Prisons Bill, 1972: Committee Stage.
Contributions 184–383 of 383. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 9 of 1972 ›
I qualify that by saying that I do not wish to bind the Governor to accept a large party of Deputies during the next few days. He may not be prepared to do so but assuming that reasonable notice is given Deputies will be welcome.
Comment on this
That is another useful clarification because under previous Ministers some Deputies have been refused permission to visit the prison.
Comment on this
I cannot comment on that because I do not recall the circumstances but I take it that the Minister is not implying any innuendo here.
Comment on this
Having cleared up those points that the three conditions which I suggested earlier as a basis for agreeing to the form of this amendment would be met, we shall not oppose the amendment in its present form. However, I am concerned on one aspect. The reason why so much suspicion has been aroused in our minds is because of a passage in the Minister's speech which, to me at any rate, carried the clear implication that he was intending to consider using military custody not merely because of the absence of accommodation but because in his view certain prisoners require different treatment. There is a serious constitutional issue raised here. The passage is:
Nevertheless I could not give a reasonable assurance of protection to prison officers and other prisoners against the background of the risk of a repetition of last week's disorders unless I have the authority, which I am asking the House to give me now, to transfer to military custody certain prisoners who are liable to cause trouble.
I am afraid the Minister may have got himself into considerable difficulties with that statement because if that is really what is behind this Bill and if the Minister intends to operate it in that way and instead of simply selecting prisoners arbitrarily on the basis that they simply cannot be fitted into existing prisons, he intends to use military custody selectively in the way suggested here that is, to pick particular prisoners who are liable to cause trouble, as I understand it, the Bill would be unconstitutional. This is a matter to which we must give attention. As I understand from what was said last night on television by Senator John Kelly, who is a considerable authority on Irish constitutional law, it had been established in some case that if a Minister seeks in such a way to transfer prisoners to particular custody of a kind different from the normal kind and to discriminate against particular prisoners with the intention of so discriminating, such practice is unconstitutional. In so far as this Bill in its present wording permits this and in so far as it only requires him to have regard to the desirability of ensuring that the conditions of custody are not less favourable and in so far as he has specified that the intention is to pick on certain prisoners who are liable to cause trouble, I am afraid that all our efforts here today may be in vain and that the Bill may be unconstitutional.
Comment on this
What provision of the Constitution is the section of my speech alleged to contravene?
Comment on this
I am not in a position to be very helpful on this because I only heard what Professor Kelly said on television but I think it is related to the separation of powers, that only the judiciary can sentence people and that the Minister cannot vary the sentence. It seems to me that to send certain prisoners to a form of custody that is different from that to which others are sent is varying the sentence and would be likely to be so held by our courts. I am concerned that by that statement and by the inadequacy of the formulation of subsection (8) the Minister may have endangered this whole Bill.
Comment on this
It is because I want to explain why our suspicions have been aroused and why we have been so concerned that I have mentioned this but I mention it also for another practical reason which I hope I am in order in mentioning. This practical reason is that we will not reach subsection (8) and I would suggest to the Minister that between now and 3 o'clock he considers very seriously the Fine Gael amendment which may help to retrieve the position. I am not sure that in the light of the Minister's speech anything could retrieve the position but if anything can, it is the Fine Gael amendment.
Comment on this
There are a number of amendments but the ones with which I am concerned particularly are either 19 or 20. Number 20 is our preference but if not accepted it may be that No. 19 will save the situation. At this stage I merely suggest to the Minister that he would have his advisers look at these amendments, that he would not reject them out of hand at 3 o'clock in a series of votes before we have had a chance to explain the reasons for them. The acceptance of one or other of these amendments would result in saving the situation so that we would not be back here in a few days time with another Bill to overcome the problems created by the Minister's unfortunate reference and by the bad drafting of the Bill. I make that point at this stage because it is of vital importance.
In conclusion I would like to make one point in reply to a reference by Deputy O'Leary to allegations from these benches as to the Labour Party having associations with subversives.
Comment on this
As I have pointed out in a letter to the Irish Times in reply to Mr. Jack Dowling, I never made any reference during that campaign to anybody as being a subversive in any sense without specifically distinguishing the Labour Party and saying I was not referring to them and that their campaign was a constructive one which was being damaged by the actions of other elements.
Comment on this
Regarding the Fine Gael Ard-Fheis the only point I want to make is that Deputy O'Higgins paid tribute to the responsible members of the Labour Party for the courage they had shown in standing up to subversives. May I say that the Labour Party received a sustained ovation from the Fine Gael Ard-Fheis on that occasion. The Press, apparently, had left at that stage.
Comment on this
I shall be very brief. The Minister has complained about the time being allocated to this debate but this has not been a waste of time. The question of a time limit has been very important in the consideration of this Bill. It is not often that I pay tribute here to this particular Minister but we should recognise that he has made a move in the direction in which his critics have urged him to move, that is, in accepting the dropping of the word "later" but we on these benches would like this to be made more concise. I am not blaming the Minister for the wording because this was done in a hurry and did not, perhaps, get all the consideration it should have got, but I want to be quite clear that I understand the position aright. If Deputy Pattison tables a resolution on 30th November next—I am not now asking the Minister to commit the Government on this—will the Minister pledge himself to recommend to the Government that Government time will be allowed for the consideration of such a resolution within one month of its being tabled?
Comment on this
Yes, I will be prepared to do that. I am prepared to do that. I will make that recommendation.
Comment on this
First and foremost, I should like to place on record the fact that I wholeheartedly welcome the speech of the Taoiseach yesterday and the reinforcing of that speech by the undertaking given to this House this morning by the Minister for Justice that it is not intended to introduce detention without trial and that there will be no military courts. The Minister has given that undertaking. I welcome it.
Every Member of this House has a very grave responsibility in relation to these amendments and in relation to the underlying principle of the Bill. I am amazed that, despite the fact that it will take at least 12 months to repair and restore Mountjoy, we have this panic measure being rushed through Dáil Éireann, depriving the House of the opportunity of giving to the Bill the long and serious consideration legislation of this kind warrants. The Minister says it will take 12 months to repair Mountjoy. Is it not a fact that a considerable time will elapse during which the Office of Public Works will be engaged on inspecting and planning the premises? All the Minister told us was that the prison is to be restored to normal conditions in a period of 12 months. I fail then to understand the anxiety of the Minister to keep this Bill on the Statute Book for a period of two years. I do not see anything wrong with the Fine Gael amendment. To me it is a common-sense and logical amendment. It gives the Minister several months after the prison has been restored to a proper state of repair and the amendment tabled by the Labour Party is also a reasonable amendment because it merely seeks an opportunity for the House to review the whole position at the end of that period.
