We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Finance Bill, 1974: Second Stage.

Contributions 119–276 of 276. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Finance Bill 1974
Enacted

No. 13 of 1974 ›

It is only right that in provisions dealing with taxation, capital gains tax, and taxation of farming profits, the Minister should ensure that a wealthy person should not be able to live too easily without using his wealth properly, and having his wealth work for him, so that there will be a difference between earned and unearned income. While I would subscribe to the view that wealthy people should be made to use their wealth, I would also subscribe to the view that it should not be made too easy for lazy people to live without working. Fortunately, we have not got a welfare State to the same extent they have in England. We should be careful to ensure that there is not an incentive to people not to work at all, as Deputy Gallagher pointed out. Our taxation proposals should not be so geared that those who do not want to work can live easily.

After the budget I criticised the Minister for taking no steps to curb inflation. In the provisions of this Finance Bill I see no steps which will help to curb inflation. The Minister should have made some effort to curb rising prices. The inflation he mentioned has helped to create poverty. He and the Tanaiste should put their heads together and discuss this matter. Before the last election Deputy Corish assured everyone that there was an alternative to rising prices, and that there was an alternative to redundancies and to the crippling rates burden.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Prices are a matter for the Estimate for the Department of Industry and Commerce. That matter is not relevant on this occasion.

Comment on this

On a previous occasion when I attempted to use the same quotation you cut me short, too, Sir.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair merely seeks to govern affairs in accordance with the measure under discussion—nothing else.

Comment on this

An arduous task, Sir. The people expected that the Government would make an honest effort to keep down prices. I see no provision in the wide earthly world for doing that. The Minister should realise he has a duty to keep the promises he made, the promises which placed him on that side of the House. He has a duty to do that, and he should make some attempt to do it.

The Minister could well ask himself two questions in regard to the provisions of this Finance Bill: (1) Am I getting all the money? And (2) am I raising the money in the right way? I believe that in conscience he cannot say he is doing that and that he is doing all he could do. This is the Minister's first real budget. The budget of 1973 was not a budget for which he could claim sole credit. This is the Minister's budget and I pronounce it a failure, and the people of Ireland will also pronounce it a failure when they get an opportunity of doing so.

Comment on this

I had no intention of intervening in this debate but I have been forced to my feet by the Member from Kildare who was defending from taxation the £100 valuation people. If I saw a man in my area with a valuation of £100. I would wonder at him being there. I come from an area where the valuation is as low as 40 pence. I am not here to defend the ranchers of the east, of the Killing Kildare plains.

Comment on this

What about your Galway Blazers?

Comment on this

They are glad to come there with their racehorses.

Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted and 20 Members being present,

Comment on this

I was saying when I was interrupted by the rancher who has now disappeared, the Killing Kildares——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Members should be referred to as Deputies. No other appendage should be applied.

Comment on this

The Deputy decided to attack the valuation system, which is 100 years old. Of that hundred years Fianna Fáil have been in power for 30 years. What have they done in the last 30 years? Only tonight they realise there is something wrong with the valuation system that affects the ranchers in Kildare. I referred to men in the west whose valuation is 40 pence. What would they give to get into these ranches? Let the people who are complaining get out. We have men who will go in and work that land.

Comment on this

We took a lot of them in the Land Commission days. They were happy and they never went back.

Comment on this

We sent them down and they showed you how to work the land. They came down from the rocks among the gentry, and they were looked down on by you.

Comment on this

I defy the Deputy to produce one who was looked down on. They were received with open arms, and if the position was reversed it would be different.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Could we get back to the Finance Bill?

Comment on this

The Deputy is here to defend the ranchers because they are going to be squeezed. Who would Fianna Fáil squeezed? Is it the 40 pence valuation man in the west? I expect that Deputy Dowling will defend the ranchers. Coming from Dublin it will sound well, Joe.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Dowling.

Comment on this

The Opposition are not prepared to admit that our entry into the EEC has affected the cost of living to a degree, but let me remind the defenders of the ranchers that it was the then Taoiseach, Deputy Jack Lynch, who signed us into the EEC, membership of which has affected our cost of living here today.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

This is not relevant to the measure under discussion. The Finance Bill and the taxation measures contained therein— that is what is under discussion.

Comment on this

With respect to the Chair, the cost of living has been bandied about for the last hour before you came in, Sir, and it was allowed. Let us get to the root cause of the cost of living. They talk about petrol. One would think we had oil wells in this country instead of holy wells.

Comment on this

We have oil wells.

Comment on this

I was forced to my feet having listened to a lot of rubbish from Kildare. The men of the west will show you how to work the land if it is given over to them. You are afraid to say a word against them for fear you would lose a few votes.

Comment on this

I have no fear of them, or you.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

Where are your own colleagues who are not talking tonight?

Comment on this

You have defended——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I must ask Deputy Coogan to address his remarks to the Chair and not directly to any other Member of the House.

Comment on this

I had no intention of speaking tonight, but when I hear those members of the party who were shedding tears for the people of the west now talking for the ranchers— they are afraid they will be squeezed by taxation—I say to the Minister: Go to where you can get it, and you are the man that can do it.

