Finance (No. 2) Bill, 1971: Committee Stage.
Contributions 220–451 of 451. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 30 of 1971 ›
May I say the same to the Minister? From the comments of some of his colleagues today it would appear he may be needing a little extra support before very long. Perhaps my comments before this were a little bit uncharitable because this is one of those Bills which I feel is not really a political Bill. The Government have brought it in and are going to bulldoze it through. All of us are responsible for trying to have it improved if we possibly can. Possibly it should have been dealt with in the same way as the Income Tax Consolidation Bill was dealt with a few years ago. It was discussed by a committee outside the House before it was brought in here. It could have saved us a lot of trouble if this Bill were dealt with in the same way. Perhaps Deputy Burke might be interested in this. The Minister has decided to introduce one tax to replace two. The only difference is that the one tax he proposes to introduce is a tax which applies all round. He is replacing two taxes, one of which applies fairly generally and the other is a fairly specific tax. How anybody can claim that it is all right to introduce one tax, which will cover everything, to replace two which are not the same at all, is hard to understand. Might I go back to my original comment to the Minister? Perhaps he might reconsider this again. I believe that the taxpayer, the retailer who buys goods and must of necessity pay tax on them, whether he recovers it or not, before he retails them——
Comment on this
He must pay the tax which has been paid by the person who sells the goods to him. The Minister must admit that that is so. If somebody buys something at £10 and sells it to somebody else for £12 and there is tax on that, the person who buys the article must pay the tax which has been paid beforehand. Of course, he can recover that at a later stage, but he is still out of pocket. If we want to know how many people who are not paying tax now will be caught by this, may I bore the House for a few minutes with a very brief comment on those who are exempt from turnover tax? Deputy O'Donovan said that those articles exempt from the turnover tax include agriculture plant, machinery equipment, basic building materials, commercial fishing gear, certain heavy plant machinery used in buildings, machinery plant used in transport, seeds, fertilisers, animal feeding stuffs, similar agricultural goods, tractors, lorries and so on and a lot of building materials, food, drink, medicines, other articles of a medical and spiritual nature, clothing, cloth and yarn, sole and upper leather, fuel, hydrocarbon oils, spare parts and accessories for all sorts of motor vehicles, accounting machines and equipment, books, tobacco and motor cars. With an exemption list such as that, how anybody can claim that it does not make any difference that these people will now be included for tax purposes is something I cannot understand.
The Minister gave certain figures to the House of the number of people paying tax, the number of people collecting tax. Surely the volume is what is important here, the amount of goods that carries tax, the percentage of the total which carries tax at the present time and which will in the future carry tax. The Minister says that it is estimated it will bring in the same amount, but I do not think that is so. I believe the Minister's own argument proves that it will bring in very much more and in the process of bringing it in I can see a number of reasonably small retailers being squeezed out of existence. Not enough attention has been given to this by those who frame the Bill.
Comment on this
If I might give an example of what I was referring to earlier, the McKenna duties. These duties were imposed by Mr. Reginald McKenna in 1916, during the first World War. That is a long time ago but we still collect them here—that is subject to correction—on parts of motor cars which are imported. In fact we collect on parts which go into the manufacture of motor cars. This is a cause of complaint by manufacturers.The rate is 22 2/9 per cent. That has been the position for 56 years.
The turnover tax came into operation in this country, and did not come into operation in either Northern Ireland or Great Britain, at the beginning of 1964. The legislation was passed at the end of 1963. The legislation covering the wholesale tax was passed in 1966 and the tax came into operation at the beginning of 1967. I would feel sore if I was a businessman that a few years after changing this whole system another very complicated system is introduced. A value-added system of taxation is extremely complicated.I am not saying that, give it five or six years, it will not resolve itself, that we will get used to it.
There was a great deal of adverse comment on this tax when it was first introduced into the EEC. Since we had the turnover tax system, why are we changing it now? In Britain they might as well introduce the value-added tax because they have no turnover tax system, but we are not in that position. We have already what I presume the Minister and his officials would call a sophisticated tax system. I do not understand why we should push everybody around to comply with a very complex EEC system of taxation. I do not believe the EEC people would object to us continuing our present system and therefore I cannot understand why we should have this new system of tax.
I know a great deal of hard work has gone into all this, but the people who did all this work have been paid for it. They got as good a remuneration for it, whether it goes into operation or not, although they may get more satisfaction out of their work if it goes into operation. I can see no advantage in introducing this new system of taxation and changing from our present system of turnover tax and wholesale tax which our business people and our manufacturers have only just absorbed. I could quote instances of manufacturers who have got themselves just right at the end of last year and now they are faced with a completely new system of taxation. These are the people the Minister is talking about who are subject to wholesale tax and retail tax.
