Donegal factory worker unemployment benefit
A Donegal shirt factory worker’s unemployment benefit claim was disallowed because she was found not available for work, and an appeals officer upheld the decision. Cunningham argued that no work was available locally and sought a remedy; Cluskey said he could not direct the independent officers’ decisions and offered to provide the case details privately.
asked the Minister for Social Welfare the present position regarding the case of a person in County Donegal (name supplied), a shirt factory worker, who has been claiming unemployment benefit since 12th August, 1974.
Comment on this
The person concerned had her claim to unemployment benefit disallowed by a deciding officer on the grounds that she was not available for employment. She appealed against the decision. Following an oral hearing of her appeal at which she attended and gave evidence, the appeals officer upheld the decision of the deciding officer.
Comment on this
This lady is a shirt factory worker. There is a lot of unemployment and redundancy in that business in Donegal. The fact that I have a question to the Minister for Industry and Commerce—Question No. 182—would probably confirm that the Minister is aware of this. In these circumstances, would the Parliamentary Secretary withdraw the statement that this lady is not available for work? Purely and simply, there is no work available.
Comment on this
As the Deputy is aware, I did not determine that this lady was not available for work. This was decided by a deciding officer and on appeal that decision was upheld by an appeals officer. I have no jurisdiction over deciding officers or appeals officers and I am sure the Deputy would agree that that should be the case.
Comment on this
If I can produce evidence to the Parliamentary Secretary to prove that work is not available will he accept that or will he accept the report of the investigating officer?
Comment on this
I am afraid the Deputy does not understand the situation. It is not a question of my accepting or not accepting. By legislation passed by this House, I have no jurisdiction over deciding officers or appeals officers and cannot direct them to find for or against a person. I think the Deputy would agree that it is not desirable that I should have such authority.
Comment on this
In an area where hundreds of girls and women are being paid off and are becoming unemployed and redundant, would the Parliamentary Secretary indicate what remedy there is if an official of his Department says that there is work when everybody in the area knows that there is no work? What does the Parliamentary Secretary suggest that I should do about it other than bring it to his notice?
Comment on this
Is the Deputy aware of all the circumstances of the case? I am quite sure that a deciding officer and an appeals officer would undoubtedly take those very relevant factors into consideration in their findings. I think the Deputy has more information on the case than the form of his supplementary questions would imply.