Comment on this

I should like to say a few brief words on the Minister's Second Reading speech. I found it, to say the least of it, confusing having previously read the White Paper, the document condemned so vigorously by another Government Minister, the document relating to tax reforms, the tax reforms we were going to have in a short time. The Minister for Defence, Deputy Donegan, on the instructions of the Taoiseach, torpedoed the White Paper at an early stage. The country at large, having examined the proposed tax reforms the Minister for Finance was about to launch, the greatest tax reforms ever known here, now find that the Minister had modifications forced upon him by faceless individuals, possibly the same individuals addressed by the Minister for Foreign Affairs, Deputy Dr. Garret FitzGerald, when he spoke to the stockbroker belt prior to the general election and gave several indications of alterations in the tax structure and the manner in which taxes would be levied.

I should like to know if it was the present Minister, the present Government or, in fact, this group of faceless men, the stockbrokers and the bankers, who were responsible for the issue of this special document from Fine Gael explaining the changes that would take place, clearly outlined in Hibernia of Friday, 30th March. There you have the various statements made by the Minister for Foreign Affairs and it is quite clear that this influential group, as it has been described, small but influential, a group of bankers, financiers and stockbrokers, received this special document that Members of this House and even ordinary Fine Gael Deputies did not have a chance to examine. Indeed, they knew nothing whatsoever of the contents.

Was it this small but influential group who changed the Government's attitude and the Minister's mind? Was it this group of faceless people who got the assurances that certain changes would take place and other proposed changes, mooted prior to the election by the Labour Party, would not take place? They got the assurance from the Minister in relation to the attitude of the Fine Gael Party to the Labour Party. They got an assurance from the Minister that the aims of the Labour Party would not be tolerated in a Coalition Government and that Fine Gael were outlining what would take place in relation to the proposed changes. These changes, outlined prior to any budget, gave an indication of alterations in various tax structures. As we know, this was a violation of this House: information was given which could have lined pockets and possibly did line the pockets of this small but influential group of financiers, stockbrokers and bankers. Even in the first budget in which the value-added tax was a factor they got a complete insight into the changes the Government proposed to make.

Comment on this

On a point of order, Deputy Dowling has made an allegation that the Minister for Finance leaked information to the public before presenting this budget.

Comment on this

That is exactly what I said.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The budget debate has long since passed and I deem the allegation to be a political charge.

Comment on this

That is exactly what I said.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Dowling, the Chair is addressing you. I am anxious that you would grapple with the Finance Bill before the House and its taxation proposals. The Deputy is dealing with the past tense; I want him to deal in the present tense. I want him to deal with the Finance Bill before the House.

Comment on this

Proposed alteration in the tax structure as previously indicated by the Minister for Finance and, indeed, by some members of the Government, the broad question of taxation, the failure of the Government to live up to promises made previously, their backing out of their responsibilities, their being pressurised into modifying the legislation to the extent to which it has been modified, surely these are all factors with which one can deal in relation to the Finance Bill because the Finance Bill is the measure which alters taxation in a very substantial way and any Member is entitled to comment on the attitude of the Government to taxation over a period of years and not just in relation to one year or two years. It is only fair and reasonable that any Member should be able to convey his views as to the inadequacies of the present Bill, as to the provisions he feels should have been modified, the provisions which may have been modified or the provisions which should have been embodied in the Bill in a much more substantial way. In doing so, it is necessary to refer to other factors, not specifically mentioned but, nevertheless, bordering on the Bill. I mentioned one, the one about which I was questioned by Deputy Esmonde. I repeat what I said: the disclosure was made by personnel of the present Government in relation to certain matters of taxation to an influential group of people outside this House. That small but influential group were given that information and possibly lined their pockets as a result of that. If Deputy Esmonde wants to read about it, he can read about it in Hibernia of Friday, March 30th, 1973. If he wants me to quote I will quote. This was a breach of confidence of this House. That was the situation and if Deputy Esmonde reads the article he will see there was this disclosure.

Comment on this

I have no retainer from Hibernia.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The budget has been passed and the debate on the budget is over and done with. We cannot now have a rehash of that debate.

Comment on this

The Deputy is not rehashing the budget of this year but last year's budget.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary should not try to suppress free speech. He has suppressed his own Deputies. Why try to suppress our Deputies?

Comment on this

Because they are deliberately wasting Parliamentary time just as they did last year.

Comment on this

Do not be so irate.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order. Deputy Dowling on the Finance Bill.

Comment on this

I will come back to value-added tax at a later stage.

Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted and 12 Members being present.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Dowling on the Finance Bill.

Comment on this

And not on last year's budget.

Comment on this

I am amazed that the Government Chief Whip should indicate that Members of the Opposition should not speak on this important debate. I am sure the Minister for Finance would welcome the views of Members from both sides of the House. The only contribution made from the Government side today came from Deputy Coogan who spoke for three minutes. If one were to divide those three minutes into the cost to the taxpayer, one would find that it is costing the taxpayers a very substantial amount.

