Economic and monetary union and regional funding
Flanagan and others questioned whether the small regional fund allocation undermined progress towards EMU. FitzGerald agreed the fund was inadequate for that purpose, but said the 1980 target had become unrealistic as progress towards EMU had moved backwards; the remaining questions were deferred to the next Order Paper.
asked the Minister for Foreign Affairs the present position concerning the question of economic and monetary union in the EEC, in view of the very small sum allocated to Ireland in the regional fund; and whether the Government's fears about the dangers of economic and monetary union have been exacerbated by the disappointing regional fund allocations.
Comment on this
At their meeting in Paris on 9-10th December, 1974, the heads of Government of the Community repeated the objective of establishing an economic and monetary union, an objective previously agreed in the Paris Summit Conference of 1972. Ireland, along with other member states, remains committed to pursuing the goal of economic and monetary union. Apart from supporting this aim in the context of European union as a whole, it can be argued that our own interests are best served by movement towards EMU. For example, it is important to this country to preserve the common agricultural policy, the functioning of which is seriously impaired by the continued absence of fixed parities between Community currencies. Of course, we consider that progress towards achievement of EMU in the Community should be accompanied by satisfactory progress in improving the decision-making arrangements in the Community and in ensuring that policy-making at Community level is brought under more effective democratic control involving for instance greater powers for and direct election to the European Parliament.
The heads of Government also decided to set up the European Regional Development Fund as from 1st January, 1975. For its first three years of operation (1975-77) the fund will be endowed with 1,300 million units of account (£542 million) of which Ireland will receive 84 million units of account (£35 million). In the view of the Government the annual amounts involved in this contribution of 84 million units of account, while being a useful addition to our domestic resources for regional development would be quite inadequate as a contribution to the Irish economy in the middle and latter periods of adjustment towards EMU when the pressures on the Irish economy that could arise as a result of these adjustments would require much more extensive action by the Community than is involved in the regional fund as proposed for the years 1975-77
Comment on this
Would the Minister agree that the regional fund as announced after the last summit will not be effective towards achieving economic and monetary union as enunciated by the Paris summit?
Comment on this
In view of that would the Minister not think that it would have been desirable for our representation, particularly at the last summit, to enter a reservation to the summit communiqué to that effect, clearly indicating that it was not honouring the commitments of the Paris summit?
Comment on this
No, because the Paris summit discussed the question of the 1980 deadline for EMU and the wording of the Paris summit communiqué indicates clearly that that deadline is recognised as being unrealistic.
Comment on this
It is certainly rendered much more unrealistic now by the operation of the last summit. Is that not so?
Comment on this
Does the Minister not think, in view of what he has said now about our Government's attitude, that it would have been well for our leader at the time to have expressed that reservation in that communiqué, as other Governments did about matters of vital concern to them?
Comment on this
No. In fact the EMU target of 1980 was not pressed and the communiqué wording makes it clear that it is no longer thought to be realistic. Therefore, the argument that we must now have a regional fund of a much larger amount to reach the EMU target of 1980 is no longer as relevant an argument as it was once the 1980 deadline argument was eroded at that point.
Comment on this
Is the Minister saying if you want to erode the target of the EMU you have a very simple way of doing it, that in fact you act totally contrary to your principles in the regional fund? Is that what the Minister is saying?
Comment on this
No, I am not saying that. The progress towards EMU generally has not been good. It has, if anything, been in the opposite direction to the one intended. The necessary steps towards achieving that objective are not being taken in fields other than regional policy and consequently the target date is no longer realistic. This unfortunately from our point of view reduces the strength of the particular argument for a large-scale regional policy deriving from this EMU deadline.
Comment on this
Would the Minister not agree that control by the European Parliament is far more important now that the currencies are in a chaotic situation vis-á-vis each other than if you had EMU? Would he not further agree that there is absolutely no will at all at the moment to produce a situation where there is economic and monetary union and that the whole talk of the summit is poppycock?
Comment on this
I think there is a recognition that we have moved backwards rather than forwards in the direction of this target in the last couple of years and the summit communiqué gently indicated that by its wording on this particular point.