaps unnecessarily suspicious remarks and bitter personal remarks made, I am acquiring a growing tolerance which allows me to accept everything that is said in the spirit of making allowances for the necessity for an Opposition to be seen to oppose even when they know very well that what they are opposing is perfectly fair and valid and more or less what they would do if they were to act responsibly in government.
What I want to say first is that, to varying degrees, a number of Deputies opposite have found fault with me or with the Government that a riot took place in Mountjoy Jail on Thursday night last. Deputy FitzGerald went so far as to say that I should resign because that riot took place.
Comment on this
If that were so I doubt if there would be a Minister for Justice in any country in the world who had not been called on to resign during the past few months. In France alone there have been seven serious riots in seven prisons and in the United States the riots have reached such a proportion that there were not only several but quite a number of deaths.
Comment on this
While I accept full responsibility for the action or failure to act on the part of my servants there is nothing that they did or failed to do for which I could be reproached.
Comment on this
I have sat here for most of the five hours of this debate and during that time I did not interrupt anybody except to take a very minor part in Deputy Joseph Lenehan's jocose contribution.
Comment on this
I would be glad if I could have some time in which to reply to about 20 speeches, most of which were good and constructive. I see nothing in what my servants did or failed to do on Thursday night whereby I can be reproached because I cannot see that they fell down on the job in any way. Indeed, on the contrary—and I was there myself that night, the only Member of this House who was——
Comment on this
——they acted splendidly and in many respects acted well beyond the call of duty. I am blamed that a riot took place in Mountjoy. By our standards, at any rate, there was a very serious riot there. I could have prevented a riot taking place in Mountjoy and I could give an assurance to this House now that no riot would ever take place again in any prison in this country while I am Minister for Justice but I will not do that because the means that I would have to use to ensure that and the means which I could have used during the past two years to ensure that there would not have been a riot would be so Draconian and so inhuman that not only would it be grossly unfair and over-penalise grossly the prisoners but it would not allow the slightest effort to be made towards their rehabilitation.
Whatever views may be expressed here tonight or in the country in the aftermath of the serious riot in Mountjoy Jail I have believed during the time that I have been Minister for Justice and, notwithstanding the riot of Thursday last I will continue to believe, that the reason that men are in jail in this or in any other civilised country is because we might seek to rehabilitate them. A very secondary consideration, even fourth perhaps in order of priorities, is that there should be an element of punishment in it and the only element of punishment that there should be in incarceration in a prison is a simple deprivation of liberty, liberty to go outside and to take part in normal affairs. While a man is inside and if he is to be rehabilitated he should have maximum freedom compatible with his rehabilitation and unless men in prison have a reasonable degree of freedom one cannot even hope to begin to rehabilitate them. On the contrary, if they are not given some reasonable degree of freedom and if some reasonable degree of trust is not imposed in them, not only will there be no possibility of rehabilitating them but they will be very much worse citizens on leaving prison.
The fact is that two things are not compatible; these are maximum security and reasonable rehabilitation. During the years we have endeavoured and, in particular, I have endeavoured during the past two years, to rehabilitate men to the best of our ability and of our resources, limited though they be. I have tried to do that in a way that is reasonably compatible with reasonable security in the prison and I can say that during the past two years in Mountjoy Prison as in all our other institutions, we have been reasonably successful in our primary efforts towards rehabilitation. I do not think it is an idle boast to say that in the past two years the facilities available in Mountjoy and in our other prisons have increased and improved very considerably.
Comment on this
On my first visit to the prison I endeavoured to do away with the old traditional industries that existed in prisons, probably since the last century. These were useless so far as rehabilitation was concerned and they lowered the dignity of the men who were supposed to be involved in them. We have introduced much more elaborate schemes of education and much more specialised psychology and psychiatry. Also, we have introduced trades into the prisons such as motor mechanics and modern printing which will give prisoners a genuine chance of getting a good and well-paid job on their discharge, unlike the sort of training which was traditional in our prisons.
I make no apology for having done that because I regard the rehabilitation of those men as my primary task and notwithstanding what happened last Thursday I will continue to regard it as such.
