Offences against the State (Amendment) Bill, 1972: Second Stage.
Contributions 118–262 of 262. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 30 of 1972 ›
There is two-way traffic in Fine Gael. The members of the Fine Gael Party in particular have been saying from time to time that in so far as we want help from them we will get it. On the 13th April, 1972. Volume 260, No. 2, column 174, of the Official Report Deputy Cooney, referring in particular to Mr. Mac Stiofáin, says:
He is described as Chief of Staff of what I would call the woman beaters, the Provisional IRA. Again, the fact that our Government will tolerate this is indicative of their philosophy and indicative of the approach, the softly, softly approach, which they have towards these people. They seem to be always looking over their shoulder in some fear that, if they take action against these groups which are subversive and which have threatened this democracy they are not being true to themselves and they are in some way being anti-national.
This is what we are doing today. Is it not being true to ourselves? Can it be suggested that we are anti-national because we are bringing in legislation of this nature? Deputy Cooney also said:
I would hope that, in the course of this debate, many more Deputies from the Minister's party will rise here and encourage him to take firm and positive action in dealing with these subversive organisations.
What else are we doing on this occasion?
On the 5th August, 1971, Volume 25, No. 19, column 3450, of the Official Report Deputy Garret FitzGerald said:
... if this Government can come to this House at some stage and say "we went through trial by jury; witnesses were intimidated, juries were intimidated, and we had to introduce special Criminal Courts. We did that; we charged people, but the scale of the problem is such that we are now threatened with civil war and the only solution is internment", the Government will get from this party support in that action—then and only then; but it will get that support when necessary because this party has always stood by any Government no matter how much it is opposed to it, which acting properly and with due process, seeks to protect the liberties and lives of our people and the society in which we live.
There is a serious situation in this country. We do not want to impose internment. We are not intending to impose internment in this Bill, but we want to do something far less and we want the help from the Fine Gael Party that they promised through so many of their speakers. Deputy Cosgrave on many occasions—and I have several quotations from his speeches— has said as Leader of the party that he will give us whatever support, by way of new legislation, if necessary, is needed to deal with this problem.
We are now looking for that support and it is, apparently, going to be denied us. We have indicated and, indeed, we have proved the difficulties we have, difficulties Deputy Garret FitzGerald spelled out so eloquently. We went through everything. Our courts have not been effective. Juries have been intimidated. Witnesses have been intimidated. The Special Court itself has not been successful because, as I indicated, the rules of evidence prevented that court from bringing in convictions against known leaders of the IRA. Therefore, having proved our difficulty—I can assure Deputies opposite that it has been a serious difficulty indeed—we had no alternative but to take steps to cope with the difficulty.
As I said at the outset, we are the people who are operating this legislation on the ground. It is we who have to stand over everything we do and, not being able to do what we should do in the manner we would like for the protection of our people, we are asking Dáil Éireann to help us to ensure that we will have the necessary means of protecting our community. The people against whom this legislation is directed have been active in many parts of the country, but particularly in the North. They have turned their guns now on the security forces of this State. Everybody knows they have. We have had a close experience of their bombs. Not in Belfast and not in Derry but in Dublin people have been maimed. But that is not the only reason why we should introduce this legislation. The lives of the people in Derry and Belfast should be, and are, as dear to us as are the lives of innocent people in Dublin.
These people, as I say, have detonated their bombs within a few hundred yards of this House. Will they next turn their rockets on targets in this part of the country? The fact that they have done it in another part of the country, a part over which we do not, unfortunately, exercise jurisdiction, should be sufficient reason for us to take effective action to curb now these activities to the best of our ability.
Deputy Cruise-O'Brien very rightly said that freedom was not unlimited. Liberty is not unlimited, but the safety of citizens must be unlimited. If what has been happening is allowed to go on, how can we, without adequate powers for dealing with the situation, guarantee in so far as we can the safety of any citizen? In my statement yesterday I referred to what we regarded as a threat presented by the situation generally, apart from the incident to which Deputy Thornley referred. I said that the issue in the present case—I can expand that by saying "the issue at the present time"—is nothing less than whether Parliament, Government, the courts and the law have all to surrender to an unlawful organisation. The challenge to the institutions of the State is direct, deliberate and unmistakable. The Government have no choice but to meet it. We propose to meet it and we want to be helped in meeting it by passing this legislation.
Comment on this
I am not as experienced as other Members and I am in some doubt as to what is likely to happen in relation to the vote which, I presume, will be pressed at the end of the Second Stage. Am I to take it that there will be two votes, one on the Fine Gael motion and one subsequently on the question that the Bill be now read a Second Time?
Comment on this
Will Deputies please cease interrupting? Deputy Sherwin is seeking the help of the Chair. If the amendment is carried there will be only the one vote.
Comment on this
Before I came into the House this evening I was asked to meet a deputation at the gates of Leinster House. The deputation was comprised of a group of ladies from the Derry area. They presented a petition to me and I should like to put that petition on the record. The petition is in relation to this Bill.
Comment on this
On a point of order, is the Deputy entitled to read a statement handed to him without any reference attaching to it? There is no indication who gave him this.
Comment on this
It is addressed to "Mr. Jack Lynch, Eire Prime Minister". There are 13,867 signatures. "We protest in the strongest possible terms against the setting up of military courts and repressive laws, the arrest and imprisonment of fellow Irishmen and women as a stab in the back against the oppressed people of the North. This you are doing in collab-eration with the British Government and history will prove you and your henchman, O'Malley, to be traitors to the Irish nation."
Comment on this
On a point of order, is it in order to refer to "O'Malley?" Is it in order to refer to a Member of the House in that fashion?
Comment on this
There were prisoners on the Curragh when the Deputy's leader was Minister for Defence.
Comment on this
These signatures were collected in the past two days in Derry, which is outside the jurisdiction of this Dáil. I am merely quoting what is in the statement. It goes on to demand that Seán Mac Stiofáin be transferred immediately to an intensive care unit and out of the Curragh concentration camp.
Comment on this
On a point of order, would the Deputy inform us were any of those women included in those who were refused a meeting by Seán Mac Stiofáin and his comrades when they came down here some months ago?
Comment on this
Instead of the Bill now before us, we should be discussing the abolition of the Offences against the State Act, 1939. If it was ever justifiable to withdraw a fundamental right from the people of Ireland—and I doubt that it was ever in order—it is not in order now.
Comment on this
If it was justifiable then, there was an emergency situation. It was during the war years. Practically 30 years have passed since this emergency was declared. Are we saying that a state of emergency still exists? Apart from a few incidents that have been provoked by the Government, there are peaceful conditions in this part of Ireland, the so-called free part of Ireland.
Comment on this
Is there any possibility that the Government who are seeking to put laws through the House in order to keep order, as they say themselves, would keep a little bit of order and allow the odd person who does not say "Yes" to them to say what he has to say?
Comment on this
There is no justification for the continued operation of the Offences against the State Act. There is no justification for the special courts. There is no justification for muzzling RTE. There is no justification for the Prisons Act. Certainly there is no justification for this Bill. Recently the Minister for Justice, on television and other media, referred to the difficulties in achieving convictions in our courts. When he was asked what he would do about it, the general tone of his reply was that he was finding it very difficult to produce legislation which would help him, but that he was working on it, and hoped he would be able to introduce this legislation within a month.
The Minister said this Bill does not give the powers which the great majority of the people who are protesting and will continue to protest against it believe it does. He said the only innovation is the provision in relation to the evidence of the chief superintendent. After all, we are talking only about a particular chief superintendent. His evidence is to be admissible. If the difficulties the Minister was talking about to the British television audience, and other audiences, are to be surmounted by this legislation, surely we must accept that the inclusion of the admissible evidence provision is very significant? It is not just an extra little piece of evidence that can be brought in because all other matters must be related to it, and related to the judge's decision. In framing this legislation the Minister wants to select which individuals in our society are to be put behind bars and locked away. The Government are setting about doing that.
