Minister’s discussions with the HEA
The Minister said he had met the Higher Education Authority six times. Supplementaries examined differences between its recommendations and the Government’s tertiary-education proposals, including university science arrangements, Galway’s status and the balance between technological and academic subjects; the Minister defended the Government’s decisions.
asked the Minister for Education the number of times since the date of his appointment on which he has met the members of the Higher Education Authority for discussions upon tertiary education.
Comment on this
I tried yesterday to ask a supplementary question, and did not get an opportunity, in regard to an academic bias in education. Would you give me an opportunity of asking it now?
Comment on this
No. When the Deputy rose the time had expired for questions. I could not permit him to raise a question at that time.
Comment on this
It was not my fault, a Cheann Comhairle, that you did not see me but I did offer. I have been denied an opportunity and I will not have an opportunity for six months to ask a question. Do you not feel I am entitled to ask it now?
Comment on this
Since I assumed office as Minister for Education I have met members of the Higher Education Authority on six occasions and in addition I have had many informal meetings with the chairman. Officers of my Department are in regular contact with members and staff of the HEA.
Comment on this
May I ask the Minister if the recommendations made by the Higher Education Authority differed substantially from the proposals which he made on the 16th of December in regard to tertiary education?
Comment on this
As is obvious from reading the documents, there are some differences. If the Deputy wants me to elaborate on these I can do so.
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware that the present chairman of the Higher Education Authority, in an article in The Irish Times some time ago, advocated the retention of the binary system in third level education?
Comment on this
Would the Minister indicate, as requested in Deputy Thornley's question, the number of times on which he has met the members of the Higher Education Authority for discussions on tertiary education?
Comment on this
I have met them six times and on each occasion we discussed tertiary education.
Comment on this
My supplementary question does not come up later on as far as I can see and I would like to hear an answer to it from the Minister.
Comment on this
Would the Minister not accept that according to the report of his reply, which was totally inaudible to everybody in the House yesterday owing to the rather disgraceful squabble which took place, the Minister has completely rejected the recommendations of the Higher Education Authority in respect of the disposition of engineering, biological and physical sciences between the Dublin universities?
Comment on this
The Government in making their decisions, as I pointed out in the reply, put a moratorium on the development of the educational science faculty in Trinity and made decisions which would be a departure from the physical biological divide between Trinity and UCD.
Comment on this
You have called the next question, a Cheann Comhairle.
Comment on this
Arising out of the six discussions which the Minister had with the members of the Higher Education Authority did they recommend to him that University College, Galway, should not be established as a university in its own right?
Comment on this
My discussions with these bodies are normally kept confidential.
Comment on this
My supplementary was whether the Minister knew that the present chairman of the Higher Education Authority is on record as being in favour of the retention of the binary system in third level education.
Comment on this
I have not seen the report to which the Deputy refers.
Comment on this
Deputies will have to obey the Chair. I am calling on Deputy Power for a final supplementary.
Comment on this
Would the Minister indicate whether he feels that the recent proposals put forward by him will have the effect of making it more enticing for students to go on for a degree in technological subjects rather than academic subjects and does he feel that the imbalance from which we now suffer will be corrected by his proposals?
Comment on this
That is the fundamental reason for the proposals.
2.