School transport system and eligibility
Mr. Bruton says the system is continually reviewed, constrained by cost, and recently extended through a fare-paying concession for some pupils without transport to their nearest school. Deputies challenge distance rules, alleged service withdrawals, and the Department’s approach; Bruton says minimum-number rules remain and clarifies that the Department ultimately determines school areas, taking prior amalgamations into account.
asked the Minister for Education if he has any proposals to improve the primary and post-primary school transport system.
Comment on this
The operation of the school transport system is constantly under review with the view to implementing improvements, wherever possible. A major consideration in effecting any improvement is that of cost. The provision in this Department's Estimates for this service in 1975 is £7.382 million.
I have recently introduced a concession for pupils attending national schools who are basically eligible for free transport and for whom there is no transport available to their nearest school. Under this concession, such pupils may avail of transport on a fare-paying basis to the next nearest school if a suitable service is in operation to that school and provided they make their own way to the boundary point between the two school districts. This concession is subject to the condition that there is room on the bus after the eligible children availing of transport to their nearest school are accommodated.
Comment on this
Does the Minister not envisage cutting out all this niggling about distances and so on and giving all children free transport?
Comment on this
The Deputy will appreciate that the cost of eliminating all eligibility requirements in relation to distance over the whole system would be enormous.
Comment on this
Is the Parliamentary Secretary aware that inspectors from his Department were around Kerry recently measuring distances from schools to doors and we were told that this was on the instructions of the Department of Education and they had to measure the distance to the yard, the foot or the inch, if necessary, with a view to trying to knock the school transport system?
Comment on this
It appears that it is the intention of the Department of Education to knock the post primary school transport system and to disrupt the primary school service as was indicated in Question No. 25 by me.
Comment on this
Can the Parliamentary Secretary explain the massive withdrawal of free transport that is taking place throughout the country?
Comment on this
Of course, there has been. Is the Parliamentary Secretary denying that children who have had free transport to primary and post primary schools in the past have had that concession withdrawn?
Comment on this
I accept that, as the position has always been in relation to transport regulations, a certain minimum number of children in any locality is required for the maintenance of such a service and if the minimum number is not maintained over a certain number of terms it may happen that such a service is withdrawn. That provision existed in the scheme operated by my predecessor and it continues to exist.
Comment on this
That is not correct. Is the Parliamentary Secretary trying to get away from the well-established precedent and the regulation which was made at the time that in the case of a school closing all pupils in that catchment area must get free school transport? Is he welshing on that now?
Comment on this
No, I am not. I am talking about a situation other than the situation to which the Deputy refers.
Comment on this
The Chair has given Deputy O'Leary a lot of latitude which he does not seem to appreciate. He wants to dominate Question Time. I have called Question No. 28. The Chair must be obeyed and will not be defied in this matter. The Chair has given too much latitude.
Comment on this
One final supplementary. Could the Parliamentary Secretary say if it is the local school manager, the local teaching organisation or the Minister for Education who states to what schools pupils get free public transport.?
Comment on this
The school area in which a child resides is, for the purpose of transport, in the final analysis determined by the Department of Education but needless to say these areas may be defined on the basis of amalgamation arrangements which were previously entered into in which, of course, all local interests, including the manager and the teacher may have been involved.
28.