We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 42: Posts and Telegraphs (Resumed).

Contributions 118–248 of 248. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

I would die for the principle of freedom of the news media but I would not die for Deputy Bruton.

Comment on this

The Government set a trap for the RTE Authority. The authority were inexorably led into it. If the Government look at their relationship with the RTE Authority they will see their mounting impatience because the authority were not reflecting establishment thinking, whatever that might be. This can be traced back to the moneylending scandal and the tribunal set up. The Government were trying to get control of the television services. After that we had the softening up process which was seen in the speeches of Deputy Flor Crowley and others. The Minister knew he would get an opportunity. When requested by the RTE Authority to clarify what anybody could see was a vague directive the Minister said that he could see no point in prolonging the correspondence. He was not prepared to clarify what the directive meant. He allowed RTE to go on in the hope that the interpretation which they put on it would not be questioned. The Minister let them go ahead. When they had this interview last week the Minister stepped in and chopped them. He did not tell them beforehand what his exact interpretation of the directive was. He just let them walk into the trap set for them and then he did what Fianna Fáil had been building up to for a long time. He chopped the authority. It is important that the people on the authority should be of independent minds. No matter how independent-minded they are, they are living under the shadow of what has happened and they know what will happen if they do not do what they are told.

Comment on this

It is possible the Deputy is just giving us his opinions.

Comment on this

This is like the introduction to a comic strip.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Order. Deputy Bruton, without interruption.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair has repeatedly reminded the House that interruptions are disorderly.

Comment on this

It is worth reminding the House that the Fine Gael Party envisaged this use of the powers under section 31 by the Government for political purposes and proposed in 1968 an a amendment which would have insisted that any directive under section 31 be countersigned by one or other of the Opposition party leaders. This would have ensured that when this power was being exercised it would have been exercised genuinely in the interest of the whole community and not for party political advantage.

Comment on this

That would be an abdication of Government, in my opinion.

Comment on this

That is the Deputy's opinion. I believe that the people come before the Government and they are better represented by both sides than by one side.

Comment on this

Let the people elect the other side. The Opposition might get a surprise if the opportunity to do so arose. The Taoiseach would come back with 100 seats.

Comment on this

You did not win the Referendum on PR.

Comment on this

What about the referendum in the last six months?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Bruton to continue.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil won it and nobody else.

Comment on this

I knew Fine Gael would be taunted with that.

Comment on this

I do not know what Deputy Andrews came in here for.

Comment on this

He is not learning much.

Comment on this

I am here to confer enlightenment on Deputy Andrews and the difficulty is that he is impervious to it.

Comment on this

I will give the Deputy more enlightenment if he wants it. I am sorry for the interruption.

Comment on this

Another point which needs to be made in relation to the directive under section 31 is that there is no appeal against it. The Minister in this context is exercising a quasi-judicial function. There should be an appeal to a non-partisan body against any decision taken by the Minister in this matter. This is a defect which should have been remedied. I believe that if any impartial body were to examine the Minister's conduct in relation to this matter, if they examined the fact that he failed to clarify the meaning of the directive, then on the basis of an interpretation which the Minister knew was not that which the RTE were putting on the directive, they would on appeal have decided in favour of the authority and not the Minister.

Against the background of such developments, it is almost futile to talk about what one would like to see by way of improvement of the television service. I speak at a time when the Minister has struck so fundamentally at the freedom of television. At the same time, it is worth putting on record a few thoughts in relation to this matter. I believe that television as a medium of communication if used properly can be a very important influence in improving understanding between peoples. It could be a very useful way to promote understanding within the 32 Counties of Ireland. It is unfortunate that the television stations operating from Northern Ireland from which the people in the North of Ireland draw their daily news and on which their lives are depicted in drama as well as in news stories, cannot be seen in many parts of the rest of the island. Therefore, people in the south and west are deprived of an opportunity of understanding not only the political views but the way of life of the people in the North because they cannot see BBC Northern Ireland or Ulster Television.

The same can be said about people living in large areas of Northern Ireland. They do not understand the way we feel and think because they cannot see RTE television. They, too, are deprived of the opportunity of seeing programmes like "The Riordans", "Tolka Row" and so on, programmes which do not set out a political viewpoint but which depict the social fabric of this part of Ireland. It is, therefore, important that these programmes should be seen in all parts of the island on both sides of the Border. One of the practical co-operative steps between North and South would be a joint agreement to boost all these television stations across the whole island of Ireland.

On the same topic of North-South relations, one of the things that strikes me as very odd is that we do not have one telephone directory for the whole island. The fact is that one can telephone directly to Belfast. The biggest block to doing so, to using this facility, is that you have to ring up telephone inquiries to get the telephone number. In post offices here there is not access to a telephone directory for Northern Ireland. If this is one island and if we are all one people, surely we should be able to consult a telephone directory if we want to ring a person in Northern Ireland. It is worth remembering that the telephone directory is used not only for telephone calls but also as a source of information about people's addresses and the various services. If we want to promote in a simple way greater understanding between the people of the whole island, this is another practical way in which we can do it. I suggest that the Minister take steps to promote agreement with the people in Northern Ireland to have one directory. It would promote trade as well as social understanding.

I wonder if it is feasible to boost certain continental radio stations in Ireland. I have found that listening to continental radio stations is a good way of learning the language. If one has any basic facility, one can pick up quite a bit by listening to continental radio stations. One can get a knowledge of how they pronounce the language and so forth. The big problem here is that the reception is bad. I do not know how expensive booster facilities would be but I would hope that we could do so for a limited period every day. We could boost a German station for two hours and a French station for another two hours so that people who want to listen to French being spoken by Frenchmen could do so. This might be a useful way to encourage people to learn Continental languages which will be of considerable practical value in the context of EEC membership.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy look for the same boost for Radio na Gaeltachta?

Comment on this

I hope that Radio na Gaeltachta will be available across the whole of Ireland. As the Deputy is no doubt aware, there is a Gaeltacht in my constituency.

Comment on this

I did not think the Deputy was aware of it.

Comment on this

I was the only Deputy to raise the problems of the Meath Gaeltacht in the Dáil for years. I put down a long series of questions in relation to the Meath Gaeltacht and I can assure the Deputy that the results in the next election in the Meath Gaeltacht will be an indication as to which party in Meath are concerned about the practical problems which those people face, as distinct from going around posturing in a political fashion about love for the language which is not translated into practical concern for the people who speak it. If it comes to that, I can assure the Deputy that I have nothing to answer for to him.

Comment on this

The Deputy is on record——

Comment on this

If the Deputy looks at the record he will find that I am the only Deputy who put down Parliamentary questions about the problems faced by the people in the Meath Gaeltacht. The Deputy will not find that any Fianna Fáil Deputy asked questions about the Meath Gaeltacht.