Did the Minister, or a faceless group of people, force the changes in this Bill? Changes were promised in the taxation system which are not now forthcoming. Why this watered down version in the present Bill? Was this modified version the result of pressures from a variety of people? The Labour Party must have been instrumental in bringing about some of these modifications. We have not had any contributions from the Labour benches. In fact, we have seen very few Labour Deputies in the House during the debate. It is an indication that they do not have any interest in the affairs of this House when they fail to make their contributions. They have not allowed us and the nation to see if they are behind the Government and whether they and the group of faceless bankers, stockbrokers and——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is consistently repeating himself. He should endeavour to come to grips with the Finance Bill, 1974.

Comment on this

This and similar pieces of legislation were promised by the Government. Modifications were then made followed by a collapse. This happened with other legislation, such as that dealing with the health services which did not materialise. The Government are incompetent when it comes to dealing with affairs of State. They show their incompetence when dealing with taxation. They are faced with a very big problem. The country faces disaster. The question of relieving the burdens on certain sections of the community——

Comment on this

There is no problem.

Comment on this

Because they have brought the nation to disaster point, the Government may be looking for a way out. This is the considered opinion of many people. This watered down version is meant to appease those who may support them in the elections which may follow.

I should like to deal with the question of taxing farmers. Deputy Coogan said I would probably support the farmers and I do. At the moment the Minister is about to tax the farming community——

Comment on this

Ranchers.

Comment on this

He proposes to tax certain sections of the farming community. I have no objection to taxing people who can pay. Let us look at this position of the farmers at the moment. The Dublin housewife will pay 14p for a head of cabbage. Does the farmer get 14p? No. The Dublin housewife must pay 8p for a lettuce. Will the producer get 8p? No. The Dublin housewife pays 17p for three pounds of potatoes. This means she pays approximately £140 a ton. Does the farmer get £140 a ton? No.

Comment on this

This is sour grapes.

Comment on this

Cucumbers cost 27p. Does the producer get this price? When one takes into account the high price which the housewife must pay for farm produce, one realises that farmers are being treated very unfairly. The Minister should ensure that they get a reasonable return for their labours.

Comment on this

The Deputy advocated tax on cabbages.

Comment on this

If that was so, the housewife——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order, please.

Comment on this

——would not have this appalling bill.

Comment on this

The Fianna Fáil Party advocated a tax on cabbages and Deputy Briscoe agreed.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order, please. Deputy Dowling, without interruption.

Comment on this

I want to make the point that the Dublin housewife is being robbed by the middleman.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is irrelevant to the matter under debate.

Comment on this

I am pointing out that there is no provision in the Bill to ensure that the middlemen will be caught. It is almost impossible to get money from some of them. They work in offices, are up to their knees in carpets and merely have a book-keeping transaction which doubles or trebles the price. I am confident that the Minister will not extract 1p extra from that group. If the farmers got a reasonable return, the housewife could purchase their produce at a reasonable price.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy knows that farm prices should be discussed on an Estimate.

Comment on this

Surely this is a question relating——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Farm prices are not relevant to this Bill.

Comment on this

——to the ability of the farmer to pay. I am merely pointing out in relation to the taxation of farmers that if they got a fair price from consumers the housewives would have cheaper commodities and the Minister would have a greater amount of revenue. At the moment, there are a group of middle-men who are robbing the housewives in the city but the Minister has done nothing to tax them. These gentlemen have large offices, with carpets up to their knees, but they provide only a book-keeping transaction in regard to the produce of the farmers. They charge double or treble the price; for instance, potatoes are £140 per ton——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is repeating himself. He knows that repetition is not in order.

Comment on this

I am pointing out that the situation is unrealistic. I am speaking as a Dublin Deputy——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy has made his point. The Chair would be grateful if he related his remarks to the Bill.

Comment on this

I am dealing with the taxation of farming profits. I want to point out to the Minister how he could get greater revenue if an effort was made to ensure that those middle-men, the people who have been robbing the public for many years, either are eliminated or are taxed on their substantial profits——

Comment on this

Or a special tax on a long-playing record?

Comment on this

If Deputy Esmonde wishes to speak I have no objection to making way for him. However, if that is his only contribution, it is a very poor one.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy tell us about the ranchers?

Comment on this

The Deputy will have an adequate opportunity of making a case if he wishes. However, I am sure he has been told by the Chief Whip not to open his mouth in case he puts his foot into it.

Comment on this

Tell us about the ranchers.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Coogan has fallen into the habit of referring to a Deputy on the other side of the House by his Christian name. That is not in order. Standing Orders lay down that a Member must be referred to as "Deputy". However friendly disposed the remark may have been, it is not in order.

Comment on this

I am afraid the Chair misunderstood me. I was talking about ranchers. I did not mention any names.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I have heard the Deputy on occasion refer to Deputy Dowling as Joe.

Comment on this

I was pointing out how the Minister could obtain more revenue by way of taxation while, at the same time, giving advantages to the section of the community being victimised by a group of middle-men, or fiddle men, or whatever one might like to call them. I have pointed out that in this city potatoes cost £140 per ton and it is the housewives who have to bear this burden. The Minister should arrange to have an investigation carried out into this matter.

