We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - School Transport Service.

Transport to Faha or Firies school

Summary

A five-year-old from the former Ballinalane school area was refused transport to Faha because the amalgamation assigns children to Firies, where transport is available. Mr. O’Leary argues that nearby families use a half-empty bus to Faha and that the child faces an unnecessary journey; Mr. Bruton cites the amalgamation arrangement and says the Department determines school areas.

John O'Leary Mr. J. O'Leary Fianna Fáil

asked the Minister for Education why a school child aged five years (name supplied) in County Kerry was refused public transport to the local primary school despite the fact that children of other families living in the same yard have free public transport to this school.

Comment on this

This child resides in the area of Ballinalane national school which was closed and amalgamated with Firies national school in 1971. She is accordingly entitled to free transport on the service which operates from the closed school area to Firies central school. In view of this, and in view of the fact that the school authorities in Firies national school objected very strongly to the suggestion that she should be given transport to any school other than the central school, transport to Faha national school for her was refused.

Comment on this
John O'Leary Mr. J. O'Leary Fianna Fáil

If this townland is in the area of the closed Ballinalane national school and there are two or three families from this townland getting free transport to Faha national school, could the Parliamentary Secretary explain why cannot this child get the same free transport to Faha school, which is the nearest national school?

Comment on this

This is quite an involved situation. The area where the children reside belongs to the Firies national school because Ballinalane national school was amalgamated with Firies and the idea of an amalgamation is to ensure that there will be sufficient pupils in the central school to maintain numbers and teacher strength in that school—Firies in this case. It would appear that, as the Deputy indicated, prior to the closure of Ballinalane national school the other family got transport to Faha national school. This seems to have been an irregular decision but as these children are near the end of their school career it is probably as well that they should be allowed to continue in the school in which they started even though that may have been on the basis of a decision that was irregular at that time. But the child in which the Deputy is interested is commencing a school career and, at least on the face of it, it should not be a great hardship to that child to attend the Firies school. As I indicated, a convenient transport service to the Firies school is available to that child and I hope he or she will be able to avail of it.

Comment on this
John O'Leary Mr. J. O'Leary Fianna Fáil

Is the Parliamentary Secretary not aware that it is grossly inconvenient for this child of five to be sent six miles away to a national school when there is a school bus passing her door, half empty going to the local national school which is only two and a half miles away and on which her neighbour's children are carried? This includes three families. If an error were made at some time—and I do not believe it was—there is a case to be made for this child. There is great local resentment due to what has happened. I made representations in this case in September and I got no reply from the Department of Education.

Comment on this

Although the distance may be six miles—I am not in a position to dispute that—there is convenient transport available to take the child that six miles. When this amalgamation was made of Ballinalane school, which is the school area in which this child resides, with Firies school, the arrangement which was made in 1971 and not by the present Minister, was that children from the Ballinalane area would go to the Firies school and that transport would be available to them. If the Deputy was concerned about it, he should have taken it up then.

Comment on this
John O'Leary Mr. J. O'Leary Fianna Fáil

Is the Parliamentary Secretary not aware that there are children in the Ballinalane area who are still going to Faha school only two and a half miles away and that their bus is half empty but this child cannot get transport? The inspector was told at one stage by the Department of Education that there must be a mistake.

Comment on this

I dealt with that point in my reply to the first supplementary question.

Comment on this

One general point on this question: does somebody other than the Minister have a veto on where a child goes? I would gather that from the first part of the answer.

Comment on this

The word "veto" would not be used in such a situation but there are a number of factors which have to be considered including the maintenance of pupil numbers in different schools and if an amalgamation arrangement was made to maintain teacher and pupil numbers in a school, obviously the transport arrangements were made accordingly. That has happened under successive Governments.

Comment on this

Use a bit of commonsense.

Comment on this

The child was only two years old when that arrangement was made. The question did not arise at the time.

26.

Comment on this