The turnover tax system was ideal, as the Minister for Finance said in the House at that time. All that was really needed was a bank statement. You showed what you had paid into the bank and you paid tax on that. This was easy from the point of view of the retailer, assuming he did not draw any money out and lodged all he had taken in. It was very complicated for certain other people. When you have got people used to doing something one way it is a very bad business for no good reason to change the system. My colleague, Deputy Tully, pointed out that it does not matter what veneer the Minister puts on it: he expects to get more money out of this new system than he gets from the present system of tax.
Comment on this
When the decimal currency system was introduced we were told that it would not affect prices but we all know that it affected prices very seriously.
Comment on this
I have been listening to this debate for the last 20 minutes on this particular subject. Deputy Burke has suggested that there may be some misunderstanding between one side of the House and the other. Any small trader who has read the Bill will not have any misunderstanding about it. He will be in difficulties if this Bill comes into operation in its present form. In the last ten minutes the Minister admitted that while there is some advantage in that for many traders, for 80 per cent of the turnover trade there is disadvantage.
Comment on this
No, but the Minister admitted there is disadvantage for many traders, although his figures declare it to be for only 20 per cent.
Comment on this
About 80 per cent of the turnover trade is exempt from wholesale tax but this Bill will impose a wholesale tax on the 80 per cent. The Minister should appreciate this and take account of the amendment before the House, in some way to compensate the small traders who are trading on the least percentage profit.
Comment on this
I am impressed by what Deputy O'Donovan had to say about the EEC Commission allowing alternatives. That is not the message he gave in the referendum campaign.
Comment on this
We had some peculiar arguments from Ministers who did not know what they were talking about. We made it clear that the obligation was binding on us—that there is a specific obligation on us in regard to VAT because our present system is incompatible with EEC requirements.This should be said lest Deputy O'Donovan should try to convince people that the EEC is less onerous than it is. Of course Deputy Burke's warm human sympathy overflowed for the Minister because he felt there would be very little revenue flowing in the early days of the operation of VAT. The effect of this Bill, whatever its immediate impact will be, will be to increase tax revenue because it extends taxation to transactions not now covered. The Revenue Commissioners, in submitting material to the Parliamentary draftsmen, ensured that nobody now taxed would escape and that tax would be extended to many not now taxed.
Comment on this
I am very glad to be so enlightened but the Minister might tell us who will be less heavily taxed in the future. My impression is that quite a significant number of things not now taxed will be taxed. There will be a tightening up in regard to evasion, which is a good thing, but the Bill extends tax to areas not now covered.
Deputy Burke, in expressing sympathy with the Minister because he might lose in the first month, ignored the long term result to the Exchequer. The Minister should accept this three month proposal because in not doing so he is creating a real problem for the manufacturing sector and possibly other sectors of the community. This has been fully realised in Britain in the White Paper attached to the Bill there because the standard period is three months, with a month's grace.
On amendment No. 10, which I hope I will be allowed to discuss at this point, I should like to say there is a further aspect of the British system which from the Minister's point of view should be introduced here. There, the accounting periods will be so allocated that onethird of the three month period would be returnable once a month.
Here the Minister proposes to collect tax every two months and everybody is due to pay it at the one period of the two months. This will lead to an uneven flow of work in the Department and it will lead to an uneven flow of revenue. My amendment is designed in part to assist the Minister by defining the taxable period as three months, commencing at such times as may be determined under regulations by the Minister. The Minister's wording is a period of two months beginning on the first day of January, March, May, July, September or November, thereby tying himself to this timetable and to a fluctuating pattern which could mean an overburdening of work at one period and too little at another period, whereas a three month period as in Britain, which has a much stronger industrial structure than our fragile one, would mean a more even flow of work with consequent advantages. The Minister has not done that and although the problem is somewhat less acute in a two-month cycle than a three month one, nevertheless there is much to be said for having the latter, which would allow the Minister to determine that certain taxpayers would pay the tax in one month and others in another.
The Minister's original proposal was for a period of a month. If such a period operated he could have envisaged a system of operation in which staff would be able to get the job done within the month and get ready for the next month. Without making pro-vision to stagger the two months, it seems to me entirely correct to say that an uneven flow of work will ensue.We have argued cogently on this side for a three month period and I cannot see why the Minister will not accept it.
Comment on this
I considered the question of splitting the payments but found that although there were certain advantages, the disadvantages outweighed them. Deputy FitzGerald has spoken three times since I last spoke and he seems to have convinced himself that there are no advantages under VAT to the bulk of retailers.
Comment on this
He is mistaken for a number of reasons. When he tells us that even the two monthly taxable period I am proposing will mean that a great many manufacturers will be in difficulties, what he is saying in effect is that a great many manufacturers will have to extend credit to wholesalers or to retailers over and above two months.
