We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

County Management (Amendment) Bill, 1972: Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 163–331 of 331. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill County Management (Amendment) Bill, 1972
Enacted

No. 27 of 1972 ›

I wish to put a few matters straight. Recently in County Dublin five rate collectors were appointed.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

Six.

Comment on this

Yes, six to be specific. Prior to the appointment of these rate collectors, the posts were advertised.

The number of applications received was 120. Some of these people had no chance of being appointed, others had a slight chance and some were members of various organisations: some were members of either Fine Gael, Labour or Fianna Fáil and these were the people who were regarded as having the best chance of appointment. These applicants applied in good faith and were under the impression that by applying formally they would be granted an interview on the basis of which they would be considered for appointment. They understood that their applications would be considered, too, on the basis of their qualifications and having regard to the areas from which they came. However, that was not the case. The appointments were made as a result of overnight collaboration between Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

That agreement was there for years.

Comment on this

The appointments were made on the basis of the representation of both these parties on the council. That, of course, left the Labour Party out in the cold. It is regrettable that politics should be brought to such a low level. Some of the Fianna Fáil appointees were not even members of the local cumann or of the organisation at all, but their fathers happened to be the secretaries of local comhairle ceanntair or they had relatives who were very friendly with local councillors. It was a case of "You scratch my back and I will scratch yours". It is rarely I get up and say newspapers were telling the truth but the articles in The Sunday Press and in the evening papers with regard to this matter were certainly telling the truth in all that they had to say about the appointment of rate collectors at that particular time. That was one scandal that called for nationwide publicity.

It has been said that rate collectors should be familiar with the particular areas to which they are appointed, that they should know the people and their financial position and should be able to deal with the farmers. For the record, three of the individuals appointed on that occasion did not even know the areas of north or south County Dublin. None had ever stood in a farmyard except, perhaps, to collect the Christmas turkey by way of bonus. Nevertheless these were appointed. Everyone knows Dublin County Council were most embarrassed because of these particular appointments. The embarrassment was not caused because of the collaboration; it was caused by the fact that only six could be appointed and, six having been appointed, a great many members of the organisation were left out. Needless to say this must have prompted the Minister, as well as what I mentioned earlier, to bring in this legislation. I agree the legislation is necessary because, if it does not solve the problem of preventing a split in some Fianna Fáil organisation in County Dublin, it will certainly solve the problem of county councillors being committed to endorsing the appointments made by people who are their seniors on the council and who tell them that their job is to vote for a particular individual for a rate collectorship: you do that or you get out. The screws are put on and councillors have to do what they are told or get out.

These individuals will now become redundant and that will not be before its time. The Minister said quite rightly that the appointment would be made by the manager. I have not always had co-operation from the manager of either Dublin city or county, but I will say that he will certainly not be "got at" in the same way as members of the county council were got at. I am not saying they got cheque book endorsements for their efforts, but they lived well afterwards and their appointees are still trying to make up the ground they lost as a result of their appointments.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

Poor Deputy Burke.

Comment on this

This kind of thing must be stopped. It should be brought to the notice of people generally because public representatives are increasingly getting themselves a very bad name and this, in turn, reflects on local authorities and gets them a very bad name. Irrespective of their abilities, rate collectors in the past have been appointed because of their existing or promised support of a particular political organisation. Neither Fianna Fáil nor Fine Gael are without sin in this regard.

This applies to a very small extent to Labour in County Dublin because they are in a minority and were left out in the cold, and that was unjust; but collaboration in the appointment of the chairman of the county council is something with which I entirely disagree and that disagreement has been responsible in some small measure for having me sitting now on this side of the House. My senior colleague at the time, who was alleged to have more knowledge and more ability in dealing with local affairs, thought it was right to collaborate with the Fine Gael Party so that the Chair could be switched about and the Labour Party left out in the cold.

Comment on this
Frank Carter Acting Chairman (Mr. Carter) Fianna Fáil

The Deputy will come to the Bill now.

Comment on this

Just hold on.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Deputy will please come to the Bill.

Comment on this

I will. Do not get excited.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Deputy has concentrated sufficiently on that aspect.

Comment on this

I will come to the Bill. This is all relevant to the Bill. The individuals involved in the appointments of rate collectors have the same sins to answers for in regard to appointments on Dublin County Council and if these sins are applicable in one direction——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

This Bill has nothing to do with the election of chairmen of county councils. Would the Deputy please deal with the Bill?

Comment on this

I yield to your request. What I am trying to suggest is that this kind of collusion in Dublin County Council should be stopped. To emphasise that I had to widen the range a little in order to show that that type of collusion is both unwarranted and unnecessary. The Minister pinpointed the problem. This kind of thing has got a certain amount of publicity. Forgiveness for the sins that have been committed cannot be offered at this particular stage and the only way in which to deal with the situation is to take them out of purgatory now, though I believe that those who selected those rate collectors in Dublin County Council can never be forgiven.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

The Donegal one came after that. Tell us about that.

Comment on this

Everyone can speak for himself. I am glad the Minister has taken the initiative during his term of office, however long or short it may be, to bring in this Bill. This will save everybody embarrassment. It will ensure that justice is done. Some people have alleged that they might not have faith in the managers. That causes me to wonder somewhat because the majority of the managers were appointed by the Local Appointments Commissions. Everyone of them was scrutinised and interviewed and the scrutiny was both searching and strenuous. If people have not faith in this type of individual they will not have faith in a county council. A person who has no voice in the matter could not give a fair judgement in the appointment of a rate collector.

