Kerry applicant’s new-house grant rate
McEllistrim challenged the £350 grant paid to a Kerry applicant, arguing his income of about £805 qualified him for £450. Tully said the £350 amount was correct under the rules applicable when construction began in 1971; discussion focused on which year’s income should determine eligibility, and Tully noted the decision had been made by his predecessor.
asked the Minister for Local Government the reason why a person (name supplied) in County Kerry did not qualify for a higher rate of new house grant in view of the fact that his income is £805.62.
Comment on this
As I informed the Deputy by letter on 18th November, 1974, this applicant was paid the maximum grant allowable on the basis of his income at the time he applied for the grant. Having regard to the amount of the applicant's income and the date of commencement of the erection of his house, May, 1971, the maximum special rate of grant was £350.
Comment on this
I understood that the income for a higher rate of grant was £900 at that time; as this man has an income of approximately £805 he should have qualified for a grant of £450.
Comment on this
That is not so. The erection of the house commenced in May, 1971, and the appropriate special rate of grant payable in such circumstances to a person in the £750 to £900 income category, deriving his income solely or mainly from non-agricultural sources, is £350. This he was paid.
Comment on this
Is the income for the year in which the building of the house commenced the one which is acceptable to the Department?
Comment on this
This is the one that was produced for the particular time. My own ruling on it would be the year from the time the application was made for the grant is the one that should apply. In this case the decision was taken in 1971 and it was apparently the year ended 5th April, 1971 or the financial year, 31st March, 1971, which was then considered to be the date applied.
Comment on this
In other words, the Minister is saying there has been a change in the criteria, that he is now stipulating a year back from the date of application irrespective of when the house building commences.
Comment on this
I would consider if somebody wants to build a house and he needs grant assistance he would apply for the grant as quickly as possible, often before the commencement of the erection of the house. If the application is sent in and approved on a date it is reasonable that the 12 months prior to the date of application is the one that should be taken into consideration. It is only a small thing and I do not think it makes much difference.
Comment on this
The Minister should operate the provision in the 1970 Housing Act which states that the year before——
Comment on this
I am afraid the Deputy is going into the larger area of grants generally. This deals with a specific applicant.
Comment on this
Will the Minister consider in this case applying the provision of the 1970 Act which states that the income for the year subsequent to the date the house was built, which he has recommended to county councils, should be the one applied?
Comment on this
We are clearly entering into a broader area altogether. The Chair cannot allow that.
Comment on this
I did not apply any year. Deputy Molloy applied the year. This was done three years ago.
Comment on this
If the question is in relation to the applicant in Kerry the Deputy is in order. If not he is not in order.
Comment on this
Deputy Cunningham's Minister made the decision in 1971 and Deputy McEllistrim, realising that now there would be a reasonable approach to it if it could be done, asked me if I could do anything for the poor fellow, whom he thought was badly dealt with by my predecessor. Unfortunately I could not oblige Deputy McEllistrim. It is as simple as that.
Comment on this
Does the Minister accept the income mentioned in this question by Deputy McEllistrim as being the correct income for the year? Would he give us the income ceiling?
Comment on this
I do not wish to badger the Minister but as the House is aware an applicant with £805 would get the full grant.