We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 3: Department of the Taoiseach (Resumed).

Contributions 105–217 of 217. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

It was the speaker that morning.

Comment on this

Whatever it was the Dáil was alive on that occasion. The Dáil has not been alive during this debate. There have been very sincere contributions made but they have been made for the most part to empty benches. I have as good a House now as any speaker had. It it not unnatural that this House should be more concerned, as it undoubtedly is, with the mid-Cork by-election than it is with the North, for the very simple reason that we are in fact a Twenty-six County Parliament representing a 26-County electorate. That is what is real about us. When we stand on that ground we are as the Americans say: "For real."

We are a Twenty-six County parliament claiming to be a Thirty-two county one, claiming the right of jurisdiction over the Six Counties of Northern Ireland. It is where that claim supervenes, when we are talking as if that claim was a reality, that we lose reality and lose credibility. We know that Articles 2 and 3 of our Constitution assert a right of jurisdiction over the Six Counties of Northern Ireland but of course it is not just Articles 2 and 3. They are important only because they represent, recognise and legitimatise a certain attitude. They are certainly important for that. For a parliament to claim a right of jurisdiction over people who are not represented in it, and the majority of whom are known not to want to be represented in it, is to assume a fearful responsibility.

Deputy Ryan said just now that he was opposed to a plebiscite in Northern Ireland. If we are opposed to a plebiscite in Northern Ireland it is because we know what the result of a plebiscite would be. It would be heavily against that right of jursidiction which our parliament has assumed. That is a fearful responsibility. It would be a fearful responsibility even if we were thoroughly committed to it in our lives, dedicated to it and really working for it. In fact it is a responsibility which has been borne with a fearful levity. When things were quiet in the North and Deputies know well what I say is true, our governments and parliaments did not bother their heads about the place except for perfunctory platitudes at commemorative ceremonies.

We now all speak with indignation of those 50 terrible years when the minority was crushed but most of us bore those 50 years with considerable equanimity for most of the time. Even now, with the North thrashing about in agony the Dáil is going into recess and into a by-election, which will be concerned almost entirely with Twenty-six County bread and butter issues. That is inevitable. When we go to mid-Cork we must talk about what the people there are interested in.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy going down?

Comment on this

I most certainly am and I hope our paths may cross down there so that we may have a chance of relaxed and courteous discourse. The gravity of our claim to a Thirty-two County jurisdiction and the levity of the actual commitment to that claim has had, I suggest to the House, dire consequences. The existence of that claim to jurisdiction over people who were not consulted about it has encouraged the polarisation of the two communities in Northern Ireland which now takes the sinister form of incipient sectarian civil war. I think that is an accurate diagnosis of what we have now.

The claim for one thing is at the very root of the siege mentality demonstrated by the Protestants of Northern Ireland and demonstrated by some of them now in such very terrible ways. They fear the claim of a Catholic majority in this island through its largely Catholic parliament to rule over them. They see—this is worse still—the Catholics of Northern Ireland as the instruments of that claim so that those Catholics become on the one hand a kind of trojan horse, a fifth column and on the other side they are handed over as hostages in this system. Unionists spokesmen use this claim of ours expressed in our Constitution and in other ways, in our general attitudes and the speeches of our public men down the years to justify those discriminatory measures against Catholics which are indeed among the root causes of the present troubles. We watered those roots. We rightly condemn the Unionist leaders for setting up that iniquitous system but we usually forget, as people forget their responsibilities most easily, that we provided them with their best pretext for maintaining it.

That is the effect of that claim so solemnly professed and in fact so lightly held on the Ulster Protestants but it also had an effect on the Ulster Catholics. It encouraged them but it was an unreal and dangerous kind of encouragement. They were encouraged to say: "We are supposed to be a minority here but we are not really a minority. We are really a majority. The South is at our back." The South was at their back in a kind of tricky, distant, unreliable way. They were encouraged to think that the South would somehow come to the rescue. I was in Derry during that terrible week of August, 1969, and I met the Citizens Defence Committee there.

Comment on this

So was I.

Comment on this

Yes, indeed, the Deputy's heroism is fully equal to my own.

Comment on this

He is bigger than the Deputy. He is a bigger target too. He is on a higher level.

Comment on this

I accept that he is on a higher level. At that time I met, as the Deputy did, the Citizens Defence Committee and I am sure he heard what I did. They had heard our Taoiseach on television say: "We will not stand idly by" and they believed him. They believed he was going to intervene, that they were going to be rescued. I had to explain to them that these words of our dear Taoiseach did not mean precisely what they took them to mean and indeed what they meant was not very clear but that reinforcements were not immediately about to arrive. I am sure Deputy Burke gave them that message, too, but probably in a more emollient way than I did. Then they heard the claim that the Taoiseach was their second guarantor. He guaranteed their rights and liberties. This encouraged the Catholics to take risks they might otherwise not have taken. They felt they had friends at hand who were about to come to their rescue. What he did was to stir up the Catholics and then let them down. I am afraid we are still engaged in various forms of that exercise.

I have spoken of the effect of this claim on Ulster Catholics and Ulster Protestants. There is another subcategory more powerfully affected by the claim and affecting others. I am speaking of young people, young men in particular, who are brought up on this claim, who take it seriously. They are earnest, often dedicated young men. They take it seriously and are offended to see their Government and their Parliament paying lip service to a claim which they quite palpably do not take seriously, as any of these young men could see if they came in here during this debate. In this way these young people lose faith in parliamentary democracy since we do not take seriously a law which we tell them is solemn, fundamental and enshrined in our Constitution. When they see us not taking that seriously, the most active, the most ardent of them turn from us. There are mixtures of motives in these things. I am taking a particular type of person. They turn from us and take the law into their own hands. Our precepts and our practice contrasted with our precepts have helped to create the IRA which we then condemn. This is only one aspect of it I know. Probably most people are brought into the IRA as much by family tradition as anything else. You go into the movement because your uncle or your daddy was in it. This would not so easily have continued, would not have seeded itself again after the independence of the Twenty-six County Republic, the IRA tradition might have begun to fade away, if it had not been legitimised, sanctified and sustained in existence by this State, by its Constitution, by many of its schools, by its glorification of past violence and by its cult for the dead.

I should like now to consider the Taoiseach's role in regard to all this. The Taoiseach has condemned violence, but. There is always a "but". Every sentence of the Taoiseach's, which has to be related to other sentences in the past and perhaps in the future, has a back door, an escape hatch. His opening speech in this debate was a relatively good one. His speeches oscillate. There is the one with the stress on unity, what we must get, what they must do, what we will not accept; and there is the one with emphasis on peace and reconciliation. They come at appropriate moments, cyclically. This one I would regard as one of the good ones, the emphasis was back more on peace. It was more conciliatory than his foreign affairs essay which was rather minatory and distinctly low on condemnations of violence. He does concede that unity is not exactly around the corner. That is something. There is a beginning of reality there. I hope it sinks home to certain editorial writers in this city who are making things worse than they need be by encouraging this will-o'-the-wisp of unity round the corner provided some negotiating table is set up and some papers are exchanged.

There are basic contradictions in the Taoiseach's position as set out in various statements. He tells us that violence is bad but he also tells us that it will go on until Partition is abolished. Violence, he has told us, is a by-product of the division of our country. That statement is completely unhistoric as the violence preceded the division and the threat of violence and violence were among the causes of that division, not just among the results. It is unhistoric but that is not the worst thing about it. A statement could be unhistoric and relatively harmless. I am thinking in terms of what effect a statement like that has on the majority in Northern Ireland, who are opposed not merely to unity with this country but even to have anything to do with us, opposed to dialogue. These are the people we should be trying to reach.

We are not reaching them. The thing has been moving backwards. A group of whom too much was made here a little time ago—the New Ireland Group in the North formed around Mr. Dick Ferguson and others —has broken up. That group of moderate Protestants have broken up in disgust and discouragement, and among the reasons for that is the implication which they take from the words: "Violence is a by-product of the division of our country." To them what we seem to be saying in remarks like that is: "If you do not come to terms with me now the Provos will keep it up until you do come to terms with me." I am speaking now of moderate Protestants. The Taoiseach will say he does not intend that that implication should be taken, but who believes him? Certainly not the people whom it is most important for him to convince, the Ulster Protestants. They remember, as the rest of us do, that it was the Taoiseach's first Government in this Dáil that hatched out the Provisional IRA. That was the Government that sowed these dragon's teeth in those fatal months of late 1969 and early 1970. It is true that the Taoiseach dropped certain Ministers, but only when their activities surfaced inconveniently when they came to the attention of Deputy Cosgrave.

The Taoiseach's own role in the activities of the Government during that period remains murky and casts a dark shadow over his credibility on this entire question. That is an unfortunate thing. I would not wish—I would ask Deputies opposite to believe me if they can—to make this a party issue. I do not like attacking our Taoiseach on a matter such as this and I have on the whole, with occasional exceptions, rather held back on it. I have tried to believe what he was saying but I am afraid I cannot maintain that.

The shadow deepens whenever we consider the statements and the silences of certain members of his party. There are members of his party who have spoken out very well on this issue. We have heard some of them in this debate, Deputy Michael O'Kennedy just now. There are others who have talked in quite a different way, just occasionally publicly. One Deputy, a colleague of Deputy Burke's, has said that maybe, as Cardinal Conway said in a statement attributed to me by Deputy Blaney, we should not try to bomb a million Protestants into a united Ireland. That was said by a Deputy of this House in Sligo and never disavowed. The Deputy is here. He votes for the Taoiseach and his peace-loving statements. That is what he said. I am not particularly faulting that Deputy but I think he said out loud what a lot of other members of that party—not all of them and probably not any of those who are listening to me now—what a lot of them say in private or semi-private, in the corridors and bars of this House where they express their open admiration for the Provisional IRA. The implication of the relaxed discourse of this not negligible group of Deputies is that while the Taoiseach has, of course, to condemn violence, in fact the Provos supply the necessary levers for the Taoiseach's diplomacy whereby he will, in their system of fantasy, unite Ireland.