Comment on this
If that is true it means a great many wholesalers and retailers will be in the position that as soon as they have been invoiced for the goods supplied to them, they get credit for the tax they have paid, but they will not actually have to pay for the goods or for the tax which they collect for at least two months. I wonder if Deputy FitzGerald follows the point I am making?
Comment on this
Deputy FitzGerald will see that to the extent that his argument is true about difficulties for manufacturers, he is establishing that correspondingly there are advantages to wholesalers and retailers, which is a point I was making earlier. I do not think Deputy FitzGerald has realised that one of the features of a VAT system is that so far as retailers are concerned they are, under that system, going to be in a position to claim credit against their tax liability for items for which they cannot claim credit at the moment. For instance, on such things as wrapping paper, scales, or new fitments they pay tax at present and they do not recover it. Under the VAT system, they can recover the tax element in any of these things on which they pay.
Comment on this
How often do they pay for them? They will all be buying new ones now because although they have just changed over to decimals they will have to change again.
Comment on this
Whether on fixed or current outgoings, they will be able to recover in full the tax which they have paid on these items, which they cannot do at the moment. Furthermore, as I pointed out, to the extent that they get credit over and above the time they have to pay the tax, they have that much use of the money concerned. Under the VAT system, as soon as the trader gets an invoice he gets credit immediately for the tax which he has paid, and thereafter the goods which he has, he has them at tax-free cost. If they remain unsold he has them at tax-free cost. Although we have been arguing about the percentage of goods in which wholesale tax is involved, the fact is that for the vast majority of retailers—some to a great extent, some to a small extent, but almost all to some extent—there is at the moment involved for them the question of having to pay wholesale tax in the price which they pay for their goods, on such items as are subject to wholesale tax. Until they have sold those goods they do not recover the wholesale tax which they have paid out. Under the VAT system this will not be so. They will recover in full, on receipt of an invoice for the goods, credit for all the tax they have paid, whether it is the equivalent of the wholesale tax or the turnover tax. They will get that, irrespective of whether they have sold the goods themselves or not. It is quite clear, if one examines this situation, that there are considerable advantages which can accrue to wholesalers and retailers under the VAT system. If one takes into account especially the fact that it is now proposed to increase the taxable period from one month to two months, one can see that there is a considerable amount in additional liquidity, to put it no higher than that, for wholesalers and retailers.
Therefore, it seems to me that the argument which I have made for this amendment which is primarily designed to relieve manufacturers but, in fact, has the effect of being a bonus for wholesalers and most retailers certainly—this is the effect of it—has another affect which is to affect the income of the Exchequer. I believe, as I said earlier, having regard to all these factors that the two-monthly period is a reasonable approach to this problem. If it is said that it is not an answer to the manufacturers' problem, I think this is not true. It is the answer to most of the problem of most of the manufacturers.To the extent that it is not, then whatever about the situation of the manufacturers who do not benefit, the extent to which a problem remains is a measure of the benefit accruing to wholesalers and retailers.
That, as Deputy FitzGerald says, may not be much consolation to the manufacturers concerned, but at least let it be recognised that this is so. We should not imagine that what we are doing is of no benefit, or very little benefit, to wholesalers and retailers and of considerable difficulty to manufacturers, which is more or less how Deputy FitzGerald presented it. This, in fact, is not so.
Comment on this
From a long-term point of view and in this sense I use the words "a year or two", because I am not talking about ten years, it makes no difference whatever to the Exchequer whether it be every two or three months. I would admit that if you fix any system, for the first short period it makes a difference to you. We have had a good example of this in this country. We pay ESB bills every two months, gas bills every three months and telephone bills every three months. I seem to get bills that I pay every three months as frequently as the ones I pay every two months.
Comment on this
From a long-term point of view, it astounds me that in the period we have gone through, during which a predecessor of the Minister, the late Dr. Jim Ryan, used to say "revenue has been buoyant", why we had continuously to do these niggling kinds of things. I do not understand it. From a long-term point of view it makes no difference whatever to the Exchequer.
Comment on this
I am afraid it does. I could not see it myself at first, but when I got down to it I found it did.
Comment on this
Once you are in the system, once it is going, it does not matter at all whether it is every two or three months. To use an expression I do not like, the cash flow will be even, through time. It will make no difference. I will admit that it will make a difference in the initial period, sbut once you are in it it will not do so. This is one of the difficulties I see about all modern, trendy thinking. We are always involved in this kind of thing. What is the immediate effect? I am quite prepared to admit that the revenue will be out of money for a month in the first instance, but after that it is going to be an even flow and it does not matter whether it comes in every two months or every three months, once you are over the initial period.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy accept that there would be a once for all loss which would never be recovered?
Comment on this
All I can say to that is that I had a once for all loss when I was charged five quarters income tax in four quarters in 1959. I protested very strongly about it then.
Comment on this
All I am saying is that it is long since gone with the wind and there is a big difference between paying five quarters of income tax in four quarters and collecting your money at the end of three months instead of two months. All it means is that at the end of the year, you have collected 11 months when you should have collected 12.