The time is long overdue for prison reform. Perhaps the riot last week and this panic legislation will result in bringing home to all of us the importance of giving special attention and consideration to the whole subject of prison reform. Many of us are deeply concerned about prison reform and there are those of us who devote a good deal of time to the submission of memoranda and the preparation of articles on prison reform. In the event of Mountjoy being fully restored at the end of the 12 months, what will be the purpose of detaining people in the Curragh under military supervision for a period longer than that? I should like to point out, too, that prison officers are highly trained personnel. That is more than can be said for the personnel of the Army. It is no part of their training to supervise detention.
It is regrettable that it should be necessary to table these amendments. It is regrettable that it was necessary for the Minister to introduce a Bill of this kind. There must be a place in which to detain those who break the law. Those who damage property or person must be catered for in institutions in which they can be rehabilitated so that they will emerge as publicspirited citizens and not just law breakers. With regard to the supervision by Army personnel of prisoners in the Curragh.
Comment on this
The period of this Bill. Prisoners who would normally be in the custody of prison officers will now be in the custody of Army personnel. I want to draw a comparison between the supervision exercised by Army personnel and that exercised by trained prison officers.
Comment on this
That might arise on the following amendments, but it certainly does not arise on these amendments.
Comment on this
We must ensure that what happened last week in Mountjoy will not recur. There must have been a reason for the deplorable disturbance and, in the event of such a disturbance in the Curragh——
Comment on this
These matters would not arise on these amendments. The amendments are very specific.
Comment on this
What I am saying is relevant to these amendments. It is wrong that prisoners convicted of offences—that could happen to any of us because there, but for the grace of God, go I—should be put under military supervision.
Comment on this
We have a guarantee from the Minister that this will only be for the period during which Mountjoy is being repaired and reconstructed. I do not know why the Minister wants the legislation to operate for one hour longer than the time taken to complete that work. The Government are not being honest in this matter because of the speed with which they are steamrolling this measure through because they want to have certain prisoners under military supervision for longer than is necessary. These are the difficulties I find and the reason why I support the amendments tabled. Citizens have certain rights and it is our duty to protect these rights. It may be said that a citizen loses his rights when he breaks the law and becomes a prisoner, but the law should be such as to give these people the rights to which they are entitled. Any prisoner found guilty of breaking the law and sentenced should be sent to the ordinary State prison administered by State machinery and not under Army supervision. It has been argued that however desirable it may be to find immediate accommodation for prisoners it will now be left in the hands of the Minister for Justice to decide what type of prisoner will be under military supervision.
Comment on this
The Deputy should speak to the amendment. We cannot have a Second Reading speech on the amendments.
Comment on this
I have made my point and I can make any further points on the Final Stage but I want to go on record as saying that it is wrong for the Government to rush this Bill through the House, as they are doing, depriving Deputies of time to deal with a vitally important piece of legislation. It may have become necessary in unusual circumstances but if it will take over 12 months to restore Mountjoy why could we not have at least one week to discuss this measure in Parliament? Therefore, I want to express my disapproval of the hasty, panic fashion in which the legislation is being put through the House. At the same time I agree with and wholeheartedly support the idea that we must have law and order and that people who break the law must be put away. This House must also ensure that there is justice and proper supervision and that prisoners will get whatever privileges the law entitles them to get. This Bill is inclined to take away certain rights from those convicted as regards the manner in which they must pay the penalty for the duration of their sentences and the circumstances in which they are detained.
The Minister says Deputies will be welcome to see what conditions are in Mountjoy. Could he give an undertaking that during the operation of this period any Deputy who desires to inspect the conditions of prisoners detained at the Curragh will get the same facilities, not for the purpose of causing embarrassment but in order to see that justice is done to those who may be detained there, that there are proper conditions, that the sanitary arrangements are in order and that in general the conditions which would operate in either Portlaoise or Mountjoy are maintained? To my knowledge prisoners' conditions in Portlaoise could not be improved. When we are detaining people for 12 or 15 months or two years in the Curragh in the absence of the experience of qualified prison governors such as we have in Mountjoy and Portlaoise——
Comment on this
I completely disapprove of rushing this measure through the House. There is an element of dishonesty associated with it and I want to go on record as having said that. Finally, will the Minister agree that if Deputies feel it necessary to visit the Curragh dentention camp, where certain prisoners at the discretion of the Minister will be maintained, they will be given the Minister's co-operation in satisfying themselves that conditions are as they should be?
Comment on this
The Minister is not here now and there is one point I should like to have clarified. Perhaps the Minister for Transport and Power might be able to clarify it. I understand the Minister has suggested that in six months he is prepared to have this matter reconsidered if it is raised in the House, that is the termination issue. In the Minister's amendment it is stated:
This section shall continue in operation until 31st day of May, 1974.
He is prepared to withdraw the remainder of that. If that is so, would the Minister be able to say if he considers it is possible to terminate it at an earlier date without having amending legislation brought into it, in view of the fact that this is written into the existing Bill? Would it not be preferable to have all the amendments withdrawn and the original text left with a guarantee from the Minister that he would be prepared to allow the matter to be raised after six months? I should like to have that clarified before we make up our minds.
Comment on this
I think that is a very constructive suggestion. If we delete "later", leaving "or such date" and if we can give the assurance that any motion can be put down——
Comment on this
That is not exactly what I am referring to. I am refering to the first line of the Minister's amendment:
This section shall continue in operation until 31st day of May, 1974.
Does the Minister consider if that is written into an Act it will be possible, without introducing amending legislation, to have the date earlier than 31st May, 1974?
Comment on this
May I point out that by deleting sections 1 and 2 in the original Bill we are taking out the power of resolution totally. If we merely accept the first line of the Minister's amendment we are confining everything to the 31st May, 1974. All we then have is an assurance, a very definite one, by the Minister that he would consider any resolution from the Labour Party in say six months time to change or terminate the operation of the Act. There is a genuine difficulty. It may be, as Deputy Tully suggests, that if we delete the word "later" and leave in the question of the resolution as suggested by the Minister also, we could proceed on that line.
