Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - French Examination.
- Notice of French examination alternative 6 speeches
The Minister said schools were notified on 5 December 1974, earlier than in previous years. Faulkner argued that uncertainty about the examination made the timing inadequate encouragement; the Minister said there was no worthwhile reason for doubt.
Padraig Faulkner, Richard Burke, Mr. R. Burke
- French alternative at Leaving Certificate 14 speeches
The Minister said he would not yet extend the experimental oral alternative from the Intermediate Certificate, pending further review. Faulkner argued that students following the course needed an oral option; the Minister cited unresolved issues including university recognition, assessment reliability and linguistic standards. He said the matters were under consideration with the examination board, but did not confirm whether universities had commented.
Padraig Faulkner, Mr. R. Burke, John P. Wilson, Seán Treacy
asked the Minister for Education the date on which secondary schools were informed by his Department that the alternative examination in French would be available in the intermediate examination, 1975.
Comment on this
Details of the alternative examination in French to be provided at the intermediate certificate examination, 1975, were conveyed to secondary school authorities on 5th December, 1974.
Comment on this
In reply to supplementary questions on the same subject on an earlier date the Minister stated that he was anxious to encourage the alternative examination. Does he consider that notifying the schools in December that the alternative examination will be available the following summer could be deemed to be encouraging the examination?
Comment on this
As the Deputy will know, the 1972, 1973 and 1974 notifications were given in February, January and January respectively. As he will further know, it has been the practice in the Department to await the review of the current year's examination before issuing details for the alternative examination the following year. This year, in fact, we are a month in advance of previous practice. I think that answers the question.
Comment on this
The Minister will be aware that there was no doubt in the minds of the schools as to whether the alternative examination would be carried out or not during the years he has specified but there was a very considerable doubt in relation to the present year?
Comment on this
That may be so but there was no worthwhile and just reason for such doubt.
20.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Education if he proposes to extend the alternative examination in French to the leaving certificate.
Comment on this
I do not propose at present to extend the alternative examination in French to the leaving certificate. The alternative examination on the intermediate certificate has been in operation since 1972 on an experimental basis only and, pending further experience, I am not in a position to consider extending it to the leaving certificate.
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware that in schools where the alternative examination is being carried out at present the teaching of French continued along these lines in the fifth year and it is hardly reasonable to expect the students who are following the course relating to the alternative examination to do the written examination in the leaving certificate in those circumstances?
Comment on this
The difficulties of introducing it at leaving certificate are obvious on an examination of the question which, by the way, is continuing in the Department all the time. The question of extending the mode to the leaving certificate has been given consideration in the Department and when the Department are satisfied as to the effectiveness and value of the mode in the intermediate certificate examination steps may be taken to introduce it at leaving certificate level also. This consideration has not concluded.
Comment on this
Would the Minister agree that an oral content in an examination of this kind is desirable?
Comment on this
I would agree with the Deputy but there are other questions which need to be investigated. For example, at the leaving certificate the problem of recognition of the mode by university authorities is important because of matriculation links between the leaving certificate and the university. The question of the reliability of teachers' evaluation at this level in assessing, for example, university scholarships and the range of linguistic skills which school-leavers will be expected to have, all these problems make the question of the alternative at leaving certificate much more complex than at intermediate level.
Comment on this
Is the Minister having discussions with the universities on this aspect of the matter?
Comment on this
——about the examination board. These questions are all being looked into.
Comment on this
Am I to take it from the Minister's reply that the university has indicated its suspicion of the alternative method?
Comment on this
The Deputy would not be right in drawing that conclusion from my reply.