Comment on this
When one gets over the initial horror and shock of what I saw happen on Thursday night and Friday morning last, one's greatest regret in retrospect is not so much that men acted as they did, and that physical damage of such a nature was caused, but that all our efforts at rehabilitation and retraining and trying to give a new dignity to these men have been set at naught. That is the real tragedy of the aftermath of what happened and the worst thing that anybody in this House or outside it could do in the context of that situation is to suggest, as has been suggested widely here today by the Opposition, that security is the be-all and the end-all of our prisons. We have a very good security record in our prisons. The security that existed in them up to Thursday last was more than adequate for any normal type of prisoner or even groups of prisoners such as we have seen in our prisons in the last few decades but where there is a group of 40 determined men whose sole objective is to create havoc in a prison, no security except the most severe, will ensure with certainty that they will not create that havoc. Had I imposed, before last Thursday, the sort of security that would have ensured that that havoc and that destruction would not have happened, then it would not have been just those 40 men who caused it but also the 470 other men who did not cause it who would have suffered; their lives, their prospects and their whole chance of rehabilitation and retraining in prison would suffer and suffer drastically.
When I was last in Portlaoise, about six or eight weeks ago, I was speaking to the Governor and he told me about the very much more stringent security arrangements they had to enforce because he had 15 particularly dangerous criminals in his custody at a particular period. He said: "The depressing thing about this is not that we are put to this trouble but, because we have to do this, it makes life so unbearable for those who have been with us for so very long." They are men who have been four, six or eight years in prison, men who have built up a trust in and a friendship with the prison officers and they are trusted by the prison officers. No longer does that situation prevail. No longer can they trust. No longer is there any beneficial friendship because of the conditions that must now be imposed on all our prisons as a result of the activities of a certain group, conditions under which every one of our prisoners suffers and suffers grievously.
That was the choice with which I was faced. They are not going to make our prisons literally unbearable for everyone—remember, we have 1,075 prisoners at the moment—simply in order to ensure that there can be no danger of a riot or of destruction by a certain small group. I could not in conscience make that decision, a decision which would make life literally unbearable for over 1,000 men. Even in hindsight I could not do it. I would not do it again tomorrow because, as I said at the outset, above all else our dedication should be towards the rehabilitation of these men, towards training them and giving them the chance they did not, perhaps, get in the world outside.
It has been argued that I am at fault because I allowed a security system to exist whereby a master key could be taken from one prison officer and used to open all the prison cells. Deputy FitzGerald argued after this fashion tonight. He attributed his conclusion to an alleged statement made by me last week. In fact, I made no such statement. My recollection is that this was a theory which appeared in a speculative article in the Irish Independent of Saturday last. There is no foundation for it. No master key was taken from any prison officer. Three wings had been master locked at the time this riot started. One ordinary key was taken from an officer. It was used to open a limited number of cells in one wing and, these having been opened, the doors of a large number of cells in the other wings were broken or burst open.
Comment on this
Enough to release enough people to burst open the rest. The Minister admits it is true.
Comment on this
I most certainly do not admit it is true. It is impossible for any prison officer who has to lock up 510 prisoners, as was the case in Mountjoy last Thursday, to carry 510 separate keys. Indeed, I venture to suggest it would be a highly dangerous thing for that officer to do. One key opens and closes a limited number of cells and there is just no question of a situation such as that portrayed so graphically by Deputy FitzGerald and attributed to me, though I did not say it, as being true.
Deputy Dowling mentioned the question of allowing a visit by Deputies to Mountjoy. I am very glad he did because that is something I would welcome.
Comment on this
I welcomed the suggestion on previous occasions when it was made on the other side of this House.
Comment on this
I got applications from two Deputies, Deputy Fitzpatrick of Meath. I immediately Bruton of Meath. I immediately replied that they were more than welcome to visit. Unfortunately, so far as I am aware, neither of them did visit Mountjoy. I make this offer again now. I issue this invitation and I would be glad if not alone Deputy Dowling but Deputies of all parties would at a convenient date visit Mountjoy.
Comment on this
I would suggest that Deputies would, as far as possible, come together because it would be more convenient for the prison staff to show a number of Deputies over the prison at the same time but, subject to that, they will be very welcome as soon as things have been straightened out.