Comment on this

We have not heard much of the language from the Deputy.

Comment on this

I understand the people's problems because I represent them. The Deputy does not represent any Gaeltacht but he comes in here and talks as if he did. I represent the people and the people are a lot more important in my book than the language. The mistake the Deputy seems to be making all the time is that he seeks to decry the people while making a big thing about his alleged fluency in the language.

Comment on this

He is very fluent in the language and he is proud of it. I suggest that the Deputy withdraws that remark in the interests of the honesty of the record.

Comment on this

Ná bactar leis an Rúnaí Parlaiminte.

Comment on this

The Deputy said he would deny a civic guard the right to speak the language. That is on record. All the Deputy is interested in is French, German and all the other languages but not the language of the peasant.

Comment on this

Deputy Tunney has made a false statement.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputies should allow Deputy Bruton to continue.

Comment on this

Abair i ngGaeilge é

Comment on this

Ní thuigfeadh sé é. Thuigfeadh sé an Fhraincís nó an Ghearmáinis ach ní thuigfeadh sé teanga na ndaoine.

Comment on this

I do not think many Irish speakers would recognise the language Deputy Tunney speaks in this House most of the time.

Comment on this

Is cinnte nach dtuigfeadh an Teachta í. Is fada uaithi a tógadh é.

Comment on this

That is Navan Road Irish which I do not think has ever been spoken by any true native Irish speaker. At least I speak the language that I know. As I said, consideration should be given to boosting Continental radio stations. Failing that, the news could be recorded by Radio Telefís Éireann and broadcast again by Radio Telefis Éireann. Listening to news in another language is one of the most useful ways in which to learn the language because one has heard the news in one's own language and one has a fair idea of its content and is, therefore, attuned to an understanding of the news in another language. This is a development that should be considered.

I should like to compliment Radio Éireann on the very high standard of their programmes. It is, I think, fairly well recognised that there are excellent programmes on radio. People do not, perhaps, listen to them as much as they should. I certainly do not but I know from those who do that they have a very high opinion indeed of the programmes on the radio.

We have very many temporary postmen. These men have no pension rights. I find it hard to understand the situation. These men should have been made permanent and could have been made permanent without any great dislocation of the Department's activities. This is really an exercise in cheeseparing. The Minister refuses to make them permanent, thereby depriving them of adequate remuneration and pension rights. The Minister and the Government should reconsider their attitude in this.

Another matter in which the Government and the Minister should act more quickly is in the granting of political rights to officers in the Post Office below the executive grade. These people are not involved in policy decisions. People have been making noises about this for some time, but nothing has been done. It is not right that they should be denied the opportunity of standing in elections and participating in political activities. It cannot be justified on any ground of policy because we have in this House members of local authorities who are much more deeply involved in policy-making but they are permitted to stand for Parliament. I do not see why Post Office clerks, sitting behind a counter and not involved in policy decisions, should be precluded from active participation in politics. This is a regulation that should be revised.

The development of the telephone service is of crucial importance in national planning. We should see the telephone service in the context of social and economic development. It is essential that rural areas should have the best possible telephone service even though that service may not be economic from the point of view of earning a return for the Department. It is the policy of all parties here to encourage those in rural areas to remain in them. It is also their policy to encourage urban dwellers to move to the country because the quality of life there is better. That is a sensible policy because, if country dwellers leave rural areas, they contribute to congestion in the cities. If it is our aim to encourage people to stay in rural Ireland we must provide them with the best means of communication possible. The first priority is a good telephone service. Capital investment on such a service should be subsidised to ensure that rural telephone services are kept up to an adequate standard.

There is a good deal of matter being printed on regional development and growth targets for particular areas. We have the IDA plan which pinpoints particular areas for concentrated development. These are the areas into which we will seek to attract industry. There is a good deal of talk about the role of the infrastructure in attracting industry to particular areas. Among the items constituting such a structure is a telephone service. There are, of course, roads and rail links, water, sanitary services and so on. If the telephone service is to be a means of attracting industry to a particular area in which industry is needed and one in which it can become viable, then a good automatic telephone service should be co-ordinated into the targets set by the IDA, in so far as these targets are genuinely accepted by the Government. I wonder whether they are accepted or is it just a matter of giving lists of a number of jobs, which might be useful at the church gate for some Government speaker? If these plans are serious then, as a first priority, we should ensure that there is an automatic telephone service in the particular area, a service of the highest standard possible. There is no point in producing regional plans unless they have an effect over the whole range of Government. I should like the Minister to tell us if the activities of the Department of Posts and Telegraphs are being integrated into the IDA regional plans.

The next point is one on which I feel very strongly. The capital provision for installations should be related as closely as possible to projections of area population. From the rate of marriages and births, the growth of population reflected in the census, the numbers on the electoral register, the age structure of the population reflected in the census and from the development plans of the county council you can project fairly accurately what the population of an area will be for five to ten years. That is a very good guide, if you have basic data of the economic position of the area, to the future demand for telephones. That is the time to start thinking about the provision of capital for new exchanges and additional switching equipment. A period of four years may elapse between the ordering of such equipment and its delivery and installation.

If the Department genuinely want to ensure that the service will be provided when the demand arises, the obvious thing to do is to use these demographic forecasts to estimate the demand in a given area and then to order the equipment which it is estimated will be required. This will involve certain risks. If investment is undertaken and the estimated demand does not arise the Government will be condemned from Opposition benches for squandering money. On the other hand, the Government must take certain risks if the telephone service is to be maintained at a standard adequate to meet demands.

Dunboyne is a case in point. The Dunboyne exchange covers Dunshaughlin, Ashbourne, Garristown and an area stretching towards Summerhill but not including Summerhill. The service there is very bad. At certain times of the day one lifts the phone only to get the engaged tone, which indicates that you cannot get a line. This is particularly the case during office hours. I understand that there is an insufficient number of lines in the exchange, due to the insufficient equipment installed there.

The population expansion of Dunboyne, which is reflected in the increased demand for telephones and an increased number of telephones not served by adequate switching equipment in the exchange, could have been projected on the basis of the development plans of Meath County Council and population trends. The equipment could be in the area now if the Government had looked ahead. Instead, something is being done about it only now. The result is a bad service due to lack of foresight on the part of the Government.

The same goes for the Navan exchange. Navan is an area where there has been rapid expansion of population. There is bad service for existing telephones because of inadequate equipment and because of the extra telephones in the area overtaxing the very limited equipment there. It is virtually impossible to get a new connection in the Navan exchange area because the Minister's representative quite rightly says that the existing equipment is overtaxed and if he were to add another connection without supplementing the equipment there could be further deterioration in the service. The reason for that is the insufficient equipment provided for that exchange because of the failure to foresee the increase in population. It is well known that Meath is an expanding area, that it is near distribution areas, near the east coast, has industrial potential and there is the predictable expansion of Navan as a result of mining development. I hope that this time the Government will not be found without adequate telephone equipment. Adequate equipment must be provided to cater for the increased population of Navan. Otherwise, in ten years' time the service will be worse than it is now. Now is the time to provide equipment.

