Pension supplements for apprentices aged 18 to 21
Faulkner proposed extending widow’s child supplements to apprentices aged 18–21, arguing their low incomes can leave widows without meaningful support. Cluskey said apprentices generally earn £18–£24 weekly and are wage earners rather than dependants, so he had no plans to extend the supplement.
asked the Minister for Social Welfare if he will consider paying an additional amount to widows for children between 18 and 21 years who are apprentices.
Comment on this
Increases of widows' pensions are paid in respect of all qualified children up to age 18, and in respect of children who are in full-time attendance by day at any university, college, school or other educational establishment up to age 21, as such children are normally still dependent on the widow. This consideration does not necessarily apply in the case of apprentices between the ages of 18 and 21 who are independent wage earners rather than dependants, and in the absence of evidence that their exclusion is a source of hardship I have at present no proposals for the introduction of the legislation which would be necessary to permit payment of an increase in such cases.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary has indicated that the concession is available where the child is in full-time education. Would he agree that apprenticeship is equivalent to full-time education?
Comment on this
I definitely agree that there is an element of education in an apprenticeship period but we have ascertained from AnCO that apprentices in the age categories mentioned by the Deputy—18 to 21 years—are earning amounts between £18 and £24 per week. So, they could not be described as being in the same category with regard to dependency as a person of that age who is in full-time education in a school, college or university. They are wage-earners and, in some cases, reasonably substantial wage-earners.
Comment on this
Would the Parliamentary Secretary not agree that while that may be so in the case of certain apprentices being trained or retrained by AnCO, generally speaking, the income of apprentices is very low and does not provide any particular assistance to a widow? In such circumstances, would the Parliamentary Secretary not agree that it would be a boost to education on the technical side if he were to make this concession available in relation to apprentices?
Comment on this
No. I may have led the Deputy into a misunderstanding. My reply related not to persons being trained by AnCO but to apprentices generally in which the wages quoted —£18 to £24 a week—applied. With trade union organisation and the proper regulation of apprentices, apprentices are not now as they used to be described when I was an apprentice, the lowest form of animal life. They are paid reasonably well and, as I stated in the reply, they could not accurately be described as dependants.