Comment on this
The Curragh is and will remain a matter entirely for the Minister for Defence. I have no reason whatever to think that the Minister for Defence will refuse any bona fide Deputy and I will use my good offices in requesting him to admit such Deputies. I do not see what members of the Labour Party have to sneer about. With the exception of Deputy Tunney no other Deputy in this House ever saw fit to visit our prisons and Deputy Tunney gave long service indeed as a member of the visiting committee. Recently, because of parliamentary duties, he has had to give up this work. It is regrettable that no other Deputy saw fit to visit our prisons.
Comment on this
Deputy Clinton and I tried on one occasion and we were refused by Deputy Lenihan; he was Minister for Justice at the time.
Comment on this
Deputy Cruise-O'Brien in his contribution tonight appeared to support the Bill fairly strenuously, with some slightly irrelevant reservations.
Comment on this
I would not expect the Deputy to; if the Deputy supported me I would be in strange company. The Deputy referred, by implication more or less, to Deputies of this party who have, as he described it, sympathy with the Provisional IRA.
Comment on this
He described the alleged connection of some members of this party with the Provisional IRA as an unholy alliance.
Comment on this
I deliberately did not interrupt Deputy Cruise-O'Brien, even though he said things which I knew were untrue.
Comment on this
I want to make it clear that there is no alliance, holy or unholy, and no sympathy on the part of any man who sits in these benches with either the Provisional IRA or the Official IRA.
Comment on this
When I say this I am very conscious of the fact that, in saying this, it is more than anyone can say for the Labour Party.
Comment on this
It was revealing to see Deputy Corish—and I felt sympathy for him—open for the Labour Party and declare at the end of his speech that as far as the Labour Party were concerned it was a free vote and all their Members would speak and vote according to their consciences.
Deputy Dr. O'Brien suggested that in some way in the administration of the law in relation to prisons there might be some unfairness to the Official IRA, as against the Provisional IRA. I wondered why. Then it struck me—and I think I can fairly say this because of the innuendoes against Members of this party—that this Bill was introduced by the Minister for Justice. It is clearly a Justice measure but we did not see or hear tonight from the spokesman of the Labour Party on Justice.
Comment on this
Perhaps the reason is that the last time he spoke in this House on my Estimate he spent a great deal of time criticising me and the Garda Síochána for affording protection to certain lorries plying on the export trade between Freshford, County Kilkenny and the Six Counties. He spent between 30 and 45 minutes telling me that it was unnecessary that the Garda should protect those lorries, that nobody associated with him or with the struggle there would do anything wrong.
Comment on this
On a point of order, the Minister has only seven minutes left; might I suggest that he deal with the Bill?
Comment on this
Some days after this had been debated here a man named Woods in Newry was shot through the legs and his supermarket blown up beyond repair; and before he was shot he was told that this was done because some of his lorries were used to go to Freshford, County Kilkenny, and that it was the policy of the IRA to support workers who were in dispute with their employers. I do not see that any further comment is needed.
Comment on this
The Minister has by implication accused workers and trade unions of being implicated in this act.
Comment on this
I accuse no such person. The Official IRA issued a statement accepting responsibility for this act.
Comment on this
On a point of order, the Minister has accused workers by implication of being implicated in this incident. It is a despicable——
Comment on this
Deputy Corish, together with a number of other Deputies, inquired why people should be on remand so long. I think this inquiry is fair enough.
Comment on this
Would the Minister withdraw that accusation? By implication he has accused people I represent, workers and trade unionists, of Freshford, of being implicated——
Comment on this
But the Minister is connecting innocent workers in Freshford with this and putting a slur on trade unionists, a number of whom were locked out of work in Freshford.
Comment on this
The Minister is disgracing himself. It is no wonder that people riot when they have to listen to that kind of thing.
Comment on this
We had some cases of persons being held for some months in the file of prisoners on remand. I want——
Comment on this
On a point of order, in the various speeches made tonight the Minister was asked as to whether he would agree to a time limit.
