Higher education grant levels and eligibility
The Minister outlined current grant levels and said he would review alternative funding methods, but argued that increases depend on available resources. O’Kennedy challenged the grants’ adequacy and outdated parental income thresholds, saying the scheme excludes families it was intended to help; the Minister acknowledged the effects of inflation and noted the points.
asked the Minister for Education the levels of grants paid to university students today; and the proportion by which they have been increased since their inception.
Comment on this
(a) The levels of higher education grants in the present academic year are: (i) Lecture fee up to £172 and this upper limit may be exceeded to the extent necessary to cover total lecture fees in certain years of the degree courses in the Medical, Veterinary and Dental Faculties in the Colleges of the National University of Ireland and in Trinity College, Dublin. (ii) An allowance in respect of maintenance and other expenses of up to £300 per annum for a student whose normal family residence is not in or adjacent to a university town and £120 per annum for a student whose normal family residence is in or adjacent to a university town.
(b) In the case of students whose lecture fees are £172 and who are in receipt of the maximum allowance in respect of maintenance and other expenses, the present level of grants represents an increase over the level in 1968 of 57.3 per cent for a student whose normal family residence is not in or adjacent to a university town and 66.8 per cent for a student whose normal family residence is in or adjacent to a university town.
Comment on this
First, does the Minister accept that these increases are adequate and, secondly, does he feel that the argument that a student would be in or adjacent to a college is an adequate argument for defending the measure of the grant?
Comment on this
In respect of the latter part of the Deputy's supplementary question, I agree with him that perhaps some other method of financing higher education would be desirable and I am going to have that looked at. In respect of the first part of the Deputy's question, I am always in a difficulty on this because, as Minister, I am responsible for differentiating between the various sectors and putting the money where I think the best results will be got. If I had more money I would like to put it into this sector but resources are not unlimited and I have to make my judgment.
Comment on this
Would the Minister agree that the income level of the parents is now grossly out of line with the income level when the scheme was introduced? I could give ten examples. I shall give one. A parent with one child with £1,700 could qualify for a grant when the scheme was introduced in 1968. Now a parent with one child and £2,275 finds that that child is excluded. You can go down through the scale, whether you are talking about two, three or four, and does the Minister not accept that £2,275 today is in no way related to £1,800 in 1968 and, if he so accepts, what will he or the Government do about it?
Comment on this
The Deputy has made this point to me on a previous occasion. I accept the general drift of his point. However, I am limited by the resources available to me, but the matter is under constant review. On the face of it, the Deputy has a point.
Comment on this
I accept that this is a matter for the Government, but does the Minister accept that, when the scheme was introduced, it was intended to benefit the majority of those who could not pay, and does he now accept that the scheme as at present operating is benefiting only a minority of those who cannot pay for higher education?
Comment on this
This scheme is obviously the victim of the fall in the value of money. I am keeping the scheme under constant review and, as resources are available, we make these very desirable changes.
Comment on this
We must pass on to the next question. The Chair has been very generous with the Deputy.
Comment on this
If the Deputy wants to ask a question, well and good but, if the Deputy wants to impart information, that would not be in order.
Comment on this
I want to ask a question. Does the Minister accept that it is not the scheme that is the victim but the children of the type of parents who were intended to benefit from the scheme and who are now being excluded and will the Minister state clearly that the scheme is not now as extensive, or nearly so, as it was originally intended to be and, in fact, as it was over the last few years?
Comment on this
All I can say is that I have noted the Deputy's points.
10.