While that impression is known to be there, and it is known, the Taoiseach's more peace-loving utterances—and he has made some of them and they have been extremely felicitously expressed— can, unfortunately, carry little conviction and that is unfortunate for more than the Taoiseach; it is unfortunate for all of us, of whatever persuasion, tradition, allegiance, living in this island. The Taoiseach says the unity we want is a unity by consent but he also says the majority in Northern Ireland, being a minority in the whole island, has no right to a veto on unity. Now, that, if you put the two bits together, boils down to saying we must have unity with their consent which they have no right to withhold. And if they do, nonetheless, continue to withhold it, what happens then? The Taoiseach has to remind them, sadly, that violence is a by-product of the division of our country, as he says. And what message does that convey? The unfortunate fact is that it no longer much matters what the Taoiseach says about the North because hardly anybody in the North any longer believes a word he says.

Comment on this

That is exactly it.

Comment on this

I am sorry to say that. I wish it was not what I had to say but I think it is true and that it is important that it should be said. If you take the two main communities, for the Catholics, the Taoiseach, Mr. Lynch, is the man who said he would not stand idly by and then stood idly by. That is another thing, incidentally—a small digression—the official record of what the Taoiseach said on that notable occasion omits the word "idly", just says that he said: "We will not stand by" but the word "idly" is audible on the recording made at that time, which Deputies can consult in RTE, if they wish. It was edited out of the official record and that is a small index of the rather odd way in which these things are handled.

For the Catholics, too, he is the man who put himself forward as second guarantor and was able to guarantee them nothing at all as they were buffeted about in their agony between the two varieties of IRA, the British Army, the UDA, and Lord knows what forms of private enterprise lawless violence there. What good was a second guarantor to them in those conditions?

For the Protestants, the honeyed words which Mr. Lynch so often addresses to them come across as velvety blackmail, sleeven provisionalism. He may make a mild, conciliatory speech today. They know he will make a truculent and military speech tomorrow if the Twenty-six Counties situation or the inner pressures of the Fianna Fáil Party so require. I admired at the time his Tralee speech in the autumn of 1969. I had not learned to know him so well then through his actions as I have now. It is very sad to think of what his Government were actually doing at the time that Tralee speech was made, what, at least, certain powerful members of his Government were doing when they were engaged in certain activities which helped the Provisional IRA to come into being. The Taoiseach either knew or did not know what certain of his Ministers were then doing. What view you take of that, whether he knew or did not know, depends on whether you regard the Taoiseach as competent or, alternatively, as honest. Personally, I think he is highly competent and that he knew what was going on.

With this record, unfortunately, the Taoiseach can do no good now on the North. With this record his very presence as Taoiseach is a scarecrow, a deterrent, not merely against unity but against the beginning of any dialogue with Ulster Protestants. We need a credible Taoiseach and a credible Government. We need to drop our claim to jurisdiction over people who have conferred no such right of jurisdiction on us until some day perhaps they do. We should be saying to the North, in effect, "What we want to see in Northern Ireland is peace first and foremost. Then we want to see reconstruction with equal opportunities for all. We are not insisting on unity. We will be glad to talk about unity if and when a majority among you want to talk about it. Until then we shall not be talking about it. We shall refrain from all propaganda about it. We are taking all necessary steps to prevent our territory from being used as a base for attack on you. Nor shall we permit private people within the area of our jurisdiction to make public statements arrogating to themselves the right to make war or peace. We will not tolerate any private armies or headquarters of private armies on our soil. We are ready to co-operate with all elected representatives in the North and with the British Government in all ways in which we may facilitate peace and reconstruction in the North. What we are interested in is sharing this island in peace, justice and equality of opportunities. Some day political unity may be the best way of sharing this island. We recognise that it is not now an acceptable way. We are not interested in imposing our own conceptions on those who do not share them, whether these concepts are theological or political. We are interested in dialogue, that is, we are prepared to listen as well as to talk". We have, of course, never listened to the people whom we have purportedly tried to persuade.

All that needs to be said. I believe our people would overwhelmingly approve it if it were said but it needs to be said by people who will be believed when they say it. It needs to be said by people whose practice will live up to their word. The record of our present Taoiseach and his Government—his Governments—in such that they will not be believed in the North whatever they say because their practice has belied their words. That is, perhaps, the gravest reason why we need a new Taoiseach and a new Government.

Deputy Blaney in his speech this morning suggested that it was abominable heresy, blasphemy, and what not, on the part of certain speakers in this debate to suggest that we should abandon insistence on unity. Now, there is a very interesting text here. I am to quote, a Cheann Comhairle, from Suiona Priobháideacha an Dara Dáil —Private Sessions of Second Dáil— 1921-22, which has just been published by the Stationery Office and released to the world for the first time. I shall quote from pages 28 and 29 of the debate for Monday, 22nd August, 1921:

An tUachtarán—

Éamon de Valera

—explained it was difficult to have a policy for Ulster when they could not get in contact.

This is put in the third person; it is a minute.

Their present aim was to get in touch with them. They had not the power, and some of them had not the inclination, to use force with Ulster. He did not think that policy would be successful. They would be making the same mistake with that section as England had made with Ireland.

"They would be making the same mistake with that section as England had made with Ireland"—that is a very important statement indeed and it is one which has been lost to us down the years because it was said in private session of the Dáil; it was not offered to the people as a thought. But, when some of us more recently said that our claim to the Twenty-six Counties elected Parliament, our claim to impose our concept of what was right on Northern Ireland, was essentially a colonial claim, we were shouted at in some quarters as betraying the nation, the past, the heroes and all. Yet, that it essentially what Éamon de Valera said here: "They would be making the same mistake with that section as England had made with Ireland"— that is, the colonial mistake. He went on:

He would not be responsible for such a policy. Ulster's present position was that she claimed the Six Counties as a constitutional right given to her constitutionally through the Realm and did not want to be under the domination of the rest of Ireland whose sentiments, ideals and religion were different. They said they would not give away their established rights and that they were prepared to die for them. The question was how they were to deal with Ulster— peace or war conditions. At the present the Ministry proposed to act as they had done before under war conditions. He could not definitely say further than that their object at present was to get in contact to see what exactly Ulster wanted. The moment contact was established they were up against a big difficulty. Ulster would say she was as devotedly attached to the Empire as they were to their independence and that she would fight for one as much as they would do for the other. In case of coercion she would get sympathy and help from her friends all over the world.

There is a certain understanding of the Ulster Protestant's position contained in these words which was lost sight of for many years thereafter.

Deputy J.J. Walsh asked if they understood that under no circumstances were they prepared to give any sanction to dual nationality in this country.

He was a hardliner.

An tUachtarán replied as far as dual nationality was concerned, they never recognised it, but that fact would not prevent the British Government from establishing it. For his part, if the Republic were recognised, he would be in favour of giving each county power to vote itself out of the Republic if it so wished. Otherwise they would be compelled to use force.

Deputy J.J. Walsh indicated that he disagreed with that policy.

Comment on this

Tempora mutantur, nos et mutamur in illis.

Comment on this

A very suitable tag, indeed.

Comment on this

Translate, please.

Comment on this

Times change and we change with them.

Comment on this

We are coming back to the wisdom of words uttered in private and away from the "unwisdom"——

Comment on this

He also said he would wade deep in brothers' blood.

Comment on this

That is another matter. This is what he said. On that occasion, and in that debate, his whole emphasis was on the theme of consent of the governed and that this was the key to the whole problem. It was the key to the claim of the majority of this country to be released from English rule and should also be the key to our conduct in relation to those who reject our rule. He laid the emphasis there and that is where it belongs—on accepting the principle of consent of the governed. No majority in this country has yet done it properly. The Ulster Protestant majority in Northern Ireland did not bother setting about getting the consent of the Catholic minority. They seem to act sometimes as if they wanted not to get it. The majority in this country never accepted the legitimacy of the same principle as applying to the position of the Ulster Protestant as long as they object to being ruled by the Parliament here. That principle of consent of the governed is the key to the whole situation here in the long run and is a key which has been lost for more than 50 years.

Deputy P.J. Burke rose.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Tully is entitled to reply.

Comment on this

If Deputy Tully will give me three minutes——

Comment on this

If the Taoiseach will give me three minutes at the end——

Comment on this

I am grateful. I want to thank Deputy Tully very much for allowing me to speak now. I will reciprocate some day. I wish to thank the national newspapers for their conduct during all the trouble over the last three years. They all behaved very well in so far as the troubles in Northern Ireland were concerned. This morning I had to interrupt Deputy Blaney. The reason I interrupted him was because he spoke of the late Mr. Childers, the father of Deputy Childers, who contributed more to the national independence of this country than any man in Ireland. He made it possible for us to have freedom here. For 13 years Deputy Blaney was a Minister in this Government. We are a party governed by majority rule and the day that any party, whether the Labour Party or Fine Gael, cannot be ruled by majority rule is the day that democracy will completely and utterly fail. So far as we are concerned, the Taoiseach only did what the majority rule of our party dictated to him to do. We did everything possible except declare war on the North of Ireland. We tried to focus attention internationally on the position without involving our people or the people of the North in total war. If Deputy Blaney and others want their homes destroyed, that is their business. I went through the Civil War. I saw homes burning in my parish. I am nearly 29 years here.

Comment on this

What about my three minutes?

Comment on this

I want to thank you, Deputy Tully. We went through all these things. If the Taoiseach did anything in this House, he did it on the instructions of the majority of our Party. Is the Taoiseach wrong in taking majority rule and abiding by it after consulting us? I want to say the hardest thing I ever said against anybody. Deputy Blaney is not in the House now. I am sorry that is so, and that a few others are not here also. They took upon themselves to be bigger than the whole group of the Fianna Fáil Party and to do anything they liked. I want to tell the leader of the Labour Party and the representatives of the Fine Gael Party that I believe in majority rule. May I also say——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There is no time.

Comment on this

It looks as if the Deputy will take all my time.