The Government may have to interrupt the housing programme to house the number of people who object to this Bill, and to house the people the superintendent and the Department may wish to remove from our society. I charge that the Government have been engaged in a deliberate campaign of trying to provoke a situation in which the people of Ireland will accept that this legislation and the continued use of the Offences against the State Act are justified. Since the Taoiseach visited Chequers a little over a year ago, this type of provocation has developed to the point at which it is today.
These people in Derry felt three years ago that they had a second guarantor ready to back them in a doomsday situation. The Taoiseach said that we have no jurisdiction, unfortunately, over the people within the Six County area, but I wonder does he mean it? They are now looking at what we are doing in this Parliament. They remember the Taoiseach said on television that he would not stand by and allow what was happening then to continue. These are citizens under our Constitution. What are they to think when they see us proposing legislation which goes beyond the Special Powers Act in the Six County area? There are two differences. Within the Six County area Her Majesty's Government operate, and within the Twenty-Six County area a native Irish Government operate. That is a hell of a difference, but unfortunately we have reached the stage where it makes no difference. I daresay that my voice will not be heard too strongly——
Comment on this
I want to get this on the record. I am still a junior in the political field and if matters were expounded by people who are older than I, and longer in politics, perhaps their voice would carry more weight, but I will leave it to my constituents in Dublin South-West, and to the rest of the people, to decide who will be listened to now. I consider it is a lie and a lie that is being promoted by the Government, being promoted by the so-called Opposition in this House and a lie being promoted by every journalist that refers to the IRA as being a threat to the security of this State. I do not accept that the IRA have proved themselves to be a threat to the security of the State. What I would say is that they are certainly a threat to the security of the Six County area, which has no parliament at the present time because the people saw to that, which is, in fact, in a warlike situation declared by Mr. Maudling.
I remember incidents like the incidents in the Ballyshannon area where the Government ordered members of the Garda to force themselves into a situation where they might antaganise a protest meeting, a public meeting, in order to get the justification necessary to be able to introduced legislation similar to that introduced today. The Government have failed to do it.
When the Taoiseach was preparing to go to speak at the Oxford Union debate he knew he was going to speak to the British Premier the next day. He knew very well he could not face the British Premier, especially after the Munich talks, without doing something in relation to what instructions he certainly was given on that occasion.
Let us understand very clearly that Seán Mac Stiofáin, unfortunately not now, was up to his arrest the No. 1 British enemy within the Six County area and the Taoiseach, Jack Lynch, was, indeed, told this by Mr. Heath, although Mr. Heath did not seem to so regard him when he had Seán Mac Stiofáin and other members of the IRA movement within the Six Counties and operating within the Six County area over in England with him not too long ago.
The Taoiseach surely must have agreed that if he were to strike a blow, in the collaboration that is obviously going on with this Government and the British forces in the Six Counties, he must go to the top and he must arrest the man who, as I say, has been regarded by the British as the No. 1 enemy.
Let me digress here slightly and say that a couple of weeks ago there was the 50th commemoration of the death of Erskine Childers. I am not quoting from the Sunday Press but on that day the Sunday Press had an article giving details of how it came about that Erskine Childers was arrested, how it came about that he was convicted. That article referred to the fact that this man was an Englishman. It talked of the British propaganda at the time that this man was a British spy and it also made mention of the dubious nature of his involvement at the time. All the propaganda was geared to convict Erskine Childers and to execute him. Without meaning to imply any remarkable parallel between Erskine Childers and Seán Mac Stiofáin, let me say that recently and over the past 12 months, the calculated attempt to influence the people of Ireland, North and South, that Seán Mac Stiofáin was a British spy, that Seán Mac Stiofáin was an Englishman and therefore how could he be on the Irish side, shows great similarity with what was said of Erskine Childers. I do not think people could say anything about Erskine Childers or his patriotism towards this country.
It is not unfair for me to say that Government Ministers and, indeed, Fianna Fáil Deputies, have been going around the country over the past 12 months whispering of civil strife, whispering of what would happen if the IRA took over the country. This is all part of a deliberate attempt to foment trouble in this country. As I have said, in my opinion the IRA, in spite of all the provocation, did not in fact show themselves to be a threat to the security of this State. Indeed, when Deputy Cooney mentions mini-Dáils, et cetera, he is making the same mistake as other people have made in confusing what Sinn Féin is and what the IRA is.
I should like to clarify a matter, that the IRA would cease to operate, would cease in fact to see their existence to be necessary, in the event of a 32-county election and whatever government the voters would elect would be the government that any citizen of the 32-County State would support.
Let us not try to fly the kite that when the IRA have succeeded in their operations within the Six County area, in a war that Mr. Maudling has declared against the Irish people, that after that is demolished they will turn on the 26 County State because let us understand clearly that, whether we like it or not, in the event of the Six County situation being complete, we will be in the situation that an entire new Ireland can be produced and can be developed and can be in a position to elect its own entire Government.
The Taoiseach's actions in stabbing the Citizens Defence Committee in the back in May, 1970, initiated the violence within the Six County area because, let us take our minds back to the situation that existed at that time. The British Army had just arrived within the Six County area and the British Army were clearly in the position of trying to keep both sides of that community at peace. The British Army up to that point in time had not taken sides. But, facts are facts and the fact is that when John Kelly was arrested by this Government, this native Government, the violence of the British Army showed itself very clearly. I do not know the reasons for the Taoiseach's actions and his Government's actions in attempting to spread this violence over the whole country. When I asked the Taoiseach yesterday, by way of supplementary question as to the threat to the security of the people of this country if Seán Mac Stiofáin should die——
Comment on this
——the Taoiseach certainly did not answer my question but he referred to the 600 and 700 dead in this country. He did not say the 600 or 700 dead within the Six County area, over which we have no jurisdiction. He did not call it, as he usually calls it, Northern Ireland. He did not separate or try to separate the deaths for which the British Army the SAS and British spies and forces within the Six County area were responsible. Indeed, we have them in this community of ours as well. He did not separate the deaths publicly proclaimed as the responsibility of the UDA and other extreme Protestant forces within that Six County area. He clearly gave the impression, or tried to give it, that the whole 600 or 700 deaths in this country were at the behest and willingness of the IRA. That is a very dishonest and a very wrong attempt for the Taoiseach to make in this House.
Comment on this
I would ask Deputy FitzGerald, how many, and to what extent would violence exist if the IRA did not face the B Specials and the RUC in the defence of the people? Let your minds go back to the statements of the Catholic minority within the Six County area who endorsed that defence. They did not have at their disposal the Saracen tanks and the other equipment and ammunition that was available to the British. They were forced to resort to other forms of warfare to fight the war that Maudling had declared. In the face of the offensive operations of the British forces they had to be offensive also.
Comment on this
Why were these offensive operations launched? Was it not because of the arms that people in this House helped to provide?
Comment on this
If this Bill is enacted it will not be necessary to prove charges in order to obtain a conviction. This proposal is more sinister than internment which at least is honest in so far as it is a declaration that the authorities wish to have certain persons removed from society and placed without trial in an internment camp. This Bill purports to give a fair trial but the Government know that it will give them the power, on the evidence of a chief superintendent to say that a man is a member of an illegal organisation and to imprison him on that account. In other words, the Bill provides a dishonest means of introducing internment.
