Consultation on tertiary-education decisions
The Minister said his 16 December statement had not been circulated in advance, but copies were sent to relevant institutions and groups later that day. He maintained that the Government’s announced decisions were final while further details remained open to representations, and said meetings with universities, the Federation and Dublin VEC were being arranged. Deputies pressed him on what consultation could achieve, his responsibility for the decisions and the origin of technological-education proposals; he promised a White Paper.
asked the Minister for Education if his statement on 16th December, 1974, concerning the future of tertiary education in the Republic of Ireland was communicated before its release to the Press to (a) the universities or university colleges concerned (b) the Irish Federation of University Teachers (c) the Union of Students in Ireland and (d) the staff associations of the various colleges involved.
Comment on this
Copies of the statement on higher education made by me at a Press reception on 16th December, 1974, were not circulated in advance to anyone or any body. Copies were, however, sent to the heads of the universities, principals of other higher level colleges, the Irish Federation of University Teachers, the Higher Education Authority, the National Council for Educational Awards, the Union of Students and other interested parties later that day.
Comment on this
Would the Minister clarify my befuddled and uneducated mind as to what constitutes consultation? He spoke in the Dáil yesterday, as far as I can understand, of his willingness to receive representations from the bodies which are mentioned in this question. He has also said that the terms he has prescribed are not negotiable. Would the Minister kindly explain to my befuddled mind how terms which are not negotiable are also going to be subject to representations by the bodies which I mentioned?
Comment on this
I was at pains over a period of weeks to explain the point and I laboured it yesterday in response to questions in the Dáil. The announcement made on 16th December in respect of the various matters such as the conjoint board, the National University of Ireland, the University of Dublin and the various other matters, related to decisions taken by the Government. Consequential on the taking of these decisions, other matters will have to be decided in the course of filling out such things as the composition, nature, functions and relationships of the conjoint board, the various bodies in these new universities and so on. These are matters which are being compiled and which will be discussed by the Government and, may I stress, even to the most befuddled brain, that I cannot pre-empt the Government's right in this area to make decisions. If I were to do so and announce them I would be reneging on my responsibility as a member of a Cabinet which is bound by collective responsibility.
Comment on this
Has the Minister considered the degree of unsettlement in the junior staff of the various Irish colleges and of the students in respect of their ultimate fate in the event of his apparently non-negotiable decisions being put into operation?
Comment on this
If the hesitations arise in respect of decisions already announced, they would have some reason for apprehension if they feel strongly about these. In respect of those matters in which they could offer a useful input into the further elaboration of the composition of bodies, then I have received and will continue to receive representations. Only on Monday last I received representations from the board of Trinity College. I am meeting the heads of the universities next week, the Dublin VEC and the Irish Federation of University Teachers. Various independent pieces of advice are given to me by people working in the Dublin technological colleges, people working in the regional technical colleges, principals, students and various others. In fact, I am inundated with pieces of advice which I will incorporate in so far as these are not in conflict with the basic decisions already taken.
Comment on this
Will the Minister indicate when he got the last piece of advice from the City of Dublin VEC?
Comment on this
My office was in consultation with the headquarters of the VEC to set up a meeting between that body and myself. I also have other ways of knowing what goes on in the VEC.
Comment on this
I can give the Deputy the exact information shortly. I do not think the office at Ballsbridge has come back to us with a date. I will tell the Deputy the date as soon as possible.
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware that the office at Ballsbridge has been awaiting a reply from him to indicate the date on which he might receive a representative of the VEC?
Comment on this
I have not been tardy in accepting invitations from people who want to come to see me. The Dublin VEC will be coming in in the near future.
Comment on this
May I ask the Minister whether he agrees with some or all of the decisions taken by the Government which were announced in his statement of 16th December? Will he indicate to us the ones with which he personally does not agree?
Comment on this
The Deputy is being very clever when he uses this kind of phraseology. In fact, in one of the papers this morning a phrase used by him was attributed to another Deputy. I never used the word "some" in relation to reasons raised yesterday. This is a mischievous question and I do not intend to answer it.
Comment on this
The Minister alleges he was misreported, presumably by the Official Reporter as well as by Press reporters, in the statement he made yesterday in my hearing that he knew of some of the reasons why the decisions announced on 16th December were taken——
Comment on this
I want to advise the Deputy that although he rose on a point of order he is now proceeding to make a speech. That is not in order.
Comment on this
It is only right that I should draw the Chair's attention to it because the Chair heard, as everyone in the House heard——
Comment on this
Now that we have cleared that up, would the Minister care to answer my supplementary?
Comment on this
What was it? It appears that even the Deputy cannot remember it.
Comment on this
We are already dealing with Question No. 4 which the Chair has called.
Comment on this
There is no need to engender heat into this matter at this stage. Has Deputy O'Malley a pertinent, final supplementary to put?
Comment on this
That was the second last question the Chair called.
Comment on this
In relation to the statement the Minister issued on 16th December which he was at great pains to point out was a collective decision of the Government as a whole, numerous points were set out——
Comment on this
With how many of those decisions does the Minister agree, and with how many does he disagree?
Comment on this
Even for Deputy O'Malley that question is naïve. As I said yesterday, if they want me to talk about Cabinet responsibility we can go back three or four years to discuss that concept.
Comment on this
Will Deputies please allow the Chair to make reasonable progress at Question Time? When the Chair calls the next question, will Deputies please desist from putting further supplementaries, thereby placing the Chair in an invidious position?
Comment on this
Will the Minister state if the proposals on technological education came in the first instance from the Minister for Education?
Comment on this
The proposals for the organisation of technological education at regional and central levels.
Comment on this
This was the decision of the Government. That does not necessarily exclude the arrival of suggestions from any particular quarter.
Comment on this
Further to the Minister's reply to Deputy Thornley's question and supplementary, like Deputy Thornley I am somewhat befuddled. Perhaps the Minister would clarify the matter further. As I understood his reply, he said the decisions announced were Government decisions that are final but that there are a number of consequential decisions yet to be made on which he is prepared to receive representations. I would assume from that that the Minister means that representations from any of the bodies mentioned by Deputy Thornley in regard to the decisions already announced are futile. Am I interpreting the Minister correctly?
Comment on this
I would not use the word "futile". The decisions have been taken. I am a member of a Cabinet who have taken the decisions and, to that extent, they are final. May I say in relation to a radio programe that I heard today——
Comment on this
——someone said that the Minister was back-tracking. I am not back-tracking.
Comment on this
The Minister said he did not regard the word "futile" as being the right one. Can he suggest the correct description of representations in regard to decisions already announced?
Comment on this
I have laboured incessantly in the last three days to explain the representations which I am receiving from the various bodies——
Comment on this
I have said that a White Paper has been prepared, that it will be published and brought before the House.
Comment on this
If I may put a final supplementary question? I am the last person to wish to embarrass the Minister and I think the performance of the House in the last two days has been unseemly and disgraceful. However, I accept Deputy Colley's point. How on earth does the Minister propose to accept representations about decisions he has already announced?
Comment on this
If the Deputy checks the official record he will find my reply to that question.