I have every faith in county managers. I do not say that every single one of them has committed the same offences as are associated with councillors regarding the appointment of rate collectors. Managers are responsible for their deeds whereas the 15 or 16 members on a council are individually responsible for nothing.

The Minister's suggestion that the appointment should be made by the county manager gets my full endorsement. I say to him, thank Heavens he has brought in this Bill and had the initiative to see that the type of collaboration which has gone on can be stopped and I say also, thank Heavens that Dublin County Council and the Fianna Fáil organisation and the Fine Gael organisation in Dublin County Council will not have to come together again to appoint rate collectors pro rata on a party basis. We can look forward to the appointment of rate collectors on the basis of ability and local knowledge and can be assured that they have been fairly selected and not by way of political persuasion.

Comment on this

The measure before the House deals with the system of collecting rates. Changes are suggested. I have been a member of a local authority for many years and I have a view with regard to the collection of rates which I have firmly held for more than 20 years. The system that I favour has been in operation in County Cork and has been working efficiently and well. It is the system of office collection. Members of the staff of the authority collect the rates. I am very much in favour of that system. That is not to say that I in any way reflect on rate collectors as a body. They had a difficult job to perform in years gone by when money was scarce and rate collection was not a very popular job. They had to press for payment by persons who were experiencing difficulty in meeting their rate commitments. The rate collectors generally did a reasonably good job and are doing it but in my view the need for that system no longer exists.

It was agreed in Cork almost 20 years ago that the rates would be collected by the office. That agreement was reached on the basis that it would be a cheaper method and that the approach to rate collection would be uniform. Naturally, individual collectors differed in their methods of collection whereas a central collecting body usually can bring about uniformity of approach. That system was continued for a number of years and then, due to heavy pressures on members of the council, some seven or eight years ago the system was changed to allow of four appointments being made. At that time I opposed the change as vehemently as possible. I have no fault to find with the authority's right to make that decision. The majority on the council were legally entitled to come to that decision and to make appointments in accordance with law.

My view on this Bill is that it should not be a question of changing the system of appointments; it should be a question of changing the system of collection. If I had my way I would strongly favour the system of collection through the office and make that applicable to every local authority. That would not interfere with existing rate collectors. The present system could be phased out according as rate collectors would retire. I have made myself clear and the records of Cork County Council indicate what my view has been. Having said all that, may I say that I am not at all satisfied with what is embodied in the Minister's statement or with his hypothesis. As Simon Pure he states that everything will be fair and impartial and that Fianna Fáil want to appoint people on merit. Everybody knows that Fianna Fáil do not believe in appointing people on merit. The main qualification Fianna Fáil seek in the matter of appointments is political allegiance. It is hypocrisy for the Minister to state as he did:

It is, as I have said, my view that appointments of county rate collectors should be made strictly on the basis of merit and I fell the time is now opportune to make the change and that it should be made as soon as possible.

I will deal with that statement in a few moments. Of course, I am well aware of the Government's continuing efforts to whittle away the powers of locally elected members of councils. Members of councils are elected in the same way as Members of this House are elected, by the vote of the electorate, and can be removed from office periodically when the people get the opportunity to remove them. That is entirely different from the case of executive staffs who cannot be removed from office except in exceptional circumstances.

The Minister said that he would like to see appointments made on merit. How many more appointments would he like to see on merit? Is the rule that is to be applied to rate collectors to be applied generally in other areas? As a Deputy asked, are the Judiciary to be appointed on merit in future? Are State prosecutors to be appointed on merit? Are State solicitors to be appointed on merit? Are postmasters, sub-postmasters and post office staff generally to be appointed on merit? These appointments, are more important than the appointments of rate collectors. Are Fianna Fáil candidates in future to stop saying and implying when canvassing votes that if the voter votes for them they may be able to get help them, they may be able to get Johnny or Mary a job? Will they stop saying: "If you join the cumann you will have a better chance of getting a grant"? The manner in which grants are disbursed at present is scandalous. It is a well known fact that preferential treatment is given to supporters of the Government. There is this kind of a Simon Pure attitude in regard to this group of appointments of rate collectors. Who will answer that question? I dislike mentioning these facts here but a possible answer is that the Government are entitled to have certain gifts to bestow on their friends, certain rights in making appointments. Under the Constituation they say they must appoint the Judiciary but there is nothing to preclude the Government from setting up a commission, in the same way as county managers are allegedly appointed by county councils, and getting the commission to recommend a particular nominee for a post. The Government's say would then be purely formal. In Ireland we do not act impartially and at present appointments to very important posts in different fields are not made impartially over a wide area.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

This Bill deals specifically with one range of appointments in local authorities and the discussion may not be widened.

Comment on this

With respect, I think it is quite in order to make comparisons between the type of appointments under discussion and other types.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

It is not so much what the Deputy may think; it is what is in the Bill.

