Finance Bill, 1973: Second Stage.
Contributions 112–245 of 245. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 17 of 1973 ›
Financially, the country was in good shape. I hope that in subsequent years the Government will have an opportunity of improving social welfare benefits, that they will not say that things have gone sour on them and they cannot do certain things. We admit this is a budget which we could have introduced although we maintain we would have done so without any increase in taxation. We do not think that in a time of inflation it is necessarily a desirable thing to increase taxes.
There is no doubt that taxes have been increased; they have gone up this year from £235 per head of the population to £265 per head of population— an £11 increase per head. We do not know what is the figure for the working population. I hope the Government will bear in mind that the sections paying most in this country are the lower middle and middle income groups. We should not confuse these groups with class—a mistake made by many people is that they mean middleclass. We should be thankful we have a classless society here; many people who came from humble beginnings are doing very well and long may this continue.
The lower middle and middle income groups are being hit by taxation on cars and petrol. If there is another increase in the price of petrol I hope the Minister for Finance will implement the suggestion he made when in Opposition, that the Government remit part of the taxation to offset the increase. We know there are applications at the moment before the Minister for Industry and Commerce for an increase in the price of petrol. It would be desirable if the Minister for Finance implemented his own suggestion made in 1971 in connection with this matter.
Comment on this
I had hoped not to contribute to the debate on this Bill until next week because, although I spent some hours trying to examine its implications, I am afraid there is much more in it than appears at first sight. When the Minister decided to have a £40 million deficit, obviously he was taking a chance not only on the budget but with the economy generally. He was gambling on greater buoyancy and on many other things that may not happen. Should we find ourselves in a situation where there is no national agreement in the autumn, if the Bill we discussed here yesterday falls down and if we have a bank strike, if the Irish Congress of Trade Unions lose confidence in the people whom they consider to be their representatives in this House, if there is a break up of the economic development and in the question of pay increases within the next 12 months, that chance will not come off. I expect that the Minister was encouraged in his decisions as a result of the good government that preceded him. The previous Administration left the Minister £27.8 million better off than was forecast this time last year. There was a further saving of £31 million in the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture and Fisheries as a result of our membership of the EEC. Despite the fact that no Government in the history of this State have ever taken office with an amount in pocket of £58 million, £59 million or £60 million——
Comment on this
Would the Minister like to read his own Estimates? There is a saving of £31 million in respect of agriculture. I have it here even on——
Comment on this
The Deputy is being so inaccurate that it does not matter whether the amount is £27 million or some other figure.
Comment on this
I reaffirm that the income to the previous Government was increased over and above the Estimate presented here 12 months ago by £27.8 million. Despite all these advantages we have had a budget——
Comment on this
Let me remind the Deputy that the budget has been debated already in this House in great detail and that we are now dealing with the Finance Bill and, in accordance with the tradition of the House, the Chair, cannot allow the same scope on a Finance Bill as is allowed during a debate on a budget. The Chair would wish the Deputy to confine his remarks to the Finance Bill as such.
Comment on this
I was interrupted, Sir, but I assure you that all my remarks will be related directly to the Finance Bill although you might find that some of them will be out of order.
Comment on this
Having made it clear that there was much scope available to the Government to facilitate them in introducing this Bill and without going into the early sections, it seems that they have been out of office for so long, perhaps because of our PR system, that they could not be aware of how best to use the moneys available to them. When this Government took office the rate of expansion in the economy of the country was going forward at such a great momentum that it had to continue at that rate for some months. Perhaps, now, those months are up and we will have to find out what the Government have to offer. Maybe in framing the Bill, the Minister for Finance was looking forward hopefully to a repetition of last year's situation when taxes brought in a sum of £36.7 million more than the Minister forecast the previous year.
Comment on this
The expenditure was only exceeded by £12.3 million. For the sake of the people of this country I hope sincerely that the Minister's forecasts are realised. It would be a great tragedy if we were to fall back into the same sort of situations as those of 1948 and 1954.
Comment on this
It seems to me that the Deputy is making a speech that would be more appropriate to a budget debate.
Comment on this
The budget appears to me to be a gambler's budget, a budget in which the Government have taken a chance on certain events happening during the next year but without any guarantee that such events will occur. Yesterday we discussed the question of the pay of bank officials. Perhaps we have taken a gamble on that which will not come off.
Comment on this
From research I have done it seems to me that the present Government are doing exactly what the Government of 1948 to 1951 did.
Comment on this
It seems to the Chair that the Deputy is making a general speech that would be more appropriate to a budget debate.
Comment on this
I offered to contribute to the budget debate. I understood that the Whips agreed on a curtailment. In the Finance Bills of 1948 and 1951 there were certain similarities with the Bill that is now before us. These similarities are apparent to anyone who has been involved in politics. It seems that the present Bill was designed originally for the purpose of trying to give credibility to the new Government, to bring about the greatest national support possible for this Government. I should like to say to the men who are sitting over there on the Front Bench at the moment that the Bill may have been designed for the purpose of having a snap election in the autumn so as to get rid of those two gentlemen. I know that the media have been making excuses for this Government before they even act on anything. The Government were so confident of winning the Presidential election in which the Labour Party were supporting Fine Gael——
Comment on this
The result of the Presidential election was an indication of what the people think of this Government.
Comment on this
I have been a Member of this House since 1956. This is not my first time to serve in Opposition. Indeed, I first took an active interest in politics as long ago as 1948. I remember exactly what happened then and what sort of Finance Bill was introduced in that year.
Comment on this
Surely, the Finance Bill of 1948 is relevant. Admittedly, the Coalition Government of that time had a certain difficulty because it was then sacrosanct to have a balanced budget but now there is a gamble involving £40 million to £50 million. Despite the fact that the Coalition Government of 1948 introduced a Finance Bill that was similar in many respects to the Bill now before us and that they tried to gain popularity, they also tried to cut out any worthwhile scheme that the previous Fianna Fáil administration had put in. Thank God in the 1950's they had more sense but they did exactly as they are doing now, introducing policies and programmes. Indeed we have millions of pounds committed already before the Finance Bill is even passed, millions of pounds in promises. It is probably a criticism of the democratic system. Perhaps Fianna Fáil were too long in government. It is certainly true that those boys have been out of government too long because they do not know what it is about.
Comment on this
You did that in 1948. All you are doing now is introducing our legislation. You have not introduced one bit of legislation yourselves except this Bill that is before us now. It is the only one and that was prepared for you before you came in. I can even tell you where the cuts are in it because I know about it. I was in the Department of Finance, and do not forget that.