I wonder whether any members of the Fianna Fáil backbench who, since 1969 and indeed, in a couple of instances prior to then, boasted of the help they gave to the Catholic nationalist majority of the Six Counties, could prove before a court that they were not members of an illegal organisation if a chief superintendent were to say that by virtue of their handing over shotguns or rifles they could be described as having been members of the IRA at that material time. How can any one of us prove that he is not a member of an illegal organisation?
Comment on this
It appears that with the assistance of, perhaps, a free vote on the part of Fine Gael and others, this Bill will go through. Maybe some Fine Gael Deputies will be lost and, consequently, will not be here to vote. This is a clear opportunity for the two main Opposition parties to do what they threatened to do at other times and that is to remove this Government from office. I am sure that Fine Gael in particular will endeavour to avoid this opportunity of forcing the Government to resign because they do not want an election. I challenge them now to do what they ought to do as an Opposition. There is very little opposition in this House to this proposed legislation. The difference would appear to be merely a matter of timing. The Fine Gael spokesman on Justice said that there were adequate measures within the Offences against the State Act for the bringing of convictions. Therefore, there is no real difference in the approach of Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil. It is a disgrace to this House that the only real opposition to the Government and their acts is coming from those people who are now outside the gates.
It is typical of what has become an outstanding characteristic of the Taoiseach's administration that the Government cannot introduce internment openly. Up to the time of the arrest of Seán Mac Stiofáin their attitude was that if we do not do anything, we cannot do anything wrong but the Taoiseach had to meet Mr. Heath and had to report to him on what action he had taken since the Munich meeting. He had to let Mr. Heath know what he was doing by way of collaboration with the British forces in the Six Counties. The Government's attitude on these matters has been never to do anything in a straightforward way if there is a crooked way of doing it. If it is the Government's purpose to endeavour to avoid the outcry that would follow the introduction of internment in the Twenty-six Counties, I wish to tell them that they are not succeeding because the people who are outside the gates this evening and all those people from factories in my constituency who walked to this House yesterday evening to ask me and other representatives from Dublin South-West to oppose the Bill are all aware that this legislation would provide the Government with the means of introducing internment.
The Bill as proposed is an infringement of fundamental rights in that it dispenses with the need for proof in order to obtain a conviction. The measures that are proposed under this Bill are more repressive and more dictatorial than is internment and this is a matter that should concern every one of our citizens. Following the enacting of the Prisons' Bill, there was the setting-up of the special courts and this was followed by an announcement from the Minister for Justice, which has been put into effect since, that those who oppose the Government policy of full scale collaboration with the British are to be harassed by the police. This Bill is a major step in that direction. On that point I asked the Minister for Justice recently whether he would be prepared to make a statement about a search carried out recently in the house of a member of my party in Cork. Very arrogantly, the Minister's reply was "no". That is the answer I got after waiting for two weeks and when I agreed to accept a written answer. The individual concerned is joint general Secretary of Aontacht Éireann. Can I interpret the search on that private citizen as implying that Aontacht Éireann is an illegal organisation?
If this Bill is passed we will have acquired the same status as Greece and communist countries. The Garda, not I think that they are too happy about the situation, are being unashamedly converted into part of the political establishment. I should like to raise here a recent debate in the House of Commons on the thoughts of a British Army officer by the name of Kitson on how Government and security forces should collaborate with one another. The British House of Commons did not endorse what this man was saying. They rejected this man's thoughts. They were described by that Parliament as the elements of a police State. We have gone beyond what even Mr. Kitson was suggesting. We are on the brink of a police State. Progress towards a full scale police State has been taking place for over two years and this is a giant step in that direction.
It seems to me and, indeed, to the Leader of my Party, Mr. Kevin Boland, that this has been initiated by the Tánaiste who blatantly attempted to interfere with the course of justice in the arms conspiracy trial in 1970. At that time when five people, including two Members of this House, were awaiting trial on a charge of conspiracy, the Tánaiste, with complete disregard for the elementary principles of justice, went on television and attempted to prejudice the mind of every potential juror in the country by describing two former Ministers as conspirators. Section 4 (1) (b) of this Bill reads:
A statement, meeting, procession or demonstration shall be deemed to constitute an interference with the course of justice if it is intended, or is of such a character as to be likely, directly or indirectly to influence any court, person or authority concerned with the institution, conduct or defence of any civil or criminal proceedings (including a party or witness) as to whether or how the proceedings should be instituted, conducted, continued or defended, or as to what should be their outcome.
Bearing in mind what the Tánaiste did in 1970, if this Bill becomes an Act I wonder would the Tánaiste now be regarded as blatantly interfering with the course of justice. In fact, even without this Bill I think what he did was against the law. He said these things when these men were awaiting trial and by implication three other persons awaiting trial were also classified as conspirators. The law was, as is not unusual under the present Government, selectively applied. The Tánaiste was guilty. He was not charged, nothing happened and he got away with his stunt. The course of justice was, in fact, proven and the jurors, in accepting the evidence presented to them in court, did come up with a decision which did not suit the Tánaiste, which did not suit the Government. These men were found not guilty of the charge of conspiracy despite the fact that prior to the case coming into court the Tánaiste had described them as conspirators. This was no less than contempt of court.
From that time on the Government, mainly through the Taoiseach, the Tánaiste and the Minister for Justice, have been complaining about the restrictions placed on them by the laws of evidence, the difficulty of proof, the system of trial by jury—we have got rid of that—and the independance of the judiciary. We have had trial by jury done away with. We now have the three judges in the Special Criminal Court. Following that there is the problem of securing convictions because the Government want these people out of the way. They cannot prove it in the normal way, so they have to bring extra provisions into the law to prove that these men are what they claim them to be. This is what the Government are doing in this Bill.
It may be too late when the public realise what the Fianna Fáil Government are doing. When these safeguards are gone it will be too late because the very difficulties the Minister for Justice speaks about are the fundamental rights of the people. Trial by jury for selected offences has been abolished because juries persisted in deciding cases in accordance with their oath in bringing in true verdicts based on the evidence rather than bringing in verdicts as demanded by the political powers that be.
The rule of law within which even the Dublin Castle regime was able to operate in dealing with the forerunners of the present subversives is being set aside in 1972. If this Bill had been enacted one week ago every journalist in this city would be in clear breach of section 4 by virtue of their action in going on strike in support of Mr. O'Kelly. Mr. O'Kelly has been convicted and his case is on appeal. I know the matter is sub judice but the point I want to get across is that if this Bill was in operation last week every journalist by virtue of this fact could be held to be guilty and could be locked up. Presumably the striking journalists would be likely to have the minor penalty imposed—£200, or at the discretion of the court imprisonment for a term not exceeding 12 months or both such fine and such imprisonment but I wonder what about the members of the Executive of the NUJ. Would they be liable for the heavier fine of £1,000 or to imprisonment for a term not exceeding five years or to both such fine and such imprisonment? It is reasonable to assume that the NUJ took this action because they believed it to be called for by the circumstances and that their action would not have been affected by the fact that it would make them liable to these penalties. The question is: would these men have had this law invoked against them? I am sure not but the intention of the Government in enacting this repressive, politically-motivated legislation is to apply the law selectively. The Government will decide who is amenable to it and who is to be immune from it. It can safely be assumed for instance, that the Tánaiste will still be free to use the television service in his efforts to prejudice further trials. It can also be assumed that his action against the law will not lead to the use of section 31 against him.
This repressive legislation may or may not be used against the ordinary citizen. Why is it that the law which sufficed to suppress the United Irishmen and the Fenians is not sufficiently repressive and sufficiently capable of being loaded against the oppressed people in the Six Counties to satisfy the Fianna Fáil Government? I think external forces are at work here, that external instructions are at work and that we must comply "or else".
