We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee On Finance. - Vote 8: Public Works and Buildings (Resumed).

Contributions 101–216 of 216. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

The Parliamentary Secretary might consider it.

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

Yes. If the Deputy gave a suggestion as to what pictures he wanted, we might be able to accede to his wishes.

Comment on this

These are pictures that have been hidden away. The Leas-Cheann Comhairle has a lovely one in his office.

Comment on this

Is it possible that some of the pictures we get are the ones that Mr. White will not hang in the Gallery?

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

No. I am sure we can take our choice of the pictures.

Comment on this

Hardly.

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

We shall get some of them anyway.

Comment on this

May I ask if there is only one Department involved in decentralisation?

Comment on this
A Deputy

Education is going.

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

I understand we are stopping for a short time in Athlone. We are then going straight to Castlebar. Deputy Lemass referred to a difference of £100,000 between the amount, £5 million, included in the Estimate for the building of national schools and what he suggested was proposed to be provided before the change of Government. I would refer the Deputy to the reply to a recent Parliamentary question by him on the subject. There may have been a further reference at some stage to a possible provision of £5.1 million—I cannot be specific on this—but the amount which the commissioners were told by the Department of Education was being allocated was £5 million. Deputy Lemass asked if there had been a reduction in the number of national schools. Strictly speaking, this question is more appropriate to the Vote for Primary Education, but according to the Office of Public Works records the number of national schools now stands at about 3,800 compared with 4,625 in 1967.

A number of Deputies referred to the need to have the work of providing schools for the mentally handicapped speeded up. We in the Office of Public Works are fully cognisant of this matter and will do what we can to expedite the programme. For the record, I should like to outline the up-to-date position which is as follows: schools for the handicapped completed in 1972-73: St. Anne's Special, Roscrea, new school; Wexford Special, new school; St. Joseph's School, Cabra, improvement scheme. New schools in progress: St. Paul's, Beaumont, Dublin; Carlow Special; St. Gabriel's, Kilkenny; Newbridge, Kildare; Cootehill, Cavan; Sligo Special; Gregg House Special, Sligo; St. Mary's Special, Cabra. An improvement scheme is in progress at Airhill, Roscrea. The following schools are at various stages of preparation: Ballina, Dungarvan, Portlaoise, St. Hilda's, Athlone; St. Vincent's, Navan Road, Dublin: St. Mary's, Drurncar; St. Brigid's, Castlebar; St. Michael's, Waterford; Raheny, Dublin; Castleknock, Dublin; St. Killian's, Cork; Cork; Limerick Special; Letterkenny. The following improvement schemes are at various stages of preparation: St. Dympna's, Dundalk; St. Cormac's, Cashel; Lisnagry, Limerick: Central Remedial Clinic, Dublin; John Street West, Dublin.

In the case of national schools, Deputy McLaughlin referred to the case of Carney National School, County Sligo, where he suggested there is a dispute over a grant of £500 which he claimed is needed to provide modern toilet facilities, pending the erection of a new central school at Rathcormac. On inquiry, I find that the plans and specifications for the new central school at Rathcormac are virtually completed and the preparation of bills of quantities will shortly be put in hands with a view to inviting tenders. The case is being expedited as much as possible. A group water scheme serving the Carney area is in progress, but the question of allowing a grant for the provision of toilet facilities at the school pending the erection of the new central school at Rathcormac is primarily a matter for the Department of Education.

I might, perhaps, mention that the cost of such facilities would be at least £1,100 and naturally the question now arises whether it would be worthwhile spending that money for the limited period until the new central school is ready.

Deputy Calleary inquired about a proposed new central school at Attymass. County Mayo and the installation of electricity, et cetera, at Creevagh national school, County Mayo. In the case of Attymass plans and specifications have been prepared and bills of quantity have been put in hands. When these are completed tenders will be invited. The Department of Education recently asked the Office of Public Works to report on the feasibility of installing water flush sanitation and electric lighting at Creevagh national school. A report will be furnished as quickly as possible.

Deputy Gilhawley mentioned Collooney Protestant central national school, County Sligo. As this was the subject of a Parliamentary Question by the Deputy on the 21st June I do not propose to comment further on it at this stage because he got the fullest information then.

Deputy Calleary referred to Swinford boys' national school. The Commissioners of Public Works are about to recommend to the Department of Education the sanction of a grant towards the cost of works which will provide four classrooms in the existing school. There is no room on the site for a prefab. The Reverend manager has already provided terminal storage heating in the school. A new school is proposed but title to the site is not clear. In reply to questions by Deputy Calleary on the 10th May, 1973, the Minister for Education said that he was unable to say when the new primary accommodation would be provided; every effort would be made to ensure that there would be no delay in the final arrangements. The Office of Public Works were asked to advise as to any necessary work at the existing school pending the provision of the new accommodation.

Deputy Bermingham of Kildare referred to Ballyroe national school, County Kildare. A supply of water for this recently erected school has been taken from a nearby council well. An electric pump has been installed and a tap for public use provided on the school boundary. It is understood that recently the electric pump was not functioning satisfactorily and an Office of Public Works engineer will inspect it during the week. In the meantime, the old hand operated pump is providing a supply for local people. This well is not considered suitable as a permanent source of supply. A group water supply is proposed and the school will be connected to this supply as soon as it becomes available. We are not aware of any proposals to provide a public sewer which would serve this school.

Deputy McMahon asked about a contribution towards the cost of school sites and he also asked about the grant towards cleaning or painting schools. These are all matters of policy and must be settled by the Department of Education, not by the Office of Public Works.

Deputy Gilhawley asked about Easky Catholic national school, County Sligo. This was the subject of a Parliamentary Question by the Deputy and it is unnecessary for me to deal with it here because he got full details and information already. Depuy Gallagher asked about Newport central school, County Mayo. The information I have here is that a sketch scheme for the new central school at Newport has been approved by the commissioners and the Department of Education but a grant for the work has not yet been sanctioned by the Department. I understand there is difficulty in relation to the title to the site.

The Deputy also asked about the position of Derrypark national school, County Mayo. The position is that the Department of Education recently authorised an improvement scheme comprising the provision of water flush sanitation, storage heating, a play shelter and the execution of other minor works for Derrypark national school. The works are necessary to cater for the amalgamation of Finny and Shanafarachain schools with this school. Plans and specifications are at present being prepared for the scheme. The manager has requested a more extensive scheme and I have suggested that he take up the matter with the Department of Education.

Comment on this

It is all County Mayo.

Comment on this
Ray Burke Mr. R.P. Burke Fianna Fáil

Is this a tour of the national schools of County Mayo?

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

This is an educational tour for some of the people here. Deputy Gallagher asked about physical education facilities at national schools. I want to inform the Deputy that grants are available towards the cost of providing some gymnastic equip ment, mats, scramble tables, ribbed bar box and balancing benches for use in general purpose rooms, ball courts suitable for basket ball and volley ball, including the initial supply of posts, net, et cetera, and, where possible, a separate area for infants is provided away from the ball court Swimming pools are not provided at national schools out of grant moneys. This is a question of policy and their provision might be a matter for local authorities.

I am now coming to the Deputy Deputy Raphael Burke asked about Swords boys and girls schools. A site for the erection of two 16-room schools at Rathbeale, Swords, has been approved but the commissioners do not know yet if it has been acquired. Grants for the erection of the schools have still to be sanctioned by the Department of Education. It is understood that the architects appointed by the reverend manager have been proceeding with the preparation of plans. Pending the erection of these new schools the old Swords school has been temporarily re-occupied. Some works have been carried out and further works will be carried out during the school holidays.

Deputy Taylor asked about Kilkee boys national school, County Clare. A grant has been sanctioned by the Department of Education for the erection of an additional classroom at this school to facilitate the transfer of pupils from Kilferagh national school. It is hoped to commence the preparation of working drawings for the project in July and to invite tenders in the autumn.

