We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Offences against the State (Amendment) Bill, 1972: Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 197–406 of 406. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Offences against the State (Amendment) Bill, 1972
Enacted

No. 30 of 1972 ›

Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): None of us ever said outside the Four Courts: “Comrades, we will have to get rid of Jack.”

Comment on this

I know the Deputies do no like it but it has to be said.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Minister without interruption. Other Deputies will have a chance of speaking later.

Comment on this

When this Bill came along these men who had been trying so hard to get rid of Deputy Cosgrave —it is no business of mine or no concern of mine whether they succeed or not—saw their chance and they seized it because whatever view one may take of Deputy Cosgrave they knew on this issue he had the firmest convictions and that he had to take a stand in favour of this Bill. They knew that so they said: "Here is our chance."

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Minister's kith and kin and Deputy Aiken's shot his father's Ministers.

Comment on this

Obviously I am getting through.

Comment on this

Is this the way the Minister is confused?

Comment on this

This was their chance to wrong foot their Leader. They seized this opportunity, unmindful of their repeated pledges to the electorate and unmindful of the security of this State. If this were merely an internal Fine Gael affair I would not refer to it because it would be no business of mine but the consequences of this sordid, opportunistic and unprincipled intrigue are a matter of great public concern when they lead to all out opposition to this Bill by Fine Gael. Let me warn the Deputies opposite that they are playing with fire.

Comment on this

Mind Charlie.

Comment on this

Deputy Spring had better watch it because his party are also involved but not to the degree of sordid, unprincipled scheming that has brought about the situation in Fine Gael today.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

That is an untruth.

Comment on this

The arrogant assumption by these men that the voters would not know what was going on is hard to believe.

Comment on this

On a point of order——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Who is the point of order?

Comment on this

On a point of order, in what way is this related to the Bill?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Will the Deputy cease interrupting? Will he let the Minister make his speech?

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

Do not interrupt Machiavelli.

Comment on this

I quoted Deputy Coughlan but he was not here, unfortunately.

Comment on this

The Minister is telling an untruth.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Will Deputy Coughlan also cease interrupting?

Comment on this

It is clear, of course, from the reaction that I am getting very close to the bone. I want to make it quite clear that this arrogant assumption——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Charlie is getting very close to the Minister.

Comment on this

On a point of order——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Will Deputy Harte please resume his seat?

Comment on this

On a point of order——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

What is the point of order? Will the Minister let us hear the point of order?

Comment on this

On a point of order, for reasons I do not have to give I was absent from the House yesterday and the day before. I came in here today to listen to the arguments of Government Ministers.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

This is not a point of order. Will the Deputy please resume his seat? He will have the opportunity of speaking later.

Comment on this

Deputy Oliver Flanagan was speaking about Santa Claus.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Minister without interruption.

Comment on this

Maybe Deputy Harte missed some of this. Let him have a word with Deputy FitzGerald and he might be able to tell him about it.

Comment on this

What has this to do with the Bill?

Comment on this

It has a great deal to do with what is happening on those benches today and the public have a right to know about it. The Deputy will see the relevance in a moment. I said that this whole intrigue that went on, included an arrogant assumption that the public would not understand and maybe they assumed the public would not be told. I can assure the Deputies they are being told and they will understand. This is where this becomes fully relevant even in Deputy Harte's terms. On the basis of that intrigue and that effort to dislodge the party's Leader, the Fine Gael Party are now coming out in all out opposition to this Bill.

Comment on this

The Minister's assumption is wrong.

Comment on this

I know you have changed.

Comment on this

The Minister is presuming that we use the same tactics as Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Other Deputies can answer this. The Minister is in possession.

Comment on this

The Minister came back from America when there was trouble in the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): He was received with open arms but not by Charlie.

Comment on this

He came back from America.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Will Deputy Coughlan please resume his seat?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Do the Deputies wish to have ordered debate in the House or is the House to descend to the position where nobody may speak? Deputies will have to observe the rules of the House and the rules of debate.

Comment on this

And Ministers.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

And Ministers. Everybody will have to observe the rules of debate. Ministers or Deputies have to observe the rules of debate and the rules of the House.

Comment on this

Will you throw your eye in that direction?

Comment on this

I am surprised that Deputy Coughlan should be so disturbed by my attack on the Fine Gael Party.

Comment on this

The Minister included Deputy Coughlan and I am here to defend myself.

Comment on this

That was another point I made about Deputy Coughlan. I assured the Deputies opposite that I would say what I had to say whether they interrupted me or not and I am going to say it. It is this.

Comment on this

Tell us about the Bill.

Comment on this

I will make my own speech. Are all the Deputies sitting comfortably? Can we begin?

Comment on this

The Minister must have nothing to say.

Comment on this

There is the man who met you at the airport.

Comment on this

Just as an aside, I came back on the invitation of the late Seán Lemass and Deputy Aiken did not arrive home for some days after I arrived so the Deputy's recollection is somewhat mistaken.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Interruptions are disorderly.

Comment on this

I know the Deputies do not like it but they are going to hear it. If they are going to stay here all night interrupting me that is all right with me.

Comment on this

Tell us about the repressive legislation.

Comment on this

It is a pity Deputy O'Connell was not here when I was dealing with his party and their inglorious performance on this Bill. I will not repeat it because the Leas-Cheann Comhairle will not allow me. I think he would have enjoyed it. He is a damn good example of the two-faced carry-on in the Labour Party in regard to this whole business.

Comment on this

I will stand up against this Bill anywhere.

Comment on this

It may be that his only objective is to achieve publicity or maybe he has another objective, but whatever the objective is he is facing at least two ways, if not more, on this whole issue. I was talking about the Fine Gael arrogance in assuming that the public would not know the reasons for their, to most people, amazing volte face on this issue. They are assuming that those reasons would not be known or understood by the public but I want to tell them that the public do understand and that there will be a massive retribution on that party at the next election.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): They have not forgotten the arms trial and that Deputy Haughey may be the next Taoiseach if they return to power.

Comment on this

There was a reference, now fairly famous, by Deputy Cosgrave, I think at the last Fine Gael Ard Fheis, to mongrel foxes. I thought foxes were supposed to be clever but obviously, whatever the right description of these people is, mongrel foxes was not the right one because they are not clever. They are going to ruin the Fine Gael Party. It is no worry to me. In fact, secretly I am very pleased. What does worry me is that they are doing it for purely low, sordid motives and to hell with the national interest as far as they are concerned. That is what worries me. That is what I am talking about.

Comment on this

The Minister is not responsible for that party.

Comment on this

I am responsible as a public man, as a Deputy is, for the general approach of this House and I think that it is a sad day for democracy in this country when you have the major opposition party, for these base motives, forgetting about the national interest, throwing it to one side, with the sole objective of unseating their leader.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

An tAire.

Comment on this

This party has had to deal with situations such as we are facing today in the past. Under each of our leaders, including the founder of our party, we have had to deal with them.

Comment on this

When we had to do so we did not particularly want to have that situation but no Fianna Fáil Government ever ran away from their duty and neither will this one.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

You have done it for the last three years, as the Taoiseach admitted.

Comment on this

Never. There are the parties who ran away when the pressure came on. This Government had their problems but they sorted them out and they held fast to their duty to the Irish people, as they are doing today with this Bill. The public know what is happening over there and we will make sure that any of them who do not know will know.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

What about the last three years which the Taoiseach referred to? What have you done about it?

Comment on this

The dithering, the failure to match actions to words, the opportunism and the cowardice displayed on the Opposition benches on this issue will have removed any lingering doubt that anyone may have had as to the unfitness of the parties opposite to govern this country. Indeed, it has raised starkly the question of the fitness of some of the people over there to sit in this House at all. That question will be answered by the people at the next election and I look forward avidly to the answer to that question. It cannot come too soon for me.

Comment on this

In my long experience in public life and in this House I do not know of any piece of legislation which has caused such widespread indignation and hostility as this one. It is said to be anti-IRA but it clearly offends the susceptibilities of all our people over the whole spectrum of our society. The indignation is to be seen in all facets of society—judges, lawyers, groups of priests, educationalists, journalists, trade unionists. Members of virtually all organisations in the country are astonished and dismayed that this piece of reprehensible legislation should be brought in here under the guise of securing law and order.