Comment on this
Even with the present yield from these taxes, it is relatively small. This is what I am arguing.
Comment on this
If it be a serious point, and I assume that people engaged in business do regard it as a serious matter, I cannot see why the Revenue Commissioners cannot accept this once for all loss, as the Minister calls it. Frankly, it is not worth talking about. It might upset the Minister's budget a little but it would not upset it nearly as much as borrowing £30 million for current expenditure in one year.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): I accept that a Bill like this is very complicated and there are many other sections of it on which I will have something different to say, but this is a section which I welcome from the point of view of the wholesale and the retail trade. We have an extension from one month to two months. At the moment turnover tax is accountable every month and I believe that this additional month will be an advantage to the retail and the wholesale trade. I am not altogether sure that too lengthy a period would be a good thing for any trade and I doubt if I would welcome it myself—having turnover tax over four or five months and being faced then with an enormous bill for which one might not have the money. This period of two months is reasonable and I welcome it. It gives wholesalers and retailers an advantage as against the present system. It may not be to the same advantage of the manufacturers but I doubt if they will be very much out of pocket in their liquid cash. The whole system of the Bill in this regard will give an advantage in that we can claim back on fittings and other expenses incurred in the day-to-day running of a business, whether they be bottles, corks or glasses. It was not possible to claim wholesale tax back on these but now it will be an advantage to the retail and wholesale trade.
The Minister mentioned that where wholesale tax is charged it will be possible to claim the credit back, and I know this is so but how long will this take—from the time we get the invoice, which I presume is 15th of the following month, and this must be submitted then to the Revenue Commissioners for a refund. Will there be a long delay here? How is this credit operated? When wholesale tax is charged to the retailer, it will be charged in the invoice, I presume.
Comment on this
It can be set off as a credit against the retailer's liability to tax which he should pay to the revenue so that he will only pay the net amount. If by any chance the amount he is setting off exceeds the amount of tax he owes, so that there is money due back to him, the Revenue Commissioners will pay that about three weeks after the claim coming in.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): I was hoping that there would be no long delay in getting the money back from the Revenue Commission. I had one experience of that in the past but under different circumstances. This provision allowing two months is a reasonably fair provision and I personally welcome it.
Comment on this
I do not want to throw cold water on this enthusiasm but I am not yet fully understanding where the benefit lies. May I simply give a national example?
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): At the moment we pay turnover tax every month but now we will have the particular cash for two months.
Comment on this
Could I give a case and be told where the advantage lies because due to a defect in understanding on my part by reason of not having practical experience, I am just not with it? A retailer buys £100 worth of goods in month one and sells those goods a month or so later for £120, but because of the tax element he sells them for £126, turnover tax at 5 per cent having to be paid, so that he receives £126 in month two for what he bought but did not pay for in month one. He then has to pay his turnover tax and I take it he will pay it about a month later.
Comment on this
Yes, but if I am wrong in my timing because of lack of experience of the practical working of it, I shall be glad to be put right. About a month after he sells the goods, he has to pay the tax. It looks to me about three weeks in the typical case, looking at the cyclical pattern of the figures paid to the Exchequer week by week. He has to pay £6 in month three and with three months credit, has to pay for the goods originally bought in month four and he pays £100. That seems to be the typical present pattern. Think in terms now of the new tax— buying the goods in one month and selling them the next month. At that stage he recovers what he paid for them with his profit margin of about 20 per cent, and he will have to recover another £5 at that point—will he? I am afraid I am in difficulty in working it out. He must charge the same amount if he is going to pay the same amount of tax and he has to charge £126 to whomever he sells to.
Comment on this
He then is faced with recovering some tax and paying some tax. He can recover the tax which was paid at previous stages within a month or so of buying the goods so that he would get another £5 in the second month.
Comment on this
Recovering from the Revenue Commissioners that portion of tax that was on the goods before he bought them. I am sorry I have got this wrong. Let us start again. He pays £105 for the goods now—is that the position—including the tax which was borne at previous stages. Then he sells them a month later for £126 and recovers around the same time the £5 tax which had previously been paid. Then he has to pay his own tax on the Minister's scheme two months later. He has to pay £6 tax and he has to pay, at that stage, in month four, to the person from whom he bought the goods, the wholesaler or manufacturer, the £100 due. Is that roughly the position? Have I got it right?
Let us recapitulate. In month one he pays £105 whereas at the moment he pays £100. He is out of £5 at that stage compared with his present position.The next month he gets £126 by selling the goods and he gets back the £5 tax he paid, so that restores his position. He has been out of £5 for one month which he would not have been out but for this system. At the end of that month he is back in the position he was in before. He then has two months in which to pay the tax whereas, under the present system, he might have got one month in which to pay it, so he has the benefit of £6 for one month longer but he has been out £5 for one month previously.