Deputy Fitzgerald wanted to know what was the position of the Carrigaline Church of Ireland school extension. Tenders are being considered and it is hoped that acceptance will issue shortly. He also inquired about Carrigaline boys national school. The manager is authorised to accept tenders for two prefabs at the girls school and a mobile classroom at the boys' national school.

Nobody realises better than I do the dire need there is for adequate working accommodation for the Garda force, the members of which are so conscientious and efficient in the performance of their duties. The general concern felt by Deputies in regard to adequate accommodation for Garda personnel is reflected in the number of references there were to this matter in the course of the debate. I agree with the views expressed as to the need for improved accommodation for the Garda Síochána and I am glad to inform the House that we have now set up a special architectural unit to cope with the problem. The problem has become pretty severe. There is difficulty in getting the number of architects we want and the Office of Public Works are in dire need of extra personnel to cope with the demand for buildings.

Comment on this

And the demand will be increasing.

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

It will and, while one may have the money, one cannot get the personnel to cope with the demand. One cannot get the trained architects and trained engineers.

Comment on this

They are not just answering the advertisements.

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

As far as I understand, they get better pay elsewhere. Deputy Finn referred to the need for a new station at Kilkelly in Mayo. The position is that plans and specifications for a new station there are being prepared and tenders will be invited later this year.

Deputy McLaughlin referred to the stations in Sligo and Manorhamilton. A contract has been placed for improvement works at Sligo. A new station has been proposed for Manorhamilton and arrangements are in hand for the acquisition of a site.

Deputy Andrews referred to the stations at Shankill, Cabinteely and Blackrock. It is accepted that all three stations leave a great deal to be desired. Shankill is probably the most urgent. Unfortunately, the acquisition of a suitable site here has presented considerable difficulty, but it is hoped this difficulty will be overcome this year.

Deputy McMahon inquired about Tallaght Garda Station. I understand the future of that station is being considered by the Department of justice and the Commissioners of Public Works are awaiting that Department's instructions in the matter.

Deputy McMahon also inquired about Sundrive Road station. He alleged that the outside of the building had not been painted since it was erected. This station has, in fact, been painted externally on a number of occasions. Work is again due and an order to have it done was issued by the Office of Public Works some months ago. I understand the contractors are starting work this week. Deputy Reynolds inquired about Carrick-on-Shannon Garda station. Steps have been taken to acquire a site for the erection of a new station here. Deputy Burke inquired about Lusk Garda station. Arrangements are being made to have an improvement scheme carried out at this station. Deputy Enright raised the question of Portiaoise Garda station. A major scheme of improvement on this station is being considered.

Deputy Geoghegan asked about Rosmuck Garda station. Tenders for the erection of a new station here are about to be invited and it is hoped to place the contract in a period of two or three months. Deputy White inquired about Ballyshannon Garda station. Authority was recently received for the erection of a new district headquarters and two houses here and arrangements are being made for the preparation of drawings and specifications and bills of quantity for the work prior to the invitation of tenders. It is hoped a contract can be placed before the end of 1973. Deputy White also inquired about Letterkenny Garda station. A site for a new station in Letterkenny is being sought. Deputy Seán Flanagan has just left the House and will not, therefore hear the good news, about Kiltimagh; a site for a new station is being sought there.

Deputy Bermingham inquired about the position of Naas Garda station. Plans and specifications have been prepared for a scheme of improvement at an estimated cost of £12,000 and, when these plans and specifications are finalised, tenders will be invited.

Deputy Bermingham thinks the present Garda station at Athy too far out from the town and he says the gardaí cannot adequately perform their duties. The present Garda station at Athy had to be occupied in 1971 because the lease of the former station had expired. The building was also in bad condition. It is the ultimate intention to build a new Garda station in Athy and preliminary inquiries about the acqusition of a new site are under way. Deputy Bermingham intimated that he could point to a new site and if the Deputy will let me have particulars of the central site he says is available I shall be glad to have it considered.

Comment on this

That must be all the bad news.

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

It is. I come now to a matter of importance to both rural and urban Deputies. It is the subject of arterial drainage. Some Deputies are not sure what a cost benefit survey is all about. I shall try to explain briefly exactly what it is. Some years ago certain people alleged that the expenditure incurred on arterial drainage was not justified and that the money did not produce the anticipated benefits to the farmers and, through the farmers, to the national economy. That is why this cost benefit survey was initiated in the first instance.

As is to be expected, many Deputies are interested in arterial drainage because of the growing value of agricultural land. I think it would be well, therefore, if I restated the fundamental issues. Arterial drainage is a very large and important national problem. To deal with it would require a very big input of capital, technical expertise, manpower and time. Arterial drainage executed in a localised, haphazard and piecemeal way could be expensive, inefficient and even counter-productive. It is the best accepted practice to carry out comprehensive schemes dealing with all the drainage areas of a catchment once and for all.

When so much is to be done and resources are limited, it is necessary to establish priorities based on the principal catchments in the country. These priorities have been published and adhered to by successive Governments. In a trial period, an attempt was made to fit into the arterial drainage programme a sub-programme of small, in-between schemes such as has been suggested by some Deputies. This, however, was discontinued because the main programme suffered from diversion of funds, manpower, technical skill and plans.

Deputies have inquired about the cost benefit study which is at present being made in regard to arterial drainage. In recent years there has been much criticism of arterial drainage as a capital investment. When there are so many demands being made on the national resources it is necessary to be certain that they will be spent to the best advantage. For some time a specially qualified team have been investigating the effort and expenditure on and the return and the benefits resulting from arterial drainage, with special reference to the Maigue and the Groody schemes in County Limerick.

This is a very complicated and difficult exercise but the report is expected shortly. Deputies will agree that it is time arterial drainage should be viewed in a fresh perspective. The methodology being employed will be valid for all future schemes. That means, of course, that the experience gained by a detailed study of the catchments of the Maigue and the Groody will be used in cost benefit surveys of every proposal being placed before the arterial drainage authorities and by that experience this period of cost benefit survey and analysis will be shortened so that in the detailed study the experience gained of the Maigue and Groody catchments will have beneficial results and will shorten the periods of other proposals.

Thus, the specific proposals mentioned by Deputies, now in various stages of investigation and consideration, will also be submitted to cost benefit studies, namely, the Dunkellin, the Boyle River, the Lung, the Corrib, the Mask, Roe—they form No. 1. Then there is the Bonnet, the Owenmore, Lough Alien and all the others. When the Maigue scheme commences this year and the operations on other schemes commence in their due turn, we hope that because of cost benefit studies we will be able to assure critics of arterial drainage that the money and effort are being spent profitably. We can count the benefits particularly because of the increased value of land, the increased price of stock and the decrease in animal disease as a consequence of effective drainage. We can point out that investment in arterial drainage is the same as investing capital in industries. All rural Deputies know—I do not know whether the Dublin people do or not—that our best investment is in agriculture and it is appreciating every year.

Comment on this

Are we putting enough into it?

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

Few people today are inclined to recall that before the Moy scheme was embarked on in 1960 there were almost 50,000 acres of agricultural land and more than 11,000 acres of bog in County Mayo permanently water-logged and unproductive. Some will remember the prolonged rainfall of seven inches during November, 1968, and again in December, 1969, when two inches of rain fell in the Moy catchment area within 24 hours. The newly designed drainage channels stood the tests successfully. In no part of the catchment where drainage had been carried out was flooding recorded. In pre-drainage conditions flooding would have been considerable and prolonged.

I am happy to say that the Office of Public Works are fully alive to the problems of conservation in all its aspects. Indeed, they maintain close liaison with cultural, environmental, fishery, game and wild fowl interests. I have been anxious to ascertain if the pace of arterial drainage could be accelerated with the help of money from the EEC. The merits of arterial drainage for this type of aid have been and will be pressed with a view to obtaining assistance from all such quarters.