I listened to most of what the Minister for Finance had to say. He was caustic in his remarks about members of the Labour Party and the Fine Gael Party, but it comes ill from this Minister to try to pretend to the Irish people that they and they alone in Fianna Fáil are the saviours of law and order in our society. As the Minister knows full well, he would not be sitting in that seat here tonight as Minister for Finance, were it not that a colleague of his was sacked, in the person of Deputy Charles Haughey. He knows full well and better than anyone in the House why Deputy Haughey was ignominiously dismissed at that time. It was for acts deemed to undermine the security of this State that he was sacked. It would have been a treasonable crime in any other country, and there were many other sackings as well, but I have a lot of respect for Deputy Colley, Minister for Finance, who was portrayed to the Irish people a short time ago as the greatest republican of them all. It was Deputy Aiken who sought to place across his shoulder the cloak of republicanism par excellence. He was said to have the condonance of President Éamon de Valera in his bid for the leadership of the Fianna Fáil Party. We all know the manner in which his ghost writers of that day portrayed him to us as the great republican.

Are we to take it that he has gone back on all he ever stood for as a republican because this Bill is a betrayal of all that Fianna Fáil ever stood for, a betrayal of national aims and aspirations, and in particular a betrayal of the beleaguered people of north-east Ulster tonight? What then of Deputy Colley's republicanism?

It is true that we live in very difficult and, indeed, dangerous times. It is true that all our people dearly wish for peace, tranquillity and normality to return, but if it is to be a true and lasting peace in Ireland, north and south, it has to be an honourable peace. What we are asked to vote on here tonight is a Bill which is designed to subjugate the people of Ireland, especially the people of north-east Ulster, to Unionism, to the dictates of the British, and that in my opinion is most certainly not the road to peace and to tranquillity in Ireland. This Bill will not merely subjugate the people in this part of Ireland; it will subjugate the people of all Ireland and is designed to set the clock back 100 years at least in the Republic.

There are contained in this legislation far-reaching and sweeping changes in the law which affects the traditional rights of all our people. Inherent in this measure is the clear denial of fundamental rights and essential liberties. Freedom of speech, freedom of association, freedom of assembly, freedom of the Press, TV and radio, the right to a fair trial before the law—all these fundamental issues are involved in this measure, and there is no good in Fianna Fáil or any of their party spokesmen concealing the grave and serious implications of this Bill. The rights cherished by our people are being attacked in a most serious way. Already we have had here in the Twenty-six Counties a most serious erosion of our essential rights. We have seen the setting up of special courts, devoid and bereft of juries as such; we have seen the creation of internment camps to which we said we were implacably opposed and one internment camp which has been established is operating now at the Curragh under the guise of repairs being carried out to Mountjoy Jail. We have seen moreover the transfer of prisoners from the judicial authority to the military authority under this guise also.

We have had here, too, another piece of repressive legislation in the recent passing of the Forcible Entry Bill which is being used for purposes this House never intended. It is being used to beat down the tenants' associations and to deprive these organisations of their fundamental right to defend the interests of the tenants of this country. It has been used against journalists and assurances were given in this House that amendments would be brought in and we are still waiting for these amendments. We have had, too, something which shocked the conscience of all freedom-loving people in the ignominious sacking of the board of Radio Telefís Éireann.

This is by any standard a most vicious and repressive piece of legislation, one of the most ruthless pieces of legislation ever introduced in these islands, Britain or Ireland, in recent times. It seeks to set back the clock some hundreds of years in the Republic. I believe that it is fascist in its conception and dictatorial in its designs. It is a challenge to the cherished liberties of all our people and I say sincerely that I never thought I would see such a despicable piece of legislation introduced into an Irish Parliament. It brings shame and disgrace upon our country. The Fianna Fáil Government are now recognised for what they are, a byword for repression and degeneracy among progressive democratic States. This movement away from the democratic institutions we cherish has even gone beyond that which exists in the last bastion of tyranny in Europe—in Northern Ireland. It has gone beyond the extremes of the ruthless legislation and the overbearing tyranny that battened on the minority there for the past half-century. The odious system which so many of us sought to bring down in north-east Ulster, to our shame is now emulated in this House by Fianna Fáil, the Republican Party in brackets.

How can we talk about civil rights in Ireland? How we can advance the cause of civil rights? How we can talk about the shame and disgrace of internment without trial, which every political party in this country, with the exception of the Unionists, have set their faces against? How can we go to the European Court and speak about human rights? How can we seek amelioration there for the oppressed people in north-east Ulster? By this action the Minister for Finance, the Taoiseach, Deputy Jackie Fahey and those in Fianna Fáil are setting back irreparably the advance of the Irish nation towards unity, freedom and peace.

We cannot speak about these fundamental issues any more because this legislation which Fianna Fáil have had the audacity to bring in is designed clearly to shackle and to silence all those people in Ireland who dare to assert their rights and speak out against the regime. The tragedy is that in this process the Government are abandoning the people of north-east Ulster in their greatest hour of need. The only people who are encouraged and heartened by this legislation are the Unionists. The Craigs and the Faulkners are on record as saying: "Jack is right". This measure has brought joy and solace to the enemies of Ireland but it saddens the hearts of those of us who aspired to a united Ireland. This is an act of great betrayal of national abasement, and Fianna Fáil must suffer retribution for this great betrayal. They are now seen clearly doing the dirty work for the Unionists and carrying out the dictates of the British in this important matter.

It is a despicable sell-out of national aspirations. It condones and emulates all we found abhorrent and detestable in the Stormont regime, possibly the most sordid, corrupt, overbearing and tyrannical regime in Europe. This Bill has offended all who believe sincerely in human rights and fundamental freedoms. It may be the last piece of legislation of the present Government and it will go down in history as an act of treachery, a blot on our society, to the eternal shame and disgrace of Fianna Fáil. Fianna Fáil have reneged on all they stood and fought for during the years. The Taoiseach said he would not stand idly by. Tonight he is not standing idly by. He has obviously shifted his feet and has gone over to the other side, over to the Unionists. He has left the minority, of which he declared he would be the second guarantor, at the mercy of the Orange mobs. Bereft of hope, tonight they are defenceless and betrayed by Jack Lynch, his Government and his party. I do not believe this Government can be forgiven for such an act of national abasement.

The most disgusting aspect of this measure is the statement by Fianna Fáil that they need this draconian repressive legislation to maintain law and order, to put down the IRA and the subversive organisations. Fianna Fáil must think the people have very short memories. Only a short time ago there were sensational events in this House and it was revealed that the people who were undermining law and order and the security of the State were Fianna Fáil Ministers, Deputies and supporters. Not only did Fianna Fáil not take steps over the past three years to deal with subversion but we know in this House, and I know in particular as a member of the Public Accounts Committee, that they aided, and condoned subversion. Far from interfering in order to eliminate subversion they were clearly seen to interfere with the due process of law in 1969 and that interference with the courts and due process of law and the action of the police was such as to bring about the resignation of the then secretary of the Department of Justice who resigned in utter disgust.

Are the Irish people, are the Members of this House expected to forget the gun-running of 1969 in which so many of the Fianna Fáil Party Ministers and supporters were clearly involved? Did Government Ministers not give aid and succour to subversive organisations? Did they not give money and guns? Is this not a fact? Are we to take it that this is the party which is genuinely concerned about law and order? Apart altogether from the misappropriation of a large amount of public funds used in an endeavour to bring in a large consignment of arms to this country, is it not a fact that ordinary Fianna Fáil Party members gloated over going about in recent years and securing guns and arms anywhere they could and handing them over joyfully and gleefully to members of various organisations? We had that on the records of the House from an ex-member of the Fianna Fáil Party and now Aontacht Éireann Member, Deputy Sherwin.

They assisted by money and guns the organisation they now seek to outlaw and put down in this Bill, and they want us and the Irish people to accept that they are doing it in the interests of law and order. What right have this Government to talk about law and order? They fooled no one. Is it not a fact that after this Dáil had been elected in 1969 evidence very quickly emerged that Government Ministers were hellbent on taking over and controlling the IRA? Were Fianna Fáil not responsible for splitting the IRA and the Sinn Féin movement in a nefarious design to control one part of it and destroy the other?

Fianna Fáil must accept the main brunt of responsibility for the present state of affairs in our country. They cannot expect to be bailed out by the Labour Party or any other party. A Fianna Fáil Minister and a Government had the brazen audacity in recent days to sack the RTE Authority allegedly for presenting or preaching subversion on television and radio. The Government sacked that authority because it gave vent to the voice of republicanism and, at the same time, they allowed the voice of extreme Orangeism and Unionism to rant and rave on. They sacked the RTE Authority and they expect us to forget that in 1969, with the approval of certain Fianna Fáil Ministers—and I would say with the approval of the Government—they set about the establisment of a clandestine paper known as "The Voice of the North" to pump propaganda into north-east Ulster. A sizeable amount of public funds were misappropriated for that purpose, the purpose of subversion.