I have made the provision of telephone kiosks a subject of special interest. The policy in regard to the provision of telephone kiosks is inconsistent. In order to get a kiosk in a rural area it has to be a place in which there is a post office and the post office telephone has to be very heavily used. This telephone is available only during opening hours. There are many areas where a telephone service is needed and where there is not a post office. Such areas cannot even be considered under the present situation. There are pubs and other establishments in villages which have coin boxes and where people do not bother to use the post office telephone during opening hours but when all these establishments are closed at night, there is no kiosk available. The classic example in my constituency is the village of Kilmessan. There are places where one sees a kiosk at a crossroads and where there may be only two or three houses. There is no kiosk in Kilmessan. The reason is that the post office is at one end of the village and persons shopping in the village do not see the post office which is hidden at one end and they use the telephone in the licensed premises or in a shop. The result is that the village does not meet the criterion in regard to use of the post office phone.

The real need for a kiosk in Kilmessan is considerably higher than it is in other places where there are kiosks. It is ruled out because of this rule of thumb which is operated. The Minister requires to have some objective criteria. Otherwise he would be open to the charge of favouring one area over and above another, for political or other reasons. He might be accused of providing a kiosk in an area where there was large Fianna Fáil support while depriving another area of a kiosk because the people there happened to make the terrible mistake of voting for Opposition politicians.

There is a way around this which I might suggest to the Minister. Already there is provision for county councils to be brought into this matter. Given that the Minister has a programme for the provision of kiosks and let us say that in a particular area 15 kiosks are to be provided within the next three or four years, the answer might be that in each county half or may be three-quarters of the projected number of kiosks could be provided by the criteria used at present while the county councils would be asked to nominate two or three sites each year where they consider kiosks should be provided. In this way the existing criteria would be supplemented and no injustice would be done because exceptional cases such as Kilmessan could be covered while at the same time the ordinary run of applications could be dealt with under existing procedures.

Comment on this

As the Deputy is aware, that can be done if the councils underwrite them.

Comment on this

Naturally, county councillors who are responsible to the ratepayers are not anxious to take the risk of providing a kiosk for one area at the expense of the ratepayers of the entire area. County Councillors know that they must bear the responsibility of such decisions and that they might be depending on votes in one end of an area while having to vote for the provision of a kiosk in an area in which they would receive no votes. The amount of money involved might not be very great in so far as the ratepayers were concerned but it is something of which they might remind councillors at election time. I am not suggesting a vast increase in the provision of kiosks but rather that a different criterion be used in deciding on locations. I hope the Minister will give some consideration to this suggestion. However, should he fail to do so there will be no great outcry but the proposal is worth considering.

Comment on this

What attraction have kiosks for rural Deputies? Looking through the Order Paper this evening I noticed many questions on this subject.

Comment on this

The Deputy should ask Deputy Bruton. He wants a kiosk erected at every crossroads.

Comment on this

I could explain that to Deputy O'Donovan but he would not understand since he does not come from a rural area.

Comment on this

The Deputy was born and reared in one of the most rural areas in Ireland.

Comment on this

Then, he would understand. Regarding post office buildings, some improvements should be carried out in respect of the post office in Navan. This town is growing very rapidly and there is a need for an expansion of the post office facilities. I understand that the staff there are very concerned about this matter and working conditions are such that the effectiveness of the staff is being diminished. The Minister said that certain minor alterations are taking place there. Perhaps the only reason these alterations are being carried out is that one official took a legal action against the Department on the grounds that they were not complying with the regulations of a particular Act which provides that people in charge of office premises should ensure that certain standards are maintained. It was found that the Department of Posts and Telegraphs were defaulting in respect of provisions which the inspectors of other Departments were seeking to impose on the owners of other premises. A new post office is needed in Navan to cater for the vast expansion which is taking place and which will continue to take place there.

I wish to reiterate something which was said by Deputy Flanagan. I refer to the failure of the Minister to disclose the price that the Department paid for a site. I do not understand why this information should not be made available to public representatives. The money being spent on the purchase of sites by the Department is not the personal property of the Minister or of any official. It is the property of the people of Ireland and they are entitled to know how it is used.

In conclusion, I compliment the sections of both radio and television who are involved in the production of farm programmes. These programmes have been recognised as playing a very significant role in improving the knowledge of agricultural techniques throughout the country. I hope that those responsible will continue to produce such programmes.

There is a case to be made for the appointment by RTE of an agricultural reporter. There are correspondents to cover economic, industrial and other matters but there is no one to cover agriculture.

Comment on this

There is Mr. Dillon.

Comment on this

He cannot be described as performing the role of an agricultural reporter. His job is to give information concerning demand, supply and prices at the various marts.

Comment on this

I would have thought that was very important information.

Comment on this

It is one of the very important factors of agriculture but it is not the only one. Mr. Dillion does not comment on policy or decisions, for instance. Indeed, he might be the most suitable man for the job I have in mind but it would be wrong to suggest that he is performing the same function as, say, Mr. Sweeney in relation to labour relations or as Mr. John Feeney in relation to economics. I hope RTE will consider the appointment of an agricultural correspondent.

Comment on this

I yield to nobody in my knowledge as a television viewer. The only thing I am sorry about is that the Minister is not here to hear my few words on the subject.

Comment on this

He will be here in a few minutes.

Comment on this

I am glad to hear that. I do not blame him for being tired.

Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted and 20 Members being present,

Comment on this

I was just saying I was sorry the Minister was not here to hear my few words, not that they will enlighten him in any way. I would like him to be here out of friendship, especially as I am so out of practice in speaking in this House. One thing that interests me about Estimates in recent times is the fact that nobody talks about the increase in the amount of the Estimates. The enormity of them is such that everybody is afraid to say anything about them. The expenditure on this Estimate in 1966-67 was £19 million and this year it will be £46 million.

Comment on this

Did you want a few people in here to hear you talking?

Comment on this

For the information of the Deputy who has just arrived it was not I who called for the quorum. When the former Deputy Corry was here every time he got up he called for a quorum. It is not a bad idea because if everybody did it there would always be somebody in the House instead of it being empty the way it has been for most of this evening. I would be delighted if Deputy Burke would stay here to help me.

Comment on this

It is seldom you are here in the House.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Burke may not interrupt in this fashion.

Comment on this

I apologise.