Deputy White asked about certain aspects of flooding in the Ballybofey area of Donegal. He said the people in that area are anxious that when flooding occurs some excavators would be made available to relieve flash flooding. The excavators asked for by the local people for work at Ballybofey are held available for them and an Office of Public Works engineer will give them operational advice.

In the case of the Boyne scheme in respect of which Deputy Crinion asked the question, I am glad to say that liberal stocks of salmon and trout will be available for the whole catchment from the new hatchery which is being constructed for the fishery conservatories at Virginia.

In regard to comprehensive drainage surveys, the reduction in expenditure from £5,000 to £2,200 merely reflects an emphasis on design and headquarters work rather than field work. It indicates progress rather than otherwise. Somebody suggested that the reduction in the amount for this work was a retrograde step. It is not. It means that just as much work can now be done for £2,200 as could be done for £5,000 heretofore because of experience gained.

Comment on this

It is a good example for other Departments.

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

It would be. To return to arterial drainage, some Deputies referred to the spoil on the banks of rivers. Everybody who travels in an area where drainage has been carried out has noticed those unsightly heaps of spoil composed of silt, stones or other unsightly matters. There is no doubt about their being unsightly and something should be done about them. My idea is that the county councils should have some type of mobile crusher and, in co-operation with the Board of Works, reduce those heaps of limestone spoil to road material. Such material would be ideal for secondary roads and accommodation roads and boreens. We have 1,600 miles of untarred roads in County Mayo and those heaps of good class limestone and rock, which are lying there in unsightly heaps, could be used on those roads. I am glad that some Deputies referred to the existence of these unsightly spoil heaps in scenically sensitive areas. Reference was made in particular to the Boyne catchment.

Comment on this

Did the Parliamentary Secretary say "scientifically"?

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

I said "scenically". Did the Deputy mishear me? New instructions for the treatment of spoil have been issued to the engineers in charge of arterial drainage works and provision for appropriate treatment of spoil banks is now being made in the estimate for arterial drainage schemes. This new policy has received the enthusiastic support of the arterial drainage staff and a number of letters of appreciation have been received from the general public.

In regard to the maintenance of rivers, people must understand that when an arterial drainage scheme is finished the Office of Public works have no further function other than to maintain, at the expense of the county council, the drains, to keep them open and to keep them clean. They cannot open any new drains. Deputies should understand that. Representations have been made from various quarters to have new drains opened after schemes have finished. Under statutory regulations, the Office of Public Works are not allowed to do that. Maintenance of completed works is attended to each year. The guiding principle behind the maintenance programme is to ensure that the channels are adequate for drainage requirements. Maintenance work is costly and every effort is made to carry it out as economically as possible. Accordingly, where possible and economic, machinery is used in maintenance work. That note is for the benefit solely of the one Deputy who asked that maintenance work should be carried out by manual labour. That was Deputy Seán Calleary. Experience in county council drainage boards, which are now obsolete, proved that manual labour was a failure. Drags and men are futile in comparison with modern machinery for results. Maintenance work is carried out by the personnel of the Office of Public Works and the cost is then recouped through the rates from each local authority.

Regarding coast erosion, Deputy Esmonde and others referred to the slow progress on coast protection proposals. I am concerned with the position and as far as it is due to any difficulties which I can influence, for example shortages of staff or money, I propose to make every effort to improve the situation. However, realising the protracted procedures required by the Act and the fact that this is a very specialised branch of engineering with special emphasis on practical operation and experience. I regret that I cannot promise any great improvement in the short term.

Comment on this

That is very serious.

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

This is the realistic fact. In coast erosion every single instance must have its own separate remedy because the sea does not do things in the same pattern in different locations. Each particular case of coast erosion must get the full treatment in a specialised way, in its own way, because the same treatment does not do for two different problems of coast erosion. The first step must come from the local authority itself.

Comment on this

Would the Parliamentary Secretary agree that once land has gone into the sea it is gone for ever and there is no way of getting it back?

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

Yes, that was emphasised today by Deputy Esmonde.

Comment on this

And other Deputies.

Comment on this

I tried very hard to gel more finance for this purpose. I hope the Parliamentary Secretary will have more success than I had.

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

I may be luckier than the Deputy was. I will try my best too.

Comment on this

Does that mean there is nothing happening at the moment?

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

It does not mean that. Everything is happening. The sea is still working.

Comment on this

We know the sea is doing its job but are we doing our job against the sea?

Comment on this

Why did you not do it when you had the opportunity? You had 16 years.

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

We are doing our best.

Comment on this

The Coast Erosion Act has only been in existence about four years.

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

Many Deputies, especially those from maritime areas, referred to fishery piers and harbours. Expenditure on fishery piers and harbours is normally borne on the Fisheries Vote administered by the Department of Agriculture and Fisheries.

There was a query about Dinish Island, Castletownbere. Work at Dinish Island is proceeding. The bridge to the island will be open in a few months but all the other structural work on the island—wharf, roads, synchrolift and boatyard—will take until 1975.

Work at Dunmore East is virtually finished while the Killybegs scheme is making good progress. Deputy Geoghegan had a query about Inishbofin. Proposals for improvements have not yet been formulated. It is, of course, the practice to consult local interests in all such cases. No proposals have been made to the Office of Public Works about Kincasslagh or Burtonport, mentioned by Deputy White. The operations in progress at Burtonport provide for dredging to a depth of seven feet around the new jetty and from thence outward for 60 feet. If any further dredging is required representations should be made to the proper authorities. The work at Inisheer, Aran Islands, is a concern of Roinn na Gaeltachta who I understand have the case under consideration. I regret that contractual difficulties are delaying the start of work at Rossaveel but a special effort is being made to resolve them as soon as possible. I shall deal with that again when I am dealing with specific representations made because I think Deputies who mention specific things like their names to be mentioned.

Comment on this

Or their questions to be answered.

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

Or their questions to be answered, if possible. If the information is there they will get it. Deputy R.P. Burke mentioned Skerries harbour. He suggested that an examination from the fishery point of view should be extended to take into account the commercial possibilities. This is a matter of policy, a decision on which must be made by the Department of Transport and Power.

Deputy Coogan mentioned Rosaveen harbour in Connemara. This was the subject of a Parliamentary question in Irish by Deputy Molloy about three weeks ago. The position is the same in English as in Irish but I will give it in English as the query was made in English. The position in brief is that a tender for the work was accepted. Certain difficulties, however, arose regarding the dredging and rock removal and, as a result, the start of the job has been delayed. It would appear that the contractor had not the necessary experience or plant to remove the rock base underneath the water and that he was not experienced enough either with regard to the dredging. This part of the contract was allowed by the Office of Public Works to be handed over to another firm acting for the first contractor and that difficulty now has been overcome. It is hoped that work will commence shortly. I said to Deputy Molloy that it would be within a few months; I am not certain of that but that is the term we think it will be.

Comment on this

Is the Parliamentary Secretary aware that that was brought up a week before the election as a gimmick?

Comment on this

It was the subject of discussion for some time.

Comment on this

This is not by way of interruption, but I would like to know if the Parliamentary Secretary could give the information as to when the contractor was appointed for this work.

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

I am sorry, I have not got that information.

Comment on this

Before the election.

Comment on this

When were the tenders got out?

Comment on this

Before the election.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary has ail the files and knows what the position is. Deputy Coogan is talking nonsense.

Comment on this

I am not. You put out a circular the night before the previous election. We know all about the famous circular.

Comment on this

Look at the files.

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

Deputy Gallagher mentioned the marine works on Clare Island. It would appear that when these plans were being formulated and information sought about the length of the pier and the depth of flotation required to make adequate landing at Clare Island local interests were included in the team of experts and Mr. Hayes, who is secretary of the association on Clare Island, now requires 15 feet extra on the seaward end of the pier. That may be considered favourably, but as it is now, the present contract will go on and later on we may consider favourably, if flotation is not adequate, adding the required number of feet to the seaward end of the pier.