Comment on this
We are aware of that. There is no point in talking of this afterwards. Let us clear it now. The amendment states:
This section shall continue in operation until the 31st day of May, 1974, or such later date (if any) as may for the time being stand specified by resolution of Dáil Éireann passed at a time when this section is in operation, and it shall then expire.
If the Bill is passed by this House and the Seanad and is signed and becomes law—although there may be a doubt about that and there could be a stormy passage if somebody decides to take it to the High Court—would the Minister be able to say there is no resolution required if we have a closing date? If the date is 31st May, 1974, we will then have no resolution or no necessity of having a resolution passed. Does the fact that a final date is specified mean that there is then no necessity for a resolution for a date? Will somebody at a later stage, perhaps the present Minister, say "that would only be if a resolution had been passed but no resolution was passed. Therefore 31st May, 1974, must stand as a date". It is only a matter for clarification.
Comment on this
My advice is that the resolution will negative the statutory situation.
Comment on this
It would be a major safeguard to the Bill in terms of the rights of the House if the clause was left in "may, by resolution, declare that it is satisfied as aforesaid and appoint a day on which this section shall cease to be in operation". We must retain within the Bill the power of termination.
Comment on this
Section 2 as it was appears to be better, on condition that it would be reviewed in six months time.
Comment on this
You are talking about subsection (1) of section 2. That seems better and clearer now.
Comment on this
This is relevant to a point I raised last night and to which the Minister did not reply. It was answered in this amendment as put down by the Minister. There was no provision in the Bill for a starting date. It was dealt with in this amendment. If the section—the existing subsection (2) —were to be left in, this would still leave you with the problem.
Comment on this
There is a great game that the Establishment is always right. Therefore, there is a pretence that the point I raised last night was not raised at all.
Comment on this
Why did he not say so publicly? I know why he did not do so. I am not under any illusions. I am not crowing over it. The answer is obvious. Common decency demands that if somebody raises a worthwhile point and if the Minister accepts it he should have the ordinary decency to say so. He should say that he is covering the point raised by Deputy So-and-So. I appreciate that Deputy Geoghegan is very quiet today.
Comment on this
Could we have it clarified by putting in the Minister's first line and after that subsection (1) of section 2? Would that copperfasten it so that there would be no doubt?
Comment on this
It is agreed that the amendment, as amended, shall constitute subsection (1) of section 2 and shall read:
(1) This section shall continue in operation until the 31st day of May, 1974.
That to be followed by the present subsection (1) of section 2 and subsection (2) of the section to be deleted.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 4 is more or less consequential on the other one. I will not be moving it. It does not arise.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 5:
In subsection (3), page 2, line 20, to delete "or prison staff".
The purpose of this amendment is to limit the operation of this section of the Bill to the problems arising from shortage of accommodation. The reason for the Bill was the damage done to accommodation in Mountjoy Prison. The words which I propose to delete are ones whose inclusion would justify the transfer to military custody of certain prisoners simply because the Minister had failed to ensure adequate prison staff. This is a different issue. Because the building has been damaged does not seem any reason for giving the Minister power to remedy inadequacies on his part in relation to the recruitment of prison staff by transferring people to military custody. The stated object of the Bill is to deal with the situation at Mountjoy. The inclusion of these words widens the operation of the Bill unduly and introduces another principle altogether whereby the Minister can hive off his responsibility for not employing prison staff and then say: "Take them away to the Curragh and put them in the charge of the Irish Army." This is objectionable and for that reason I put down this amendment.
Comment on this
We agree that this amendment is a reasonable one. Possibly the Minister did not think of the situation in that way when the section was being written. All of us agree that the prison staff have bewhich certainly were not usual. While haved very well——
Comment on this
——in circumstances there was a slight suggestion made by Deputy FitzGerald, I am sure he did not mean to cast a slur on a certain official when he asked about the official going around with a master key of the prison in his possession. I have never been in a prison in my life and I hope to stay out of it too, but we must all appreciate that in order to carry out his normal duty it would be necessary for a senior official to carry a key such as was in this man's possession. He as well as those who are under him deserve all credit for doing a tough job very well.
One thing which the Minister, who is now present, might convey to the Minister for Justice is in connection with the recruitment of staff, which is effected by this section. In my opinion, it is not being dealt with properly, because I understand some excellent people who have been interviewed have not been appointed because of their lack of knowledge of the Irish language. While it is a grand thing to know Irish and everybody should make an effort to learn it, if a suitable person offers himself for a job such as this—and we know what we mean by a suitable person: good character, good physique and so on— it is ridiculous that because he has not brushed up his Irish before he goes in for the interview and because of a stupid requirement like this the Minister can say in this House: "I am sorry, we cannot get the staff." I would suggest that this amendment by Fine Gael should be accepted by the Minister, as it would improve the Bill.
Comment on this
I am sure Deputy FitzGerald's amendment will have the wholehearted support of this House and I am convinced that it will be accepted by the Minister. We should place on record that there are no more dedicated personnel in the Public Service than the staff of our prisons. As a result of the passing of this legislation it may be possible for the Minister for Justice to use the circumstances at Mountjoy and the fact that certain prisoners will be detained in military custody as an excuse for not employing additional prison officers. I have never been, I am happy to announce, in the custody of these prison officers, but from my experience I know they are highly trained and devoted to the rehabilitation of those in their charge.
I have known for over 30 years, certainly much longer than the Minister for Justice, the Governor of Mountjoy Prison. It is only right that it should go on record that no single person in the Public Service has done more to reform and rehabilitate many of those who are in his charge. This same governor has impressed on his staff the necessity to be human and sympathetic towards prisoners and do all in their power to rehabilitate those prisoners. A few moments ago when I was speaking on the other amendments you, Sir, correctly advised me that I was not in order. I feel I am in order now on this amendment in saying that the Army personnel would not have the same understanding or method of approach in dealing with prisoners or prison officers. I would like to impress on the Government the necessity for continuance of recruitment of men of the very high standard of those who are in our prison service. Many of them have entered on a career in which they feel they can do something useful and effective in life. They are there not because it is a job but because they are devoted to their calling in the same way as a doctor or a nurse is devoted to his or her calling. They feel that they have a contribution to make towards rehabilitating the less fortunate citizens who find themselves in conflict with the law. Many of those who have served various sentences in our prisons are now rehabilitated in life and in employment and have never since broken the law.
