Suitability of farm modernisation scheme
Fahey and other Deputies argued that the scheme was unsuitable for Irish farmers and sought changes, citing few successful applicants, difficulties qualifying as development farmers and perceived inequalities. Clinton said the scheme had operated for only a short time and needed at least 12 months’ experience before he could make a convincing case for changes at EEC level; he noted that grants continued and disadvantaged areas were exempt from the 1977 deadline.
asked the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries if he will seek changes in the farm modernisation scheme to make it more suitable to Irish conditions.
Comment on this
As I indicated in my address to the General Council of Committees of Agriculture on 2nd December, I am keeping the operation of EEC Directive 159 of 1972 under close review and if it proves to be necessary I may ask the Council of Ministers to have the effects of the directive examined.
Comment on this
The Minister must be aware that it is not workable. Out of a huge application in my county only three were successful. That is proof enough.
Comment on this
I agree with the Deputy that certain indications are appearing. I think he will agree that I could not possibly go to the Council of Ministers and make a case for a scheme which has not really been operated. If we were to make a convincing case in the EEC, we would have to operate this scheme for a period of 12 months at least.
Comment on this
We have been trying to go into this scheme for the last six months but the instructors are finding that nobody, with the exception of very large farmers, will qualify as development farmers. The scheme is completely unsuitable for our farmers.
Comment on this
I do not accept what the Deputy has said. I hold that the farmers he is concerned about are getting grants at least as good as they got before, and in some cases better. The fact that the majority of them will not be classified as development farmers is unfortunate and we are looking at the reasons and the causes for this and at the possibility of having a second comparable income for the western areas.
Comment on this
The fact remains that traditional farmers, as the directive stands, will only be subsidised up to 1977 when the matter will be reviewed. The whole idea was to get a scheme to help farmers develop.
Comment on this
The Deputy is aware that in those parts of the country where the disadvantaged area scheme will apply the 1977 deadline is removed for the subsidisation of farmers.
Comment on this
Surely the Minister must be aware that, with the information available to him in his Department, this scheme is not operative? Is the Minister, because of this, preparing a submission to the EEC for changes?
Comment on this
I am so aware but there are a number of reasons which I indicated last week why we are getting so many transition farmers coming up. They do not have to be examined at all. The ones who have to be examined are those who are likely to be development farmers.
Comment on this
Is the Minister going to let this drift on until it is too late to do anything about it?
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware that there are frightful anomalies and inequalities in the scheme? Does the Minister not feel that now is the time to change the scheme rather than impose a structure on the farming community which they dislike and which we are conditioning them to dislike and distrust?