Comment on this

Last Saturday my home was picketed for two and a half hours. I was out and when I came home my wife had collapsed. I had to go for a doctor. I do not give a damn if these people stand by me every day of the week, but I do not like anybody upsetting my wife in my own home. I had to get the doctor for my wife and she had to get treatment. These men were indicating that we are not Republicans. This is our country and anything I can do in my time I will do, and so will my party and all the parties in this House. It is our fondest desire to do everything we can to reunite our country. This crowd are trying to frighten wives, daughters and mothers. If we are not going to make this Parliament supreme——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Tully, please.

Comment on this

I apologise.

Comment on this

I am sure that Deputy P.J. Burke, looking around at some of his former colleagues, can recall what his late colleague, Deputy Seán Dunne, said: "With friends like these what need we of enemies?" I have been here quite a long time and, in my early years here, on the occasion of the Taoiseach's Estimate, it was usual for the Taoiseach of the day to give what we genuinely referred to as something similar to the American President's "State of the Nation" speech. He usually tried to review what had happened during the year that had gone and what the prospects were for the coming year and, indeed, he did it quite well and, in his reply at the end of the debate, he would deal with the points that had been raised during the course of the debate

This was the pattern in the days of Mr. de Valera and in the days of Mr. Lemass. It happened in the first year, I think, of Deputy Lynch but he, becoming very astute as the years went by, developed a new technique. What he does now is he gets up and talks for three-quarters of an hour or so, saying things which any of his backbenchers could say, not giving much information, not being a bit contentious, just passing it along quietly and waiting until everyone else has spoken, and then, knowing there is no opportunity to reply or comment for a period of two or three months, while the House is in recess, he launches his attack on everybody and, as Deputy Corish said yesterday, he usually finishes up by saying we can go off on our recess quite comfortably because the country is in safe hands. At least, he has said so up till now and I will be very interested this evening to see if, finishing his speech in reply to this debate, he once more says that the country is in safe hands because, while I do not want to introduce a note of acrimony, I would like to point out that, judging by recent happenings particularly, it would appear as if the country is in anything but safe hands.

Surely we can all see that what has happened over the last six or 12 months is simply the chickens coming home to roost on the Front Bench of Fianna Fáil. Surely Fianna Fáil must understand that they have brought this upon themselves by closing their eyes to what they knew or, if they did not know, must have had an educated guess about, was happening even within their own Cabinet. I do not want again to drag out here the events which were discussed two-and-a-half to three years ago as a result of the arms trial and what followed, but anybody who comes in here and pretends all this did not happen, pretends there was no truth whatever in it, pretends that Fianna Fáil, the pure-souled patriots of this country, sailed along over the years without doing anything out of the way, nothing which anyone could be ashamed of, is either distorting the facts or is not prepared to face up to them.

I honestly believe that the situation which has arisen has left us, along with the worry of the North, a worry for the South because, if we are to take seriously the activities of some of the people who have been going around masquerading as patriots over the last few months, we must realise that the Government, the very State itself, is in danger when we hear people talking about the State as if it were a puppet state, as if the Government had no authority to rule, as if the right to rule lay in the hands of self-elected people outside this House. When we hear people in this House saying that authority has gone outside, that Dáil and Seanad Éireann are no longer as important as they were, that they do not really matter, then surely the Government have something to think about and surely the people have something to think about.

May I repeat now what Deputy Corish said yesterday. There is one way to test. If the people who claim they have the authority to speak for the majority, and that includes Fianna Fáil, if they have this authority, then why do they not test it? Why do they not give the people the opportunity to decide? We had by a mistake, or a trick—call it what you like—the moving of the writ for the Cork by-election, the by-election resulting from the lamented death of a Member of this House. Now, if Fianna Fáil win, which is very unlikely, they will say the people are behind them; if they lose, they will say it does not matter. God be with the days when Mr. Seán Lemass spelled it out openly and said: "If we lose we will have a general election immediately" and was as good as his word. Unfortunately, those who now control the destinies of this State do not seem to be of the same calibre as Mr. Lemass. Whether we agreed with him or whether we did not, he was man enough to stand up to realities. If any of the so-called republican bodies feel they have a right to talk, then the place to do their talking is at a general election and, if we cannot persuade, coax, entice the Government to have a general election, then let us see what the colour of their money is in the Cork by-election. Let us see how far they will go. Let us see what the popular support is for them. I honestly believe we are now reaching the stage at which, unless we are very careful, those people to whom I referred will do here what they have been promising or threatening to do for a long time; they will succeed in persuading enough people that they represent the people and they will do untold damage before action is taken to either control or prevent it.

While we blame these people, and rightly so, it is only less than half a century we have to go back to find the example they are following. They are doing exactly what was done before and it is no use for old men to come along now and say: "We were wrong. We should not have done it." They did it and the youth and the not so young today are now following their example.

With regard to the North, as far as what is happening there is concerned, while we must condemn what is happening because of acts by the British Army, we must also remember that atrocities are being committed by both sides. It is a shocking thing that the Irish nation should have some of the things which are being done in the North bandied around the world as the normal activities of the Irish people. Whether a person is murdered by the British soldiers, by the UVF or by the IRA, he is just as dead. If he is maimed he suffers just as much if one does it as the other. Therefore, the sooner we stop, or persuade these people to stop, doing these things—in the name of Christianity, if you do not mind—the sooner we will be able to face up to the rest of the world and say that we are, in fact, civilised human beings. Certainly the activities of some of these people cannot be described as civilised by any standards.

To come now to the economy of the country, I am sorry that the Taoiseach in his opening address here yesterday did not go into a little more detail about what was happening and what he hoped would happen to the economy over the next 12 months. Even if he had given a guess as to what was likely to happen over the next few months it would have been a help. It does appear that the Government are reasonably satisfied with the way things are going but they must know that on the economic front the signs of Government failure are everywhere to be seen. Whether we measure them by high unemployment, by escalating consumer price trends or in terms of real economic growth, the Government have failed on all counts. The late Seán Lemass said on one occasion that the way to judge whether a Government were doing well or otherwise was to consider the employment and unemployment figures. If we go by that and consider our present unemployment figures, it is obvious that the Government must be condemned for their failure.

There does not seem to be a clearly defined strategy for economic development. It seems to be a question of playing along and the recent IDA report can in no way substitute for a detailed comprehensive approach in planning for our need of a long-term sustained growth. The Government have not resolved the problem of increasing productivity fostered on income increases. They may say that is not entirely their fault and that the fault lies with the trade unions and the workers who are looking for more than their share. In this context we must consider prices. Surely the Government understand that if they allow price increases there must be corresponding increases in wages. A Bill was passed here a few days ago for the purpose of taking action in respect of price increases but on the following day the Minister for Finance said there was no way in which prices could be controlled at the retail level. If that is the position why did this House waste its time passing a Bill to control prices? Was that Bill merely eye-wash to cod people who do not understand the position as well as the Minister for Finance understands it and who might be led to believe that some effort was being made to control prices?

If prices cannot be controlled the workers are entitled to seek compensation so that they can live at least as well as they lived 12 months ago and that is not the situation now. The position has not been helped by the proposed introduction of VAT. I was amused to hear the Minister for Finance tell us, not once but on a number of occasions, that we need have no fear of increases in prices as a result of VAT because this tax is simply a substitute for another tax. When it was pointed out to the Minister that he had said something similar in relation to the introduction of decimal currency he did not seem to understand that what happened then could and would happen as a result of VAT. At the time of the introduction of decimal currency, the Minister suggested that there was a danger that people would be inclined to charge too much for small articles but that this would be offset by reducing the prices of other articles. It did not take very long for certain people who believe in collecting a fast halfpenny to add on the halfpenny to the fast selling items and take it off the slow selling ones.

Under VAT something similar will happen. I do not wish to go into this question in detail because it has been discussed at length already. But the Minister must be prepared to accept that there will be a lot of trouble in having wage adjustments fixed because the workers realise there will be increases in prices. That is the reason why we in the trade union movement are having so much difficulty in having a long-term agreement accepted by the workers. The workers know that there is no point in accepting an agreement for 12 months when the Government, who are supposed to be controlling certain prices, allow such increases to take place that any increase granted would be eroded within a very short time.

If anybody wishes to verify whether consumer price increases have increased to the extent we are suggesting, we would remind them that during the past 12 months the consumer price increase has been 8 per cent. The increase in respect of food prices alone was 10 per cent as against 4.5 per cent for the previous year. Is it any wonder, then, that people who must live on a weekly wage are not satisfied to accept that an increase which they are being offered now will not be sufficient to carry them over a period of from 12 to 18 months?

I would like to see a period of stability. I would like to see a situation where we could be sure that during the next 12 or 18 months there would not be an increase in the cost of living. However, nobody could guarantee that for as long as the present Government are in power because, apparently, they have decided that prices will be allowed to rise in any way that those who control prices wish them to rise.

Another problem in respect of this wage increase is the question of house prices. If we take into account rent and rates, we find that during the past 12 months the cost of housing has increased by 13.5 per cent. The extraordinary thing is that while many people are living in accommodation rented to them by local authorities, the Minister for Local Government can stand up here and assert brazenly that there is nothing wrong in charging rents of between £4 and £8 per week. That might be all right for a Minister or even for any other member of this House but it is not all right for any man who is trying to rear a young family to have to put aside one-sixth of his earnings, and in some cases, one-fifth, before he can spend any of the money that he has earned so hard. In addition to that the State have refused to do anything about the personal allowances for income tax. Twenty years ago when the standard wage was £6 per week the income tax allowance for a single person was £6 10s per week and £10 10s for a married couple but now the standard wage is more than three times what it was then but the income tax allowance is almost the same. If it was considered wrong to charge income tax then on what was considered to be the minimum required for existence, surely it is very wrong now to charge income tax on two-thirds of earnings? Apparently so far as the State is concerned there is nothing wrong so long as people do not notice the wrong. They seem to think there is nothing wrong in taking one-third of a £2 increase and then to take a further one-sixth of that increase by way of rent. When all these expenses are considered as well as the extra social welfare contributions is it any wonder that a man should have asked me recently to whom the increases in wages were being given because, as he said, he got very little by way of them?