Comment on this

It is all right with me. I was interested to hear Deputy Bruton talking so much about kiosks. The cost of the questions asked about kiosks in this House must be a sizeable sum in this £46 million. I do not know why people ask questions about kiosks. The Department of Posts and Telegraphs would put in kiosks any place if they had the resources for them. I am afraid I must talk about Radio Telefís Éireann, not in the sense that certain people have been trying to bell it up into a great public matter of dispute. I want to say what I think about it. I was a television addict for years. I used to sit in front of the television and go asleep. I can say that I never saw a worse television service than we had for a number of years after the station opened.

Comment on this

It was not too bad when it put you to sleep.

Comment on this

This is no time for TV spongers to interrupt.

Comment on this

It interested me to compare this with the BBC Northern Ireland. When that station was set up it was pretty crude and had a kind of rural outlook about it. In a couple of years it was the best service in these islands. The reason for that was explained to me by a man associated with it. They had the best camera crews in these islands. I thought that RTE would never get off the ground. For a period I could not get any other station and I had no option but to watch RTE. I used never look at RTE except when football matches were on or when there were political broadcasts.

Comment on this

I always thought you were a man of charity but after that I would say you are very uncharitable.

Comment on this

I am not uncharitable. I am telling the literal truth. If Deputy Burke would wait a moment——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would the Deputy address the Chair. I am very interested in what he is saying.

Comment on this

Ba mhaith liom dá bhfanfadh sé anseo ar feadh cúpla noiméad. Tar ar ais. There is a lot of talk about what the Minister did. He could do nothing worse than was done in the first two months Telefís Éireann was in existence. In that period no Opposition politicans were seen on it. The President and the late Séan Lemass were seen very frequently and eventually in a corner of a church Deputy Corish, the leader of the Labour Party, was shown. I had a real rumpus on one occasion with one of the Fine Gael members of the staff who said this was not true, that he had interviewed Deputy Cosgrave about six weeks after it was set up. I am certain about this because, being interested in television, I used to look at it every night. I looked at it for the best part of two months before an Opposition politician was seen on it. I know the Fianna Fáil idea of fair play is that they should hog the whole thing themselves. If the present Minister for Posts and Telegraphs did anything wrong last week he was continuing a good tradition.

Comment on this

The Deputy was asleep for the two months his own colleague was on and that is the reason he did not see any Opposition Deputies.

Comment on this

I have told the truth that, for the first two months, no Opposition Deputy was seen on RTE.

Does the Deputy want to take a bet on it?

Comment on this

Deputy O'Donovan is being interrupted by the Deputies opposite who have ample opportunity in the next three weeks to talk on this debate.

Comment on this

In these islands which are called the British Islands— I have the approval of the President for calling them that in a geographical way—RTE was very bad. Why was it so bad? The real reason was the method of recruitment of the staff. It was deplorable—the nice cosy group from Dublin who got into the television service regardless of whether or not they were fit for the jobs. One of the first things that happened on Telefís Éireann was the sad fate that befell "Broadsheet", and that was because the one first class person in it was Mr. John O'Donoghue. He was the interviewer on "Broadsheet". The Government party could not take what he was doing to their politicians though he was in the halfpenny place compared with John Freeman of the BBC. He was sacked and the programme was wound up.

I remember when Mr. Kevin McCourt was appointed director of RTE. I met one of the senior men in the place at the time in St. Stephen's Green. I asked him: "Will he be able to do anything with it?" He said: "It is doubtful if he can reach down far enough into the organisation, John." The man was right. Of all the go brónach, absurd organisations ever, it was one of the worst. The strange thing is that for a period it did fairly well and in the last six months it has gone to bits again. I shall explain why. Let us take the attitude of the Government party. Take what happened during the Presidential election. It would not be right for the Opposition candidate to be seen on television but there was no difficulty about seeing the incumbent on it. Certain things were arranged, such as the honorary degree that was conferred on him by a University in Belgium——

Comment on this

The freedom of Bruree.

Comment on this

——his grandchildren receiving their first Holy Communion. I love the Fianna Fáil Party for their thick skins.

Comment on this

Their thick skulls.

Comment on this

I do not think they have thick skulls at all. On the contrary, they are very astute politicians.

What about the money lending inquiry? How did the staff to whom that happened feel? Can any organisation put up with that kind of skull-dragging without being destroyed? Why was there an inquiry at all into that "7 Days" programme? Because the Government wanted to get their own back on the people who exposed what was happening in the community.

Perhaps the Minister will be proved to have been justified if the authority have, in fact, anything at all to do with the actual programmes because certainly there has been a sad deterioration in the quality of the programmes over the last six months. Frankly, I could see no reason for dismissing the authority. They were mainly supporters of the present Government. I do not know why they were dismissed. The amount of publicity given to the Provisional IRA is supposed to be the cause of this. As was said to me in this House this evening, the father can repudiate his child and, therefore, the Fianna Fáil Party can repudiate the IRA. It would not be so easy if they were the mother but being the father it is easy enough to repudiate the IRA.

At present the RTE picture here in the city is deplorably bad. I am told it is because it is so close at hand.

I should like to refer to a matter which would interest Deputy Tunney. Both on television and radio there were long stretches of years when the Irish spoken was deplorable. On the whole I can understand even Northern Irish as it is spoken by Deputy Tunney without any great difficulty but there were some newscasters—I can guess who appointed them; I will not mention the man's name but anything he touched he made a mess of it; he is in his old age now but I would say he had some hand in the game—and they were the most deplorable speakers of Irish that anybody ever heard. As far as I am concerned the standard of Irish on both radio and television has improved very considerably in the past few years whoever has taken over the job of appointing the speakers.

There are certain obvious things in relation to RTE. The most obvious is that not enough of the programmes are original to our own country. In particular there is not adequate drama, not enough stories that are racy of the soil, and so on. "Tolka Row" was a good programme and it was taken off. I do not know why. "The Riordans" has lasted for an exceptionally long period but I have been told that they have been censured recently because of the drinking in "Johnny Mac's" pub. This is quite possible. We all know how fond some people in this country are of censorship of one kind or another. I think that as a nation we do not drink nearly as much as we did 40 or 50 years ago.

There is one other grave defect in both radio and television and that is the complete absence of educational programmes. They would not cost so much. It is not like setting up a huge assortment of cameras as is done for the Sweeps Derby at the Curragh. It would be a relatively simple thing.

There is one other subject which is not adequately dealt with, though an effort was made not so long ago to do so. There is not sufficient Irish music particularly on the television service, though when Séan Ó Riada died there were a number of programmes presented but we could do with more. We have what is generally admitted to be one of the finest folk music systems in the world. The great composers in other countries based their symphonies on folk music. No real effort has been made to build up anything from our folk music. The late Séan Ó Riada was in the process of doing it but there is no evidence of anybody replacing him.