The benefit to me seems to be extraordinarly marginal. The net benefit to him is to have available to him £1 which he would not otherwise have had for a period of one extra month. This does not seem to me to be an enormous benefit, if I understand the system correctly. I wonder is the Minister not exaggerating the benefits to retailers involved in a typical case? It may be that I have misunderstood it or got it wrong. I am open to correction but that is the position as I see it: the net benefit in a typical case of £100 worth of goods is that the retailer might have £1 extra for one month extra in credit. That will not get him very far. Compare that with the problem of the manufacturer——
Comment on this
Before the Deputy goes on to the manufacturer, in that example is he assuming three months credit? Is that right?
Comment on this
Three months credit from the wholesaler or manufacturer. Let us take it that it is manufacturer to retailer to simplify it, and leave out the wholesaler for this purpose.
Comment on this
We are talking of a typical case of credit for three months. We are told by the Dublin Chamber of Commerce, in their submission, that the typical credit period is about three months. It is on that basis that this amendment is put down and it is on that basis that the British have allowed three months. What I am trying to establish factually at this point is what exactly is the kind of benefit the average retailer will get by comparison with his present situation as a result of this Bill because the Minister has been extolling this benefit and telling us the difference it will make.
I may be quite wrong but my impression is that on a £100 transaction with three months credit the net benefit to a retailer is that he is out of £5 that he would not have been out of for a month during the first month, and he has the benefit of £6 for two months instead of one month once he has sold the goods and is waiting to pay for them. Therefore he has a net £1 for one month longer, if I have got it right.
Comment on this
He has it for two months but he would have had it for one month anyway. He has £1 extra for one month longer. By comparison with that the manufacturer surely is out of £5 for an extra month. Again I am open to correction. The Minister is giving him two months to pay but, in fact, it is a three months period and he will be out of that £5 for one month. If I am right in that, and I may not be, it seems that any benefit to the retailer is tiny compared with the loss to the manufacturer. If I am right I do not think the Minister is giving a very fair picture of the equation between the loss in one case and the gain in the other. As I say, I may have misunderstood it. I should like to give the Minister a chance of clarifying the point and of putting me right if I am wrong in my notional example, or if there is any basic fallacy in my thinking.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): I can see a point with regard to purchasing where you have a two or three months basis. There is a possibility here as regards purchasing that the retailers might only purchase every two months. This would save a certain amount of outlay. Can the Deputy follow my line of argument that if you purchase every two months there would be an advantage. You would not have an outlay of money over the two months period. I do not think it would be good practice but I could see people doing it.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): I am taking the two months which the Minister has allowed. If you purchase every two months this might be a saving which people might try to develop and which I think would not be desirable.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): At the current rate you normally have a turnover every month or may be every few weeks.
Comment on this
The Deputy is suggesting that the retailer might only purchase every two months as compared with doing what at present.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): That would not be desirable but it is probably something that could be done.
Comment on this
If he does that he will lose a month's credit. He will be carrying stock for a month longer. I cannot see any advantage to the retailer in that.
Comment on this
I think I have a vague idea of what Deputy Fitzpatrick is getting at. Since he is a practical man of business I suspect that he probably knows a great deal more about this than Deputy FitzGerald and myself.
Comment on this
If I have understood Deputy FitzGerald's example correctly I would say that this is the position. Under the present system the retailer would pay £6 in month two, £6 tax. Under VAT he would pay £1 tax in month two, that is, £6 less £5 credit which he would claim he had paid already. He would pay £5 in month three to the supplier. Does that mean anything to Deputy FitzGerald?
Comment on this
I am afraid it does not bear any relation to the picture as I visualise it. That may be my fault. I would have thought that having bought the goods but paid nothing for them he would recover £5 tax a month later by sending in invoices. In the second month, which I call month two, that is one month after the transaction started, in month two as against month one, he would get £5 back. In that same month he sells the goods for £126. He then has to pay the supplier and pay his tax. Am I right in thinking he pays the tax?
Comment on this
I tried to compare them. I said that under the present system in month two he would pay £6 tax. Under the value-added tax system in month two he would pay £1 tax. He would be due to pay £6 but he would be claiming a credit of £5, not having paid it but having been invoiced for it but, having been invoiced for it, he would claim it as a credit and then in month three on the assumption of three months credit he would pay £5 to the supplier. This would have been the credit he would have claimed in month two although, in fact, he did not have to pay it until month three. Does Deputy FitzGerald follow that? I am sorry, I am not expressing it very clearly perhaps.
Comment on this
The Minister is perhaps nearer to the reality than I was. I am not quite clear as to why he only gets credit for £1 in the second month because has he not got two months in which to pay the tax after he collects the money. Is that wrong?