When a man finds that he is not getting sufficient to live on he asks his employer to allow him work overtime if possible but of course the State is waiting for its 35p in the pound on every pound he earns and the overtime is taken into account also in assessing his rent. Yet we are told that this is the affluent society and that everybody should be happy with the situation as it is. It is obvious that anyone who says this votes Fianna Fáil and has been indoctrinated with the idea that whatever Fianna Fáil do must be right.

In relation to housing the situation is that the number of new houses built by the local authorities in 1967-68 was 4,045, and of other houses built by private individuals, 7,972; in 1968-69, local authorities built 4,613; others, 8,420; in 1969-70 the figures were 4,706 and 8,938 respectively; in 1971, they were 3,875 and 9,796; in 1971-72 they were 5,106 and 10,815. In the North of Ireland, about which there is so much talk of how bad things are, and we know how bad they are, the situation is that the ratio is three to one of local authority houses against private houses. Here it is two to one the other way round. Surely there is something wrong. If the Minister for Local Government could stand here yesterday and the day before and tell Deputies that although he knew that schemes submitted for sanction to his Department, schemes submitted for payment of loans from the Local Loans Fund which would allow them to start, were held up by his Department he could not see anything wrong with that. He said it was all right, that he would release them en bloc when he thought the money would be released.

Would the Taoiseach, when replying, say if we have reached the stage where money required for local authority housing, even with the exorbitant rents being charged, is no longer available? If that is so, we should know it because there is no point in Government Ministers issuing statements about the high level of housing and saying that any money required is available if it cannot be got from the Department of Local Government because that is the acid test. I am sure there is no Deputy who in the past 12 months has not had occasion to bring this to the notice of the Minister for Local Government— with very little result I may add.

Similarly, people building new houses or reconstructing them apply for grants to the Department. Is the Taoiseach aware that it is almost impossible to get any money out of the Department of Local Government and the only way we appear to be able to get a response is by putting down a question to the Minister. Then, in some peculiar way the money becomes available and the grant is paid and the Minister can stand up and say: "That grant was paid." When he is questioned it is revealed that it was paid the day before the question was answered or two days after it was asked. If the present Government, for whatever short time they will be here, are prepared to stand up to 100 or 150 questions on housing loans and grants being asked every day that these questions are to be taken, I guarantee to the Taoiseach that those questions will be put down.

I am glad the Taoiseach has come in for the final stage of the debate. I should like to know if he is aware of the situation in regard to factory closures. There is a great song and dance about new factories opening and we are told what a great thing it is if a factory is opened, usually in the West of Ireland or occasionally near the area I represent on the Cavan or Monaghan border. They do not build in County Meath because they do not get the grants they get in Cavan or Monaghan which are represented by people with sufficient influence to have them classified as undeveloped areas and they are, therefore, able to qualify for increased grants. We do not hear of the factories that are closing.

Navan has been known for many years as a furniture town but a couple of large furniture factories have closed there. The last one to close was Crannac and the workers there decided to take steps to protect not only their jobs but an industry which had its roots in that town traditionally. I am glad these workers have been successful but I want to ask the Taoiseach: if those workers could prove that they were in a position not only to keep their factory open and keep their jobs but to increase an export business which the factory had and thereby produce wealth for the nation, is there any explanation as to why, when factories are closing, no effort is made by any Government Department to see if there is a way to keep them open?

I instanced here what I considered to be a scandalous case, a case where a factory closed putting 140 workers out of jobs. Those workers signed on the labour exchange and on average they got over £10 per week and were entitled to get that sum for 12 months. Most of them had long service; they had about £25 per week and were entitled to 50 per cent of that in redundancy payments leaving them a net £22.50 a week for 12 months. In addition, the State lost the production of the factory, lost social welfare insurance and lost the income tax which would have been paid by these workers. It is estimated that about £140,000 was lost in the first 12 months and that, over a little longer period when all the redundancy money had been paid, almost £250,000 of a loss would have accrued to the State. That factory could have been kept open with a loan of £60,000. Surely there is something wrong when something like that happens. That is a case I know of without reference to the many hundreds of factories that have closed without any explanation.

The State should carry out, in the case of every substantial factory at least, a cost-benefit analysis to see if it is cheaper to keep the factory open or to close it. If it is to be closed there should be a good reason and, if it is to be kept open, it does not matter who keeps it open. The State must enter into this matter in a much bigger way. I believe it is up to them to take control and run factories which some people want to be rid of in order to get some liquid assets and they do not mind about people who lose their livelihood as a result. This situation is ludicrous and should not be allowed to continue. I ask the Taoiseach to make some effort to remedy it.

There are so many things which should be dealt with on this Estimate and such a short time to deal with them that I must omit quite a number of matters I had intended to deal with—I do not blame Deputy Burke. Apparently, no effort is being made to do anything about employment despite the fact that we had 80,000 unemployed last winter and now have about 68,000 and that, unlike other years, in June and July of this year when the normal trend in unemployment is downwards, we have an upward trend. Surely something has gone seriously wrong. Apparently, the State are not interested in doing something about it. Yes, they have talked about a Fourth Programme of Economic Expansion, the Second Programme having died a natural death and the Third one being forgotten half-way through in case anybody would think of referring to it. I suppose the Fourth one will not fare much better.

When Deputy MacEntee was Minister for Local Government some years ago he used talk about crystal balls and he would look into the crystal ball to see what was happening. Apparently, he did not pass on the crystal ball to his successor. The result is that the Taoiseach is unable to say what is going to happen next week. He had better buy himself a new crystal ball or get somebody in his Department to try to find out what is likely to happen. Without talking about the EEC at all, it does look as if our industrial expansion has ceased and we are now running into a slide which must get greater as we come nearer to entry into Europe.

Deputy Corish said yesterday, and rightly so, that we contested the referendum against entry into the EEC, that we did everything we possibly could to prevent it. We put the facts before the public and, while doing so, met and discussed with members of both Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil, and particularly with Fianna Fáil, various things which we believe would bring ruin to this country. We got what they considered, and what the public considered, to be satisfactory answers. The answers having been given and accepted by the public, we are now committed to entry into the EEC the very same as the other two parties are. That having been said, however, it is rather a pity that those who are now striking notes of warning—I think that is the expression they are using—about things that can go wrong, should have had those notes of warning struck before the referendum took place.

Surely the farmers of Cork who fatten pigs, as quite a number of them do, for a living should have been told there is no future for the bacon industry in this country in EEC conditions. They might as well have been told that because it is the truth. Did they not hear the gentleman from Denmark who was interviewed on "Farmers Forum" on Radio Éireann just before the referendum, who explained that in Denmark there are 12 million pigs per year fattened and handled in 12 factories, each of which handles one million pigs. When he was asked: What about expansion in the EEC? he said: "We hope to expand to 16 million." Then the interviewer, feeling he was on good ground, said: "Does that mean there is a prospect for pig-fattening in Ireland in the EEC?" The Danish gentleman was a little taken aback but he gave an answer, and I do not think it was the one that was expected, because he said: "Any person in Ireland who is fattening more than 1,000 pigs per year will be all right, but if he is not I would advise him to get out of the business now."

I am sure they will be heartening words when they are eventually passed on to the people of Cork who are depending to a certain extent on the fattening of pigs for their livelihood, and when it really comes down to brass tacks I hope it will not be denied any longer and that the people will be told this. The Government knew this before the referendum took place and did not go to the trouble of telling them this was so.

The balance of payments has been going screwy for some time and I understand that the deficit for 1972 was expanding to around £70 million. I take a peculiar view of this, because the balance of payments deficit may not mean an awful lot to the ordinary man, but if the upward trend continues it is bound to cause concern, although the Government do not seem to be very concerned about it.

As far as the whole question of investment in this country is concerned, there are some people who believe there should be some way whereby external assets should be brought back to this country. I do not know how it could be done because most of it is held by private individuals or private concerns. However, the Government themselves are responsible for generating the industrial expansion which will be necessary if the country is to continue at all but they are not doing anything about it and had not, indeed, until the timorous step taken this year by the Minister for Finance when he decided he would go for a deficit budget. This was the first step in that direction, and, as I say, it was a timorous one. Those of us who have been watching those figures over the years are satisfied that something similar to what happened over the past two years is bound to happen again. I referred earlier to the question of the increases which are granted in wages and which are taken back by the Government in income tax. In view of the amount of increased income tax which is being collected by the State I would suggest that when the Minister was going for the so-called deficit budget he was quite satisfied in his own mind that by the end of the year enough money will have come in—let us call it buoyancy of the revenue or anything else—to compensate for that and that we will have a balanced budget. The unfortunate thing is that unless some effort is made by the State to accept that it is its responsibility to try to create full employment we will not have full employment. Therefore if this Government do not accept that responsibility, and I am satisfied that this Government do not want to accept it, then they must get out and make room for a government which will be prepared to face up to this problem.

It has been stated on a number of occasions that State investment is perhaps greater in this country than in any other country except the Soviet Union. That may be so, but it is the type of State investment we are not looking for. We firmly believe that the State should be able to take up a great deal of the money which is uselessly spent on imports and spend it in this country, thus creating employment. I would refer, as I did on one previous occasion here, to the Department of Posts and Telegraphs. A very substantial amount of equipment for the Department of Posts and Telegraphs is required annually for replacements and expansion of the service. Most of that is at present and will continue to be imported for no reason at all except that the Government have not decided that they could set up an industry which would manufacture this type of equipment and thereby make employment available.

Time is running out so I want to conclude on this point. Recently we had an example of muddling in this country which should never happen again. We have, thank God, and have always had, a police force and an Army which have been loyal to the State, and, I hope it will long remain so. However, last year the Garda were treated shamefully before eventually a report that was prepared gave them a promise of a little of what they were entitled to but which has not yet been fully implemented. It has solved some of their problems but does not solve the problem at senior level and that is where it must now receive attention.