Comment on this

Without wishing to interrupt the Deputy, is it actually a fact that these funds were so misappropriated? Where has it so been declared and by whom?

Comment on this

I shall deal with that on another occasion when it comes to the debate on the report of the Committee of Public Accounts.

Comment on this

I am waiting on a reply. I am not interrupting but I do want clarification or correction or withdrawal.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): We had votes of confidence about that and the Deputy did not help.

Comment on this

Why do you not bring it on?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): We had a vote of confidence——

Comment on this

Where is the report?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan):—— and the Deputy had coffee during it.

Comment on this

Where is the full report?

Comment on this

This Government were prepared to embark upon this propaganda device and yet they now have the audacity to suppress the freedom of television, radio and press in this part of Ireland. It seems that the wheel has turned full circle in this regard. Fianna Fáil are fooling nobody; they want to create the impression that they alone are the saviours of law and order when everyone knows that Ministers and members of that Government were the first to undermine the security of this State and drag law and order into disrepute. This Bill is not merely designed to put down the IRA; it undermines the rights and the liberties of all our people. No citizen is free under this measure. No citizen is free from interrogation by a member of the Garda. No group can assemble or march peacefully any more without tending to violate this measure. No journalist can publish freely. Television and radio are clearly circumscribed. The fate of all of us now rests with the say-so of a chief superintendent of the Garda Síochána. If we are found to have been near a place where an offence was committed we must answer for our actions. We must give name and address, account for our movements, and if we talk we may incriminate ourselves. If we talk we are clearly becoming informers and if we do not talk we are deemed to be guilty anyway, and there is the penalty of £ 200 fine or 12 months in jail.

This is the kind of legislation we used to associate with Russia, Nazi Germany, Fascist Italy or the Smith regime in Rhodesia. This legislation has no place whatsoever in the lives of the Irish people and it will be resisted with all the power and influence at our disposal. It is bunkum for the Minister for Justice to talk about a fair trial or cross-examination of a chief superintendent. Was there ever an occasion in the long history of jurisprudence and court procedure when a judge failed to accept the word on oath of a superintendent or a chief superintendent of the Garda Síochána? It is simply not on.

This Bill is essentially despicable in that, for the first time, you are declared to be guilty until you prove yourself innocent. This is a radical change in the law and is repulsive to all sections of our people. Equality before the law is guaranteed in our Constitution and there are many who feel that this Bill is repugnant to the Constitution. It is no longer accepted that you are innocent until proved guilty, and the onus of proving innocence is placed on the individual, and the word of a chief superintendent will determine whether you are convicted or not.

This is typical Fianna Fáil legislation: shoot first and ask questions afterwards. Get them and put them away by fair or foul means. The Bill has far-reaching implications and has the features of a panic measure, a Bill conceived and drawn up in fear, the device of a frightened Government, frightened by an enemy, imaginary or otherwise, but if that enemy is there it is of Fianna Fáil's making.

Apart from the sacking of the board of Telefís Éireann, the freedom of the Press is severely interfered with in this Bill. The Press are clearly placed in an invidious position. They may not be clearly committing an offence under the Bill, as the Minister says, but they will certainly be open to criticism or far worse for publishing statements or photographs which may lead to the arrest, trial and conviction of people. In such a situation the Press are circumscribed. They will be slow to report events, meetings, marches and demonstrations, which are very largely proscribed in this Bill; and they will be slow to publish names, speeches and photographs lest they incriminate innocent people as well as guilty.

Section 4 of this Bill deals, in particular, with alleged interference with the course of justice. Public statements, oral or in writing, any meetings, processions, and demonstrations in public that constitute interference with the course of justice, are deemed to be unlawful under this measure. If this section of the Bill is passed any meeting, procession or demonstration is likely to be unlawful. No one seemingly, according to Fianna Fáil, will be allowed to protest about any issue whatsoever. No one will be allowed to protest, for instance, about the trial and sentence of Kevin O'Kelly or about the hunger strike of Seán Mac Stiofáin or anything else without incurring the displeasure of the Government and breaking the law. Tenants associations would be outside the law in demonstrating or protesting about evictions while a case for ejectment might be before the courts. This is an ominous piece of legislation for all organisations and for the trade union movement at large. The trade union movement are conscious of the inroads which this measure seeks to make into their liberty and they are not accepting it. The fines in respect of this measure are vicious. The sentences prescribed are vicious. The fines here are not £ 100, but £ 1,000. The sentence is not for one year, but for five years.

Freedom of association, of assembly, of speech and of the press are fundamental to our Irish way of life. They must be and will be maintained at all costs, come hell or high water. No piece of legislation which does not meet with the respect or approval of the mass of our people can work. This has been demonstrated on many occasions. This piece of legislation offends against all our highest principles and all cherished beliefs and fundamental rights. It cannot operate against the wishes of the majority of our people. It must not and will not be allowed to operate.

I trust that this Bill will be treated with the disdain and contempt by the mass of our people, which it deserves. Outside this House there is massed opposition to this legislation Inside the House there is a united opposition. There are some dissidents and defections from the Government party as well. It is true to say that many of the Fianna Fáil Party will vote for this measure with their feet and not with their hearts. If they had the courage of their convictions they would never lend their support to such a piece of repressive legislation.

The spirit of the Irish people would want to be stone dead to accept this measure or allow it to be implemented. All our national aims and cherished rights cannot and will not be filched away from us like this by a Government which have reneged on all they ever stood for. I believe that this piece of legislation will be seen for what it is—a piece of bluff and political window dressing to give a veneer of decency, solidarity and respectability to a tattered party. It will be seen for what it is—a piece of utter hypocrisy. Fundamentally, I believe that the Irish people will never bow the knee or be slaves to an arrogant, neo-Fascist regime.

This is a black day in the history of this Dáil. It is a black day in the history of the country because the blinds are coming down on freedom and democracy all around us. It is for us in these benches to ensure that the torch of liberty shines on. Fianna Fáil will soon realise that they cannot force the Irish people, north and south, to abandon national aims, total freedom and sovereignty. Ireland's historic claim is for total freedom and the Government which accept anything less will be repudiated by the Irish people. I am convinced of that.

Fianna Fáil are now seen for what they are—the Unionist Party of Southern Ireland. They have the same designs for power in perpetuity. They have the same desire to bend the institutions of our State towards their own ends. I am pleased to speak from these benches here tonight and to pledge the implacable opposition of the Labour Party to this despicable measure. We will fight it at every Stage. We will fight it by any means at our disposal. We are confident that, when the Irish people get the opportunity, they will reject outright the Government which sought to impose this despicable measure on them.

Comment on this

This proposed legislation which we have before us now is certainly, for all of us, rather a shock. It is a shock because there does not seem to be the slightest reason why any additional laws of repression are needed in this country at the moment. It is a surprise because of the fact that the laws which we now have have been successfully bent in these recent months and years in order to try to put away those who did not agree with the outlook of the establishment—which is rather a new outlook—as has been remarked by many speakers tonight. That we should have it raises the first question in my mind. Why should we have this sort of legislation? Who wants it? What is the need for it? Is there any true, clear indication given by the Minister why, even as he sees things at the moment, he needs further laws in order not just to prosecute Republicans and their sympathisers in this country but to persecute them?

How can we possibly listen with any sort of quiet on our part to a Minister talking, on behalf of the Government, about the weaknesses that they have discovered in the laws? How can we listen to a further spokesman for the Government explaining, when he was asked why did they not tell the Opposition what the weaknesses were so that they could get together and sort them out, that, if they did that, and if they made known what the weaknesses were, the subversives and others would take advantage of those weaknesses to do still greater depredation? Can anybody seriously consider those two attitudes from two front bench members of the Government? Can anybody regard them with anything but distaste and distrust in the knowledge that both must be dishonest. We ask ourselves has the law not worked beyond that which it was ever intended to do when we find the like of Máire Drumm being released two days ago, after spending 22 days in custody for a statement alleged to have been made by her last St. Patrick's Day, a statement which was said to be an incitement. An incitement to what? An incitement to whose disadvantage? Máire Drumm at that time, as far as I know, and I have the very great privilege of knowing this lady for a considerable time, had two sons and her husband interned. I thank the gentleman of the liberal Labour Party who made the scathing remark, if it was a member of the Labour Party.

Comment on this

I said the Deputy was welcome.

Comment on this

I could have guessed. It could not have been anybody else in the Labour Party who would have that attitude in circumstances such as this. Máire Drumm was 22 days in custody, awaiting trial for something she said on St. Patrick's Day, something which apparently displeased the Occupation Forces and the Crown representatives in the Six Counties and across in Westminster. We had to nail this lady down in order to placate those people whom we now seem to be collaborating with and with whom we seem to be in collusion in order to try to beat the last vestiges of republicanism out of the people in this part of the country and in the Six Counties as well. Is the law that could bring this about defective? This lady had two sons and her husband interned at that particular time.