This is one section of our Public Service of which we can be proud. These prison officers seldom come under notice or discussion but, by their humanity, sympathy and understanding, they have done great work in Portlaoise, Mountjoy, Cork and Limerick. I hope that recruitment will be continued and that some arrangement can be made between the Minister for Justice and the Minister for Defence so that there can be some form of liaison between the prison officers and the military authorities in order to ensure that those who will be detained will not find themselves under the complete supervision of the military authorities. I do not know if Deputy FitzGerald and Deputy Tully have considered this matter, but since there is about to be detention at the Curragh, I am wondering if there could be a sharing of responsibility between the Army authorities and the prison officers staff.
Comment on this
This is something that should be done and it is one of the reasons that I am sorry this legislation is being put through hastily. As I say, the prison officers deserve our deepest appreciation for the manner in which they have carried out their duties in the various prisons.
Comment on this
I wish to support Deputy FitzGerald's reasoning on this amendment. However, I believe that Members of the House are not being entirely honest in facing up to the implications of the section and the Bill itself. It may be appropriate to pose the question: What if some of the prisoners are not amenable, in any circumstances, to supervision by prison staff? If the accommodation were fully adequate, if the prisoners could not be kept in normal security in normal prison circumstances, what if they would not respond? This is the nub of the Bill, the reason why the Bill was introduced. It is fortuitous as far as the Government are concerned that there was a particular occurrence in Mountjoy which the Government have availed of to have a second form of detention—military and custodial. Therefore, I wonder as to real purpose or value of the amendment. If one deletes the words "prison staff" there will remain the sole question of prison accommodation. I believe that the words "prison staff" should be deleted. It is implied in the amendment that there is a security problem facing prison staff. I do not think we should stress the point. Therefore it would be as well to delete the words "prison staff" and as soon as prison accommodation is adequate and is restored to normal the prisoners concerned would go back to normal prison life.
I must confess that section 3 as it stands and as it is proposed to be amended raises the whole question of military custody and it is an issue which deserves to be thoroughly teased out. The most remarkable feature of this debate has been the total absence of any contribution from the Minister for Defence.
Comment on this
The fact that powers are proposed to be devolved on the Irish Army is directly connected with the question of taking out the words "prison staff" in the amendment. It would be wise that the House should hear from the Minister for Defence what kind of arrangements will be made.
Comment on this
It is a question of responsibility being allocated. It is the job of the Minister for Justice.
Comment on this
I should like to endorse what Deputy Desmond has said. Normal procedure in a case like this in a normal Parliamentary assembly is for two Ministers to sit together there and to be joined in the discussion. It is very curious that the Minister for Defence has not bothered to appear in the House during this discussion. It does suggest a very odd method of government.
Comment on this
It is an elementary management principle. The responsibility rests with the Minister for Justice.
Comment on this
The responsibility rests with the Minister for Justice. The normal thing is for another Minister who is involved to be present beside him and in consultation with him and to be able to contribute.
Comment on this
This is what government is about—allocating responsibility.
Comment on this
Will the Minister explain why the Minister for Defence has not come in and sat down where he is?
Comment on this
The next point I want to make is to support what Deputy Tully has said on the question of recruitment of prison staff. There is nothing that would be more abhorrent than that the imposition of a condition in respect of the Irish language would be used as an excuse to lock people up in military custody rather than in civil custody. I should like an assurance from the Minister that in the recruitment of prison staff, announced by the Minister for Justice, any inhibitions of that kind will not be allowed to stand in the way of recruiting sufficient staff and that if there are any provisions or regulations that they will be waived. The emergency is much too serious for this. We are not in the position where, when we recruit for the Army, we insist that they can speak Irish and allow the country to be defenceless because of people's inadequacy in that language. I do not see why that should be so in the case of prison staff. I would be glad if the Minister could offer me an assurance there.
Comment on this
In the matter of looking after his interests we should be quite sure that there will be somebody who could chat with him and advise him and show an interest in his position in the language to which he is accustomed.
Comment on this
During the last emergency in the Curragh there was a very good Irish school set up by the internees and they learned more Irish than was learned for a long time.
Comment on this
Nobody is in doubt about that. We are talking about any regulation which would say that nobody could be recruited who was not fluent in Irish. Of course, every effort should be made to recruit people who are fluent in Irish. Of course, the present staff have been recruited on that basis and, of course, therefore, the fact that some recruits in this emergency period might not have Irish would not mean that there would not be the great majority of the prison staff capable of conversing in Irish. That was implicit in what I said. I am glad that Deputy Tunney has given me the opportunity of making it explicit.
The third point I want to make is something which Deputy Tully raised. I am glad of the opportunity of making it clear that I did not intend last night any reflection on a particular officer because I was trying to pinpoint responsibility on the Minister and to inquire from him precisely what were the circumstances in which this riot happened. If anything I said appeared to reflect on an officer, it was inadvertent and I would certainly like to withdraw it and I am glad that Deputy Tully has given me the opportunity to do so.
On the particular point of the wording here, "prison staff", I want to press this point: Deputy Desmond seems to suggest that the inclusion of this might in some way open it up to the Minister to transfer prisoners to military custody because it would be beyond the powers of the prison staff to control them. My understanding of the word "insufficient" in this context is that it means numerically insufficient. The inclusion of "prison staff" therefore merely means that an insufficiency of number of prison staff would under this Bill justify a transfer. There is nothing in this Bill that would justify transfer of prisoners, as I understand it, on the basis that the prison staff were incapable, by virtue of some incapacity, of handling prisoners. Transfer would only arise if they were incapable of doing so by virtue of inadequate numbers.
Comment on this
I am glad to see that the Minister agrees with me on that point. We are down then to the question as to whether the opportunity provided by this riot should be used to introduce legislation enabling the Minister for Justice to shrug off his responsibility for the recruitment of prison staff by transferring prisoners over to military custody because he has not recruited enough prison staff. It is suggested that if the riot had not occurred the Minister would not have been coming in here seeking this power. There is no reason why he should take advantage of it to get this power now.
Comment on this
No, I do not think I can. I am concerned about the reality of the situation. I think Deputy FitzGerald at the end of his contribution got to the nub of it. It is quite clearly included in subsection (3) to accommodate a situation that could arise very easily. Once we are bringing in a measure of this kind it is important that all the eventualities should be covered. One of the realities of the situation may be that there may be an insufficiency of prison staff and if that is the case then the subsection covers it. It is designed entirely to cover eventualities. Prison staff recruitment is being accelerated. There have been a number of interviews very recently for this purpose. The personnel are being increased. The main purpose of the subsection—and it does not seem to me to make very much point to delete by way of amendment, as suggested, "or prison staff"—is to cover eventualities, to cover situations that may arise. It is a perfectly practical coverage envisaged in the subsection and in my view the proposed amendment would delimit the subsection.