I do not know what problems we shall have in the EEC but if we must do these things for money, for extra payments to keep the people of the west of Ireland happy, it is not worth while. It is not worth it to have that type of commitment to Her Majesty's Government for support in a European Parliament for subsidies to help the farmers of the west. I am certain that the authorities in Europe care little about the farmers of the west and about Ireland's problems. I appreciate that I am going on to another subject but I am merely indicating that we are bending our knees and continuing to bend our knees, not to the Irish people but to foreigners.
In order that the Taoiseach should not be ticked off by Mr. Heath, Seán Mac Stiofáin is now in the Curragh in a very grave condition without the best that medical science can offer. I should like to make a strong appeal on humanitarian and compassionate grounds, on any grounds, so long as it gets through to the Government, that they should see it as their duty to avoid any situation that will increase the dangers within the Twenty-six Counties of civil strife. I am convinced that the arrest of this man was a provocation calculated to react on or produce a reaction from the IRA elements in this community. I hope that despite this provocation, despite the unjustifiable actions of the Government, the IRA will continue to direct whatever operations they have within the occupied part of the Six Counties. I make no apology for stating that in my opinion the IRA are the only force that the Irish, Catholic, nationalist population of the Six Counties—where we cannot do a damn thing to help— have standing between them and the Thompson machine guns of the British Army and, as Deputy Blaney has reminded me, of the UDA and the other extreme Protestant armies in the Six County area.
It is not unfair for me to suggest that Deputies were pretty much annoyed that they could not get this Bill prior to last Monday. They got it on Monday but I question whether the British Ambassador received it on Monday or prior to that. I should like to know if the details of this Bill which we are going through the motion—that is all it is—of discussing were discussed in London recently when the Taoiseach met Mr. Heath.
I do not desire to extend my time in speaking on this Bill but if this legislation is not to be selectively applied where will all the criminals be housed? Where will they be imprisoned? People are protesting now and will continue to protest massively against this unjust law after its enactment, if it is enacted, if the President secures the decision of the High Court before he signs it. They will protest and demonstrate against the decisions that will be made in accordance with this law without evidence. This law will fail. It sets out to make every citizen who respects freedom a criminal. In such a case the lawbreakers, the Government, are in fact the real criminals. If this law passes, every right-thinking person must have contempt not only for this Parliament, not only for this Government but for the law in its entirety. This Bill is worthy of the Greek colonels' regime on which the present Fianna Fáil Government are modelling themselves.
Comment on this
I want to begin my contribution by repeating what both Deputy Cooney, our spokesman on Justice, and the leader of our party, Deputy Cosgrave said at the beginning of their speeches. Fine Gael do not need to say it but on such a serious occasion as this we must say each time we speak that we stand for law and order. We are the party that do not need to say that; our record over the years proves this to have been the case. I shall not bother scoring petty points but perhaps it is not too petty a point to say that there were times when other parties who have been in Government many times have not always adhered to that idea. But Fine Gael, whether it lost them votes or gained them votes, always stood for law and order.
The 1939 Offences against the State Act has a list of provisions which were read out today by Deputy Cooney and other contributors to this debate and I do not intend to refer back to very many of these provisions. But it was the view of our party in deliberating this matter that there were sufficient powers within the provisions of that Act, as continued by the amending Act of 1940, to mean that if the Government wanted to act against unlawful bodies in this country from 1969 on or at any time because the Act was never repealed or never by order put aside, they could have used this legislation to keep order in the country. It is just as if I did not pay the tax on my car. I would arrive in court at a certain stage, having been caught, and would be duly dealt with. The truth is that in the entire period before 1969 and the time of the riots in the Bogside in Derry and the troubles since then the Government disregarded all sorts of unlawful comings together, all sorts of unlawful meetings, all sorts of printing of unlawful documents because it suited them politically to do so, but they always had the power. That power was always there and it was used by the inter-Party Government in 1956-57 when I was here as a Deputy and after we left office in that year, the succeeding Fianna Fáil Government again used the 1939 Act to introduce internment. That is the fact of the case. Nobody in the House of whatever view who stands up to make a contribution to the debate can refute that self-evident fact.
There the Government stand in this position, that they used this parent Act of which this Bill is merely an amendment and had the power, if they so wished, to act against all sorts of unlawful bodies and all sorts of unlawful acts perpetrated by people or groups of people. I do not want to get into an argument with Deputy Sherwin because he has a certain point of view which I do not think is very common in the House and as far as I am concerned, he is fully entitled to have that view but we cannot disregard the fact, that in the past 48 hours and certainly in the past 72 hours, we had a policeman killed by a rocket and a doctor's son, a boy of 14, being driven to school by his father, shot dead in presumably an attempt, as I would hope, to shoot his father because it is bad enough to turn a gun on an adult but to turn a gun on a 14 year old boy in the presence of his father seems to be the lowest thing anybody could do. We have also had two people killed in the Bogside in an explosion which could have been an activity in the production of gelignite or some of these things which apparently can be made from fertiliser and such. This has been happening since 1969.
I was in the Bogside in that year with the late Deputy Sweetman, Lord rest him, and Deputy Clinton. We went around that area and saw the havoc wrought there, accompanied by Mr. John Hume. We met Mr. Ivan Cooper and various other people and then went to Belfast and saw what had happened in the Shankill and in the Falls Road. The damage done at that time constituted quite clearly not only a danger to the people of the North of Ireland but grave danger to the people down here and it would immediately have brought to mind in the deliberations of any responsible Government whether or not sections of the 1939 Act should have been used forthwith. Again, there may be people who would say that at the time they should not have been used but certainly the matter should have been considered, and from that time on whoever occupied the seat now occupied by the Minister for Justice should at all times have been considering what way the 1939 Act should have been used and would properly have been used to stop bloodshed in this country, in whatever part of it.
The Taoiseach made great play with the fact that he could not get convictions in the courts and in what I am going to say now I want to make it quite clear that I am making no charge, no suggestion of a charge, against any district justice or judge. I say that if there is dissatisfaction with any of these gentlemen, the whole patern of whose behaviour is meant to be at a level which is above influence by anybody, there is machinery in each court of the land by which such a gentleman can be interviewed and steps taken. In other words, if there were district justices who were not doing their duty from 1969 on and if there were cases in which convictions should have been got, there is the head of the district court before whom a district justice guilty of such behaviour could have been arraigned and a discussion held about it. The same would hold for the circuit court and I understand it holds also for the High Court. This was not done. The machinery was there but this was not done. If there was anything wrong with the courts, anything wrong in relation even to juries, the meaning of the position of head of the district court, the President of the Circuit Court and the other heads of the court is that even on the question of a jury situation, there could be discussion between the judge in the case in which the jury acted in a rather extraordinary way and the head of the court and this could have meant that the Government could have entered into it.
Comment on this
I am not. What I am saying is that there is provision by which the Minister for Justice at the time could quite easily even on such a questiton as whether a jury had or had not acted properly have had a discussion between the head of the district court and the justice concerned. I am not saying that there was anything wrong with the justice. I am saying that the opinion of such a justice could have been got in relation to a decision of a jury. No such decision was taken by the Minister at any time.
We now have had the Special Criminal Courts for some months and I understand that there have been over 100 convictions out of 140 charges, so it has not been going so badly. The sentences imposed by these courts have been pretty stiff and such as to bring to anybody's mind who would have an unlawful act in mind a little doubt as to whether or not he would take the risk. I want to know why is it the Government want this amendment Bill now. The Taoiseach came in here and I thought that at the start of his contribution he was extremely weak. He talked about the Fine Gael amendment to which I will come later and said it was a shilly-shally amendment. I think he attacked a member of the Labour Party—two of them but certainly one—in a manner which was not very much in keeping with the office he holds. I go no further than that because I am quite sure the Labour Party and the Deputies concerned can defend themselves, but it is my considered opinion, and I feel I am entitled to say so in this House, that he is perpetrating an untruth when he says that section 30, backed by section 52, of the Offences against the State Act, 1939 is contrary to the Convention on Human Rights and that they have had to bring in this Bill in order to change the situation.