Secondly, the Army should have got an increase. It should have been paid to them, not promised, many months ago. It was only when there were threats, which should not be necessary, of unrest in the Forces, at a time when it is essential to keep the Defence Forces happy, that the Minister for Defence announced that an increase was being given. Even the announcement being made officially by the Department was incorrect in its content and therefore caused a lot of extra trouble.

Would the Taoiseach realise that both the Government party and the other two parties here are interested in keeping the ship floating, are interested in ensuring a happy and free Ireland, that they are interested in seeing things done in the correct way. He should realise that if he is prepared to say "I want this done; it is in everybody's interest that it should be done", he can call on the support of both Fine Gael, I am sure, and ourselves in doing it. However, if he shilly-shallies, makes double-meaning statements and suggests something which eventually turns out to be entirely different, he can hardly blame us if we wonder whether or not it is worth pursuing the matter any further or supporting him any further. We, therefore, say to him now: "You are having a by-election in Cork. Why not go the whole way? Why not either dissolve the Dáil this evening and have a general election instead, or if you are not prepared to do that do as your predecessor did and say that if you lose Cork you will take it as evidence that the people are dissatisfied with your Government and test them in a general election."

Comment on this

The Dáil is now going into recess and this time there must be a real doubt as to whether it will meet again. I propose to suggest in the remarks I am going to make that the various problems now facing the country, referred to in his speech by the Taoiseach, have produced a state of mind amongst the people which now make a change of Government absolutely imperative for their solution.

First of all, we have the vista of Europe which now opens up in front of us. It is not necessary to say now that in relation to Europe we face a period of very serious challenge but also we face an era abounding in opportunity. It is essential for the survival of this country and our people that we go into Europe knowing the role we propose to play in the building of an entirely new international society. We must also go into Europe confident in our ability to avail of the opportunities which Europe will provide. This means that next year, in particular, from January 1973, those who lead and those who constitute the Government of this country must be known to have the people's loyalty and support and must be a united team portraying a dynamism and a confidence which can affect the outlook of the ordinary people of this country.

Do the present Government provide that? I do not believe they do. I believe that the Taoiseach now leads a second rate team. I am sorry to have to say that the ability and the competence of the personnel constituting this Government must be amongst the lowest in Europe. This is not the kind of team that will give confidence to our people as we enter Europe. This is not the kind of ministerial team that will expand and expound the kind of dynamism which our people require to enter with confidence into Europe and to avail of its opportunities.

In relation to Europe it is too serious for us to face what is involved with a Government that is too long in office, that is tired and weary. I believe in that respect also the need is there for new men and new ideas. Europe is one problem but we also have what has been referred to I must say by almost every Deputy, very properly, in this debate, as the problem of incipient civil war in the North.

The outbreak of violence, hatred, murder and arson have shocked our people and have caused dismay to people from other countries watching us. Those of us living in this island appear to be a community divided and torn asunder by bitter divisions based on past events and of bitter religious bigotry. All of us who have been engaged in politics over the past 50 years have known of the danger of this. Let us not cod ourselves that this is something emerging now to our astonishment, surprise and dismay.

All of us have a responsibility for not facing facts decades ago. We have a responsibility for our double-thinking, double-dealing and double standards. Let us not forget that in the part of Ireland over which our tri-colour flies we made a blatant effort to establish a purely Gaelic state. Time and time again in the past by the things we said and the intolerance we displayed we have tried to assert that an Orangeman could not be an Irishman and we made it clear by the way we administered our affairs here that we were aiming for a Gaelic speaking Ireland, an Ireland which would only acknowledge the heritage and traditions of those who comprised the majority of the people on this island.

Was that a mistake? If it was let us frankly admit it now and get on with the job of healing the breaches which our actions in the past have created. That was not the only mistake. We have a Constitution which asserts the rights of this Parliament to legislate for all of Ireland without regard to the views, the wishes, the ideals or the sentiments of those living at the moment in our Six Northern Counties. How does that assertion coincide with the declared policy by the Taoiseach that we seek only union with the will of the majority of those at present living in the North? For years we down here have refused to recognise that on this island, as part of the humus of our community, there were people who came here historically from different strains, from a variety of backgrounds, and who held traditions which they regarded as sacred, who held ideas and views they were prepared to die for. We consistently refused to recognise that fact and to recognise that our society and our community is essentially pluralistic in origin.

Who can forget that an evening paper yesterday carried a banner headline: "Gardaí Protect Orangemen", instead of acknowledging the fact that every man, no matter what his creed, his background or his ideals may be, is essentially and fundamentally an Irishman and that the divisions we talk about are divisions between Irishmen who should have and share a common responsibility in the future of this island. These are the things we have done to ourselves. These are the mistakes we have made in the past. Let the blame be shared by all of us because there is none of us who is a Simon Pure in this respect and there is not one of us who can look at the record and say: "At least I was not one of those." We all were. But this is changing now. The question is whether it is changing too late.

The Leader of the Government now asserts—each time he speaks a little more emphatically, each time he speaks a little more explicitly—on behalf of the Irish people that down here we do not seek unity by violence, by force, that we only seek the re-union of our people with the consent, the agreement, the co-operation and generous support of the majority of the people who live in the North.

I give credit to the Taoiseach for so speaking. I give credit to the Leader of the Fianna Fáil Party for saying that, because this was not the policy of Fianna Fáil. Let us recognise that. Deputy Blaney who spoke here today could speak with conviction when he assailed these views as not representing the Fianna Fáil Party in which he grew up, and in which so many others grew up, but the credit is that the change is there and that they now speak the kind of good sense and pure patriotism that, if it had been spoken 50 years ago, we might not have seen the birth of partition and division and, indeed, might not have seen the bitterness of a civil war that caused so much bloodshed and suffering to our people.

Of course this view honestly expressed by the Taoiseach, and now supported by the vast majority of the Fianna Fáil Party and by the members of the Government, has not been expressed without its cost, without a price which had to be paid in dismissals of Ministers and resignations of Ministers, in sackings from the ranks of the Fianna Fáil Party. All this was a price that had to be paid for a fundamental change in policy and change in outlook. What is the present position? I suppose I can say, as a Fianna Fáil watcher, that probably now an uneasy peace has eventually been arrived at inside the ranks of Fianna Fáil. Probably the position now is that so far as the Government are concerned they now constitute a coalition based on the common instinct of over self-preservation and designed to tide the transition between this and the next election. That coalition exists between the old guard Fianna Fáil Republicans and the supporters of the Taoiseach.

That is as it may be but here again in relation to our common problem, the problem in the North of Ireland, its future and what may emerge, can we afford a continuance of such a Government in office? Can we afford a continuance of a situation in which necessarily, if not the Taoiseach, certain other members of the Fianna Fáil Government, must speak with double tongue in order to assuage the ruffled feelings of those who never knew the truth. Can we afford the continuance of a situation which may make possible double standards in government in relation to a matter so important as the survival of our community and of those of us who live on this island.

I, as an Irishman, with feeling, share with every Deputy who has spoken here, from the Fianna Fáil benches, from the Labour benches and from my own benches, the condemnation of what has been happening over the last 12 or 18 months in the North of Ireland. I want to say that if the harm now being done by the IRA, by the Provisionals—I do not mind what they call themselves— by these gunmen, to the cause of Irish unity is to be curtailed and diminished and reduced it is essential that we have in office in this part of Ireland a united and strong Government that can speak clearly without hesitation and whose Leader has not to think before he speaks. If we do not achieve that there is a very grave danger that those misguided men may feel that somewhere in Dublin, in the Government, they still have friends. We cannot forget that much of what has taken place in the last two years in Belfast and in Derry would have been avoided, and certainly would not have continued, were it not for the common belief that it represented at least the view of a number of Ministers in the Fianna Fáil Government.

In relation to the North of Ireland, just as in relation to Europe, the situation of this country and the welfare of its people requires and necessitates a change in Government. Look at our economy. Look at our domestic situation. Look at the ordinary matters relating to the bread and butter of the people. Look at how, in relation to discharging their responsibility as a Government, this Government have cared for the ordinary people. Inflation has been referred to. We have had continuing and violent inflation marked with high unemployment. We have had a series of stop-go policies in relation to economic activity. Looking back on all of this, it is becoming more and more apparent that the period since the last general election has been marked spectacularly by the consistency of this Government in failing to deliver the goods. There has been an absence of policy and programming and the only consistency has been in failure.

We cannot afford a continuance of that kind of situation. How is our economy ever to expand to provide a way of life for our people, to provide a home and a job for every one of our young people, how can that hope be held out to them if from the Government, from the Government's Ministers, there is nothing but evidence of muddling, spasmodic thinking and a complete failure to plan or hold out a programme?

We had an effort some 18 months ago, a last minute effort, conceived in haste, to bring in some form of control in relation to prices and wages and incomes and the very moment people asked what did this mean it was dropped like a hot potato by the Minister for Finance. We have had another effort at controlling prices and in particular one felt in relation to social needs that the price of houses and the cost of houses to people might well be controlled but that went out of the legislation. Why? Was it because the silent men in the back rooms of power objected to that kind of control?

We have had recently an example of an obstinate Minister surrounded by advice from bureaucrats refusing to recognise, in these days of inflation and of rising prices, the sanity of zero-rating food under the VAT proposals. What does this indicate to the people? It indicates a team of Ministers whose only common bond is the fact that they are all Ministers and all members of Fianna Fáil but they do not act as a team. There does not appear to be a policy which binds them together. There does not appear to be an aim towards which they are directing their efforts. There is no goal ahead for Fianna Fáil. It is mark-time and stay in office as long as you can, boys. Can we afford this kind of Government? Look at the result on the lives of the people. Altered though the names may be, no matter how the appearance may have been changed a bit, we are still carrying on with a standard of health services which came straight from the last century. We still carry on in relation to the health of the people on the basis that want must be established before the State recognises an obligation.

