We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Portlaoise Prison Disturbances.

Portlaoise Prison Disturbances

Summary

The Minister said officers had been commended after a surprise attack by prisoners, rejected claims they faced discipline, and said future attacks could not be ruled out. Repairs were nearly complete and visits were to resume; the Minister denied claims about prisoners eating off the floor, confirmed one prisoner per cell, and reported 17 inmates on hunger strike.

asked the Minister for Justice is he aware of the grave concern expressed by some prison officers about the recent disturbances in Portlaoise Prison; and the action, if any, he intends to take in the matter.

Comment on this

I am not so aware. If the Deputy is referring to certain newspaper reports alleging that the prison officers in Portlaoise were in fear of being disciplined in connection with the recent disturbances, I am glad to have the opportunity to say publicly that, on the contrary, the prison officers were commended for their behaviour throughout this difficult period and the entire body of officers in the prison were well aware of this commendation. Accordingly, the reports that they were in fear of disciplinary action were without foundation and could not have emanated from the officers.

While I am satisfied that there was no question of concern about possible disciplinary action, I am equally satisfied that there was, obviously, serious concern about the ordeal to which those prison officers who were taken hostage were subjected, a concern which every reasonable person must share. We all hope that such a situation does not recur. Every effort is made by all concerned to minimise the risks and the best and most practicable ways of attaining that objective are kept constantly under review.

Comment on this

I share the Minister's sentiments for the welfare of the prison officers. Can he tell us the circumstances in which 140 prisoners overpowered 27 prison officers? Could he give the House that information?

Comment on this

I do not know what the Deputy means by the circumstances but——

Comment on this

Can he give us the time and day and describe how it happened?

Comment on this

In reply to a written question I have already issued a full statement to the Deputy on the events of that day in Portlaoise. The bald fact is that the prisoners overpowered the officers in question. There were no particular circumstances that would have given any advance warning that such action was planned because, of course, if there had been, suitable action would have been taken by the prison staff and by the security forces in the prison. This was a surprise attack on the officers in question—a ruthless determined attack by ruthless and dangerous criminals.

Comment on this

The Minister went through that litany before.

Comment on this

I feel it cannot be emphasised too often. I would like the Deputy to concur with me that his opinion of these people is, as mine is, that the inmates of Portlaoise are ruthless and dangerous criminals.

Comment on this

The Minister knows my views in that respect very well. Will the circumstances arise again in the near or distant future where 27, 30 or 37 prison officers will be exposed to the position of finding themselves being overpowered by prisoners?

Comment on this

I sincerely hope that the situation will not arise again——

Comment on this

What action has the Minister taken?

Comment on this

Will the Deputy let me finish my reply? I hope the situation will not arise again but I cannot give a guarantee. From visiting prisons the Deputy is aware of the regimen within a prison, that the prison officers must move through prisoners in the course of their work. If prisoners are so badly disposed as to attack a prison officer, they cannot be prevented. The best remedy is to make the prisoners fully aware that there will be instant and severe reaction on the part of the authorities against them for any such illegal activity. It is impossible to say that never again will a prison officer be attacked, jostled or taken hostage by prisoners. The fact that I must say this—and this is a fact of life in prisons— might highlight for the public the difficult and dangerous job the prison staff are doing on our behalf. That is the factual position.

Comment on this

I am sorry to pursue this but the Minister is aware that he gave a written reply to a number of questions in circumstances about which he knows. I would like to ask him a number of questions arising from the written reply.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy must stick to the questions on the paper. Question No. 51.

Comment on this

I will be pleased to facilitate the Deputy.

Comment on this

I do not want to insist but——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

If there was a written reply the Chair——

Comment on this

A Leas-Cheann Comhairle, you are not listening to me. A certian situation arose where I was asked to accede to a request for a written reply to three questions. I acceded on the basis that I would be able to raise supplementary questions on that reply in the House. That is what I am trying to do but you are preventing me.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair has no information about that. We are dealing with Question No. 50. I am allowing the Deputy supplementary questions on that question.

Comment on this

The Minister is prepared to answer the questions.

Comment on this

Question No. 51 is on the same subject.

Comment on this

The Minister said in the written reply that the damage to the facilities and so on amounted to some £14,000 and that it would be repaired shortly. Has the damage been repaired?

Comment on this

The damage has practically been repaired. The cell doors have been replaced. Beds are back in all the cells, furniture is being restored and is now in the majority of cells. The demands on prison officers' time in restoring and supervising the prison in its disordered state are less and as a result I will be announcing later today that the temporary ban on visits has been lifted and visits may be resumed.

Comment on this

There has been a suggestion, again in the newspapers, that a group visiting Portlaoise had to wait some two hours before they could visit their people. I do not know who they were visiting.

Comment on this

I am not aware of this. If the Deputy gives me details of it I will have it investigated, but when a very large number of people arrive it is inevitable that those at the end of the queue may have a long wait before their turn comes.

Comment on this

How many prisoners are there per cell at the moment?

Comment on this

One prisoner per cell. For some days, while the prison was in a disordered state, there were two and, in some cases, three per cell.

That was only a very temporary arrangement and pertained for only a matter of days.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Question No. 51.

Comment on this

There was a leaflet circulated in my constituency——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy is giving information, not asking a question.

Comment on this

——which alleged that prisoners were eating food off the floor.

Comment on this

I am aware of that leaflet. The allegations in it were completely without foundation.

Comment on this

Can the Minister tell us how many prisoners are on hunger strike?

Comment on this

My information is that there are 17 on hunger strike.

Comment on this

For how long?

Comment on this

Seven have been on hunger strike for approximately three weeks. The exact date of commencement is somewhat vague in regard to some of them. The balance have been on hunger strike a week.

Comment on this