I should like to quote section 52 which supports section 30. Anybody who wishes can read section 30—it is a long section and it would be unfair of me to read it out—which gives a right to a garda to question a person as to his movements. This is supported by section 52 and the Taoiseach said, and is recorded as having said, that section 52 is contrary to the Convention on Human Rights. I must read out section 52 and then the section which supplants it, section 2. Section 52 of the Act of 1939 sets out:
(1) Whenever a person is detained in custody under the provisions in that behalf contained in Part IV of this Act, any member of the Garda Síochána may demand of such person, at any time while he is so detained, a full account of such person's movements and actions during any specified period and all information in his possession in relation to the commission or intended commission by another person of any offence under any section or sub-section of this Act or any scheduled offence.
(2) If any person of whom any such account or information as is mentioned in the foregoing sub-section of this section is demanded under that sub-section by a member of the Garda Síochána, fails or refuses to give to such member such account or any such information or gives to such member any account or information which is false or misleading, he shall be guilty of an offence under this section and shall be liable on summary conviction thereof to imprisonment for a term not exceeding six months.
Now listen to what supplants this and consider whether the Convention of Human Rights in Strasbourg would consider whether the Convention of the House as more repressive or more in contradiction of human rights than what I have just read out. I contend that it is far more repressive. Section 2 reads as follows:
Where a member of the Garda Síochána—
(a) has reasonable grounds for believing that an offence which is for the time being a scheduled offence for the purposes of Part V of the Act of 1939 is being or was committed at any place,
(b) has reasonable grounds for believing that any person whom he finds at or near the place at the time of the commission of the offence or soon afterwards knows, or knew at that time, of its commission, and
(c) informs the person of his belief as aforesaid,
the member may demand of the person his name and address and an account of his recent movements and, if the person fails or refuses to give the information or gives information that is false or misleading, he shall be guilty of an offence and shall be liable on summary conviction to a fine not exceeding £200 or, at the discretion of the court, to imprisonment for a term not exceeding twelve months or to both such fine and such imprisonment.
How can the Taoiseach come in here and say that section 52 would be more in contravention of the Convention of Human Rights at Strasbourg and that section 2 of the Bill before the House would not be so? I wonder if the reason for having section 2 of the Bill before the House to supplant section 52 was so serious, if in fact it was in contradiction of the Convention of Human Rights and the Government were so advised why was it not included in the speech of the Minister for Justice? The Minister for Justice came in with the Bill knowing it had been subjected to criticism all around the country over the last few days and he knew that he was going to get a rough ride, as newspapers said, and if so respected a body as the Convention of Human Rights could prove his case in respect of section 2 why did he not say so? Why was it that the Taoiseach could come in here and start his contribution, in the worst of form and in bad humour which improved as he went on, and state this? Why was it left to the Taoiseach to do that? Why did the Minister not show his cards to the Opposition in this regard?
I come to the further part of the Taoiseach's speech, nearing its conclusion, when the Taoiseach made great play, having at the start of the speech referred to the Fine Gael amendment as shilly-shally, of the fact that Deputy Cosgrave in particular, Deputy FitzGerald and Deputy Cooney of this party had given full guarantees on previous occasions that we would support any measure that would bring law and order to this country. They did so, and the Taoiseach's quotations were quite correct. The Taoiseach did not give any of Deputy Cosgrave's quotations because he said he had many quotations from him. He would have if the people who look after his filing did their jobs properly. The Taoiseach would have many quotations from Deputy Cosgrave saying that anything which would give law and order a fillip would get support from the Fine Gael Party.
In the last few months Deputy Cosgrave and Deputy Corish have had consultations with the Taoiseach in relation to the North of Ireland. There is extant in this House an all-party committee on the North of Ireland and the implications of unity for the whole of Ireland. There was the machinery, if the Taoiseach wanted the full backing of this House, without any of the trouble which he has today, whereby all he had to do was to ask Deputy Cosgrave and Deputy Corish to come in and he could say to them "here in private and in consultation with you two gentlemen are the reasons why I need certain things put through this House". The Taoiseach did not ask for the co-operation and, therefore, there is not much point now in his criticising these people if he is not getting that co-operation.
This is not a party political matter. It is probably the most serious matter which has come before the Dáil since its inception, or even before earlier Dála. It was the duty of the Taoiseach not to introduce a Bill giving the minimum period before the Second Reading, particularly a Bill which might or might not be accepted in the present national circumstances, when 600 or 700 people have been shot. I do not mind whether it is an unfortunate Protestant boy or girl or a member of the IRA who is shot. I would feel more sympathy for a non-member of these bodies. I do not mind which side the shot person is on. The tragedy is that 600 or 700 people were shot.
If there is a national emergency now there was a precedent for calling in Deputy Cosgrave and Deputy Corish. This has been done many times over the past few years. There is an all-party committee on the North of Ireland. If the Taoiseach wanted this legislation through and to get more power, all he had to do was to call in these two Deputies. This is clear evidence that the Taoiseach is interested in the survival of Fianna Fáil, not in the nation. I want to say that it is my considered opinion that he was never interested in the nation but he is like 99 per cent of the Fianna Fáil Party in being more interested in the continued survival of the Government of Fianna Fáil. They remind me of people who put Fianna Fáil on top, God second and themselves third. That is the way some of them act.
The Taoiseach acted in this matter, which is a matter of the gravest national emergency, in a party-political way. He need not come in here with a white face and a whining voice during the first five or ten minutes before he warmed up, and complain because he did not get absolute agreement with everything he has put before this House. The Taoiseach's talk about the Fine Gael amendment being a shilly-shally amendment requires me to remind the House what the amendment is. It says:
To delete all words after "That" and substitute:—
"Dáil Éireann declines to give a Second Reading to the Bill on the ground that it contains matter which is unnecessary and excessive and which is repugnant to basic principles of justice and liberty and the long established fundamental rights of citizens."
If we, in 1956-57, could get convictions, if we could put people in jail then, which is not a nice thing to have to do, and if the predecessors of the Taoiseach could intern people in the succeeding Dáil what more power does he want? Can he answer that? We say there is much that is unnecessary and excessive in this Bill and which is repugnant to the basic principles of justice and liberty and the long-established fundamental rights of citizens. It is clear there are such things in this Bill.
I would back the Taoiseach and his party with my own party and would be very nearly tempted even to ask the permission of my own party to go across the floor of the House on the question of legislation which will bring about an end to hostilities and to the senseless killing of people. I lost my seat in 1957 and one of the reasons why I lost it was as follows.
Two unfortunate young boys called South and O'Hanlon went up to Rossleigh Barracks and got themselves shot in an IRA activity. The following Monday there was a meeting of Louth County Council. I was a member. I was not at that time as politically astute as I am now. Standing Orders were suspended and a motion of sympathy was proposed with the relatives of the two men. I dissented; I was the only dissenter out of 26 members of the council. I argued that if two young boys had been killed by a motor car outside the county council offices that Monday morning there would have been no vote of sympathy and what we were doing was in fact providing an incentive and giving encouragement for more young boys to go up to the North and get themselves shot. Naturally I was heavily criticised in my constituency. There was a wave of sympathy. There was an election and I lost my seat. At the funerals of Mr. South and Mr. O'Hanlon there were no fewer than 13 Fianna Fáil Deputies. They did not lose their seats and, mark you, responsibility is something they should accept now and not use this House for party political purposes, trying to make people think that they are the angels and the saints and the others as Deputy Cruise-O'Brien said, are the devils in all this. I would go to the ends of the earth to stop the IRA, the UDA and every other subversive group anywhere in the country. I would back Jack Lynch in going to Chequers and making whatever bargains he wanted to make.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach. I regard all this exercise here today as just so much window-dressing in preparation for an election. Why did the Government not want this legislation two years ago? Why did they not want it after the deaths of 13 people in Derry? Why did they not want it when 40,000 people marched in Newry? I was there along with other Members of this House. The Government did not want it then because an election was not nigh. The time is nigh now. It may be next May. It may be next week.