Most of the essential items are beyond the reach of the ordinary worker's family. We know the enormous cost of meat in the shops in this city. An extraordinary situation is that when the price falls on the Dublin cattle market the price in the shops does not decrease at the same time. It may happen that even after two or three weeks when the price has fallen on the cattle market the price in the shops is not decreased but when there is an increase it is immediately passed to the consumer.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I regret having to interrupt the Deputy but what he is saying is not strictly relevant to the measure under discussion. I want him to relate his remarks precisely to the Finance Bill, 1974. As yet the Deputy has not adverted to any section of the Bill.

Comment on this

Chapter II of the Bill, comprising sections 13 to 28, deals with taxation of farming profits. I propose to deal with those sections——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

If the Deputy intends going into detail, as seemingly he has been, it would be more appropriate to do so on Committee Stage. I think the Deputy will agree with the Chair in that regard.

Comment on this

Committee Stage is purely for the purpose of putting down amendments for discussion and debate. I do not want to disclose what amendments, if any, may be put forward but I wish to give the Minister some indication of the views of Deputies from the city with regard to farming profits, and to a situation whereby the Minister could obtain a greater amount of tax while giving the farmers a fair return and the housewives a reasonable cut with regard to commodities. If farming profits increase the Minister will get more revenue. Many reforms were promised but they did not materialise. Bearing in mind that the pressure groups have been at work, he may well now, on the realistic side, examine the possibility of ensuring that the promises made by the Government in relation to the cost of living—which is affected by taxation— are carried out and a reduction in food prices is effected; that food prices can in fact——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is deviating again.

Comment on this

I am merely indicating that food prices can be reduced as a result of ministerial——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy may not get around it that way; he knows it is not relevant.

Comment on this

I want to devise a way in which the amount of taxation the Minister can reap can be increased without any undue effort, at the same volume of production, simultaneously, giving two very important sections of the community an advantage and deterring people who set out to wreck family life by putting the cost of many commodities beyond their reach I think that is a fair and reasonable argument. This is probably the only opportunity Dublin Deputies will have to illustrate the plight of the Dublin housewife, to show how her lot can be improved and, at the same time, give the Minister a greater tax return and the farmer more profit. I shall not deal with other matters, such as prices for bread, margarine, cheese or various other items which have risen beyond the reach of the ordinary housewife.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy said he was not going to deal with them.

Comment on this

Those are aspects with which I shall not deal now but possibly at another stage I will have an opportunity to do so in greater depth. I would ask the Minister again to consider this aspect, if he requires more finance, which I am sure he will get from this sector putting their hands deep into the purses of housewives at the moment. The whole question of pricing of commodities is affected, to some degree, by this budget. Indeed, in the future, foodstuffs may well——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The budget debate has long passed. This is the Finance Bill.

Comment on this

I am dealing with the question of taxation of farming profits. In order to pay taxation which formerly he had not to pay, it will be necessary for the farmer to increase his volume of production or, in order to maintain the profits he had in the past, it will be necessary for him to increase his volume of production. I want to point out that, in relation to foodstuffs essential to the life of the community, and in particular to the weaker sections, substantial efforts can be made.

While taxation does not deal with value-added tax—and one can only relate this Bill to the taxation system as a whole—we have had a variety of tax codes other than those mentioned in this Bill. Take the example of value-added tax and the promises made in the past in relation to a particular form of taxation. If we examine how false and erroneous was the information given to the public in relation to the removal of VAT from foodstuffs, we can well understand the anxiety of different sections of the community with regard to the imposition of additional taxation in other areas, such as that indicated in sections 13 to 28 and, indeed, in other sections of this Bill. They amount to a complete betrayal of promises and undertakings given. This one refers to farming; others refer to housewives.

Prior to the general election we were given the assurance that a certain system of taxation, if modified, would bring about great relief to the weaker sections of the community. However, we found that the modification of value-added tax increased the burden on those sections. We saw the situation which resulted from the alterations; the removal of tax from one item only to be placed on another brought about increases over a much wider field, giving a greater yield and for which the public had to pay. When examining any tax reform or operation, one must take into consideration the experiences of the past in relation to promises and undertakings given by Ministers with regard to taxation. It is worth recording here that the removal of VAT from foodstuffs brought about a substantial increase in the cost of living. If the Minister is as confident now that the taxation being imposed will bring a substantial return to the Exchequer which can be used for other purposes, he may well be just as far off the mark as he was on the occasion when he indicated that VAT being taken off foodstuffs would reduce the cost of living. While tax as a whole may be siphoned off to some necessary service or relief, one can well understand people being fooled into a situation by glib speakers and erroneous propaganda such as occurred prior to the last general election. When we see the realities of the situation, we know what changes in the tax structure can mean to the ordinary people and, indeed, to the depressed sections of this city. We know that the removal of tax from one item to be placed on another can mean enormous difficulties as were created on that occasion by the removal of tax from food and its placement on other essential commodities such as clothing, footwear and others too numerous to mention.