Comment on this

I think I have made my point reasonably well. In regard to the system which applies here we got great insight into what happens from Deputy Foley. I do not want to reflect on councillors in any county because I could not substantiate any charge from my own personal knowledge but, speaking as a Labour Member, I think the Deputy summed up our position reasonably well when he said that Labour was out in the cold as regards appointments under the present system. That is generally correct: few Labour men can hope to get appointments by votes of councils when we have not sufficient representation, but that is not my reason for criticising the system that exists. If the majority of members of a council decide to act within the law I respect their decision. That is what the Dáil are doing. A slight majority of elected Members of the House gave Fianna Fáil preference in the last election and they are acting accordingly.

As regards the rate collectors I do not want to repeat how I think rates should be collected. I am not in favour of this proposal. However, I do not want to have this Simon Pure attitude that because Fianna Fáil have lost in the last election control of a number of councils business is not now so good, and possibly in councils where they hold control it is difficult to satisfy the contenders in their own party for selection, that the present system has outlived its usefulness and therefore should be abolished. Deputy Foley told us something about Dublin County Council and he was probably correct in his appraisal of what happened there. I accept the appointments were made by Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael at meetings held prior to the ordinary council meeting where such appointments were to be determined. Significance should be placed on Deputy Foley's comments; he is a long standing member of the Fianna Fáil Party and he has told us that, when they were unable because of lack of votes to get their own men nominated in Dublin, his former senior colleague made overtures to Fine Gael and between them they scooped the pool so that others, including anybody with Labour affiliations, seemingly had little or no chance.

However, these appointments were made in the open; people knew what was happening. If the councillors were wrong, people know what happened and if the people of Dublin county dislike the manner in which their councillors are acting they will have an opportunity, possibly in the next 12 months, of saying so through the ballot boxes and of removing them from office. I make this statement on the remarks of Deputy Foley that they were "got at". How does one define "got at"? Is it not the normal practice when seeking election to this House that we try to pressurise people into voting for us and our parties, that we go out and ask them to do so and indicate that we can do a better job than the other parties? Is that not normal procedure in a democracy? Where appointments are made, as rate collecting appointments were made up to now on a voting system, there is nothing wrong in an individual applicant trying to further his application. I understand that serious allegations are being made here that this was done by understand methods. I believe when such allegations are made by a Member of the House in a privileged position he should elaborate and if, as alleged, corruption existed he should expose it.

The question of an alternative system arises. We all know what happens at a council meeting but nobody knows, perhaps, what would happen at the alternative meeting suggested by the Minister in this Bill. Are we to assume that all appointments are made fairly and impartially, that everything is above board in all the local authorities and in State appointments and that interview boards act with absolute impartiality? I have spent 25 years in public life but I do not make all those assumptions. Even assuming that everything was not satisfactory in the appointment of rate collectors, the same could be said about other systems of appointment. There are men of the highest integrity in the public service and I have no doubt they discharge their duty admirably and impartially, but that may not be the position in all cases.

The Minister stated: "As things now stand there is scope for canvassing and unreasonable pressures may be exerted on elected members." I remember when Fianna Fáil tried to get back into power in 1951 and it could be stated that then they exerted pressure. They put pressure—I do not know if it was reasonable or unreasonable—on the four Independent Members who elected them in 1951. It was the joke of the country. Everyone here saw the poor Members being followed around the place and we all knew that the Government were formed as a result of pressure. When turnover tax was introduced pressure was used. Do Fianna Fáil exert undesirable pressures? Coming from the Government, the language used in this instance is hypocritical.

Is this a new game in the Dáil? Will the Government make changes with regard to other appointments? The Government dislike the elected members of local authorities having the right to make appointments. Will the Government hand over their rights to a commission? The Government are notorious for handing over matters to commissions, not only to Irish commissions but to foreign ones. We had McKinsey telling us how local government should be restructured; we asked a group called Markpress to tell us how to advertise Ireland; there was a commission to report on the pay structure of Members of this House and others outside——

Comment on this
Augustine Healy Acting Chairman (Mr. Healy) Fianna Fáil

I would ask the Deputy to refrain from broadening the scope of debate on this Bill. The Deputy should confine his remarks to the Bill and to its implications. He should not extend it to the ramifications of the State.

Comment on this

We are appointing commissions to examine the reports of commissions.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Bill has nothing to do with commissions. I have asked the Deputy to confine his remarks to the Bill.

Comment on this

Is this the forerunner of a changed structure so far as appointments generally are concerned? Are we to assume that in the legal field there will be a change? Will it be necessary to be a member of a cumann, or possibly a Deputy, as happened in other instances, in order to get a senior appointment on the bench or as a State solicitor? We are told that with regard to the appointment of rate collectors the system was rotten and it was time to change it. It is implied in the Minister's statement that it is the only system that needs change. Will an independent authority examine the claims of people who require development grants and will there be an impartial system to determine whether their application will be approved? Will an impartial system be set up to determine other public and Government appointments?

As the Chair seems to be under the impression that I am extending the scope of the debate, I do not propose to dwell on the matter further as we will have other opportunties to do this. However, I resent the hyprocrisy of the statement made by the Minister. The Government are trying to pretend they are not guilty and that everything is fair and above-board in State affairs. It is no pleasure for me or for any Member to cast aspersions on public administration but this is the place to give viewpoints and to make a factual appraisal of the situation.

I would appeal to the Minister but I realise that appeals from the Opposition to the Government are never heard or heeded. However, many years after an appeal is made occasionally it is acted on. Can the Minister tell me if it is possible to have rates throughout the country collected through the offices? I see that Deputy Burke has returned. It is regrettable he was not here earlier because we had a glowing account from a junior colleague of his of how the Deputy does his job on the Dublin County Council.