We have not yet learned the lesson which every other country in Western Europe learned after the last war, that a community survives by community effort and that there is a common responsibility on every person in each community to help to shoulder the problem of his neighbour. We from these benches over the years have preached the necessity for health insurance, for providing a comprehensive scheme of medical services based on community insurance. That has been tinkered with in the last couple of years but there has been no step forward towards providing a fundamental improvement in the standard of our health services. How could there be when there is not a united Government with a clear policy ahead of it? How could there be when Fianna Fáil are so formed and constituted that they believe that what was done under the Health Acts of 1953 and around that period remains static Fianna Fáil policy?

In relation to health services, in relation to social welfare services for the raising of standards of our people, the provision of income related benefits and of proper family allowance—all these things which other countries are constantly aiming to achieve and improve—we are doing nothing. We have not even faced up to the one question that every citizen of Ireland living in Belfast or Derry will ask you: what will happen if we go into the Republic? What about the social welfare standards? We have not even begun to think along those lines.

This, Sir, is because we have in office a Government the personnel of which—they are all decent men; they are all fine men; individually they have their own gifts and so on— taken together, is a second division team and that is not good enough for Ireland now that we are playing in the first division. We need a better team of Ministers if we are to survive and if our people are to have their problems dealt with.

I mentioned Europe. I mentioned the North. I mentioned the domestic front. I believe that the result of the emergence of these problems, the result of the failure of this Government properly to face up to them, has resulted in a feeling—and I regret to have to say this—a feeling of disillusionment amongst our people today, disillusionment with the Government—that is understandable and may I say as an Opposition Deputy, perhaps tolerable—but that disillusionment has extended further than that. There is today, I regret to say, a disillusionment with the functioning of democracy itself. Our people are losing heart. They are losing heart at what has taken place, particularly in the last two and a half years since the last general election. From the heights of Government itself we have seen very, very low standards in these high places and this has caused a reaction, a reaction against the Government initially and a reaction against the functioning of democracy itself.

There are those who have tried to batten on this reaction, those who have tried to turn young people, and older people too, in disgust against not merely how democracy has functioned in this country but against the institutions of the State itself. Thanks be to God, that effort has not been accompanied with any significant degree of success and—it has been correctly referred to here—the spectacle of Irish people, in the name of Ireland, attacking Irish soldiers at the Curragh is a matter of shame on anyone who conceived such a result.

But there exist at the moment in our society real areas of danger and there are a number of agents very avid to make these conditions worse. As I say, this has been contributed to largely by disillusionment with the Government and by the conduct of this Government since the last general election. The people today do not know where this Government stand. They recognise now that this Government have been too long in office, too long there.

It is well to recall to the people outside that the Fianna Fáil Party have now been continuously in office for 15 years and that prior to that they were in office for a total of 19 years. For all the things which have happened in this country over well-nigh the last 40 years, and for all the things which have not happened, all the hopes that have been blighted, all the bitter disappointments that the people have suffered, the blame lies largely at the feet of the Fianna Fáil Party. Today the ordinary citizen of this country does not know where the Government stand nor do they know who controls the Government. Is it the Civil Service? Is it bureaucracy? Does the Taoiseach merely read out speeches prepared for him by a civil servant? Who writes his speeches? Where do they come from? Are they expressing the faith, conviction and belief of the Taoiseach himself, or are they an agreed formula from time to time to declare what is commonly agreed on among disparate elements?

Comment on this

Is he controlled by independent Fianna Fáil?

Comment on this

Is it the Civil Service which controls this Government? Is it big business, whatever that may be in this country, which control the Government in this country? It was significant to observe on Tuesday in the Seanad a Private Member's Bill which sought to make it obligatory on companies to disclose political subscriptions not even given a First Reading because there was a Fianna Fáil whip out to ensure that the Bill would not even be printed.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

The Tacateers again.

Comment on this

At this moment, is there a liaison committee at the back of the Government contriving to keep the difficult Fianna Fáil dissidents in line, and at what a price? On what grounds? On what conditions? Who controls Fianna Fáil? There ought to be no such question asked. It ought to be clear in this Dáil that the people have a government, rightly or wrongly, that carries their confidence and retains their trust. This was not the Fianna Fáil Party which the people voted for in 1969. Let us remember the boasters—a united party, the party of reality. Where are the absent men? Where is Kevin Boland? Where is Neil Blaney? Where is Charles Haughey? Where are all the others that composed the government which was elected in June, 1969? Do the men who are now in government speak with the same tongue? Do they act in the same way? Do they represent the policy and the promises and the programmes which were put before the people in the last general election?

If we have to face Europe and to provide hope for the unfortunate, suffering people in Belfast, Derry and elsewhere in the North of Ireland, if we have to provide for our own people here at home an assurance that it would be the continuing aim of Government every day in every way to improve our own country and to make things better for Irishmen and women to live and to work in, and if we are to restore confidence in democracy, there must be for the people a real prospect of a change in government. Responsibility rests on those to whom the people look to make this possible. We are all Irishmen here in this Dáil in all political parties. We have been called to political action. A vocation and dedication to the giving of service, often service that is not recognised, exists in each of us. In all of the political parties each of us endeavours to do his best to make his contribution to the improvement of our country. Those who serve in Fianna Fáil and those who serve in the present Government and who have served for many years have done their best as Irishmen to help to improve our country. But that is what is behind us. Now there is need for a change. There is a need for fresh minds and for new men to give the people new heart and new hope in the work of government. I hope that in the weeks and months that he ahead this message will be carried to every part of Ireland.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

As anticipated, this debate inevitably covered a very wide field. I indicated at the outset that I would try to meet and answer as many points as I could. I did not sit in during all the speeches but I got a report of their content. It would be very difficult for me in the time at my disposal to deal with every point made, but I will endeavour to deal with as many points as I can.

It was inevitable as a result of the times that are in it that the situation in the North of Ireland would be very much highlighted in the course of the debate. I will try to deal later with some of the points made in that context. While I was sitting in during Deputy Tully's speech he made an allegation which repeated one made yesterday by Deputy Corish with regard to speeches made by me before and during the referendum campaign. The Deputy alleged that at no time did I give the people any indication that there were certain problems and certain dangers inherent in our membership of the EEC and that certain difficulties might have to be met, particularly by industry. It was suggested that only now that the referendum is behind us am I referring to problems or difficulties which might arise as a result of EEC membership.

First, I want to reject completely any suggestion to this effect. I consistently enunciated the view, which I repeated yesterday, that EEC membership held out the best prospects of attaining our development objectives, but I warned that successes would not be universal nor automatic. I have checked the record on this point. I want to say that from the beginning of the year up to 10th May I made something over 20 speeches in all dealing with the EEC. Not all of these speeches contained warnings about the problems or difficulties that membership would entail because their context did not on occasion lend itself to such remarks. In dealing with the general aspects, such as sovereignty, it would not have been appropriate to digress into warnings about vulnerable enterprises or industries, but in the set of speeches which dealt with industrial or employment prospects I find in each one of them there is a warning of obstacles likely to arise and necessary to overcome in relation to such subjects as industry and employment. For example—I want to say this deliberately in order to nail this suggestion; I will not call it a lie because I would not be within the rules of order-but, to nail this unfounded suggestion, I give as one example what I said when I was speaking in this House on March 21st, two months before the Referendum. I said:

I am not seeking to play down the difficulties which would have to be overcome in some sectors. The Government have never pretended that the structure of industry would remain unaffected by the transition from a highly protected market to free trading conditions. In fact, they have over the years spared no effort to facilitate this transition both by encouraging existing industry to adapt to a changing environment and by new export based industries on a large scale. Notwithstanding all that has been done there are likely to be some losses.

Was that not a warning or was it something that Deputy Corish and Deputy Tully could dismiss?

Comment on this

Not very specific, was it?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Taoiseach.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

When I opened the Referendum campaign on April 17 I said this:

We have never denied that free trade will cause problems for some firms for, over the years, we have used money, time and energy in making Irish firms more efficient so that they could compete with imports. These efforts have had a great deal of success but, again, we would not deny that some firms still need to do more.

On the eve of the poll, I said in a statement in the Sunday Press of 7th May:

The Government have never pretended that membership of the EEC will not lead to some economic difficulties. There will, for example, be an increase in the cost of some foods, principally beef and butter, and some industries will suffer, but these difficulties must be weighed against the economic advantages of membership.

Perhaps I have dealt with this point at too much length, but I have quoted these excerpts because not only Deputy Corish and Deputy Tully but other Opposition speakers frequently make allegations which cannot be substantiated. There were several other examples, in fact, in the course of the debate to which I need not refer but, if I had time to deal with them, I can assure the House that I could establish that there is no substance whatever in the careless generalisations in which some Opposition members frequently indulge.

Comment on this

We are not going to give the Taoiseach an Aunt Sally anyway.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Order.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Please, will members of the Labour Party be fair and honest when they allege that no warnings or no indications of difficulties were issued or stated by the Government?

The question of landing rights was raised by Deputy O'Donnell. I know he is deeply interested and involved in this subject. I refer to the landing rights for USA airlines in Dublin. Deputy O'Donnell alleged, as he has done before, that a deal had already been made, a deal which would be announced after the Dáil had adjourned for the Summer Recess. Again I want categorically to deny that allegation. It was made by other people too on the eve of the referendum, people who had a vested interest of one kind or another in the defeat of the Referendum proposal. I do not have to elaborate on who they are, but I want to say that no deal whatever has been made and no agreement has been reached with the Americans. Discussions have been going on in an endeavour to reach a solution, but it is not possible at this stage to say when a decision will be arrived at.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Donnell

I am very glad the Taoiseach has made that statement.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Taoiseach.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

If the Deputy, or anybody else, makes the allegation often enough there will come a time when an agreement will have been made and, therefore, the latest allegation will then have the appearance of credibility.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Donnell

The whole country was saying what I said.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Taoiseach.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I want to repeat, for Deputy O'Donnell's information and for the benefit of anybody else who cares to believe the allegation, that no agreement has yet been made.