The proper procedure for the Taoiseach would have been to call in Deputy Corish and Deputy Cosgrave and, I am perfectly certain, with 18 years behind me in this House, that full co-operation would have been forthcoming. However, if the ambition is to put party first, then proposed legislation must be scrutinised in every line, and have every "i" dotted and every "t" crossed.
Comment on this
Let the Parliamentary Secretary mind his party and we will mind ours. We got our agreement. You have the unknown quantities, sitting there behind you, one from your own constituency, God help you.
I want to return to the Bill now. All the Government need do is take the existing legislation and implement and enforce it. If they do that they will get results. They would have had results years ago if they had done that when they should have done it. We had Deputies saying in this House today that nobody's house had been picketed by an unlawful organisation. My house was picketed for three hours. It did not worry me. I knew most of the fellows on the picket. None would, I believe, have hurt me or my family. But it was not so pleasant when one was away from home and returned to find that these people had been there. The squad car arrived and naturally I asked the men to come in and sit down by the fire. But it is a little disconcerting when one's ten or eleven year old daughter asks: "Why have you the guards in talking to you?" That was not so pleasant. The same night the Minister for Education's house was picketed and last week Deputy Hilliard's house was picketed. Not a thing has been done about it though the 1939 Act gives the authorities full power and there is a penalty of six months imprisonment. I do not want people behind bars. I know at least half of them. I asked them on the occasion I mentioned: "For God's sake, go away".
Had the Government wanted to take action when there were 500 dead they could have taken it. The legislation was there. Why do they want special powers now because there are 600 dead? As far as I am concerned, the deaths of one, or ten, or 13 are as important as 600. Consider how this Government, who now try to convince us that this legislation is necessary, have behaved. People have set up in various places institutions which they call "Dala"— Dáil Uladh, Dáil Connacht, Dáil Mumhan, Dáil Laighean. They allege these are proper institutions and the writ of this Dáil no longer runs. Quite clearly, that action is an offence under the 1939 Act.
Again, how many are there who can raise their hands and say they have never been offered a paper that certainly preached, if not outright sedition, such criticism of the State and the Government that went far beyond the definition of normal criticism and, at the same time incited to violence? Maybe I myself am guilty. Out of curiosity I have bought such a paper dozens of times. I know a Deputy who had occasion to go to the North quite recently and on his way back he suddenly bethought himself that there were several copies of a certain publication in the back of his car. If he had not stopped and removed them maybe he would have ended up in Crumlin Road jail.
All these things proclaim that the Government had the power but did not use it. They did not appoint the special criminal court until this year. Were they waiting until the concentration of headstones reached the stage at which something had to be done?
I say, without fear of contradiction, that what is agitating the Government is the fact that they have to face, first of all, a presidential election and, secondly, a general election quite soon. My hope is that the latter will come as a result of the vote on this Bill. The sooner the better because I believe we will be able to prove to the people how craven this Government are in their political operations.
The Fine Gael Party have always been synonymous with law and order. The origins of Fianna Fáil were different. For a period they did not come into this Dáil. I do not say this in criticism of them. I am not interested in the past. They were involved in a civil war against the then legal Government, Cumann na nGaedheal. Inevitably that brings them closer to the IRA. They are affiliated with and very much in favour of the Old IRA. I am in favour of the work of the Old IRA for Ireland but not of the new organisations. Whether they like it or not, whether it be through brother, son, uncle, third cousin, fourth cousin or friend, the Fianna Fáil Party in this House tonight are the nearest party to the IRA.
Because the Fine Gael Party were forced into the position of being the Cumann na nGaedheal Government repressively putting down the Irregulars, or what was virtually the founding situation of the Fianna Fáil Party, they are synonymous with law and order. We cannot get away from that. The youngest Fine Gael county councillor who gets up to make a speech at his first county council meeting talks about law and order. Maybe he does not gain votes but that is what he talks about. Because the Labour Party are the Labour Party they are very interested in the rights of individuals and in civil rights. All over the world Labour Parties, or parties that are more Socialist than other parties, are more solicitous for the rights of individuals and for civil rights, for the simple reason that they are needed by the downtrodden.
These are the three ingredients of the Irish stew. The Government Party are closer than any other party to the IRA. I do not think they could deny that, even taking into account the events of 1969 and the Arms Trial. Because of their beginnings the Fine Gael Party are very close to law and order. The Labour Party, of necessity, must always be most solicitous for civil rights and the rights of the individual. There will probably be a shot at an inter-Party Government in the next couple of months. Would not the most wonderful thing a Machiavellian Taoiseach could do tonight be to split the Labour Party and the Fine Gael Party, if he could? Would that not be the greatest move that ever was made? And as well as splitting them to do it in the name of law and order.
These are the people who were involved in the most difficult party political situation themselves with several of their Ministers sacked in 1969. Since then they have not done their job on law and order, notwithstanding the fact that they had the legislation available in the shape of the Offences against the State Act, 1939. Would it not be the greatest political move anybody ever made?
Would it not have put—not to refer to him as he is now—Taoiseach de Valera in his most Machiavellian mood to shame? It will not succeed. In our reasoned amendment Fine Gael are not against what is required by the Government, when they can prove on Committee, that for the immediate restoration of law and order and the end of the activities of the UDA, whether in coming across and blowing up a fertiliser store in Donegal, or the activities of the IRA in blowing up something else somewhere else, or any other unlawful organisation——
Comment on this
If it is defeated on Second Stage law and order might be produced immediately by the removal of Fianna Fáil from office.
Comment on this
The reason why we have not got law and order is that they are in office. That is the answer to that question. I am deliberately not saying that any of these organisations shot anybody, because to kill somebody is a dreadful thing to do. Anything that is required the Fine Gael Party will give, but we want to be shown why. I know that in the heel of the hunt the Labour Party will have the same idea. If the Government think that by a piece of window-dressing they can split the Opposition and, at the same time, whitewash their own failure to deal with the IRA and unlawful organisations over the past number of years, they have another think coming to them.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach's initial remarks were quite predictable and were forecast by speakers from these benches. He insisted that this was a Government Bill and not an "O'Malley Bill". It is about time we saw some evidence of Cabinet responsibility. We remember a recent case where a senior Minister in the Fianna Fáil Cabinet did not disclose certain vital information to the Taoiseach, which was of great consequence at a certain time.
The Taoiseach was predictable when he criticised members of the Labour Party and suggested they were in some sort of association with the Provisional IRA. He was not even gracious enough to accept the statement by the Deputy from this side of the House that he had no association with and no support for the Provisional wing of the IRA. The Taoiseach accused the Labour Party, by inference if not directly, of being pro-IRA. We predicted this type of accusation when the Bill was introduced. It is a short time since the Taoiseach and members of the Fianna Fáil Party were saying the opposite about the Labour Party and were describing them as anti-national and as felon-setters. We are entitled, therefore, to say that the Taoiseach's only interest in intervening tonight, when he spoke about the Labour Party, was to cause mischief.