I do not wish to cast any aspersions on the collectors who have been doing their job. They have a difficult job to do but they carry it out admirably and efficiently. However, it has been my belief that office collection would ensure more uniformity and this would be an advantage. Different methods are applied by different collectors; some are more lenient than others but on the whole it would be preferable to have uniformity in the method of collection.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

I am glad to see that Fianna Fáil intend to change the system of appointment of rate collectors but surely we cannot be blamed on this side of the House if we begin to wonder and ask why this belated conversion of Fianna Fáil. Down through the years Fianna Fáil have held sway on a great many of our county councils. They have taken full advantage of this in appointing rate collectors. There are different systems which can be employed for the collection of rates. We could continue to use the present system which I think nobody advocates. If there is to be a change it could be arranged that the city manager would appoint a commission to appoint rate collectors as envisaged in the Minister's proposal. We could also have the system of the Local Appointments Commission making the appointments, as suggested by Deputy T.J. Fitzpatrick. I think this would prove to be a better and a fairer system. I cannot at all agree with the suggestion in the Minister's speech that while some of the major appointments should be made by the Local Appointments Commission smaller appointments could not very effectively be made by that commission because of their local character and the necessity of having local knowledge. This could easily be overcome by having a condition of residence over a number of years and making it necessary that the applicants should furnish particulars of their knowledge of the area. This is not of great magnitude and could easily be overcome.

Another method which could be adopted is that of direct payment to the office. The Minister must concede it is a compliment to certain councils where Fianna Fáil have not got a majority but other parties have the majority and could appoint rate collectors of their own choice, if they so wished, that they have refrained from doing this. In Cork they could appoint rate collectors but they have retained the system of collecting rates through the office. This has also happened in Counties Westmeath and Kerry. The Minister will agree that the councillors in those areas have not tried to take advantage of their superior numbers over Fianna Fáil. They have not tried to select their own people.

Deputy Foley was very critical of recent happenings in Dublin County Council in connection with the appointment of rate collectors. I do not intend to go deeply into that but on a previous occasion members of Dublin County Council, the majority of them being against the Fianna Fáil Party, appointed a well-known and prominent member of the Fianna Fáil Party as rate collector. I am not saying he was not entitled to be appointed if he was the best man but they did not take advantage of their superior numbers to get the position for themselves.

I was beginning to think that there was some hope of Fianna Fáil doing the right thing in this House when they announced that after long agitation they had decided to change the method of planning appeals to the Minister. For many years it had been in the hands of the Minister himself but now they had agreed that it should be subject to a commission. In this Bill they seem to be doing quite the reverse and the reverse of what Deputy Fitzpatrick had asked them to do. They are vesting in one man the power to appoint rate collectors. It would be fairer to have a commission and it would not be placing complete responsibility on or giving full power to one individual. If this plan envisaged by the Minister would result in a saving there might be some merit in it.

He has not indicated to us that he has given any consideration to the method of collecting rates through the offices. Several Deputies have stated that they have practical experience of having rates collected through the offices in their counties as effectively as if rate collectors were employed, and at a much cheaper rate. Surely in this day and age with rising costs, the Minister should give serious consideration to this matter. If rates can be collected as effectively and at a cheaper rate, surely he should try to save even a small sum.

I do not know that the system envisaged by the Minister, whereby the manager will appoint a commission to select rate collectors, will take local knowledge into account. In Dublin city, rate collectors are appointed from the existing staff. I do not think one of the conditions is that whatever member of the staff is being appointed must have a thorough knowledge of the area to which he is being appointed. They are doing their job very effectively and very well. We have two systems in Dublin city and Dublin county. Deputy Burke has experience of both the city and the county. He has been a member of both local authorities and I think he will agree that the rate collectors in Dublin county are doing an equally good job. While I do not agree with the method of selection employed heretofore, and while it probably led to certain mal-practices, I do not think it is as bad as some people would lead you to believe.

The Minister said that before he decided to bring in this Bill he consulted with many people, including councillors.

Comment on this

I did not say that. I did not use the word "consult".

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): His phraseology was very careful.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

The Minister said:

I had the matter further considered and in the light of views submitted by many people, including councillors...

Comment on this

I did not consult.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

Views were submitted by many people, including councillors.

Comment on this

Anybody was free to submit his views.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

I should like the Minister to tell us who the people were and who the councillors were. Was this solely confined to councillors of one party, or did he get views from councillors of different parties? What type of people were in consultation with him? Were they members of his own party, or members of the general public, or members of other political parties? The Minister should be a little more specific about this and let us know what people and what councillors submitted views to him.

In his anxiety to agree with the method envisaged by the Minister for collecting the rates, Deputy Foley made an excellent case when he said the county manager was the ideal person because he had been examined and appointed by the Local Appointments Commission and that the Local Appointments Commission, having inquired into every aspect of his career, had found that he was a fit and proper person. If the Local Appointments Commission, in Deputy Foley's words, succeeded in getting the very best person as county manager, surely they are quite capable of finding the most suitable person to be a rate collector.