The same Deputy inquired about the position regarding the major fishery harbour at Ballyglass. I went down personally to see the site of the proposed pier about three weeks ago. I was brought around by the local people. I had no engineer with me but from the look of the place, the site is on a rocky promontory and when the pier is built, the further or sea end of it will give, as I understand from the local interests concerned, perfect flotation for any boat that might come in there. As Deputy Gallagher said, and as I said on last year's Estimate, knowing the country and the ground, it will give the fishermen of Killybegs who fish off the Stags of Broadhaven and the north coast of Mayo where the richest fishing grounds are now, six hours in hand of steaming from Killybegs out of their fishing grounds and, of course, they can always pull in there if a sudden storm arises.

Comment on this

It is all happening in Mayo.

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

Deputy O'Sullivan and Deputy Crowley mentioned Courtmacsherry pier and I am glad to be able to tell them that the matter is being considered at present.

Comment on this

How soon may we expect the child to be born?

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

In due course. Deputy Blaney mentioned the five-year plan for fishery harbours for which £1 million was supposed to be allocated. He mentioned three or four piers and said that the money expended on the one at Glengad, Malin, County Donegal, was expended in a very futile way, and also mentioned Ruadhóig, Curransport and Magheraroarty. He did mention another but I did not catch the name. I can assure him that intensive investigations will be made into his allegations regarding the meeting to which he was not invited. When a Deputy represents a certain constituency, no matter of what party he is, he should in courtesy be invited to every meeting held for the benefit of the people. He alleged that he was not invited and asked me to investigate the matter to see if any Government Department were involved. I will give him all the information I can uncover.

Deputy Coogan inquired about the major fishing harbour at Galway. A decision on the future of this proposal is a matter for the Department of Agriculture and Fisheries and not for the Office of Public Works.

Deputy Taylor inquired about Liscannor harbour in County Clare and I understand that plans for improvements at this harbour, including an electric winch in lieu of the existing hand winch are under consideration. These works were recommended by the Clare survey team and the Office of Public Works sent a report and an estimate to the Department of Agriculture and Fisheries in August, 1971, and it would appear that they are still under consideration.

Many Dublin Deputies inquired about Dún Laoghaire harbour and its amenities and here I would repeat that I am not aware of any proposal to diminish these amenities. I should point out, however, that the harbour was constructed as a mail package station and not as an amenity harbour. The restoration of the East Pier will be completed shortly under a contract to be arranged. The suggestion made by Deputy Lemass that the work is being held up because of the change of Government is completely without foundation. The surface of the West Pier, and its approach, is not too bad but resurfacing it with tarmacadam is being considered. The matter of the level-crossing beside the West Pier is a matter wholly for CIE. The introduction of container traffic is at present not a live issue.

Deputy Moore made a suggestion about the provision of a yacht haven outside the harbour. The provision of such a facility is outside the powers, and duties, of the Office of Public Works. The Deputy will have to go to the Department of Agriculture and Fisheries, or some such Department, for such a project.

Comment on this

In relation to Dun Laoghaire harbour, is there not a provision in this year's estimate of £50,000 to improve facilities for container traffic?

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

I will inform the Deputy of the position at a later stage.

Comment on this

Provision is there already although it may happen that it will not come into operation until later in the financial year.

Comment on this

It must be bad news again.

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

No. I might mention the Deputy later. I will inform Deputy Lemass of the position later. I should like now to deal with references, suggestions and queries regarding national monuments and matters relevant to them which have been mentioned by Deputies during this debate. It is hard to keep track of all the Deputies so if I omit any names I will be excused.

Deputy Kelly asked about an archaeological survey. Two archaeologists are working on the survey. However, I feel that the progress on this survey is too slow and I am investigating the possibility of increasing the number of archaeologists on this work. Three Office of Public Works archaeologists, and 13 others, financed by the Office of Public Works, are engaged on excavations this season. It is agreed that more staff for this work, especially for rescue excavations, would be desirable.

Deputy Davern last night, in the presence of the Ceann Comhairle, got in on this debate because Deputy Ruairí Brugha allowed him. He got in under the pretext that he would speak only for five minutes but this eventually led to half an hour. The Ceann Comhairle got uneasy, but Deputy Davern was in for half an hour.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

In fairness to Deputy Davern the agreement in question was for ten minutes.

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

Deputy Davern had some interesting comments to make about his native town and other places in County Tipperary. He had some interesting comments, and suggestions, to make in connection with the Rock of Cashel, a national monument, and they will be borne in mind. The rate of pay for the caretaker is under review and a decision on it will be taken shortly. However, I should like to add that the concession for the sale of literature, which the caretaker has free, is a valuable one and, if advertised on the open market, would command a high rental.

Deputy Ruairí Brugha mentioned that monuments should be put to use. He made the interesting suggestion that, where appropriate, national monuments which are in, or can be put into a suitable condition should be put to use. This is in keeping with the modern thinking which is that our ancient buildings should be brought more into the life of our people and not left as dead reminders of our past. This is being borne in mind in preparing our programme for European Architectural Heritage Year 1975.

Deputy Davern also commented on Saint Dominic's Abbey, Cashel. I should like to inform the Deputy that I am having inquiries made into his allegation that an unauthorised carnival was held in one of our national monuments. I understand that the monument in question is Saint Dominic's. I will refrain from saying anything more on this subject until the facts have been ascertained.

We had a wonderful contribution last night from Deputy Coughlan. He had very interesting things to say and two of these he emphasised. He also made the very same comments to my predecessor, Deputy Lemass, as can be seen in the Official Report, column 1358, Volume 261, 13th June, 1972. At that time he was very concerned about the wages and the conditions of employment enjoyed by the employees of the Office of Public Works. He was concerned a year ago. My predecessor, Deputy Lemass, then stated:

Deputy Coughlan expressed concern regarding the conditions of employment in the Office of Public Works. He said that although a number of people have been employed by the Office for between five and 20 years they are still temporary and are not entitled to pensions. I am not clear as to what particular employees the Deputy has in mind, but if he will let me have the details I will look into the matter.

Those are the words of my predecessor, and it appears that the details requested were not supplied by Deputy Coughlan to Deputy Lemass a year ago. I am asking Deputy Coughlan to supply me with the same details. If he does so, I will look into the matter.

There was an interesting comment from the Deputy in relation to King John's Castle in Limerick. This Castle is only a shell of a famous fortress. It has a tower but the castle precincts are surrounded by a wall and, so far as I can ascertain from the Office of Public Works, they can only conserve but not restore any ancient building. It would appear that within the precincts of the walls the local authority have built a scheme of houses and that the local authority and the Shannon Free Airport Development Company wish to build a banqueting hall in the middle of this space that is bounded by the ancient walls. This year the Office of Public Works have allocated a certain sum of money for the preservation of the walls but I doubt if they can do anything in the matter of the erection of a new building within the walls.

King John's Castle is State-owned and all but the battlements, external walls and towers was leased in 1933 to Limerick Corporation who erected houses there and converted relatively modern military buildings for housing purposes. The proposal in connection with the banqueting hall which is sponsored by SFADCO is to remove at least some of the houses and to erect on the site a new building to be used as a banqueting hall and for meetings, et cetera.

The Commissioners of Public Works have, under the National Monuments Act, responsibility for the preservation, maintenance and presentation of national monuments. Provision in this year's Estimate for the Office of Public Works to which I referred in my opening statement is for a scheme of conservation works at the battlements. These are about to commence. It is evident that the proposed new hall which is a commercial project does not come in any way within the functions of the Office of Public Works under the National Monuments Act except to ensure that the building, in so far as possible, be in sympathy with its surroundings, that it should interfere as little as possible with the potentially archaeologically-fertile area and, if necessary, that an archaeological excavation be carried out in any area that is to be disturbed.