Comment on this
Some of the promises have been spent. They have been cashed by the old age pensioners.
Comment on this
The present Government may not realise that the forces that were at work in 1948 and in the 1950's are not dead. They are at work again today.
Comment on this
The Chair is very anxious that the Deputy would relate his remarks to the matter under discussion.
Comment on this
These forces are still at work and the Government must recognise them. Otherwise this Finance Bill cannot have any effect. In 1948 the then Minister for Agriculture, the late Mr. James Dillon, a man for whom I had great respect——
Comment on this
The former Deputy James Dillon. He not only had plans for land reclamation but he was going to put every brick in Connemara into the Atlantic Ocean. Each coalition came up with these ambitious ideas. Everything was going to be great until Mr. McGilligan, a former Minister for Finance——
Comment on this
Mr. McGilligan found out he had a Bill. On our side of the House it was termed the "McGilligan Axe".
Comment on this
Richie Ryan, I am afraid, is less credible than Mr. McGilligan was. Of all the first Finance Bills I have seen introduced by Coalition Governments this is probably the poorest attempt.
Comment on this
The Deputy said not ten minutes ago that it was Deputy Ryan's predecessor who prepared that Bill.
Comment on this
I said that this is the first bit of legislation the new Government have brought in. Deputy O'Leary yesterday was at pains to explain that the Bill he was introducing was prepared by his predecessor, with one amendment. This is the first thing we can get our teeth into, if the Ceann Comhairle will allow us.
Comment on this
The Deputy spoke of so many things conceived but never delivered. It was incredible.
Comment on this
I am trying to warn the Tánaiste, not the Parliamentary Secretary, that the same forces that were at work in 1948——
Comment on this
I suggest the Tánaiste goes and has a chat with Matty Merrigan or Noel Browne, or someone.
Comment on this
The experience we had of Finance Bills from previous coalition governments is that they have been designed to ensure the extension of reclamation of land, the extension of house building, road building and anything at all that would get the new government quick, popular support and give them the reputation of a government that could work. I regret that I see these same tactics again today. If the Labour Party are going to succumb completely to Fine Gael that is their business, it has nothing to do with me, but I see the same tactics. Perhaps we are to have an election in the autumn. We have the quick introduction of measures that have not been fully thought out. Any item put to this House by the Government should be thought out and they should ensure that it will benefit the people as a whole.
When Mr. McGilligan was Minister for Finance balanced budgets were absolutely sacrosanct. Now, we can have a deficit budget. Indeed, I think it was a Fianna Fáil Minister who introduced the first one. The deficit in this Bill is such that it cannot be fiddled with any more. We have gone as far as we possibly can. What happens if there is a national strike, if there is a breakdown in international co-operation, if we cannot export our products? What happens? The Government are in trouble. They cannot do it again next year and the "McGilligan Axe" comes down again. What happened the last time? Who paid the piper? The ordinary worker who lost his job. I saw ordinary workers who had been in jobs for 40 years being put out of work because of the sort of gambler's budget we have before us now. The Minister for Finance pays the piper and he calls the tune. The Minister for Finance has spoken off the cuff a few times here without checking the record. I would warn the Tánaiste that no Minister, particularly a Minister for Finance, should speak off the cuff without checking the record. The Minister for Local Government and the Minister for Education come second and third in that regard. I tabled many questions to find the weaknesses and the biggest weakness in this Government is the Minister for Finance because he is not prepared to check his record. He is prepared to speak off the cuff any time he takes it into his head. Neither you, nor you, will be consulted. He does it when he takes it into his head. I am sorry, I should address the Chair.
Comment on this
The Chair dislikes intervening, but if the Deputy continues to make a wide-ranging speech going back over a considerable period of time and utterly unrelated to the matter under discussion, I shall have to ask him to desist from making any further comments.
Comment on this
Even if you rule me out of order, Sir, I have something else to follow up. I believe it is relevant to refer to the first Finance Bill introduced by three coalition governments. I will hand credit to the Minister for Local Government in 1948 who set an all-time record in local government housing. I do not think the Fianna Fáil Government were able to catch up on that. At the same time the "McGilligan Axe" fell.
Comment on this
There is. There is £3.5 million. Indeed, we were promised in The Irish Times of Thursday, 15th February, that there would be £15 million for housing.
Comment on this
The Chair is concerned about the Deputy going into the matter of the housing policy.
Comment on this
I am only mentioning that in a general way as a warning to the Government not to do what their predecessors did in the last Coalition. I am pleading with the Government to check their facts and not to make statements until they are sure of what they are talking about. They are not doing that now and are apparently speaking as individual back-benchers. If my plea has any effect on them I believe I am doing the nation a service.
If one goes back to the Finance Act of 1948 and studies it, and then studies the present Finance Bill, one will see that all the great promises, which were not thought out, cannot be financed. Then we will see this great image, this great project, starting to crumble. What will happen? The Government will break up and they will go to the country to try to salvage any support they have left. Then, naturally, it will be left to Fianna Fáil to clean up the mess.
The latest example of what I mean is the concession given by the Minister for Local Government in an effort to try to settle the very serious dispute in relation to differential rents.
Comment on this
That is completely out of order. The Deputy cannot refer to that matter at all. It is more appropriate to the Estimate for Local Government which will be introduced in this House shortly.
Comment on this
I should like to make a general remark. It is obvious that the Minister for Local Government has not checked out what it is going to cost. He has given a figure, and I know, from the checks I made, that he knows less about what it is going to cost than any commissioner he has appointed to the Dublin Corporation.
We are faced again with another nice, rosy first Coalition Government Finance Bill. It is probably the worst first Coalition Finance Bill we have ever seen. I know that because I have been at this thing since 1948.
Comment on this
I would describe this Bill as the Bill of a gambler. That accusation was made against my father when he was a Minister by James Dillon. It is absolutely a gambler's budget, and a gambler's Finance Bill, and if certain things happen it will work. It is only being introduced with a gambler's instinct, no doubt the Taoiseach gave his approval because I know he is keen on that sort of thing, because of the great growth in taxation that took place as a result of the impetus given by the previous administration.
Since this Bill was introduced we have had promises, not only about differential rents, but promises across the board which could involve millions of pounds of expenditure. Nobody states where that money is going to come from, they are just promises which gives me the suspicion that we may be going to the country again before Christmas, much to the detriment of the Labour Party. Is reference to differential rents completely out of order.
Comment on this
I am very anxious to help the Deputy but he is roaming away from the subject matter on this question altogether. He should get back to the Finance Bill.