I do not think the Minister is doing himself any good by advocating that this power should be vested in the city or county manager. Because of the structure of local authorities, practically everything done by a local authority is subject to the Minister's sanction. Therefore, the Minister and the manager must be in close consultation. They must meet regularly. People cannot be blamed if they say at times that the Minister is influencing the city or county manager, or that the managers are influenced by the Minister. Many of those suspicions could be removed from people's minds. If there is in a system the slightest taint of suspicion, to use a term employed by the Taoiseach, that system should not be used. I am sure the Minister will admit that there is just as good a chance of getting the right person selected as a rate collector by allowing the Local Appointments Commission to appoint him, as there is by allowing the city or county manager to make the appointment. This would remove any suspicion of undue influence being used.

For many years local authorities have been jealous of their powers being taken away from them and extra powers being granted to the managers. The fact that the Minister is taking away power from elected representatives on the one hand is bad enough, but at the same time he is granting extra powers to the managers, thereby widening the gap in respect of the extent of power vested in the elected representatives and that vested in the managers. This will not lead to harmonious relationships between the elected representatives and the managers. This measure will not result in any saving in expense and will not make for better relations between managers and elected representatives and the suggestion might be made that undue influence could be used by the Minister or by his Department in respect of a manager appointing a person whom he considered suited best for the post. Therefore, this measure is not solving any problem. Rather, it will create extra problems.

Comment on this

It was not my intention to intervene in this debate but I understand that in Deputy Foley's address to the House there were certain inferences regarding my colleagues in Dublin County Council. I have not got a copy of the Deputy's speech but I hope to be able to read it after I move the adjournment of the debate.

When the appointments to which Deputy Foley referred were made I was in hospital suffering from double pneumonia. However, I must say that all those men on Dublin County Council who were associated with the appointments are honourable men and if there was an agreement reached between Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil, it was reached honourably. Obviously, I could not have been present at the meeting when the decisions were made but Mr. Joseph MacAnthony who was rejected twice by the electorate of County Dublin made much play of that meeting and he blackguarded me in every way possible. The electorate of County Dublin have been returning me to this House for almost 29 years.

At that meeting of the county council the Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael members voted for three appointments on each side. There was no influence one way or the other. I have been chairman of the county council on two occasions so I am in a position to speak for the members. It is my duty to defend them here regardless of whether they are for me or against me.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Is the Deputy aware that questions are not being taken until 3 p.m.?

Comment on this

I thought they were being taken at 2.30 and that I would then have an opportunity of reading Deputy Foley's speech. It is a dastardly situation that anyone should come here and use this House for the purpose of impugning any of these honourable men. In regard to the decisions reached I found it embarrassing that about 30 of the applicants were political friends of mine but that, of course, only three of those could be appointed. The same applies to Fine Gael. One of the most difficult tasks for a man in public life is to have to decide on matters such as this.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): There is no scarcity of friends on an occasion like that.

Comment on this

I agree and the problem is that in retaining the friendship of three people, one would be creating, perhaps, 100 enemies because there were more than 200 applications for the posts. Mr. MacAnthony had the effrontery to imply that there was something wrong in three Fine Gael and three Fianna Fáil supporters being appointed.

Anything done at county council level is above board and open to criticism whereas anything done behind doors by, for instance, a city or county manager, cannot be questioned. I have never known anybody who did not have likes and dislikes regardless of what position he might hold. My only objection to the system of appointments in operation up to now is that a public representative makes more enemies than friends in respect of appointments.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): There was a net loss of votes in the whole operation. Is that not the point?

Comment on this

I agree and there was much pressure on Deputies during that period. So far as Dublin County Council are concerned it is very wrong for anyone to imply that there was anything wrong or that there was any reward in respect of any appointments. I defend categorically all the members of the council, regardless of which party they represent. Any member that has ever been appointed to Dublin County Council, and I include in that members who were appointed long before my time there, have done a good job. The fact that a person might have many letters after his name would not convince me in the least that he would make a good rate collector. Somebody who would have the right approach and who would be prepared to speak to the people in a humane way would be the best person for the job, who will say to Johnny Murphy, or whoever it may be: "Give me what you can. Do what you can for me. I will not injure you." That is the type of human being we have appointed. Going back 40 years in Dublin County Council I can safely say that no appointee has ever let us down. A few appointed by another agency did let us down. The man who is appointed by the county council is always a good man, a man who is loyal to and commands the loyalty of those who vote for him. All our rate collectors in County Dublin are men of the highest integrity. As far as the councillors are concerned, I have yet to meet the man who would give his vote for any consideration other than loyalty to his own party and to the person for whom he votes. He will not allow himself to be influenced by somebody whom the people twice rejected. I am sorry to have to say that here, but I have to say it because of the allegations made by a man who was once a colleague of mine but is now an Independent.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): He might be back with the Deputy soon.

Comment on this

I will not tolerate anybody impugning any colleague of mine, no matter what his views are. I am sorry I have not got a copy of Deputy Foley's speech so that I could deal with it as drastically as it deserves, but there will be another day on which I will do that. Like Deputy Fitzpatrick, I do not approve of this House being used to the disadvantage of anybody else, and I will always defend the people I work with, irrespective of their political affiliations. I respect them as decent, honourable men. That is what my colleagues in Dublin County Council are. Not one would do a dishonourable act for reward. I say that in all seriousness.