The National Monuments Advisory Council have been in correspondence with the sponsors and with the local authority in regard to the plan. They are an independent body appointed by the Minister for Finance under the National Monuments Act to give advice to the commissioners and they also have prescribed functions under the planning Acts. Of course, the commissioners would have to consider seriously any advice which the advisory council might give to them in connection with the project. I have no responsibility for the other problems in connection with the project mentioned also by the Deputy and I do not propose that the Office of Public Works or myself should become involved in them.

Deputy Lemass mentioned King John's Castle, too, and the reply I have given to Deputy Coughlan's remarks are applicable also to Deputy Lemass's queries. Deputy Lemass referred also to the Rock of Cashel. As I said in my opening statement, the Deputy went over the whole field of the activities of the Office of Public Works but, of course, he is familiar with every aspect of the situation because he was in that office during the past three years.

Floodlighting at the Rock of Cashel was provided and is maintainable by Cashel UDC under licence from the Office of Public Works. The property is not trespass-proof and it would be difficult either for the caretaker or for the gardaí to give round the clock protection to it from vandals. It is a disgrace that vandalism was carried out to such an extent as to destroy this amenity. The Rock of Cashel had been floodlit during the past few years but some time ago it was visited by vandals —I do not know whether they were local or otherwise—who must have had some kind of axe or other heavy weapon with them because they hacked away the cables of the floodlighting apparatus. I would urge the people of the area to endeavour to impress on the minds of anyone of whom they might know who would be aware of such vandalism the need to respect and have affection for the heritage of their town. The Rock of Cashel and the monastic settlements on its summit rank among our greatest and priceless treasures. If young people were responsible for the acts of vandalism, perhaps it is difficult to blame them too much, but if adults were responsible and if they could be apprehended and brought before the courts, I cannot think of any punishment that would be severe enough for them.

Comment on this

Is there no caretaker there?

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

Yes, but it would not be possible to have a caretaker service for 24 hours of the day without having a three-shift service. Caretakers must sleep.

I had occasion last week to visit the town of Cahir for the purpose of officiating at a ceremony of floodlighting the historic Cahir Castle, a beautiful and impregnable fortress which dates from about the 10th century. It has its Elizabethan features but underneath its site a fortress was built in the 3rd century, giving the town the name of Cahir which means a fort or a strong point but from the 3rd century on the place was inhabited and in later years this fortress of the Butlers was constructed. It was a mighty place and a mighty stronghold and was left in fairly good repair. I wish to express my admiration and my appreciation, first, to the local people for their commendable spirit in helping to put that historical monument into such good condition, and secondly, to the workmen of the Office of Public Works who did such a magnificent job of restoration there. While I was in the town a very generous offer was made of another portion of the castle to the Office of Public Works by a very gracious townswoman, Mrs. Kenny. The lady has been mentioned in this connection already this evening by a Deputy from the town. For my part, I will do my utmost to see that the offer is accepted. If the conservation work on the old part of the building is of the same standard, the people of Cahir will be delighted with their heritage and with what is one of the most attractive tourist resorts in the country.

Deputy Gilhawley who comes from a most historic place in Sligo mentioned the Carrowkeel megalithic cemetery in County Sligo. The Commissioners of Public Works, aware of the need to protect this important group of monuments, opened negotiations in 1967 to take them into State care. As a result, all of the passage graves which formed this group are now in the guardianship of the Commissioners. A caretaker has been appointed to keep the monuments under observation and to report any interference or damage to them. The Garda Síochána at Ballymote, Riverstown and Boyle have been directed to co-operate with the commissioners in the preservation of these monuments. The commissioners are not aware of any damage to the monuments since taking them into guardianship.

Deputy Gilhawley also mentioned another famous place, a haven for tourists all over the world, namely, Creevykeel, Court Cairn, County Sligo. This monument is vested in the Commissioners of Public Works and the caretaker lives nearby. It is as well protected as any monument can be. Deputy Gilhawley who is observant, energetic and conscious of the great historical heritage of his native county, mentioned this area in particular as a priceless gem for the archaeologist and tourist.

Deputy J. O'Leary referred to an extension to the local burial ground inside Muckross Abbey. The Office of Public Works are opposed to burials in or near national monuments and they would not be disposed to allow an extension to the burial ground in this case.

Deputy Lemass referred to Holy Cross Abbey and suggested additional financial help for restoration work. The Act provides for restoration of the church on the basis of the total cost of the restoration work, exclusive of the cost of conservation work being recouped by the archdiocese. Any alteration in that arrangement would be contrary to the Holy Cross Abbey Act, 1969.

Comment on this

Has the State not given a contribution to the diocese on the basis of what it would cost to maintain the abbey over a number of years?

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

Only on the conservation work, not restoration. Deputy O'Sullivan and another Deputy mentioned Charles Fort as a national monument. Some weeks ago a deputation from Kinsale headed by Deputies O'Sullivan and Crowley and the other Deputy in the constituency and with some of the associations involved, came to see the personnel of the Office of Public Works. They appealed for a grant for a fort I have never seen but one that is reputed to be one of the most outstanding star fortresses in Europe. After meeting the deputation from Kinsale and as a justification for our expenditure in this matter, I should like to put on record what Charles Fort means.

The site on which Charles Fort stands is an ancient one with associations dating back to prehistoric times. At first it was an Irish ringfort overlooking Kinsale harbour. With the coming of Christianity a church was built in its shadow, one traditionally associated with St. Eitin, the patron of Kinsale. Sometime in the 14th century Barry Óg erected the castle of Ringcurran and made it the headquarters for the barony of Kinalea. The castle was later rebuilt in stone and it stood intact until the siege of 1601.

The defence of Ringcurran Castle in that siege stands out in our history as an episode of high valour. The Spanish commander preferred to be buried in its ruins rather than accept dishonourable terms. After the siege and battle the demolished castle was partly rebuilt and beside it was erected one of the six lighthouses of Ireland.

From early in the 17th century shipping using Kinsale harbour was so considerable and valuable as to require the protection of a fort. Accordingly, in 1667 an earthen fort was built around the castle and ten years later the stone structure we see today was commenced. Apart from Dún an Mhishtealaigh which is occupied, it is the only perfect star fort in the country. As an example of period military architecture it is unique in these islands, and internationally there are few such period pieces. Structurally, it lacks nothing but its guns. It has even a ghost— the White Lady, whose ghost-story is regarded as premier in Ireland.

The barrack buildings within were burnt during the Civil War but the walls are still intact. It has a history also, of which a few episodes must suffice. Within the fort King James held court in 1689, at which attended Patrick Sarsfield and the Irish leaders. Subsequently, James went to Cork and to the Boyne. In the following year the fort was still held for James and it withstood a full-scale siege conducted by one of the great European generals, Marlborough. The siege lasted 14 days in contrast to the five days it took to reduce Cork. The fort surrendered on honourable terms and the garrison marched to Limerick and from there they joined the Wild Geese.

The number of notable persons who have been associated with the fort since that time is considerable. During the Napoleonic Wars many prisoners-of-war were held there and it continued to be used as a barracks until the formation of the State. It is important to remember that Charles Fort is an essential counterpart both in the study of the strategy associated with Kinsale harbour defences and in the development of the science of fortification to James Fort which is now a national monument on the opposite side of the harbour. This is what Charles Fort means and I think it is a valid justification for the grant we offered to the people of Cork when they came in a deputation.

Comment on this

Is there any justification for the name "Charles" ?

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

It is Cathal. I have not that information but I will get it for the Deputy.

Comment on this

It might be construed with the later period in our history.

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

The Bourn Vincent Memorial Park is one of our greatest parks. Deputy J. O'Leary inquired about Muckross House. Originally, Muckross House was built as a private residence but since 1964 it has been used as a folk museum. During the peak tourist season the average number of visitors now reaches 1,000 persons a day and is expected to rise still further. The water and sewerage system which was designed to meet the needs of a family and staff is now totally inadequate. The water supply comes from a spring well which has an output of only about 5,500 gallons per day during summer conditions compared with the anticipated requirement of about 24,000 gallons per day. The sewerage discharges untreated into Muckross Lake and, while in the past this may have presented little or no problem, it can no longer be tolerated in present circumstances.