It does not surprise me one bit to see the Fianna Fáil Party suddenly blow their top about the Provisional IRA, their own child. The IRA were shown a great deal more on the BBC than they were on RTE. It shows how absurd we are. For the first few years that there was trouble in the North, in 1969 and 1970, they were not shown at all here. They were constantly shown on the BBC in Northern Ireland and on the BBC in London. I cannot understand what it is about us that we put up with everything up to a point and then suddenly blow ourselves asunder. This is what the Government are doing about this problem: they have suddenly blown themselves asunder. If it does not bring on a general election it will be just a marginal thing. This is all I want to say on the subject.

Comment on this

The immediate concern of Opposition Deputies, I think, was the circumstances in which this otherwise uneventful annual Estimate which is normally concerned with telephone kiosks—and indeed still is—is being discussed. The telephone service may be one of the more important aspects of the Department's work and may long outlive the memory of the Minister's disgraceful treatment of the late television authority. Let us hope for the good of the Minister's memory that this will be the case. I think it will be agreed on all sides of the House that the Minister has been very keen on telephone installation and with the limitation of the money available to him he has done all it is possible to do in this important matter.

We are aware of the complaints of the many people who want phones installed, about the long waiting period, but, to be fair, the Minister has been doing his utmost to improve the service. I hope his good work in this important area will outlive what was referred to earlier as his shabby treatment of the worthy members of the television authority.

Having seen an official of the sub-postmasters' union complain only last week about the debate being monopolised by the television service, I think he was justified. This Estimate and the debate on it is, in fact, monopolised by this discussion of the broadcasting service in general. That is rather a pity because there are a number of important services undertaken by this Department all of which are worthy of lengthy treatment in this debate. In normal circumstances they would probably be more worthy of discussion and scrutiny than the television service but the week in which we are having this debate has been extraordinary in terms of ministerial reaction and ministerial treatment of people working on the board of a semi-State body, as were the members of the authority.

Throughout the country among ordinary people there has been the idea, I think, that the Government have taken leave of their senses in regard to its treatment of Telefís Éireann. For people on the east coast this may not be a very important matter because they can always separate themselves from the results of the eccentricities of any Fianna Fáil Minister for Posts and Telegraphs by switching to another station but in the extreme south and west the problem is that the broadcasts and television they are able to receive come from RTE and this is their only source of broadcast information.

What I find inexplicable is the enormity of the Minister's action when you consider the events preceding it. The Minister acted under section 31 which sets out the responsibility of the Oireachtas and its overall control in public matters in relation to RTE. Under that section the Minister issued a directive to the authority and the authority found that directive vague. They subsequently asked the Minister to elaborate on his directive, the terms of which they found confusing. They wanted some clear direction on this directive which they found confusing. The Minister's reaction was to say that he found his directive in all respects absolutely clear and lucid and he saw no reason why anybody should demand any clarification of it. Later, we had the circumstances of the interview which was the immediate occasion of the Minister's intervention and sacking of the authority and we had the authority referring to their action in seeking clarification of the directive and we had the Minister acting under the directive which the authority found mystifying. The Minister based his action on the directive about which the authority members were not clear.

Other speakers have referred to the apparent unfairness of the Minister's decision. The Minister would have us believe that the authority were a group of subversives, in league with subversives, ready to overthrow the State. I was not fortunate enough to hear the actual interview when it went on the air in the "This Week" programme but the Minister would have us believe that the interview itself was subversive of the State and its fundamental laws and by his action in dismissing the authority he would appear to and that the authority itself was suspect in its approach to supporting the fundamental law of the State. Other speakers have remarked on the fact that the members of the authority were by no means known for their revolutionary opinions: they are a most respectable body of citizens. The Minister would appear to say that he would no longer trust each member of that authority in the positions which they held by his own appointment.

I do not know if any members of the sacked authority have any legal cases on hands. I imagine that any bright and upcoming lawyer could base a very interesting case on the manner of their sacking by the Minister. There have been developments in the past year in regard to suing Ireland as a person and if lawyers are really using their minds they may find that they have the basis of an interesting case in regard to the justifiable sense of grievance on the part of any member of the sacked authority in his or her dispute with the Minister. I believe the Minister's dismissal letter states or posits no reason, expresses no dissatisfaction with individual members of the authority but simply tells them that they are no longer required. It could be that under the Civil Liability Act, 1961 these professional people could suggest that the manner of their dismissal was disparaging to themselves in their occupations and professions. It would be interesting to see how this could be developed. I suggest that if properly examined there may be the basis of an interesting legal case in regard to the manner of dismissal of the authority. I have certainly seen cases based on flimsier pretexts brought before our courts and, as a legal case I think this would provide interesting material on which to base future legal cases—the relationship between the Minister and his appointees on State boards.

Presumably the Minister originally appoints people to these boards because of their worthiness for the positions. If subsequently the Minister dispenses with the services of such people in the circumstances in which the Minister sacked the members of the authority it follows that the individual members may have material for a legal case against the Minister based on the manner of their dismissal. I am no lawyer and I am not basing my opinion here on any legal advice but simply on the circumstances of the dismissals.

In ordinary human terms the Minister erred. As has been pointed out during the debate, he showed a lack of courtesy. I understand that on the last occasion when the Minister asked the members of the authority to remain on at their posts some of them requested to be relieved and said they no longer wished to serve the authority. All the members of the authority had other interests. They were not merely political appointees who were dependent on this; they had other occupations or interests.

When certain members of this authority asked to be relieved of their positions the very same Minister who came to the conclusion that the services of each and every member of the authority could be dispensed with, asked them to remain on, presumably with the impression forming in their minds, and certainly in his mind, that he regarded them as indispensable. Certainly when Professor Moody, who was mentioned in the debate here today, asked to be relieved, the Minister requested that he would remain on. The Minister did not say: "I am doubtful of your loyalty. You may, in your leisure moments, be a subversive." The Minister did not say that. He said to each and every member of the authority: "Remain on at your post, I am totally satisfied with the result of your monthly meetings. Whatever misgivings there may be about this or that programme, I consider all you members of the authority honourable men and women."

This same Minister delivered a peremptory note to the authority last week demanding an explanation as to why a certain programme was put on, rejected the explanation given and then sent a letter dismissing the authority. In any court the Minister's action would be considered extraordinary and unreasonable. There would be an onus of proof resting on the Minister as to why he considered it necessary to take this drastic action. Seeing that the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs was so satisfied with the labours of the authority a short time before their dismissal, the question arises: did somebody speak to the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs before he came to that decision? Was he influenced by any other member of the Cabinet in taking this extraordinary decision? Who else in the Cabinet would have been interested in seeing the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs take this decision?