Without going into any of the gory details which could be added with regard to the tortures and the treatment to which these people were subjected, and which we here hypocritically are protesting about by way of a case stated to the Court of Human Rights, is our law so defective that it can do that to which I have referred in those circumstances after all these months? Is there not something very wrong with a law that allows this sort of thing to happen in those circumstances? Is there not something wrong with that law when a man can be served on 23rd June with a summons relating to an alleged statement made by him on the previous 9th September? I saw that summons issued to a constituent of mine. The 23rd June was the first he heard of an intended prosecution and of that to which it was alleged to refer. The statement was said to be inciting and he was taken before the courts and charged. In all truth and honesty, no man, after nine months, without notice of prosecution, could possibly recall what he said, could possibly, in all genuineness, either affirm or deny what he had or had not said at that particular time, or day, or date nine months previously.

What are we trying to do? Who are we trying to suppress? Whom are we trying to please? This is really what comes through from all these things and this is far removed from the attitude of the Fine Gael Party, who allege that the laws are adequate but are not being applied. I reckon they are more than adequate and they are being rigorously, too rigorously, applied. It is not more of these laws we need at this particular time. After the three horrible, tragic years in the north-east of this country of ours, without any real trouble descending upon us, much though we deserved it, we should now be gladly considering the wiping out and the deletion from our Statute Book of the mother and father of this amendment, the Offences Against the State Act, 1939, and the amending Act of 1940. We do not need them. That has been proved beyond any doubt. There is no need for any of these laws at this time and, if ever there was a time of testing to find whether or not they were needed, surely to God the last three years has been that time.

Do we want, following the wild fantasies of the Minister for Justice, to provoke trouble in this country to justify the laws and the abuse of those laws, the abuse that has already occurred, by bringing in yet more repressive laws in order deliberately to provoke? Is this Bill, in fact, part of a plot hatched over the last ten days in which the arrest of Mac Stiofáin was to be the catalyst to bring about trouble in the streets of Dublin and make it so that no Member of this House could, in the light of the outcry that would bring from the public, vote against the Bill?

Maybe I am being very cynical and maybe not, but there is a fair belief in the minds of many people that this is why Mac Stiofáin could be arrested a couple of weeks after the Minister for Justice stood up here or, perhaps, elsewhere—I do not remember—and, on being chided as to why this man could freely come and go to the Sinn Féin Árd Fheis in Liberty Hall, stated that there was no case against him. I want to know what did he do since then that made it possible for a case to be taken against him? I want to know why whatever it was that he had done was not produced in evidence when he was prosecuted only a week ago. I want to know of what he was convicted. I want to know what the evidence was and how it came about. I think we will be asking these questions for quite a long time before we eventually get the answers. Unfortunately it will not be soon enough to thwart the efforts of the present Government to further provoke a situation that will bring them into the realm they now claim to be in, the realm of the protectors of the peace and the guardians of law and order. In fact, there is no danger of any kind except of their own imagining or of their own making.

We sat here during the night hours 2½ years or more ago and we listened then to the most dishonest prognostications and scare stories from the Fianna Fáil front bench about the imminent danger of civil war. Dear God, surely the time since then has proven that those statements were abject lies at that time, that there was no truth whatever in them. In fact, there is no truth in them today, except that danger is possibly nearer because of the attitude of the Government, the Government which have reversed their engines completely and absolutely and are now trying to justify their doing so by letting down and betraying the friends of those days, the friends they now call the enemies of the people.

This is the background to this sordid, repressive piece of proposed legislation. This is what was brought into this House yesterday and today, and it is being supported by speeches, some of them no doubt well meant, and made in good faith as a result of listening to "his master's voice" but without real thought, without real examination, without people asking themselves are these repressive, nasty, new laws really necessary. Is there one indication, is there one iota of evidence—and you would need a lot— to support the plea that further and more repressive laws are needed and that these laws, even if they infringe the rights of the people deeply and gravely, are justified because of the situation, the crisis, the emergency that exists in our community?

I say there is no crisis. I say there is no emergency and there has not been for the past three years. There will not be, provided the people in Government today have enough sense to fall back even at this late stage, and realise that they have allowed their enthusiasm in their new found antagonism towards republican ideals, to run away with them. I tell them sincerely, and in order to avoid the trouble that they are allegedly trying to prevent, that the surest and truest way of getting real trouble in this country is to impose that sort of law unnecessarily on a freedom loving people.

Those who try to put this across on our people will have a lot to answer for if they succeed. I only hope they do not, for their own sake as well as the sake of the rest of the people. I believe that, if this is enacted, we will really get a taste of what we have been turning our backs on, and not wanting to see although it was there, in the Six Counties for the past three years. Cannot we get a little sanity even at this late stage? It would not be a loss of face for any Government to recognise the plea of the people on the streets, well behaved, remember, despite the emotive and emotional circumstances of last weekend. Surely if any proof was needed by the Government that there is no intention and no wish and no desire to have bloodshed on the streets of Dublin or any other part of the Twenty-six Counties, that peaceful demonstration which went off with thousands there coming out, without any planned arrangements, from all walks of life, should be positive proof that there is no need for this sort of legislation.

Last night there were a couple of thousand gardaí and troops surrounding this place from the early afternoon while it was still bright, and not a being out there on the streets, but with the gates closed as if we were under siege. I remarked to some of the people I met when I saw this: "The only thing they must be trying to keep out is the rain," because it was raining very heavily. Nobody was trying to break the place down. Nobody was attempting to do so.

Surely it is a well-known and well established fact that, if the Establishment of any country, and particularly in a democracy, show that they are expecting and, indeed, almost welcoming this sort of disorder, then it follows very often that they get it. Make the preparations so obvious and you raise in the minds of people who otherwise would not in any way be disorderly an antagonism that may bring them out in large numbers to do things they had no wish or intention to do. Last night's display of strength around this House was, wittingly or otherwise, most provocative. Despite the provocation, and despite the fact that thousands turned up, despite the deluge of rain, I have not heard even from the most prejudiced source that there was any cause for complaint about the overall behaviour of that large crowd.

Surely this must be evidence to the Government that this sort of law is unnecessary. It must be further evidence that a great wave of feeling is developing throughout the country, in all walks of life and amongst all sorts of people and, indeed, funnily enough, more so in the more adult population, than in the younger population, against this sort of suppression. Surely the Government must be aware of this through their contacts throughout the country. Surely they are not blind to the signs. The real danger is emerging now and they are, wittingly or unwittingly, provoking it. It is being provoked; do not let us have any doubt about that.

We hear some rare explanations of this Bill. I was, perhaps, fortunate enough to listen to the explanation by the Minister for Transport and Power this evening. As soon as I heard he was on I said: "That is for me. This will be no problem." Neither was it. There is no doubt about it: the veneer was there, put on, polished up and put across, but still falling very far short of being convincing.

Comment on this

He is not biting.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Gone are the days.

Comment on this

He dealt with the two subsections which apparently it boils down to the only ones objectionable to Fine Gael and he dealt very glibly with the protection for the public and defendants which are inherent in the Bill. Perhaps I might be wronging the Minister if I say he claimed they were inherent in the Bill, but he rubbed it along that they were inherent in our present laws. You could not lose——

Comment on this

He is going to bite.

Comment on this

The fact is that their protection is this. A chief superintendent is informed by his superintendent, who is informed by his inspector, who got it from the station sergeant, who got it from the sergeant on the beat, who got it from the garda, who got it from a tout who is paid on results. Let us not minimise it. This is the fact. I am not belittling the Garda. I am belittling the defence that has been made by the Minister and others of the non-hurtful nature of the subsections in this proposed legislation. That chief superintendent will come in, in those circumstances. Let us suppose it was the name Des Foley which came up seven, eight or nine stages from the tout down the line. The fact is that the chief superintendent puts the finger out and says that Foley is, in fact, as far as he believes a member of an illegal organisation.

Comment on this

Behold the man.

Comment on this

His defence and safeguards are these according to what we have been told tonight. He may deny the charge, I presume not in writing or by a telephone call from some distant place. He will do it if he chooses to do it by going into the witness box under oath. Right?

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

Yes.

Comment on this

The silence has been broken.

Comment on this

What follows from that is that, if he wishes to deny a baseless charge, he is compelled to go into the witness box, a layman without any experience of courts or their proceedings, and he is then laid open to the legal wolves who will be set upon him by the State who wish to name anybody they feel should be put out of the way.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

What about the courts? The independent courts?