The Taoiseach should remember when he talks about members of a political party that, in a very critical situation about three years ago, Deputy Blaney, who sits in the back of these benches, was a Minister in the Fianna Fáil Government and he was making sounds and speeches which were not in conformity with the policy of the Fianna Fáil Party. All he got from this now tough Taoiseach was a slight reprimand when he met him in the corridors of Leinster House. We also remember that Deputy Blaney could be contained in that party as an ordinary member when, in accordance with what he believed was right, he was making speeches that were not in accord with the speeches being made by the Taoiseach. No action was taken. The only way this tough Taoiseach and his organisation could deal with Deputy Blaney was to catch him out on some technicality about a national collection for the Fianna Fáil Party.
People in the South are concerned about the activities of illegal organisations. Members of the House who said that they had been intimidated by pickets have cause for concern. I had pickets on my house. I had intimidating phone calls. I am a public representative and I must expect these things, as long as the demonstrations are kept within the law, and as long as violence is not done to any person, whether it is somebody from my family, or Deputy Donegan's family, or Deputy Treacy's family, or anybody else's family.
I do not think the Taoiseach tonight did a service to the country when he talked about the people being scared. His was a scare speech in itself in order to try to stampede the people of the country into giving their support to this measure which we regard as being oppressive.
I do not under-estimate the threat of the IRA either in the North or in the South. The position of the Labour Party has been made abundantly clear over the last three years on the North and on the activities of the IRA and there is no other single party in the House who have made such efforts, particularly with the British Labour Party and the British Labour Government in order to ensure that peace would come to the North of Ireland. No later than two weeks ago, because we are concerned and because we do not play political tricks, we went to London and saw the members of the British Labour Party there and we saw Mr. Whitelaw in an effort to ensure that the plebiscite which he says is to be held early next year would not do the harm that we believe it would do.
There are some people who have suggested, maybe unconsciously, that there was consultation between the Taoiseach and Deputy Cosgrave and myself on this Bill and on other matters in recent times. I want to say categorically that I have had no consultation with the Taoiseach, nor did he ask to consult with me, on these matters. The only consultation I had with the Taoiseach in recent times was on the format of the referendum in connection with the Constitution that is to be held next week.
This Bill, as has been stated by two of our speakers, is a drastic departure from the rule of law. I was appalled to hear the suggestion from the Minister for Justice today when he implied that the newspapers were whipping up opposition. I know it is a very nice thing as a politician to say nice things about the Press but I do not think we could accuse the Irish newspapers or the Irish media of whipping up opposition against this particular Bill for some foul purpose. They acted in a very sane and logical way. They had their protest for one day. They came to Leinster House in an orderly fashion and with great courtesy and with logic in their arguments they presented to the three parties in the House what we consider to be a reasonable and a logical document. If the Press wanted to make mischief in connection with this Bill they could well do it.
I resent also the inference—he was not quite coherent when he talked about it—by the Taoiseach that certain trade unions were giving support to illegal organisations by resolutions they may have passed or by people demonstrating over the past 24 hours. I do not think anybody can accuse any union in this country of being in league with or giving support to the Provisional IRA. It is a shame that the Taoiseach should take this occasion to suggest that they marched or passed resolutions for some sinister purpose which might lead us to believe —and I hope it will never be the case—that some of these trade unions or the trade union movement on a particular occasion will be regarded as a subversive organisation and will be treated in accordance with the measures that are proposed in this Bill which we hope will not be passed either this week or next week.
The newspapers are reflecting public opinion and the leader writers are reflecting public opinion. We thought we were right on occasions and have been faulted by the Press. We were probably wrong. So have Fine Gael and so have individuals. So have members of our party. The Fianna Fáil Party will have to learn to take criticism from people whose job it is to reflect public opinion.
The kernel of this measure is that it is, as I said, a drastic departure from the rule of law and one is deemed to be guilty until one proves oneself innocent. It has been suggested by the Fine Gael Party here that there may be some amendments. These proposals are so direct and so naked I am afraid they cannot be amended and I do not think we would be able to consider any sort of amendments that would make it acceptable to us or acceptable to a majority of the Irish people. As I said, it is a major departure from established practice, a very serious departure.
Comment on this
Up to recently the Minister for Justice did not complain of inadequate powers. He mumbled about it in some speech in August of this year. What has changed the situation? If he wanted powers or thought he wanted powers to deal with a certain situation or with certain organisations, the time to do it was about two or three years ago.
Let not the Minister, let not the Taoiseach, think that those who protest against this Bill are people who are necessarily supporters of the Provisionals or any wing of the IRA or any other subversive organisation. There is widespread public alarm. As was quoted today by Deputy Cluskey, there was a telegram received by Deputy Tully asking the Labour Party to vote against this measure. This is the view of very many people in this country, people who seriously value civil liberties, as I say, not necessarily, as the Taoiseach tried to say in what I described as his predictable comments, from the people I have mentioned. That telegram came from the Navan Chamber of Commerce and I am sure there are other organisations who feel as we do about this measure.
We are dealing with illegal organisations and, as far as the Minister is concerned, intimidation of courts of justice and the securing of evidence for conviction. As far as the intimidation of courts of justice is concerned, the Minister has adequate powers. The courts that have been established are adequate. They are operating freely and I think they are operating fairly. They are dangerous enough but there are no grounds for saying they are not getting the evidence. There are many examples of convictions being sought and secured.
It is surely not being suggested in this day and age that the Garda are not capable of getting or not equipped to get normal evidence. Of course, the Government, having failed to deal with the IRA for the past three years, now seek to excuse themselves for their past inactivity by saying they have not sufficient powers. As I have said, the time to take action was the time when people were murmuring within the Fianna Fáil Party. Again, let me emphasise that this party were consistent and always have been consistent in their opposition to those who would use violent means, either in the northern part of the country or down here in the Republic.
Comment on this
That sort of excuse will not wash so far as we are concerned and, I hope, so far as this House it concerned. Our claim is that the Government were not restricted by legal problems but by political problems and that is the reason for the inactivity on the part of the Taoiseach who pretended here tonight to be so tough. The difficulties were within their own party. It is not for me to go over that matter. The arms trial was more than an embarrassment to them. In a comment which he made after returning from New York, the Taoiseach indicated that he still did not believe there had not been a conspiracy. Despite that, he did not take action against those members of his party who continued to make their militant speeches as they had been doing during their time as members of Fianna Fáil. At that time I suggested that if the Taoiseach was convinced that these men had been engaged in any sort of conspiracy, his duty as Leader of his party and as head of this State was to seek their removal from Dáil Éireann. However, he pussy-footed with them and all the signs are that one member who was involved and who was dismissed may now be offered a post in a reshuffled Cabinet. If that is so, shame on the Taoiseach.
Comment on this
I have not as much information as the Parliamentary Secretary. I do not know which page of the Evening Press he is reading but if he is relying on that source for his information, he is not with it so far as this discussion is concerned. Up to recently there was the question also of the disposal of the money voted by this House for the relief of distress in the North. I recall a boast the Taoiseach made when he said that this Bill was not an O'Malley Bill but that it was a Bill which has the full backing not only of the Government but of the entire party.
Comment on this
All right, I accept that. Our decision also was unanimous. However, the Taoiseach did not think of Cabinet responsibility when the report of the Committee of Public Accounts was published recently and which suggested very clearly that a member of the present Cabinet withheld information from the Taoiseach which was vital at that critical time of the dismissal of the Ministers.
Comment on this
I must say that I find the Evening Herald more interesting than the Deputy's contribution.
Comment on this
So far as political problems are concerned, the Government brought this on their own heads and on their own heads be it if they insist on pushing through this legislation. The danger is in making it too easy to secure convictions and in giving the police powers that are much too wide, powers which I believe the Garda do not want.