The events of the past week have been so crowded and turbulent that it is very difficult to see any pattern emerging, but we can say that the Taoiseach has taken a great interest in this problem of Telefís Éireann. Throughout this 69th Dáil the Taoiseach has been interested in fundamental change in Telefís Éireann. We often forget that the period of the last three years opened with court trials; in fact whether we have had more court trials than politics is anybody's guess. We can recall that very early on in this Dáil there was an attempt to bring Telefís Éireann before the courts. In connection with one of the most important and most interesting of their public discussion programmes, "7 Days" we had the tribunal on moneylending. Throughout, the Taoiseach and certain members of the Cabinet have been very interested in controlling public relations programmes on RTE. I do not know whether this arises from complaints by people in parts of the country where no other television station is received. It is a matter for speculation whether the traditional TDs of the Government party who lived in a spirit of peaceful co-existence with the local newspapers in their own areas have considered the public affairs programmes of Telefís Éireann to be an intrusion into their power bases in the south and the west where previously the only agencies of public discussion were the local journals. One way or the other, the conclusion is inescapable that since the election of this Government in 1969 they have been extremely sensitive to the public affairs programmes of Telefís Éireann.

The first signal that this Government were out to get Telefís Éireann was the "7 Days" tribunal. That cost us about £250,000. One can recall the various charges that were flung down during that period at Question Time and other times. The tragedy of the northern part of our country has intervened in the meantime and we tend to forget that in a peaceful period of this Government's existence when in fact it was pressurised by no outside event, this Government deliberately and cold-bloodedly took after Telefís Éireann in the matter of the "7 Days" Tribunal so that there may be this pattern, may be this connection, and this consistent thread that this Government and Cabinet have throughout been insistent on controlling that medium of public communication, Radio Telefís Éireann. That at any rate is my opinion.

Now, section 31, this section which expresses in statutory terms that part of the Broadcasting Act which stresses the connecting link between the Parliament or the Government of the country and the radio and television station has been referred to throughout this debate and the point has been made that it is for Parliament and the Government here to decide on matters that concern the citizens of the country, that the Government and Parliament must be in control and in the final resort are responsible for security. I do not quarrel with or argue about that. The point has been made that Telefís Éireann and the broadcasting authority set out to be second guarantors on the matter of liabilities and political questions in the State. I do not believe that this argument holds water but this was the argument set out, the reason, the backing for this drastic action by the Government. We would say that the Government and Parliament and the executive at any time, are obviously responsible for security in the State. Nobody else has responsibility. It is the majority party holding government of the country who are responsible for security matters. But what we would see in this mysterious directive of the Minister to the authority, this directive in respect of which they said in their defence a long time ago that they did not understand the requirements of the directive and when they sought guidance on the interpretation of the directive, the Minister said that for guidance to them, the directive was sufficient——

Comment on this
Noel T. Lemass Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr. Lemass) Fianna Fáil

The Deputy did not hear the radio today?

Comment on this

What did the radio say today?

Comment on this

The Minister explained the matter in great detail after the news at 1.30 p.m.

Comment on this

I am going on the correspondence in the press in the last few days from the chairman of the defunct authority.

Comment on this

Unfortunately the Minister's radio broadcast was held up, due to a stoppage of work, and it was broadcast today.

Comment on this

I will be interested to hear the Minister's explanation. I did not hear today's radio announcement.

Comment on this

It was very clear and precise.

Comment on this

Let me say in sympathy with the RTE Authority that I find, as they find, the Minister's letter to them to be mysterious and certainly I find eminently reasonable their request for clarification of what exactly the Minister meant by that particular directive.

Comment on this

Did the Deputy say he did not understand what was meant?

Comment on this

There was no organisation referred to.

Comment on this

No, not any particular organisation.

Comment on this

No particular organisation was referred to and I think it was quite understandable that the authority in good faith, running day-to-day programmes, should seek clearer guidance from the Minister. The Minister refused to give them any guidance in correspondence form.

Comment on this

The point I am trying to make is that the Minister met the authority on two or three separate occasions to explain exactly what was meant by the directive.

Comment on this

That is very interesting.

Comment on this

It was on the radio today.

Comment on this

That is very interesting. The Minister therefore favoured a verbal message to the authority?

Comment on this

No. He made a clear direction on section 31.

Comment on this

He wrote to them on section 31 and gave them a directive in written form, I understand. If the Parliamentary Secretary is saying that the Minister subsequently met the authority and explained further in meetings with the authority what exactly he meant by the letter, I am very interested to hear it.

Comment on this

I think the Minister's direction was very clear and be made a statement on the radio today which cleared up any ambiguity if there was ambiguity in what he said.

Comment on this

I am unclear whether the Parliamentary Secretary is saying that the Minister met the members of the authority subsequent to the directive which he delivered to the authority and which the authority found baffling.

Comment on this

I am merely sitting here for the Minister and I am not going to speak with authority on any of these matters but the Minister certainly made it very clear on the radio today.

Comment on this

We gather that the Minister was on radio today and that is very good for radio. I hope the Minister has given a certain clarification but what I find baffling, what I think is uncontested is that the Minister did not reply subsequently to the authority's letter seeking direction. The Minister may have met the authority on numerous occasions and may have explained this and that to them, but he did not put down anything so far as I am aware in written form to the authority subsequent to his directive. Subject to correction and to hearing exactly what the Minister said on radio today, I understand that to be the position. I know that the Minister is one of these charming politicians who tells you what he did mean in a written form. This is so, and it is a valuable attribute and asset which the Minister has, but I could understand the authority asking on so important a matter as this for a clear written direction and so far as we are aware, they received no such direction from the Minister. He cannot plead that he is short of secretaries. There is a whole Department of secretaries there ready to write out letters and the same secretaries have been prolific in the number of letters they have addressed to the Minister's constituents in Limerick West. There is no shortage of secretaries and therefore the mystery remains why this problem of non-communication to the authority on their request for clarification of this directive and that, however often they rang, however often they complained, the Minister for some peculiar reason refused to give them any further clarification.

I doubt that the members of the authority were dangerous men, were people who needed to be sacked or were subversives. I do not think they were any of these things. I think that they were attempting in concert with the Director-General to run a television station in very difficult times indeed, and I am not saying that Telefís Éireann has been free of certain excesses in their reportage of certain events in Northern Ireland. I am not saying they have been and neither for that matter have any other media, the newspapers down in this part of the country. I often think that when the history of this time comes to be written, if anybody sits down to write it or if any of us survive for it to be written——

Comment on this

It would probably make a play.

Comment on this

It would be difficult to get any comedy out of it. If somebody sits down to write anything about the period, he must report that a great number of us at this period took a very one-sided—it would be wrong to call it jingoistic but certainly one-sided—approach to this whole question, this complicated, many faceted question of Irish unity which has been occupying our minds over the past three years.