Comment on this

If the Minister and others in his Government are so concerned about the independence of the courts, why did they find it necessary to set up special courts without jury trial?

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

Composed of judges.

Comment on this

Which ball game is the Minister in now?

Comment on this

One of the reasons advanced to me by the Minister for Justice at the time was that the special courts procedure would help to get on with the business of the courts which was then in bad arrears. I asked at the time how do you proceed to make up a backlog of business that is already there in the operation of our courts of justice by putting three men doing one man's job and removing jury trial in cases of this kind of offence. That is only as a digression from the two arguments advanced as to the safeguards that exist for a person brought before the court. I am not sure as to whether or not this also includes being brought before the special court. That has not emerged as yet. I should like to be informed as to whether the special court will be the court or one of the courts before which the chief superintendent will point the finger and say on information seven or eight times removed so-and-so is a member of an illegal organisation and the person goes into the box, very annoyed, and says: "I am not a member. I have never been a member and have no intention of becoming a member" and then we have the boys at him. Before they let him out of there the possibility is they will in one shape or another have elicited more from him, to his own detriment and against his own defence than was against him when the chief superintendent put his finger on him in the first place.

Secondly, we have the great and much lauded advantage of the chief superintendent, if you do not mind, being cross-examined. Who do the people in the front bench who have advanced this as a reason think they are codding? It just does not operate that way and every Member who said otherwise knows it does not operate that way and that the chief superintendent will, in fact, as he is wont to do in all cases, claim privilege. I saw a chief superintendent not so very long ago in the Four Courts claiming privilege. Is that same chief superintendent of the Special Branch the chief superintendent that this law is being passed to use and not the ordinary decent chief superintendents throughout the country and have we to bring in the other 22 or 23 in order to give to this chief superintendent the power to put people away at his dictates or on the instructions or whispers of the desires of his political bosses?

Can we have a clear picture? If this should, unfortunately, go through and is not withdrawn, which would be the sensible thing to do, are we going to have the chief superintentdent, the boss of the Special Branch, operating this law in his own particular, peculiar, special way? Are we going to have such a man as has indicated in the court that as the day changes and the weather changes so could he change his evidence on oath? Are we prepared to give to such a man who before our own committee set up by this House made absolutely dishonest and untrue allegations this overall power?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not single out an individual for criticism in the House. The individual has no opportunity of replying to the Deputy.

Comment on this

I appreciate this but the trouble is there is only one of them and it is like saying: "The lord mayor of this town, who shall be nameless". This is the dilemma I am in.

Comment on this

There is no lord mayor. Your crowd sacked him.

Comment on this

This is the same man, whose position, perhaps rightly, has been defended by the custodian of order in this House, who took it on himself to make his foul and untrue and dishonest allegations and to name people where they had no opportunity of defending themselves when he was sitting down in that room being heard by this committee. If we had nothing else to go on but our knowledge of this man, surely that would be sufficient to say "Stop". Even if the law was needed, this man should be excluded from the use of it even if the other 22 chief superintendents were entitled to use it.

Are we then going to bring about a catastrophe? For what unknown, obscure reason is it being attempted to be perpetrated at this time? Why are we trying to provoke by over suppressing the already suppressed? Why should this be so? What is the need for it? These are questions that the Government must have asked themselves before they came to a decision even to consider doing this. It was said here tonight by a Government speaker that this was not of the Government's making, that this thought came from the permanent law officers or law officer, those who are practised in and have had long experience of operating the laws of this land, that it was they who found the defects in our law to be to such a degree that they were able to convince, the Minister for Justice presumably, and he in turn convinced the Government, no doubt after a great struggle, that the law was so defective that he needed much more severe, repressive legislation.

Did the Government at that time really go into this need that was alleged to exist by these very silent and well practised and long experienced law officers? Were they thoroughly cross-examined, if not by all of the members of the Cabinet, at least by the members who are also members of the legal profession? Were they made to justify the suggestion that there had been a disastrous lack of application of law due to a lack of law or a weakness in our laws over the recent years? Has that been attempted to be done? Was it sought? Why has the House not been given the benefit in detail and the case samples of what brought this necessity upon us? That is the very least that would be expected from any body, Government or otherwise, who would at this time attempt to bring into existence laws which, because they are unnecessary, bring only trouble in their train rather than, as is claimed, settle things so that there will be no more bother.

There is not much bother. There was far more bother four, five, six, seven years ago on many occasions than we have seen in these recent times. In fact, the times are quite quiet, despite the fact that we have the odd explosion taking place now south of the Border and that the very well-known UDA organisation are actually facilitating us by claiming credit, or otherwise, for them and that, by some strange device, people divine that it is not the people who have claimed to have done what would seem to them logical to do, by blowing up something on this side of the Border, but we are informed by reason of some mysterious divine insight that it was the IRA who were responsible. There was a bomb explosion in a public house in St. Johnston in my constituency. It was not very serious but, perhaps, its implications were great. The UDA claimed responsibility for it but despite that a statement was issued 24 hours later to the effect that the Garda believed that the IRA were responsible. Was it not quick work to disbelieve the UDA and place the blame on the IRA? However, there has not been one shred of evidence since to indicate that the IRA were responsible and neither has there been any sign of a prosecution being brought. I suggest to the Minister that he pass the case to the Minister for Justice. Without any great perceptive ability in the field of detection, if the Minister were to ;7spend a day in St. Johnston I am sure he would come back with the names of the people who were responsible for that explosion and they are not in the IRA, whatever else they may be in.

What is the end product desired by these efforts on the part of the Government? The same sort of situation arose last week-end after the unfortunate incident in Dublin. While there was no claim for responsibility for that, we were told that the IRA were responsible. If there is no evidence to support that claim why was it made? Why do we go out of our way in this manner? It is to try to nail people or organisations while not producing any evidence to sustain the allegations. If there is evidence, let us have it but if there is not let there be silence at least until sufficient evidence to back such claims would come to light. Are we so imbued in following the propaganda machine that almost continuously spews out anti-Republican, pro-Unionist propaganda from Lisburn that we can see any happening only as the work of the IRA? This is the manner in which the Lisburn propaganda machine works. It is well known that some of those in the Press who have the temerity to keep in touch continuously with these people for the purpose of obtaining whatever handouts are available, are given tomorrow's news today because a story is written already to cover any eventuality and in all cases the culprits are the IRA.

Do we recall a few weeks ago an incident when a lad of about 14 was shot for allegedly shooting at the army. It was reported here immediately that when the lad dropped his rifle a woman who was standing by grabbed it and ran away with it but that when she was shouted at to halt she was shot. That story came from Lisburn. It was the story that our media were expected to put out straight away but a couple of hours later there was a denial from the army that the incident had taken place as described in the report and that the woman was an innocent by-stander who was shot accidentally by one of the soldiers or by somebody else. These are isolated but typical cases of what is going on there day after day and we here through our blinkered outlook are only too ready to take what we get from there and give it the first flush of publicity. No matter what denials emerge, the lies are never corrected. Why do we not suppress this sort of news? Why do we not put a stop on a story until somebody whom we know would make some inquiries through the sources best known to them had done so? Why do we issue these handouts to our own radio and television media without making an effort to establish the truth from the pressman on the ground or even from the representatives up there of our own media? All the time we run out with hands up to help those who would put an end to the whole concept of unity for this country. Why must a native Irish government representing the people of 26 of our counties behave in this way?

I know the members of the Government individually and I can ask with, perhaps, more wonder and amazement than people on the other side of the House can realise what has gone wrong with the Government. For a time I may have been annoyed but now I am utterly amazed as to what happened and I am saddened by it. Even on this very serious problem and at this late stage could they even attempt to explain what has brought about this behaviour on their part? If they made such an attempt, perhaps we would be able to see that we err in our ways and not they in theirs. However, we have not had explanations. Occasionally we are abused or are subjected to snide remarks or criticism but there is never any question of explanation as to how this amazing change came about to such a degree that the members of that party with whom I have worked and who I admired and was glad to work with——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Hear, hear.

Comment on this

——have changed so much that I do not know them any more and I certainly do not understand them. Is the lack on my part or on theirs? Is the lack on the part of the few of us here because we are few and must they be right? If that is so, perhaps we might be given an explanation that would remove the scales from our eyes and permit us to see as, apparently, the majority see but which they see in a manner that is very different from the way in which I see the situation and in which they saw it only a few years ago.