Dublin County Council has never acted dishonourably and it is because they refused to act dishonourably that we have this Bill before the House today. The Bill will remove a great deal of responsibility from us. We appointed six rate collectors in County Dublin. At the time they were appointed I was ill, but I know that the appointments were made honourably. My only regret was that we could not appoint all the applicants. We could appoint only three and, from that point of view, we lost out politically. But the decision was an honourable one. There was no promise of reward to anyone. They were appointed because they were the best. Even though I was not there I take full responsibility with my colleagues for these appointments.

Deputy Fitzpatrick has recommended an alternative way out. I have to support my colleague, the Minister for Local Government, in this.

Comment on this

Deputy Burke talked about gentlemen in Dublin. It is good to know that there are some gentlemen somewhere who have a grievance. There are a number of gentlemen in my county. The Minister has been a county councillor in Galway. Deputy Hussey is a county councillor.

Comment on this

I am proud of it.

Comment on this

I had great respect for Deputy Hussey always. This Bill is an open confession by the Minister that the time has come when jobs for the boys are running out and the boys are now running out of the party because there are not enough jobs to go around. I can remember a caucus meeting when the present Minister was a county councillor. The councillors trailed in through the door at 25 minutes past three like a bunch of sheep; they had been brainwashed and told exactly what they had to do. It is as a result of that that we have this Bill before the House. We have reached the stage at which Fianna Fáil are losing out, especially in my county. We put people forward who had never been members of any party; we put them forward because they were men fit for the job. What happened? They got nowhere. But I knew Fianna Fáil to put some hacks forward who subsequently turned out utterly unfit for the job.

Comment on this

That is cherishing all the children of the nation equally.

Comment on this

It may be, but some are more equal than others. When we, in my party, discovered what had happened we brought a High Court action and, in spite of the Minister at the time, we got the appointment for the right candidate. The office method collection has been mentioned. There are certain aspects of that method about which I am not satisfied. A rate collector has other duties to perform, such as the compilation of the register. I do not know how the office method would work in that respect. I have known how it has worked over the years. I have known some great Fine Gael supporters ticked off the register by the appointees of Fianna Fáil. Electors have had a vote for years and have not left their address and have found that their names were not on the register. The "boys" were working on the list.

It has been suggested that the county managers should make the appointments. I do not think county managers want this kind of work. There are county managers who support Fianna Fáil and there are county managers who support Fine Gael. Irrespective of what Government are in power, county managers should not be in the position that pressure could be put on them in regard to appointments. The Local Appointments Commission is the proper body to make the appointments.

I have witnessed over a long period the appointment of rate collectors in Galway. I have seen members of the council walking into the chamber like lads going into court to be charged with something. One man would be told to propose a candidate and another would be told to second the motion. There would be no use in proposing a candidate. The steamroller was used. I have seen some of the great henchmen of Fianna Fáil being appointed. I would remind the Minister that my people were on that county council long before he put shoes on or was out of nappies. I know the history. Deputy Hussey saw them come in there, like they did on the last day on the Oranmore question.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

It is not applicable to the Bill.

Comment on this

It is in the rate collecting area.

Comment on this

It shows Fianna Fáil corruption.

Comment on this

It shows what they do when they get their hands on anything. I know all about Oranmore.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Will the Deputy please keep to the Bill before the House?

Comment on this

Oranmore is in the catchment area where the rate would be collected. If more rates are to be collected in that area we will need a good man there. There will be a great deal of building done.

Comment on this

The Minister objected to canvassing. Who canvassed the people in regard to this venture and got them to change their vote? The Minister refused to do his duty when it went to him. It was sent back because they knew they had a majority on Galway County Council.

Comment on this

The people of Oranmore have no objection.

Comment on this

The secretary, a doctor, has called the local Fianna Fáil councillors before him to ask them why they changed their mind.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I thought the Fianna Fáil Cumann objected.

Comment on this

Who made them change their mind?

Comment on this

The Minister did it and then he objected to canvassing.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Order. Deputy Coogan on the Bill.

Comment on this

If a rate collector is to be appointed now the proposal will go back and forward, like the Oranmore matter. I am talking about the rate collectors.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I hope the Deputy is.

Comment on this

It will be like a game of ping pong. I cannot get the Minister to open his mouth. I heard he was on his feet last night.

Comment on this

The Deputy must know a few things. The Minister is keeping quiet.

Comment on this

If the appointment is to be made by the manager, the Minister will find a little fault and will send back the proposal, saying that he is not satisfied. There may be some history behind the candidate that would not suit the party. The Barna area is another area of rate collecting which received great publicity in the papers, which the Minister did not deny, in regard to the question of planning being made in a public house.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

It has nothing to do with this Bill. If the Deputy persists the Chair will ask him to resume his seat. The Deputy will keep to the Bill.

Comment on this

I have mentioned an area where rates are collected. Some people in the Barna area may not be able to afford to pay their rates and the rate collector can bring pressure on them. If people build in this area the rate collector will come down on them.

Comment on this

In Oranmore they will get a good price for their land.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy L'Estrange is not helping by interrupting.

Comment on this

I should like to hinder the Fianna Fáil Party in any way I could.

Comment on this

The Minister knows the little bits of corruption and the background there. I am sorry that the whole House cannot follow this but they will be able to do so before long. There will be another debate in this House that will expose a great many things.

Comment on this

I never saw the Minister so quiet. Whatever knowledge the Deputy has, the Minister will not talk.