Comment on this
It appears to me that the Minister for Local Government is trying to gain short-term personal popularity at the expense of long-term national interest.
I would like to remind the House that we have a commitment from the Government not only to declare a national emergency in relation to housing but in the first year to increase expenditure on housing by £15 million. The increase, however, only amounts to £3.5 million.
Comment on this
We cannot have a debate on housing at this juncture. It does not appertain to taxation. The Estimate for the Department of Local Government is about to come before the House, possibly tomorrow, certainly next week. The Deputy can make a speech appertaining to differential rents and housing during the debate on that Estimate.
Comment on this
Can anyone explain to me how it is that we have a commitment from the Government to spend £15 million on housing and to declare a national emergency but the Bill only provides for £3.5 million?
Comment on this
This is very difficult because surely the whole basis of our political thinking, and programming, is dependant upon the Finance Bill which is the Bill which brings in the money. It is not going to bring in as much as the Government think. When the £15 million which was promised was reduced to £3.5 million the Minister for Local Government gave as his excuse for doing this the fact that plans had not been made. As far as I am aware, the biggest owner of building land in the country is Dublin Corporation and if the city medical officer were to approve of drainage systems such as septic tanks, which are acceptable in every country in the EEC, there would be no difficulty in increasing the building target to what was promised before the election.
Comment on this
The Deputy must know that what he is speaking about now is more appropriate to the Estimate for the Department of Local Government.
Comment on this
The Deputy is continuing to circumvent the advice, and the rulings, of the Chair. If he persists in that I shall have to ask him to sit down.
Comment on this
I have given the Deputy every latitude. Almost all of what he is saying, and has said, does not relate to the Finance Bill. I would ask the Deputy to forget about whatever brief he has and to get down to the Finance Bill.
Comment on this
I should now like to refer to a copy of The Irish Times of February 15th which carried the following headline: “Coalition Plans Tax On Capital Wealth”. I wonder can Chapter II of this Bill justify the headline? In that Chapter we have “Interpretation,”“Charge of stamp duty,” and “Statement to be charged with stamp duty.” If one goes through all of this section one will find that this pre-election headline was completely unjustified. We had a statement from the Minister for Finance yesterday and a statement from many Ministers about the new Government's intent. The first time that it appeared, The Irish Times again turned around and said that at last they have to hold their own buck— that is, their own legislation. The Minister for Labour came in here and said that that legislation was prepared, with one amendment, by the previous Administration.
Coalition plans, a tax on capital wealth: I listened to all the promises and statements made by the new Government and I got worried about things and I decided to put down a question. I have here a letter signed by the Ceann Comhairle:
I regret that I have to disallow this question as it contains argument—
I do not think it contains argument; I just wanted a "yes" or "no".
The question addressed by you to the Taoiseach regarding action the Government proposes to take other than issuing statements of legislative intent...
That is all we have had—statements of legislative intent, no action.
Again in The Irish Times of 15th February we read that the Coalition parties announced that, if they were elected with a majority, they would abolish the means test. Where is that in this Finance Bill? I cannot see it anywhere. The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Social Welfare, Deputy Cluskey, and I know each other well and he knows that this is not a fulfilment of that commitment. We read of a promise of the total abolition of estate duties. This has not happened in this Bill. This was what we were looking for in this Bill. We had a statement from the Minister for Finance yesterday telling us he was going to do away with surtax and God knows what else. I do not know who will pay the bill.
Then we read in the same paper about the rates on houses and taxes and so on and no mention of castles and office blocks and factory premises. These are going to be reduced by half. On the rates question we were led to believe we would get the devil and all. The rates on my house went up by 1p in the £. They could have gone up more if health charges had not been removed. All these frauds are being put across on the public and, when I take all these frauds into consideration, I can only call the Minister for Finance by the same sobriquet as is applied to a much more illustrious person at the moment and call him "Tricky Dicky". Is that out of order?
Comment on this
There is one thing very clear in this Finance Bill. We find that the rich are getting richer and those less rich will be lucky if they are able to hold their own. I have been associated with the Minister for Finance for a long time, since before he won the by-election in Dublin South West. When one thinks of his statement in the last week about sur-tax and when one examines the budget and this Finance Bill before us today one can only come to the conclusion that the Labour Party have been completely absorbed by the right wing thinking of the Fine Gael Party because this Bill, to my mind, confers very little benefit on the lower paid in our community. If sur-tax is abolished, as was announced by the Minister, though it is not in the Bill, who will pay for its abolition? It will be the lower paid worker. It will be part of value-added tax. This is traditional Fine Gael thinking and I hope the Labour Party have not been swallowed up by it completely.
The Minister for Finance has seen fit to announce a basic change in taxation policy. I assume he did not consult his Labour colleagues; he just went out on a limb and announced this basic change in taxation policy in relation to sur-tax. It seems to me the Minister for Finance, the Minister for Local Government, the Minister for Education, and others I could name but they are not relevant to this Bill, are going off half cocked, without checking up on their statements and checking out the ultimate result.
Comment on this
The Deputy has repeated these sentiments before. The Deputy is indulging in repetition.
Comment on this
I am trying to relate my remarks to the statement of the Minister for Finance last week. The Minister has come out now and made statements and, before this Bill is passed, he is changing the content of the Bill. Surely that is relevant.
Comment on this
I have got trick-of-the-loops and gimmicks here which you, Sir, ruled out of order before. I do not know whether you are trying to knock me off or what. I have the stuff written down here. I will get back to it. Basic changes planned in our income tax: again this seems to be a hasty commitment. Is that repetition? I do not think so. Not thought out in full. That is not repetition. A gimmick, a trick-of-the-loop directed at courting short-term popularity rather than the long-term welfare of the State.
Comment on this
Yes, but it was in relation to something else. I will go back to The Irish Times of February 15th in which the Minister for Foreign Affairs, Dr. Garret FitzGerald, says that £30 million will be available through membership of the EEC and this money will be used for social purposes. There is, of course, no need to remind the House that this commitment was first made by the Fianna Fáil Party. The Minister for Finance in his financial statement, which I have here, suggested that this was a misleading situation and that this £30 million was not available and, if it is in order, I would refer the House to Vote No. 37, Agriculture, 1972-73, where £86.4 million was allocated for that year and for the year 1973-74 the amount was £59.5 million and, in anyone's language, that is a saving of £31 million. I do not care how you add it up, it must be. It is very difficult for people on this side of the House to analyse out fully. When I was on that side of the House I could ring up and ask: “Could you give me a few notes on this or that?” Now I have to do it all myself. I spent five or six hours reading this Finance Bill and the more I read it the more I was inclined to come back to the description given to the President of the United States—“Tricky Dicky”.