We see from experience, or possibly lack of experience, on the part of some of the Ministers in the Coalition Government that they can make statements, possibly in the belief that they can attain certain standards and bring about a reduction in the cost of living. That will not wash with us any more. We have seen the result of the removal of VAT from food and the alteration of that system, with the placement of the burden on sections of the community unable to fend for themselves, on wheelchairs and medical devices necessary for people afficted in one way or another. We have experienced the lack of thought in relation to the placement of taxation on that occasion which might well recur on this one. With the alteration in the taxation system in relation to VAT disabled people were required to pay a greater amount for such things as wheelchairs or other essential appliances. On this occasion we may well find that the alterations will not measure up to the statements made by Ministers. Indeed, when challenged some time ago about statements made during the general election, one Minister stated that the slogan and the reality were two different things. He realised that only when he came into Government. It may well be that the present Minister will realise too that the slogan and the reality are two different things.

The change in the taxation system which has brought about difficulty and created many problems for the less well off and other unassisted sections of the community in the past may well happen again. The changes were dictated by some pressure groups and I am sure that before the debate on this Bill concludes we will be able to discover the groups responsible for the various motivations which were given great prominence on the television, radio and in the media. The Minister has failed to measure up to the reality of the situation.

I hope that any alteration in the taxation system will ensure that the essential commodities of life will not be affected. I hope that these changes will not further complicate the position of those people who are in some cases hungry because of their inability to procure with their wages and meagre incomes the necessities of life. At present the aged and other less well off sections are endeavouring to ensure that they will have some warmth in the coming winter by stockpiling coal but we should bear in mind that the cost of fuel has doubled, and in some cases trebled, in recent months.

The Minister should siphon off some of the taxation which will be raised as a result of the provisions in this Bill for the relief of the poorer sections. I hope that adequate and favourable consideration will be given to those people who were conned by the statements of Ministers of the present Government. These Ministers should examine their conscience, if they have a conscience, with regard to their treatment of the poor. They should do everything possible to see that the aged do not go cold and hungry this winter and they can best do this by using the additional income which the Minister for Finance will reap as a result of the provisions in this Bill to help these people.

Deputy Barrett, in the course of a debate in this House last week, drew attention to the substantial profits being made by the oil companies as a result of recent price increases. He told the House that the profits amounted to millions of pounds. We are informed by the Minister for Finance that we have the cheapest petrol in Europe but, at the same time, the people who commute to their employment and those who must run a motor car do not earn as much as workers in other European countries. I see a lot of sense in the suggestion made by Deputy Barrett which was to the effect that some of the substantial profits made by the oil companies should be given back to the users of motor vehicles or taken by the Government for the purpose of improving the living standards of the poor. The Minister has two options in this regard.

When the Minister informed us that petrol prices here were the lowest in Europe he did not bear in mind the fact that the other countries of Europe are highly industrialised and that the wage rates are far beyond those which apply here.

Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted and 20 Members being present,

Comment on this

Because the wage rates are higher in other European countries it is understandable that the price of petrol, and other commodities, should be greater in those countries than it is here. One must measure the situation in a realistic manner. One cannot examine the situation on the basis of a remark by a Minister which was to the effect that the price of petrol here is lower than in any other country in Europe. The Minister has failed to take into consideration the other important factors which I have mentioned. If this is the type of thinking behind this Bill, then I can understand the grave blunders made in the past in relation to VAT and the other promises.

If one was to examine Government policy in recent months in depth, one would find that many of the statements were erroneous. We heard a lot about the reduction that was to take place in the cost of living. We were told of the wonderful opportunities that were being offered to the people of this nation, that their way of life would be completely changed. They would have essential commodities at lower prices. The salesmen did not measure up to their promises and, indeed, one Minister stated that the slogan is different from the reality. This may well happen in relation to this Bill and indeed in relation to other Bills that have been promised. We have defective legislation being put through the House. The Government cannot find agreement among themselves to put through essential legislation or legislation which some Ministers consider essential. They are so divided that there is complete disarray within the two parties.

We hope that the reforms that are contained in the Bill will meet with success. We hope that the anti-avoidance measures will be successful. We hope the Minister will get support for the justifiable parts of the Bill. For the sections of the Bill which measure up to the ideals of all the Members of the House, I am sure he will get support but, as has been pointed out, the Bill is not all that it should be and it needs revamping before it meets with the approval of this House.

Recent wage increases have been eroded by increases in the price of the essentials of life. In many cases the workers are worse off than they were prior to the national wage agreement. One can read between the lines when one sees various trade unions warning the Government in relation to the cost of living, warning the Government that action will be taken against them by trade unions and trade unionists if they do not measure up to their promises and meet their responsibilities in full and ensure that the wage-earner is able to meet his responsibilities. I speak to many workers. I know they feel that the increases they obtained were obtained under false pretences as regards the cost of living. The Government have failed miserably to control living costs. I am sure that if the national wage agreement was re-examined a month after it was signed the results would be different. I would appeal to the Minister to ensure that the Government honour the promises made to the workers, the housewives, the weaker sections. The promises made to the ordinary workers seem to be completely forgotten. Many workers at present are unable to purchase the necessities of life. They will have another day when they can answer the Government in relation to the promises that were given prior to the national wage agreement.