I have asked what is this Bill. In my humble estimation it is a provocative, repressive and ugly proposal to enable to be put out of the way some few persons that others have feared and who now cannot be silenced or put away. That is the only possible answer one is left with but, difficult as that is to believe, what is the alternative? Why is the Bill necessary? From where did it emanate? Above all, I warn of the great danger of total disaster that would follow the enactment of this Bill. I am not saying this by way of agreement or disagreement with it. I say it as my firm conviction, my firm belief, that disaster is very likely to follow if this legislation goes on the statute book. I do so because of the fact that, as I pointed out already, there has not been any evidence that our present laws are inadequate. To me the application of them has indicated that they are more than adequate. Even if they were inclined to be wanting in certain directions, steps have been taken to take the short cuts and get ourselves away from the botheration of jury trials. What the hell do they know about things? They do not count when there is pressure on. It is a different matter when times are such that you can take up their time, waste their time and pay them nothing for it.

When it comes down to the liberty of many subjects, as the case may be here, then away with the juries, set up the special courts, utilise three judges and then add three or four more on as reserves. This is a better way to carry out the law than the existing system of law as it is being practised—the time-worn practice of the judge and his jury sitting and deliberating and finally deciding how the justice of the case should stand. We have these three or four reserves and we have backlogs of cases of the ordinary nature in our courts but I do not hear any outcry about the backlog now. I do not hear it being advanced any more as a reason for bringing in special courts that would speed up things.

I ask now, as I asked then how do you speed up the administration of justice in our courts by putting three judges to do the job which one did before this? Maybe there is a new method, maybe there is a new sort of analysis carried out by the Government through some of their agencies that has found a way in which you employ more people doing the same job at the same time and you get a bigger work out-turn as a result. That applies to machines and mass-production but I do not think it applies to the administration of justice in our courts and I do not think it was intended. I think it was a shortcut not for the administration of justice but perhaps in order that the laws should be stretched to their limits, that the ordinary uneducated, perhaps somewhat ignorant and backward jurymen would not be able to appreciate or understand and contribute their share to the manipulations.

Is that why we have these? Are they any different to that which we condemn in the Six Counties today? Is there any difference between this proposal in this Bill and the internment which was mooted by the Taoiseach nearly two years ago and was then taken up and put into operation by the fools in Britain? It was not followed here at that time; but it is, in my estimation, being followed now and followed in a way that is far more repugnant, far more dangerous, than ever straightforward internment could be, because this is internment by subterfuge. This is internment by passing the buck down to your 23 chief superintendents and giving it a veneer of having the laws of the land applied to it. A false veneer—something nasty and totally repugnant to any freedom-loving people—is being given to this. If you want internment, why the hell do you not stand up and give it to us? Stop this sham. If it is internment I am asking: is that what you want? I see the Minister for Transport and Power nodding his head.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

I assume the Deputy wants internment. We do not want that.

Comment on this

Do not forget you used it before.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): And so did Deputy Blaney as a member of the Government.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Blaney without interruption.

Comment on this

If it were not for the Labour Party—four of us were expelled—we would have had it. We stopped you from introducing internment.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The founder of Aontacht Éireann was Minister for Defence.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

Let you all fight it out among yourselves.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Blaney is in possession. He should be allowed to speak.

Comment on this

This is naked, cold-blooded internment and nothing else.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

Fight it out among yourselves and the people will decide.

Comment on this

The Minister has been very quiet during the last 25 minutes. I wonder why?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Will the Deputy cease interrupting.

Comment on this

He is just supporting. That is all he is doing.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

Let you fight it out among yourselves.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Interruptions are disorderly and they must cease.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): In 1970 the Minister for Transport and Power did not know whether or not to come in behind the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

That was a different ball game.

Comment on this

The Deputy will never come in behind the Taoiseach.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Blaney. Interruptions from any side of the House are not in order.

Comment on this

The Minister knows what ball game I am talking about.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair will not allow this kind of thing to continue.

Comment on this

Lest I should forget, I want to comment and reply to the Minister's misconception of what I was saying. I do not want internment. I do not reckon there is any reason or need in any circumstances whatsoever for internment. At least we are agreed this far. If we get you the rest of the way the job will be right.

Comment on this

I am sorry if I seem rather ponderous in trying to get this across but, having established that neither the Minister nor I want internment under any circumstances, would he please use his best endeavours and influence to convince his colleagues, and particularly the Minister for Justice, not to introduce internment by subterfuge as is inherent in the proposal now before us. If it is a case that the Minister for Justice cannot be prevailed on to realise that internment is not needed and if the majority of the Government back his view, despite the best endeavours of the Minister for Transport and Power to convince them otherwise, then I would ask that he would switch his attack and plead that they should seek internment openly and honestly, in the interests of the public, who would then clearly understand what they were now being confronted with.

Comment on this
A Deputy

A good election issue.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

I certainly do not intend to follow that role of recommending internment, as suggested by Deputy Blaney.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Interruptions must cease. Deputy Blaney is in possession.

Comment on this

It is presumptuous of me to say so but I seem to have been one of the very few Ministers at that crucial time who was honest.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Will Deputies please cease interrupting and allow Deputy Blaney to continue?

Comment on this

In deference to Deputy Cowen, it is amazing how news travels fast, and particularly good news. I am not surprised at the Deputy being rather riled at my not liking this particular legislation. The other night in his constituency he was confronted by a number of his constituents perhaps at a Fianna Fáil meeting—I am not sure as I do not get to the official ones any more—he was asked and the Deputy can deny this if he wants to——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Will Deputies please cease interrupting?

Comment on this

The Deputy will have the opportunity of denying this: when he was taxed and asked by some of his constituents, acquaintances or friends or all the lot rolled in together, whether he should not, in the interests of the public and of justice, vote against the Bill that is now before us, he replied that if he had ten votes they would go for it. I believe this. I am like the chief superintendent. I only heard it from two or three down the line. I am not concerned whether the Deputy is worried or not. I am merely giving him the opportunity of denying it, as he is prepared to give to the defendant under this Bill the opportunity to deny when the chief superintendent says: "I believe what I heard from several removes from me down the line". I heard it and I believe that that was the Deputy's answer to his own constituents who asked him and taxed him not to support it and he said that if he had ten votes he would not give one against this Bill.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

Cut out the comic opera.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Blaney on the Bill.

Comment on this

On a point of order, is it not true that Deputy Blaney was a member of the Government that introduced internment in 1957?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

That is not a point of order.

Comment on this

From that I gather that there is hope. It would seem from that interjection that Deputy Cowen believes that it was then wrong to do it so why should it be done dishonestly now and that is what he is voting for in this Bill.

Comment on this

Sit down, you renegade.

Comment on this

May I say, in fairness to Deputy Cowen——

Comment on this

You know an awful lot about Deputy Cowen in a short time.

Comment on this

Go in and vote for Fine Gael and forget about it.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Interruptions are disorderly.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I do not want to help you with your job, but could I appeal for an audience for the ex-Fianna Fáil Minister?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

That is not a point of order. The Chair is doing what it can. Deputy Blaney.

Comment on this

You are all very worried over there. What is wrong? Is he sticking the knife in too far? Are you afraid there is something coming?

Comment on this
Deputies

No.

Comment on this

We are not afraid of anyone.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Go back and kiss the bride again.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

There is certainly one thing about the Deputies in general at the moment. They have not much regard for order in the House—Deputies on any side of the House.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The House is supposed to be discussing a serious measure at the moment and the House is not allowing a Deputy in possession to make his contribution. If Deputies would allow the Deputy in possession to make his contribution then, perhaps, we could carry on this as a serious debate.

Comment on this

Thank you very much, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle. There was a suggestion that the comedy should finish and I quite agree but the trouble is that it was the arch-comic on the front bench who made the suggestion and nobody should recognise the comedy of things better than he does. I would say to those who feel annoyed that an ex-Minister should get a bad time that I am not getting a bad time. In fact, it would appear from the come back from over there that some people feel that they are getting a bad time. That is not intended either. It is purely accidental, no more.

Going back to this matter, I wanted to say in deference to Deputy Cowen's short while in this House, that he is not the only one, he is not the only Deputy in Fianna Fáil, and you know that from talking to them. There is a whole lot more of them getting the same razz all around the country at the moment. He was not an exception. I just happened to hear about it and I happened to hear about his reply. That is the only difference.

Comment on this

If the Deputy was told that was the reply I made he got very false and wrong information.

Comment on this

I asked the Deputy to deny it and he did not.

Comment on this

I deny it now.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

Should Deputy Blaney address remarks across the House to another Deputy?

Comment on this

I am glad to have given the opportunity to Deputy Cowen to indicate that if he had ten votes he would give some of them against the Bill.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Blaney.

Comment on this

I suppose I was like the Deputy at one time too. He is easily "riz" and hard to settle.