No one has to go further than section 3. When we come to section 3 we can best understand the devious mind of the Minister for Finance. I have just given my wife a rise because I am anticipating one myself. Under section 3, if I earn £2,500 a year plus, there is a direct transfer from my income to my wife by way of children's allowances. I know the Minister. We stood in the same constituency until the last revision. I now represent Ballyfermot, Inchicore, Drimnagh, and so on. Most husbands give children's allowances to their wives. What the Minister has done in section 3 is to take £1 per week from me and give it to my wife. Nothing more and nothing less. My wife is probably delighted. Do you not think that "Tricky Dick" is a good name?
Comment on this
However, I think it is a good title. Section 4 is also peculiar. This is probably the first chance we had of saying something without the Minister for Local Government asking: "What did you do about it in the past 16 years?" I am getting a bit sick of that. The record is getting worn out. To me politics is an evolving situation. A Local Government Bill can be brought in this year which will be outdated next year. You are very strict, Sir.
Comment on this
I should like the Minister to explain fully to the House exactly what he means about his amendments to the national taxation code, particularly in relation to sur-tax. This is a very serious matter. I have dealt with it lightly tonight but it is not a matter that should be dealt with lightly. I am very concerned about what the Minister has in mind. I am concerned to know if he has collective Government support for his announcement. I am very concerned to know if this is his only budget for this financial year.
Comment on this
When I decided to speak on the Second Reading of the Finance Bill I had hoped that I could come into the House and listen to speeches made by members of the National Coalition parties. It is a pity that we are getting a walk-over tonight and that only two members of the smaller Government party are in the House tonight. Perhaps at this time of the year, when the ground is hard, we can understand the field being small but a walk-over is something we were not expecting. I intend to confine my remarks to the speech made by the Minister for Finance when he moved the Second Stage of this Bill. The Minister's opening remarks give us a clue to his ideas about this Bill. He said:
This Government aim to make Ireland a new and better land.
By "new" I presume he meant that there would be new thinking by this galaxy of talent which we were told was available and the new Cabinet who would provide an antidote for all ills. We were expecting that and, because it was new, we were to presume that automatically it would be better. The Minister also said that this is one of the prosaic but essential steps he had to take to legalise the measures in his budget. The word "prosaic" to me indicates that the Minister felt it a pity he had to make use of this old vehicle which proved so very cumbersome when he viewed it from this side of the House. I should like the Minister to let us know what is new in it and what is better. The Minister indicated, when he presented his budget, and all the items included in this Finance Bill, that he had three aims in view. He said:
... first of all, its central fiscal action was designed to lift the growth rate appreciably, thereby taking up the slack and underused capacity in the economy and helping to reduce the level of unemployment, which is a serious social and economic problem....
I should like to compliment the civil servant who framed that beautiful sentence. To me it is simply a hackneyed phrase. I hope it will be achieved. More about that anon.
The second aim of the Minister's budget was that it should provide worthwhile improvement in the social welfare sphere. I must admit that it provides some worthwhile improvements but, as already stated, all these improvements were envisaged by our party and announced, not before the general election, but exactly a year ago during a campaign in west Cork. We announced that £30 million would be spent on social welfare improvements and I am glad the Minister has abided by that decision and honoured the promises made by his predecessor. The Minister also said:
... finally, the first stage of the implementation of a comprehensive tax reform programme.
I have looked at the different sections of the Bill and have yet to find evidence of any major or worthwhile tax reforms. The Minister goes on to state how his action will help to stimulate the economy and strengthen the infrastructure and provide a higher level of employment, and forecasts that there will be a rise of £130 million in current expenditure. He has high hopes that during the year our industrial production will increase and domestic consumer investment demand will be expanded. He thinks many beneficial results will accrue to our economy and he ends on the hopeful note that all sectors will benefit from the increased activity which will be generated.
In the Minister's case that is wishful thinking but, for the sake of the people, I sincerely hope the Minister is correct because, as our previous speaker said, he is playing with the economy of the nation and the jobs and the means of livelihood of our people. Since a forgiving electorate forgave the two parties opposite twice before, I do not think they deserve to be duped a third time. I hope for the sake of the people, more so than for the sake of the Government, that his forecast will prove correct.
I note that there are increases in pensions and allowances and we are all glad of that. It should be mentioned that those increases will only do the good they were expected to do if they keep pace with price increases. I saw recently that the £ in May, 1972, was worth only 89.6p. If the rate of inflation increases it is unlikely that the good we had hoped would be done by social welfare increases will accrue to those most in need. The fact that the Minister for Finance was in a position in Government to bring in the budget possibly can be attributed to the fact that his party promised to stop the price rises.
Comment on this
I would remind the Deputy that we are dealing with the Finance Bill which deals primarily with taxation. The Deputy's remarks would be more appropriate on the Budget. I feel that the Deputy did speak on the budget and I would prefer if the Deputy would keep his remarks to the Finance Bill.
Comment on this
I regret if I have strayed. There is a link between the price increases people on social welfare have to pay and the increases in benefits that they have perceived. I had hoped that one would counteract the other. Now I am doubtful.
When the increases were first forecast it was mentioned that all the recipients would get the increases in July. The Tánaiste made great capital of the fact that the increases would be implemented in July, a month earlier than they had ever been implemented in our case. I hope everybody has got the increase. I am doubtful if they did.
Comment on this
Again, the Deputy is referring to policy matters appertaining to social welfare. It is not in order.
Comment on this
I am dealing with page 2 where the Minister states that in a full year the increase in existing expenditure on social welfare will be 44 per cent. When the Minister makes such a statement one would expect that social welfare recipients would be delighted. I do not see any great sign that they are very thankful. It would be wrong of me to suggest that the electorate are a thankless people. Are we to conclude, then, that they do not appreciate the benefits?
I should like to know why the Government found it necessary to spend a lot of money on very expensive press advertising to tell the people how well off they were and how well off they would be and to indicate that they are the "greatest". It is generally accepted, I think, that they are the "greatest". Such publicity suggests the lady doth protest too much. One wonders if the publicity is true.