Comment on this

They had it on the 8th June and they beat you two to one in Dublin.

Comment on this

The people will have an opportunity at another time to deal with national affairs. They will deal in an effective way with the people who did not keep their word, who failed miserably in their responsibilities.

Comment on this
Séamus Pattison Acting Chairman (Mr. Pattison) Labour Party

I must remind the Deputy that he is going far outside the scope of the Finance Bill.

Comment on this

I was a bit upset by the heckling.

Comment on this

The people will have an opportunity——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Will the Deputy return to the Finance Bill?

Comment on this

——to rectify the situation. If promises were dishonoured before, they may well be dishonoured in relation to this legislation. The Government have changed their mind so many times in relation to so many factors that one must doubt every piece of legislation that goes through this House. That is the reason why the Bill must be examined——

Comment on this

I am glad the Deputy said reason, not reasons.

Comment on this

I do not know what type of phraseology Deputy Belton wants. If he wants to speak, I will make way for him but I am quite sure he does not. He has already been told by the Chief Whip not to speack. He does not want him to make a show of himself.

Comment on this

Deputy L'Estrange is sent in to interrupt. That is his role. He is the arch-interruptor. Before I was——

Comment on this

So rudely interrupted.

Comment on this

I was dealing with the promises made to the workers——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Deputy must deal with taxation and the Finance Bill.

Comment on this

I am dealing with the entire question of taxation. There are aspects in the Bill that must be commented on and there are aspects outside the Bill that must be commented on. One cannot divorce the amendments to a taxation system from the entire system because it becomes part of the entire system.

I have mentioned some of the problems which confront the people of this city. The interruptions indicate that the Deputies opposite are in favour of Government action that would bring a about increases in the cost of living, that they see nothing wrong with these substantial increases in the cost of the necessities of life.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I must appeal to the Deputy to return to taxation and what is in the Finance Bill. The cost of living is not a subject for discussion.

Comment on this

I am talking about the increases which have been applied to the various essential commodities.

Comment on this

On a point of order, is it not a fact that VAT was removed from foodstuffs by the Minister and the Deputy is harping on that line all the time?

Comment on this

I am well aware that the price of foodstuffs increased before and after the removal of VAT. I am also aware that the prices of other essentials, such as clothing and footwear, have also been increased. As I pointed out, the disabled section of the community have now to pay a higher price for wheelchairs and the essentials which are necessary to keep them in moderate comfort. The Deputy should be well aware that the price of every single item, other than foodstuffs, was increased as a result of the change in VAT. The only item on which there was no alteration, as far as the tax system was concerned, was dancing. There is no doubt we have a Government of dancers.

Comment on this

What about the old age pensioners?

Comment on this

They will not go dancing so it does not affect them. Do the Government feel that the stabilisation of taxation on dancing is a contribution to the old age pensioners, the widows, the orphans, the unemployed and the people in need of the necessities of life? Is that Deputy Coogan's idea of relief to the weaker sections of the community? I dealt with petrol. Today we read of substantial changes made in the fare structure for the travelling public of this city, for the workers and the housewives.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I again must interrupt the Deputy to tell him that the fare structure does not arise on this Bill.

Comment on this

As the Chairman is well aware, the substantial subsidies promised to CIE by the Government——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Deputy is now dealing with administration and it does not arise. I must appeal to him to abide by the ruling of the Chair and to refer to what is in the Bill and to taxation.

Comment on this

I have absolute respect for the ruling of the Chair.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Deputy has got wide scope and he has dealt with many matters that are not in the Bill.

Comment on this

I want to point out that the money available to the Minister for Finance to give to various groups, such as CIE, will come from taxation.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Deputy cannot debate in what way the money is to be spent.

Comment on this

Surely if one is to raise finance and to spend it——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Deputy can refer to the spending of the money at another time.

Comment on this

I would like to point out that money is being obtained from the public by this Finance Bill, which will be distributed by the Minister on receipt of a variety of demands. I want to point out that one of the demands for additional finance will come from CIE.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I must again ask the Deputy to abide by the ruling of the Chair. Government expenditure is not under discussion. It is taxation.

Comment on this

Can one not refer to the plight of the workers and ask the Minister to ensure that money he will receive as a result of additional taxation——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Deputy will get another opportunity to discuss that. This evening we are discussing the taxation proposals in the Finance Bill.

Comment on this

Before I make up my mind to vote one way or another on the Bill I want the Minister to assure me——

Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted and 20 Members being present,

Comment on this

As I was pointing out in relation to voting for or against this measure I would like an indication, when the Minister is replying, about the manner in which he may or may not allocate the moneys he receives in taxation. My plea was to ensure that the section of the community I am concerned with would get——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I have told the Deputy three times already he cannot discuss expenditure. He must discuss taxation and what is in the Bill.

Comment on this

The grave situation which faces workers as a result of this and other taxation will create a problem that will mean additional taxation on workers, either directly or indirectly. I pointed out some ways in which reliefs could be given to the workers. Where demands come for additional taxation the opportunities are open to producers to increase costs in order to offset the taxation to some degree, to ensure a reasonable profit margin and that the workers will have fair play.