Deputy Lemass and Deputy J. O'Leary referred to the discharge of crude sewage from Muckross House into the lake and each pressed for the early provision of a septic tank. They both suggested that when this had been done I should get after other parties who were also discharging crude sewage into the lake. In January, 1972, the Office of Public Works commissioned a consultant to investigate the matter and recommend remedial measures. His report has been received and is being examined. No time will be lost in making a decision on what action should be taken and giving effect to this decision. Provision has been made in subhead E. of Vote 8 to enable a start to be made this year.

Town sewage also discharges into Muckross Lake. Kerry County Council are at present constructing a treatment plant which, we understand, will considerably improve conditions in Loch Lein into which the town sewage is at present discharged in an untreated condition. Both Deputies also asked about private premises and their authority to discharge raw sewage into the beautiful Lakes of Killarney. A number of large privately-owned premises, such as hotels, also discharge untreated sewage into Loch Lein. The Commissioners of Public Works have no statutory power to compel the owners of these establishments to discontinue this practice but they are seriously concerned about the situation in view of their responsibility for the national park. They intend to raise the matter in due course with the Department of Local Government and with Kerry County Council to see what appropriate action may be taken.

Deputy J. O'Leary requested discussion and consultation with Killarney UDC and local voluntary organisations on the future use and development of the Kenmare Estates. He suggested that the creation of a small town park in part of this would help to keep people in Killarney and ease the traffic problem between Killarney and Muckross. The commissioners are obliged to manage the estate in the national interest and their policy will be to preserve as far as possible the natural amenities of the property. The provision of town parks is primarily the responsibility of local authorities but the Deputy's suggestion about consultation will be borne in mind in deciding on a management plan.

The former Taoiseach, Deputy Lynch, suggested that the house on the estate be used as a country residence for the President. From the viewpoint of the Killarney area the idea would obviously be attractive but it would have to be considered in the broad national context. As the Deputy is aware, the matter is one for Government decision and all I can do is to have his proposal put forward for consideration. I understand that many years ago there was a suggestion that Muckross House be used for the same purpose but the idea was never considered in depth and nothing came of it.

Deputy Lemass spoke about property in Cork called Garnish Island which to me is one of our greatest and most beautiful tourist attractions. Deputy Lemass suggested that he had got some report that the boatmen conveying passengers to Garnish Island overcharged their customers.

Comment on this

On occasion, yes.

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

He wished some bye-laws to be framed to prevent boatmen who overcharged from landing passengers on the island. There are no bye-laws; they are being prepared. The Office of Public Works have at present no control over the boatmen or their charges but the whole question is being examined. I am sure Deputy Crowley will be delighted that these people who go there in good faith will not be overcharged.

He says that no people around Garnish Island would overcharge.

Comment on this

There is no overcharging that I know of. They find it very hard to make a living there.

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

When they see the Deputy coming they do not charge him at all.

Comment on this

What about the pier at Glengarriff?

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

The Deputy mentioned that before. I said it would be borne in mind and Courtmacsherry as well.

Comment on this

Like it was for the past 15 years. What does that mean —in due course?

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

In connection with the report of the Bolton Street Students' Study Group, Deputy Lemass suggested that cars should be excluded from the Phoenix Park as a first priority. The students' report recommended the exclusion of traffic from the park, but on a phased basis when the roadway system in the vicinity of the park is eventually improved. In the meantime, the Commissioners of Public Works are examining the implications, legal and otherwise, of having certain roads closed in the park either on a temporary or long-term basis.

Comment on this

It is a good job you did not close them before last Sunday.

Comment on this

They were taxed to capacity.

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

Last Sunday? Yes, I almost forgot that incident.

Comment on this

For the big funeral.

Comment on this

A funeral for Deputy Coogan and his like.

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

Deputy Lemass also suggested, seeing that there was to be a change of Presidency and the Zoo needed more space, apparently that the change of President would be a good opportunity to consider their case sympathetically. He said he would not favour encroaching on the polo ground. He meant that the Office of Public Works should surrender portion of the Phoenix Park called the Fish Pond, an area of about ten acres, and hand it over to the Zoo for whatever purpose required. An application has been received from the Royal Zoological Society for additional land and is being considered in relation to the use of the park as a whole but at this stage it would be premature to comment on the outcome. About five weeks ago I was invited to a function at Aras an Uachtaráin and was afterwards introduced to the then President. We had a chat in Irish and in English. He enjoined upon me, recognising who I was and the position I held, not to give up one perch of the Phoenix Park to anybody. I think he was right. I agree with Deputy Tunney and those people who said that if you encroach at all on the green belt in any city, one acre will lead to two acres, and this will happen as long as human beings live.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

It must be stopped.

Comment on this

This suggestion was made in relation to the Zoological Gardens and the Parliamentary Secretary must agree that they are doing a good job.

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

I understand they are, but the Zoological Gardens are an artificial entity. The Phoenix Park is a natural lung for Dublin and, if you take away ten acres, you deprive people of those ten acres and, if you lose them. you will never get them back.

Comment on this

I agree completely with the Parliamentary Secretary.

Comment on this

The Deputy does not agree with Dev. so.

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

Deputy Lemass also inquired if a tree-planting programme had been agreed with the Department of Lands. The Commissioners of Public Works have consulted the Forestry section of the Department of Lands and a survey of the trees is in progress.

Plans for a nature trail in the Furry Glen area of the Phoenix Park are at a more advanced stage. The details of the route, et cetera, have been agreed and leaflets have been prepared. Some steps and other physical improvements along the route of the trail remain to be completed, but the trail should be ready to be opened within the next few weeks. Deputy Esmonde, Deputy Tunney, Deputy Ruairí Brugha, Deputy Burke and others were very interested in the activities and incidents and physical exercises in the Phoenix Park.

Comment on this

Is that a follow-lip to the Furry Glen?

Comment on this

Or the Hollow?

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

That is for young people. Deputy Tunney and others referred to many problems in connection with horse-riding and motor traffic in the Phoenix Park. As mentioned in my opening statement, these and other problems are being examined in the light of the report on the Phoenix Park by the students from Bolton Street College. A very great volume of correspondence with interested parties has resulted from the report. With regard to horse-riding and the danger to pedestrians and children and people who normally use the park for recreational purposes, I do not know whether the proprietors of the stables take out an insurance policy on the horsemen, horsewomen or pedestrians who may be injured in the case of an accident. In the Office of Public Works we have no information at all on the subject. If it is a problem——

Comment on this

You have no public liability insurance yourselves?

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

No.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Parliamentary Secretary might inquire into it.

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

We will if it becomes a problem. It might be suggested that the people concerned should have a place like Rotten Row in London and that they should be confined to that area and trot their horses up and down inside a railing. Perhaps they should be given a paddock and let them do that. The allegation by Deputy Tunney that we were accessories after the fact was absolutely wrong because the Office of Public Works have nothing to do with commercialised horse-riding in the Phoenix Park.

Comment on this

Can we expect new bye-laws?

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

If the problem becomes acute we will have to have bye-laws.

With reference to the Phoenix Park Extension golf course, Deputy Seán Walsh made a strong appeal regarding the position of the people who would use this. He suggested that as it was a people's golf course the fees should be moderately low.

Deputy Lemass mentioned very many aspects of the rehabilitation of St. Enda's. With regard to permanent playing pitches in the precincts of St. Enda's, the area set aside for the pitches has been prepared and made ready and the Commissioners of Public Works are waiting to hear from the GAA about the lay-out of the pitches. It is all set and, when the GAA send in the area required for the pitches, everything will be arranged for them.

