Costs for Redundancy Act appeals
High Court appeals are limited to points of law, and the court may order appeal costs to be paid from the redundancy fund; in three cases, employees did not bear the costs. The Minister will refer Tunney’s concern that the provision deters workers from appealing to the Minister for Labour.
asked the Minister for Labour if any financial assistance is made available to a worker making an appeal to the High Court against his exclusion from the provisions of the Redundancy Act.
Comment on this
An appeal to the High Court can be made only on a point of law under the Redundancy Payments Acts.
The Acts provide that if a person appeals to the High Court from a decision by the Redundancy Appeals Tribunal, on a point of law, the court may, at its discretion, order the payment by the Minister for Labour from the redundancy fund of the costs, in whole or in part as so ordered.
Comment on this
Would the Minister accept that that is not very inviting for the unfortunate labourer who may have failed initially in his claim?
Comment on this
There have been three cases in respect of which there were appeals. In the first, costs were given against the employer and in the other two it was ordered that the costs would be paid from the redundancy fund. Therefore, in so far as these three cases were concerned, the employees did not lose anything.
Comment on this
Would the Minister agree that the provision is very inhibiting in the case of disappointed workers who may be anxious to make a deal?