The Minister has made provision in this Bill for penalties for employers who do not keep their books and do not submit PAYE payments up to date. I suppose this is as it should be. He now intends charging interest in respect of delayed payments. I suppose that is as it should be. I wonder what reaction there would be to the suggestion that interest should be paid in respect of delay in payments on the part of the Government. I have in mind social welfare payments that are delayed for quite a long time. I venture to suggest that the amount of money waiting to be paid to social welfare recipients would offset the amount involved in delayed payment of tax. My sympathy is with employers, in particular small employers, who have to keep their own books and who, in fact, are unpaid tax collectors and who are in for a very difficult time because of the varying rates of tax.
The Minister again found it necessary to refer to the yacht and the motor car, as he did when he was presenting his budget. I welcome this because a person who can afford to keep a car worth more than £2,500 deserves to be taxed on it. Very few of us can afford to have a yacht. We might aspire to getting a spin in one occasionally. It is only right that yachts should be taxed. I compliment the Minister on that. I would not agree with Government speakers who have tried to suggest that it is only persons on this side of the House who are fortunate enough to have yachts. If this suggestion is to be pursued it should be substantiated.
I am happy to note that the Minister had a change of heart and has allowed small investors to get interest of up to £70 free of tax. I compliment the Minister on that because when he first indicated that he was going to tax these persons it was an indication to me that the small investor would be taxed and also persons or companies who have saving schemes. I have in mind Bord na Móna and other concerns whose employees were encouraged to save. If these small investors were taxed there would be no encouragement to save. If that policy had been pursued it would have had a detrimental effect on the economy. Small investors who, perhaps, had sold property and invested the proceeds in the hope of securing a modest living for themselves would have been in a bad way. I realise that the Minister has some difficulties. There are persons who deposit in various banks amounts small enough to ensure that the interest will not reach £70. If that is done on an extensive scale by an investor, say, investing in ten or 12 banks, it can lead to considerable tax evasion. In general, the Minister is to be complimented on choosing the lesser of two evils. By this means he will help to keep money in this country and that money will be available to building societies and the banks. The Minister refers to the fact that an effort has been made to encourage the giving of loans by building societies.
I realise that the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Local Government are very concerned about the need for housing. A great deal of money will be required. I calculate that if the target indicated by the Coalition parties in pre-election promises of 25,000 houses a year is to be reached it will require £100 million. I do not see any provision in the Finance Bill for that £100 million. I hope it will appear. I know that an earnest effort is being made by the Minister for Local Government to provide houses. This was one of the planks in the pre-election campaign. When I mentioned on a former occasion that this promise was made, the Chief Whip of the Government party asked me to substantiate that. I am now prepared to do so. I have here a document issued by his party.
Comment on this
He did offer to contribute £1 to our election fund in my constituency. I would just like to bring that matter to his notice. If he cares to contact me I will be very pleased to accept that £1 and put it to very good use. I have the evidence here to indicate that I was right and the Chief Whip was wrong. I shall compliment the Minister on any effort he may make to ensure that this £100 million will be available to build the 25,000 houses this year. Whatever Government succeed in solving the housing problem will be doing a great day's work.
I am not so happy about the increase on beer, spirits and tobacco. When the year is over I wonder if the increase will mean we have crossed over the thin line of diminishing returns and that we will have less revenue from these items than we had last year. Will it mean that it was not worthwhile increasing the prices? I have in mind the old age pensioner who has received an increase in his pension but finds he must pay more for cigarettes and tobacco. I am not sure the Minister made a wise decision in this matter.
I am not happy with the manner of dealing with estate duty. Admittedly the changes that have been made are welcome but not enough has been done. It is not in keeping with the promise made by Fine Gael that when they came into government they would abolish estate duties on property. Deputy Lemass used an expression I shall not use, but perhaps the phrase "Risky Richard" might not be too bad to use. I hope that the Minister will raise the limit with regard to estate duty to £10,000.
Much play has been made of the effect of the removal of VAT from food. We have been told that great benefits will accrue to the consumer, although I wonder what the consumer thinks about it. Some months ago we forecast that the removal of VAT from food would not have the considerable effect on the household budget as stated by the Government and we maintain that what we said was correct. The Minister mentioned that the £30 million we forecast would be available for increased social welfare benefits had been swallowed in a sea of inflation——
Comment on this
I am satisfied that when VAT is removed from food the effect will not be as forecast by the Minister; it will be smothered by galloping inflation and no benefit whatever will accrue to the consumer. I am sure that anyone who has to keep to a tight budget every week will agree with me on this. Even at this stage, I wonder if it would be any use in prevailing on the Minister, now that he has decided to remove VAT from food, to remove it also from footwear, clothing and fuel? I mentioned this before but the Taoiseach did not appear to consider fuel as an essential and said it was only a seasonal item. I consider it is essential and, seeing that measures have been taken to remove VAT from food, I am sorry fuel was not included also. With the removal of VAT from food, shopkeepers will have to cope with different taxes and they will have more trouble with their book-keeping. These unpaid tax collectors will have more trouble and possibly will get less money.
The Minister paid tribute to the Minister for Industry and Commerce in connection with price control measures. We were promised as an immediate measure that price increases would be curbed immediately. I appreciate it is not easy to do this and I hope the recent measures taken by the Minister will have an effect. He delayed some time in taking them but I hope he will be in a position to tell us that price increases are under control. It would be pleasant to know that this was one pre-election promise that was kept and honoured. Up to now statistics have shown that prices have increased much more in the last few months than in the previous year.
However, all is not on the debit side so far as the budget is concerned. I should like to compliment the Minister for exempting horses and greyhounds from tax. This will be welcomed particularly in my constituency. These two industries have made much progress, they have achieved a high place in the world market and we can more than hold our own with any other country. Both industries give plenty of employment and it is nice to know that whether a bloodstock breeder decides to sell at Ballsbridge or Newmarket he will get the same opportunity in either place. I hope the measure taken by the Minister will ensure that both industries continue in their present buoyant state.
When the Minister was dealing with the amendment of the Finance (Excise Duties) (Vehicles) Act he skipped rather lightly over the matter. I was sorry he did not tell us more about it; he should have told us more about the £50 tax on cut-down trucks. It was scarcely mentioned on budget day and the Minister got away with it very lightly now. I note that tractors are now taxed at £50. I know of many farmers who have supported the Minister's party in the past who are perturbed about this, who consider this measure should not be taken and that it will be detrimental to farmers.
The Minister concluded his speech by commending the Bill to the House. The effects of the Bill cannot be judged now—they will be judged in April or May, 1974. Will we have the new and better land the Minister promised? Will the Bill ensure protection for the individual? Is the Minister happy that this Bill gives a fair chance to the middle income man whose means are known? Will the man earning more than £50 per week suffer because of this Bill? I think he will because he is the person who is paying the piper but is not allowed to call the tune. Will this taxation be used to cure the housing ills that exist? Will the Minister for Industry and Commerce be able to halt the spiralling price increases? This is something about which everyone is concerned and I hope the efforts he will make will be effective.
