Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Butter Production.
- Butter stocks in Ireland and EEC 2 speeches
Ireland held 14,234 tons of butter in cold storage on 1 December 1974; the Minister also supplied EEC public, private and total stocks for December 1973 and 1974.
Thomas J. V. Meaney, Mark A. Clinton
- Withdrawal of butter subsidy 16 speeches
The Minister said the subsidy withdrawn under Article 88 of the Treaty of Accession was due to be phased out by 1977, saving about £2 million annually; a separate subsidy under EEC Regulation 1191/73 continued at an estimated annual cost of £1 million. He confirmed the first subsidy had been ended early, prompting Colley to argue this unnecessarily increased the cost of living; the Minister defended ending a consumer subsidy for butter.
Thomas J. V. Meaney, Mark A. Clinton, George Colley, Seán Treacy
asked the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries the amount of butter stocks that are now in cold storage in this country; and the amount of such stocks in EEC countries in general on 1st December in 1973 and 1974.
Comment on this
As the reply is in the form of a tabular statement. I propose with the permission of the Ceann Comhairle, to circulate it with the Official Report.
Following is the statement:
(a) The quantity of butter in cold storage in Ireland on 1st December, 1974 was 14,234 tons.
(b) Quantities of butter in cold storage in EEC Countries in general.
Date | Public Stocks (i.e. intervention stocks) | Private Stocks (See footnote) | Total
Metric tons | Metric tons | Metric tons
1st December, 1974 | 73,126 | 131,103 | 204,229
1st December, 1973 | 124,335 | 124,416 | 248,751
Footnote: The figures given for private stocks represent the quantities returned under the EEC scheme of aids for the private cold storage of butter.
9.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries why the Government withdrew the butter subsidy to creameries; the amount of the saving to his Department; and if he will quote the relevant EEC regulation.
Comment on this
Under Article 88 of the Treaty of Accession this country was authorised to pay a consumer subsidy on butter subject to its being phased out over the transitional period. We are also authorised to pay a consumer subsidy under EEC Regulation 1191/73. This latter subsidy is continuing and is estimated to cost about £1 million in a full year. The saving in the withdrawal of the subsidy authorised under Article 88 is approximately £2 million in a full year.
Comment on this
Did the Minister state that the subsidy to which he first referred was to be phased out over the transitional period?
Comment on this
Are we to understand from what the Minister has said that, in fact, the subsidy under the regulation has been phased out completely?
Comment on this
Yes. As the Deputy knows, it was really a producer subsidy previously. When we entered the EEC it became a consumer subsidy. In my view, it should never have been under the vote for the Department of Agriculture and Fisheries because it is not normal to have a consumer subsidy under that vote.
Comment on this
Is this not a further example of the tendency of members of the Government to have no regard whatever to the increase in the cost of living which they are bringing about? This is a classic example of it. There was no necessity, no obligation, on the Minister's own say so, under the EEC to do what was done.
Comment on this
A Cheann Comhairle, as you know I dealt with this in great detail on the Adjournment last week. The reasons I gave were fully accepted by the people who were present on that occasion.
Comment on this
Can the Deputy suggest any reason why butter should be singled out from all other food commodities to be exceptionally subsidised by the taxpayers?
Comment on this
I would suggest, and I have suggested, that in present circumstances there is a case for dealing with other food subsidies. At least the Government should do nothing whatever which would increase the cost of living at this time.