With regard to the orchard and the walled-in garden, work is in progress on the development of the walled-in garden. It is agreed that a nature trail would be a very desirable asset in the grounds of St. Enda's. The trail will be provided when the grounds are a little more developed and the general public will be better able to appreciate the surroundings. With regard to the outbuildings in St. Enda's, a working group composed of persons formerly connected with St. Enda's and representative of the Office of Public Works meet at certain intervals to make suggestions as to the best way of implementing the donor's wishes to have the property kept as a memorial to Patrick and William Pearse. It has been suggested that the science room and one classroom should be rehabilitated as far as possible and that two further rooms should be used as a centre for field studies. No suggestion has yet been made regarding the use of two other rooms in the outbuildings.

Deputy Andrews spoke about St. Stephen's Green and playing facilities there for both adults and children. That was adequately answered in reply to a Parliamentary Question this week and I do not propose to give any further information about it because I gave him all the information in the reply.

Derrynane National Park comprises an area of about 300 acres of some of the most beautiful scenery in the Iveragh Peninsula. It contains a mile-long stretch of sandy beach, small sheltered beaches, expansive sand dunes and woodlands. The management policy will be to preserve the unspoiled character of the park while affording the public the fullest opportunity to enjoy its various attractions consistent with sound conservation practice. Since the park was acquired the following works have been carried out. A serious breach in the sand dunes has been repaired. The sea wall protecting the sand dunes has been repaired. Three car parks have been provided, one at either end of the beach, and one near Derrynane House. Picnic sites, drinking water outlets and lifebelt stands have been provided at suitable locations. Two mobile toilets have been located at the beach car park. At present we are creating a water fowl sanctuary in a swampy area behind the sand dunes by dredging and the construction of a series of islands.

If the experiment proves successful it is intended to erect a small observation building for ornithologists and visitors interested in the hobby of bird watching. That might interest some Deputies. Informational and directional signs designed by the Kilkenny Design Workshop have been ordered and should be erected this summer. The approach roads are narrow and winding and it is proposed to discuss with Kerry County Council the question of widening these roads at certain points. The foregoing development should adequately meet the requirement of visitors for some years at least but the question of further improvements will be kept in mind if the need should arise.

Deputy Lemass raised the question of Kilkenny Castle and was critical of the fact that work has not yet commenced on the picture gallery although tenders were accepted before he left office. A tender has been accepted for the restoration of the picture gallery in the castle but the contractor was unable to proceed. New tenders had to be sought. These have been recently received and are being examined. This would be the second stage of work to the castle. The first stage mainly involved the checking of the spread of dry rot. Following completion of the restoration of the picture gallery other works would be tackled ill stages.

The Deputy also asked what progress the Butler Society had made with their fund raising campaign to finance the restoration of the south tower. A lease of the south tower to the society is being drafted. When this has been done the society intend to give the draft lease to their fund raising committee in America so that it can be shown to intending subscribers. The society state that there is considerable evidence of goodwill.

Then the Deputy asked what progress there has been towards the provision of a bar and restaurant. The provision of a bar and restaurant is proposed but this is a long-term project and it will not be considered in more detail, at least until the works on the picture gallery are well under way.

Deputy John Kelly asked about the future use of the castle; he also suggested that charges for entry to the castle should be made. When the castle was handed over to the Office of Public Works, the Kilkenny Castle restoration and development Society put forward certain ideas about the future use of the castle for various cultural activities, et cetera. These are being borne in mind. The Deputy's suggestion about charges for entry to the castle and use of the facilities will also be borne in mind. The feasibility of a nature trail in Kilkenny Castle park is being examined. It is thought that there are insufficient relatively natural features for an adequate trail in the park.

Deputy Lemass was anxious for information regarding the Shannon navigational system. He asked were there further meetings with the boat hirers on the Shannon. Deputy Lemass met a deputation of boat owners representing the Irish Boat Rental Association on 13th October, 1972. Representatives of the Office of Public Works met the association twice subsequently and informed the members of their office's maintenance and development programme for the 1973-74 financial year. The association appeared pleased with the proposals and it was agreed to hold other meetings in 1973. So far, the association have not requested any further meetings.

In reply to the Dáil question on 3rd May, 1973 Deputy Lemass was informed that at a recent meeting the association was made aware of the development and maintenance pro posals for the River Shannon for the coming financial year. These proposals include additional landing facilities at Mouthshannon, County Clare, Rossmore and Portumna, County Galway, Cloondara, County Longford, Albert Lough, Hudsons Bay and Rooskey, County Roscommon, Victoria Lough, County Offaly and Athlone. He also asked what was the position regarding the transfer of the Grand Canal and the Barrow navigation to the Office of Public Works. The arrangements for the future use of the Grand Canal, the Barrow navigation and also the Royal Canal are being considered at present by the Department of Transport and Power.

Deputy Calleary went far afield from the Grand Canal, as far as Lough Conn and Lough Curran, County Mayo, and he suggested the desirability of connecting Lough Conn and Lough Curran with the River Moy. That would be around Foxford. Row boats with outboard motors can travel along the Moy from Foxford into Lough Curran and thence into Lough Conn. As far as we know, there has been no great demand for the provision, of navigation for vessels of deeper draught.

Deputy Reynolds drew attention to the fact that the Ballinamore-Bally-connell Canal has two functions—as a waterway for boats and as a drainage channel. To reconcile these two functions may present problems. I am very conscious of its great potential as a link between the Shannon and the Erne and, indeed, in its own right, because of the very scenic area through which it passes. On receipt of the report and survey now in progress, I am hoping an early decision will be taken on it. It is evident that the great growth throughout the world of the use of inland waterways for recreational purposes offers tremendous possibilities for the development of such regions in this country and we should be prepared to take full advantage of them.

There were many miscellaneous queries from Deputies that do not fall into any specific category. I shall deal with those as briefly as I can. Deputy Lemass was anxious to know the position about the inscription on the back wall of the Garden of Remembrance in Parnell Square. As the Deputy will recall, a competition was held for a suitable initial inscription and poem in Irish. At the moment the commissioners are awaiting a lay-out of the design from the artist who is to do the inscription. I trust the work will start soon. I should, perhaps, point out that the poem will occupy only a small area of the wall. The intention seems to have been that inscriptions on the remainder of the wall had best be left to the future. There will be blank spaces on the wall so that at some future date suitable inscriptions can be made thereon.

In regard to the Casement memorial at Glasnevin, also referred to by Deputy Lemass, the statue has been cast and the pedestal has been prepared and it is hoped that the erection of a memorial will take place before long.

The same Deputy was critical of the delay in proceeding with the restoration of the Royal Hospital, Kilmainham. The Deputy should be aware of the very heavy pressure of urgent work to which all of the staff of the Office of Public Works are subject. This is the simple reason for there not being greater progress with the project. The Deputy may rest assured that the work will now be pushed ahead as quickly as possible but I am afraid it cannot be dealt with in the facile manner of picking an architect in private practice and giving him a free hand.

I do not propose to comment on the highly controversial issue of a special display of what to some people is unwelcome statuary beyond saying, like Deputy Kelly, the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach, that I think such objects should be left where they were first erected. This comment was consequent on a suggestion made by a Deputy whose name I forget that all the statues that were not wanted, including that of Queen Victoria, should be gathered together in some place—I think it was the Royal Hospital Kilmainham. This is a most beautiful place and if all the stray statues around the country were gathered and placed in various positions around it, it would spoil the balance of the place. I have a suggestion to make. This is ancillary to a suggestion made by Deputy Coogan. Deputy Coogan came up with the brilliant idea that we should have a "speaker's corner" like at Hyde Park. I would suggest that all these statues should be brought to the Phoenix Park or elsewhere and left there for the speakers to talk to.

Deputy Lemass raised the question of the supply of dungarees on a personal basis to employees in the central engineering workshops at Inchicore. This matter has been raised intermittently over the years but the claim has not yet been granted. I have requested that the matter be pursued energetically with the other Departments concerned.

