Prosecution decision in fatal Curraghbeg accident
The Taoiseach said the Attorney General considered the case and decided that a prosecution was not warranted. Asked about alleged vehicle defects, the decision process and the Taoiseach’s own review, he declined to give reasons, citing established practice and natural justice, and confirmed the decision was the Attorney General’s.
asked the Taoiseach why no prosecution was brought in connection with a road accident on the 1st June, 1973, at Curraghbeg, Skibbereen, County Cork, resulting in the death of a person (name supplied).
Comment on this
The Attorney General, having given full consideration to this case, directed that a criminal charge in respect of the manner of driving of the motor vehicle involved was not warranted.
Comment on this
Is the Taoiseach aware that there were serious lighting defects in the car in question and also serious defects in respect of at least one tyre and, if so, would he say why a prosecution was not initiated under the Road Traffic Act?
Comment on this
As the Deputy is probably aware, it is not the practice to give reasons why a prosecution is taken or why a decision is taken not to prosecute and, in the circumstances, I cannot add anything further to the reply.
Comment on this
In view of the seriousness of the matter and in view of the fact that a man lost his life, would the Taoiseach not think it worthwhile saying why it was decided that proceedings should not be initiated in this particular case?
Comment on this
I fully appreciate what the Deputy says and the circumstances he mentions in connection with the case but he will, I think, on reflection, appreciate that it has never been the practice to give reasons why a prosecution is taken or, on the other hand, why a prosecution is not taken, and to depart from that practice could interfere with the principles of natural justice.
Comment on this
Would the Taoiseach not agree that invariably when life is lost as a result of an accident there is a prosecution even though the blame may be assessed on a degree of responsibility?
Comment on this
I do not know whether the Deputy is correct in saying "invariably". I suppose it generally happens, but the Attorney General considered all the facts of this case and decided that a prosecution did not lie.
Comment on this
Could the Taoiseach say if he looked at this file himself and is satisfied with the decision taken?
Comment on this
I have looked at the file, but this is not a matter for me to express an opinion. It is the Attorney General who is the appropriate officer in this regard and is not a question of what my opinion is.
Comment on this
Would the Taoiseach say if this was the Attorney General's decision and not a recommendation from or the decision of the local Garda?