Several speakers, including Deputy Cosgrave and Deputy Corish, referred to the forthcoming legislation on value-added tax. Deputy O'Higgin's also referred to it. The Deputies alleged that it would mean an increase in prices, especially food prices. Again, I want to reject these suggestions. Every Deputy must know that basically the switch to turnover tax will simply mean a switch from the existing turnover and wholesale taxes which presently affect food. There is no reason, therefore, why the changeover should lead to any increase in prices. This is especially the case with food where there is no change in the present position. In contrast, some suggestions have been made from the Opposition benches to the effect that food should be exempted so that taxation on non-food items would, therefore, be increased. This would obviously mean changes in all prices with increases in the majority of cases. I think it is well to remember that the poor and the not-so-poor, the middle-income group, who buy food also like to indulge in the modest luxuries of having a drink or a smoke and perhaps buying a transistor radio or a television.

Comment on this

They cannot afford to as often as the rest of us.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Taoiseach.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

It would, of course, be nice to remove taxation on food items, but it would not be so nice to raise taxes on almost everything else and, if Deputy FitzGerald is, as he threatened he would, going to tell the story throughout the country, I hope he will remember to tell both sides of the story.

Comment on this

Of course I will.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Taoiseach.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Changing all prices at a time when many prices are rising anyway would, for other reasons, as the Deputy well knows, create conditions in which the upward pressure of prices would increase. These would also be the conditions in which it would be most difficult to supervise or control all price changes in order to ensure that any tax reductions were passed on in full to the consumer. It is for this reason the Minister for Finance pointed out that the passing on of all tax reductions could not be guaranteed, and for the Deputy to allege this means Government incompetence is, I think, unworthy of him. He ought to know better. I am sure he does. He knows perfectly well that any administration in any democratic society, if faced with a similar proposal to change prices, could not guarantee the precise outcome because, as he well knows, it would take an army of officials to supervise all transactions.

While I am on prices, perhaps I could refer to what Deputy Cosgrave said. He said that, as a result of value-added tax, there would be an increase in prices because decimalisation did cause some increase in prices. I do not deny that, but I do deny that the introduction of decimalisation was itself the sole cause, though it is a fact it was utilised and exploited by some people.

Comment on this

Does the Taoiseach deny that value-added tax will not increase prices?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Taoiseach must be allowed to make his speech.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

If the Deputy is to interrupt, perhaps he will not hear some of what I would like to tell him later on. Deputy Cosgrave said that decimalisation had caused an explosion in prices and that statistics could be produced to support that claim. I would ask the Deputy what statistics he is speaking of? Prices increased in 1971 but there was no explosion because the increase was at a lesser rate than the rate for 1970. It was a 9 per cent increase as opposed to 10 per cent.

Comment on this

Ten per cent on food.

Comment on this

It was 11 per cent on food.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

We do not have to look very far for an explanation as to why prices increased in those two years. In 1970 workers 'wages increased by about 17 per cent and by about 13 per cent last year. Everybody knows that such large increases in labour costs must inevitably affect prices. There is no use in pretending otherwise. I mention this point not only for the benefit of Deputy Cosgrave but for the benefit also of Deputy Keating, who criticised attempts to create the impression that wage costs were the main cause of inflation I am not trying to say something against the interest of workers that is not capable of being established. I know this view is accepted widely but if Deputy Keating does not accept my word for it, I would refer him to the ICTU document which was presented on this subject at their recent conference in Galway. It is said in this document, and I quote:

Trade unions cannot escape from the dilemma posed by the vicious spiral of prices-incomes, prices-incomes escalating in turn, that the gap between increases in income and the growth of national production (in 1971 incomes increased by 13 per cent while GNP increased by only 3 per cent) has not been the sole cause of rising prices but that it has, unquestionably, been a major and persistent cause.

The document goes on to say that the National Prices Commission put it very well in one of its reports when it stated that:

It was quite clear that increases in money incomes unmatched by improvements in efficiency are the main causes of price increases. It is not possible to get a quart from a pint pot, when the quart is nevertheless sought. Price increases are the mechanism that force people to make do with the pint that is the limit of the pot's capacity.

I would suppose Deputy Keating would take the word of the ICTU on this question if he is not prepared to take my word. I shall depart now from the economic side of the debate and refer to the suggestion made by Deputy Cosgrave yesterday when he tried to create the impression that my statement that the Government were resolved not to allow private armies use our territory to impose their will either on the people of Northern Ireland or on the people of this part of the country, represented a change in attitude on the part of the Government to those engaging in subversive activities. I reject totally that suggestion whether it comes from Deputy Cosgrave or from anybody else. The policy of this Government towards private armies and subversive groups has been firm and unambiguous. The Government have not hesitated to take effective action against such groups immediately it became clear that such action was necessary in order to deal effectively with them.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

At 11 of the general elections held in this country during the past 40 years, Fianna Fáil have been returned to office and anybody who cares to study the record will see clearly that when private armies appeared on the scene, it was not from Fianna Fáil they originated or from whom they drew their support.

Comment on this

They attended some of the funerals.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Successive Fianna Fáil Governments, including the present Government, have never lacked the strength and determination or the political courage to take whatever steps were necessary to protect the State and its institutions and to uphold its laws. I would remind Fine Gael that the preservation of the rule of law is not something which was invented by them or which is their sole prerogative. It is time they stopped pretending it was. Of course, Deputy L'Estrange is one of the great defenders of the institutions. Regularly he alleges that the Government are not doing enough but I would like to ask this great caller-of-bluff what more would he or his Party do.

The use of violence for any political purpose was condemned rightly on all sides during the course of the debate. In this part of my contribution I propose to direct my remarks to those who are pursuing violent means in the cause of Irish unity in the North of Ireland. However, in referring to them, I do not wish in any way to suggest that they are the only ones who are engaged in violence. I would ask those people who seek to unite Ireland by violence if they really want a united Ireland. Do they know what a united Ireland means? Do they not realise that a united Ireland means a united Irish population? Not only are the perpetrators of violence driving the population further apart but they are putting off further the day of reconciliation. Also, they are playing into the hands of the extreme and militant Unionists.

These Unionists are represented on such bodies as the UDA who, as the IRA know well, will exploit every situation for their own ends, the principal one of which is continued Unionist domination and continued suppression of the minority, for example, as we saw on Sunday week last, the denial of houses to those who were justly and legally entitled to them. If those people who use that violence stop and think they must arrive at the same conclusion at which any objectively minded person would arrive; or, if they have arrived at this conclusion, are they, instead, coldly, calculatedly and deliberately trying to drive the North into full-scale civil war? If that is the case they are flying in the face of reason and in the face of the great majority of those whom they purport to protect, those whose yearning for peace has been manifested many times. They refused to listen to the women whose homes they say they protect, the women-for-peace who, with their families, have to bear the agony, the suffering and, indeed, bereavements in their families. These women played an important part in bringing about the short-lived truce and are now desperately trying to restore it. We saw them in the precincts of this House during the week but so far as I know the people who support, guide and, perhaps, decide on the type of violence that is being carried on in the North refused to see these women.

I said yesterday that those who pursued violence should be denied support and resources. I said also that we must speak out clearly and dispel any romanticism or idealism which may surround this violence. Appeals to history or any roll call of the patriots of the past do not legitimise squalid acts of bloodshed. It is an insult to the Irish leaders of the past to link their names with these acts of violence. It is a travesty to try to equate any motives of the men and women of the 1916-21 period with the motives of those who prolong the present agony. If violence is pursued to the point of provoking civil strife in the North, I should like to tell those who do so that they need expect no support, no resources and no symathy from here or from anybody in this part of the country whom we represent in this House.

We have had our civil war. Some people in the House remember it; most of us do not, but we all know what its consequences were. Those who were involved in it on one side or another have, in the intervening 50 years, to some extent or another in one constructive way or another, contributed to the healing of the wounds, personal, mental, social and economic of the civil war. They have passed on to us a high standard of toleration—I think it is no longer necessary to make the claim that we do value toleration in this country. They have also passed on to us the true principles and practice of Republican democracy and they have given us, no matter what we say among ourselves, a sound and progressive economy.

We do not want, nor will we permit by act or omission, these wounds to be torn open again or our democratic institutions or economic structures to be torn down. The strife in the North has already caused enough economic damage not only to the people of the North but to us here also. The jobs of workers, Catholic and Protestant, in the North have been literally bombed out of existence. Industrial investment, North and South, has been retarded and the tourist trade of both parts of the country has been seriously damaged. To sum up on this, violence has destroyed jobs and job opportunities and has thereby denied thousands of ordinary men and women a decent means of livelihood both North and South.

Before I leave the subject of violence I should like to refer to the incident after the Orange parade in St. Johnston, County Donegal. I have not yet got the details or a full report of what happened there but I want to say to the people of St. Johnston, no matter what religion they profess, that adequate security forces are now available to ensure the security of their lives and their property.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

To come to the Northern subject in general, it has been suggested that I share the view— at least by implication—that we have a right here to dispose of the Northern majority over their heads in negotiation with England. Almost anything can be implied or imputed to anyone but I want to deny that allegation. It would have been considerably more useful to have described where and when I suggested anything quite so extraordinary: in fact, I have said exactly the opposite. It has also been suggested that my disapproval of a plebiscite on the Border in the North in some way contradicts the Government's policy that Irish unity is to be sought by agreement. I want to say emphatically that it does nothing of the sort.

My main objection to a plebiscite is—and I think it was stated here from the other side of the House—that it purports to give one section of the Irish people a right of decision on a question that affects the country as a whole. In so far as it is the Government's policy to seek areas of agreement between North and South which would lead by gradual stages to agreement on unity itself, it is completely consistent with this that we should oppose a step which we believe leads in exactly the opposite direction. I mentioned that I had other objections also. It is claimed, for example, that plebiscites in the North about the Border would take the issue out of Northern politics. I know of no firm foundation for such a claim; indeed I believe the opposite can be readily demonstrated. We are told that the positive reason for a plebiscite is to reassure the Northern majority. It seems to me that it is the Northern minority who have suffered most since 1920 and have suffered in the last few years, the last few months and even in the last few weeks and that the minority also—perhaps even more so —need assurance. Adequate assurances have already been given to the majority, time and again, including the assurance of my Government that our policy is to obtain Irish unity by agreement and not by force.

