Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Border Damage Protest.
- Protest over Castleblayney road cratering 9 speeches
The Minister is awaiting a full report on damage from explosives used to crater a cross-border road. He says the evidence will be assessed and a protest made to the British Government if excessive explosives were used.
James Leonard, John M. Kelly, Raymond MacSharry
- Claims for border damage compensation 14 speeches
The Parliamentary Secretary says individuals may pursue malicious-damage claims against their local county council, while the Minister may separately take the matter up with the British if evidence warrants it. He clarifies that he is not saying all such cases must be brought against councils and declines to advise on the 21-day time limit.
Raymond MacSharry, John M. Kelly, Seán Treacy, Noel T. Lemass
asked the Minister for Foreign Affairs whether he protested to the British Government at the damage caused to lands and buildings in the Castleblaney border region arising from the apparent overuse of explosives in road cratering recently.
Comment on this
The facts concerning closing of a cross-Border road near Castleblayney to which the Deputy refers are still under investigation by the relevant authorities but preliminary investigations would seem to suggest that a greater amount of explosives may have been used than was necessary. When a full report is available, the matter will be considered and whatever action is appropriate will be taken.
Comment on this
Does the Parliamentary Secretary not agree that in the comparatively simple operation of cratering roads to use such an amount of explosive which scattered rocks across fields and damaged buildings was not necessary? Will the Parliamentary Secretary ensure that a strong protest is made, and ensure that this will not happen again?
Comment on this
The Minister cannot ensure that but he is prepared to assure the Deputy he is pursuing the matter in the form of a protest to the British Government regarding the amount of explosives used which appears to have been excessive.
Comment on this
Will the Parliamentary Secretary impress on the Minister the urgency of the matter so that there will not be a repetition in the future?
Comment on this
The Minister was originally asked whether he had protested and the answer given was that inquiries were being made. Will the Parliamentary Secretary state if a protest was made regarding the excessive use of explosives in the cratering of the road?
Comment on this
The report which the Minister has received is what he has described as a preliminary one. A full report is awaited, together with a full account of the damage caused by the explosives. The Minister is prepared to assure the Deputy that when these are available the information will be assessed with a view to raising the matter with the British, if appropriate. I take that to mean that if the evidence suggests——
Comment on this
Will the Parliamentary Secretary state if the Department of Foreign Affairs will process claims for compensation for property damaged on this side of the Border?
Comment on this
As the Deputy knows, or should know, the law is that damage maliciously caused in any county can be the subject of a claim against the local council.
Comment on this
It may seem mad to the Deputy but that is the law. Any kind of malicious damage caused in a county area can be the subject of a malicious damage application.
Comment on this
I have given the Deputy a lot of latitude on this matter. I am calling Question No. 29.
Comment on this
There are many cases such as the one mentioned in the question. Is the Parliamentary Secretary now stating that in respect of any damage caused on this side of the Border as a result of British interference along the Border malicious damage claims must be brought by the people concerned against the council?
Comment on this
What I am saying is that, if the Minister is driven to the conclusion by the evidence which he finally gets that an undue amount of explosives was used which caused damage within the boundaries of the State, he will pursue the matter with the British but the Deputy's supplementary question related to——
Comment on this
It is not what the Deputy asked. His supplementary question related to compensation for individuals and individuals are quite free, irrespective of the progress or success of whatever the Minister may do with the British, to make malicious injuries claims against the local county council.