I want to ensure that the workers will get fair play in any alteration in the tax system. I pointed out before that undertakings given by Ministers cannot be trusted. We have had evidence in the past of this. Ministers promised that they would bring down prices and that they would make the lot of the workers happier. The Minister for Industry and Commerce comments upon all important measures in this House and he is noticeably absent today. The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs also makes statements on all important matters in this House. This is a very important matter. The Minister for Industry and Commerce who made so many promises and so many statements prior to the general election——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I must again remind the Deputy that he should relate his remarks to what is in the Finance Bill.

Comment on this

I am referring to the taxation which was to be altered. Assurances were given by Government Ministers in and out of office that they would make the lot of the worker and the housewife a happier one. They showed their complete disregard for the workers after they had enterenched themselves in office. There have been substantial increases in prices. Those men failed to come into the House today to justify their actions on this important measure dealing with tax reform. Pressures were applied on the Minister to modify the White Paper and to modify the tax reform measures which were promised on radio, television and in the newspapers. Was it the Minister for Defence who brought about this reversal? He made statements to the effect that certain measures which the Minister for Finance said were necessary and desirable would not come into effect. Has the Minister yielded to that pressure or has he yielded to pressure by the stockbroker group, the bankers and the other people——

Comment on this

The auctioneers.

Comment on this

And the publicans.

Comment on this

Heathens and publicans. They can be classed together. They are in the same category.

Comment on this

A confidential document was circulated to a small and influential group. Was it this small and influential group who changed the Minister's mind or was it the Minister for Defence? One would like to know because it is important that one should have some insight into the pressures that were applied to the Minister and into the way the Minister yielded. Normally speaking, the Minister does not yield to pressure, so some great pressure must have been applied. If the Minister for Defence could persuade the Minister to make the substantial changes which will affect a large number of the bankers and financiers and stockbrokers, fair dues to the Minister for Defence. He has done his job well.

The Minister for Foreign Affairs outlined clearly the tax reforms which would be brought about in the period of office of the Coalition Government. If we had this insight we could examine the Bill to a greater degree. We know that the division in the Government on the alteration in the tax laws is fairly widespread and that it has created problems within the Cabinet. We know that this watered-down version was meant to appease those who support the financiers, the bankers and other important people to whom the secret document was circulated. It is disastrous that we have no stability in regard to promises made by the Government. Piecemeal and defective legislation has been going through the House.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Deputy may not refer to any other Bill.

Comment on this

I was just pointing out that this legislation is no different from the Bill which the Minister for Health introduced to provide free medical treatment for all our people.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Deputy is out of order in mentioning any other Bill except the Bill before the House.

Comment on this

One must compare this Bill with other legislation. If we cannot take the word of the Minister, or the word of the Government, in presenting legislation, we must try to find out the reason. We have ample evidence of the bungling, the conniving and the pressures within the Government which have changed legislation at the stage where the matter has been discussed at length in this House. It may well happen that, like other Bills, this Bill may be shelved or modified, or withdrawn, if the pressure is great enough. There had to be some agreement within the Government to ensure that the Bill would be acceptable to the Coalition Parties.

We have had a two minute sprint from Deputy Coogan. That was the sole contribution from members of the Coalition Parties on this very important aspect of tax reform. The Whip must have issued precise instructions that no backbencher was to speak on this Bill. Only when they were dragged into the House were members of the Labour Party in the House. Their absence is an indication of their lack of support for this Bill. It is a clear indication of the disruption within the Government.

It is clear that the Labour Party were seeking some further changes in the tax code and that the Fine Gael section were not prepared to be diverted from the undertaking given to the influential people I mentioned. The absence of the Labour Party from the House is rather peculiar. We have not heard a socialist speech on tax reform all day. Listening to Labour spokesmen in the past one would think that this was a most important aspect.

Comment on this

We have not even seen a socialist.

Comment on this

Not since Santa Claus. Perhaps we will hear one of them before the debate concludes. We hope that at least one member of the Labour Party will listen to the discussion and inform the group so that they can analyse it. They should express their disapproval of the watered-down Bill which the Minister has presented. Undertakings were given by the socialist party, or the Labour Party, or whatever tag one wishes to apply to them—some call themselves socialists and others call themselves as members of the Labour Party. Undertakings were given to the public and statements were made by these people in relation to changes in taxation and one would have hoped that they would have been here to lend their voices to the voices of the many other Deputies who have an interest in the affairs of this country, who have an interest in tax reform and in the changes that will be taking place in taxation. The fact that the Labour Party members are not in the House but probably listening in on the intercom, is an indication of the divisions that now exist between the socialists and the conservatives on the opposite side. One wonders whether those who have failed to make a contribution from the Fine Gael Party are acting on the dictates of the Whip or whether their absence is due to disgust for the Minister for Finance. If the Labour Party members fail to measure up to their responsibilities, perhaps some member of the Fine Gael Party will make a contribution. The sole contribution from the backbenchers of the Coalition Government was made by Deputy Coogan. The Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach and to the Minister for Defence indicated that the Members on this side of the House should not be speaking on this important aspect of tax reform, indicated that we are taking up too much time, while at the same time on the opposite side we have those who have been silenced by the decree of the Parliamentary Secretary.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Mount Mellary.