Comment on this

I am sick and tired of the method adopted in Galway County Council. I have seen the henchmen outside the door in groups. They are lined up. They say, "I will do my best for you. I will do what I can".

Comment on this

And "God willing".

Comment on this

The member is not honest enough to tell the applicant that he can do nothing for him, that it will have to be done in the inner sanctum, where the decisions are taken. Deputy Hussey is a decent man and as a member of Galway County Council should be out of that room if there are any more of these appointments being made.

Comment on this

My advice to the Deputy would be to keep away from it.

Comment on this

I have always done so. The first day Deputy Hussey came in he looked to me to be a decent man. I would ask him when these appointments come up not to lend himself to this thing.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Will the Deputy keep to the Bill?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): We are discussing every county council in the country, whether we like it or not.

Comment on this

The only place in which we got an appointment on merit was the Four Courts. When Fianna Fáil had done the dirt and appointed one of their crowd who was not fit for the job, we proved in court that he was not fit. This Bill represents a bit of conscience worrying the Minister.

Comment on this

Yes, about canvassing.

Comment on this

The Minister said that the appointment of county rate collectors should be made strictly on the basis of merit. Who wrote that for the Minister? Was it one of the officials who wrote it? The Minister should have studied the script because if this were to appear in the Connacht Tribune, especially after Oranmore, it would be too bad. The Minister said: “...and for this reason I have the matter covered in a separate Bill which I now commend to the House and ask that it be dealt with as quickly as possible.” Is some rate collectorship coming up which will cause us trouble in Galway?

Comment on this

No. They have lost the majority of the county councils. They control only six now out of 27.

Comment on this

The few we have look healthy enough. Does Deputy Hussey know anything of any of them, getting a bit thin in the back of the neck or anything like that? That reminds me: there was an undertaker in our town and when he would go to church he would look at the back of a man's neck and if he saw the figure 11 come on the back of a man's neck he would talk to the wife. It is the same way now. These fellows are watching the rate collectors and if they see the figure 11 coming on the back of their necks they are already fixing up the jobs. I am only asking Deputy Hussey if there are any of them like this around.

Comment on this
A Deputy

There are a few people watching the back of the Deputy's neck and they are not rate collectors.

Comment on this

The Minister may not have the head for the job but he has the neck.

Comment on this

All good men come out on top. That is where we shine and when you are as long in this House——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Coogan should address the Chair on the Bill. He should not be diverted.

Comment on this

They tried that for a long time in my town. It would be a good thing to deal with the caucus meetings that stink in our town and to finish once and for all these men coming in groups outside the chamber. Deputy Hussey had to go through that mill also. The whip is out then and the boys move off saying they will see what they can do. They are like sheep. They are brainwashed when they go up into the inner chamber. When they come out one has been appointed as proposer and the other as seconder.

There is a certain amount of merit in the Bill but it does not go the whole way. Appointments should be made through the appointments commission because the handling of money like this is important. Other things are also involved. I point out the weaknesses in the Bill and I should like the Minister to consider the possibility of having the appointments commission make the appointment and I would also like him to let us know what snags are involved in regard to office collection. I can commend part of the Bill but I cannot go the whole way.

Comment on this

I was very amused listening to Deputy Coogan trying to make his case for the retention of the present system of rate collectors.

Comment on this

He did not.

Comment on this

I said I was very amused listening to him make a case for the retention of the present system of rate collecting because——

Comment on this

He did not do that. He said he agreed with the change but that they should be appointed by the Local Appointments Commission.

Comment on this

Yes, but what I am coming at is that down through the years in County Galway Deputy Coogan and all the other Fine Gael supporters——

Comment on this

I think the Minister might have no brain to wash either. Some of the civil servants may have no brains to wash. Some of them are there on account of their politics and they need not jibe about Members not having brains to wash. That is not the civil servant's job.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Hussey. Deputy L'Estrange should not attack any civil servant in the House.

Comment on this

No civil servant should say anything about a Member not having brains to wash. Civil servants are paid officials——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): On a point of order, I do not blame the civil servants; they are obliged to laugh when the Minister cracks a joke.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

No Deputy may attack civil servants in the House.

Comment on this

Civil servants are supposed to be above that sort of thing. Some of them would not be there only for their politics and they should not make such remarks about any Deputy.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy is accusing civil servants——

Comment on this

I heard them. I overheard the Minister and a civil servant discussing this——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy will withdraw that statement.

Comment on this

I certainly will not withdraw it. I overheard the two of them and I certainly will not withdraw it.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy will withdraw it.

Comment on this

I certainly will not withdraw it. No civil servant has authority to come in here and speak of any Fine Gael Deputy——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy will withdraw the statement.

Comment on this

He was appointed because he was a Fianna Fáil——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy will withdraw the statement.

Comment on this

I certainly will not withdraw it. I overheard them——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

If the Deputy will not withdraw the statement he will have to leave the House.

Comment on this

I certainly will not leave the House.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Assume for a moment that it did happen and suppose it was a joke——

Comment on this

It did happen.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Then is a Deputy obliged to withdraw a statement that he heard something with his own ears which did, in fact, happen? If he is compelled to withdraw that, I would, with the greatest respect, say that he would be compelled to tell a lie in the House.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy made a statement and the Chair asked him to withdraw that statement, not to attack civil servants in the House.

