Donegal unemployment assistance delays
Cunningham sought faster review of a Donegal claim and challenged delays in assistance cases, including lengthy investigations. Cluskey said the specific review was underway, accepted responsibility for some delays, but attributed many cases to concealed means and disputed Cunningham’s broader criticism; the exchange became heated over whether the Deputy’s questions were intended for local publicity.
asked the Minister for Social Welfare if he will arrange to expedite the unemployment assistance case of a person (name supplied) in County Donegal which has been under consideration for some time.
Comment on this
I have arranged as the Deputy asks. The necessary investigations are being carried out immediately and the review of the claim will then be concluded.
Comment on this
Actually he was. I have arranged as the Deputy asks. The necessary investigations are being carried out immediately and the review of the claim will then be concluded.
Comment on this
Would the Parliamentary Secretary agree that it is unsatisfactory that a Deputy should have to resort to the rather expensive method of getting information in this way and will he ensure that, when a Deputy makes representations in these cases, his representations are dealt with quickly and that he is informed in a reasonable time? Secondly would the Parliamentary Secretary agree with me when I say that an alarming number of reinvestigations and queries are being raised in respect of existing recipients of unemployment assistance especially in my county?
Comment on this
I would not agree with the second part of the Deputy's supplementary question. I certainly agree that representations made by Deputies, or any member of the public, should be dealt with as speedily as possible. In the second part of the Deputy's supplementary question he referred to undue delays or reinvestigations particularly in his own constituency. The Deputy has submitted quite a number of questions along the general lines of this question and, almost invariably, I have found on investigation that the matter has been protracted and the decision delayed because there was concealment of rateable land or other means by the person making the complaint. In fact, this applies to the present case as it has to so many more which the Deputy has submitted in the past.
Comment on this
This is a sweeping general statement which the Parliamentary Secretary knows is quite untrue. I am not denying that there may be concealment in some cases but not in all cases, and certainly not in all the cases I have brought to his notice.
Comment on this
I did not say in all cases, but in a very large number of cases submitted by the Deputy. I replied to the Deputy's supplementary question in which he implied that there was some sort of a conspiracy against him or his constituency by the Department. I thought I was justified in stating what I have stated, which is true, in order to inform the House what the circumstances were and why the Deputy was apparently experiencing this difficulty.
Comment on this
Will the Parliamentary Secretary agree that today's Order Paper indicates that I am not the only Deputy who is having this problem? Similar questions are down with names and addresses supplied by other Deputies. This has become the pattern of parliamentary questions to the Department of Social Welfare put down not by me but by many other Deputies over a period? Would he not agree with that?
Comment on this
I think the Deputy will agree that I have never maintained that the Department are never at fault. Undoubtedly there are occasions when they are. If the Deputy looks at the record for the past 20 months he will see the number of times I have come into the House and accepted responsibility for what I described as unjustified delay. With regard to other questions on the Order Paper, undoubtedly with the large volumes of claims paid and processed there are delays due to human error on the part of members of the staff of the Department. I accept full responsibility when they occur.
I still maintain that what I said with regard to a number of questions along these lines submitted by the Deputy is true. In his supplementary question he insinuated that there was some sort of conspiracy against him or his constituency. The majority of questions the Deputy has submitted along these lines have shown that the cause of the delay lies with the claimant. I will go further. In some cases the Deputy has already been informed by letter of the exact circumstances which caused the delay.
Comment on this
Surely the Parliamentary Secretary will recall his reply to three questions I tabled two weeks ago, one relating to a delay of 33 weeks, another relating to a delay of 24 weeks, and a third relating to a delay of 18 weeks. He apologised for the delay and admitted that I was correct. He said he was having a special investigation in the matter.
Comment on this
Undoubtedly there are delays and, where there are, they are acknowledged and I accept responsibility.
Comment on this
I do not think it helps this House when the Deputy submits questions to which he knows the answer, knows who is at fault, and knows it is not the Department's fault. That might look well in the Deputy's local paper, but it does not help the House.