To get back to the subject, why was it necessary to sack this authority which had evidently sought direction and got none from the Minister. The Government of which the Minister is a member have not been very oncoming, especially before Christmas last, in their own naming of the organisations which were attacking the pillars of the State. This reluctance on the part of the Minister to name organisations and to say which exactly were the organisations considered subversive and who were the persons regarded as subversive has been part of the manner of dealing with the problems which we have been meeting over the last year or two. We have manufactured all kinds of meaningless euphemisms, calling them the men of violence, and the people who wish to subvert the pillars of the State. There has been reluctance to name the organisations responsible. In the past year if Telefís Éireann have occasionally erred in the direction indicated by taking a one-sided approach on a particular incident, they have not been alone in this. Some newspapers have done likewise. Telefís Éireann, in a one station State, have problems. The problem we are discussing here tonight would not be so serious if it related to a State in which there were many television stations and where people could switch from one station to another and tune into a commercial radio station or a commercial television station. Over many parts of our country RTE radio and television are the sole means of communication, apart from the newspapers.

Henceforth, however much the new authority may fight against it and however much they may attempt to develop some kind of independence in relation to the Minister, the odds are against them. How can the members of the new authority expect to have any independent existence apart from the whim of the Minister when the circumstances of their coming to their posts were so ignominious? How can they expect independence in their new positions? How can any member of the staff of the same station expect security in his position? If the board of the authority have been removed so ignominiously, what security is there for the members of the staff in the same station? What kind of message and what kind of censorship must be working, almost self-automated, in the minds of any producer this week or next week who attempts to produce a programme on a matter of public concern? At the back of his mind something must lie saying "If we take this shot or do this interview somebody up high may say this programme must be closed down".

These are the inescapable consequences of this action on the part of the Government. I was reading a newspaper editorial which said that the Opposition might do the same. The concern of the Opposition arises from this threat which we see from an all-powerful executive, secure in their power, attempting to muzzle this very important communication medium. People have scoffed at the idea of the arrogance of power in terms of the Fianna Fáil Party. The Taoiseach has earned a certain amount of popularity by dealing rather unceremoniously with members of his Cabinet who were regarded as the absolute quintessence of the insolence of power when they were in office. The Taoiseach sent these members of his Cabinet packing. They were sacked, admittedly under external pressures. But they were sacked. The Taoiseach gained a certain amount of popularity for that action. It was said that the Taoiseach changed the face of Fianna Fáil and banished the charges of the arrogance of power and gave us Fianna Fáil with a human face. I do not know about that "human face" of Fianna Fáil. That same Taoiseach, that person who never looked for high office and was pushed into the post, surrounded by his Cabinet and by the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, a charming person, has, we see, steel in his glove. We see the steel under that polite exterior and beneath that public relations smile of the Cabinet this week in the manner of their dismissal of the authority.

The Opposition are correct to be alarmed in turning this debate into an examination of the Government action. They are correct in examining, considering and questioning over again in an attempt to seek the key to this extraordinary action on the part of the Government, because it certainly was "extraordinary action". How many other remedies suggest themselves, short of this final and terrible remedy of the Minister? The Parliamentary Secretary says that the Minister called the members of the authority to his office and explained to them over and over again, as he would to children, what was meant and chided them for their shortcomings and explained to them what he meant by that mysterious letter.

Comment on this

I did not say that. Do not misquote me.

Comment on this

I gathered, subject to correction, that the Parliamentary Secretary said that the Minister, while he did not write another letter to the authority, called them often to his presence and explained to them what he meant.

Comment on this

He discussed matters of policy under sections 31 with them.

Comment on this

But he could never send a letter. I find this rather mysterious—the case of the Minister who can talk at length to the authority but cannot write a letter.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy believe we should use the RTE Authority as a platform for subversives in this country? If you believe that, say so.

Comment on this

This, coming from a Cabinet whose floors are porous with subversion, is really something.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

We will keep to a discussion of the Estimate.

Comment on this

Do not go on that line, unless you are prepared to stand over it.

Comment on this

We are ready to stand up and be counted.

Comment on this

Yourself and Deputy Thornley?

Comment on this

It was all very well after the Heath initiatives to suggest that we are for law and order but, by God, there were not many of us for law and order before last Christmas.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

We must keep to the Estimate.

Comment on this

I find it peculiar, to put no other expression on it, that the Minister was ready to meet the members of the authority on numerous occasions but was not ready to write to them and to set down in black and white which organisations were subversive and what they should be doing. That I find extraordinary.

It has often been remarked that Fianna Fáil were arrogant. As I have said, the Taoiseach was often given a great deal of praise for dealing with this charge of arrogance by dismissing certain members of his Cabinet. I am just saying that that charge of arrogance must be revived, given fresh sustenance, by the action last week of the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs who I imagine consulted the Taoiseach before sacking the members of the RTE Authority.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I am sure the Deputy appreciates it is the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs who is responsible.

Comment on this

I do. I was just speculating that the Minister probably consulted the Taoiseach before he took that action. I know personally that the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs is a most careful person in his political habits and I cannot imagine he took such a major action without consultation with the Taoiseach. I do not think this action can be interpreted in isolation from the kind of party and Cabinet we have in Fianna Fáil. They have been there since 1957 and they intend to be there until 1987 if possible. Obviously, in remaining on in this situation responsible members of the personnel of Telefís Éireann will have to exercise a certain carefulness of tone and caution in the programmes of public comment Telefís Éireann will put out.

In this context, the Opposition are concerned because we have had during the past three years the idea that the will of the majority should be the fundamental influence on the laws by which we live. That has been under severe trial all over Ireland, and I do not believe the Minister's action has had the consequence of gagging RTE. He may say: "I have no desire to impose censorship on Telefís Éireann, I have no desire to manacle this producer or to tell that producer that I do not like that particular programme", but that is the effect of his action in dismissing the authority. His action must have this consequence.

If one were tomorrow morning to be faced with the task of devising a programme on housing, a programme on a political question, and attempted to fill out that programme with various interviews, surely in the aftermath of the dismissal of the authority the uneasy thought must lie in the head of the unfortunate producer of such a programme whether the programme has a bias which the Minister or his new authority might regard as subversive.

Which political programme could possibly be devised which does not urge the attentive viewer, which is not devised to suggest to that viewer that there should be a change in the fundamental direction of our society? In one broad sense all politics, the politics of all Opposition, is concerned with subversion. There is nothing wrong with it provided the subversion is one that is assented to by the majority of fellow citizens. That is what we mean by parliamentary democracy. That is its glory above other systems. That is its desirability above other systems. Other systems demand a sudden break in the evolutionary process. They demand revolution. They demand corpses. They demand flattened houses, ruined broken lives, smashed communities.