Comment on this

If I was in Fianna Fáil as long as you were——

Comment on this

Nobody cast any aspersions on the Deputy's membership of Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Personal remarks across the House are not in order.

Comment on this

Without even the good manners to be orderly because nobody is supposed to speak from the passages in this House. They are supposed to be in their places. However, that is neither here nor there in regard to, as the Chair has said, a very serious matter. I want to go back to the internment that is inherent in the repressive proposals in this Bill. I am seriously asking the Minister again to ensure that we do not have this Bill carried through into the Statute Book. I ask him to do it because I believe it is unnecessary, it can only bring trouble. It is not doing anything for the country today or will not tomorrow. It is doing a great deal of damage to it in that it is interfering, in a very definite way, with the rights of the individuals and the citizens of this part of the country where, God knows, over the centuries we have had enough repression. Surely we do not have to continue it now that we are in charge of our own affairs, or are we in charge of our own affairs or are we being instructed what to do? Could this possibly be an explanation of what seems otherwise inexplicable? Can it be that this Bill is in order to satisfy the demands that are being made, wrongfully, by spokesmen for the Unionists in the Six Counties, by spokesmen for the government in Britain and by the British Premier himself asking that we should do more than we are doing on this side of the Border to suppress the IRA? I think these people have a bloody cheek because the fact is that with the small number of forces at our disposal, with all the inadequacies of the law that we have heard enumerated here but not in detail, with the small number of gardaí that we have, compare your performance against your own countrymen and your own republican brethren with the huge build-up of 21,000-plus troops in the Six Counties, the inflated number of RUC and their reserves and add to it, the UDR in collusion in many cases with the UVF and UDA. If they cannot manage their own little area above, why should those people demand that we should be doing it for them? If they cannot do it, should they not be told to go and take a jump at themselves when they come crying here that we are not doing enough? We are doing too damn much in my estimation to repress and suppress people who are fleeing from the terror, the torment and the torture, the internment and the jailings, the hammerings, and the batterings. We are fastening on their backs when they come here in order to ensure that it will be worse if they attempt to come in here than if they stayed where they were and took their chance.

They have a damn cheek to be talking about and abusing an Irish Government no matter what I might think of them individually or collectively, with their huge build-up of armaments, their army and all the rest. Everything that science can produce they have there and what are they doing? They are crying that we are not doing enough for them down here. They should be told to take a big long jump at themselves and should be told at the same time to get to hell out of this country, because there has never been or never will be peace while they remain as the conquerors and occupiers of lands that are not theirs. This is what they understand and they are bamboozled and confused and misled by the attitude of an Irish Government in this day and age who would appear to be supporters of the idea that the union must stand, that the army must remain and that Irish men and women of these 32 counties could not find out and work out their own salvation.

I do not believe it. I believe that is the method that has been used, along with others, to keep our people apart, to create the difference, to create the divide. We should be telling them to "hump off" and to mind their own business, to get out of the land, to get out of the country, to make a good resolution at this stage to say they are going and to stop provoking the Unionists into the belief that they are going to stay for ever and that they are going to sustain them with their millions and to defend them with their army. That is why there can be no discussion, no reasoned discussion, between the Orange and the Green in the Six Counties, because Britain's dirty paws are still on the table between them. Why do you not tell them that instead of collaborating with them?

Comment on this

There is no collaboration.

Comment on this

There is collaboration, and you know it and you must fear it more than anybody else in this House with the record you have, a record which we all honour and which inspired many of us to have the views we now have. There is collaboration on every indication of evidence there is between our forces and the forces of the Crown and the occupation, all of it designed to suppress, to harass and to set back the chances of bringing——

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

In what way is this relevant?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Perhaps the Deputy will relate this to the Bill.

Comment on this

The Minister cannot take it.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

Oh, you shut up. We are talking about a Bill here.

Comment on this

On a point of order, is it in order for a Minister——

Comment on this

These interruptions are designed to put me off but——

Comment on this

On a point of order, is it in order for a Minister to tell a Deputy twice to shut up?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Suppression of free speech.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Interruptions in this House are so frequent that many times even the Chair does not hear what is going on.

Comment on this

On a further point of order, this is not what Deputy Donegan asked. He asked was it in order for the Minister to say this. He did not necessarily ask if you heard it. We all heard it. Is it in order for the Minister to tell a Deputy to shut up twice?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair never answers theoretical questions.

Comment on this

Is it the situation——

Comment on this

Will the Minister agree to retract or confirm or deny?

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

If you have no sense of humour, that is your problem.

Comment on this

As I was saying when I was——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): So rudely interrupted.

Comment on this

No—interrupted in the usual manner. There is this sad sort of situation which again rather befuddles me, to say the least, and annoys me a great deal, that we undoubtedly do not know what is happening in the territory north of the line which is the unnatural division we know as the Border, and in so far as this Bill is concerned, I take it that, in keeping with our constitutional claims, we would if we got the opportunity, apply it to the Six County residents as well.

What I am trying to put is this, that we are not doing ourselves any good in the eyes of the people we are seeking to unite in the Six Counties and who desire unity as much as anybody down here, by passing legislation such as is here proposed because it is only natural that they should expect that if unity came about, that sort of repressive law would apply to them as it is now proposed to apply to us, because our Constitution does say that we lay claim to the whole territory and regard every citizen as a citizen thereof.

This is surely bad in itself, but worse still, it must now have infiltrated into the mind of the Government, as a result of this and the repression which has already taken place under our all too adequate laws, that we are using down here at the moment to repress republican outlook and feeling and people, that developing in the Six County minority public mind over the recent past particularly is a most unusual happening, that is, one of total disenchantment, if not disgust, with the whole thought of ever having anything to do with an Irish Government based in Dublin. I say this with the greatest regret and sadness, but it is a fact. This is, in fact, what is now becoming the public mind and outlook of the minority in the Six Counties, and perhaps the only possible ray of sunshine that might relieve the gloom created by that strange happening is that by a strange perversity perhaps, a strange coincidence, almost at the same time but no doubt for very different reasons, there is a disenchantment taking place amongst the most apt and rapt Unionists with their bosses as they now see them beginning to emerge from Westminster. Maybe in a queer, perverse and inexplicable way with these changes from the friendship and thoughts of fellowship that existed between the minority in the Six Counties and their brethren, as it were, in the South, they are now being disenchanted, looking away from them, and side by side with them the Unionists are beginning to become disenchanted with the British because they feel they are pushing them around a wee bit at the moment and they are not used in Unionist circles to being pushed around in the Six Counties. Maybe it is that this may well be in a queer, perverse, accidental way the beginning of a common bond between the people of conviction on both sides in the Six Counties and arising from it there yet may be emerging a hope that we can have the beginning of unity. It is my conviction that there cannot be any real settlement of this matter until the people of extreme views on both sides get together, not the moderates in the middle, not the people who change with whatever way the wind blows, not the people who think it is too much bother to change things. What we are doing here will not be seen as helping to achieve the unity of our country. Rather it will be seen as the result of policies that should not have been pursued here, policies that are a betrayal of the minority in the Six Counties.

Can we wonder that the people in the Six Counties have a growing disenchantment with the idea of a Dublin and all-Ireland Government? Can we blame them for their feeling of revulsion at what is contained in this Bill, namely, the provision to suppress and lock up those who may be driven by political circumstances and pressure in the Six Counties to flee across the Border? Can we blame the people in the Six Counties for looking askance at us and wondering if we are really concerned about their welfare or about the unity of our country? These are real problems but the answer being suggested to the people in the Six Counties is that we do not want them in the South, that we should prefer them to remain with their troubles in the North rather than embroil us or disturb us in a happy slumber into which we have fallen. Compared with our economic state some 30 years ago we now enjoy a certain affluence and it appears we are afraid we will lose some of that affluence if we have to share it with those people of all religions in the Six Counties who are just as Irish as we are.

Why have we developed this selfish outlook, this lack of concern over the one matter that stands out like a sore thumb, namely, the partition of our country? Partition was created by a foreign power, against the wishes of the vast majority of our people. For 50 years the Unionist junta have enacted oppressive legislation against the people in the Six Counties. Why do we not abolish our Offences Against the State Act instead of making our legislation more oppressive? This is what we should be doing as an assurance not only to the minority in the Six Counties but to the majority, to show them that we do not desire to have repressive legislation on our statute book.

