Public telephone kiosk outages and vandalism
Brugha asked about kiosk numbers, outages and repair costs, then proposed placing kiosks near residents who could help protect them. The Minister gave figures, described reinforced coin boxes and said he was open to resident-supported sites; most outages were attributed to vandalism, while questions about charges were referred to the Minister for Justice.
asked the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs the number of telephones currently out of order in public kiosks in (a) Dublin city and county and (b) the remainder of the State.
19.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs the number of public telephone kiosks in (a) Dublin city and county and (b) the remainder of the State.
Comment on this
With the permission of the Ceann Comhairle, I propose to take Questions Nos. 18 and 19 together.
There are 610 public telephone kiosks in Dublin city and county and 1,920 in the remainder of the State. Of these approximately 140 and 150 respectively were out of order on a recent date.
Comment on this
Can the Minister tell us the cost of keeping public telephones in repair?
Comment on this
The cost of repairs for the year ended 31st March, 1974, was about £101,000—£84,000 in Dublin and £17,000 in the provinces.
Comment on this
In view of the cost to the Minister's Department and in view of the number of public telephones out of order, would the Minister consider, as a trial, changing the regulations so that the Department may, in some estates at any rate, site public telephone kiosks either in the gardens or in the homes of residents who might be willing to look after them?
Comment on this
I do not exclude consideration of such measures. I will mention some measures which my Department have taken to combat vandalism. Of course those incidents which are much more numerous in Dublin city than anywhere else are mainly due to vandalism. A total of 187 new specially designed reinforced coin boxes have been installed—185 in the Dublin area and two in the provinces.
These coin boxes are proving very successful in combating vandalism. In case the success of such measures should be contested, I might give some comparative figures. The present figures, which Deputies may well find a bit alarming as I do myself, represent 23 per cent out of order in Dublin and 7.8 per cent in the provinces. The comparative figures for June, 1973, were 26.6 per cent in Dublin and 7.85 per cent in the provinces. Therefore, there has been a percentage decline although the situation is still of course far from satisfactory. We have also fitted in about 620 kiosks steel plates to which the coin box can be bolted with the object of preventing removal of the coin box. We have installed continuous fluorescent lighting in over 2,000 kiosks and an alarm system has been fitted in 97 kiosks which alerts the local manual exchange by lighting a special lamp if the coin box is being interfered with. The operator then notifies the Garda. Further alarm systems will be installed and I will be glad if any Deputy who has further ideas in this matter will communicate with my Department.
Comment on this
The Minister will appreciate that our concern is not alone the cost to the Department but also the fact that, if there are 300 public telephones out of order throughout the State at present, they are not much use to people in an emergency. Therefore the Minister might consider, in addition to what he has outlined, the possibility of a better security system which would be looked after by residents if kiosks were sited beside the hall doors of private residences rather than out on the street.
Comment on this
My Department would certainly be sympathetic to such a system where we could ensure that this would be welcomed by residents. There are areas where this would not necessarily be the case.
Comment on this
Can the Minister say whether those 300 kiosks were out of order as a result of vandalism or not?
Comment on this
Yes, the great majority of them I understand, were out of order as a result of vandalism. In 1974 there were 8,085 recorded incidents of vandalism in Dublin and 400 in the provinces. These figures do not include frequent short interruptions of service caused by misuse or minor interference with the coin box —for example, the insertion of bent coins, stuffing of slots with paper or other material. Unfortunately the incidence of vandalism in the city at least appears to have been increasing.
Comment on this
Deputy Tunney, please. The Chair has remained unduly long on this question and has made little progress at Questions today because of the large number of supplementaries and yet the Chair is being barracked.
Comment on this
Would the Minister say whether there is any record of anyone having been charged in respect of the vandalism in question?