Comment on this

Civil servants should be neutral when they come into the House and should not make jokes at the expense of any Deputy here. I will not stand for it.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): On a point of order, may we know from the Chair exactly what he wants Deputy L'Estrange to withdraw?

Comment on this

Surely no Member is entitled to come here and suggest that a civil servant had been appointed because of his politics? It is a disgraceful statement.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

In reply to Deputy Fitzpatrick's point, if Deputy L'Estrange or any other Deputy has a complaint like this to make there is a way of making it but then it should not be made in public. Every Deputy is aware of that.

Comment on this

I have made it in public because the civil servant and the Minister were talking in public and were reflecting on a Fine Gael Deputy here and no civil servant has authority to do that and I certainly will not withdraw.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

All the Chair is pointing out to Deputy L'Estrange is that these remarks should not be made. The Chair has asked him in the ordinary way to withdraw this. There is a way in which Deputy L'Estrange can make a complaint if he wishes to do so.

Comment on this

I have no intention of withdrawing what is the truth.

Comment on this

False allegation.

Comment on this

If the official concerned and the Minister stand up and withdraw what they were saying about Deputy Coogan that would be——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Everybody knows that civil servants may not rise in this House.

Comment on this

An allegation was made by Deputy L'Estrange that civil servants attained their positions through political affiliations or influence——

Comment on this

The vast majority.

Comment on this

That is a false allegation and the Deputy should withdraw it.

Comment on this

Does the Minister deny it?

Comment on this

There is not an ounce of truth in it.

Comment on this

It certainly is true. What about the chief superintendent——

Comment on this

The Minister has not the head for the job but he has a hell of a neck for it.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy should resume his seat. In the interests of order, I suggest to Deputy L'Estrange that he should withdraw his statement and that if he wishes to make a complaint he may do so in the ordinary way.

Comment on this

I have no intention of withdrawing it unless the Minister and the official concerned withdraw what they were saying about Deputy Coogan——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair has no knowledge of that.

Comment on this

When they withdraw I shall withdraw, but not until then.

Comment on this

I did not hear it or I would be on my feet also.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair has put it to Deputy L'Estrange that in the interests of order he should withdraw this statement.

Comment on this

I have no intention of withdrawing. There is too much of that going on in this House.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy is not leaving much option to the Chair.

Comment on this

That may be so, but the official concerned and the Minister have no authority to do what they have done. I will not withdraw it because I know it to be true.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Minister might help in this. The Minister was heard from this part of the House to say that the Deputy had no brains to wash. I appreciate that was said in a jocose manner but it was said by the Minister. I did not hear anyone agreeing with it. I saw the Minister lean in that direction and say “the Deputy has no brains to wash”.

Comment on this

The civil servant said nothing.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I did not say the civil servant said anything.

Comment on this

No allegations have been made against a civil servant, then?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I would not blame a civil servant for smiling. In fact, I would not blame him for smiling at any of the bishop's jokes—it would be rather like the curate laughing at the bishop.

Comment on this

The joke is all right as long as it is on the other side.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): If the Minister would withdraw his remark I think Deputy L'Estrange would withdraw his remark and we will be all a big happy family.

Comment on this

I submit that it is not in order for the Minister to seek to involve civil servants in that kind of remark. The blame has been shared here——

Comment on this

I object to this implication. I made no effort to involve the civil servants in the affairs of the House.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): There is no doubt that the Minister, addressing the civil servant, said, “the Deputy has no brains to wash”. I will say this before any tribunal.

Comment on this

As the person involved, may I say that I hit the Minister and if he hits back I can take it.

Comment on this

I should like to point out that there are distinguished visitors in the House. Let us behave like adults. Surely we are all grown up?

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

Will the Minister withdraw?

Comment on this

If Deputy L'Estrange accepts the ruling of the Chair, I shall accepts the ruling of the Chair.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Is Deputy L'Estrange withdrawing his statement about a civil servant?

Comment on this

I have no intention of withdrawing a statement I believe to be true. I overheard the remarks of the Minister. The Minister has involved a civil servant.

Comment on this

Deputy L'Estrange has made a despicable allegation. If he is not prepared to withdraw it he should not be a Member of the House.

Comment on this

It is not a despicable allegation. The Minister has no authority to talk to an official and make accusations against any Deputy in this House. The Minister is not going to cast aspersions on any Fine Gael Deputy.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): On a point of order, there is no doubt that the Minister's remarks, jocose or otherwise, gave rise to this incident. In the interests of decorum, I suggest that he be man enough to withdraw and I suggest that Deputy L'Estrange should then withdraw.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

I was involved in this. I hit the Minister and he hit me.

Comment on this

Much ado about nothing.

Comment on this

The only thing I object to very strongly are the allegations made by Deputy L'Estrange against civil servants who accompanied me to the House and who have sat here for many hours listening to a debate which has largely been repetitious. Deputy Coogan made a minimal contribution to the debate; in fact, most of the contributions consisted of jokes about country councillors being brainwashed. At the conclusion of the Deputy's few words, and as an aside to the officials here who were about to leave, I said, "some of them have no brains to wash". I did not make a specific reference to Deputy Coogan or anybody else, but if any offence has been taken to the statement I made I will withdraw it.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Will Deputy L'Estrange now withdraw his remarks?

Comment on this

If the Minister has withdrawn his remark I will withdraw.

Comment on this