Our main objection is to section 3 (2). This subsection smacks of internment. I do not know what might have been in the minds of Fianna Fáil about two years ago when they threatened to introduce that section of the Offences against the State Act which provides for internment. They tried to make a deal at that time with the Labour Party but when we insisted that there be a discussion on that particular Act we were outvoted by members of Fianna Fáil. To illustrate the insincerity of the Taoiseach at that time he wanted us to do a horse trade.
Comment on this
He tried to involve us in a dirty horse trade when he said that he would give us a debate on that particular Act if we gave him a Prices and Incomes Bill but we were not having any.
Comment on this
The procedures proposed go against all established practices. If the Bill is passed it will damage the integrity of the courts. This is our big objection. Under this Bill information would be accepted as evidence which would not otherwise be accepted because statements by a chief superintendent—and there are a limited number of them—or somebody of higher rank would be accepted as evidence. That is a form of evidence that up to now would not be admitted. To say the least, it is somewhat thick to say that a mere belief by a chief superintendent or somebody of higher rank can be accepted as evidence that a person is a member of an illegal organisation.
This Bill is lowering the standard of justice. The democratic institutions should not be damaged in the name of the preservation of democracy. The Taoiseach tonight in a very scrambled type speech during which, in my view, he lost his cool, tried to give the impression that the Bill is aimed at the preservation of democracy.
The Bill has all the characteristics of Fianna Fáil legislation. I remember the repressive legislation of 1941 or 1942 in relation to the wages standstill order and there has been other such legislation right up to the abortive Criminal Justice Bill. It is to the credit of some Fianna Fáil members that they opposed that Bill. We remember the unfortunate Minister for Justice at that time, Deputy Ó Móráin, trying to extricate himself from the provisions of that Bill at an Ard-Fheis some three or four years ago. This Bill has all the characteristics of the Forcible Entry measure in respect of which we were promised amendments but which have not yet been brought forward.
The implications of these proposals are very clear. Representations have been made by the Press concerning it in respect of section 4. Their chief worry is that under this section they could be involved unwittingly because of some report or statement.
With all due respect to the Minister, to his advisers and to the Parliamentary draftsmen, having read the Minister's speech and having listened to him put forward various qualifications and describe all the safeguards in the Bill for the preservation of civil liberties, I prefer to take the advice of Deputy Cooney who analysed the Bill line for line in a far better manner than the Minister described it. I prefer to take his word for the dangers in the proposal rather than take the word of the Minister on the safeguards contained in the Bill.
Comment on this
I do not speak for Deputy Cosgrave any more than he speaks for me. I do not know whether the Minister for Lands speaks for the Minister for Justice and neither do I know whether Deputy Blaney spoke for him when he was in the back benches and Deputy Blaney was a Minister and making revolutionary speeches about the North.
Comment on this
Why accept Deputy Cooney's word since he is quite a junior member of the party rather than Deputy Cosgrave's who is the Leader of the party?
Comment on this
I regard Deputy Cooney as an honest man, as a good parliamentarian and as a good solicitor. I will not make any comment on the Minister's profession.
Comment on this
If the Minister's only justification for the Bill is by way of trying to blackguard the Leader of the main Opposition, it is a poor justification.
Comment on this
As Deputy Cruise-O'Brien predicted, the Taoiseach came in tonight and blackguarded the Labour Party.
Comment on this
The boot was on the other foot a few weeks ago when we were all being described as being anti-national. The Minister is in funny humour now but he was not so funny while making his statement earlier.
Comment on this
He is not being funny when he is afraid to go on radio or television to defend the Bill.
Comment on this
We should get a little more information about section 5 where "document" is defined.
Comment on this
Indulging in personalities across the House does not add to the debate. Deputy Corish is in possession and ought to be listened to.
Comment on this
Section 5 reads:
The definition of "document" in section 2 of the Act of 1939 is hereby amended by the insertion after "advertisement" of the following:
"and also—
(a) any map, plan, graph or drawing,
Would the Minister tell us if it would be evidence against me, for example, if a member of the Garda Síochána found in my possession a picture of Mountjoy, Leinster House, a garda barracks?
Comment on this
Would I be incriminating myself by having such a document? While I am on section 5—this is the concern of quite a number of us in Parliament—could we have any guarantee from the Minister, because all the sounds and all the evidence, I will not be able to give direct evidence of this, are to the effect that our telephones are being tapped—will the Minister in his reply give an assurance to this House that telephone calls to and from Deputies' houses or offices are not being tapped?
Comment on this
As far as illegal organisations are concerned, the Minister must admit our consistency in the face of attack, an attack from his own party. I had this note down before and I was justified in having it down and believing that it would be said, that we would be accused of favouring the IRA and being against law and order. The boot was on the other foot about two weeks ago when we were being described as being the opposite.
Comment on this
The Minister might ask the same question of some of the buckos behind him and see what sort of an answer he would get.
Comment on this
The buckos behind the Minister were never consulted on anything. Their only concern was the concern of the Unionist Party in the North and that was to stay in power at any cost.
Comment on this
We will uphold the institutions of the State and give the Government support for upholding the institutions of the State.
Comment on this
If the democratic system in this country has been damaged it is the responsibility of the Fianna Fáil Party and their policy on the North.
Comment on this
Does the Parliamentary Secretary remember the morale of the people of this country at the time when the Taoiseach, Deputy Jack Lynch, dismissed two Ministers for allegedly conspiring to import arms into this country to give to the IRA?
Comment on this
We deplore violence from any side whether it be the IRA, the UDA, the UVF, Vanguard or anybody. Deputy Seán Sherwin may have spoken with sincerity today but if he thinks that the method which he seems to advocate will achieve the unity of this country he is very much mistaken. As far as that is concerned, I think the approach of my party is the best approach of any of the parties here. People have paid lip service to the expressions reconciliation, dialogue and all this sort of thing. We are the only party in this House who have tried and tried hard to have dialogue with the ordinary people in the North in order to provide for reconciliation because we regard the activities of the IRA, the UDA, the UVF and Vanguard as activities that are tearing the northern part of the country apart. We also say that if the IRA or any of the other organisations I have mentioned, the UDA, UVF or Vanguard, extend their activities down here they will also be tearing this part of the country apart.
They laughed at Conor Cruise-O'Brien when he talked about a backlash but there is evidence of that backlash there. The backlash has come because of the activities of those people in the Six Counties. The backlash has come from the activities of these people who had the support of members of the Fianna Fáil Party. Whatever steps the Government take or any Government take, we will support what we consider to be the proper steps in accordance with the rule of law but we oppose laws which we believe to be oppressive and this law which we believe to be oppressive. We will continue and there are dangers, there are dangers within one's party, let me freely admit it, and if you have no troubles in your party they are all fools or angels. We will continue to walk the narrow path between attacks on democracy by the Government or by illegal organisations. This we have done for the past 50 years.
The Civil War was mentioned. I do not want to talk about it but we are in the same tradition of the Labour Party that has been represented in this House over the past 50 years. We have never been engaged in violence; we have never advocated violence; we have never been involved in violence. The Government have got themselves into this crisis and they cannot involve all of us in trying to extricate themselves from that. It is up to the Government themselves, therefore, to clean up their own house and not to be doing as the Taoiseach, Deputy Jack Lynch, was doing tonight—trying to throw as much mud as he could at the Labour Party, as he did, regrettably successfully, in June, 1969.
Comment on this
The time at my disposal is very short. I hope I can come back in the morning. I have known Deputy O'Malley for quite a long time. I have had reason to visit him and to try to impress upon him the lawlessness that was going on in this State and also the activities of illegal organisations. I know the frustration with which he met me. He told me that owing to the inadequacy of the law he could not secure the convictions he would wish or, indeed, secure the arrests he would like. The speeches from the Opposition this evening were of a very political nature. If they think that the Minister is just having a verbal battle with them and that he is just doing this for fun——