The glory of the evolutionary form of democracy which we have attempted to follow is that change may come about peacefully. But such change can also be said to be a subversion of the existing order. The subversion to which Members of this House who attempt to be democratic idealists resort to is not the subversion of the gun, the bomb and the bullet. That is the subversion which we have all set our faces against. We are against it, but we are not against the subversion of the political order by rational argument, by persuasion. In this subversion of that order —this desirable subversion by democratic mandate—a free broadcasting station is essential and full rein must be given to the creative direction, the creative urge of producers and other workers in that medium.

What the Minister's cold dish cloth of last week says to directors and producers on Telefís Éireann is: "The rules of the road are not to give any free rein to your creativity. No fundamental questions are to be asked any more and any programme from now until the next election which you devise or make must ensure that you will be on the right side of the new order—that we have somebody here from the true faith, the Fianna Fáil Party, who will give his assent". I suggest that in this new order the producer who wishes to keep his job under the new authority must at all times ring Flor Crowley before he makes a programme.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Crowley.

Comment on this

Sorry, Deputy Crowley. I suggest that should be in the survival kit of any producer in TE who wishes to stay in his job in the new order. That may be a bit of a caricature but in that direction must lie the best hope for survival of any man in the broadcasting service from now on. He must have the political approval of the Government in office. The Minister may say that the dismissal of the authority need not have any such consequence. I cannot see how these consequences can be avoided, perhaps not to the extent I am suggesting but I do not think we can avoid these mental consequences as far as the people now in the broadcasting service are concerned.

Why would it be in my political interest as a member of the Opposition, why would it be in my interest if I were over there as a member of the Government party, to have a Press which is as free as possible and to have a television and radio station as free as possible? In our efforts to reform society, the greatest ally we can have, the conditions which are essential to our success, must depend on the minds of our citizens being left open to the realities of the questions before them. Our fellow citizens at all times should have available to them, both in their newspapers and on their television and radio sets the freest expression from all these agencies to mould human opinions. They should have put to them for their consideration opinions that are free and untrammelled by political connection.

That is why it is in my interest as an Opposition politician, that is why it would be in my interest if I am to be over there in any Government of any shape in the future, to get a sufficient body of opinion in this country interested in radical change in our society, and that is why it is always in my political interest to have the freest possible Press, television and radio.

Therefore, I am not disinterested in this argument and this debate. For me and my colleagues it is not simply another Opposition ploy. It is an essential condition of our continued existence and relevance that we try as much as possible to have a free Press, television and radio service in this country. It may be that the Government and the party opposite think it is in their political interest to damp down as much as possible fundamental questioning of our society. They may believe that it is in their interest to have a television and radio station broadcasting in the main sponsored, non-questioning programmes. That may be their fond belief. It is certainly not mine. From my point of view, if there is to be any future for my political beliefs, it is essential that we have a free Press and free communications media. I do not believe that the television we will see in the coming weeks, and subsequently, will be the same as we saw in the past two or three years.

I regard as patently absurd the suggestion that the sacked authority was constituted of an extraordinary collection of radicals, a bunch of subversives, according to the Minister's logical processes. These people were originally appointed by the Minister and one would assume that they were appointed initially because of a certain loyalty, But, despite that, these were the very people who felt that they could take no other action but the action they did take and, for that action, they were sacked. Whatever the origin of their appointment one can only admire people who stand by their principles to the point at which they are sacked.

We live in a political community not famed for its political courage and the Minister belongs to a party who have swallowed the most extraordinary divergences of opinion in matters of principal in the last three years and have survived. There have not been any earth-shaking battles on issues of principles within the rank and file of the party. One can only admire, therefore, when people deliberately set out on a collision course over a matter of principle with the very man who appointed them. This was what happened in the case of the RTE Authority.

It may be that the new authority will develop an extraordinary independence and may, in turn, have to be sacked. It would seem to me that the dice is loaded against any semblance of independence on the part of the new authority and the result of the Minister's action will be a closing of the minds of those appointed to the authority.

What has been the effect of the Minister's action? The Minister is a member of a Government who talk about the unity of the nation. The extraordinary thing is that in many of their actions they have shown themselves wholly insensitive to the 32-county dimension. The sacking of the authority is a notable example of that.

Comment on this

That is quite wrong.

Comment on this

Who first suggested internment without trial three years ago? Fianna Fáil. Who wanted to get rid of proportional representation? Fianna Fáil. As I say, the sacking of the authority is just one further example of this insensitivity on the part of Fianna Fáil to the existence of the Thirty-two Counties.

Comment on this

That is a terminological inexactitude.

Comment on this

That well-known radical, Captain Brooke, was provoked into saying that he found certain sections of the legislation that will come before this House tomorrow repugnant and we know Tory politicians who have declared their dislike of the Minister's action in sacking the authority.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy knows that he must not anticipate this legislation.

Comment on this

I have moved from the pending legislation. I am talking about the sacking of the authority. Captain Brooke does not like the pending legislation and Captain Brooke's political colleagues in Britain, British Tories, have expressed their dislike of the sacking of the authority by the Minister. At a time when we are seeking to amend our Constitution in an effort to demonstrate our sensitivity to the feelings of certain sections of the 32-county community we sack the authority and, in doing so, proclaim that we are on the side of political censorship; that is what the action of the Minister proclaims to the Unionists.

Comment on this

In other words, the Deputy stands for the people outside this House ruling the country and not the people elected to this Parliament.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy must not interrupt.

Comment on this

I am sorry, but Deputy O'Leary obviously stands for people outside this House ruling the country and not the elected representatives in this House.

Comment on this

I can understand Deputy Burke's indignation. I do not stand for people outside——

Comment on this

The Deputy does.

Comment on this

That is Jack Lynch's line for tomorrow.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy must refer to the Taoiseach as the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

I am sorry. The Taoiseach.

Comment on this

I am saying that the manner of the dismissal of the authority and the inevitable consequences of that is a form of political censorship which can cause nothing but dismay to Protestant and Catholic alike in Northern Ireland who would hope for the eventual possibility of a United Ireland based on agreement and consent. This savage action of the Minister shows that the Minister is insensitive to the position of these people. We know what the SDLP had to say at the annual conference in Dungiven. A resolution attacking the action of the Minister and the Government was passed unanimously. That resolution had the support of John Hume, Ivan Cooper, Austin Currie and all the other members of the SDLP. They condemned unreservedly this action taken by the Fianna Fáil Government in the South. Their opinion was that it did not help their cause in the North. How could one describe it other than as the insensitive action of people insensitive to the implications of the 32-county dimension? It is, of course, of a piece with all the other insensitive actions of this Government in recent years. God knows what foreign journalists will make of this. The Taoiseach has been at pains in the international context to argue that the breakdown and the anarchy are concentrated in the northern part of our island. What a futile exercise that is in the light of the action now considered necessary by the Taoiseach and his Cabinet colleagues in this part of the country.

Comment on this