Comment on this
Yes. In fact the position is rather better than I said because the figure I gave was based on the Bill without the amendment. If the amendment is accepted the position will be that he pays the £1 in tax in month four.
Comment on this
And he would pay the £5 that he is claiming as credit to the supplier in month three.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): The way I see it is this is starting on 1st January and you order goods right through the month to 31st January; the statement for the goods will arrive roughly around 15th February; cash is expected then around the 31st day of February or sometime early in March.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): It is not possible for the wholesalers to work it otherwise. You make payment for goods received in January roughly around 1st March.
Comment on this
That does not correspond to the credit period indicated by the Dublin Chamber of Commerce because that is an average credit period of one and a half to two months.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): It is not, because some of these goods are supplied up to 31st January.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): It is not possible for wholesalers to make up two statements. They must finish by 31st January. It is usually about the second week in February before they are in a position to send out statements so the retailer will receive his statement roughly around the middle of February.
Comment on this
That is not my experience.I get accounts much earlier from tradesmen who are not included in the retail trade, and I pay them pretty promptly. Printers and people like that send out accounts pretty quickly.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): The general pattern is you receive your statement in the second week of the following month.
Comment on this
Of the following month? But the Deputy is talking about the January account in mid-March.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): The statement arrives at that time, but it is usually the end of February or early March before these accounts are paid.
Comment on this
This does not tally at all. The Dublin Chamber of Commerce says the general average and normal credit period would be about three months. The Deputy says that goods purchased and received between 1st and 31st January—therefore, on average mid-January—would actually have to be paid for between the end of February and mid-March—say, a quarter of the way through March. That is a credit period of one and three quarter months, not three months. I defer to the Deputy's experience. I have none. But I am puzzled by the divergence in his picture and that of the Dublin Chamber of Commerce.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): The Dublin Chamber of Commerce speaks about the manufacturing business which gives a more extended credit.
Comment on this
So we are, and amendment No. 10 and many others. The problem we are discussing is primarily that of the Irish manufacturer faced with a situation of a three months' credit period in which he will have to pay his tax in two months. The situation may be different for wholesalers.We can discuss that later. The case we have been discussing is the problem of Irish industry.
Comment on this
The Deputy was also discussing whether there was any benefit for wholesalers in this. He is, I think, beginning to see that there is something in what I was saying. I was reassuring him.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): In effect, you are not paying the 5 per cent passed on until two months later when you are submitting your turnover tax, which will now be value-added tax. There is an advantage there.
Comment on this
The Deputy is taking a more realistic case, which is that of the wholesaler who is the collector.I was taking a somewhat simpler case, a case I would have some hope of understanding, but I am still not entirely clear why there is such an advantage to the retailer. The Minister has given me some indications of some possible advantages, but I am by no means entirely clear about this and I would like some further clarification before conceding the point. The problem we are concerned with is the adverse effect on the Irish manufacturer.Unless, in some peculiar way, the retailer will finance the manufacturer by extending credit backwards to him, I do not see what advantage it will be to the manufacturer to be told that the retailer is going to be more liquid. I do not see how the benefits of that liquidity will accrue to the manufacturer except by a shortening of the period extended by the manufacturer to the retailer. Perhaps that will be one of the benefits, but I am not sure that it is what we want to achieve.
Comment on this
I did refer to this. It would be unrealistic to expect the manufacturer would simply shorten the period, whether it was the wholesaler or retailer he was supplying, because he was getting a better liquid position. This will, I think, happen in some areas, but there will be some areas in which the manufacturer will not be in a position to do this because the competition will be too great and a customer who is told: "We are cutting down your credit period" will simply say: "We will deal with someone else who is not cutting it down." I recognise this; I said so at the outset. The point is I do not think we should take it that the average credit period extended by manufacturers is three months. If that was the case they made to Deputy FitzGerald——
Comment on this
It was. The words used are: "The general average and normal credit period for Irish manufacturers will be about three months."
Comment on this
I know, as I said earlier, there are some cases in which it is six months. In one case it is nine months. But these are exceptional cases and cannot be taken into account.
Comment on this
I agree. Might I say there is a certain confirmation of that in the Act that the British have; they allowed three months? I doubt if the British are allowing more than is necessary to ensure liquidity and if they have, with a much stronger industrial sector, allowed three months, I cannot see the wisdom of our making it two months.
Comment on this
It is a question of delay in getting cash in. If he has to wait three months for it, does that mean an extra month's shortage of revenue? Surely, so long as you establish a pattern, then if you get the money within the financial year, deciding how to expend it is simply a question of book-keeping.
Comment on this
Yes, you do. If you get a three-monthly cycle you must get the same after the first year.
Comment on this
There are two aspects. One is you have the once for all loss which you never recover.