Comment on this
I do not see much point in it. Having regard to the general principle of the Bill, surely here we have a subsection that is intended to make the Bill realistic in operation. Prison accommodation and prison staff are the two realities involved.
Comment on this
You do not recruit staff and, therefore, you have not got enough staff for the Curragh.
Comment on this
The two are intertwined. Whenever the Minister is of opinion that neither is suitable to do the particular job that is envisaged here, we transfer the powers and so on as set out in the remainder of the Bill. It all fits in and it would be an unnecessary minimisation of the effect of the Bill to have this amendment accepted. I am certainly against it.
Comment on this
The purpose of the amendment is to limit the Bill to the consequences of the Mountjoy riot and not to give the Minister power under it to hive off his responsibility if he fails to recruit sufficient staff. Therefore, I press the amendment.
Comment on this
Despite the fact that the evidence of your eyes is against you, in the interests of getting on with the business I shall not press it to a division. There are other very important amendments to come.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 8:
In subsection (3), page 2, line 25, after "treatment" to insert "and welfare".
This is a minor one just to ensure that account will be taken not merely of the adequacy of arrangements for rehabilitative treatment but the adequacy of arrangements for the general welfare of prisoners in making a decision on this point. It is designed to help the Bill along and perhaps in a sense to widen it but in a constructive way. I commend it to the House.
Comment on this
I think it is a very constructive amendment. We accept it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 9:
In subsection (3), page 2, line 29, after "him" to insert "provided that only that number of persons who cannot be accommodated in prisons in reasonable conditions of custody without serious detriment to the maintenance in prisons of the normal arrangements for the rehabilitative treatment and welfare of prisoners, shall be so transferred".
This is one of the most important amendments to the Bill because, as drafted, the Bill imposes no limits on the number of persons who can be transferred to military custody. It does not require that those numbers should be limited to the number for whom no accommodation, or as the Bill now exists, inadequate staff exist to look after them and to accommodate them. What this amendment seeks to do is to ensure in so far as, but only in so far as, the accommodation and staff is inadequate to cope with prisoners in civil prisons then whatever surplus of prisoners who cannot be so coped with can be transferred to military custody. As the stated purpose of the Bill is to deal with this emergency problem, this surplus of prisoners who cannot be catered for within the existing system because of what has happened in Mountjoy, it is entirely logical, entirely in concert with the spirit and the intent of the Bill, to delimit the provisions of the Bill in this way. It seems to me there can be no objection to this amendment if the Minister in his opening statement was being honest with us. He has protested that he was being honest in giving us the full picture. If that is the case, and I am prepared to accept that from him, then this amendment must be accepted. There may be some drafting problems but we gave a good deal of thought to drafting and the wording of the conditions has been drawn from the Bill itself. We say:
Provided that only that number of persons who cannot be accommodated in prisons in reasonable conditions of custody without serious detriment to the maintenance in prisons of normal arrangements for the rehabilitative treatment and welfare of prisoners, shall be so transferred.
These are precisely the conditions laid down in the Bill and this simply says that the Bill shall be used only for the purpose stated in the Bill and that there shall be no question of using the Bill to hive off responsibility and to transfer prisoners who can be accommodated in civil prisons. I think there can be no opposition to this so I shall not waste the time of the House any further on this point.
Comment on this
I am in the difficulty that I have not had an opportunity really to study the various amendments as deeply as I would like which is not my fault or anyone else's fault, but I am afraid I could not accept this particular amendment. It could considerably weaken subsection (3) of section 2 and I suggest to the House that only the Minister is in a position to know and determine who are the recalcitrant prisoners at any particular time.
Comment on this
There is nothing in the Bill about recalcitrant prisoners. That is an unfortunate gaffe in the Minister's speech.
Comment on this
What is said in the House is not of relevance to the court. A court can look at the Act and the Act only and not the speeches made in relation to it.
Comment on this
That is a very ominous statement after what has been said about section 2 when something that was said in the House was responsible for having it accepted in a certain way. The Minister has said in the House and has on record that he would allow the matter to be reviewed at the end of six months. I would be afraid that if the Minister puts that on record as well it means we are wasting time here.
Comment on this
I do not think it would be fair to bind the Minister to the restriction in this proposed amendment. There are more factors than this involved.
Comment on this
The Minister this morning made a comment about a certain type of prisoner and I assume from what he said that this arrangement is in order to deal with a certain type of prisoner.
Comment on this
That is the point I should like to have clarified. Perhaps the Minister can take us into his confidence and let us know what exactly is the position because if he is saying now that any person who is awkward can be put into military custody when what the Minister has at the back of his mind is that it is intended for prisoners who have been associated with arms et cetera, let us hear it. It would be very unfair to the House if that is the idea and we only got a hint of it this morning from the Minister. I assume from what he said that that is what he intends. He can say that what he said in this House is not evidence in court but in my opinion that is what he said. I should like to get this clarified.
Comment on this
What I have said is that the type of prisoner one envisages transferring would be primarily prisoners who are liable to cause trouble and serious trouble in prisons. They are not confined entirely to the classes that I think possibly the Deputy may have in mind.
Comment on this
The Minister would want to go back and get the statement he made this morning. If he had the same crystal ball as the Taoiseach he might know this matter was going to be raised. If he looks at the unrevised documentation he will find that he was far more specific than that this morning. This should be clarified. In addition to the people who are on charges for possession of arms or explosives for bank robberies and so on, for being in either wing of the IRA, the Minister is now including people who might be awkward. He did not say that this morning and I should like clarification on this point.
Comment on this
Those who are in the Curragh at the moment are not confined to the group who describe themselves as political prisoners. It also includes people up on certain other crimes of violence.
Comment on this
That is not the point. We are not talking about socalled political prisoners and the rest. We are talking about vital constitutional points on which the survival of this Bill may depend. The Minister seems to be imperilling it every time he speaks on the subject. Will the Minister not accept that in so far as he describes military custody as being different from normal custody, as being a custody which is more secure involving conditions which will create greater security, arguably this means different conditions for the prisoners? In this case any attempt by him to select prisoners on a basis of what he regards as their recalcitrance or their liability to cause trouble and to send them to a different kind of custody is, of its nature, unconstitutional. The more the Minister introduces that principle the more trouble he is in.