However, when they were framing policies that appealed to the people and which resulted in their being elected, there seemed to be no difficulty in promising that prices would not be increased. I hope they can now honour such promises. I hope, too, that the economy will remain as buoyant as the Minister expects it to remain. It is a pity that on this occasion ex-Deputy, Dr. O'Donovan, who was always so brilliant when speaking on either the floating or the sinking of the £, is not with us because I am sure he would be able to give us a lot of information about the present state of the economy.
I notice also that the Labour Party promised to increase the level of the personal tax-free allowance. I do not see any evidence of any such increase. The promise was one that could be forgotten easily. All we can do is wait and hope that we will be proved wrong in some of our dismal forecasts. Only in a year's time will we be in a position really to judge the merits or demerits of this Bill. Perhaps, then we may have an indication as to why that brilliant and loquacious team who have been telling us for so many years what we should do have remained sullen and silent while this Bill was being debated.
Comment on this
Deputy Power opened his speech by referring to a sentence in the first paragraph of the Minister's brief. The Deputy remarked that this sentence seemed odd to him. Perhaps if I quote the sentence concerned, people other than Deputy Power and I will detect something either odd or naïve in regard to the Minister when he said:
This Government aim to make Ireland a new and better land.
This hypocritical philosophy is being used to keep the citizens happy while the Government are testing the effectiveness or ineffectiveness of the budget. Lest the Minister should think that any such philosophy might cheer us up, we must tell him that his help will have to take the form of something more firm and not be as prosaic as that put forward.
This Bill has a kind of schizophrenic outlook in the sense that the Government are claiming credit for anything that is good in it while blaming the ineffectiveness of the previous Government for anything that is putrid in it. The Government cannot have it both ways. The Minister, in his wisdom or otherwise, has set out on a false premise in regard to this Bill because the greatest problem of this country today is that of inflation, but one can find nothing but inflationary tendencies in every line of the Bill Indeed, the lot of many people will be worsened greatly by this time next year as a result of it. To give an indication of what I mean, I shall refer to a letter sent by Dublin Corporation to an old age pensioner in which he is told that he is being granted a waiver of rates in accordance with the policy of the Government but that his rent, which had been £2.05 per week, is now being increased to £2.62. At the top of the letter there is a note reminding the recipient that the increased social welfare benefits must be taken into account in assessing his new rent. Consequently, this man will now have to pay an extra 57p per week in rent. That sums up the effectiveness of this budget.
The Finance Bill proposes no fewer than 17 amendments to existing legislation. I do not wish to decry the Finance Bill in all its aspects but it is the duty of every Deputy to point out the wrongs that are inherent in the Bill and why it will not help in bringing about a new or a better Ireland. As Deputy Lemass pointed out earlier, even the increases that are being given in respect of children's allowances will be subject to a clawback in so far as one section of the community are concerned. I expect that the Minister did his best in preparing the budget; it may be said that the time available to him to do so was not sufficient but we must remember that no Minister in the history of this State has ever had such advantages in preparing his budget as had the present Minister. We know that there was a large saving available to him in respect of agricultural subsidies by reason of our membership of the EEC and that there was a large saving also as a result of the thrift of the previous Government. Admittedly, some good increases are being given on the social welfare side but there was no relief whatever in respect of income tax apart from the provision in relation to a wife's earned income.
Comment on this
Fianna Fáil gave such relief in several of their budgets, including the last one they introduced.
Comment on this
The Deputy is on the losing side if he wishes to compare the last budget with Fianna Fáil budgets. The whole fault of this Bill is that it proposes to impose much greater taxation. The Government may say that there is £140 million on current expenditure and £60 million on capital expenditure but I wonder whether, at the end of the financial year when the £60 million capital investment has been exhausted—I remember the last Coalition Government voting huge sums towards national development but——
Comment on this
I would not wish in any way to question your ruling, Sir, but I think that in his brief the Minister set the headline for some of the speeches that are being made here, because he referred very much to the budget and to expenditure.
Comment on this
The Chair must point out that the scope of the debate on the Finance Bill cannot be of the same latitude as that of a budget debate.
Comment on this
I understand that, but if the Minister deals with all those other matters, Deputies on this side should be entitled to follow his brief.
Comment on this
Surely it is in order to quote from the first page of the Minister's brief, if not, the Minister should have been ruled out of order. I shall quote from the Minister's brief. He said:
The budgetary action to stimulate the economy, strengthen the national infrastructure and thereby raise the level of employment is clearly evidenced by the rise of £130 million in current expenditure and of some £60 million in capital expenditure or a combined rise of over 20 per cent.
The Minister takes £130 million plus £60 million and rounds it off at a combined rise of over 20 per cent. The Minister may be right, his experts would probably find that he was right, but I am saying that even though the Minister has this in his brief there is no guarantee that by the end of the current financial year there will have been a combined rise of over 20 per cent. The weakness in this Finance Bill is that it is inflationary. The Minister boasts of £190 million being given out. If we accept what he states as true, and I am not saying it is not, this must be taken back in taxation. He does not elaborate on how this will increase employment. Unless we can increase the growth rate we will not lessen the incidence of unemployment. If I go on quoting, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, from the Minister's brief, you may find it very boring but you can blame the Minister. Even assuming that the Minister's figures are correct, it is no guarantee that the Bill will be effective in the way he wants it to be.
The Minister spoke of the growth in social services. He said:
The social welfare concessions in the budget have made possible a striking betterment in the quality of life of the many thousands of people in this country who are dependent on social welfare benefits to sustain their standard of living.
The Minister was quite correct in giving the increase but the inflation is evidenced by this Dublin old age pensioner who because of the budget has had his rent increased by 57 pence per week. I have here the official document. Therefore, after only a month or six weeks we can see what is happening. Perhaps in the autumn the Minister may have to have a second budget and Finance Bill in order to counteract this kind of suffering inflicted on the old age pensioner.
The Minister went on to say:
An indication of the extent of these improvements can be had by considering the amount of additional outlay involved: in a full year, the increase over existing expenditure on the social services will be 44 per cent.
I know that comparisons are often odious and I do not intend to refer to previous Finance Acts or budgets. I am convinced that there are some good things in this one, as, for instance, the relief to be given to the parents of thalidomide children if and when they get money from Germany.