Comment on this
That is one. The other aspect is that you have a continuing loss which depends on the extent, whether it is one month, two months or three months. On the present basis of two-monthly periods as against the present monthly period, this will give us an annual loss of about £250,000 because of the slower flow of tax revenue. In effect, it is the interest on the money. That is a continuing loss and, of course, it is bigger if the period is three months. You have this permanent loss all the time and you have a once for all loss.
Comment on this
Once you have the once for all loss, the money is flowing in regularly. There are no gaps but of course the Minister will have to borrow presumably to meet that. But he should not double-count.
Comment on this
The difference between the two months and the three months would be an extra month in each period during which some interest would have to be paid.
Comment on this
The fact is that once the Minister has the system going, he is paid for every month but his problem is that there is an initial loss because of the postponement of the additional month for receiving money. He is changing the system and in the beginning he is out of revenue for one month. He has to borrow as a result of that and that borrowing would have to be remunerated over the continuing period thereafter. But we must not double-count this.
Comment on this
I am not double-counting it. The argument about the British, as I tried to indicate before, is not, I think, relevant. The British situation is quite different from ours. They are trying to introduce a system which is quite new to them, quite far removed from their present system. Ours is not. Their problems are quite different: they have to sell it as well as make it work.
Comment on this
But since it is new to the manufacturers the Minister is not giving them much assistance.
Comment on this
While the manufacturers would not be expected to say that they are completely satisfied with this amendment they would, I think, say that it goes a considerable distance to meet their difficulties.
Comment on this
I do not accept that the average for them is three months. There are two months plus the 19 days. We provide for payment not later than the 19th day of the month following the two-monthly period.
Comment on this
That only affects the beginning. In the next one it is the same period between payment and payment and so on after that. This only applies the first time you do it.
Comment on this
If that argument is true you might as well say, once you make it one month, it is the same every month after that.
Comment on this
No, it is two months or three months, whichever you wish to have, from the 19th day of one month until the 19th day in the next second or third month.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): The turn-over taxation at the moment is £84 million payable once every month. Let us assume £80 million for a round figure. That is about £6 million a month. If you extend that to three months would that not mean that £12 million would be continuously going on carrying interest?
Comment on this
If there is a month during which no money comes in for this tax as a result of the change from one tax system to the other—if that is the case and I am not convinced because I do not understand it—then one's month's tax is missing and that sum of money will have to be replaced somehow by borrowing. The Minister could then say that he is burdened with an extra sum for interest on that indefinitely thereafter.
Comment on this
If he has to borrow to replace one month's loss of revenue presumably the interest will be continuing.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): If we accept this amendment it would be two months and in effect it would be carrying a continuous interest in my opinion.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): I am assuming a round figure of approximately £84 million for turn-over tax at present——
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): I am just taking a round figure as an example. At the moment we are paying it every month. Deputy FitzGerald's amendment would make it every three months. I believe that on my figure, which is roughly £7 million a month, the Exchequer would always be at the loss in interest of £14 million.
Comment on this
That is provided they were short £7 million, that they did not write it off at some stage.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): No. The Revenue Commissioners should normally have that £14 million. They have not got it. They have to pay interest on it.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy is right on the hypothesis that they do lose a whole month's revenue but the Minister has not persuaded me that this happens. Therefore, the conclusion from the hypothesis does not seem to me to follow. In fact, the Minister himself mentioned a figure of £250,000. If the figure of interest cost is £250,000, at a reasonable rate of interest at the present time, that suggests being out of about £3 million, which is a great deal less than one month's proceeds of wholesale and turnover tax. It is only about half the proceeds. This suggests that the Minister thinks he will be out of a fortnight's tax, not a month's tax. That is why I am very suspicious about his statement about losing a month's tax.
Comment on this
And if he is right he should think of the unfortunate local authorities who must wait for the State to pay them at the end of 12 months.
Comment on this
That is in reference to the previous Bill, the Local Elections Bill. Could the Minister explain a little more clearly where he gets the £250,000? It does not relate to being out of one month's tax.
Comment on this
The Exchequer cannot be out of money. Whether it accrues in the second month or in the third month they will get it. The only thing they will be out is the interest they will have to pay because of not getting the money on the dot. This will happen once.
Comment on this
We are all at loggerheads. It seems to me that if they are going to be out of any amount of tax revenue any month they will have to find that somewhere and money will have to be borrowed and interest will be payable on that indefinitely. Perhaps I have misunderstood this and am making the position worse than it is because I do not understand where the £250,000 comes from.
Comment on this
That is the interest which has to be paid by the Exchequer for the amount it does not get in in the first month.
Comment on this
But it does not tally with the figure for losing a month's revenue. Can the Minister help us there?
Comment on this
On the assumption of a two-monthly tax period, there would be six months' revenue, one month late.
Comment on this
That is the mistake I was making earlier. I think the Minister is wrong in that. It is not three-monthly intervals. Every month, the return is being made.