Comment on this
That principle does not necessarily arise here. The Deputy should remember that at the moment the Minister for Justice has considerable discretion in his treatment of sentenced people. For example, I am empowered to transfer them from one prison to another——
Comment on this
That is not so. For example, the conditions in Portlaoise prison, which was formerly known as our convict prison, clearly are different from conditions in the Limerick or the new Cork prisons which are prisons for persons serving short terms of imprisonment. One must differentiate even within Mountjoy itself—there are different classes there. There are people who after a time are entitled to be treated in the corrective training unit and the treatment in that unit is different from that in the division for what might be described as ordinary convicted prisoners. In turn, the conditions there are significantly different from what remand prisoners are subject to; one might say each class has a different category of rights.
Comment on this
We accept that. When a judge sentences a person to prison he is sentencing him to a condition of confinement which may vary in detail from prison to prison, even within a prison, depending on a prisoner's behaviour. We are talking here of the handing over of prisoners to military custody, specified by the Minister in his opening speech and in what he has said just now, designed to be so much more onerous in terms of security arrangements as to be likely to create a more disciplined situation among those concerned. This appears to me to be varying the sentence.
The Minister might succeed in getting away with this in the courts on the basis that this Bill simply tries to deal with a situation where there is a surplus of prisoners who cannot be accommodated and that all he is doing is selecting on a non-selective basis a number who have to be temporarily held in military custody. However, once he starts speaking about selecting recalcitrant prisoners or prisoners liable to cause trouble and putting them in different conditions outside the civil prison, he is probably doing something which could be described as varying the sentence. The more the Minister speaks about his selecting people on this basis and on the need to be able to put into military custody more than that number that is necessitated by the lack of accommodation in the civil prison, by definition he is estopped from arguing that this is simply an emergency and temporary provision. The Minister has spoken about recalcitrant people and those liable to cause trouble. If he is selecting people for different kinds of treatment the constitutional issue could be brought in here. If the Minister accepts my amendment I hope it will help in some way to protect him from the constitutional consequences of certain aspects of the Bill and of his whole approach to this problem.
Comment on this
I appreciate what the Deputy is getting at but, although his point might appear very well in theory, I do not think the Deputy appreciates the practicalities of the matter. If I pick X number of prisoners and send them into military custody for the reasons set out here, because their retention in ordinary custody would be seriously detrimental to the maintenance in prisons of the normal arrangements for the rehabilitative treatment and welfare of prisoners, I can well be faced immediately afterwards with an action in the High Court looking for a certiorari or possibly habeas corpus on the grounds that I was not right in my judgement. It might be stated that to transfer 40 prisoners was excessive, that under this section, if this amendment were accepted, I should have transferred only 35 persons. Evidence would be called to prove that 35 was the correct number to transfer, not 40. One would have an intolerable situation because no Minister could safely transfer anyone. What the Deputy says may have a certain validity in theory but he must face up to practicalities. In fact, the provision would introduce a degree of rigidity into the operation of the section which unquestionably would leave the Minister open to vexatious and frivolous actions.
The Minister frequently may have to make up his mind very quickly when a particular situation arises. Such a situation could arise in an afternoon if a large number of people were arrested and remanded in custody. I do not think any Minister could reasonably operate under a provision such as this where there would be a solemn finding in the High Court, possibly several months afterwards, by a judge that the transfer of 40 persons to military custody was excessive and that under the provisions of this section 35 should have been sufficient. I do not think it would be fair to a Minister to bind him to that extent, that a perfectly valid and bona fide transfer order, or series of orders, could be upset afterwards.
Comment on this
Did I understand the Minister to say that it is his intention only to transfer that number of prisoners who cannot be accommodated on the conditions set out here?
Comment on this
It is my intention to transfer only such a number of prisoners as is necessary to allow the maintenance in prisons of the normal arrangements for rehabilitative treatment and welfare of prisoners generally.
Comment on this
Yes, but I do not want it to be said to me afterwards if there are a dozen vacant cells in Mountjoy, Portlaoise or Limerick that I could take 12 of these people out of the Curragh and put them in there.
Comment on this
The Minister is concerned with not getting into a position where he can be dragged into the courts on an argument as to whether there were two cells available on a certain night and whether people could have been transferred over to the prison that night. This seems reasonable and we should like to accommodate him on it. If we have an assurance that he will operate the Bill in that way we will accept it. If at some stage it transpires that for prolonged periods there were 12 cells empty in Portlaoise naturally we would come back and take it up with him to find out whether it was in accordance with his assurance. That is the duty of an Opposition.
I am asking him if he will give an assurance that this is the way the Bill will be operated. Of course, we have to be reasonable. Of course, if there is a spare cell somewhere for a couple of nights we will not complain that somebody was not shifted from the Curragh that night. Is it the intention broadly that it will be operated in that way?
Comment on this
The point I am making is this: there could be ten or 12 vacant cells in one of our prisons over a prolonged period and I would still feel justified in keeping X number in the Curragh or in military custody.
Comment on this
Because to bring back those ten or 12 might then be a serious detriment to the maintenance in prisons of the normal arrangements for the rehabilitative treatment and welfare of prisoners. If the Deputy would come down out of the clouds of theory and put his feet on the ground and see reality, he would realise that you could have ten vacant cells for a long time in a prison but if I were to fill those ten cells with ten people who would wreck that prison, and the whole organisation of it, I would not feel myself bound to bring them back.
Comment on this
The Minister is now talking in terms which are not warranted by the wording in the Bill. He is not entitled to talk in terms of certain individuals who may cause trouble. The point is whether the number of persons—not the number, and quality, or calibre, or political attitudes, or aggressiveness—would be such that it would be impossible to provide reasonable conditions of custody and secure the maintenance of normal arrangements.
Comment on this
The wording in the Bill is that "prison accommodation or prison staff is insufficient".