Comment on this
Before coming to that I want to deal with the question of remands, because most of the prisoners in Mountjoy who were involved in this matter were, in fact, on remand. The first point in regard to it is that a very high proportion of them were in custody on remand of their own volition. They were there because they chose not to take bail which was offered to them, not because the bail was unobtainable but because, as a matter of principle, they decided they did not want to do it. The length of time for which they had been on remand is by no means excessive because in each court they come before, because of the fact that they are in custody even though it is of their own volition, they get priority in having their cases heard.
As regards the matter of a time limit in this Bill, I was surprised that this should be raised today because of the provisions of subsections (1) and (2) of section 2, which seem to have been ignored by Deputies opposite. One finds deep suspicion of motives read into almost any Bill one introduces nowadays without any reason for such motives existing. If I thought that it would be thought that I intended to keep this Bill or Act in force indefinitely I would have made it perfectly clear that there must be some time limit on it. I did not think that necessary. I thought subsection (1) of section 2 made that clear. I am prepared to approach this matter perfectly reasonably on the basis mentioned in my opening speech. Between now and tomorrow morning I am prepared to think up some amendment that would impose a time limit on it. The length of it I do not know: I would have to consult my advisers on that point.
Comment on this
In view of the opinions expressed fairly widely in the House and in most cases quite genuinely I feel I should accede to those views and include some time limit. I did mention that the repair of Mountjoy would take at least 12 months and there is no doubt that, in fact, it will. One of the methods by which Mountjoy will have to be repaired goes beyond just patching up damage that was done. The roofs in Mountjoy at the moment are very un-satisfactory. Unfortunately, because of their unusual design they are very accessible to prisoners climbing up inside. We will have to ensure that that problem will not continue. For that reason it will be necessary to put a new flat roof on each of the wings, one by one. The roofs will have to be stripped down. The additional cost, while it will be considerable, will not be as considerable as it might otherwise have been. Because the wings will have to be re-roofed one by one, the work is going to take a fairly considerable period to complete. Certain rebuilding will have to be done inside the building, from a security point of view. Because Mountjoy will not be fully secure to the extent I would wish it to be for an appreciable period over 12 months, the time limit which it will be decided between now and tomorrow morning, to insert into this Bill, in deference to the wishes of Deputies, will have to take these points into account.
Many other points were made to which I would like to refer. Unfortunately, in a debate like this I am as restricted as the Deputies opposite who are not able to speak. I cannot deal with all the points, but perhaps I could deal with specific points at least on Committee Stage.
Comment on this
Could I ask the Minister a question now? Would the Minister not consider supervision from his Department over what is termed in the Bill "military custody"?
Comment on this
No. This military detention barracks which we are using at the Curragh is in the middle of a large military complex. It creates enormous problems if there is any question of divided responsibility. The Minister for Defence will be responsible for the custody of these prisoners and he, in turn, will be responsible to this House in the same way as I am responsible to the House for the custody of prisoners in a civil prison. Since it is ensured in this Bill that the regulations governing their custody in military custody will not be less favourable that what would obtain for them in civil custody and since the Minister for Defence is answerable to this House, I do not think anybody need have any fears in that regard.
Comment on this
The Minister does make the point about conditions being "less favourable". It is not clear in the Bill that this is so. The Bill does not ensure that conditions will be the same. Will the Minister look at that point?
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?
Before the House adjourns may I inquire in what circumstances amendments may be submitted tomorrow morning?
Comment on this
I understand it has been arranged to accept amendments up to 1 o'clock this morning.
Comment on this
Who decided that? The normal way to decide business in the House is through the Whips. Has there been a discussion?
Comment on this
Inquiries have been made and we have been informed that amendments will be accepted as I have stated.
Comment on this
This just cannot be done. There is a procedure which must be adopted. I presume it was the Minister who decided this.
Comment on this
Could you say, Sir, if the normal procedure can be adopted and amendments be accepted up to some time tomorrow morning?
Comment on this
As the Bill is being taken at 10 o'clock it is under-standable that the amendments must be in before 10.
Comment on this
If Deputies arrive at, say, 9.31 with amendments, is that all right? In other words, they will not be locked out for the sake of a minute or two?