Comment on this
May I suggest that Deputies, in the quiet of their own homes, should write it down, taking it month by month, not doing it theoretically, and they will see that it works out in that way? I did not believe it at first and I asked and had it put down on paper and saw how it worked. Having taken it for the 12 months you have to follow right through on paper and see what happens.
Comment on this
If he gets in £15 million —I am exaggerating the amount—on 19th April and £15 million on 19th May and £15 million on 19th June, could the Minister explain to me where this loss will recur? It must occur the first time. It is once for all. It does not occur again. It cannot occur again. If it were three monthly periods, which I thought at first we were talking about, instead of two monthly, it would mean that there would be a break of one month in each series but once it starts it is being paid every month. There must be a return every month, even though it is three months behind. There is only one loss and that is the first one. At least, that is as I see it.
Comment on this
On 1st November value-added tax is coming in. The first cheques for that will arrive on 19th January. Is that correct?
Comment on this
February. For the goods sold in November they will get two months, December and January. They will pay by 19th February. If you extend it to March you only lose interest once on the money that you do not have between 19th February and 19th March, because on the 19th of every subsequent month the cheque will arrive. In April, the December cheque will arrive, in May, the January cheque, and so on.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): I believe it will be continuous. Let us take a round figure of £6 million. At the moment we pay it monthly. Now it will be two monthly. Deputy FitzGerald has an amendment suggesting three months. In February there is £6 million due, assuming £6 million is owed for January. Deputy FitzGerald wants it extended to February and March. There is £6 million for February, £6 million for March. Will that ever be recovered? It will be recovered, but three months later. That is continuing all the time. It will be always three months later. There is bound to be interest accruing.
Comment on this
Perhaps what we have forgotten is this: Deputies may be thinking as though there was a trader who was one month late with his cheques but he pays it up one month late and that is the end of it. That is the way they are thinking. That is not, in fact, what is happening. Remember, at the moment the tax is paid at the end of every month. If we make this at the end of a two-monthly period it means that in every two monthly period there is a month's tax late. If it is a two-monthly accounting period, you have, in fact, got six months revenue one month late and if it is a three monthly accounting period you have a year's revenue one month late, because it continues in each taxable period. If the Deputies go home and put it down on paper they will see it.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Minister could tell me where you get the money originally to extend it. Would you borrow that? If you never repaid that I can see that the interest will be there all the time on that.
Comment on this
Under the Minister's scheme you get paid in February, April, June and under my scheme you get paid in March, May, July, et cetera. That means that there is an initial deferment of one month of these regular payments and you have to borrow for that one month. Having deferred by that one month, you then get paid at the same——
Comment on this
Deputy FitzGerald is falling into the trap the Minister is falling into. There is not a three months period. There is a payment every month. You are two months behind or you are three months behind.
Comment on this
Under the Minister's scheme, unlike my scheme, the payments are related to periods of January, March, May, July, September, November—amendment No. 9.
Comment on this
I must suggest that Deputy Tully has not grasped this. He is still thinking in terms of somebody being a month late. That is not what is involved. If there is a two monthly taxable period, tax is paid, not every month, but every second month.
Comment on this
If the tax which is due for November and December is paid on 19th January, when is the next tax payable?
Comment on this
No, because the tax that is paid on 19th January is the November tax. There is always a month in between.
Comment on this
The Deputy has not grasped that we are talking here about making it a two monthly period instead of one monthly.
Comment on this
Of course you are, but even with a two-monthly period it is still once only because the next time it comes around you will be paying it at regular intervals.
Comment on this
You are paying tax in respect of a two months period of transactions and you are paying it at an interval after that. You then have to wait two months for the next two months period to elapse to incur liability which is paid at an interval after that and the tax is paid only six times a year. Is that right?
Comment on this
To get back to my point, whereas under the Minister's scheme the tax is paid in February, April, June, under my scheme it is paid in March, May, July. There is a deferment of one month which has to be financed.
Comment on this
I am talking about my three months as against the Minister's two months. The Minister is objecting to my three months.
Comment on this
A deferment of two months for the revenue because at the moment it is at monthly intervals.
Comment on this
I appreciate that, of course. The Minister is objecting to my amendment and I am trying to argue in favour of it. I am concerned with the difference between me and him, not with the difference between him and the Revenue Commissioners.
Comment on this
There is a deferment, by my scheme, of one month in the first instance. He has to find finance for that. Having found finance for that, the money thereafter flows in at exactly the same two month intervals as previously and he has had to find finance for one extra month. Then every two months money comes in. I do not see that there is anything more than one extra month deferment of revenue and the interest on that, but perhaps I have it wrong.
Comment on this
No. Once you have found that money and started a month later, everything happens in exactly the same two monthly intervals thereafter as under the Minister's scheme but you do start one month late. The whole tax payment starts a month later and it goes on then at exactly the same interval.