Deputy Bermingham from Kildare alleged that the Office of Public Works extensively use imported plywood in their activities. It is completely incorrect to say that the Office of Public Works insist on imported plywood being used. Specifications for Office of Public Works jobs have, for a long time, provided that Irish-manufactured goods should be used so far as possible. I would ask the Deputy to let me know some specific instances of the position of which he complains and I will have them investigated. If necessary, I will meet the representatives of whatever Irish company may have complained through him.

Deputy Lemass and other Deputies referred to the matter of access for disabled people to public buildings. It is the settled policy of the Office of Public Works that all State buildings should be designed and existing buildings adapted, where possible and as opportunity offers, for easy access and use by the disabled. Particular care is given to the elimination of steps at entrances and on corridors, to making doors and corridors wide enough to take wheelchairs, bringing equipment such as telephones, switches, et cctera, within easy reach of wheelchair users, and the provision in every building of specially designed sanitary accommodation. Many of the aids for the disabled, such as properly designed staircases and ramps, also help to make buildings much safer to nondisabled users. The deaf and hard-ofhearing are catered for by supplementary audible alarms and flashing lights, The guidance and detailed instructions which were issued to all Office of Public Works architects will be reviewed in 1974 and modified, if this proves necessary.

Deputy John O'Leary considered that the cost of providing and maintaining courthouses should be borne by the State. This is a matter of policy, not for the Office of Public Works, but primarily for the Department of Justice in conjunction with the Department of Local Government.

Deputy John Kelly was critical of the scheme of decoration and carpeting in the State Apartments in Dublin Castle. He stressed that he was expressing a personal view. I must say that from national and international sources we heard nothing but the highest praise for the decor and furnishing of the apartments which attract thousands of visitors each year. Some years ago 40 or 50 experts as a group visited Dublin Castle. They were interested in the renovation, restoration, furnishing and decor of period buildings all over Europe. The leader of this group writing after the journey through Europe and in Ireland wrote that in the overall effect as regards restoration, et cetera, the State Apartments at Dublin Castle were the second best in Europe. The premier one was at some state building outside Paris. This criticism by Deputy John Kelly holds no water whatever according to the standards of European society.

Deputy Lemass referred to the question of the disposal of a site at Galway harbour which, he suggested, was the property of the commissioners. I am advised that the commissioners are not the owners of the site in question.

The proposed women's prison at Kilbarrack, Dublin, was the subject of a recent question to the Minister for Justice. Consequently, I do not propose to comment on it. In any event, discussion on the subject is proper to the discussion on the Estimate dealing with prisons and not on this Estimate.

The provision of a post office at Ballyfermot, Dublin, is a matter for the Department of Posts and Telegraphs. Deputy Lemass asked for an assurance that there would be no pull-back on the maintenance of our embassies abroad. I am happy to give the Deputy the assurance which he sought. In regard to the Asgard, the question of her future is now under careful consideration.

Deputy J. Lynch suggested the provision of an official residence for the Taoiseach. I accept that the Deputy made a most reasoned case for the proposal. I have made a note of his arguments and will have them submitted to the appropriate quarter for consideration.

Deputies Moore, Enright and Brugha referred to the problem of pollution and to conservation and were concerned about a central State body to be responsible for these matters. The Minister for Local Government is primarily responsible for the problem of pollution. It is a problem closely associated with the operation of the Planning Acts. The Office of Public Works have no power in that regard. They are vigilant to ensure the protection of the quality of life. Deputy Brugha was allowed to talk about a commission with reserved powers, and compulsory powers for conservation and the avoidance of pollution. Many bodies are concerned about this, but they are all going their separate ways. There seems to be no unified effort. The three Deputies concerned wish to make a suggestion that there should be a unified power such as a semi-State body or some kind of commission with reserved powers and that the efforts of local authorities and others should be unified.

Comment on this

Not a semi-State body.

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

They wish to have some kind of commission having reserved powers and with compulsory powers under which conservation and the avoidance of pollution could be assisted. I think it is a good idea. If that can be attempted in the near future it will get very favourable consideration.

Deputy Brugha and others referred to the position regarding the Kennedy Concert Hall. This was the subject of a Parliamentary Question to the Minister for Finance last week and it is unnecessary—indeed, it would be improper—for me to talk about the matter at this stage.

Deputy Seán Moore referred to the accommodation in the Children's Court and the bad condition of the building. and he suggested the provision of a temporary building pending the erection of the new major courts complex which is in progress at the present time. If the Deputy will look at page 10 of my introductory statement he will see it is intended to do this as soon as possible. The planning of the temporary building is, in fact, well in hand.

Deputy Gene Fitzgerald suggested that the Office of Public Works should delegate some of its authority for expenditure in the districts outside Dublin. It is the policy of the Office of Public Works to delegate as far as possible to local staffs, but I am sure the Deputy will appreciate that the commissioners are not without their own limits of authority.

Deputy Esmonde referred to the delay in payments to contractors who have built national schools. The Deputy is probably referring to final payment. Contractors go ahead with their commitments and with their assignments of contracting and they get interim payments as the building goes up. If the building does not come up to the standards required by the Office of Public Works, then, in ail justice, final payments must be retained until the building is in a satisfactory condition.

The provision of computers was mentioned by Deputy Crowley. There are seven computers for different Departments. One is in Inchicore for the Department of Finance and certain other Departments; one is in Kilmainham for Revenue; one is in Dundrum for Posts and Telegraphs; one is in Store Street for Social Welfare. The one for Defence is located at Coláiste Caoimhfn. There is one in Merrion Street for the Department of Lands, and one in Aras Brugha for Revenue.

I was talking to the Captain of the Guard, Commandant McEvoy, some time ago and he told me that since the last Estimate was introduced two members of his staff go at certain times to Strasbourg for experience in Parliaments of Europe. He accompanied them, of course, and, in his own words, he was very happy to relate and to record that they can hold their own amongst any personnel of the same category in any Parliament of Europe.

Comment on this

We would agree with that.

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

Before I conclude I should like to pay tribute to the staff and personnel of the Office of Public Works from the most menial post upwards in the whole organisation, both in Leinster House and in 51 St. Stephen's Green and in all the other locations scattered all over the city and country. They are efficient, courteous and co-operative, and I trust they will continue to be so. Since I took over this office they have always treated me in the very same way as they treated my predecessors down the years. I should also like to express my appreciation and sincere thanks to Deputies on both sides of the House who have offered their congratulations to me. I trust that when we next introduce our Estimate their feelings for me will be the very same as my feelings for them. I want to thank them most sincerely, because I believe that in offering me their congratulations and good wishes they were very sincere.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary dealt pretty quickly with the arrangement I made regarding certain flooding in Ballybofey. May I take it the arrangement we made to help to eliminate the flooding there will be proceeded with?

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

During my reply I mentioned that the excavators that were asked for by the people of Ballybofey were held in readiness by the Office of Public Works and, furthermore, that the services and advice of the engineers of the Office of Public Works will be given freely to the people of Ballybofey.

Comment on this

I just want to clarify this. I understand that the local authority have voted money from the rates to help towards the expenditure. I thought that this work should be starting about now during the summer months and I was wondering if the Parliamentary Secretary could give me some idea as to when it might commence.

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

That is a matter for the local authority. They must take the initiative.

Comment on this

Is there any problem between the engineers of the local authority and the Board of Works?

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

I do not think there is.

Comment on this

When is the next phase of decentralisation? Did the Parliamentary Secretary say the first one was in a fortnight's time?

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

It depends upon the location.

Comment on this

When will it be?

Comment on this
Mr. Kenny

Athlone is the next one for the Department of Education, unless, of course, the Deputy would prefer to have that moved down to Courtmacsherry.

Comment on this

Not Courtmacsherry, but other places.

Comment on this