In recent days John Brooke has indicated his disagreement with what is proposed in this Bill. However, there may be a brighter side in that John Brooke and others like him, despite their statement of non-concern, are concerned about what we do on this side of the Border because of their deep inner convictions that they are Irish, that the whole of the island is Ireland and that they belong to it as much as we do, that Dublin is part of their heritage as it is of ours. Maybe this is the hopeful message we can get from the condemnation by John Brooke, but is it not sad that a man in his position is forced to indicate he does not consider it is good legislation? If Mr. Brooke found it necessary to express even mild dislike of the Bill, surely our Government and Parliament should have no illusions about the trouble we are creating and the wrong we will do if this legislation is enacted.

I would ask that this Bill be withdrawn. As the Opposition have stated already, if there are real problems in the administration of law here these could be considered and settled. If the Bill is withdrawn I would not regard it as a loss of face for the Government or as a lessening of the stature of the Government. In view of the speeches made here and the messages that have been pouring in from all sections, if the Bill were withdrawn it would not be so regarded. Rather it would increase their stature because, for once, it would be seen that they stopped and said: "We may think this legislation is right but so many think it is wrong we will take it out. We can live without it as we have done up to now and will talk to the Opposition about our problems regarding the inadequacy of the law". If the Government adopted this course and sought the expertise of the Opposition in this matter this would be of considerable benefit and would fill whatever gaps may exist in the law.

I do not think there are any gaps. When law becomes too closed up and tight it gets stuffy and that is what will happen here. However, if it were possible for the Government and the Opposition to come together on this matter I would be glad to chair the initial meeting.

Despite the opposition of Fine Gael, and their motion to refuse a Second Reading by submitting a reasoned amendment, I think that is the way it is put, despite that, I had been told before Monday—and I had not seen the Bill at the time—that the contents of this Bill may well have been known to some person or persons in Fine Gael and that if it were not for assurances from such person or persons that it would ultimately be helped through by Fine Gael it would never have seen the light of day.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows that is not so.

Comment on this

Not only am I prepared to accept the word of any Deputy there who says it is not true but I shall be quite happy to see, by the steadfast and unchanged opposition of Fine Gael to it, that there is not the slightest grain of truth in what I am saying. I am not saying this merely to have a crack at Fine Gael but because this persistent rumour is going around. It would be a sad thing if there was any semblance of truth in such a rumour because not only would we have repressive legislation but we would have a major Opposition party proclaiming publicly that they are against this legislation but perhaps ultimately accepting assurances, which I was given to understand will come from the Minister for Justice in concluding that the two subsections to which Fine Gael really object will be suitably amended. On that promise, which is not an unusual one when a Government are under pressure in regard to some obnoxious feature of a Bill, the Fine Gael opposition would, it is suggested, withdraw their motion and on Committee Stage a formula would be produced to change these two sections but only in words and not in content or intent. That is the story; if it is not true, so much the better. This is one occasion on which if it is not true it will be seen to be so before very long.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): We shall not be taking coffee when the division is on as the Deputy did on a number of occasions in the past couple of years.

Comment on this

If I had as little conviction about the rights of what I do as I know the Deputy to have, he would be at home most of the time instead of taking up the time of this House.

Comment on this

That is a non-answer.

Comment on this

Work it out for yourself. This is just a telegram; let nobody be alarmed. I remember reading one here quite a few years ago; it is not the same kind. It is a telegram that has just been handed in from my own constituency, Lifford, Donegal. It is addressed to me here and I am sure other Deputies, including Deputy Harte, will have got one. It says:

"The Donegal branch of the Local Government and Public Services Union call on you to vote against the Offences against the State (Amendment) Bill, 1972," and it is signed by their branch secretary. It is interesting that it asks me to vote against the measure rather than, as one might expect from the voice of the Fianna Fáil Party, perhaps, a telegram asking me to support it. This is a body against which I do not think anybody could point a finger and say that they are either the fringe of the subversives or likely to be malcontents or misfits. Within that Local Government and Public Services Union there is probably a sound collection of the most stable citizens in our community. That is only the Donegal branch and perhaps we are a bit daft up there but these are mostly outsiders——

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

The Deputy will appreciate that it is our business here to make up our own minds. That is what we are here for.

Comment on this

The Minister visited Donegal recently; had he told me he was coming I might have had somebody bake a cake for him but coming as he did somewhat surreptitiously, I did not like it.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

Not surreptitiously.

Comment on this

As the Minister may have found on his visit to the football pitch on his way to north-east Donegal he did not even fancy it there either and it was a foolish venture on the part of the alleged friend who induced the Minister to participate in some sort of political gimmick.

Comment on this

Being very tourist conscious, anybody is welcome in my county provided he does not upset the rhythm of things and, in all fairness, I do not think the Minister did that. To come back to the repressive proposals, are we doing this to satisfy Mr. Heath? If so, I do not think this will endear us to him or to anybody in the British Government who would feel that in bowing to their wishes in a matter that is purely our own concern we only show ourselves to be weak and not really of any great account and not to be taken seriously. There are many suggestions that this is the case, that this is one of the main reasons we are doing this; that this is why we arrested Mac Stiofáin, got him convicted in some way—I read about it but I still do not know how it was done. But it is done, and having had it done, let us not forget that this man we understand, is not in the best physical condition at the moment. Is he to be allowed to continue his hunger strike despite the fact that his health condition, we understand, was not good recently before his arrest?

Is it so important to satisfy the Government's ego or sense of importance that this man must have his life further endangered? This is a man of whom the Minister for Justice three weeks ago was able to say in this House that he had no case against him. If a man had shown himself in every respect to be unworthy of circulating in our community here and, on conviction, he decided to go on hunger strike for whatever motive, it just might be—I do not know—in those very extreme circumstances justifiable to allow such a person to die. But I do not know of any reason why a man who had no case against him less than three weeks ago, and who since then had not committed any crime that was indicated in the court, be committed to prison. In protest and in furtherance of his beliefs and principles he goes on thirst and hunger strike almost to the point of death. Perhaps before we come back here, if we come back at all after this week, this man may have died. All I am asking is, is his crime grave enough to allow him to die? I do not think so. As well as that, trouble could follow from it because, as other Deputies said here tonight, these things raise emotions and are provocative. We must ask ourselves is this feeling on the part of the Government of being the power in the land so all important as to justify a man being allowed to die——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair has allowed references to this matter, but the Deputy is going away from the Bill.

Comment on this

I am sorry, Sir. I should have put it the other way around. This arrest would appear to have been part of the pattern that has produced this Bill here, to have been done at the behest of Mr. Heath. It would appear that the whole thing was a planned operation to satisfy Mr. Heath that we here really mean business, that we are doing more than our part to defeat those who hold Republican views.

Our failure to object strongly to the holding of a plebiscite in the Six Counties is also in keeping with the instructions of Mr. Heath, that we should dither around and not do the logical thing, hold one here on the same day so that we get the true answer from the people of the Thirty-two Counties.

Is it that or is it some other reason? I am at a loss to know what is the reason, but I do not think even that is a satisfactory explanation. However, some explanation is necessary as to why this series of events should continue to happen contrary to what one would naturally expect from an Irish Government acting in this House on behalf of the Irish people.

I wonder as well whether the comments of the other speakers I have had the good fortune to hear at an earlier stage in the debate can throw some light on the introduction of this Bill. I was amazed and even slightly amused to hear the comments of Deputy Corish, the leader of the Labour Party—this was trotted out in other terms tonight by Deputy Treacy —about the whiter than white peaceful corps that the Labour Party are now and always have been and how consistent they are as against the inconsistency of both Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael over the violence in the last three years. I assert that in 1969 neither the members of the Labour Party, of the Fianna Fáil Party or of the Fine Gael Party ran away from those who came in their dire straits at that time from Belfast seeking arms. How many of you told them to "hump off", that it was a wrong thing to do?

Comment on this

They did not come to us.

Comment on this

They did not come to us either.

Comment on this

They knew where to go—over there.

Comment on this

Do not rush your fences.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): We had not the money.

Comment on this

The strange thing is that that is what a member of the Labour Party told them when they visited him; he was full of sympathy.

Comment on this

Which one?

Comment on this

It was not you.

Comment on this

Which one? Be honest.

Comment on this

I am merely refreshing the memory of who it was.

Comment on this

Let the man make his alibi clear.

Comment on this

It is not a question of an alibi. All I am saying is that there seems to be a hell of a short memory in the minds of many of the Members of this House, no matter in what benches they sit, as to how they have changed their outlook, although they now claim in retrospect that they never were otherwise. I do not think they are being dishonest but that they were conveniently deluding themselves that they never encouraged or made promises or gave sympathy or support to those who were seeking methods of defending themselves against the rampages of the B Specials and the RUC in 1969. It is only the few who are now branded as violent people, and it is those few people who not only have not changed their minds or their outlook since then but who have not the facility to delude themselves that they never did think that way three years ago.

Comment on this