The Minister said:
The purpose of section 13 is to ensure that the benefit of the tax exemption in respect of non-bedded minerals must be passed on by a holding company when paying dividends out of exempted income.
That may sound strange but it is connected with payments of income to or in respect of Irish thalidomide children from the German Foundation which will be free of tax by virtue of section 18. I do not think anybody in the House would cavil at any help given to these unfortunate children or their parents. I accept the Minister's good faith in doing this though I think he could have gone much further. I hope that in future budgets this provision will be made.
The Minister mentioned the "charity exemption," something we have needed for a long time but the Minister was very selective. He said:
Section 14 is linked with section 19 which extends "charity exemption" to bodies of persons whose objects are the promotion of observance of the provisions of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights or the implementation of the European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms. Section 14 secures that annual contributions made under convenant by any person to such bodies for a period exceeding three years will be recognised for income tax purposes.
This in itself is good but why not extend it to any established charity in the country? This would encourage people to bequeath far more money to charity. They could be given some recognition, as they are in other countries, by way of tax exemption. This, in effect, would be anti-inflationary because the money would be used well by the charities and the person giving the money would have his good deed recognised by a tax reduction.
The Minister also said:
Any payment made by a trader to an Irish university for the purpose of enabling the university to undertake research in, or engage in the teaching of, industrial relations, marketing and other approved subjects will benefit from the tax relief provided in section 20.
This, again, is praiseworthy and is a step forward. The "charity exemption" should be widened and, perhaps, on the next Stage of the Bill we could consider widening this provision so as to include all contributions given at regular times or for a stated period. In a small way this would have an anti-inflationary effect. Unless the Minister can by this Finance Bill try to curb the inflationary tendencies there will be chaos before the financial year is out. We have a very high rate of inflation for which we cannot entirely blame the Government but we can blame them for not taking all possible steps to curb the upward trend.
The Minister also continues for a period of a further two years relief given on depreciation for new plant and machinery provided for use outside certain areas and 100 per cent initial allowance for capital expenditure incurred on new plant and machinery. This is praiseworthy but it is not original. It has been contained in budgets and Finance Acts for many years past.
Section 33 exempts from income tax, sur-tax and corporation profits tax income derived from patent royalties arising to individuals, or companies, resident in the State where the work in connection with the devising of the patent invention is carried out in the State. This is, to an extent, an extension of the tax relief given to authors and dramatists by a previous budget.
Having examined the budget, and the Finance Bill, I do not think that anyone of us has any confidence that this will lead to the "new Ireland" referred to by the Minister in his speech. I noticed that in one or two Estimate briefs introduced in this House by Ministers that we get the same preamble, a kind of do-gooder outlook. I am afraid that in this hard world something else is expected.
Section 1 of this Bill gives us the great news that if we do not pay our income tax on time we will pay a penalty. That section informs us that section 129 of the Income Tax Act, 1967 is being amended by an addition which provides that if the amount of the interest calculated is less than £5 the amount of interest payable will be £5.
As Deputy Power remarked, supposing the Government owes a citizen money or they do not pay a citizen promptly money that is due to him, can this citizen claim against the Government for the interest due on the amount owed? Very often people approach public representatives about pensions and social welfare payments that have not been paid when due. It often happens that a long time elapses before the recipient receives the money due to him. I am tempted the next time such a case arises to write to the Minister for Finance and point out to him that as he is charging interest on income tax due he should pay the interest for the period the social welfare benefit or other payment is overdue.
The question of interest should apply in both directions. The old age pensioner is entitled to claim interest from the Minister if payment is overdue just as the Minister is entitled to claim against the tax-dodger. No one will defend a tax-dodger. All of us have to pay our taxes but the charging of interest should work both ways.
The Minister has certainly gone after the men with the expense sheet. Nobody will quarrel with that or with the fact that the motor car used by firms or their staff will have to be within a certain price range. That is all on the State side. I believe that every payment which is overdue from the State should be subject to an interest charge in favour of the citizen. It may be a vicious circle that having taxed the State to pay the pensioner the pensioner will have to pay a further tax to make up for what the State paid out. That may sound confusing but there are many parts of the Finance Bill which are confusing.
While this Finance Bill is meant to stimulate the national growth it may well act in the opposite way and stunt that growth. In the last three months we had a 3 per cent increase in the cost of living. If we had a 3 per cent growth in the gross national product we would be doing well but this Finance Bill is not going to encourage that.
Subsection 1 of section 2 of the Bill is almost incomprehensible. Unless one is a financial wizard it is impossible to understand it and I do not see how any employer will understand it.
The amendment of section 138 of the Income Tax Act, 1967, which increases the amount of earned income relief in respect of a wife's earnings from £74 to £104 is the only reduction in income tax given in this Bill. The remainder of the taxation is increasing, in some way, the tax payable by all of us. It also puts a penal tax on us if we do not pay on time. I do not think that by fining people the Government are going to make things any easier. Some people will try to avoid paying. The vast majority want to pay on time but are prevented from doing so because they have not the money.
It may be said that this system operates in other countries but we should frame our own budget to suit our own circumstances. By saying that I will be told by some of the speakers on the Government side that it is our budget. If it is our budget, then we must take credit for what is good in it. I have admitted that the social welfare payments were very good but they have been eroded by the matters I have referred to.
At the time the National Coalition were campaigning on the basis that they would remove VAT from food it seemed a very wise decision but the people now realise what it means and they are not keen on it. When VAT is removed from food we will have to see if prices will fall. I do not believe that they will. Shopkeepers, even with the best will in the world, may not be able to separate the prices. It will take more than the extra weekend which the Minister has given them to make up their minds. Talk about The Lost Weekend. Value-added tax comes off food but, in order to meet the deficit created by its removal from food, footwear and clothing will have to bear increased rates of tax.
The Minister says this change will operate as much to the advantage of the consumers as to the traders as food prices will be reduced as on and from 3rd September next. We should all make a note of that date because this will be the operative date on which alleged reductions will take place in food prices. The Minister for Industry and Commerce is in the House at the moment. I wish him the best of luck in his efforts to keep down prices but I doubt if the Minister for Finance will be much help to him in his efforts. Even if he sends out inspectors to check, I doubt if shopkeepers will be able in the week-end from 1st September to 3rd September, even with the best will in the world, to reduce prices because prices are increasing all the time. I doubt very much that there will be any reduction in the price of food. It is not something to which we can look forward and we have a duty to remind people that, even though a benevolent Minister for Finance gives the shopkeepers a long week-end in which to reduce prices, they will not be able to reduce prices unless they happen to be financial geniuses. But even the Gnomes of Zurich cannot settle money matters and I doubt if our shopkeepers will be able to effect a reduction in food prices on September 3rd. It is an historic date. It is the date on which World War II broke out. The disappointment of the housewives will be understandable when they find the prices they expected to topple have not toppled very far at all.