Comment on this

I hope that before this debate concludes some Member will get a dispensation and be allowed to speak. We have heard the moans and groans of people who were sent in here to disrupt the debate. We wonder will the Labour Party vote against the Bill with which they disagree. As I say, there was violent disagreement at the Government meetings between the socialists and conservatives in regard to this measure. Will they measure up to their responsibilities and to the promises they made to their constituents? I do not think they will. Again I would appeal to the backbenchers over there——

Comment on this

To both of them.

Comment on this

Yes, the two of them, that at least 50 per cent of the backbenchers present would speak.

Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted and 20 Members being present,

Comment on this

We have failed miserably to bring the socialists into the House. We have brought plenty of capitalists in.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Would Deputy Dowling refer to what is in the Bill?

Comment on this

I would like to draw attention to the complete lack of interest of one of the parties that form the Government.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Deputy is repeating himself. Would he return to what is in the Bill?

Comment on this

Their failure to come into the House is an indication of their disregard for the——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Deputy is completely disregarding the Chair. Would he return to what is in the Bill?

Comment on this

They were not allowed to speak before. Now they can interrupt. It is rather remarkable that one cannot comment on the composition of the House in relation to the debate, to inquire whether all Members of the House are fully behind the aims and the provisions of this Bill. I have quite a lot to say, but if one is to be denied the right to comment upon this aspect of the matter, to comment on the fact that a socialist has not appeared here for quite a long time, then it is time to conclude. I hope, when the Minister is replying, he will cover the various points I and other speakers have made. There is no doubt the Government, in relation to promises——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Again, the Deputy is going out of order.

Comment on this

I appear to be out of order all the time. If the Chair does not rule me out of order I am ruled out of order by the backbenchers on the other side of the House.

This Bill, in the light of the Minister's unfulfilled promises, is the worst failure since the Famine. I hope the Minister will reply to the various points made so that we can further study the effects the Bill will have on the community at large.

In conclusion, in the light of the appeals made on behalf of the housewives of this city, caught in the upward spiral of inflation——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Deputy is repeating what he said earlier and repetition is disorderly. If he is concluding, will he please conclude on what is in the Bill before the House?

Comment on this

Sections 13 to 28, inclusive, deal with the taxation of farming profits. I just want to point out that the housewife of this city can get relief at the same time as the farmer gains some advantage if the middleman is cut out. I ask the Minister to ensure that any taxation that is imposed will in no way affect the weaker sections of the community. I have already commented on bus fares. I trust the Minister will deal with all the points made when he is replying.

Comment on this

When one sees a bulky Bill of this nature, comprising 85 sections divided into six chapters, plus two schedules, one anticipates that in such a measure there is ample food for thought, sufficient certainly to stimulate a member of the Government or some members of the Government parties speaking to some effect on the measure. Up to now we have had only a two-minute streak, apart from the Minister's introductory speech. In regard to a reform of taxation, the Minister said:

It must be realised, however, that a thorough reform of any system of taxation is a complex and prolonged exercise. Nevertheless, the fact that perfection cannot be achieved in one move is no reason why we should not make an effort to make some advance in the right direction.

I would have welcomed this afternoon and evening some comment from backbenchers in the Government parties to show us we are going in the right direction, but there were no signposts. They preferred to remain mute. Apart from being silenced by the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach, perhaps they, too, are tired of this kind of comment.

Again, the Minister said:

The Government's objective is that people with similar incomes should pay a comparable amount of tax. There will be one law for all, not one for the rich and another for the poor.

The people are tired of this kind of comment. What they want is action, action long overdue in a seriously declining economic situation. Inflation at the moment is running at 20 per cent. Under a Fianna Fáil Government it was only 8 to 9 per cent. Since the Coalition Government took office we have had inflation at the rate of 1 per cent per month. Coupled with that is the fact that between February, 1973, and May of this year the value of the £ fell by 17p. The Minister says that, while perfection cannot be achieved, we are going in the right direction.

Government Ministers blame the international situation and world trends for this raging inflation and high prices. To ensure I keep within the rules of order, the Minister in his speech referred to other countries and their enlightened taxation codes. I wish he and his colleagues in the Government would have a look at what other countries are doing to stem the tide of inflation. France has introduced certain remedial measures. So have the United Kingdom and Italy. Last week Italy imposed some very heavy taxation. If remedial measures were introduced here we could say the country was moving in the right direction once more.

While the Government did not increase taxation they did negotiate a credit facility of £83 million for capital expansion. Elementary arithmetic shows this represents a £27 overdraft for every man, woman and child in the State. Surely that is fuel to the inflationary fire.

Would the Minister now like to re-assess his trade deficit forecast of £140 million last April? Perhaps he will adjust that forecast in the light of experience. I will not hazard a guess at the actual extent of our trade deficit. The Minister has available to him all the expertise of an efficient Civil Service and I hope he will in the due course give us an up-to-date forecast. Surely this figure of £140 million has now gone by the board.

Comment on this