May I say to Deputy O'Higgins that this is no new-found policy. It is the policy of the Fianna Fáil Party and there is no member of the Fianna Fáil Party now who disagrees in one iota with that policy. Even Deputy Dr. O'Brien, when speaking today, referred to a speech by Mr. de Valera, subsequently Leader of Fianna Fáil, in the Dáil in 1921 in the Secret Debates, in which he ruled out any question of force in relation to unity in the North. That has been Fianna Fáil policy consistently since 1921. It has also been suggested, more particularly, I think, by Deputy Dr. O'Brien, that to talk about Irish unity as the only solution encourages civil war. Again, in so far as this might be imputed to me, I should prefer that the whole question to which Deputy Dr. O'Brien referred and which I have used frequently, and not only in the article in the magazine, “Foreign Affairs”, should be used. I said, and I quote:

I consider that the only solution is an Ireland united by agreement in independence.

In this connection the words "by agreement" are deliberate and meaningful. I do not believe that the idea taken as a whole should drive anyone to have recourse to arms; on the contrary, it is an invitation to the conference table.

There are others who feel that no reference should be made to unity when talking of affairs in the North. I do not share that view. It is widely known, both at home and abroad, that there is a strong desire for a united Ireland among the people of the South and amongst the great majority of the Irish people as a whole. If, then, we were to remain silent so that all references to unity were left to men of violence, this, to my mind, would be open to the dangerous interpretation that we shared not alone this goal of unity but that we were also acquiescing in the violent means being used allegedly to promote it. The sublety of silence would be lost in the clamour and confusion of the exploding bombs and the unseen bullets.

The need is to make clear that we have not as a people suddenly changed our basic attitudes and aspirations; nobody would believe us if we tried to pretend this. In the same way we do not believe, nor do we expect, the Northern people to surrender their traditions or loyalties whatever the pressures might be. Progress in understanding and in respecting one another demands that we be capable of speaking plainly and honestly when necessary and at present it is surely necessary that we should speak plainly to disassociate ourselves from violence in any form. There are also those who appear to expect that plain speaking will demand that we should attempt to set out in detail our views on the course of future progress. A leader writer in a newspaper today, it seems to me, made a suggestion of that nature.

On this I should like to say that, while it is desirable and necessary to indicate one's basic position, there is no merit in attempting to dictate the course which future events might follow. Indeed, part of the problem of the North is that there is too great a tendency already to enunciate positions from which people are unable or unwilling to depart. Progress in understanding and resolving common problems requires not alone plain speaking and honesty but, when necessary, calls also for an ability and willingness to adapt oneself to changes, changes which may necessarily form part of progress.

In this connection I claim no novelty for the suggestion I made in the course of the debate yesterday of a regional form of administration for the North of Ireland. It must now be obvious even to the most intransigent Unionists that Stormont as it has existed will not re-emerge. I envisage the regional administration emerging only after discussions between the interests concerned. While a necessary preliminary must be reconciliation, I have said again and again that the interests I have in mind are the legitimate representatives of both Northern communities and the representatives of the Governments in Dublin and Westminster.

I would be prepared now or next week or as soon as ever possible to take part in such discussions, but I believe that to take a rigid position in advance of these discussions would prejudice even their being started. The minority in the North will not accept Government by Unionists and this cannot be reimposed on the situation. They demand, and must be guaranteed, the right to work peacefully towards Irish unity. On the other hand, there is no intention—and may I repeat it again and again—of imposing unity on the majority of the North by force. The British Government have inferred that they will not stand in the way of unity between North and South. For my part I have suggested that they should go further and encourage such an agreement rather than obstruct that agreement by policies that I believe are not intended to have that effect.

Within these considerations it should not be beyond the wit and skill of political leadership in the North, in London and here to consult together to find a means of eliminating the violence, of creating a regional administration in the North from which no options are excluded and of moving in the direction of a permanent accommodation in the country as a whole. Time is not on the side of peace. We must move quickly and convincingly in the time we have left.

Deputy O'Higgins, whose speech we heard a few minutes ago, tried to disparage the capacity and capability of the members of this Government, individually and collectively. Others have tried to do it too, but I would say to Deputy O'Higgins and Fine Gael that, man for man, Minister for shadow Minister, we are prepared to match them at any time, and we will be here a long time. However, I shall come back to this in another way in a few minutes. He made allegations, first of all, that we had no policy that would bind us, that our actions are the result of ad hoc policies dictated by bureaucrats, that even the thoughts in our speeches are formulated and our speeches themselves written on our behalf. If that is the case, the people of Ireland must be very guillible indeed because we have proceeded in the present Government as Fianna Fáil have done for the past 40 years.

Deputy O'Higgins said we have no policy that will bind us together. This is an interesting remark coming from Deputy O'Higgins who is a member of a party whose policy changed, not only from general election to general election, but from by-election to by-election. But what are the prospects for a policy that will bind the new-found coalition together? I noticed nothing in Deputy O'Higgins's speech that would indicate that they in Fine Gael were ready, willing and able to form a one-party Government, a very notable omission. Of course it is hardly surprising, in that, as soon as Deputy Corish said his party were prepared to go into coalition, Deputy Cosgrave described it as a dramatic development —dramatic, I suppose, because there at last he saw a chance of Fine Gael getting back into Government, realising they could not do it alone, realising that the people of Ireland had rejected them as a single party so often that they now must have recourse to the Labour Party. I said in a television or radio interview subsequently that we have always said that it is before, and not after, an election that the people should be told of the imminence of a coalition. But that is not enough. That suggested coalition should formulate its policies before the election.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach would like that?

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

We would like that. Obviously that snide remark indicates that we are not going to get it. If we do not, the people will deal with them very readily.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil have no policy at all before an election.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Deputy O'Higgins had the gall to say that we had established here no decent social welfare standards. I am not the oldest Member of the House but I remember well that when the late Bill Norton brought in a comprehensive Social Welfare Bill it was strangled and choked by Fine Gael and it was left to the incoming Fianna Fáil Government to implement it.

Comment on this

The only decent piece of legislation that was ever brought in. Fianna Fáil never brought in anything.

Comment on this

Are Fianna Fáil hacks in the Gallery entitled to clap?

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

It is not the first time we heard a clap in the Gallery.

Comment on this

You will stand for what you think the people will fall for.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Deputy O'Higgins went on to say—and this is something that needs to be mentioned—that Fianna Fáil is supported by big business.

Comment on this

TACA.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Of course we get subscriptions from substantial firms.

Comment on this

Why do you not publish them?

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I shall give Deputy Desmond this little bit of information. Some of these same firms sent us reasonably substantial cheques during the last referendum campaign and told us at the same time they were giving similar cheques to the other main party that was supporting us in the referendum.

Comment on this

Publish your list.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I am not saying who these people were but I am sure Deputy Cosgrave knows who they were because I have no doubt that he was told, as I was, that they were sending a cheque for a similar amount in the other direction.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Is there anything wrong or to be ashamed of in people who can afford it subscribing to the political party or regime they think best fitted for the administration of the country's affairs?

Comment on this

What about Paul Singer? He got away with £1 million because he subscribed handsomely at that time. The Attorney General let him out because he subscribed handsomely.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order. Could we have the Taoiseach's speech without interruption?

Comment on this

He is sunning himself now where the Taoiseach would like to be and would be inside of the next month only for the elections.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I shall deal with that in a second.

Comment on this

You will not be able to go to Majorca for your holidays this year.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I was never in Majorca in my life and I propose to spend any holidays that I get in my own country.

Comment on this

We will keep you here.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Deputy O'Higgins was generous to me. I paced my speech on the assumption that he would take up his full time. I have just a few remarks left and I do not want to keep the House very long. Normally at this time of the year when we adjourn for the summer recess we do not expect to see each other perhaps for about ten weeks. I have given an assurance already that, should the situation warrant it, I will remain in touch with the leaders of the Opposition parties to see whether the recall of the Dáil will be necessary.

However, in beginning of the period of recess we will be seeing a lot of each other. In the next two or three weeks in the mid-Cork by-election we will see much of each other. I will not make much of a point of the fact that Fine Gael produced that motion the other day but, when they produced it, they thought we would run away from it.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Only the motion was put down there would be no election.

Comment on this

You are running away.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

It is not in the character or tradition of Fianna Fáil to run away from things like that or from any challenge that is presented to them.

Comment on this

You ran as hard as you could for as long as you could.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Those who sit behind me, and they were here in great numbers on Wednesday, had no idea what I was going to say in response to Fine Gael.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Only the motion was put down there would be no by-election.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Their reaction to what I said to Fine Gael shows the determination that Fianna Fáil will face up to any challenge that Fine Gael or anybody puts up to them.

Comment on this

Where are the dissidents? Where is Haughey? You sent him to America to have him out of the way because it did not suit him to vote for you and he did not want to vote against you.

Comment on this

Where is Boland now?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will Deputies please allow the Taoiseach to speak?

Comment on this

You told us that Deputy Moran was seriously ill when you were sacking him. He is in the best of health. There is nothing bothering him. I wish I was in as good health as he is.

Comment on this

I think the Taoiseach should let Deputy L'Estrange reply to this debate.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

He was seriously ill at that time.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I was referring to the reaction behind me. Anybody observing the reaction over there will know exactly the spirit in which they are going into the by-election. I did not intend to move the writ until the autumn.

Comment on this

The holidays were all arranged.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I candidly admit that I did not intend to move the writ until the autumn because I expected another by-election. As Deputies opposite know, we in the Government party have to keep our Deputies here to maintain the business of the House while Opposition Deputies are free to go to any part of their constituency they like. Now, for the first time, we can meet you on level ground as far as personnel is concerned.

Comment on this

With all the Ministers' cars behind you.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

We will beat you despite all the cars. You are the outsiders.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

If what Deputy L'Estrange is now professing represents the ordinary observer's view, that we are the outsiders, let me say: "We will see."

Comment on this

We have not got the protection of the cars.

Comment on this

Now the round up of the reverend mothers begins.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 67
·
Níl 64
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?