Comment on this
I accept that—insufficient for this purpose. The Minister is seeking to suggest that the Bill, as drafted, enables him not merely to operate on the basis of the sufficiency in terms of numbers of staff and amount of accommodation but also whether particular individuals put into a prison will cause trouble. I do not think the Bill justifies that and if it does, it is unconstitutional, I think. I wish the Minister would not press that point. It seems to be a very weak argument, indeed. If he intends to use this Bill selectively and to take people out because he does not fancy the way they might behave, and shove them into military custody, and keep them there while there is accommodation in the prisons, and staff, I do not accept that. I do not believe it is what the Bill gives effect to. If the Bill does mean that, it is unconstitutional; and I cannot accept it. If the Minister cannot give the assurance I am looking for, the amendment will have to be pressed.
Comment on this
I have given the assurance that the sort of people who will be transferred are those who cannot be held in civil prison without serious detriment to the maintenance in prison of the normal arrangements for the rehabilitative treatment and welfare of prisoners. They are the words in the amendment. I can give an undertaking to that extent, subject to the point I am making, because I do not want the Deputy to come back afterwards and say, if there are a few vacant cells in a prison, I did not fulfil this undertaking.
With all respect, the Deputy is a very good arguer in theory, one might say in vacuo, but you must have your feet on the ground and see what the situation is and realise the sort of situation a governor is faced with in an emergency and what that governor can do.
Comment on this
The Minister is talking himself into a corner. He will not get away with that. If he starts transferring people simply because of the way he thinks they will behave and he is taken to court on that, even with the Bill as it stands never mind my amendment, no court will sustain him on that. The wording of the Bill does not relate to how the person behaves or might behave, but to the sufficiency of accommodation and staff. These are the only criteria in the Bill.
The Bill does not tie down how many people the Minister transfers. It makes it perfectly clear that the only criterion for having a transfer of some kind and some number is sufficiency of staff and accommodation. If the Minister is brought to court and starts arguing that these people are recalcitrant and he has to keep them in military custody, even though there is accommodation in the prison, the Bill will not support him. If that is what he wants he had better draft a different Bill and see if he can get it past the Constitution which I doubt.
He is now playing a very difficult and foolish game of using a Bill designed to deal with the Mountjoy situation, and the lack of accommodation as a result of the Mountjoy situation, to try to get around the Constitution by setting criteria in the Bill while he intends to operate totally different criteria contrary to the provisions of the Constitution. The more he says that, the less will the Bill stand up on any grounds. We are concerned not that the Minister can discriminate amongst prisoners and lock up particular groups of prisoners in the Curragh because he thinks they will cause trouble, but with getting over the problem created by Mountjoy being destroyed effectively, and to ensure that, as from now, prisoners cannot take a habeas corpus action because they are in military custody and get out. We are trying to help the Minister towards that, but he is playing a different game altogether.
Comment on this
With all due respect to the Deputy who cannot, I think, envisage the practicalities of it, the amendment as part of this Bill will not get over the problem of habeas corpus with which I am faced. It will involve me as defendant in a large number of frivolous actions by people who will say: "There are 40 people in the Curragh today; there should be only 35," and start subpoenaing governors to say how many vacant cells they had on the night of 22nd May, or whatever it is, and try then by a process of addition and subtraction to say: "There were 40 of us in the Curragh that night but the Minister could have accommodated five of us, if he put two in Cork, and one in Limerick, and one in St. Patrick's, or somewhere else." The court would then find itself bound to make a nominal finding, at any rate, for the plaintiff in such an action against me. I would be tied up in knots.
It would mean that any time you wanted to make a transfer you would have to make all kinds of elaborate calculations as to whether or not it was justified. I am prepared to operate this reasonably but I cannot be tied down to the sheer mathematical accuracy of one vacant cell which may become vacant at very short notice in Cork. If a man is in Cork prison for non-payment of a fine and his wife or brother arrives in with the money and hands it to the governor, there and then the governor discharges that man. That vacancy may occur at 5 o'clock in the evening. The governor may have reported to the Department at 10 o'clock that morning that he did not have any vacancies. One could find oneself tied up in the courts in all this kind of trivia. It would become impossible to operate the section if this amendment were put in. I see what the Deputy is getting at. I do not disagree with him in theory but I ask him not to bind me so precisely in words that I would find myself in that situation.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I can see the Minister's difficulty. I can see that he does not want to provide a sort of bed bureau such as is operated by Bord Fáilte or the tourist organisations. I was a little alarmed at a statement by the Minister since he came in here. He said that if he had ten vacant cells in a prison it would not be reasonable for him to transfer to that prison ten prisoners he thought might wreck the place.
That suggests to me that the Minister, or somebody under his authority, will decide on the type of prisoner who will be detained in the ordinary prisons, and the type of prisoner who will be detained in military custody. If that is what we are doing, we should say so. If we are providing a political prison let us stop shadow-boxing. If IRA prisoners who started the rumpus in Mountjoy are to be transferred to the Curragh Camp the Minister should tell the House that. So far as I know he has not said that, or anything like it, when introducing the Bill.
Comment on this
Of course the Deputy will appreciate that one of my difficulties in dealing with that field at all, or speaking in that field, is the imminence, as I understand it, of charges against quite a number of these people many of whom come into that particular category, and while what I say in the House cannot be used in a court in the interpretation of an Act, what I say can be used on behalf of a defendant.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I can appreciate that the Minister might be in trouble in discussing existing prisoners but there is nothing to prevent him discussing prisoners who may come into custody months ahead. I get the impression from what the Minister says that he intends to transfer political prisoners, IRA prisoners, to the Curragh. That may be necessary and it may not be necessary—I do not know—but it certainly appears to me that the security was grossly inadequate in Mountjoy Prison, and if it had not been grossly inadequate and if the staff had not been ridiculously inadequate in numbers, what happened last week should not have happened and certainly could not have developed into the riot into which it did develop. I believe in calling a spade a spade and I believe the Minister has come to the House to introduce a Bill in the terms in which it is, knowing he will have power to be selective under it, to select the prisoners he will send to a certain detention centre. I think he should tell the House that because it is only a continuation of the sort of shadow-boxing the Taoiseach has been going on with for the past two or three years, in not calling a spade a spade and making a statement today that could mean anything and contradicting it tomorrow. I am as certain as I can be on anything that the Minister thinks that he has now, or will have in the future, a type of prisoner he cannot either contain or control in a civilian prison and is going to transfer them into military custody. He should say that and ask the House for the necessary powers to enable him to do that. He should make the case.