The Minister says:
As regards the effect of the changes on retail prices, my colleague, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, has already announced a series of price control measures. These will help to minimise any risk that the full tax reductions will not be passed on by traders.
The Minister for Finance and I, and others, know that 3rd September will just not be the day of days. The measures taken by his colleague, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, will help to minimise, not prevent, any risk that the full tax reductions will not be passed on by traders. Only last week there were certain price increases and prices will go on increasing despite the best efforts of the Minister. We import certain foodstuffs and the exporters of these cannot be prevented putting on another 5 or 10 per cent, if they feel like it. If we are not prepared to pay their prices, then we will have to do without the commodities. I do not think this is the right way to tackle inflation. I believe the Minister has the same uneasy feeling that all the rest of us have that prices will not fall on 3rd September. There are too many adverse factors operating, some of which the Government have allowed to operate, and these will prevent any decrease in food prices on 3rd September.
The Minister also states:
Besides the adjustments I have mentioned, Part V of the Bill also contains certain provisions, mainly of a supplementary or consequential nature.
He says he would like to mention some of them.
Under the value-added tax farmers and fishermen are not required to register or to pay tax on sales. Instead they are compensated for tax borne by them on their purchases of, e.g., agricultural machinery and fuel, by a 1 per cent addition to their output prices which addition, however, ranks for credit or refund in the hands of a regular purchaser of agricultural produce.
I have a certain sympathy with the unfortunate farmer trying to elucidate how he will obtain his 1 per cent addition. He does not register. He would be far better off registered because he would save himself all that trouble about the 1 per cent addition.
The Minister goes on to say:
Rather than revise the 1 per cent addition, to which farmers have become accustomed, I decided to extend the zero rate, which at present applies to manufactured fertilisers and feeding stuffs, so as to cover unprocessed feeding stuffs, such as green grains, and to animal oral medicines as well as seeds and plans for the production of food.
We are always very keen not to tax anything that is used for animals. That may be because we are a predominantly agricultural country and animals generally are so many sacred cows, but playing around with value-added tax as the Minister is doing may well mean that we will not gain the benefits other countries will from the application of value-added tax in our general system of taxation.
One criticism made of the Minister's policy was that it went a bit of the way with everything but pleased no one. Section 87 proves that the Minister tried to spread whatever jam there is over too wide a surface and has ended up by pleasing no one. I can visualise the Minister a couple of months hence having to introduce a supplementary budget or amend this Finance Bill. Whether it is that the Minister did not have sufficient time to frame his budget or whether it is he lacked experience what we are offered here is a Finance Bill which will be ineffective. Worst of all, it will have an inflationary effect and make the position worse than it is at the moment.
The Minister goes on to say:
Before leaving the subject of agriculture I should mention that section 86 provides for the exemption from the tax of horses and greyhounds. It is a necessary part of the operation of the bloodstock and greyhound industries that animals are frequently exported and imported for varying periods, and it was found that the operation of VAT on importation was seriously affecting the smooth functioning of the industries.
The bloodstock industry is very important to the country. The Minister bent backwards to ensure that VAT is not paid on greyhounds but VAT must be paid on footwear and clothing.
The Minister said:
Section 78 substitutes a new and more exact provision enabling the Revenue Commissioners to provide by regulation for the taxing of services provided by a trader for his own business or in connection with it even if no charge is made for the service. This is necessary to ensure that major differences in tax incidence do not arise as between certain services provided within a firm and similar services provided by a contractor.
Somebody some day will write a Finance Bill which will be capable of being read by a young person leaving primary school. If we are to become a fully Irish speaking nation I suggest that it would be far easier to read the Irish language than some of this English. If the intention is to keep from the people what is contained in the Finance Bill, that would serve some purpose, if not a very worthy one. Surely it is possible to write these Bills in readable English. Civil servants and Ministers who have to live with this Bill day after day and try to decipher some of its provisions have my sympathy.
The Minister said:
Section 79, as well as providing for the new rates to be charged as from 3rd September next, gives the Revenue Commissioners power to determine the rate of tax to be applied in any particular case or class of cases, either upon request by a taxpayer or where the Commissioners are satisfied that doubt as to the correct rate would otherwise exist.
Surely every previous Finance Bill must have contained that clause. I do not see why it should have been written especially into this one. I do not know if this is new legislation.
Comment on this
Because of your ruling I am sticking strictly to the Minister's statement. I am not disputing your ruling in anyway.
Comment on this
I do not want to argue with the Chair but the Minister read all this today. I will have an opportunity on Committee Stage to discuss this in more detail. The Finance Bill is so late this year that anything which would expedite its acceptance or rejection would be worthwhile. If Committee Stage is a replica of Second Stage we will be here until 3rd September.
I must refer to the postponement of the changes in VAT from 1st to 3rd September. The Minister said:
In order to facilitate accounting for the tax it is provided, in the Tenth Schedule, as a transitional arrangement...
The Minister is being so magnanimous as to give the shopkeepers an extra weekend in which to bring about price reductions. I wish them well in doing that over a weekend. I am sure there will be many a headache for the shopkeepers and also for the people who will want to buy cheaper food the following day.
The Minister has been generous in extending zero rating to the many articles to which I have already referred. I welcome the fact that zero rating is to be applied to life-saving services of the Royal National Lifeboat Institution. The Minister said that the inclusion of a toy or other similar item of insignificant value in a packet of zero rated food will not render the packet liable to tax. The British Government were criticised for their lollipop budget some time ago when they brought in a tax on ice cream and sweets. Children are lucky that the Minister has not taxed their bags of fizz which contain a little toy. They should thank the Minister for being so magnanimous. This makes me wonder if we are all joking about this. Could not the time spent on drawing up this provision have been given to some more worthy provision in the Finance Bill?
I hope that the Minister on Committee Stage will amend section 87 in order to make it less of a joke, because even if one needs a sense of humour to accept this Finance Bill, it is stretching it too far to ask the national assembly to discuss that provision in section 87 of the Finance Bill, 1973. Deputy Power mentioned Richie's mints. I am sure some greater financial brain than mine will some day sort out the effect of not taxing a toy or similar item of insignificant value put into a packet of sweets for a young child.