Comment on this
If I have enough room and enough staff in the civil prison, I will not have to do so, but I cannot frankly envisage that situation existing in the next two years because I have lost so much accommodation in Mountjoy and on top of that, the graph gives every indication that the numbers of those committed to prison will continue to rise and possibly at a fairly steep rate.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I put it to the Minister, the Minister having said that, that the Minister over the past 12 months had sufficient accommodation but did not get sufficient civil staff.
Comment on this
On the contrary, I employed over 100 additional staff in the prisons in the past 12 months and when I speak of 100 additional people, I do not mean any element of the filling of vacancies—100 extra people were employed. I have been constantly very short of accommodation over the past 12 months and have had to take a step which I regret of having in certain instances—fortunately they were very limited—to release prisoners before the expiration of their sentences.
Comment on this
(Cavan): The Minister is getting me away from the point I was making. I am suggesting to him that he knowing the number of prisoners and the type of prisoner he had in Mountjoy, his security was inadequate. Here is what happened as far as I understand. One senior prison officer was overcome and there was nobody to come to his aid and the people who overpowered him took the keys from him, and everybody ran amok.
Comment on this
If the Deputy goes back to his speeches around Christmas, he will find that his criticism of me in relation to Mountjoy was that there was too much security.
Comment on this
I was told that there was not sufficient effort to rehabilitate prisoners and too much emphasis in our prisons on security.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I defy the Minister to find any quotation from a speech of mine to justify that. I put it to the Minister in relation to the powers he is seeking now that he had a situation in Mountjoy within the past week, knowing the type of prisoner he had there in which one senior officer was overpowered, in which there was nobody to come to his aid, in which he was single-handed, walking around the prison with the master key in his pocket which was taken from him, with nobody there to rescue it. That is the simple state of affairs. This may be more appropriate on the Estimate and when we come to the Estimate I intend to drive it home.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I want the Minister to clarify his intentions with regard to the Bill. I am not saying he should not do it. When we are dealing with men who have dangerous ideas——
Comment on this
Surely what the Deputy is endeavouring to get me to say now is the very thing which Deputy FitzGerald has been suggesting to me I should not say. Whatever about the future, the best indication of things is the present and the present inmates of the Curragh, detention prison or whatever it is— military detention barracks is its precise and full title—are there on a great variety of charges which go far beyond firearms and Offences Against the State Act charges.
Comment on this
(Cavan): There are prisoners of a type there but what I am trying to get the Minister to do is to call a spade a spade, to tell us what he intends to do.
Comment on this
Deputy FitzGerald does not want me to call it a spade because he is afraid we will run into trouble.
Comment on this
(Cavan): What the Minister is doing is trying to sell the House a pig in a poke, to get a blank cheque. That has been fairly consistent Government policy over the years—“Give us a blank cheque and we will operate it.” I do not say for one moment that the powers being sought are not necessary, but I say that they are being sought in a dishonest way, in a camouflaged manner, so that the Government will have the best of both worlds. I would like the Minister to come out in the open and tell us what he is at.
Comment on this
What I am at, and I have said it many times, is endeavouring to solve over the next two years the accommodation problem created by recent events in Mountjoy, bearing in mind, and I must bear it in mind as a result of what happened last Thursday night, that there is a certain type of prisoner in our prisons who is more liable than another type, shall we say, to cause this trouble. I must bear that in mind, but that is only a factor I keep in the back of my mind. The problem I have is that I have not enough accommodation and if I did not get the Curragh the other day, I would have had to release 40 people. I would not want to release 40 people and particularly if the reason I was releasing them would in effect have been their own criminal actions last Thursday night.
Comment on this
We would like to help the Minister because I can see that the amendment as drafted could pose problems for him because of a certain rigidity and get him into difficulties in the courts, even where he was doing his best to operate it but where a cell happened to be free on a particular night, but to drop it we need an assurance which is adequate and unfortunately the form of assurance given by the Minister is that he talks selectively about recalcitrant prisoners and it makes it very difficult to accept it when the Bill never contemplates this category. The Bill is concerned with lack of accommodation and staff and I have to repeat my question to the Minister: could he not find some way to say to us that if we do not press the amendment, it is his intention that in so far as accommodation and staff are adequate to provide secure and reasonable conditions of custody and adequate rehabilitative treatment of prisoners, to the extent and only to the extent that accommodation is inadequate for that purpose, he will——
Comment on this
We might get over the difficulty for both of us in this way. I think that what has caused the difficulty for the Deputy is that I said that there might be instances where there were ten vacant cells on a particular night and I did not make transfers back.
Comment on this
Yes, indeed, over quite a period and I did not make transfers back to civil custody at that time. I would only refuse to make those transfers back to those ten cells if the staff were inadequate in numbers to maintain proper order and to carry out proper rehabilitation and welfare duties. That covers the point adequately. What I wished to make very clear was that the fact of there being a few vacant cells on a particular night or over a period would not, ipso facto, bind me to withdrawing people from military custody. I will keep full every civil cell I have provided I have enough civil staff to ensure not only safe custody but proper rehabilitation and welfare work.
Comment on this
(Cavan): In arriving at that the Minister would have regard to the type of prisoner he would be dealing with?
Comment on this
Has the Minister told the House that he intends to staff the Cork unit of Collins Barracks or whether it is to be staffed by military personnel?
Comment on this
Cork has been in operation since about the middle of February. There are about 90 prisoners in Cork as a result of the recent transfer which number is much higher than we intended to have there at this stage. However, the governor and staff there are doing remarkably well in the emergency in which we find ourselves. Cork is entirely a civil prison and the situation is different entirely to the Curragh situation. At the Curragh the premises we are using are in the centre of a large military complex and it is an impossible situation to try to operate together a civil and a military authority. It is in a military camp so the military must run it.
Comment on this
Cork is a separate premises and there is a public road dividing it from the military barracks. It is completely a self-contained entity and it is feasible to run it purely as a civil institution. That is being done since February and will continue to be done notwithstanding the passage of this Bill.
Comment on this
The Minister has been careful all along and I agree with him in his care, not to distinguish between different classes of prisoners in relation to the offences for which they are in prison.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I am not but when I came in the Minister was saying that he would select the type of prisons to which he would send people.
Comment on this
In view of the Minister's care not to make any distinction will he assure the House that in making transfers to military custody there will be no distinctions?
Comment on this
In view of the assurance given by the Minister, expressed as it is in terms of accommodation of staff, it seems to be entirely in line with the criteria laid down in subsection (3) and I am prepared to withdraw the amendment.